Car of Panorama.am Website’s Owner Burned

CAR OF PANORAMA.AM WEBSITE’S OWNER BURNED

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 9, NOYAN TAPAN. Nissan Exterra car of Ara
Saghatelian, owner of the newspaper "My Right" and panorama.am
website, was burned on February 8 at about 8:15 p.m. Speaking about
the details of this incident, A. Saghatelian said: "The car was in
the editorial office’s yard. In the evening, I uasually come to the
office to familiarize myself with the work done, give advice and take
some coordinating actions. About 6-7 minutes after entering the
office, I heard the sound of my car’s alarm. I went out and saw my car
burning. I took off my jacket and attempted to put out the fire, at
the same time shouting to neighbors to bring water. At that moment I
noticed a bottle with gasoline on the car roof. Later I found another
two bottles near the car." A. Saghatelain does not suspect
anyone. "I cannot tell whether the incident has a relation to my media
oulets or not. I have no personal enemies," he noted. At the same time
he said that they work "in a normal way and do not take rude steps,
thinking that speech freedom has its reasonable limits and presupposes
social responsibility." An investigation was initiated in connection
with the case.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Target Iran: US able to strike in the spring

Target Iran: US able to strike in the spring

Despite denials, Pentagon plans for possible attack on nuclear sites
are well advanced

Ewen MacAskill in Washington
Saturday February 10, 2007
The Guardian

US preparations for an air strike against Iran are at an advanced
stage, in spite of repeated public denials by the Bush administration,
according to informed sources in Washington.
The present military build-up in the Gulf would allow the US to mount
an attack by the spring. But the sources said that if there was an
attack, it was more likely next year, just before Mr Bush leaves
office.

Neo-conservatives, particularly at the Washington-based American
Enterprise Institute, are urging Mr Bush to open a new front against
Iran. So too is the vice-president, Dick Cheney. The state department
and the Pentagon are opposed, as are Democratic congressmen and the
overwhelming majority of Republicans. The sources said Mr Bush had not
yet made a decision. The Bush administration insists the military
build-up is not offensive but aimed at containing Iran and forcing it
to make diplomatic concessions. The aim is to persuade Tehran to curb
its suspect nuclear weapons programme and abandon ambitions for
regional expansion.

Robert Gates, the new US defence secretary, said yesterday: "I don’t
know how many times the president, secretary [of state Condoleezza]
Rice and I have had to repeat that we have no intention of attacking
Iran."
But Vincent Cannistraro, a Washington-based intelligence analyst,
shared the sources’ assessment that Pentagon planning was well under
way. "Planning is going on, in spite of public disavowals by
Gates. Targets have been selected. For a bombing campaign against
nuclear sites, it is quite advanced. The military assets to carry this
out are being put in place."

He added: "We are planning for war. It is incredibly dangerous."

Deployment

Mr Cannistraro, who worked for the CIA and the National Security
Council, stressed that no decision had been made.

Last month Mr Bush ordered a second battle group led by the aircraft
carrier USS John Stennis to the Gulf in support of the USS
Eisenhower. The USS Stennis is due to arrive within the next 10
days. Extra US Patriot missiles have been sent to the region, as well
as more minesweepers, in anticipation of Iranian retaliatory action.

In another sign that preparations are under way, Mr Bush has ordered
oil reserves to be stockpiled.

The danger is that the build-up could spark an accidental war. Iranian
officials said on Thursday that they had tested missiles capable of
hitting warships in the Gulf.

Colonel Sam Gardiner, a former air force officer who has carried out
war games with Iran as the target, supported the view that planning
for an air strike was under way: "Gates said there is no planning for
war. We know this is not true. He possibly meant there is no plan for
an immediate strike. It was sloppy wording.

"All the moves being made over the last few weeks are consistent with
what you would do if you were going to do an air strike. We have to
throw away the notion the US could not do it because it is too tied up
in Iraq. It is an air operation."

One of the main driving forces behind war, apart from the
vice-president’s office, is the AEI, headquarters of the
neo-conservatives. A member of the AEI coined the slogan "axis of
evil" that originally lumped Iran in with Iraq and North Korea. Its
influence on the White House appeared to be in decline last year amid
endless bad news from Iraq, for which it had been a cheerleader. But
in the face of opposition from Congress, the Pentagon and state
department, Mr Bush opted last month for an AEI plan to send more
troops to Iraq. Will he support calls from within the AEI for a strike
on Iran?

Josh Muravchik, a Middle East specialist at the AEI, is among its most
vocal supporters of such a strike.

"I do not think anyone in the US is talking about invasion. We have
been chastened by the experience of Iraq, even a hawk like myself."
But an air strike was another matter. The danger of Iran having a
nuclear weapon "is not just that it might use it out of the blue but
as a shield to do all sorts of mischief. I do not believe there will
be any way to stop this happening other than physical force."

Mr Bush is part of the American generation that refuses to forgive
Iran for the 1979-81 hostage crisis. He leaves office in January 2009
and has said repeatedly that he does not want a legacy in which Iran
has achieved superpower status in the region and come close to
acquiring a nuclear weapon capability. The logic of this is that if
diplomatic efforts fail to persuade Iran to stop uranium enrichment
then the only alternative left is to turn to the military.

Mr Muravchik is intent on holding Mr Bush to his word: "The Bush
administration have said they would not allow Iran nuclear
weapons. That is either bullshit or they mean it as a clear code: we
will do it if we have to. I would rather believe it is not hot air."

Other neo-cons elsewhere in Washington are opposed to an air strike
but advocate a different form of military action, supporting Iranian
armed groups, in particular the Mujahideen-e Khalq (MEK), even though
the state department has branded it a terrorist organisation.

Raymond Tanter, founder of the Iran Policy Committee, which includes
former officials from the White House, state department and
intelligence services, is a leading advocate of support for the
MEK. If it comes to an air strike, he favours bunker-busting bombs. "I
believe the only way to get at the deeply buried sites at Natanz and
Arak is probably to use bunker-buster bombs, some of which are nuclear
tipped. I do not believe the US would do that but it has sold them to
Israel."

Opposition support

Another neo-conservative, Meyrav Wurmser, director of the centre for
Middle East policy at the Hudson Institute, also favours supporting
Iranian opposition groups. She is disappointed with the response of
the Bush administration so far to Iran and said that if the aim of US
policy after 9/11 was to make the Middle East safer for the US, it was
not working because the administration had stopped at Iraq. "There is
not enough political will for a strike. There seems to be various
notions of what the policy should be."

In spite of the president’s veto on negotiation with Tehran, the state
department has been involved since 2003 in back-channel approaches and
meetings involving Iranian officials and members of the Bush
administration or individuals close to it. But when last year the
Iranian president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, sent a letter as an overture,
the state department dismissed it within hours of its arrival.

Support for negotiations comes from centrist and liberal
thinktanks. Afshin Molavi, a fellow of the New America Foundation,
said: "To argue diplomacy has not worked is false because it has not
been tried. Post-90s and through to today, when Iran has been ready to
dance, the US refused, and when the US has been ready to dance, Iran
has refused. We are at a stage where Iran is ready to walk across the
dance floor and the US is looking away."

He is worried about "a miscalculation that leads to an accidental
war".

The catalyst could be Iraq. The Pentagon said yesterday that it had
evidence – serial numbers of projectiles as well as explosives – of
Iraqi militants’ weapons that had come from Iran. In a further sign of
the increased tension, Iran’s main nuclear negotiator, Ali Larijani,
cancelled a visit to Munich for what would have been the first formal
meeting with his western counterparts since last year.

If it does come to war, Mr Muravchik said Iran would retaliate, but
that on balance it would be worth it to stop a country that he said
had "Death to America" as its official slogan.

"We have to gird our loins and prepare to absorb the counter-shock,"
he said.

War of words

"If Iran escalates its military action in Iraq to the detriment of our
troops and/or innocent Iraqi people, we will respond firmly" George
Bush, in an interview with National Public Radio

"The Iranians clearly believe that we are tied down in Iraq, that they
have the initiative, that they are in position to press us in many
ways. They are doing nothing to be constructive in Iraq at this point"
Robert Gates

"I think it’s been pretty well-known that Iran is fishing in troubled
waters" Dick Cheney

"It is absolutely parallel. They’re using the same dance steps –
demonise the bad guys, the pretext of diplomacy, keep out of
negotiations, use proxies. It is Iraq redux" Philip Giraldi, a former
CIA counter- terrorism specialist, in Vanity Fair, on echoes of the
run-up to the war in Iraq

"US policymakers and analysts know that the Iranian nation would not
let an invasion go without a response. Enemies of the Islamic system
fabricated various rumours about death and health to demoralise the
Iranian nation, but they did not know that they are not dealing with
only one person in Iran. They are facing a nation" Iranian supreme
leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei

Will the Opposition Renounce Political Advertisements?

A1+

WILL THE OPPOSITION RENOUNCE POLITICAL ADVERTISEMENTS?
[05:56 pm] 09 February, 2007

According to Artashes Geghamyan, the fact that the National Committee of TV
and Radio has stated the price of one minute of political advertisement as
80 thousand AMD is the greatest victory of the opposition. `Do you see how
much the authorities are afraid of the speech of the opposition that they
have stated such a high price?’ He is sure that the members of the Committee
have carried out the orders of Serge Sargsyan and Robert Kocharyan.

the National Unity is not going to make use of the opportunity of paid
advertisements as `it is immoral to pay 80 thousand AMD for a minute to make
people acquainted with their own situation of 70% of poverty’.

Member of the Orinats Yerkir party Mher Shahgeldyan shares the opinion of
Arthur Baghdasaryan that by these prices the TV Companies violate the equal
rights of competition of the candidates.

Secretary of Justice bloc Grigor Haroutyunyan noted that «one can make use
of the paid political advertisements only by dirty money». Leader of the
National Democratic Union Vazgen Manoukyan noted that even developed
countries do not have such prices.

As for the authorities, they claim that everything has been done within the
frameworks of the law, and the 80 thousand AMD is stated not only for the
opposition but also for them. Leader of the ARF Dashnaktsutyun faction Hrayr
Karapetyan voiced hope that they will be able to make use of the chance by
means of donations. And Galoust Sahakyan complained saying that «People want
to acquire power without having anything».

Arson Is a Means to Influence Press

A1+

ARSON IS A MEANS TO INFLUENCE PRESS
[07:02 pm] 09 February, 2007

`Heritage’ party is deeply worried about the new wave of violence in the
country on the eve of the upcoming Parliamentary elections. In this
connection the party condemns the arson of the car of Ara Saghatelyan, owner
of Panorama.am and the periodical `My Rights’.

`It is obvious that certain powers try to enhance the atmosphere of fear
created by the authorities and to limit the freedom of speech. Not only
oppositional politicians, by also representatives of Mass Media who are
interested in giving the people unbiased information become targets for
intimidation’, says the statement made by the party.

Let us remind you that yesterday at 08:15 p.m. unknown people set the car of
Ara Saghatelyan on fire.

Heritage Party Condemns Burning of Media Owner’s Car

Panorama.am

19:37 09/02/2007

HERITAGE PARTY CONDEMNS BURNING OF MEDIA OWNER’S CAR

The press services of `Heritage’ party say in a statement, `The Heritage
party is deeply concerned with the acts of violence before the parliamentary
elections. In this context, we strongly condemn the burning of the car
belonging to Ara Saghatelyan, owner of Panorama.am web portal and My Right
newspaper.

It is evident that recently some forces try to deepen the atmosphere of fear
created by the ruling administration of the republic and try to limit free
speech and free expression of will. Not only opposition forces, but those
media representatives that try to channel truthful word to the public are
targeted by terrorism.

We demand to end these illegal acts and to discover and punish all
transgressors – both those who are professionalized in violence and their
customers.’

Source: Panorama.am

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenian Reporter – 2/10/2007 – from the Front secton

ARMENIAN REPORTER
PO Box 129
Paramus, New Jersey 07652
Tel: 1-201-226-1995
Fax: 1-201-226-1660
Web:
Email: [email protected]

February 10, 2007 — From the front section

1. Turkish officials in Washington to block Armenian Genocide resolution

2. Administration wants aid to cut aid to Armenia and ex-USSR;
Congress yet to weigh in on proposal

3. My Turkishness in revolt

4. Georgia between Azerbaijan and Turkey: What can Armenia offer?

5. Letter: An Armenian who revolutionized sports medicine (by Peter Balakian)

6. The human face of migration

7. Editorial: Time to reinvent "Turkishness"

************************* **************************************************

1. Turkish officials in Washington to block Armenian Genocide resolution

* Turkey’s foreign minister, MPs, and Armed Forces chief are arriving
this week and next

by Emil Sanamyan (Washington Editor)

WASHINGTON — Following the introduction of a draft congressional
resolution on the Armenian Genocide on January 31, senior Turkish
officials launched a series of visits to Washington to tout Turkey’s
importance, while warning that U.S.-Turkish cooperation would be
"harmed" if a resolution affirming the U.S. record on the Genocide is
adopted.

Turkey’s Foreign Minister ABDULLAH GUL confirmed that the Genocide
resolution, along with Turkey’s concerns over Iraq, has dominated his
agenda in Washington. Turkey is seeking to prevent a vote on House
Resolution 106, which has already won support from about 170 House
members.

Speaking at Washington’s National Press Club on Tuesday, Mr. Gul
argued that Turkey is of such importance to the United States that
America should not risk aggravating its relations by affirming the
Armenian Genocide.

Asked by the ARMENIAN REPORTER why Turkey’s warnings should be taken
seriously when its relations have survived similar resolutions adopted
by over a dozen other countries, Mr. Gul hinted that the U.S. is more
vulnerable to Turkey than Canada or European countries that have
recognized the Genocide. He specifically pointed to Iraq and
Afghanistan as areas where the U.S. needs Turkey’s support.

* Bush administration opposes the resolution

On February 5 and 6, Mr.Gul met with Vice President DICK CHENEY,
President Bush’s National Security Advisor STEPHEN HADLEY and
Secretary of State CONDOLEEZZA RICE. Administration officials have
pledged to work against the resolution.

According to sources close to Congress at least one House member
received a telephone call from Undersecretary of Defense **Eric
Edelman.** A former U.S. ambassador to Turkey, Mr. Edelman resigned
his position in 2005 after repeated anti-Semitic comments made against
him in the Turkish media. He was reportedly calling to oppose the
resolution.

"We are working harder than usual [to prevent the vote]," Deputy
Assistant Secretary of State MATT BRYZA was quoted as saying by the
Associated Press. Echoing comments made by Turkish officials on the
issue, Mr. Bryza argued that "a congressional resolution would be a
tremendous blow to our bilateral relationship."

A State Department transcript of the February 1 meeting with Turkish
journalists cited Mr. Bryza as referring to the Armenian Genocide as
"so-called." But speaking with the RFE/RL Armenian Service on February
7, Mr. Bryza said that the administration "do[es] not deny the mass
killings and forced exile of up to 1.5 million Armenians."

DAN FRIED, Assistant Secretary of State and Mr. Bryza’s manager at the
State Department, told the TURKISH DAILY NEWS that while the
administration will oppose the resolution, "If a resolution does pass
. . . I hope that our Turkish friends will understand that it’s not
the position of the U.S. administration, and our interests, Turkey’s
interests and America’s interests, will still bring us together."

Mr. Fried also added, in reference to the Genocide, "Honest countries,
free countries need to seriously look at these dark spots [of
history], and no matter how painful it is, they need to confront
them."

* Turkey lobbying U.S. Congress, seeks Jewish support

On February 7, Mr. Gul was due to meet House Majority leader STENY
HOYER (D-Md.), Foreign Affairs Committee chair TOM LANTOS (D-Calif.),
and other key members of Congress.

Turkish media reported that the House Speaker NANCY PELOSI declined to
meet Mr. Gul. It is up to the Speaker whether a vote on the resolution
takes place, and Ms. Pelosi, a longtime supporter of affirmation, has
previously expressed support for the resolution.

Turkish and Azerbaijani reports suggested that the Turkish foreign
minister will be specifically lobbying Reps. JOHN MURTHA (D-Pa.) and
RAHM EMANUEL (D-Ill.) to weigh in with Speaker Pelosi.

The Azerbaijani Press Agency (APA) further claimed that Turkey was
supported by three Jewish-American organizations. It cited an unnamed
leader of one of the Jewish organizations as telling Turkish
journalists that "[Rep.] Emanuel should be persuaded of the importance
of preventing the bill. Nancy [Pelosi] always follows Emanuel’s
advice."

The Jewish Telegraph Agency (JTA) reported that on Monday night Mr.
Gul met with representatives of a number of Jewish-American
organizations and asked them for assistance in opposition to the
Armenian Genocide resolution. JTA did not say if any such assistance
was promised.

Reached by the ARMENIAN REPORTER, the American-Israeli Public Affairs
Committee (AIPAC) spokeswoman JENNIFER CANNATA said that the
organization had no formal comment on the Genocide resolution. The
American Jewish Committee (AJC), whose representatives that took part
in the meeting with Mr. Gul, could not provide comment at press time.

Starting this week, about a dozen Turkish members of parliament will
follow Mr. Gul to lobby the U.S. Congress and the public against the
Armenian Genocide resolution.

Next week, chief of staff of the Turkish Armed Forces Gen. Yasar
Buyukanit will arrive to try to mend the bilateral military relations
severely damaged as a result of the Iraq war.

* A correction

This newspaper reported last week (Feb. 3) that Rep. Lantos (D-Calif.)
had cosigned a letter to the Turkish government condemning Hrant
Dink’s assassination and calling for reform in Turkey. Sources
familiar with the matter have since told the REPORTER that while Rep.
Lantos’ staff initially indicated that he would cosign the letter, in
the end he did not.

******************************************** *******************************

2. Administration wants aid to cut aid to Armenia and ex-USSR;
Congress yet to weigh in on proposal

by Emil Sanamyan
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

WASHINGTON — The Bush Administration has proposed a significant cut
in annual assistance to the republics of the former Soviet Union,
including Armenia — a cut which, it claimed, "reflect[s] success
achieved in the region." The draft proposal would need to be approved
and is likely to be revised by both chambers of the U.S. Congress
before it can become law.

The budget request for the fiscal year 2008 (FY08) would reduce
overall assistance to the region to about $356 million from about $509
million expended in FY06.

The same proposal would reduce economic assistance to Armenia to $35
million from $69 million spent in FY06; to Azerbaijan to $18 million
from $34.2; and to Georgia to $50.5 million from $67.8. The
administration made no specific request for aid to Nagorno-Karabakh.

Congress has repeatedly reversed administration-proposed aid cuts to
Armenia in previous years. U.S. economic assistance to Armenia has
totaled over $1.6 billion since 1992. The U.S. Congress has also
provided over $30 million in aid to Nagorno-Karabakh.

[In December 2006, the United States began to provide Millennium
Challenge assistance to Armenia. This is a separate program, which
envisages $235 million in developmental aid over five years,
conditional on Armenia’s democratic progress. The U.S. has a similar
program running in Georgia; Azerbaijan, however, was not found
eligible.]

The FY08 request also seeks more military assistance to Azerbaijan
than to Armenia, proposing $5.3 million and $3.3 million respectively
for the Foreign Military Financing (FMF) and International Military
Education and Training (IMET) programs.

* Armenian-American response

Washington-based Armenian-American organizations have taken issue both
with the proposed cut in aid and unequal levels of military assistance
to Armenia and Azerbaijan.

"This budget request . . . is simply unacceptable," said BRYAN
ARDOUNY, executive director of the Armenian Assembly of America. "We
will work with Congress to correct the glaring deficiencies in the
Administration’s request," he added.

ARAM HAMPARIAN, executive director of the Armenian National Committee
of America (ANCA), similarly noted that "We look to our friends in
Congress . . . to substantially increase aid levels to Armenia and
Nagorno-Karabakh that reflect Armenia’s growing partnership with U.S."

The U.S.-Armenia Public Affairs Committee (USAPAC) "believes that
Congress will reject the Administration’s call for reduction [in aid]
to Armenia," said executive director ROSS VARTIAN.

"USAPAC will work closely with Congress to increase Armenia’s
bilateral allocation and reinstate military assistance parity. . . .
Congress will once again correct the Administration’s exclusion of
Nagorno-Karabakh," Mr. Vartian predicted.

Citing the Azerbaijani president’s war threats, Mr. Vartian argued
that "it is irresponsible for the U.S. to propose asymmetrical FMF and
IMET funding and also to continue the Caspian program." He added,
"This in effect enables Azerbaijan’s destabilizing militarization."

The UNITED STATES EUROPEAN COMMAND is spending about $100 million in
Azerbaijan under the 10-year Caspian Guard (Security) program.
According to former U.S. Ambassador to Azerbaijan Reno Harnish, $30
million of that amount had been spent by the end of 2005 to upgrade
Azerbaijan’s maritime, air, and ground capabilities.

*********************************** ****************************************

3. My Turkishness in revolt

by Taner Akçam

This essay was originally published as "Turklugumun Isyani" (The
revolt of my Turkishness) in the January 24 edition of the Turkish
daily RADIKAL. This English translation, approved by Mr. Akçam, is
being published exclusively in the ARMENIAN REPORTER by arrangement
with the author.

I am a Turk. Hrant was an Armenian. I write for AGOS. He was AGOS.
Hrant, AGOS’s Turkish writers, and AGOS itself risked everything for a
cause: to cease the hostility between Turks and Armenians; to bring
the resentment and hatred to an end. We wanted each group, each
nationality, to live together on the common ground of mutual respect.

Hrant and AGOS were a single flower blooming on the barren plains of
Turkey. That flower was destroyed, torn from the ground. Everyone
says "The bullet fired at Hrant hit Turkey." That’s true, but we need
to ask ourselves in complete and transparent honesty: Who made the
target for that bullet? Who targeted Hrant so the bullet would find
its mark? Who held him fast so the shot wasn’t wasted?

Hrant wasn’t killed by a lone 17-year-old. He was murdered by those
who made him a target and held him in place.

Nor was he killed by a single bullet. It was the targeting, month by
month, that murdered him.

"I’m afraid," he said on January fifth "I’m very afraid, Taner. The
attacks on me and on AGOS are very systematic, They called me to the
Governor’s office, where they started making threats. They said,
‘We’ll make you pay for everything you’ve been doing.’ All the attacks
began after I was threatened."

"2007 is going to be a bad year, Taner," he continued. "They’re not
going to ease off. We’ve been made into a horrible target. Between
the press, the politicians, and the lawyers, they’ve created this
atmosphere that’s so poisonous, they’ve made us such an obscenity,
that we’ve become sitting ducks.

"They’ve opened up hunting season, Taner, and they’ve got us right
where they want us."

Hrant wasn’t killed by a 17-year-old. He was murdered by those who
portrayed him as an enemy of Turkey, every single day in the press, to
that 17-year-old. He was murdered by those who dragged him to the
doors of the courthouse under Article 301. He was murdered by those
who aimed Article 301 during their open season on intellectuals, and
by those who didn’t have the courage to change Article 301. Hrant was
murdered by those who called him to the Governor’s office and then
threatened him instead of protecting him.

There’s no point in shedding crocodile tears. Let us bow our heads
and look at our hands. Let us ponder how we will clean off the blood.
You organs of the press who have expressed shock over Hrant’s death,
go read your back issues, look at what you wrote about Hrant. You
will see the murderer there. You, who used 301 as a weapon to hunt
intellectuals, see what you wrote about 301, look at the court
decisions. You will see the murderer there.

Dear government officials, spare us your crocodile tears. Tell us
what you plan to do to the Lieutenant Governor who called Hrant into
his office and, together with an official from the National
Intelligence Bureau, proceeded to threaten him. What do you intend to
do to them?

Hrant was portrayed as "the Armenian who insulted Turkishness." For
this, he was murdered. He was murdered because he said, "Turkey must
confront its history." The hands that pulled the trigger–or caused
it to be pulled–in 2007 are the same hands that shot all the Hrants
in 1915, the same hands that left all those Armenians to choke in the
desert.

Hrant’s killers are sending us a message. They’re saying "Yes! We
were behind 1915 and we’ll do it again in 2007!" Hrant’s murderers
believe they killed in the name of Turkishness, just like those who
killed all the Hrants in 1915.

For them, Turkishness is about committing murder. It means setting
someone up as the enemy and then targeting that person for
destruction.

Quite the contrary, the murderers are a black stain upon the brow of
Turkishness. It is they who have demeaned Turkish identity.

For this reason, we have stood up and we have decided to take
Turkishness out of the assassins’ hands and we have shouted out, "We
are all Hrant! We are all Armenian!" We are the resounding cry of
Turkishness and Turkey. All of us–Turks, Kurds, Alevites,
secularists, and Muslims alike–shout out on behalf of everyone who
wants to take Turkishness away from these murderers.

Turkishness is a beautiful thing that should be respected instead of
left in the hands of murderers; so is Armenianness.

We can feel proud to be Turkish only if we can acknowledge the
murderer for who he is. That is what we are doing today. By
declaring, "We are all Armenians," we know that we honor Turkishness;
by identifying the true murderer, we create a Turkishness worth
claiming.

Today we declare to the world that murder has nothing to do with
Turkishness or Turkey. We are not going to leave Turkishness in the
hands of murderers. We will not allow Turkishness to be stained by
hate crimes towards Armenians. Either Turkishness belongs to the
murderers, or it belongs to us.

Turks cry out that the person who killed Hrant is a murderer. In the
wake of his death, Turkishness affirms that we are all Armenians.

This, I say, is what we also need to do for 1915.

If we can affirm that a real Turk is someone who can distance
Turkishness from the murder of Hrant Dink, then we ought to be able to
do the same thing for the events around 1915. Those who gather in a
protective circle around Hrant’s murderer are the same people who
protected the murderers of 1915. Those who honored Talaat, Bahaettin
Sakir and Dr. Nzim yesterday are doing the same for Hrant’s murderer
today.

If we can come out and declare Hrant’s murder a "shameful act," then
we should be able to state the same, as Mustafa Kemal Ataturk did,
about the acts that occurred in 1915. Today, hundreds of thousands of
us condemn this murder by declaring "We are all Armenian." In 1915,
Turks, Kurds, Moslems and Alewites did the same. We have to choose,
not only for today but for yesterday as well.

Whose side are we on? Which "Turkishness" are we defending, the one
that defends the murderers or the one which condemns the murderous
acts? Do we stand with Kemal, the Mayor of Bogazliyan, who
annihilated Armenians in 1915, or with Abdullahzade Mehmet Efendi, the
Mufti of Bogazliyan, who bore witness against that mayor at the trial
which lead to his execution, stating "I fear the wrath of God"?

Are we going to represent the "Turkishness" that defended the crimes
of Talat, Enver, Bahaettin Sakir, Doctor Nzim, and Governor Resit of
Diyarbakir? Or will we oppose them in the name of a Turkishness that
condemns such horror?

We need to know that in 1915 we had Mazhar, the governor of Ankara;
Celal, the governor of Halep; Resit, the governor of Kastamonu; Cemal,
the lieutenant governor of Yozgat; Ali Faik, the mayor of Kütahya; and
Ali Fuat, the mayor of Der-Zor. And we had soldiers and army
commanders in 1915, men we can embrace with respect, for opposing what
happened: Vehip Pasha, Commander of the Third Army; Avni Pasha,
Commander of the Trabzon garrison; Colonel Vasfi; and Salim, Major
Commandant of the Yozgat post.

Trabzon has its share of murderers like Ögün Samast in 2007 and
Governor Cemal Azmi and Unionist "Yenibahçeli" Nail in 1915. But
those who opposed the crimes of 1915 and didn’t hesitate to identify
the murderers in court included many citizens of Trabzon: Nuri, Chief
of Police; businessman, Ahmet Ali Bey; Customs Inspector Nesim Bey,
and parliamentarian Hafiz Mehmet Emin Bey,who testified, "I saw with
my own eyes that the Armenians were loaded onto boats and taken out
and drowned, but I couldn’t do anything to stop it."

These are just a few of the dozens, hundreds, even thousands of people
who opposed the horrible acts committed.

We, Turks and Turkey, have a choice to make. We will affirm either
the Turkishness of murderers past and present, or the Turkishness of
those who cry out today, "We are all Armenian!" and who yesterday
declared, "We will not let our hands be stained with blood."

The whole world looks upon us with respect because they see us draw a
line between Turkishness and barbarism. Today we are building a wall
between murderers and Turkishness; we are Turks who know how to point
the finger at a murderer.

We must show the same courage in regard to the events of 1915. Hrant
wanted us to. When he said, "I love Turks and Turkey, and I consider
it a privilege to be living amongst Turks," that’s what he was asking
for. We need to acknowledge the murderers of the Hrants of 1915, and
we need to draw a line between them and Turkishness. If we are going
to own up to this murder in 2007 then we need to do the same for those
of 1915.

That’s what confronting one’s history is about. Today, by saying to
Hrant’s murderer, "You don’t represent me as a Turk: you are simply a
murderer," we have begun the process of confronting and acknowledging
our history. We must do the same with the murderers of 1915 by
drawing a line between their acts and our Turkishness. We must
condemn these murderers as having smeared our brows with the dark
stain of their crimes. Then, and only then, can we Turks go about the
world with our heads held high.

I cry out in the name of Turkishness. I cry out as a Turk, as a
friend who lost Hrant, my beloved Armenian brother. Let’s take back
Turkishness from the murderous hands of those who wish to smear us
with their dark deeds. Let’s shout in one voice, "WE ARE ALL HRANT!
WE ARE ALL ARMENIANS!"

***

Taner Akçam, a professor at the University of Minnesota, is the author
of A SHAMEFUL ACT: THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE AND THE QUESTION OF TURKISH
RESPONSIBILITY. He recently became the subject of a formal complaint
under Turkey’s Penal Code Article 301 — the same crime of "insulting
Turkishness" for which Hrant Dink was tried and found guilty by the
Turkish judiciary.

************************************** *************************************

4. Georgia between Azerbaijan and Turkey: What can Armenia offer?

News Analysis by Emil Sanamyan
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

EDITOR’S NOTE: Emil Sanamyan’s article in the January 13 edition of
the ARMENIAN REPORTER ("Armenia and Georgia: Will the delicate embrace
survive a gas onslaught?") discussed the mutual importance of Armenia
and Georgia and described the recent and anticipated changes in
regional energy supply patterns. In the second installment of that
article, which follows, Mr. Sanamyan looks at the possible
implications of these changes.

WASHINGTON — Following Georgia’s decision in late December to buy
Russian gas at $235 per thousand cubic meters (tcm), twice the price
Georgia paid last year, local media and pundits discussed the
possibility of increasing the tariff on Russian gas supplies to
Armenia. In other words, Georgia would look to Armenia to subsidize,
at least in part, the Russian price hike.

Armenia will be paying $110/tcm of Russian gas through the end of
2008. In exchange Russia increased its control over Armenia’s gas
transportation infrastructure.

Cory Welt, the deputy director for Eurasia at the Washington-based
Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), who watches
Georgian politics closely, told the ARMENIAN REPORTER in December that
he "doesn’t see how Georgians would allow the $110 gas to go to
Armenia, while they are paying $235…. This will pose a large problem
for Armenia."

Earlier this month, political commentator Soso Tsintsadze told the
Georgian newspaper SAKARTVELOS RESPUBLIKA that such a move was being
considered by the Georgian government. Currently, Georgia receives
100,000 tcm as a tariff for Russian gas supplies to Armenia
(equivalent to $23.5 million at the new price.)

But chairman of the Georgian Parliament’s committee on economic policy
Niko Lekishvili ruled out such a step, reported Georgia’s MESSENGER
daily on January 8. Lekishvili said that Georgia does not want to hurt
its relations with Armenia.

Higher tariffs for Armenia are just some and perhaps not the worst of
the potential consequences of the Russian price hike against Georgia.

* The Georgia-Turkey-Azerbaijan connection

Enter Azerbaijan and Turkey, which have offered Georgia gas supplies
at significantly lower prices than Russia is now asking. If Russia
conditions lower prices for its gas supplies to control of the
countries’ strategic assets and Russia-friendly policies, should not
Azerbaijan and Turkey be expected to do the same?

CSIS’s Welt called the recent preliminary agreements between
Azerbaijan, Georgia and Turkey on gas supplies a "step towards
consolidation of the Georgian-Azerbaijani partnership … leaving
Armenia on the other side."

Since questions remain on how much gas Azerbaijan can in fact produce
for itself and for export, Georgia is BOTH driving a hard bargain on
Azerbaijan-initiated projects AND biding its time. But the partnership
is already beginning to bear fruit for Azerbaijan.

On January 13, transport officials from Azerbaijan, Georgia and Turkey
met in Tbilisi and agreed to go ahead with construction of the
Tbilisi-Akhalkalaki-Kars railroad that Azerbaijan initiated to, as the
Azeri president put it, make Armenia’s future "even bleaker."

As part of the deal, Azerbaijan agreed to provide a virtually
interest-free (1 percent APR for 25 years) $220 million loan to
Georgia for the rehabilitation and construction of the Georgian
stretch of the railroad. (Georgia’s Minister of Economic Development
Georgi Arveladze, however, put the estimate for the Georgia section at
$300 million.)

The construction of the 160-mile line is expected to begin by
September of this year and to be completed by 2010, with an estimated
total cost of $600 million.

On February 7, Azerbaijani president Ilham Aliyev and Turkey’s prime
minister Recep Tayyib Erdogan were in the Georgian capital for the
inauguration of its airport’s new terminal. The terminal is
constructed by a Turkish company that has 15-year management rights
for the airport in Tbilisi, as well as the one in Batumi, in Georgia’s
Black Sea province of Ajaria.

Azerbaijani officials have previously expressed interest in buying up
key infrastructure in Georgia’s Black Sea ports of Poti and Batumi,
both heavily relied upon by Armenia.

These are just some examples of Turkish and Azerbaijani real and
potential economic expansion into Georgia, which will have
consequences for Armenia.

In addition to economics, there is the on-again, off-again issue of
the resettlement of Meskhetian Turks displaced from Central Asia into
the Armenian-populated Javakhk region, and the frequent discrimination
faced by ethnic Armenian citizens of Georgia.

In several official statements in recent months, Georgia has
explicitly endorsed Azerbaijan’s claims on Karabakh, and the two
countries cooperated on having this view endorsed at the United
Nations’ General Assembly.

There is also military cooperation between Georgia and Turkey and, to
a lesser extent, Azerbaijan. Turkey has paid for the renovation of
Georgia’s main airforce base outside the ethnically Azeri-populated
town of Marneuli, along with some of Georgia’s other military
programs. Georgia has in turn sold fighter jets to Azerbaijan.

* Opportunities for Armenia

What opportunities does Armenia have for positive engagement with
Georgia to deter future problems?

"Changes in gas supply patterns are a short-term issue," says Arthur
Martirosyan, Program Manager at the Cambridge, Massachusetts-based
Civil Society and Conflict Management Group of the Mercy Corps.
"Long-term, both Armenia and Georgia are pursuing European integration
and this process creates important leverages for Armenia; both
countries are also members of the World Trade Organization (WTO)."

"For now, Georgia is not taking any practical anti-Armenian steps,"
Martirosyan notes. "But Armenia could potentially engage WTO, European
or even American venues to moderate any such steps that Georgia may be
pushed to undertake."

More locally, while Russia appears to have taken control of future
Iranian gas supplies to Armenia, there must be a way for Armenia to be
able to offer Georgia an alternative source of gas that would come
through Armenia rather than from or through Azerbaijan.

There is certainly a need for a stronger Armenian economic presence in
Georgia. This means Armenian — including *diaspora* Armenian —
investments in Georgia. So far, the Cascade Bank and Grand Tobacco are
the only Armenian companies known to have invested in Georgia.
(Disclosure: Cascade Bank belongs to the Cafesjian Family Foundation,
which also owns this newspaper.)

Targeted economic investments in Tbilisi, Javakhk, and the Black Sea
ports would also mean strengthening the Armenian community in Georgia,
giving them the confidence to stay in Georgia and have their voices
heard in national politics.

"A democratic Georgia that shares European values provides an
important opportunity for a long-term alliance with Armenia," says
Martirosyan. "But such an alliance would require consistent
and-thought out engagement on the part of Armenia."

* * *

For photos, see

******************* ************************************************** ******

5. Letter: An Armenian who revolutionized sports medicine (by Peter Balakian)

Sir:

Maral Najarian’s "Great Armenians: Our Unsung Heroes" piece (Dec. 2,
2006) notes a group of Armenian physicians who made pioneering
contributions to medicine. I would like to add to the list Dr. Gerard
Balakian (my father), who in 1965 revolutionized the field of sports
medicine with his invention of the first electrolyte replenishment
sports drink, "Sportade."

Alarmed by the growing number of deaths among athletes from heat
stroke, Dr. Balakian in 1965 began his research on electrolyte
replenishment, and shortly thereafter developed the first electrolyte
beverage, an isotonic, thirst-quenching beverage, which he trademarked
as Sportade. Sportade was designed to replenish minerals such as
potassium and sodium that are lost by athletes during physical
exertion. Shortly after the invention of Sportade, "Gatorade" was
developed, and soon Sportade and Gatorade were competing in the new
market for electrolyte beverages. Balakian was prescient in saying as
early as 1966: "Electrolyte drinks will revolutionize sport and daily
exercise and in 20 years will be in every in household in America."

By 1968, Balakian licensed Sportade to Becton-Dickinson, a
pharmaceutical medical supply company. Sportade became a sensation
during those years, and was used by college and professional athletic
teams nationwide including the New York Giants, Notre Dame, Stanford
University, and the New York Jets. Sportade was used at the Olympics
in 1968, and in 1969 it was the featured drink at the U.S. Tennis
Open; it was also used in Southeast Asia, Africa, and Europe. Dr.
Balakian lectured extensively at universities and medical forums
across American and spoke at the World Congress of Sports Medicine at
Oxford in 1970, on the Voice of America radio program, and on NBC
television. Balakian and Sportade received extensive media coverage in
the NEW YORK TIMES (including a feature in the Sunday TIMES of Oct. 8,
1967), NEWSWEEK, WORLD TENNIS MAGAZINE, SOFT DRINKS REVIEW, and NBC
television.

Very truly yours,
Peter Balakian
Hamilton, N.Y.

******************************************** *******************************

6. The human face of migration

Living in Armenia by Maria Titizian
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

When Hagop Boghossian made the decision to migrate to Greece in 1998,
he didn’t realize at the time the consequences of such a choice. [In
this essay, the name of the family portrayed has been changed.]
Boghossian’s parents were originally from Greece and had repatriated
to Soviet Armenia in the late 1940s. With independence came freedom
and the ability to be mobile. And at the first opportunity, many like
Boghossian took the decision to go in search of a better life. But the
question was how to get there with his family? He found a way, but his
quest for a better life came with a heavy price.

Migration is not a new phenomenon for Armenia. Since independence
there has been a steady outflow of people from the republic. Estimated
figures range from 900,000 to a million Armenians having left the
country. This mass movement of people began in 1988 with the
earthquake in Spitak, which killed 25,000 (according to official
estimates) and left hundreds of thousands without shelter. This was
further compounded by the conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh, which resulted
in hundreds of thousands of refugees and internally displaced persons
(IDP’s) within the republic; and then the USSR disintegrated under its
own weight. This was followed by the energy crisis, the blockade by
Turkey and Azerbaijan, and the collapse of the already destabilized
economy of Armenia.

While migration can contribute indirectly to the development of the
country of origin – through remittances sent back home, which thereby
reduce poverty or at least provide recipient families with sustenance
– it also poses serious challenges. For a developing country like
Armenia, which receives millions of dollars annually through outside
sources, this process makes it dependent on volatile and fluctuating
growth that can be short-lived – with potentially devastating impacts
on families. Unfortunately international migration today is poorly
managed and can eventually end up impairing the lives of millions of
people who dream of a better quality of life.

The Boghossian family had to make a very difficult choice. In order to
get to Greece, they would have to apply for visitor’s visas, but the
two eldest daughters (ages 13 and 15 at the time) would have to be
left behind as a guarantee of their return. Therefore Hagop, his wife
and their 4-year-old son left for Greece assuming that they would
apply for permanent residence, get working papers, and bring over
their two daughters in a short time. The girls were temporarily left
behind in Yerevan with relatives.

This temporary separation lasted eight years.

This large-scale out-migration and its ensuing negative consequences
on the social fabric of Armenian society became one of the primary
concerns for the government. As a result, the State Department for
Migration and Refugees (DMR) was established by a governmental decree
in 1999. The creation of this department reflected the attitude that
there had to be some regulation put in place. Previously, the role of
the state in this area was limited mostly to reactionary measures and
the mitigation of negative consequences. With the establishment of the
DMR, the Armenian government is striving to implement a comprehensive
migration policy – starting from improvement of border management
systems and registration of migration flows, to re-admission and
re-integration programs, especially for those in high risk categories.

One of the primary mandates of this department is to keep the
population well informed about migration in general, including
providing information on rules of entry, residence, and employment in
destination countries. Lack of information has provided fertile ground
for illegal migration from Armenia to flourish.

A 2005 survey conducted by the Armenian Sociological Association
(ASA), titled "Trafficking and Labor Exploitation of Armenian
Migrants," found that although there was an improvement of awareness
among the population, a large number of people still lack proper
information regarding migration. One disturbing phenomenon persists:
almost two-thirds of the respondents didn’t know that to secure a job
in Europe, Russia, or the Middle East, it is necessary to have
official documents or permits from the authorities. Only 44 percent of
those who had previously traveled abroad to find employment knew that
an official permit is needed, and only 18.l percent of the respondents
knew about the procedure of getting a working visa.

Another survey, "The Awareness of Population about Migration Related
Issues," implemented by the ASA for the International Organization on
Migration (IOM), showed that 37.3 percent of the population was not
aware that Republic of Armenia citizens could not go to any European
country without a visa. Only 10 percent thought they should get
official documentation to travel legally to a foreign country. The
rest thought that any way is acceptable, including opting for illegal
migration. Most were well aware that illegal migrants were often times
exploited by their employers, that they were working overtime, were
underpaid, their movements restricted and sometimes had their
passports taken away.

According to the IOM mission in Armenia, "Distorted perceptions and
insufficient information about the realities in the countries they are
trying to reach increases the need for migrants to have access to
information. Most migrants are unaware of the practical, legal, social
and economic consequences involved in moving to another country. This
lack of awareness puts migrants at risk and undermines orderly
migration."

The urgent need to make informed decisions is why it is so imperative
to ensure that people are aware of the dangers of illegal migration.
And this is where the Boghossian family fell through the cracks in the
information net. Had they been better informed, perhaps they would
have reconsidered the decisions they took, and those decisions would
not have affected their lives as they did.

Migration statistics collected by the National Statistical Service of
Armenia are based on the registration and departure of citizens –
hardly an effective method to gauge actual migration. As a metric, it
does not indicate accurately the number of short-term labor migrants
who go abroad, nor does it identify migration flows due to transparent
borders with CIS countries, with no actual registration procedures
being applied at land border crossing points. Therefore the current
migration related data available in Armenia is insufficient for
authorities to develop an effective and long-term state policy that
will help in the fight against illegal migration.

The different state agencies, such as border guards, passport, and
visa departments of the Ministry of Interior and customs department,
do not have a unified cohesive procedure to follow, and information is
therefore not being processed properly.

On a more positive note, DMR has taken steps to organize the return of
illegal immigrants to Armenia by instituting re-admission agreements
with several countries of destination. To prevent recurring migration,
the re-admission process will be complemented with re-integration
assistance programs for irregular migrants, rejected asylum seekers,
and trafficked victims. As long as unemployment and underemployment
persist in Armenia, people will believe that the grass is greener and
will want to venture out into the world in search of new life
opportunities. Therefore, it is equally important to create legal
opportunities for labor migration, to circumvent the existence of the
illegal migration that puts people at risk.

For the Boghossian family, though their entry into Greece was
initially legal, their status became illegal once they stayed beyond
the duration of their visitor’s visa. They were left without any
status, working under the radar of the immigration authorities, until
they found a way to eventually obtain temporary residency. They were
caught in a trap: they had made a foray into the outside world – their
chance to achieve a perhaps illusory "better life" – but in the end,
they were denied the company of their children for many years.

During the eight years that the Boghossian girls were left behind,
they carried on with their education, ached for the comfort of their
lost family, graduated from university, fell in love, and moved on.
When the day finally came that Hagop was in a position to reunite his
family by bringing his daughters to Greece, the girls were torn and
confused. They had matured into young women, and now felt estranged
from their own parents and brother.

Nevertheless, they *did* eventually join their family in Greece this
past summer. I asked their aunt a few weeks ago how the girls were
adjusting to their new lives. She looked away from me and quietly
said, "One is working as a waitress in a banquet hall, and the younger
one is cleaning homes with her mother. This is how they’re putting
their university educations to use. They miss Yerevan, they miss their
lives." We were both quiet until she turned and looked me in the eyes
and said, "I wonder sometimes if their sacrifice was worth it."

* * *

Maria Titizian is a writer living in Yerevan. Her column appears
regularly in the ARMENIAN REPORTER.

*************************************** ************************************

7. Editorial: Time to reinvent "Turkishness"

The murder of Hrant Dink, the courageous Turkish-Armenian editor and
activist who was assassinated in Istanbul on January 19, grabbed the
attention of the media and elected officials in the United States and
beyond.

The crime was condemned widely as a blow against freedom of expression
in Turkey. Prime Minister Erdogan condemned it as "a bullet fired at
democracy and freedom of expression."

Practically everyone noted, however, that freedom of expression-and
specifically Hrant Dink-had been targeted by the state itself before
the assassin and the assassin’s sponsors "fired at" them. Mr. Dink had
been prosecuted repeatedly under article 301 of Turkey’s penal code
for speaking out about the Armenian Genocide. The provision makes
"insulting Turkishness" a crime.

The movement to repeal article 301 has gained steam inside and outside
Turkey, and rightly so. The state should protect free speech, not
persecute people for speaking. Unfortunately, as we reported last
week, the ruling party is unlikely to repeal this law anytime soon.

To focus exclusively on article 301 would be a mistake, however.

The murderers may well have decided to kill Mr. Dink even if there
were no law against "insulting Turkishness."

Powerful people and many of those who aspire to power in Turkey appear
to have a vested interest in enforcing a particular version of
Turkishness. That is an ongoing threat to all those who do not agree
with them.

Under article 66 of Turkey’s constitution every citizen of Turkey is a
Turk. This can mean-and should mean-that the word "Turk" is not just
an ethnic term, but also a civic one, and that it encompasses every
ethnic group in Turkey. In practice, however, tens of millions of
Kurds-as well as Armenians, Greeks, and Jews-have their identity
denied and are second-class citizens at best.

Mr. Dink was killed not just for what he said but also for who he was.
He was a Turk, in the civic sense, who was an Armenian-an Armenian who
was not willing to keep his Armenianness under wraps, to be Armenian
only in private, quietly, cautiously.

As we have noted in this space before, he was an Armenian who refused
to know his place. For that he was murdered.

The murderers’ action shocked and moved the conscience of a part of
Turkish society. Spontaneous vigils at the site of the crime
culminated in a 5-mile funeral procession that brought to the streets
100,000 Turks on a weekday morning and afternoon. Though the Turkish
nationalists are beginning to regroup, the Turkish media for three
weeks now have been immersed in introspective coverage about the
notion of Turkishness, free speech in Turkey, and Turkey’s attitude
toward its Armenian citizens.

This outpouring represented a ray of hope at a dark and painful moment.

It was a reminder that Turkey is a diverse society, in which the
forces of hate and darkness – the fascists – have to contend with the
forces of enlightenment and comity. Hrant Dink was a shining beacon in
this struggle, and the slogan, "We are all Hrant Dink" is a tribute to
his insistence on building bridges while remaining true to the shared
history of Turkey’s people of different ethnic origins.

Turkey must, of course, repeal its law against "insulting Turkishness"
and other provisions that suppress free speech. But in response to the
murder of Mr. Dink Turkish society must go well beyond that and amend
its very definition of "Turkishness."

Turkish society must come to understand that Turkey is just as much
the country of Mr. Dink and other Turkish-Armenians as it is the
country of his murderers. It must acknowledge Turkey as a multiethnic
nation built on the ruins of a multiethnic empire. This means
acknowledging the Armenian Genocide and dealing with whatever
consequences that entails. It means treating Armenians, Greeks, Jews,
Kurds, and other minorities as full citizens whose cultures and
institutions are protected, prized, and celebrated.

************************************* **************************************

Please send your news to [email protected] and your letters to
[email protected]
(c) 2007 CS Media Enterprises LLC. All Rights Reserved

http://www.armenianreporteronline.com
www.armenianreporteronline.am

Hanging together

The Caucasus
Hanging together

Feb 8th 2007 | BAKU
>From The Economist print edition

The implications of a diplomatic shift in an important oil-rich region

WHEN God was parcelling out land to the peoples of the earth, the Georgians
arrived late. But their explanation-that they had been drinking in his
honour-so delighted God that, according to a Georgian creation myth, he
granted them the world’s choicest spot. The gods have indeed favoured
Georgia this winter, bestowing a mild one when a harsh one might have been
disastrous. But the Georgians owe thanks also to an earthly benefactor:
their neighbour Azerbaijan, whose oil-fuelled foreign policy is transforming
the volatile but vital Caucasus.

Since the revolution of 2003 that swept Mikhail Saakashvili to Georgia’s
presidency, his yen to join NATO and the European Union has infuriated the
Kremlin. Last autumn, the Russians imposed postal and aviation blockades,
alongside the existing embargoes on Georgia’s water, wine and fruit. Then,
with winter approaching, they doubled the price for Russian gas-in theory
for commercial reasons, but with the real aim of taming Mr Saakashvili.

Yet, for all Mr Saakashvili’s high-profile rambunctiousness, the most
important country in the Caucasus is Azerbaijan. With around 8m people, most
of them Shia Muslims, it has the biggest population. It also has oil and
gas, which a consortium led by BP is extracting from the Caspian Sea and
pumping through new pipelines across Georgia to Turkey and beyond. All the
Caucasian economies are now picking up, after collapsing with the Soviet
Union-even corrupt Armenia’s, dependent though it mostly is on remittances.
But the growth created by Azerbaijan’s second oil boom (the first was 100
years ago) was the highest in the world last year: 34.5%, says the finance
minister.

Azerbaijan’s president is Ilham Aliev, who inherited the job from Heidar,
his strongman father. The younger Aliev seemed also to have inherited the
Caucasian skill of diplomatic balance, eschewing Georgian-style
pyrotechnics. But that careful equilibrium appeared to change in December,
when the Russians tried to hike the price of the gas that, despite its own
reserves, Azerbaijan was itself still importing. The idea was apparently to
stop Azerbaijan helping the Georgians with cheaper supplies.

"Commercial blackmail," said Mr Aliev. Azerbaijan stopped importing Russian
gas altogether-and, thanks to the warm weather, gas from Azerbaijan seems
set to help Georgia through the winter. Elmar Mammadyarov, Azerbaijan’s
foreign minister, says his country is merely "taking responsibility as a
regional leader." Mr Saakashvili is more exuberant: "a geopolitical coup",
he says of the new gas arrangements. The truth is, Mr Aliev now needs Mr
Saakashvili too. Azerbaijan’s future, and Mr Aliev’s power, rest on the new
pipelines, which have bound their two countries together, and bound both of
them to the West. In a few years they may also carry Kazakh oil from the
other side of Caspian, and-perhaps-gas from Turkmenistan. That would undo
Russia’s grip on the supply of Central Asian gas to Europe, and is as
unpopular an idea in Moscow as it is welcome elsewhere.

Two things undermine the hope that the fractious Caucasians have finally
learned to hang together, to their own benefit and that of Western energy
consumers.

One is domestic politics. Russia’s diplomatic power may be waning, but its
political model remains popular. Armen Darbinian, a former Armenian prime
minister, quips that his and other post-Soviet countries have become
"one-and-a-half party states": a party of power, plus others that are
basically decorative. In Azerbaijan, opposition activists are regularly
harassed and locked up. Like Russia, Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan will
all hold presidential polls next year. Mr Aliev will surely win his; the
whisper in Baku is that his wife will take over next. But another whisper is
that, in the absence of democracy, Islamism is on the rise-encouraged, say
some, by Iran to the south.

The Islamists, says Ali Kerimli, a disgruntled oppositionist, curry favour
with their complaint that "the West sells democracy for oil." Others say the
threat is fanciful. The call to prayer rings across the boutiques and
restaurants of downtown Baku, but there are actually more hijabs on the
streets of London, says Ilgar Ibrahimoglu, an imam. All the same, things may
change if too much of the oil money goes into nepotistic contracts and
vanity projects, and too little on diversifying the economy and easing the
grinding poverty in which many Azerbaijanis still live.

The other big Caucasian danger is war. Russian support for South Ossetia and
Abkhazia, two enclaves that broke away from Georgia in the 1990s (see map),
is one of Mr Saakashvili’s main gripes. Azerbaijan also lost a secessionist
conflict over Nagorno Karabakh, a part of Soviet Azerbaijan mostly populated
by Armenians. Mr Aliev periodically makes dark threats about retaking
Azerbaijan’s lost territory by force, though a flare-up in Georgia currently
looks likelier.

Mr Saakashvili says Russia’s economic embargo "achieved the opposite of what
was intended", and that Georgia has found new markets. Suitably cheered, he
this week hosted Mr Aliev and Turkey’s Recep Tayyip Erdogan, shaking hands
on a new railway that will link the Caucasus to Europe-but miss out Armenia.
Vartan Oskanian, Armenia’s foreign minister, complains that there is an
existing railway across Armenian-controlled territory that could be used
instead. The railway, like the pipelines, symbolises what the countries of
the Caucasus can achieve together, but also how far apart they remain.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenian Reporter – 2/10/2007 – from the Arts & Culture section

ARMENIAN REPORTER
PO Box 129
Paramus, New Jersey 07652
Tel: 1-201-226-1995
Fax: 1-201-226-1660
Web:
Email: [email protected]

February 10, 2007 — From the Arts & Culture section

1. Nuclear art: Three Egoyans in four acts

2. Cheers to POMEGRANATE WHISKY

3.Arts Briefs
* BEAUTIFUL ARMENIANS on Watertown cable in February
* New Armenian sacred music
* Zulal’s Anaïs, Teni & Yeraz: In their own words
* Minnesota Book Awards honors Akçam’s new book
* The ARMENIAN REPORTER wants your art briefs

****************************************** *********************************

1. Nuclear art: Three Egoyans in four acts

* Atom in words, Eve in notes and Arsinee in Berlin

by Paul Chaderjian
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

* Act I: Atomic Thinking & the Bigger Picture

The fascinating genius of Atom Egoyan is the subject of a new book
titled IMAGE AND TERRITORY: ESSAYS ON ATOM EGOYAN. Editors Monique
Tschofen and Jennifer Burwell, both English professors at Toronto’s
Ryerson University, offer cinephiles and fans nearly 500 pages of
thought-provoking essays about Egoyan’s body of work. The book is
published by Wilfrid Laurier University Press.

IMAGES AND TERRITORY features both in-depth essays and interviews
about one of the most talented artistic voices of the era. Penned by
leading film and media scholars, the book offers an insider’s
perspective into the mind of the award-winning director, producer,
writer, musician and artist. The essays also give the reader a
perspective of how Egoyan’s vision and words fit into, push forward,
or challenge grander milieus like the arts, philosophy and politics.

Inspiration, logic, relationships, and aesthetic are some of the
themes explored in this multidisciplinary, must-read collection of
essays about the nucleus of the man, the sought-after Hollywood
director, the cult hero indie filmmaker, and Canadian and Armenian
royalty.

While you’re on Amazon ordering the book, you may consider adding to
your DVD collection titles like the ADJUSTER, SPEAKING PARTS,
FELICIA’S JOURNEY, EXOTICA, THE SWEET HEREAFTER, WHERE THE TRUTH LIES,
CALENDAR, and of course, ARARAT.

* Act II: Mrs. Egoyan, AKA Arsinee Khanjian, takes Berlin

The 57th Annual Berlin International Film Festival opened this week
with a program of 343 films from 46 countries. One of the films chosen
to be on the Bernali’s film program this year is STONE TIME TOUCH,
starring Arsinee Khanjian.

The Canadian-Armenian film, directed by 36-year-old Gariné Torossian,
will screen on February 9, 10 and 11. Torossian, like Khanjian, was
born in Lebanon and immigrated to Canada. She says the film, her first
feature, captures the diversity of communities in Armenia, the
extremes and complexities of history since the Genocide, and explores
Armenian identity and the meaning of the homeland.

* Act III: All about Eve

Critics are still raving about Eve Egoyan’s January 25th performance
with the Victoria Symphony. Under the direction of conductor Tania
Miller, Eve (Atom’s sister), was the featured piano soloist, taking on
Rudolf Komorous’ piece for piano called THE SEVEN SIDES OF MAXINE’S
SILVER DIE.

The GLOBE AND MAIL said Egoyan’s remarkable playing balanced the
delicacy of the piece with intense focus, "holding all in a net." The
newspaper’s Elissa Poole writes, "Egoyan timed these decelerations so
perfectly that the spaces in between the notes were still charged with
presence. Similarly when scales made way for chords, it was possible
to imagine them as the same object perceived within different time
frames."

Want to know "All about Eve," point and click your way to
, check out her CDs, read the reviews, and get to
know another talented Atomic electron from Canada’s Garden of Eden.

* Act IV: Fusion vs. Fission? Censors Vote for Violence

Atom Egoyan is on film talking about the illogical rating system used
by the Motion Picture Association of America. In the new documentary
THIS FILM IS NOT RATED, Egoyan is interviewed by filmmaker Kirby Dick
about the shadowy board which controls what audiences in the U.S. see
on big and small screens.

The documentary exposes the ratings process, the subjective dynamics
and the religious-right influenced decisions that directly determine
how films are made and whether or not they are successful. THIS FILM
IS NOT RATED unmasks the decision makers who serve on the board, work
behind closed doors, and often favor big-budget studio-produced films
over independent ones.

Egoyan is interviewed about how the MPAA board threatened him with an
NC-17 rating for WHERE THE TRUTH LIES. The board told the director
that he had to make certain shots in the Kevin Bacon-Colin Firth movie
fuzzy to receive an R rating. In the documentary, Egoyan asks the head
of the board: "Would you like to edit my next film?"

Along with Egoyan, other bewildered directors interviewed about the
MPAA rating system include Kimberly Pierce (BOYS DON’T CRY), Kevin
Smith (JERSEY GIRL), Wayne Kramer (THE COOLER), Mary Heron (AMERICAN
PSYCHO), and John Waters (A DIRTY SHAME).

**************************************** ***********************************

2. Cheers to POMEGRANATE WHISKY

by Aram Kouyoumdjian

"I want to go back to France," she drones, rolling the "r" and the
cigarette in her hand. "She" happens to be the Statue of Liberty,
depressed and embittered, and bored of American shores – at least as
imagined by performance artist Lory Tatoulian in "Pomegranate Whisky,"
her latest cocktail of comedic monologues and musical numbers. The
faux cabaret plays Sunday nights at the Heartbreak House Studio in
Atwater through March 18.

Among the evening’s many highlights, the Statue of Liberty segment is
particularly memorable, thanks to Tatoulian’s sophisticated humor and
the deadpan hilarity of her performance. Lady Liberty longs for Paris
as she laments her diminishing role in welcoming immigrants and, in a
sharp political jibe, confesses fearing relocation to the Mexican
border as a guard against illegal crossings.

Despite her youth, Tatoulian is a veteran solo performer whose credits
include "Sitting Twisted, Talking Straight" and "Unplucked." Press
materials describe her as an "actress and playwright whose work
explores issues of cultural identity, gender, and ethnic community
dynamics," all true. In "Pomegranate Whisky," she morphs into diverse
characters in a dozen vignettes, promising to leave her audience
"shaken and stirred."

The show actually opens with a lesser piece about a Southern cosmetics
consultant hell-bent on introducing Western beauty techniques to the
women of the Middle East through her "Operation Makeover Takeover."
Unfortunately, "Takeover" never really takes off, despite Tatoulian’s
spot-on parody of the make-up maven.

The evening soon shifts into high gear, however, with Tatoulian’s
kinetic portrayal of a chicana madly in love with Los Angeles mayor
Antonio Villaraigosa. As she struts around exuding attitude, Tatoulian
engages in some fearless physical comedy, even as she shows off her
skill with accents and detailed, telling gestures.

Proving her versatility and range, Tatoulian follows that piece with a
vodka-swilling Russian man’s existentialist riff on Communism.
References to Dostoyevsky and Tolstoy ("funny guys") abound in the
literate monologue, which often breaks into an absurdly distorted
version of "I Love Paris."

The musical portions of the program are consistently witty. While
Tatoulian can claim credit for the clever lyrics, the arrangements and
original compositions are the work of Ara Dabandjian, who provides
instrumental accompaniment not just on keyboards, but also guitar and
accordion.

The most risqué among the songs is a subversive take on "My Favorite
Things," the all-too-familiar tune from "The Sound of Music." In her
gleeful rendition, Tatoulian – now sporting a British accent, natch –
strips the song of its family-friendly lyrics and substitutes
mischievous double entendres about the monthly visit of Aunt Flo.

The standout musical sequence of the show, however, is a medley of
Armenian children’s songs that Tatoulian performs to sultry jazz
rhythms. The concept is so inspired and the execution so flawless that
one wishes Tatoulian were in an actual cabaret club rather than the
somewhat drab studio where the show is currently staged.

Although Tatoulian is dynamic throughout the show, portions of the
evening that deal with Armenian themes and characters carry special
resonance. An improvisational bit about Armenian history fell a tad
flat during a recent performance, but Tatoulian was masterful in one
of her signature roles, the middle-aged, middle-class transplant from
Beirut to "the hills of the Glendale."

Tatoulian captures the chatty lady’s traits – from her mannerisms to
her diction – so precisely that the resulting performance proves not
just hysterically funny, but painfully honest. To be sure, the
character’s unchecked, inappropriate remarks generate hearty laughs
(the suggestive ring of her heavily-accented pronunciation of "vacuum"
leaves the audience in stitches). Yet, the power of Tatoulian’s comedy
lies in her ability to satirize the provincialism and materialism of
the character and of certain strata within the Armenian community that
she represents.

So, if it’s Sunday night and you’re in the mood for a drink, try
"Pomegranate Whisky." You will taste a wide range of surprising
flavors, from sweet vermouth to bitter gin, with a splash of Armenian
oghi thrown in.

********************************************* ******************************

3.Arts Briefs

* BEAUTIFUL ARMENIANS on Watertown cable in February

The independent documentary BEAUTIFUL ARMENIANS by Tamar Salibian is
broadcasting five days a week on Watertown’s Comcast cable channel 10
or RCN cable channel 13. The hour-long program airs on Fridays at 7
P.M., on Wednesdays and Saturdays at 9 A.M. and on Mondays and
Thursdays at 4 P.M.

In BEAUTIFUL ARMENIANS* Salibian reflects on the interrelation of
culture, family, and memory. Part travelogue, part family chronicle,
part meditation, BEAUTIFUL ARMENIANS starts in the United States and
eventually moves to the Middle East. Salibian weaves interviews,
portraits and comedic moments into a film about the place of the
individual in the contradictions of transnational identity.

Anahid Kassabian, film curator and professor at the University of
Liverpool says that Salibian’s "story sense is terrific" and the film
explores its subject with "subtlety, empathy and humor."

connect:
menians

* New Armenian sacred music

A new composition of Armenian sacred church music — the Badarak or
Divine Liturgy of the Armenian Apostolic Church — has been written by
San Diego-based composer George Kirazian and performed by the Pacific
Camerata choral group.

Composing the Badarak was a 12-year labor of love for Kirazian, who
became intimately familiar with the Yegmalian and Gomidas-composed
Badaraks while singing in San Diego’s Saint John Garabed Armenian
Church. With love and respect for the Yegmalian and Gomidas versions,
he was inspired to compose a new version of the music, combining both
modern sensibilities and traditional harmonies while retaining the
original text.

A published author and English professor at Grossmont College for
nearly forty years, Kirazian has always dedicated himself to music
since studying opera and literature at New York University as a young
student.

Selected sharagans from Kirazian’s BADARAK were recently performed by
the professional choral group, Pacific Camerata, which also plans to
record the composition.

connect:
bd.html

* Zulal’s Anaïs, Teni & Yeraz: In their own words

"We had a wonderful time in L.A. at the Mosaic Concert. The concert
was well organized by Hamazkayin, and the audience was incredibly
receptive to Zulal. We had such a warm reception from the audience
after the show, and it was truly a wonderful experience. From teens to
the older generation, it seems like we touched people and that felt
really wonderful. There’s already talk of organizing the next Mosaic 2
concert, so we might be back in L.A. again before we know it."

"As for the rest of this year, we’ll be taking a performance break to
really focus on our second album. Teni, our soprano, just moved back
to New York from Boston. So, the three of us are once again living in
the same city, and we have a found new energy to forge ahead on
several new projects."

"We’ve been working with several film directors to create music for
their soundtracks, which has been exciting. With our second album
coming out towards the end of this year, we already have booking
agents calling us to plan our concert tour, which will include New
York, L.A., and several cities in Europe."

(Editor’s note: Zulal is on the soundtrack of Arsinee Khanjian and
Gariné Torossian’s film STONE TIME TOUCH, playing this weekend at the
Berlin International Film Festival).

connect:

zulal

* Minnesota Book Awards honors Akçam’s new book

Taner Akçam’s A Shameful Act: The Armenian Genocide and the Question
of Turkish Responsibility has been named a finalist in the 19th annual
Minnesota Book Awards.

The statewide honor will pick from nearly 300 books entered in eight
categories. A SHAMEFUL ACT was one of five finalists in the General
Nonfiction category, which at 90 entries was the toughest to win.

In addition to the General Nonfiction honor, A SHAMEFUL ACT is
eligible for the Readers’ Choice Award. Minnesotans will have a chance
to vote online for this award between March 1 and April 15.

Winners will be announced on Saturday, May 5, at the Crowne Plaza
Hotel on the Saint Paul Riverfront in downtown. From 1 P.M. to 2:30
P.M. on May 5, the finalists will appear at a book signing at the
Central Library, 90 W. 4th St., Saint Paul.

connect:
[email protected]
www.th efriends.org/mnbookawards.html

* The ARMENIAN REPORTER wants your art briefs

The ARMENIAN REPORTER newspaper’s new weekly Arts & Culture section
wants your arts, entertainment, and cultural news headlines and story
ideas.
We want to know what Armenian artists and community and cultural
organizations are up to, what your accomplishments have been, and what
your future plans are. Write us if you know of or have heard about
Armenians doing anything that you feel is interesting for other
Armenians to know about, and we’ll follow up.

contact:
[email protected]

****************** ************************************************** *******

Please send your news to [email protected] and your letters to
[email protected]
(c) 2007 CS Media Enterprises LLC. All Rights Reserved

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.armenianreporteronline.com
www.EveEgoyan.com
www.myspace.com/beautifular
www.hopeforfamily.org/GODky
www.pacificcamerata.org
www.zulal.org
www.cdbaby.com/

Armenian Reporter – 2/10/2007 – from the Community section

ARMENIAN REPORTER
PO Box 129
Paramus, New Jersey 07652
Tel: 1-201-226-1995
Fax: 1-201-226-1660
Web:
Email: [email protected]

February 10, 2007 — From the Community section

1. CALIFORNIA: Dr. Arnold and Diane Gazarian invest $1.5 million in
Fresno State and the new California

2. WASHINGTON: Profiles: Armenians at DC-area universities intent on
global change

3. PENNSYLVANIA: Werfel’s FORTY DAYS featured in mini-exhibit at U-Penn library

4. CALIFORNIA: Motorcycle club launches annual toy drive: Hye Riders
set example of charity and outreach

5. CALIFORNIA: Program helps young people advance in education,
careers, and life

6. CALIFORNIA: NAASR and Ararat-Eskijian Museum host Ottoman
photography slide-lecture by Van Aroian

****************************************** *********************************

1. CALIFORNIA: Dr. Arnold and Diane Gazarian invest $1.5 million in
Fresno State and the new California

* Central California couple will help create a real estate center

by Paul Chaderjian
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

FRESNO, CA – Though Native Americans lived here as far back as 6,000
years before Christ, this story begins in the mid-1800s, when a
railroad baron established a depot here – setting modern day
development into motion.

Spanish explorers had deemed the empty, arid desert uninhabitable, and
passed through it, as did the Gold Rush-era ’49ers. But when a
labyrinth of irrigation canals was built on this mostly-flat terrain,
the region’s Mediterranean climate allowed waves of immigrants to turn
the southern San Joaquin Valley into the most agriculturally bountiful
area in the world.

Now this region, dubbed by the media as the "New California," is home
to a booming population of more than three million people. It is the
raisin capital of the world, produces more than 250 crops, and
provides a quarter of the food eaten in the U.S. The Southern San
Joaquin Valley’s agricultural business brings in more than $16 billion
in revenues every year.

In this booming region, once an empty desert, a retired dentist and
his wife, the children of hard-working immigrants, are helping the
local university to address regional challenges and to maintain its
role as the intellectual and educational center for the Central San
Joaquin Valley.

With a gift of one-and-a-half million dollars, Dr. Arnold and Diane
Gazarian are establishing a real estate center at California State
University, Fresno, and helping to launch the biggest fundraising
effort in the university’s 100-year history.

"We’ve been blessed," says Dr. Gazarian when we meet for coffee at his
daughter’s business, Uncle Harry’s New York Bagelry, in North Fresno.
"We’ve really been blessed, and we’re fortunate enough to be able to
do it. I think it’s going to be very good for the valley. I think it’s
going to help with the education of a lot of people who are interested
in this field."

"The Gazarian gift sets the stage for Fresno State and the Craig
School of Business to become the central player in real estate
research in the Central Valley," says Dr. Douglas Hensler, chair of
the Dean and Sid Craig School of Business at CSUF.

The Gazarians and university officials envision creating a think-tank
in the next three years that can execute fact-based planning for
growth, a place where academics can pursue specialized degrees,
conduct massive research projects, hold symposia, and come together
with community and business leaders and the public to jointly address
not just growth but also the economic, social, and environmental
concerns of the region.

"We talked about the donation with the Dean of the School of Business
for a number of months," says Dr. Gazarian, "and the decision was to
make the investment in the university. I think that’s what it is. It’s
an investment in the Valley’s future, the university’s future…and
hopefully an investment in humankind."

The Gazarians’ generosity and "investment in humankind" began several
decades ago. The couple has been behind some major education
initiatives, and has served on the Fresno State Foundation Board of
Governors for more than 10 years. Dianne Gazarian (nee Berberian)
directs the Berberian and Gazarian Family Foundation, and the couple
established the Haig and Isabel Berberian Endowed Chair in Armenian
Studies at Fresno State nearly two decades ago.

"Diane and Arnold have been the most impressive consistent supporters
of the Armenian Studies Program at Fresno State, since they enabled
the establishment of the first full-time and functioning endowed chair
in any discipline on our campus," says Dr. Dickran Kouymjian,
professor, director and coordinator of the Center for Armenian Studies
at CSUF.

Dr. Kouymjian, who holds the Haig and Isabel Berberian Endowed Chair,
says the Gazarians established the chair in honor of Diane’s mother
and father. "But their contribution only began with the donation,"
says Dr. Kouymjian. "For the past 20 years they have been unfailing in
their support."

Dr. Gazarian served as the president of the Armenian Studies Program
Advisory Board for many years, and Dr. Kouymjian says Arnold and Diane
have been generous with their advice and help on nearly every
important issue.

"They have also never refused to organized receptions and other events
in their gracious home," says Dr. Kouymjian. "They have asked for
nothing in return, and both of them and their children never seek
publicity or other distinctions. They are hard-working, elegant
people, with a permanent concern for the Armenian Studies Program,
Fresno State, and their city, Fresno."

* Unpaved streets and sidewalks

When 76-year-old Arnold Gazarian was a teenager, he walked a mile to
school and helped out his parents on the family’s raisin farm near
Fowler, CA. He says he remembers things very vividly, especially his
dream to grow up and become a dentist.

"An uncle in Fresno was a dentist," recalls Gazarian. "What I liked
about that is that the dental office was always clean. He was never
perspiring or dirty working under the vines. I thought, this is a
great life, and I want to be working with my hands, and this is what I
want to be."

Life on the farm was difficult, says Gazarian. "Mom and dad worked the
ranch, as raisin growers. There were no sidewalks out on the ranch, no
asphalt driveway. When it rained, it would be muddy. Hot water and
heat and cooking was done all on a wood stove, whether it was the
middle of summer or dead of winter."

Groceries were purchased on credit until the crop came in and his
parents were able to pay their bills. "I guess what we would do is
once a week, we would go to an Armenian store in Fresno to do our
shopping. After the crop would come in, mom and dad would go and pay
off the bill, or TRY to pay off the bill – almost all of it."

"After World War II was over," remembers Gazarian, "we got at that
time a butane stove and a butane heater at the house. And a butane
water heater. We’d made our weekly trip to Fresno, and we came home on
a cold winter afternoon and it had been installed. And all I did was
open the hot water tap – and voila, there was hot water!"

He laughs. "It was like downtown," he says. "I must have been about
13. It is something that I will never ever forget."

After high school, Gazarian attended Reedley Community College,
enrolled at the University of California at Berkeley for a year, then
transferred across the Bay to UC San Francisco’s School of Dentistry.
He began his dentistry practice in 1956 and retired after 33 years,
when the family’s farming, real estate, and development businesses
began demanding more of his attention.

"Since I was six or seven years old," he says, "that’s all I wanted to
be, a dentist. Little did I realize that the profession I was going in
wasn’t the cleanest in the world. The mouth has more bacteria than any
place else in the body."

But though it wasn’t exactly the clean job he had envisioned,
dentistry ended up being a very rewarding profession, says Gazarian.

"My patients were the light of my life," he says. "I’d wake up in the
morning, and I couldn’t wait to get to work, because I enjoyed it. It
was a great profession, in that I was usually done by five o’clock,
and Dianne could have dinner on the table at six o’clock to eat with
the kids, and we always did. Six, 6:15, every day, dinner was on the
table, and we sat around as a family and had dinner."

The Gazarians, whose parents came from Kars and Kharpert via
Massachusetts, raised four daughters, and now have five grandkids.
"This is my third daughter that owns this place," he says, referring
to the Bagelry. "She and her husband put together Uncle Harry’s and
now Betty’s Sandwiches, named after my mother-in-law. My father-in-law
was known as Harry back East, and my mother-in-law always used to call
him Harry. My mother-in-law’s name was Isabelle, but everybody called
her Betty."

When the Berberian and Gazarian family business began demanding more
of his attention, Dr. Gazarian had less and less time to practice
dentistry. "We farmed about a couple of thousand of acres between here
and Modesto," he says. "Our major crop was almonds. We also farmed
cling peaches, cherries, citrus, grapes and, table grapes."

When his father-in-law passed away, Gazarian found himself spending
more time in the property management and development businesses.
"Every time someone would call, I literally had my hands in someone’s
mouth. So, it got to the point that I had to move on. It was time to
close chapter in the book and open up another chapter."

* Community service

Dr. Gazarian emphasizes that he and his wife have been very fortunate,
and their latest gift to Fresno State is just another way of giving
back to the community. "The good Lord has been good to us," he says,
"and we are giving back to the community that has allowed us to do
what little we’ve been able to do."

For the past 50 years, Gazarian has been giving back as a member of
the Exchange Club community service organization. "I’ve been through
the chairs. Everything from president to secretary," he says, "and I’m
kind of now a knife-and-forker." Gazarian never missed a weekly
meeting during his career in dentistry. He says he had a lot of fun
doing good work for the community, like helping abused children.
"That’s our major project," he says.

Along with helping victims of abuse and trying to stop child abuse,
the Exchange Club reaches out to underprivileged children with help,
honors members of the law enforcement community, provides scholarships
and honors to high school students, and even has its members ring
bells for the Salvation Army every holiday season.

Gazarian says he and his wife owe their success in life to public
schools and colleges, and he attributes their education to the
education system funded by the public. "These institutions didn’t just
happen," he says. "And people don’t do things by just themselves."

The retired dentist says he could not turn down an invitation from
Fresno State President Dr. John D. Welty 10 years ago to serve on the
Fresno State Foundation Board. "Diane and I discussed it, and we said,
you know, it’s something we’re interested in – so why not? You cannot
help but get interested in what Fresno State is doing, and in
education."

With the Gazarians’ input, Fresno State strengthened its development
department and created development directors for each of the schools
at the university. "A few years ago," says Dr. Gazarian, "we decided
to move ahead with a comprehensive campaign for the university, and
the reason for that is the state of California today.

Dr. Gazarian says state funding of public universities covers only
about three-quarters of the costs, compared to a decade ago when
California covered about 95 percent of the budget. "State funding is
beginning to diminish," says Dr. Gazarian, "and without private
support, the university is not going to flourish."

* The new California

Fresno State’s largest fundraising effort touts the Central San
Joaquin Valley as the "New California," citing similar references to
the region by the SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE, National Public Radio, and
the Public Policy Institute of California. TIME Magazine called the
region "the last Real California" and said that Fresno was "the last
Real California left."

The city and county of Fresno are named after the ash trees that are
said to have lined the nearby San Joaquin River, which flowed out of
the icy Sierras. That river, which at one time was so large that
steamboats ferried people up to Stockton and Sacramento, is now dammed
in a dozen places in the mountains and nearly dry on the valley floor.

But the farmland that the canals were built to water is now being
turned into miles and miles of new neighborhoods. Escalating real
estate prices in other parts of the state are driving more and more
people to Central California from the Bay Area and Southern
California. Volumes have been written about the loss of the family
farms, and how that loss is resulting in the loss of a distinctive
American culture and family values.

Challenging development and redevelopment concerns have been
sensational cases like "Operation Rezone." The FBI investigation,
broken in the media by L.A. TIMES journalist Mark Arax, resulted in
the conviction of more than a dozen, including Fresno and Clovis city
council members. They were accused and convicted of accepting bribes
from developers to rezone parcels of land.

Cheap housing and unchecked, sometimes illegal, development have
created a shift in population in California. NPR called this
agriculturally bountiful region the final destination for a "reverse
migration" from the coast into the Central Valley.

"In the next 40 years," NPR reported, "experts foresee a California
with 24 million more residents, populating cities where now they see
only farmland and foothills. California is not an idea moving west,
but an idea moving east."

"Driven by demographic, cultural and political shifts," wrote the
CHRONICLE, "a rift is growing between California’s coast and its
interior, replacing the north-south split that has defined state
politics for more than 150 years."

Fresno State says the Public Policy Institute of California see the
Central Valley’s population increasing at a rapid pace, surpassing
every other major region of the state. "Over the years, this trend
will dramatically alter the state’s social and political landscape,"
says the Institute. "For the first time since the Gold Rush, more than
half of Californians live outside the Bay Area and Los Angeles."

Fresno State fundraisers say that this "New California" covers an area
larger than 11 states, measures up to the geographic size of
Tennessee, has three million residents, and that "in the midst of
growth is the region’s intellectual, academic and sports entertainment
leader, the University of the New California, Fresno State.

"We are in a growing part of California," says Dr. Gazarian. "We are
probably the only growing part of California. The major growing force
within California is here in the Central Valley, so it is important
for the university to thrive."

Gazarian says the "New California" campaign at Fresno State is still
in its quiet stages. "As it began rolling along," he says, "Diane and
I decided, you know, we need to do something for the university."

Their interest in education, coupled with their growing involvement
with real estate professionals and bigger investments in real estate,
helped them formulate their interest in establishing an academic
environment for the study and application of real estate.

"In real estate, when someone makes an investment," says Gazarian,
"it’s generally the biggest investment they’ll make. And ethics are
very important, whether it’s in the lending business or the mortgage
business. It all falls under the umbrella of real estate."

Gazarian says all one has to do is look at the newspaper headlines to
see how people are being cheated out of their life savings. "I’m
talking about ethics in general. I just think ethics is really
important. I don’t care what the business is. I don’t care if it’s
law, medicine, digging ditches, dentistry, plumbing or carpeting;
ethics is real important."

Dr. Gazarian’s vision for the Real Estate Center is to address issues
like ethics as well as real estate planning, sales, housing and
financing. "I’m sure there is going to be research on how many homes
are being built, how many are being sold," says Gazarian. "And
developers can use this information to plan ahead. All of this is
going to be rolled, as I understand it, under the umbrella of the Real
Estate Center."

Dr. Gazarian says he and his wife have seen the sprawl in southern
California, and it has been difficult for them to understand the
reason: whether it was poor deliberate planning or the lack of smart
planning that created the sprawl.

"We felt like we didn’t want to see growth that wasn’t really smart in
the Central Valley," says Dr. Gazarian, citing the endless list of
problems facing the Central San Joaquin, including congested roadways
and highways and environmental and air quality issues.

"We thought about it; we thought that one thing that Fresno State
doesn’t have is a real estate department," says Dr. Gazarian. "A place
where people in the business can come together under one umbrella to
discuss their needs."

"Arnold and Dianne Gazarian share our cause of taking responsibility
for the well-being of our community, and training effective planning
leaders for the future," says School of Business Dean Doug Hensler.
"We are thrilled that they have chosen to name the ‘Arnold and Dianne
Gazarian Real Estate Center,’ and we look forward to a long-term,
productive partnership with the Gazarian family in the cause of real
estate and land-use planning,"

Dr. Gazarian says the School of Business at Fresno State will offer
its real estate courses under the umbrella of the Real Estate Center,
where symposiums can be held "so we can start growing the smart way in
the Valley."

"This gift," says Dr. Hensler, "will allow us to leverage the work in
the Real Estate and Land Use Institute by John Mahoney and Garo
Kalfayan, where data is compiled and disseminated. We will begin to
use that data in a way that allows for better planning in the region."

*********************************** ****************************************

2. WASHINGTON: Profiles: Armenians at DC-area universities intent on
global change

by Alexa Millinger
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

WASHINGTON – Young Armenians are excelling in a variety of fields all
over the world; but perhaps nowhere more than in the U.S. capital,
where they are intent on creating "global change."

The universities around Washington, DC, attract young Armenians from
far and wide, who wish to learn about the world, and find a way to
play a role in shaping its future. The REPORTER spoke with four of
them.

TALAR KAZANJIAN arrived in Washington from Syria in August on a
Fulbright Scholarship; she’s studying in an international affairs
graduate program at Johns Hopkins University. Having lived in climes
from Lebanon to Canada, Talar decided to continue her studies in
Washington.

"This is a great place for anyone studying politics," she said. Talar
is going towards a degree concentrated in strategic studies and
conflict resolution. She hopes to relate these studies to Armenian
issues, and hopes others will do the same.

"As Armenians we need a lot more people to study political science and
international affairs in an Armenian context," said Talar. "We have to
prepare as many experts in the field as possible."

IRINA ALAVERDYAN, a graduate student at Georgetown University, shares
the motive of obtaining an education in the U.S. and bringing skills
back to create change in Armenia.

"The goal of studying here is to go back and make change," said Irina,
who arrived from Armenia in August. "We really need young
professionals in Armenia; young people should make this change."

Irina, who is studying culture, communication, and technology at
Georgetown, hopes to return to Armenia and start her own political
public relations company. She accumulated valuable experience working
in the public affairs section of the U.S. Embassy in Armenia, where
she had the honor of working with U.S. Ambassador John Evans.

After living in the U.S. for several months, she finds it "very
organized, compared to Armenia." However, she finds the church-related
division of the Armenian diaspora community in the U.S. to be
detrimental to Armenia.

"I realize that the church plays a very political role here," she said
– which is different from what she saw in Armenia.

ARAM AVETISYAN, a graduate student at George Mason University,
believes that Armenia’s relations with the diaspora, particularly in
the U.S., is integral to Armenia’s prosperity. He believes the
community should be more active with more "business, economic, and
cultural contact."

Aram also hopes to use his American education to return to Armenia and
mitigate some of the nation’s problems. In addition to working towards
a degree in Public Policy at GMU, Aram is simultaneously working at
the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic’s office in Washington.

Aram and his wife came to the U.S. in 2003, drawn by the promise of a
"better opportunity," yet he shares the objective of ultimately
returning to his homeland.

"I hope to use all my knowledge and skills in Armenia," he said. He
sees corruption worldwide as one of the primary problems facing
nations and believes that abating corruption in a country like Armenia
would "improve the social situation."

NAIRI SIMONIAN, a UCLA graduate from California, graduated from
American University Law School in 2005 and now works for the AU Law
School on a grant project from the Department of Justice, focusing on
prisoners’ rights.

Coming from Los Angeles, Nairi observes DC’s young Armenian community
as having a higher level of international awareness, and a greater
understanding of the government than the more "cultural" Armenian
community of southern California.

Nairi describes DC Armenians as having a considerable sense of
"responsibility" – which may explain the idealism, dedication, and
conviction of the Armenian students and young professionals in the
area.

*************************************** ************************************

3. PENNSYLVANIA: Werfel’s FORTY DAYS featured in mini-exhibit at U-Penn library

by Andrew Kevorkian
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

PHILADELPHIA — A small and fascinating, but inclusive, exhibition on
the life of Franz Werfel – including the story of THE FORTY DAYS OF
MUSA DAGH – is currently on display at the University of Pennsylvania.

The Musa Dagh story is told in one of the eight cabinet displays, and
includes the hand-written, two-volume manuscript of the book that
became a bestseller in every country into which it was translated from
the original German. The book was published in November 1933, and was
banned in Germany by Adolph Hitler in February 1934 as "undesirable."
Also shown is a copy of the original Viking Press edition of the book,
published in America in 1934.

Included in the display are the title page and six photos – from a
collection of 30 photos – presented to Werfel by his "admirer and
friend," the Rev. A.A. Bedikian, long-time pastor of the Armenian
Evangelical Church in New York. Rev. Bedikian had taken the photos in
1936, and they show what life was like post-FORTY DAYS. They would
give any film producer ideas for his choice of locale.

Werfel first learned of the events that he later novelized when he was
traveling in the Middle East and met survivors. In his follow-up
research, Werfel was given the eye-witness accounts of Rev. Dikran
Andreassian, a native of Yoghonoluk, from which many of those who took
refuge on Musa Dagh came. Because the historic accounts of the
duration of the resistance vary, Werfel selected "40" for its
symbolic, Biblical connotations.

The next cabinet contains details and reports of the circuitous and
tortuous fight from Europe of the Werfels (his wife was the famous
Alma Mahler) and a dozen other Jewish writers and scholars fleeing
Nazi Europe. In a NEW YORK TIMES cutting of October 14, 1940, in which
their arrival is reported, the first interviewee is Werfel, and THE
FORTY DAYS is describe as "an epic novel."

Indeed, the entire gem of an exhibition is about Werfel’s travel and
exile, from his Prague birth, where he started his literary career as
a poet and playwright, to his days in Vienna and France and America,
where he was to die, in 1945, in an artists’ colony in California.

In an interesting sidelight, one learns that whereas the egotistical
Gustav Mahler made the very talented Alma Schindler give up her music
and "make her music his music," Werfel was to make her a soul-mate.

The exhibition is in the Rosenwald Gallery of Penn’s Van Pelt-Dietrich
Library. Though the Library is located at 3420 Walnut Street, with its
entrance is via Locust Walk. The free exhibition is open Monday
through Friday, from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.; and on Saturday from noon to 4
p.m., by prior arrangement. It runs through April 13, and is well
worth the two-hour-or-so visit. A photo ID is required.

The exhibition is mounted by Dr. Violet Lutz.

******************************************* ********************************

4. CALIFORNIA: Motorcycle club launches annual toy drive: Hye Riders
set example of charity and outreach

by Paul Chaderjian
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

PASADENA, Calif. – The appetizing aroma from skewered kebobs barbequed
over an open flame, a giant and inviting bounce-house for kids, loud
Armenian music and nearly two dozen powerful and picture-perfect
Harley-Davidson motorcycles greeted supporters of the annual Hye
Riders motorcycle club toy drive.

"We heard about what they’re doing," says Sam Kartounian, " and we
figured it would be a great way for us to support this small niche in
the Armenian community. I think it’s really commendable what they’re
actually doing, being that the whole image of bikers is kind of
stepping out of the whole realm of what Armenian society dictates."

Throughout the sunny Sunday afternoon, Armenians from all over
Southern California, Armenian, Hispanic and African-American bikers
and their families — as well as those simply wanting to enjoy a good
Armenian picnic — stopped by the Pasadena Armenian Community Center
to donate toys.

"We brought a football, some sports equipment, coloring book, some
educational toys and board games," says Hagop Jerejian. "I didn’t know
about it last year, but a friend of mine told me about it. They do a
lot of good work for the Armenian community here and abroad, so I came
by, just a way to help them out."

After spending a number of years as a member of motorcycle clubs, Hye
Riders founder Berj Kasparian decided to create the club in 1998. His
goal was to bring young Armenians bikers together, organize monthly
rides, give young Armenian bikers an alternative to joining other
"hog" clubs and create a brotherhood based on community service and
charity… like the toy drive.

"I know it’s after Christmas," says Kasparian, "but during the
Holidays, we are all so busy. All these clubs you see here, we visit
local orphanages and retirement homes during the Holidays. So, we
decided to hold off on our toy drive for kids in Armenia until after
the Holidays."

Since its inception, Hye Riders has admitted more than 150 members
into its ranks. There are 42 members in Armenia, and members in
Southern California have set an exemplary standard for charity work to
other bike clubs. In addition to raising funds for the Hayastan
All-Armenian Fund, visiting local orphans and the elderly, Hye Riders
touch the lives of young people all over Armenia through their annual
toy drive.

"Every time I go to Armenia, I take different guys from our crew,"
says Kasparian, "and we meet up with guys from our crew over there.
The most amazing thing is that these kids, the people, they are so
surprised at what we do and how we do it. We go there, winter, summer,
it doesn’t matter, and the kids at the orphanages and in the villages
wait for us with open arms. When we leave, the kids are always crying,
asking when are we coming back. It gets extremely touching, very
touching. It’s not just a matter of taking the toys. It’s going over
there and seeing what we are able to do."

Clad in the requisite leather jacket and proudly wearing the Hye Rider
tricolor emblem on his back, biker Drtad Bedjakian say this year’s toy
drive means a lot more to him after he visited the homeland last year
and handed out the toys in person. There are two trips to Armenia
planned in 2007 — the first in May and a second one in September.

"Just seeing the happiness and the expressions on their faces, how
happy they were to see us and have us over there, the way they treated
us," says Bedjakian, "it makes you feel like you’re doing something
good for your people. Seeing that happiness on the kids’ faces is
something you very rarely see. You feel joyous when they grab a
99-cent car and treat it like it was a ten thousand dollar toy."

Kasparian says members of Hye Riders come from all walks of life.
Among the leather-clad rough and tough bikers are students,
businessmen, doctors, lawyers, but no women. The club is for men only,
but women are welcomed club activities, charity events and
get-togethers. The club has meetings, elects officers and requires
that members pass drug screen tests to ensure that they are clean. Hye
Riders has even won endorsements by legendary hog clubs that have been
around since the 60s.

"This year," says Kasparian, "these toys are going not just to an
orphanage, but to children in villages, where the kids don’t have
anything but rocks and sticks. If you’ve been there, you know what I’m
talking about. This drive helps them out tremendously, because we have
a lot of toys, clothing, blankets and everything that can be used out
there."

"Bikers always seem to get a bad reputation," says Stepan Mekhitarian,
who teaches math in Venice. "I feel like they always get labeled as
rebels, especially with Harleys going around and making a lot of
noise. I think for the most part, the public has a fairly negative
image of what they do. But I think the Hye Riders are the exception
here. They do a lot of good work. I think if they continue doing what
they’re doing, people are going to see that not every biker is
necessarily a rebel."

Kasparian says members of the club are basically sharing their
blessings and good fortune. They love their bikes and love to ride
them. He thinks they are lucky to be able to afford motorcycles that
cost anywhere between 30 to 50 thousand dollars on up. "We are
blessed, and we are spoiled," says Kasparian. "For example, you go to
Armenia, and those guys are piecing their bikes together. They take
parts from old bikes, Russian bikes, and as long as it’s rolling, and
it looks like a bike, they ride."

The Hye Riders say they share their blessings by reaching out to those
in need at home and overseas. The club often rides out to Southern
California neighborhoods where the homeless congregate . These
Armenian bikers take the homeless food and clothing, and not just
during the holidays but throughout the year.

The bike club also takes regularly scheduled rides to Armenian
retirement homes, taking food to the seniors, sitting down and
spending time with the elders. They also visit Armenian schools and
participate in April 24 memorials. Their annual genocide commemoration
ride is mandatory for each member to attend. Other rides and meetings
may be skipped by members if they have family or work related
responsibilities.

"We’re all family members, and we have businesses," says Kasparian.
"To us, number one is your family and your business. If you cannot
attend, the reason is going to be that you have a function with your
family or business." After they meet their personal responsibilities,
the Hye Riders pour their energy and resources into their bikes.

"Riding a Harley or a motorcycle is a whole different life," says
Kasparian. "You get on a bike, and you change. Your attitude changes.
You’re a happier person. It’s really enjoyable. But most of all, what
turns us on, especially in the Armenian community are the tricolor we
wear on our back. We are representing Armenians, and we have to show
the good sides of Armenians."

(Editor’s note: For more information about joining HyeRiders or to
support the club’s annual toy drive, visit the web site
)

************************* **************************************************

5. CALIFORNIA: Program helps young people advance in education,
careers, and life

* AGBU’s Generation Next mentorship program matches teens with role models

by Jenny Kiljian
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

PASADENA, Calif. — On Sunday, February 4, millions of people waited
anxiously to see who would win the Super Bowl. That bout would find
only one champion. But, the games that took place at a park in
Pasadena that same morning would ensure that everyone emerged
victorious.

Every few months, the AGBU Generation Next Mentorship Program holds a
"pairing day" to match young people between the ages of 12 and 18 with
suitable mentors. During the event, participants play games designed
to foster teamwork and build self-confidence, after which they share a
casual lunch where they can learn more about one another’s interests
and hobbies.

At the end of the day, each mentor and young person fills out a form
listing his or her top three choices for a potential pairing. Using
those lists, along with relevant biographical information, AGBU
Generation Next Director Ara Arzumanian has the enviable task of
playing matchmaker for these couplings. He said it is "an organic and
effective way to make these pairings," which often last officially for
three to five years, and develop into lifelong friendships thereafter.

Young people generally find their way into the program, now in its
10th year, through references from school counselors, friends and
family. "We look for kids with the potential to grow," said
Arzumanian, noting that the program isn’t necessarily for troubled
youth or wayward teens. Mentors guide their mentees through any number
of problems-difficulty at school, issues at home, low self-esteem, as
well as acculturating to a new environment in the case of recent
immigrants. Arzumanian explained that kids grapple with issues such as
gangs, drugs, drinking, smoking, bullying and truancy as early as
junior high. "The purpose of Generation Next is prevention, not
intervention. With the help of a good mentor, the young people able to
identify these negative situations and avoid them ahead of time."

Arzumanian said the goals of the program are to build "The Three
C’s"-self-confidence, career and culture-in each young person. By
building a foundation of strong self-confidence, he noted, the mentees
would be empowered to take the necessary steps to further their
careers, as well as to "live the Armenian culture." "Oftentimes,
people say that we should ‘preserve’ our culture," said Arzumanian.
"You preserve something with formaldehyde because it’s dead. I want
them to live our culture every day. For a youngster, having a mentor
who is a friend and good example is a huge boost in these areas."

Christine Saakyan is a "veteran mentee" who joined the program five
years ago as a seventh grader. Now a senior at Glendale High School,
Saakyan reflects positively on her experience. "Having a mentor taught
me how to communicate with people, to be open-minded, to make friends,
and it helped me do better in school," said the 18-year-old. "As
girls, we think about boys all the time. I used to be envious of other
girls, I wanted to ditch school. But my mentor taught me to do the
right thing."

She and her mentor spent time together by going to the movies, having
coffee dates, and sharing dinner with Saakyan’s home-which helped
build bridges for the family. "I have two older sisters, but they were
busy with their lives. My mentor was a friend of theirs, and she
helped us bond more. If not for the program, we might not be so
close." Others also noticed the change. "People see a difference in
me. I’m more active, friendly towards people," said Saakyan.

Saakyan, who wants to be a pastry chef, said she would continue to
support the program and become a mentor when the time was right.

For 20-year-old Lena Manoukian, that time was last year when she was
enlisted as a mentor by Arzumanian. She mentors a 12-year-old girl,
who she described as "very bright, smart and funny, with a good
heart." The girl’s parents sought a mentor for her because they wanted
her to socialize more and to be less shy. To that end, Manoukian takes
her mentee to the movies, talks to her on the phone, and participates
in AGBU-sponsored group activities with her. Manoukian explained the
difficulties that young girls face in junior high-struggling to make
friends, wear the right clothes, and have the right hair style.
Recently, her mentee asked her to fulfill a simple wish: to have
straight hair. Manoukian said that the young girl was exuberant and
felt good about herself afterward. "She’s a girl, and she needs an
older role model in her life. She just needs some attention from
someone who is like a big sister and an authority figure," said
Manoukian, who said she would be happy to stay with her mentee for
more than the one-year commitment required of each pairing.

Armen Yeghiazarians has been mentoring the same young boy for nearly
two years. "My mentee is great," said Yeghiazarians. The Clark Magnet
High School student is "very smart, and a good kid" who recently came
to the United States and "has adjusted well" to his new environs.
Their activities range from going to lunch, getting coffee and seeing
movies to playing video games at Dave and Buster’s, a popular arcade.
"He was kind of shy, and I’ve helped him to be more outgoing," said
Yeghiazarians, who noted the dearth of male mentors for what is an
increasing number of young boys seeking to join the program. "We need
mentors-young men especially to give their time to help the youth of
the community. We need positive role models for kids. For ten to
twelve hours each month, you can make a difference in a kid’s life."

Arzumanian pointed out that the program has strived to meet the same
professional criteria as mainstream mentorship programs such as Big
Brothers and Big Sisters of America. They maintain a three-fold mentor
support structure that includes ongoing training, three mentor
development days each year, as well as keen interaction with the
Generation Next Task Force. The ten-member committee comprises veteran
mentors Vrejh Aghajanian, Narine Galstian, and Yeghiazarians, along
with Arzumanian and program coordinator Nora Ayvazian. In addition to
the Task Force, the program has volunteer case managers-many of whom
are mentors themselves-who keep track of progress, assess mentors, and
address concerns from mentors, mentees or their families as they
arise.

"Too often, we see kids what they think are adult behaviors and trying
to grow up too soon. They want to drink, smoke, do drugs, have sex and
get into fights," said Arzumanian. Even if a young person demonstrates
high-risk behavior and doesn’t mesh well with the group, eventually he
or she will soften up through group activity, according to Arzumanian.
"By being with other kids, we give them an environment that allows
them to act like a kid again."

Arzumanian also emphasized that the mentor and mentee relationship is
strictly confidential, and that mentors do not serve as "spies" for
parents. Only in cases where a mentor finds out someone, whether it is
the mentee or another person, could be in harm would that
confidentiality be broken. "We are all mandated reporters," explained
Arzumanian. "But this strengthens the relationship-it shows that they
trust you, and they are seeking help in resolving a problem they can’t
handle as kids."

It’s a well-known fact that young people need boundaries, structure,
role models and guidance, particularly in junior high and high school
when much of their identity is based on comparisons and competition
with peers. Narine Galstian, who has been part of the program for five
years, said that while young people certainly appreciate their mentor
in the immediacy of their relationship, they would see the lasting
benefits into adulthood. "We build their trust and their confidence.
We make sure they understand they’re not being judged or disciplined.
We’re not a friend who will hurt them. And, they’ll see the value of
our relationship later on in life," said Galstian.

Even mentors will learn something from this relationship. "It taught
me patience," said Yeghiazarians. "I work in corporate America, and I
have to meet deadlines. But dealing with a kid is not on a deadline.
It taught me that I won’t get a result in three months or even six
months-that a relationship needs to be fostered. It made me a better
manager, and I feel good because I made a difference in a kid’s life."

Lena Manoukian saw the power of sacrifice in her mentee. "She’s not
selfish. She saves money to spend on her parents for their birthdays
because she sees how much they do to take care of her and her two
brothers."

It’s a lesson that Galstian hopes the rest of the community can learn.
"The most important message to the community is that we’re an
organization that helps build the future for our community as a whole.
These kids are the next generation. If we don’t put them on the right
track now, they’re never going to turn around to help us later," she
said. "We want them to grow up not feeling alienated, to be proud of
our history, and to give back to the community."

* * *

(Editor’s Note: AGBU Generation Next serves Armenian communities in
Greater Los Angeles with the hope of expanding its programs throughout
California and in other parts of the country served by the AGBU. For
more information on the AGBU Generation Next Mentorship Program, visit
or call 626-794-7942.)

Jenny Kiljian is a former editor of the ARMENIAN WEEKLY.

***************************************** **********************************

6. CALIFORNIA: NAASR and Ararat-Eskijian Museum host Ottoman
photography slide-lecture by Van Aroian

by Janet Samuelian
Special to the ARMENIAN REPORTER

MISSION HILLS, Calif. — The Ararat-Eskijian Museum offered more than
they advertised in "World in Transition: Armenians in the Ottoman
Photographs Collection of the J. Paul Getty Museum" on December 3,
2006. Early arrivals were treated to a sampling of a CD-Rom brought
from Armenia by art historian Levon Chookaszian – the UNESCO chair of
Armenian Art History at Yerevan State University, and current Kazan
Chair Visiting Professor at Cal State Fresno.

"At the recent world technology summit in Tunisia, this was voted one
of the ten best CDs in electronic education," Chookaszian said. He
held up the CD-Rom and added, "It took first prize especially for its
cultural content, such as the segment about the 100th anniversary of
Aram Khachaturian."

The huge electronic archive, which takes one month to see, was
researched by Garik Chookaszian, funded by the Armenian Prime
Minister, and costs $40 per copy. It was phenomenal to see such clear
images of Siamanto, Varoujan, Yessayan, Komitas, Zohrab, various
political leaders, even Khrimian Hayrig at the Berlin Congress. One
hopes that a diaspora organization will help market it.

Museum administrator Maggie Mangassarian-Goshen stood to welcome
museum founders Luther and Ann Eskijian as 65 visitors rapidly filled
the hall. She introduced guest speaker Van Aroian of Massachusetts.
The NAASR Boardmember spent two years at the Getty Research Library,
from 1999 to 2001, searching through 6,000 photos collected by Pierre
De Gigord to find Armenian themes and contributions to Ottoman
society.

"I realized people like to solve problems, such as Levon’s brother
whose CD-Rom is a fabulous development. Every problem is an
opportunity," declared Aroian. He gave an overview of the history of
photography, starting with a Chinese precursor to the CAMERA OBSCURA
from 500 BC. He credited Daguerre with the full development of the
camera in 1839.

Aroian explained that photograph collector Pierre De Gigord’s uncle
was president of the Banque Ottoman, so he had access to court
photographers such as Abdullah Freres. That is how the archive held by
the Getty came to be.

"So rather than see ourselves as victims, we were innovators,
producers, and contributors. Armenian photographers were part of the
development and expansion of that technology after 1839; we had been
expert in physics, chemistry and metallurgy – in fact, we had a
monopoly, with 25 photo studios in Bolis."

Aroian noted that Sultan Abdul Hamid was also a photographer, whose
photos were donated to Harvard University and Library of Congress, as
well as to the British Museum and Istanbul University Library.

Slide after slide showed people at varying levels of society, rich to
destitute. There were photos of Balian-designed buildings: "There is
at the Getty an inscribed red leather album of 40 photos presented by
Sarkis Balian to the King of Spain – their footprints are all over
Bolis today" Aroian revealed.

The enthusiastic speaker warned listeners to not take old photographs
for granted. "They have historic value and give an important visual
dimension; save them from the dumpster and send them to Ruth Thomasian
at Project Save. The Getty will help subsidize your publication of
their photos. They want to develop the area around the Mediterranean
world and are building a Middle Eastern program."

Aroian urged guests to join NAASR (the National Association for
Armenian Studies and Research), and during the reception that followed
the very engaging speaker responded graciously to questions from local
photographers like Levon Parian. Van Aroian’s website is
[email protected].

*********************** ************************************************** **

Please send your news to [email protected] and your letters to
[email protected]
(c) 2007 CS Media Enterprises LLC. All Rights Reserved

http://www.armenianreporteronline.com
www.hyeriders.com
www.agbugennext.org

MFA: FM Reacts to Critics on Armenia’s Isolation in Azg Daily

PRESS RELEASE
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Armenia
Contact: Information Desk
Tel: (374-10) 52-35-31
Email: [email protected]
Web:

THERE ARE CONSEQUENCES TO POLITICAL EXPLOITATION OF PRINCIPLES

I’ve been following our press for the last two days, and I’d like to
respond to those expressions which have appeared regarding my statement
that the Kars-Akhalkalak-Tbilisi-Baku railroad can’t result in Armenia’s
isolation and can’t cause additional injury to Armenia’s economy.

I have great respect toward the members of our press corps and I know that
they are neither inattentive nor naïve, and that they cannot not see the
most obvious realities. Nevertheless, those defeatist attitudes which
appeared in our press and in various public statements, truly surprised
me.

I understand that there are `objective’ reasons for these expressions. A
difficult election campaign awaits us, and each grouping is attempting to
acquire a piece of the pie, by exploiting various issues at all
appropriate and inappropriate opportunities, often, in my opinion, coming
up against our own national interests. In this context, I understand the
motivation, but I can’t justify it. Because we’re talking about elections,
efforts are made to plant such attitudes in the broadest possible
electoral field. This is what I think is dangerous and this is exactly
what our adversaries desire.

In criticizing my assessment that even when this rail line becomes
operational, Armenia will not face any new problems, my critics do not
present any evidence. Let’s evaluate the situation together. What
additional problems could the Kars-Akhalkalak line create?

The reality is that if we take into consideration the economic conditions
which exist today and which have existed for the last 15 years, then it’s
obvious that this new railroad can’t be additionally damaging to Armenia’s
economy. If the existing Kars-Gyumri-Tbilisi rail line were operating, and
this new railroad came to supplant it, or to run in parallel to it, then
yes, we could say that this new railroad would have adverse affects on
Armenia’s economy. However, that’s clearly not the case.

This criticism would also have been acceptable if the Armenian-Turkish
border were closed because of Armenia, or the Kars-Gyumri-Tbilisi railroad
did not work, because of Armenia, or if Armenia insisted on preconditions
to normalizing relations with Turkey.

However, that’s clearly not the case, either. Today, the border is closed
because of Turkey and because the Armenian side refuses to comply with
Turkey’s demands. All those who insist that the gas pipeline or the oil
pipeline or the railroad could have gone thru Armenia, should have known
full well that that would have been possible only by relinquishing our
rights regarding certain issues which constitute our national interest and
a national value. That is the price we would have had to pay; yet we
haven’t.

That is the political situation, and it is not possible to ignore that
truth and to irresponsibly insist that in this political atmosphere,
things could have been otherwise.

Those experts and organizations which have assessed this rail project have
said and continue to say that it is not economically sound and at the same
time, politically, it endangers regional cooperation. The decisions by
the US, the EU and other countries not to provide government assistance to
this project reflect these assessments.

We, too, consider this project to be, above all, a political project,
aimed, yet again, at bringing additional pressure to bear on Armenia and
attempting to secure certain concessions. In this context, this project
can create further complications in an already complex region.

The experience of these past years should have been sufficient for our
adversaries to understand that it is not possible to use such steps and
such language with Armenia, particularly regarding the Nagorno Karabakh
issue. There are matters which are non-negotiable values for us. We have
repeated frequently, and today, too, I will disappoint Azerbaijan and
those who support it by saying: Karabakh is not a tradeable commodity for
Armenians. From this perspective, Karabakh was not negotiable during the
Baku-Ceyhan discussions, nor during the Baku-Akhalkalak-Kars discussions,
and will not be negotiable at any time in the future.

Our approach is different. We believe that as regional cooperation deepens
and includes all the countries of the region, then existing regional
tensions will weaken, it will fuel greater reciprocal trust, and
strengthen linkages. All this, taken together will create an environment
so different from today’s that the many complex political issues facing us
will find a resolution. This is not just a policy, but the guideline for
the work that we do every day.

What concerns me is not the political exploitation so much as its
consequence – the defeatism being sown in our people. What we have today
is not Armenia’s isolation. What we have is two neighboring countries who
are willfully attempting to isolate Armenia. And, in spite of such
efforts, we have an Armenia that is active – in some cases even more than
those same neighbors – in every international organization from EU, to
Council of Europe, the CIS, NATO, the Black Sea Economic Cooperation and
other international organizations. Where is the isolation? It’s time to
put an end to this willful self-deception.

Don’t judge Armenia by what Turkey and Azerbaijan do. Judge Armenia by
what we do, by our own resources and opportunities.

We are faced with many foreign and domestic challenges, and we all know
well where they come from. To overcome them, it is essential that we
consider issues sensibly, assess the situation and the opportunities
accurately, demonstrate firm will, confidence and unity.

Vartan Oskanian
09 February 2007

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.ArmeniaForeignMinistry.am