Slain Priest’s Memorial In Turkey Opens Way To Reconciliation

SLAIN PRIEST’S MEMORIAL IN TURKEY OPENS WAY TO RECONCILIATION
Peter Lamprecht

Crosswalk.com, VA
Feb 8 2007

Killer’s parents show up before service for murdered clergyman.

TRABZON, Turkey – Turkey’s Catholics extended reconciliation to this
tense Black Sea city yesterday, exactly one year after a local teenager
shot an Italian priest while he was praying in his church.

Trabzon has come under increasing criticism in the Turkish and
international press after the killer of Father Andrea Santoro and the
suspected assassin of Armenian journalist Hrant Dink emerged as Black
Sea locals. Tight security both in and around the church indicated
that authorities did not want a repeat of either incident.

"Trabzon is an honest and clean city," Anatolian Bishop Luigi Padovese
said in Turkish at the opening of an 11:30 a.m. mass in Trabzon’s
St. Mary Church to commemorate the death of Fr. Santoro.

"We will continue to trust the honest people here."

Underlining the importance of these words for Turkey’s Catholics,
Cardinal Camillo Ruini, president of Italy’s Bishops Conference,
and Antonio Lucibello, Vatican nuncio to Turkey, celebrated the mass.

"The majority of [Trabzon’s] population is like us [Christians], they
reject violence and can’t understand such murders," Bishop Padovese
commented to Compass.

A Turkish Protestant attending the service said that negative press
against Trabzon has increased nationalist anger among segments of
the city’s youth.

"Certain young people have begun wearing a white hat [like that
worn by Ogun Samast, who reportedly confessed to murdering Dink]
because they see Samast as a leader and a hero," Sezgin Saglamer
told Compass. "The source of this anger is not against Christians:
it’s partly because the media have excessively faulted Trabzon."

The mother, sisters and cousin of the murdered priest were also in
attendance from Italy bearing a message of forgiveness.

Fr. Santoro’s mother’s first act upon entering the small church was
to kneel on the exact spot her son had been praying when 16-year-old
Oguzhan Aydin shot him from behind. Alone with a few security police
and clergy, she wept softly in prayer before rising to walk around
the rest of the chapel.

"My family and I have forgiven with all our hearts," Fr. Santoro’s
sister told the daily Today’s Zaman following the mass. "Before Jesus
died he said, ‘Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do.’"

The unexpected arrival of the killer’s parents at 11 a.m. created a
minor stampede as dozens of Turkish journalists cornered the pair,
climbing on pews and shoving aside a nun. The couple eventually broke
free and met privately with Cardinal Ruini and Bishop Padovese to
express their sympathy.

"It was very moving that the mother and father of the murderer came,"
Bishop Padovese commented. "We could see that they were genuinely
saddened by the whole event."

The exchange stood in sharp contrast to previous comments by Aydin’s
mother, who had reportedly defended her son after his sentence.

According to Turkish press reports, she said, "If my son is jailed
for the state, for the people, then so be it with my blessing. He is
jailed for Allah."

Media Contribution to Deaths Aydin was given a prison sentence of 18
years and 10 months in October for shooting Fr. Santoro. As a minor,
he is expected to serve only 10.5 years of that sentence.

Contrary to reports in the Turkish media, Bishop Padovese told Compass
that Aydin’s parents did not meet Fr. Santoro’s mother. The bishop
said he had hoped to prevent her from experiencing shock.

Though the ceremony received positive coverage in the Turkish media,
members of the Catholic community were wary of several dozen Turkish
journalists covering the event.

One member of the congregation commented to Compass that it was
negative nationalist media reports against Fr. Santoro, and more
recently against Dink, that had provoked their deaths. Local press
had published angry statements that the Italian priest was working
to convert Muslims to Christianity.

A heavy police presence at yesterday’s memorial service highlighted the
uncertainty that Trabzon’s small Christian community continues to face.

"Christians in Trabzon are not afraid, but they have become more
careful," Bishop Padovese told Compass, adding that he was thankful
for the excellent security provided by the city.

"Father Andrea always told us that he was more worried for us than
he was for himself," commented one Turk of Muslim background who had
attended the church during Fr. Santoro’s three years in Trabzon.

Christians in Turkey have faced increased persecution during the
past year. Attacks on foreign Catholic priests occurred in Izmir,
Mersin and Samsun in 2006, the most serious in July when a man with a
history of mental instability knifed an elderly French priest outside
Samsun’s Mater Dolorosa church.

Converts to Christianity have also faced attacks, most recently the
stoning of Agape Protestant Church in Samsun last month.

In his homily, interpreted from Italian into Turkish, Cardinal Ruini
underlined the necessity for freedom of conscience to underpin worship
of God.

"True and sincere worship of God is only possible with free and
brotherly love," Cardinal Ruini said. "We’ve come here to highlight
religious freedom."

Movie Review: ‘Screamers’

MOVIE REVIEW: ‘SCREAMERS’
By Michael Wilmington – Tribune movie critic

Crosswalk.com, VA
Feb 8 2007

** rating (out of four)

What are the roots of genocide?

"Screamers," a documentary/concert film that begins by focusing
on the Armenian genocide of 1915 and broadens to include mass
exterminations from the Holocaust on, tries to both give witness and
provide an answer. Mixing concert footage of the Armenian-American
rock group System of a Down–whose hypnotic protest ballads supply
the "screamers" of the title–with interviews and archive footage
detailing genocides throughout the 20th and 21st Centuries, director
Carla Garapedian makes us face again the appalling consequences of
untrammeled political dictatorship and of murder as a public policy.

The movie’s theme is simple. Genocides happen because of the mass
political pathologies and conditions that trigger them–but also
because the rest of the world chooses to look the other way.

Garapedian begins with the massacre in Armenia–when the Ottoman
Turkish government systematically slaughtered the Armenian population
during a time of forced deportations in 1915. (Death toll estimates
range from the Turkish government estimate of 300,000 to some Armenian
sources that cite up to two million fatalities.)

Gradually, she expands her story to include the Holocaust, Cambodia,
Rwanda, Bosnia, the Kurdish massacres in Iraq and present-day deaths
in Darfur. The Armenian slaughter remains her main concern–and also
that of System of the Down and their singer, Serj Tankian–but she does
try to tie everything together. It’s particularly infuriating, after
learning of all these often unrecorded deaths and national coverups,
to see ex-Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert–accused here of helping
bury Armenian genocide recognition bills in the House–smugly dodging
questions from Tankian.

"Screamers" is a commendably brave piece, but less focused and powerful
than you’d like. In the end, Garapedian might have been better
off concentrating her energy on the 1915 Armenian story–which has
been told on film various times (for example, in "Forty Days of Musa
Dagh" and Atom Egoyan’s "Ararat"), but never with the power of, say,
"The Pianist" or "Schindler’s List."

After a while, the other episodes of mass slaughter sometimes seem too
hastily covered and the theme not eloquently enough expressed. If you
know little about the terrible Armenian episode and its aftermath,
"Screamers" may be a good place to start. The worldwide cycle of
genocide, unfortunately, shows little sign of ending.

[email protected]

‘Screamers’

Dir ected by Carla Garapedian; photographed by Charles Rose; edited by
William Yarhaus; music by Jeff Atmajian, System of a Down; produced
by Nick de Grunwald, Guardian, Peter McAlevey, Timothy F. Swain. An
MG2 Productions/BBC Television/Raffy Manoukian Charity presentation.

MPAA rating: R (for disturbing images of genocide and language).

ies/mmx-070209-movies-review-screamers,0,2612607.s tory?coll=mmx-movies_top_heds

http://metromix.chicagotribune.com/mov

Group Seeks End To Law Against Insulting Turkey

GROUP SEEKS END TO LAW AGAINST INSULTING TURKEY
By Sebnem Arsu

The New York Times
Feb 8 2007

ISTANBUL, Feb. 8 – A group of civic organizations today proposed
changes to Article 301, a controversial section of the Turkish penal
code that makes insulting Turkey or Turkishness a crime. The section
has been used against intellectuals, journalists and writers like the
Nobel Prize winner Orhan Pamuk and the newspaper editor Hrant Dink,
who was shot dead in an Istanbul street in January.

But critics said the new proposal uses archaic language that would be
just as vague and hard to interpret as the existing article, which
the government refuses to abolish, and would not solve the problems
with the current law.

Many Turks believe that Article 301 is primarily to blame for the
murder of Mr. Dink, an ethnic Armenian who was prosecuted under the
law for comments he made about the mass deaths of Armenians before
and during World War I. His conviction publicly labeled him as a
traitor against the state in the eyes of many Turkish nationalists.

The subject of the mass deaths of the 1910’s is, nearly a century
later, still among the sorest in Turkey. Many historians call the
episode genocide on the part of the Ottoman army, but the Turkish
government denies that and insists that both ethnic Turks and ethnic
Armenians suffered in those years of wartime hardship.

Turkish courts and nationalist groups tend to interpret any public
statements that contradict that official version of events as an
"insult against the Turkish state" and a crime under Article 301.

Mr. Dink’s death reinvigorated efforts to amend or repeal the law,
which has helped attract harsh criticism of the Turkish government by
the European Union for suppressing freedom of expression by prosecuting
writers and intellectuals.

The government has responded by allowing civic organizations from
across the political spectrum to take the lead in drafting proposed
amendments to the law, while insisting that it must be retained in
some form.

"Leading up to the general elections in November, the government
has escaped from political responsibility on a controversial issue
like Article 301 in fear of losing voters," said Gencay Gurun, the
general secretary of Turkish Chamber of Doctors, which dropped out
of the amendment-drafting effort and called instead for total repeal.

"Changes are only a facade, and can never prevent bitter consequences,
as we’ve witnessed with Mr. Dink’s murder."

The new proposal, signed by 10 major civic organizations, is meant to
draw a clearer distinction between criticism and insult, but critics
say it fails to do so. For example, in place of a crime of "insulting
Turkishness," the new draft outlaws "openly abasing and deriding"
the Turkish identity.

The spokesman for the group, Davut Okutcu of the Economic Development
Foundation, acknowledged that the amendments would make no difference
unless the mind set of the country’s judges also changed, toward
greater tolerance of free expression.

"We do not claim that this is the best version," Mr. Okutcu said in a
telephone interview. "We consider this draft as an encouragement to
support better application of law, which will ultimately be worded
by Turkey’s lawmakers."

Article 301 is not the only provision of Turkish law that has been
interpreted to support prosecution of speech and opinion. Perihan
Magden, a columnist for the newspaper Radikal, was charged under a law
that makes encouraging draft-age men from fulfilling their mandatory
military service a crime. That law was not addressed by the committee.

Ms. Magden, who was given police protection following Mr. Dink’s death,
said the proposed changes to Article 301 were too small to matter.

"The fact that I have to live in my own country under police
protection shows the government acknowledgment that something is
wrong," Ms. Magden said. "They can and they have to prevent this."

The government, on the other hand, says that the European Union
bears much of the responsibility for an underlying problem in Turkey,
rising nationalist feeling that manifests itself as intolerance of
criticism and resentment of demands from abroad for change.

Egemen Bagis, a spokesman for the ruling Justice and Development party,
noted that many Turks were angered when the union froze talks over
possible Turkish membership in 2006, after Turkey had worked for years
to overhaul its laws at the union’s request to qualify for membership.

The stated reason for the freeze was that Turkey had failed to open its
ports and airports to trade with the ethnic Greek part of Cyprus, whose
government is internationally recognized and belongs to the union (the
ethnic Turkish government in the northern part of the divided island
is recognized only by Turkey). But many here saw that as a pretext,
and that rising anti-Muslim prejudice in Europe was the real reason.

"We need the motivation by the E.U. in order to improve freedom of
expression alongside other democratic reforms in Turkey," Mr. Bagis
said. "The E.U.’s double standard in treating Turkey’s candidacy,
however, is the primary reason behind the growing nationalist
tendencies in Turkey, and we expect the E.U. to change this attitude
for a better future in Turkey."

Schiff Introduces Genocide Measure

SCHIFF INTRODUCES GENOCIDE MEASURE
By Charles Cooper

Burbank Weekly, CA
Arcadia Weekly, CA
Pasadena Independent, CA
Feb 8 2007

"The Affirmation of the U.S. Record on the Armenian Genocide"
resolution has bipartisan support from of over 150 Members of the
House of Representatives. It calls on the President to "ensure that the
foreign policy of the United States reflects appropriate understanding"
of the "Armenian Genocide" and to "accurately characterize the
systematic and deliberate annihilation of 1,500,000 Armenians as
genocide."

The resolution also has the support of the Armenian National
Committee of America (ANCA), the Armenian Assembly of America (AAA),
and US-Armenia Public Affairs Committee (USAPAC).

A total of 38 Republican members have signed on as co-sponsors,
including D avid Dreier, and 39 member of the House delegation from
California

Congressman Adam Schiff, who has been the designated point man in the
effort to have the U.S. Government recognize the Armenian Genocide,
has introduced a new resolution, which may have a stronger chance
of success.

In the past, the Republican leadership has bottled up the matter in
Congress, to avoid putting President George Bush on the spot with
U.S ally Turkey.

This year, with Democrats in control of both houses, the likelihood
of success is greater.

Schiff was joined at the news conference by original cosponsors of
the resolution Reps. Frank Pallone, Jr. (D-NJ), George Radanovich
(R-CA) and Joe Knollenberg (R-MI) and Genocide survivors Mrs. Rose
Baboyan and Mrs. Sirarpi Khoyan, who recently turned 100 years old.

"The United States has a compelling historical and moral reason to
recognize the Armenian Genocide, which cost a million and a half
people their lives," said Rep. Schiff. "But we also have a powerful
contemporary reason as well — how can we take effective action
against the genocide in Darfur if we lack the will to condemn genocide
whenever and wherever it occurs? With the new leadership in Congress,
I am hopeful we can finally get this resolution passed."

Nagorno Karabakh Dispute Takes To Cyber Space

NAGORNO-KARABAKH DISPUTE TAKES TO CYBER SPACE
Rovshan Ismayilov and Onnik Krikorian

EurasiaNet, NY
Feb 8 2007

The differences between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the disputed
territory of Nagorno-Karabakh may at times seem never-ending, but
in their response to what appears to be an ongoing cyber conflict
between Armenian and Azerbaijani hackers, residents of both countries
are standing united in a push for peace.

Clashes between Armenian and Azerbaijani hackers are nothing new, but
the most recent "cyber war" has gained greater resonance. As was the
case in 2006, international observers have forecast that 2007 could
witness a breakthrough in negotiations between the two sides over
Nagorno-Karabakh. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].

At the same time, the potential for online debates about the
territorial dispute is growing rapidly, as the number of Internet
users in both countries continues to expand.

The latest cyber conflict began on January 22 when Armenian hackers
attacked the website of Azerbaijan’s public television station. The
attackers, who identified themselves as members of Armenia’s security
services, posted Armenia’s state emblem on the site’s home page,
and warned that they would kill an Azerbaijani hacker identified as
"Bacioglu" (a slang Azeri word for "nephew"), if the individual did
not stop sabotaging Armenian websites.

But the threat did little to dissuade "Bacioglu." On January 29, the
Azerbaijani hacker attacked five Armenian websites (openarmenia.com,
openarmenia.ru, tamanyan.org, homeopathy.am, photoblogs.am). He posted
Azerbaijan’s state emblem and images of Azerbaijani civilians killed
in Nagorno-Karabakh on the sites’ home pages, along with a pledge to
"fight you and all Armenians on earth as long as I live" and a threat
to destroy the official website of Armenian President Robert Kocharian.

The hacker urged Azerbaijani TV channels to cover the news, warning
that "If they don’t, it could affect my enthusiasm."

On February 5, a group of Armenian hackers calling themselves "axteam"
attacked two more Azerbaijani sites — list.az and hayat.az — as
"revenge for Bacioglu," according to text posted on hayat.az.

The Armenian security service has rejected the claim that it is
connected with any of these attacks.

Meanwhile, few in either Armenia or Azerbaijan appear to support the
hackers, despite, in the case of Azerbaijan, an appeal by "Bacioglu"
for Azerbaijanis to back his "enthusiasm."

In comments to the independent ANS television channel on January 31,
Azerbaijani Communications and Information Technology Minister Ali
Abbasov urged both sides to stop the "electronic war."

"The electronic war which has started between Armenia and Azerbaijan
is something very unpleasant," Abbasov said. The minister suggested
that both countries should sign the European convention on cyber
crimes to avoid similar incidents in the future.

As in Armenia, Azerbaijani observers largely see the attacks as
time misspent. "There will not be a winner or a loser in this war,"
commented Ilgar Mammadov, an independent Baku-based political
analyst. "That is why I believe it is just wasting time."

Osman Gunduz, president of Multimedia, a Baku-based non-governmental
organization involved with projects promoting the Internet and
information technologies in Azerbaijan, shares this view. "In both
Azerbaijan and Armenia, the governments and security services have
nothing to do with it," said Gunduz. "These attacks are undertaken
by groups of young people who are expressing themselves this way and
showing their attitude toward the conflict between the countries."

Seven years have passed since tit-for-tat attacks by Azerbaijani and
Armenian hackers almost became an all-out "cyber war." In January
and February 2000, after an ethnic Armenian in California launched
Aliyev.com, a site that disseminated "black propaganda" about then
Azerbaijani President Heydar Aliyev, Azerbaijani hackers launched an
attack against Armenian Internet sites that included National State
Television H1, and several online resources about the Turkish massacre
of hundreds of thousands of ethnic Armenians during World War I.

At the time, the Armenian foreign ministry called the attacks a
"violation of human rights," and a counter-offensive was launched by
a group of Armenian hackers, Liazor. The Russian-language Azerbaijani
daily Zerkalo (Mirror) reported that the group threatened to take down
the entire Azerbaijani Internet. Indeed, the websites of many large
Internet users, including humanitarian organizations, in Azerbaijan
were hacked, and the email connections of major Azerbaijani newspapers
disrupted.

Since then, the attacks on Armenian sites have continued. Before the
most recent run of hacking, in March 2006 Azerbaijani hackers broke
into the website of Armenia’s Eurovision Song Contest entry.

But Ruben Muradian, technical director of PanArmenian.Net, an online
news agency, says that any successful hacks from the outside are
because of careless system administrators or complacency among website
owners, not because of a concentrated cyber-war campaign.

"Any serious site should take care of its security," he said. "We
are in a situation of no-war and no-peace, and we have enemies. We
have to be prepared."

Official figures on Internet usage in both Armenia and Azerbaijan are
sketchy at best, but, as elsewhere in the former Soviet Union, user
numbers are believed to be increasing rapidly. A recent survey by the
International Telecommunication Union put the number of Azerbaijani
Internet users at 5.6 per 100 people, and the number of Armenian
users at slightly less, 5.03.

The Baku-based non-governmental organization Multimedia, which monitors
Internet usage, estimates that Azerbaijan now has some 700,000
Internet users — about 9 percent of the country’s population —
a figure that is nearly four times as high as in 2000, during the
last Armenian-Azerbaijani hacking conflict.

Despite the broader user base, the attack on Armenian sites, however,
did not mark the introduction of new, hi-tech techniques. After
accidentally opening an attachment in an email sent by an "Artur
Oganyan," all of the login details for the sites hosted on the same
US server were sent to the sender of the so-called "Trojan Horse,"
a document that contains a virus or spyware that can disseminate
a user’s password. A message stating that Nagorno-Karabakh was
"historical Azeri land" along with photographs of victims from the
Armenian attack on the Azerbaijani village of Khojali during the
Karabakh war replaced normal content.

As of February 8, the original content of all but one of the Armenian
sites was still unavailable online.

Samvel Martirosian, a local analyst and co-founder of Open Armenia,
an online forum that includes an area for discussion on the Karabakh
conflict between Armenian and Azerbaijani users, says that he is
convinced that this is not necessarily the start of new hostilities
on the Internet. As do other members of the Armenian IT community,
he strongly doubts that Armenians were responsible for the attack on
Azerbaijan’s public television site.

"The last real war was in 2000," Martirosian said. "Of course, small
attacks always come, and usually from Azeris. This time, I don’t know
for certain who attacked the sites in Azerbaijan, but I don’t think
he was an Armenian."

Martirosian points to the type of attacks experienced by Azerbaijani
sites in recent weeks and says that they are not the same as in
2000 when Liazor employed more sophisticated methods by modifying
site content. "If you destroy a website, all you succeed in doing is
taking it down for a few days and then publicizing its existence,"
he said. "That’s usually the work of some teenager living outside of
Armenia or Azerbaijan. Real hackers are more intelligent."

A report on the Azerbaijani news site Today.az that the Azerbaijani
public television website was compromised by the same method employed
against the five Armenian sites has fostered the belief in Armenia
that only one hacker is responsible.

Both PanArmenian.net’s Muradian and Martirosian second that view. "It
looks to me as though this is being done to provoke a war between
Armenian and Azerbaijani hackers," said Martirosian. "Thankfully,
one group of Azeri hackers has said it will not do anything now that
their Ministry of Communication has called for restraint, and there
is nothing to indicate the involvement of Armenians so far."

But domestic controversy surrounds one Azerbaijani government measure
to bring a halt to the hostilities. Communications and Information
Technology Minister Abbasov recently announced that all sites with
the ".az" domain, currently hosted in the United States, will soon be
relocated to Azerbaijan. "One of the reasons why Public TV’s website
was attacked so easily is that its server is located abroad, in the
US," Abbasov said, as quoted by Echo newspaper on January 31.

Some Azerbaijani Internet users see these plans as only providing the
government with greater control over digital media content. "It is
very difficult to attack our site, even theoretically," fumed Elnur
Baimov, editor-in-chief of Day.az, a popular Azerbaijani news site,
in a message posted on his site’s forum. "Who will provide us with
such security in Azerbaijan? Of course, nobody!"

"All Internet providers in Azerbaijan are under [the government’s]
control," Baimov continued. "I consider these plans a threat to freedom
of speech on the Internet." The government has not yet responded to
the charge. There are more than 3,000 websites currently registered
in Azerbaijan, according to data published on Day.az.

Other web users, however, believe the government should expand its
efforts to strengthen the security of Azerbaijani websites. "There is a
process of establishing ‘e-government’ in Azerbaijan," commented Rasim
Aliguliyev, director of the Information Technologies Institute of the
Azerbaijani National Academy of Sciences. "Therefore, the issue of
[the] security of web resources is becoming vital," Aliguliyev told
Trend news agency on January 22.

Many Armenians agree: "We cannot underestimate the role of the Internet
in our lives," commented one 22-year-old customer care professional
working for a leading foreign IT company based in Armenia. "[B]ut I
can’t see any serious person — even one concerned about the [Karabakh]
conflict — busying themselves with such childish ‘efforts.’ I would
say it’s all being done by [computer] nerds."

Editor’s Note: Rovshan Ismayilov is a freelance journalist based in
Baku. Onnik Krikorian is a freelance journalist and photographer from
the United Kingdom based in the Republic of Armenia. He works for a
variety of publications and international organizations.

ANKARA: He Said He Would Talk And He Did

HE SAID HE WOULD TALK AND HE DID

Sabah, Turkey
Feb 8 2007

Yasin Hayal initially accepted responsibility for being the solicitor
of the Hrant Dink murder, upon being arrested, however, when learning
that Tuncel was an informant, he changed his tune, placing all
responsibility on Tuncel.

Yasin Hayal, after his father told SABAH, "my son will explain
everything," answered the questions of the public prosecutors that
interrogated him in jail. However, this time he said: "the bomb
attack on McDonalds in Trabzon was solicited by Erhan as was the
assassination of Hrant Dink. He had everything done." In Hayal’s
initial interrogation upon arrest, he had confessed to being
responsible for everything.

His statement changed: "Tuncel did everything"

Since the first day he was arrested, Yasin Hayal accepted being
the solicitor in both the Hrant Dink murder as well as in the Mc
Donald’s bombing. However, after learning he was an informant Hayal
then claimed Tuncel was the solicitor of the murder. Hayal also said:
"if I had known he was an informant, I would have killed him."

Yasin Hayal was arrested and sent to jail for the solicitation of the
murder of Hrant Dink. He did what he told his father he would do over
the phone from jail and told the prosecutors, that questioned him
for a second time, that the idea of murder was actually Erhan Tuncel’s.

He had insistently stated that he solicited this murder when he
was first arrested; but now he said that he had decided to talk
since he learned that Erhan Tuncel was a police informant. He said:
"the bomb attack on McDonalds in Trabzon was solicited by Erhan as
was the assassination of Hrant Dink. He had everything done."

Civic Groups Propose Changes To Law On Insulting Turkishness

CIVIC GROUPS PROPOSE CHANGES TO LAW ON INSULTING TURKISHNESS
By Sebnem Arsu

International Herald Tribune, France
Feb 8 2007

ISTANBUL: A group of civic organizations submitted suggestions Thursday
for rewording a section of the Turkish penal code under which noted
intellectuals and writers have been charged with the crime of insulting
the Turkish identity and state.

But some groups broke with the main umbrella organization and said
the law need to be revoked, not amended.

Even Deputy Prime Minister Abdullatif Sener said that textual changes
would not mean much in themselves.

Many in Turkey consider the law, known as Article 301, to be at the
root of the murder of the Armenian-Turkish journalist Hrant Dink last
month. According to this argument, his conviction under the article,
for comments he made about the mass killings of Armenians by Turkish
forces in the early 20th century, branded him a traitor in the eyes
of many Turks and put his life in jeopardy.

For Turkey, the Armenian question is among the thorniest issues of
free speech, since a characterization of the killings as genocide
is often interpreted by the courts as an "insult against the Turkish
state" under Article 301.

Late last year, following harsh EU criticism of Article 301, the
government indicated that it was receptive to changes in the law,
but not its abolition.

That was not enough for one civic group – the Turkish Chamber of
Doctors – which broke with the umbrella group that made the proposal
Thursday.

"Leading up to the general elections in November, the government
has escaped from political responsibility on a controversial issue
like Article 301 in fear of losing voters," said Gencay Gurun, the
general secretary of the doctors’ group. "Changes are only a facade
and can never prevent bitter consequences, as we’ve witnessed with
Mr. Dink’s murder."

Signed by 10 civic organizations, the proposal aims to better
distinguish between legal criticism and illegal insult. Instead of
"insulting Turkishness" it the draft issued Thursday proposed new
wording, of "openly abasing and deriding" the Turkish identity.

The umbrella group’s spokesman, Davut Okutcu, said "we do not claim
that this is the best version."

"We consider this draft as an encouragement to support better
applications of law, which will ultimately be worded by Turkey’s
lawmakers," Okutcu said.

The next step is for the government to assess the proposal and decide
on the exact wording it will propose to Parliament for changing the
law. Political analysts say the government did not take the lead in
order not to provoke the nationalists.

Perihan Magden, a columnist for the Radikal newspaper who was given
private police protection following Dink’s death, said the suggested
changes were too mild to make a difference.

"The fact that I have to live in my own country under police protection
shows the government acknowledgment that something’s is wrong," said
Magden, who was once charged under a separate law that penalizes
those who discourage military service. "They can and they have to
prevent this."

A Little Advice

A LITTLE ADVICE
By Andre Coleman and Margaret McAustin

Pasadena Weekly, CA
Feb 8 2007

Outgoing councilman offers some opinions on what candidates in the
race for his District 2 seat should be talking about

Before attending a forum tonight, candidates for the District 2
City Council seat being vacated by three-term Councilman Paul Little
should listen to what Little has to say, which, essentially, boils
down to this: Know the people and get some distance from the opinions
of your opponents.

"I worked really hard and had a really good core group of people
devoted to the campaign and there were a couple of issues where I was
the only one to take a position," Little said recently. "That seemed
to resonate with a lot of the voters."

Unfortunately the opposite seems to be happening as the three
candidates – Margaret McAustin, Stacy Lewis and Jim Lomako – all
seem to be taking similar stands on major issues such as development,
traffic and education.

"The biggest challenge is getting growth under control in the city as
a whole," said the 59-year-old Lomako, a longtime legal investigator
who is not a lawyer but served as a former president of the Pasadena
chapter of the ACLU, and served as a member of both the city’s
Community Development Committee and the Design Commission.

"I think the most serious problem is we have been building at a rate
that exceeds what the General Plan allows. I’m making it an issue
because other candidates have not been talking about it," he said.

But they are talking about it, and sometimes they sound almost
like Lomako.

"I think we’re nearing the limits of the growth allowed in the
district according to the 1994 General Plan," said McAustin, 53,
a member of the city’s Planning Commission who helped start two
neighborhood associations, serving as president of the Pasadena
Highlands Neighborhood Association.

"I think we need to evaluate the growth in terms of the number of
people the Pasadena infrastructure can support. We need a comprehensive
approach to growth that evaluates the totality of all growth. Not just
a project by project approach," said McAustin, an executive with the
Esteve Group, an International Commodities firm based in Dallas.

Last year, McAustin worked as a neighborhood outreach consultant
for the Ambassador West Project, a planned community of more than
200 senior citizen condos on the former Ambassador College campus,
where she dealt with three neighborhood associations in areas close
to the project, including the highly anti-development West Pasadena
Residents Association, WPRA.

McAustin said she was appointed to the Planning Commission after taking
the Ambassador job, and said she never participated in any commission
discussions regarding the Ambassador West Project, which was approved
by the commission and is scheduled for City Council consideration on
Feb. 26.

"I am proud of the work I did. I even got the WPRA to support the
project," she said.

Although Little praised all the candidates overall, he observed that
there are some things that are also important but aren’t being talked
about much by any of them.

For starters, District 2 boasts a strong Latino community and a
burgeoning Armenian-American population. Much of the district includes
central and eastern portions of the city, with District 2 covering much
of the city’s central core, including East Colorado Boulevard between
Wilson and Oak avenues, an area buzzing with residential development.

In the neighborhoods north of Colorado, the district contains two
historic landmark districts, and could gain one more, with both
representing more than 1,000 homes. Over the past few years, the
district has become a prime target for developers.

"Preserving open space and development issues are important, but we
have more important issues in Pasadena. There are too many people
who are poor and homeless and too few resources dealing with those
problems. We get sidetracked spending significant amounts of money on
other things, and they are worthwhile, but we have to look at other
issues like violence in the minority community, and the underlying
issues that cause these problems," Little said.

Last year, 93 of the 124 arr-ests made by Pasadena police for suspicion
of prostitution-related crimes were made in District 2.

When it comes to homeless people, it’s hard to quantify those
numbers on a district-by-district basis. However, as the city’s
population climbs, so too does its homeless community seem to grow,
with an estimated 1,500 homeless people now calling Pasadena home on
a given night.

But along with that, District 2 wrestles with its own issues of ethnic
diversity and cultural identity. Newly immigrated Armenian-American
kids, for instance, enter schools, pick up the fashions, the fads
and all the trappings, "and that creates some tensions," Little noted.

Several years ago, these types of tensions between Armenian-American
and African-American children turned into violence at Marshall
Fundamental School, located in the heart of District 2 on Allen Avenue,
forcing campus security to lock down the campus and the now-defunct
Pasadena Unified School District Police Force to book and cite nine
students.

Only Lewis, a 43-year-old telecommunications executive, mentioned the
cultural issues associated with those incidents in his interview with
the Weekly.

"There have been some cultural problems which I think can be addressed
by reaching across cultural barriers," said Lewis. "It’s something I am
engaged in doing right now. I have had discussions with the principals
at Marshall and Webster [Elementary School] and have spoken to other
residents about the problem."

Refuting claims that he sounds much like his opponents on some issues,
Lewis has his own take on what some view as runaway development.

"I’m not worried about sounding like everyone else," Lewis said. "I
have a different understanding of development and growth. There is
nothing wrong with development. It is how it is done in Pasadena. The
question is how growth is achieved. Is the community aware of what
is being planned is there transparency in that process? People are
adverse to change. If there is change, everyone should feel like a
stakeholder in it so that there are no surprises.

"It’s not a matter of should we grow," said Lewis, who served as
president of the Brigden Ranch Neighborhood Association. "It’s a
matter of effective growth."

The race generated some controversy last week when a letter to
the editor from a person named "Miriam Brandstedt" appeared in the
Pasadena Star-News, accusing Lomako of being a "dangerous candidate"
who bullied residents to sign a petition supporting a neighborhoods
petition for landmark district status.

According to the city planner, no one named "Miriam Brandstedt" signed
the petition and the address on the letter does not exist. The daily
paper has since apologized.

Little, who has been on the council for 12 years, is resigning
to devote more attention to his son, Cameron who will be attending
college in New York in the fall, and his daughter, Courtney, who is
currently in high school.

"Twelve years is a long time and you get a little bit jaundiced about
how you view things," Little said. "I think if I spent four more
years arguing about the merits of cell phone towers in a remote part
of the city I would go berserk. I have enjoyed working with people,
but I notice that my patience is shorter. I don’t know if I would do
as good a job. It’s time somebody else stepped up."

Ambassador Of Turkmenistan In National Assembly

AMBASSADOR OF TURKMENISTAN IN NATIONAL ASSEMBLY

National Assembly of RA, Armenia
Feb 8 2007

On February 7 the RA National Assembly President Mr. Tigran Torosyan
received Ambassador of Turkmenistan in Armenia Mr. Khidir Saparliyev
on the occasion of the completion of his diplomatic mission in Armenia.

The RA NA President thanked Mr. Ambassador for short, but effective
cooperation, noting that he promoted the development of the
two countries’ relations in its natural way. The relationships
between Armenia and Turkmenistan were and will be friendly: the
two countries have bilateral strong relations; they cooperate in
international structures. Mr. Torosyan highlighted the establishment
of Intergovernmental Committee meeting, which will symbolize the
continuity of the development of inter-state relations. Touching upon
the presidential elections on February 11, the NA President expressed
hope that they will be held in natural way and will ensure sustainable
development for Turkmenistan.

Expressing gratitude to Armenian authorities for cooperation and their
support, Mr. Khidir Saparliyev noted that he gained a lot of friends
during the short time, and Armenia for a long time will remain in
his heart and memory as a second motherland, where one always wishes
to return. He assured that Turkmenistan will continue its first
President’s adopted policy and after the presidential elections on
February 11 the Turkmen-Armenian relations will continue towards
friendship and cooperation. He wished success in the parliamentary
elections in Armenia by expressing confidence that the parliament
of the new convocation will be an exemplary successor of the most
important activity – legislative function – of the state.

Other issues were discussed during the meeting as well.

Hrant Dink: The 1,500,001st Victim Of The Armenian Genocide

HRANT DINK: THE 1,500,001ST VICTIM OF THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE
The Globe – by Galip Ozben

Kurdish Aspect, CO
Feb 8 2007

Hrant was portrayed by the Turkish State as an enemy of the Turkish
nation thanks to the infamous clause 301, writes Globe analyst on
Turkish affairs, Galip Ozben.

Ozben says that unlike the Kurdish case in the country- where it
has been backed by its political and military struggle; the Armenian
cause could only rely on international pressure on Turkey.

Hrant Dink’s assassination outraged Turkey’s democratic opposition
and his funeral on 22 January turned into a mass protest with the
participation of more than a hundred thousand people putting Istanbul’s
major roads to a total halt.

The murder investigation, on the other hand, has been shaking the
foundations of the Turkish establishment, as a conspiracy relating
elements of the Turkish state to the murder unfolds day by day with
more shocking information. Under the circumstances, Premier Erdogan
overtly admitted the existence of a ‘deep state’ and his statement
heralded an intra-state struggle involving the purge of a number of
top security personnel from the ranks of bureaucracy. The murderous
semi-official gang however would not go without a bang: with the
ultra-nationalist MHP raising its voice in support of the murderers,
the whole affair seems to be turning into a counter-offensive by
Turkish nationalism against pro-democracy forces in the country.

The nationalist reaction mainly grows in its condemnation of the
slogans "We are all Hrant Dinks" and "We are all Armenians" expressed
in Kurdish and Armenian languages in addition to Turkish at Hrant’s
funeral march. This was the first in Turkey’s modern history, where
despite international guarantees, the Armenian minority have been
systematically degraded, silenced and persecuted. A consequence of
these policies has been the constant decrease of Turkey’s Armenian
population since the 1920s from 300,000 to around 60,000 in the year
2006. In fact, Hrant Dink’s assassination has been perceived by many as
a major link in this chain of constant state persecution. In Hrant’s
radical democrat personality, the Armenian community of Turkey had
found for the first time an internationally recognized representative,
who courageously broke a ninety-year-long silence about the Armenian
genocide and the constant denial, degradation and persecution that have
been in effect ever since. Hrant also led the Armenian community to
break their shell by correctly presenting the cause of his people as
a majorn concern of the broader democratic movement in Turkey. Such
dialogue had also served to break the nationalist prejudices of
the many within Turkey’s democratic opposition. For many Turks,
the Armenian cause, which had been presented in school textbooks,
‘scientific’ works, official statements and consequently popular
discourse as an exclusively foreign conspiracy, was gradually gaining
legitimacy.

Hrant’s March

In these circumstances, Hrant had become a natural target of hardline
nationalists. And if one wing of hardline nationalism is political,
the other is certainly judicial. The world is aware that authors
Orhan Pamuk and Elif Shafak have been tried for the breach of the
infamous clause 301 and acquitted. However, very few are aware that
Hrant Dink and a number of Kurdish lawyers have been the only ones who
were convicted by this clause to imprisonment. Obviously, belonging to
an ethnicity other than Turkish was in itself "degrading Turkishness."

Hrant was thus portrayed by the Turkish State as an enemy of the
Turkish nation thanks to the infamouse clause 301. He began to receive
death threats and on one occasion he was threatened by Istanbul’s
vice governor. The threats, official and unofficial alike, had the
same demand: "Stop talking or else you’ll be silenced". Like many
of us, Hrant already knew the scenario of what had happened in the
1990s to Vedat Aydin, Musa Anter and tens of Kurdish journalists
and intellectuals. After courageously stating the cause of their
people, their death penalties had to be executed for the sake
of the survival of the Turkish order based on the denial of the
Kurdish identity through political, economic and military coercion
in addition to systematic policies of demographic engineering and
cultural assimilation.

There certainly are limits to this resemblance: Firstly, the eliminated
Kurdish intelligentsia was speaking on behalf of more than one third of
Turkey’s population, in comparison to no more than 60,000 Armenians,
mainly concentrated in certain neighbourhoods of Istanbul. Secondly,
the Kurdish intelligentsia’s stance corresponded to the emergence
of a strong Kurdish political and military challenge around the
country in addition to the emergence of a de facto Kurdish entity
in northern Iraq. The Armenian diaspora in Europe and the US, and
the former Soviet republic of Armenia have no comparable effect over
Turkish politics. In these circumstances, the only force to favour
the Armenian cause has been the international pressure over Turkey,
which has tangibly intensified in parallel to the Turkish prospect
of membership to the European Union.

‘Obscuring the Facts’

Such pressure, however, vindicates further the nationalist fantasies
about fighting against foreign threats led by imaginary Armenian
‘masterplan’ of Turkey’s disintegration. They spark further official
and popular versions of nationalism, which have been united in a
persistant chorus of denial of the historical events ever since their
occurrence in the 19th and early 20th centuries that resulted in the
violent elimination of the Armenian population of the Ottoman Empire.

Following the French Parliament’s October 2006 bill that criminalizes
the denial of the Armenian genocide, the Turkish government issued a
call for historians to form an international commission to study the
event and offered to open its archives. This invitation, however,
was made by the head of the official Turkish History Institute,
Professor Yusuf Halacoglu, who had already stated that ‘there was
no genocide but some deaths from diseases and from the attacks on
the Armenian deportation convoys by Kurdish bandits.’ This statement
shows no progress in the Turkish official discourse, which had been
stated boldly in 1990 by Nuzhet Kandemir, the then Turkish Ambassador
to the US, that the Armenian deaths were ‘a result of a tragic civil
war initiated by Armenian nationalists’.

In addition to the categoric denial, and the intensive domestic
propaganda that it was in fact the Armenians who massacred the Turks,
Turkish ‘scientific’ officials backed by a fistful of internationally
degraded advisors, such as Professor Justin McCharty and Professor
Norman Stone, have been working hard on contingency plans, in case they
lost the battle of denial. In the Turkish media there has been growing
mention that the deportation had nothing to do with the republic of
Turkey, but it was an Ottoman Empire affair. There are others, relating
the whole event to the orders of the CUP (Committee of Union and
Progress) dictatorship, who were practically ruling the Empire at the
time. There has also been growing mention of the Kurdish involvement
in the Armenian genocide, which hopes to imply that it was not the
Turks or the Turkish state but the Kurds who were responsible for the
genocide. Some writers even hint at the German responsibility from the
genocide because the Turkish military was under German command at the
time. ‘Many of the Turkish efforts’, comments historian Taner Akcam,
‘aimed to obscure the facts, rather than dispute a false charge.’

Internationally, Turkish government, diplomats and academics have
been fighting hard to maintain their ‘thesis’ based on genocide
denial. Turkey is known to have offered funding for academic programmes
in universities such as Princeton and Georgetown. In 1998, UCLA’s
history department voted to reject a $1m offer to endow a programme
in Turkish and Ottoman studies because it was conditional on denying
the Armenian genocide. In August 2000, Turkey threatened Microsoft
with serious reprisals unless all mention of the Armenian genocide
was removed from an online encyclopaedia. According to Professor
Colin Tatz, an Australian academic, "Turkey has used a mix of academic
sophistication and diplomatic thuggery to put both memory and history
in reverse gear".

Most of the thuggery against Turkish citizens is performed
domestically, where any mention of the Armenian genocide is liable
to punishment by the Turkish state, to lynch attempts by nationalist
mobs, as has been observed in the recent trials of a number of writers
including Orhan Pamuk, and to political assassination as in Hrant
Dink’s case. School textbooks and the media present the Armenian
Genocide as a lie made up to degrade the Turkish nation.

According to these ‘sources’, Turks were subjected to big massacres
at the turn of the century until Ataturk emerged to save them from
their enemies. However, as the psychiatric research on the mechanism
of denial demonstrates, the actors engaged in denial are always
deeply aware of the fact of the matter, and this knowledge surfaces
from time to time as slips of tongue. This can be observed in the
threat issued by the founder of modern Turkish racism, Nihal Atsiz,
to Turkey’s Kurds in the 1930s: "I advise the Kurds to find a place to
go, for instance demand a country in Africa from the United Nations,
and ask the Armenians about the consequences if they don’t comply
with this advice."

Similar outbursts can be observed in the contemporary rightwing
discourse: "Let us be clear to the world’s public: in the past we
punished all the infamous half-casts, who, not content with profiting
from our lands, attacked our possessions, the lives and honour of the
Turks. We know that our forefathers were right, and if we were to face
such threats again, we would not hesitate to do what is necessary"
(Akit, 12 February 2001).

l

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.kurdishaspect.com/doc0208GO.htm