ANKARA: All claims over Dink murder being investigated: police

NTV MSNBC, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

All claims over Dink murder being investigated: Turkish police

A number of police officers have been suspended from duty pending an
inquiry into alleged failures to act on information warning the
Turkish-Armenian journalist would be killed.

Güncelleme: 18:37 TSÝ 09 Þubat 2007 CumaANKARA – All allegations
surrounding the murder of prominent Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant
Dink were being fully investigated by public prosecutors and civil
inspectors, a spokesman for the Turkish police said Friday.

Speaking at a regular weekly press briefing, police spokesman Ismail
Caliskan said the investigation into Dink’s murder on January 19 was
being thoroughly pursued.
Caliskan denied there was any tension between the civil police and
the paramilitary gendarme after photos and video tapes of Dink’s
alleged killer, Ogun Samast, taken while he was in custody, were
released to the media.

The photos and video showed Samast pictured in front of a Turkish
flag and being portrayed as a hero. There was controversy as to
whether the photos and video were taken while Samast was in police or
Gendarme custody.

Asked whether there had been any negligence on the part of security
forces concerning the murder of Dink, Caliskan said and investigation
into allegations was continuing and that inspectors were trying to
determine if there had been any failings on the part of police.

ANKARA: Turkish police officer denies knowing of tip offs on Dink

NTV MSNBC, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

Turkish police officer denies knowing of tip offs on Dink murder
threat

The Interior Ministry gave permission to inspectors to investigate
Istanbul police chief Celalettin Cerrah over the murder of Dink.

Güncelleme: 18:37 TSÝ 09 Þubat 2007 CumaISTANBUL – A senior Turkish
police officer has denied having any knowledge of information on
plots to murder prominent Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, who
was gunned down in Istanbul on January 19.

Istanbul police chief Celalettin Cerrah, who is currently under
investigation over claims he knew of plans to murder Dink, said
during a meeting with a delegation of Turkey’s Parliamentary Human
Rights Committee late Thursday that no information had been passed to
him over any threat to the journalist. `I did not know about the
tip-off,’ he said. The Trabzon intelligence sent a document but it
did not reach me.’

Cerrah, who has come under fire for saying that there was no
organisation behind Dink’s killing murder soon after the murder, said
that he did not make that statement officially.

In another development in the Dink murder investigation, it has been
revealed that police informant Erhan Tuncel, who has also been
claimed to be the mastermind of the assassination, was not formally
questioned by police after the slaying of Dink.

Tuncel apparently had an informal conversation with police, a
verbatim report of which was put into the records. However, police
say this report can be used in evidence. Tuncel refused to give a
formal statement before the court hearing into Dink’s murder was
opened and claimed that he would reveal all facts during the case.

Senior Turkish police officer removed over Dink’s murder

Southeast European Times, MD
Feb 9 2007

Senior Turkish police officer removed over Dink’s murder
09/02/2007

The head of Istanbul’s police intelligence was suspended this week as
part of the investigation into the murder of a prominent
Turkish-Armenian journalist who had angered nationalists.

(AP, AFP, International Herald Tribune, The New York Times, The New
Anatolian – 08/02/07; Zaman – 07/02/07; AP, BBC, VOA, Turkish Daily
News – 06/02/07; AFP, BBC – 02/02/07)

Video footage showed Hrant Dink’s confessed killer, Ogun Samast,
posing with police officers and a Turkish flag. [Getty Images]

A senior Turkish police officer was removed from duty this week
following revelations that police were warned in advance about the
planned murder of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink. Police
reportedly received a tip about the plot in February 2006.

"I admit all my guilt for not sharing the intelligence I received
regarding the assassination plot," a report in The New Anatolian on
Thursday (February 8th) quoted the head of Istanbul’s police
intelligence, Ahmet Ilhan Guler, as saying.

He was suspended late Monday as part of the investigation into the
murder. The Interior Ministry also has reportedly cleared the way for
a probe into Istanbul Police Chief Celalettin Cerrah’s actions. Dink,
52, the editor-in-chief of the Istanbul-based bilingual
Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos, was gunned down in broad daylight on
January 19th, outside his office.

Ogun Samast, a 17-year-old from the eastern city of Trabzon, has
confessed to killing the journalist because he "insulted Turkish
blood". Seven other people have been arrested on suspicion of
involvement in the case. All of them are from Trabzon.

Dink angered Turkish nationalists by maintaining that the killings of
some 1.5 million Armenians in the waning days of the Ottoman empire
amounted to genocide, a characterisation that Ankara firmly denies.

Trabzon Governor Huseyin Yavuzdemir and Police Chief Resat Altay were
removed from office soon after the murder.

Guler’s suspension came only days after five police officers and five
members of the Gendarmerie in the Black Sea province of Samsun were
dismissed after the release of video footage that showed them posing
alongside Samast and giving him a "hero’s welcome".

The footage rekindled concerns among Turks about the existence of a
shadowy "deep state" — a term denoting hardline nationalists
operating within the state ready to breach the law in defence of
their beliefs.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has pledged to deal with what he
described as "gangs within state institutions".

Dink’s funeral was attended by more than 100,000 people, who silently
expressed their protest against hardline nationalism, blaming his
death also on Article 301 in Turkey’s penal code.

Like Orhan Pamuk, the winner of last year’s Nobel Prize for
literature, and scores of other Turkish intellectuals, Dink was
prosecuted under the controversial article, which makes it a crime to
"insult Turkishness".

A group of ten civic organisations submitted a proposal Thursday to
amend the article, which has been widely criticised by the EU and
international rights groups. "We believe our proposal will help
overcome existing difficulties," Davut Okutcu, the head of the
Economic Development Foundation, said in a televised news conference.

The proposed amendments seek to better distinguish between legal
criticism and illegal denigration. Among other changes, the draft
reportedly proposes that the phrase "insulting Turkishness" be
replaced by "openly scorning and deriding" the Turkish identity. Some
groups, however, say Article 301 should be scrapped altogether,
rather than simply toned down.

"Leading up to the general elections in November, the government has
escaped from political responsibility on a controversial issue like
Article 301 in fear of losing voters," the International Herald
Tribune quoted Gencay Gurun, the general secretary of the Turkish
Chamber of Doctors, as saying on Thursday.

"Changes are only a facade and can never prevent bitter consequences,
as we’ve witnessed with Mr. Dink’s murder," he said.

ANKARA: Nationalist Mvt Party (MHP) would become 3rd largest in NA

Sabah, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) would become the third largest party
in parliament

Turkey’s far-right Nationalist Movement Party (MHP) would become the
third largest party in parliament after this year’s election, a
survey published on Friday showed.

The poll, conducted by Selcuk University in the central city
of Konya and carried in several newspapers, showed the ruling AK
Party would again be the largest party with 31.6 percent. The
MHP would win 14.2 percent, the poll showed.

The main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP),
nominally left-leaning but also nationalist-minded, would win
15.5 percent in the election, which must be held by November.
Only parties with more than 10 percent can enter parliament.
The MHP is not represented in the current parliament.
Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan’s AK Party has presided over
strong economic growth and the launch of Turkey’s European Union
entry talks since taking power in November 2002, but analysts say the
more nationalist mood is now forcing it to shelve
liberal political reforms and some planned privatisations.

If the AK Party fails to win an outright majority in the
2007 election, it will have to form a coalition, possibly with
one of the smaller nationalist parties — a move sure to further
complicate Ankara’s already troubled relations with the EU.
Friday’s poll also showed more than half of Turks are
opposed to the scrapping of a law which makes it a crime to
insult Turkish national identity or state institutions.
The EU has sharply criticised Article 301, which has
triggered court cases against dozens of writers including Nobel
Laureate Orhan Pamuk and Turkish Armenian editor Hrant Dink.
An ultra-nationalist youth shot Dink dead outside his
newspaper office in Istanbul last month. About 100,000 people
attended his funeral to protest against violent nationalism.
Friday’s poll, mirroring the findings of other recent
surveys, showed a majority of voters who support the AK Party donot
want Erdogan to run for the presidency when incumbent AhmetNecdet
Sezer retires in May.

It gave no reason, but many think the AK Party will lose
votes if Erdogan, their main electoral asset, quits. As
president he would have to stay above party politics.
The poll showed Erdogan remained the single most popular
candidate to replace Sezer, with 17.1 percent support, but he
was only narrowly ahead of Bulent Arinc, the speaker of
parliament and also from the AK Party, who had 16.8 percent.
Both Erdogan and Arinc are unacceptable to Turkey’s secular
establishment, including the powerful military, because of their
roots in political Islam. Their wives wear the Muslim headscarf.
The poll canvassed the views of 7,325 people in 43 cities.

Kars-Tbilisi-Baku railroad: Azerbaijan as locomotive of reg projects

Eurasia Daily Monitor, DC
Feb 9 2007

KARS-TBILISI-BAKU RAILROAD: AZERBAIJAN AS LOCOMOTIVE OF REGIONAL
PROJECTS

By Vladimir Socor

Friday, February 9, 2007

Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev, Georgian President Mikheil
Saakashvili, and Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyp Erdohan witnessed
on February 7 in Tbilisi the signing of a tripartite agreement to
launch construction work this year on the railroad connecting their
countries. The presidents signed a declaration on a `Common Vision
for Regional Cooperation’ on this occasion.

The three countries’ regional cooperation far transcends the South
Caucasus, as it entails projects of intercontinental scope. These
are: the recently inaugurated Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline, with
a planned trans-Caspian link to Kazakhstan; the now-operational
Baku-Tbilisi-Erzurum gas pipeline, with a potential link via the
Nabucco project to Central Europe; and the
Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku (KATB) railroad, which will link not
only the three countries with each other, but also the South Caucasus
directly with Europe in the near term and potentially with Central
Asia not long thereafter.

Azerbaijan can be said to function as the locomotive of the railroad
project, as well as a path-breaker in initiating the oil and gas
extraction projects with their westbound export routes. The KATB
railroad is now being turned into reality thanks to Azerbaijan’s
financing of the project’s longest and most challenging sections,
both in Georgia: 30 kilometers to be built from scratch from the
Turkish border to Akhalkalaki and another 160 kilometers to be
repaired and modernized from Akhalkalaki to the Georgia-Azerbaijan
border. Azerbaijan will also modernize the railroad on its territory,
while Turkey will build a 68-kilometer line from Kars to the
Turkish-Georgian border from scratch.

Azerbaijan is providing a $220 million loan, repayable in 25 years,
with an annual interest rate of only 1%, for the construction work on
Georgian territory. Georgia plans to repay the loan by using its
share of the transit revenue, once the railroad becomes operational.
The credit agreement, signed last month, is to be ratified by the two
parliaments and to be followed by a bilateral inter-bank agreement
and a tender to select the construction companies. This railroad has
become vital for Georgia in the wake of Russia’s 2006 decision to
impose a blockade on Georgia’s transport communications.

Azerbaijan’s Transport Minister Zia Mamedov, Georgian Economic
Development Minister Giorgi Arveladze, and Turkish Transport Minister
Binali Ildirim signed in Tbilisi on February 7 the agreement on
construction work. The work in Georgia is expected to start in the
third quarter of 2007 and to require two-and-a-half years. The
railroad’s anticipated capacity is 5 million tons per year initially,
10 to 15 million tons annually after the third year of operation, and
ultimately up to 20 million tons annually. The KATB railroad will
connect Azerbaijan and Georgia via Turkey with the tunnel crossing
under the Bosporus Strait to Europe.

The KATB project was held up for more than a decade by a lack of
funding, mainly on its Georgia section. Azerbaijan is now taking the
lead in this transport project thanks to revenue from oil projects
that Azerbaijan itself had initiated during that past decade. During
the signing ceremonies, Saakashvili paid tribute to the late
Azerbaijani president Heydar Aliyev for laying the foundations of
these integration projects. A section of the Mtkvari River’s
embankment in central Tbilisi was renamed after Heydar Aliyev in the
presence of the three state leaders on this occasion. The Georgian
president also called on his nation to `never forget’ Azerbaijan’s
decisions to supply Georgia with gas during the Russian energy
blockade of January 2006 and again this winter, despite Russian cuts
in gas and electricity supplies to Azerbaijan in retaliation.

The presidents also inaugurated a state-of-the art terminal at
Tbilisi airport, built by a Turkish-Austrian consortium in one year.
Concurrently, Turkey is building on its territory a highway that
should reach the Georgian border near Batumi by the end of 2007,
while Georgia is building a highway from Tbilisi to Batumi.
Cumulatively, these developments are rapidly ushering in what
Saakashvili called a `new era’ in the South Caucasus.

Armenia continues to oppose the KATB project. Yerevan insists that
Turkey should instead use the existing Kars-Gyumri (Armenia) railroad
link, which Turkey closed in 1994 after Armenian forces had seized
extensive territories of Azerbaijan. However, KATB and Kars-Gyumri
are in no way comparable. While KATB is a project of transcontinental
scope, Kars-Gyumri is merely a local link.

Armenia’s opposition to KATB, against the interests of three
neighboring countries, looks like a replay of Yerevan’s long,
ultimately futile resistance to the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline
project. In the case of KATB, however, Armenian lobbying groups have
succeeded in blocking U.S. loans to the railroad project. From
Yerevan’s own standpoint, this attitude ignores the interests of the
ethnic Armenian population in the deeply impoverished Akhalkalaki
area, where this railroad brings the only real hope of economic
development. More broadly, Yerevan’s opposition to KATB significantly
complicates the U.S. administration’s efforts to pull Armenia out of
its quasi-isolation and into regional integration projects.

(Civil Georgia, Georgian Public Television, ANS, Turan, Anatolia News
Agency, February 6, 7; see EDM, January 19)

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Statement of the National Assembly of the Republic of Armenia

National Assembly of RA, Armenia
Feb 9 2007

Statement of the National Assembly of the Republic of Armenia

The National Assembly of the Republic of Armenia strictly condemns
the treacherous assassination of Hrant Dink, editor-in-chief of the
weekly `Agos’ and assessed the crime as a crime against freedom of
speech, human rights and the representative of the Armenian minority.

Expressing its indignation, the National Assembly of the Republic of
Armenia states that the premeditated inhumane crime left very deep
roots caused by the nationalistic circles of Turkey as a result of
disseminating anti-Armenian propaganda. Negation of its own history
at the level of Turkish authorities, wide dissemination propaganda of
the denial of the 1915 Armenian Genocide, as well as the unleashing
of criminal persecutions towards numerous intellectuals, who raised
that issue, caused a desire in the minds of nationalistic circles to
silence the voice of freedom with such crime.

At the same time we express our concern on the latest developments
regarding this heinous crime. After Dink’s assassination the public
outbreak today has already being replaced by the reverse tendency –
the Turkish nationalism, hatred against other nations, making a hero
the criminal is being revived again, and as a result, the threats
addressed to the newspaper edited by Hrant Dink, free-thinking people
and the Armenians gather momentum.

The disclosures of this crime are of concern and need to be
thoroughly examined, and according to them, the law enforcement
bodies knew beforehand and did not try to prevent the assassination.
Today, the necessity of the disclosure of the whole crime, including
those who ordered it, is vital.

The National Assembly states: this assassination once again
reiterated the reality that for the establishment of the atmosphere
of two peoples’ mutual trust, the reconciliation with its own history
and recognition of the 1915 Armenian Genocide by Turkish authorities,
as well as the implementation of the demand of the international
community of abolishing the Article 301 of the Criminal Code that
enables to violate the free speech and similar developments, is a
matter of present interest.

ANKARA: `Genocide’ Issue Tops Gl’s Talks with US Congressmen

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

`Genocide’ Issue Tops Gül’s Talks with US Congressmen

Friday , 09 February 2007

In Washington for talks with senior US officials, Foreign Minister
Abdullah Gül met with John Murtha, the chairman of the defense
sub-committee of the House of Representatives Appropriations
Committee, and House majority leader Congressman Steny Hoyer.

During both meetings Gül said a resolution proposed to the US House
of Representatives constitutes a threat to relations between the two
countries.

Gül later had talks with Congressman Robert Wexler, co-chairman of
the Turkish- American Friendship Group, Tom Lantos, the chairman of
the House Committee on Foreign Relations, and Congressman Roy Blunt.
Lantos had supported Turkey’s position on the "Armenian genocide"
issue in the past, but after the Turkish Parliament’s refusal on
March 1, 2003 to allow the deployment of 62,000 US troops in Turkish
territory to launch a northern front in the war with Iraq, Lantos
said he would shift his position and back the resolution.

Turkish Foreign Ministry spokesman Levent Balman said Gül’s meetings
at the US Congress have been positive. US State Department spokesman
Sean McCormack said, "We understand very clearly that this is a
sensitive issue not only for the Turkish people but also for the
Armenian people." McCormack also said that the State Department is
working with the Congress to pass Turkey’s concerns regarding the
issue. However, he said, "I think Gül and the Turkish government
understand how our government system work, and that the Congress is a
separate body."
US President George Bush will have to persuade the new
Democratic-controlled congress, which does not need presidential
approval to pass such a resolution. Members behind the proposed bill
have said they expect a push by the administration and lobbyists
working for the Turkish government to keep the resolution from a full
vote by the House. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who will decide
whether to offer the bill for a full vote if, as expected, it is
approved by the House Foreign Affairs Committee, has already
expressed support.

Gül said they do not plan to meet with Pelosi because she is "too
engaged" in the issue but he will meet with her close aides and
friends to make sure Turkey’s views are heard. Turkey rejects the
"genocide" label and argues that only 300,000 Armenians and at least
as many Turks died in mutual civil strife.

Another Azeri prisoner of war accused of treason

Reuters AlertNet, UK
Feb 9 2007

Another Azeri prisoner of war accused of treason
09 Feb 2007 13:58:45 GMT
Source: Reuters

BAKU, Feb 9 (Reuters) – Azerbaijan has accused a second soldier in
two weeks with treason following his return from Armenia where he had
been taken prisoner by Armenian forces.

Azerbaijan is officially in a state of war with neighbouring Armenia.
The two sides patrol a tense ceasefire line around the disputed
territory of Nagorno-Karabakh.

A military prosecutor’s office spokesman said Eldaniz Nuriyev,
captured by Armenian forces in December 2006, was suspected of having
betrayed his country while in captivity.

The spokesman said Nuriyev was arrested on arrival home. It was
unclear what he had done to betray Azerbaijan.

On Monday, Azeri prosecutors charged with treason another soldier,
Vyusal Garajayev. Both servicemen were returned under the auspices of
the Red Cross.

Armenian officials were not available for comment.

Nuriyev, like the first solider, was captured by ethnic Armenian
separatists who, with Armenian support, control most of
Nagorno-Karabakh.

More than 35,000 people died in a conflict over the mountainous
territory about half the size of the Mediterranean island of Cyprus.
A ceasefire was agreed in 1994.

The region is internationally recognised as part of Azerbaijan but
nearly all of it, as well as a large swathe of Azeri territory on its
borders, has been controlled by the separatists since the war.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Report on mission to Istanbul to rep. EP at funeral of Hrant Dink

AB Haber, Belgium
EU-Turkey News Network
Feb 9 2007

Report on the mission to Istanbul of 18 to 19 January 2007 to
represent the European Parliament at the Funeral Mass for the
Armenian journalist Hrant Dink

Rapporteur: Joost Lagendijk

Hrant Dink, publisher and editor-in-chief of the Turkish-Armenian
weekly newspaper Agos, published in Istanbul, was shot in front of
his newspaper’s offices on Friday, 19 January 2007. He died at the
scene from three gunshot wounds to the head. The news spread across
the world within minutes and there was a great sense of outrage
within Turkey and in Europe as a whole. The murderer was a
17-year-old youth from ultra-nationalist circles in the city of
Trabzon. Although those who gave the assassination order have since
been arrested, many questions surrounding this crime remain
unanswered. As well as covering the Mass and visits to the family and
to the editorial staff of the Agos newspaper, this report examines
the background to the crime as well as the significance of Hrant
Dink’s work in the context of efforts to improve relations between
Armenia and Turkey. Let us begin, however, with a brief biography of
Hrant Dink:

Hrant Dink

Hrant Dink was born into an Armenian family from the town of Malayta
in eastern Turkey. The Armenian Patriarch of Constantinople, Mesrob
II, described his development and personality in the following words:

‘His life of struggle and hardship made Hrant Dink a courageous,
sensitive and resolute person. These qualities enabled him to become
an advocate and a symbol of justice, freedom of belief and human
rights. He stood up for his opinions and his ideas without fear of
possible consequences. He was equally resolute in taking action when
he was convinced that action was needed.

Hrant had the same affinity with his native country as he had with
his ethnic roots. He loved his birthplace, his country and its people
without rejecting the values of his origins. His courage reflected
his Anatolian attitude to people – full of love, making no
distinction on the basis of religion, race or origin. In this, Hrant
followed God’s commandment.’

With these words, Patriarch Mesrob II expressed the joy he felt when,
calling on Mrs Dink to express his condolences, he learned that Hrant
believed in Jesus and honoured him as the Saviour. The fact that the
Patriarch did not discover until after Hrant Dink’s death that this
prominent member of his small community had been a Christian believer
says a great deal about Hrant’s work in Turkey. With his liberal
left-wing convictions, he was not only on the side of the opposition
in national politics but he also belonged to the opposition within
the small Armenian community, which is dominated by the Armenian
Apostolic Church. He had been especially critical of the leaders of
the community for not being vociferous enough in condemning the
numerous instances of discrimination against minorities in general
and against the Armenian community in particular. Nevertheless, or
perhaps precisely because of that criticism and that courage, he was
extremely popular within his community.

Hrant Dink, whose journalism was honoured with numerous awards, had
also established a firm place within Turkish society. Agos, the
newspaper he published – which, unlike other Armenian newspapers,
also appears in Turkish – was held in high regard by its Turkish
readers too. His foremost concerns were Turkish-Armenian dialogue and
rapprochement, and the promotion of relations between Turkey and
Armenia.

Hrant firmly believed that the past can only be addressed and
understood where there are prospects of future relations. Armenia’s
painful history exercised his mind no less than the Armenian
Diaspora. But he took a different, and perhaps more effective,
approach to the debate on the Armenian genocide of 1915 than is
customary in Turkey. In his speeches and writings, he tried to avoid
the term ‘genocide’. He informed his readers and listeners,
describing the events of 1915, but left the definition to them and
invited them to find the appropriate term.

Hrant was also loved by his Turkish friends because, like many other
critical journalists in that country, he was persecuted on account of
his work. He was the subject of several criminal trials. He was
sentenced to six months in prison under Article 301 of the Criminal
Code for ‘denigration of Turkishness’. His last newspaper article
contained a very tactful analysis of the reasons why charges against
‘Turkish’ writers such as Orhan Pamuk and Elif Þafak had been dropped
whereas he had been convicted. He could rebel like nobody else
against exclusion and injustice without bowing to anyone or indeed
taking pleasure in his resistance. His conviction hurt him not only
because he considered it unjust but also because he felt it as an
affront to his deeply held anti-racist convictions. This made him a
unique journalist in Turkey, a much-loved and respected figure. His
death is undoubtedly a great loss to Turkey and to the Armenian
community around the world.

The funeral – a political event

The funeral of Hrant Dink turned into one of the largest ever mass
demonstrations in the city of Istanbul. Although it was expected that
thousands would come to pay their last respects to Hrant Dink, not
even the greatest of optimists could have foreseen the vast sea of
more than a hundred thousand people. At 10 a.m. on Tuesday, 23
January, when we[1] arrived in the boulevard in front of the Agos
offices, thousands of people had already gathered for the
demonstration, which was due to begin in one hour’s time. As we
waited for the start of the demonstration, which began with a speech
from Hrant Dink’s widow in the form of a letter, entitled Sevgilim
(‘My Beloved’),[2] floods of people poured into the street in front
of the Agos offices from all parts of the city. Mrs Dink’s speech, a
declaration of love, not only moved the listening crowds to profound
grief but also contained an appeal to refrain from the chanting of
slogans and to accompany Hrant in silence on his final journey. This
wish was respected. It was not easy to take in this mass of
participants, young and old, who seemed to come from all strata of
society. It was as if we were in the midst of a sea and could only
make out waves of people. It was impossible to see where the crowds
began or ended.

After a few kilometres the family and guests left the demonstration
to attend the Funeral Mass in the Church of the Virgin Mary. This was
not easy either. The guests’ path was blocked not only by the
traffic, which had been brought to a standstill by the demonstration,
but also by the sheer mass of people around the church. All the
streets around the Church of the Virgin Mary, the seat of the
Patriarch, were jammed with masses of people. The ambassadors of many
countries, including the United States, the Netherlands and Germany,
had travelled up from Ankara, and the Turkish Government was also
represented by two ministers. The press, representatives of
employers’ organisations, trade unions and political parties, the
Mayor of the City of Istanbul and representatives of the Armenian
community throughout the world were gathered in the church.

In his remarks during the Mass, the Patriarch was very restrained. He
neither attempted to assess the political motives for the murder nor
apportioned blame to the security forces for failing to protect Hrant
Dink, nor did he even comment on speculation and accusations
concerning these matters. Two important demands did, however, emerge
clearly: the Patriarch asked the Turkish Government to grant full
freedom of expression and to ensure that people would no longer be
charged or convicted, let alone murdered, for expressing their
opinion. The second demand related to discrimination against the
Armenian community in Turkey. The Patriarch called for recognition
that ‘the Armenians are Turkish nationals who have lived for
thousands of years in this country, and they must no longer be
perceived as a foreign body or a threat’. The removal of this
prejudice, he said, should begin with the revision of school
textbooks.

The liturgy was accompanied and concluded by Gregorian chant and
hymns. The congregation rejoined the demonstrators at the cemetery.

The family and the editorial staff of Agos

On 22 January, shortly after our arrival, we had visited the family
to express our condolences and convey the condolences of the
President of the European Parliament. The small modest flat in the
Bakýrköy district of Istanbul was crammed with family and friends of
Hrant Dink. Representatives of political parties were in the room.
The youngest daughter was with her mother. Mrs Dink was outwardly
composed, but her grief was evident. The constant flow of callers was
surely stressful, but at the same time it helped to ease the family’s
pain. As we were leaving the flat, the Minister for the Interior
arrived. Two days later, it was reported in the press that the Prime
Minister had paid a call. Mr Erdogan spent more than an hour with the
family. Some press reports seem to indicate that his visit was more
than just a courtesy call.

Thanks to the bookshop that Hrant Dink established in the Bakýrköy
district, the family’s economic circumstances seem to be stable.
Before his murder, he was building a new house to reduce the burden
of a high rent for the bookshop. Nevertheless, it will not be easy
for the family to continue Hrant Dink’s work and maintain his
personal network. His children are still too young to contribute, not
having yet completed their education.

The family will also have to bear his political legacy, a task made
even more onerous by his murder. There is a need not only to maintain
the Agos newspaper, which was partly funded from Hrant Dink’s own
pocket, but also to channel many initiatives designed to keep Hrant
Dink’s ideas alive through the creation of foundations and other
cultural and political activities, and these things are not easy to
organise.

The twenty or so people who work for Agos, his political and cultural
platform, showed through the organisation of the demonstration that
they will continue to run the newspaper successfully. Dink’s closest
friend, the journalist Etyen Mahçupyan, will take over as
editor-in-chief in the meantime and will assist the family, who will
be publishing Agos. The financial situation, though not particularly
stable, seems to be sound enough for the newspaper to cover its
costs. It would be a great loss for Turkey if Agos were to die with
Hrant Dink. We visited the newspaper offices twice and assured the
editorial team of our support.

The murderers and freedom of expression in Turkey

The murderer, a 17-year-old youth, was arrested fairly quickly, two
days after the crime. The murder of an Italian priest a year before,
which was also committed by a youth, aged 16, not only put the city
in the spotlight but also alerted the press to the fact that
fanaticised minors were being used for political assassinations. So
far seven men from ultra-nationalist circles who are believed to have
been behind the crime have been arrested, and they are currently
being questioned. They too are young people in their mid-twenties.
Two theories are being discussed in the Turkish press.

It is being suggested that those who give the orders are using the
same methods as the organisers of suicide bombings and deliberately
choosing minors to carry out their crimes. Fanaticised by
nationalists and fundamentalists, these young people are sent to
assassinate critical journalists, writers and politicians. After his
arrest, one of the young people also made death threats against the
writer Orhan Pamuk, last year’s winner of the Nobel Prize for
Literature, who was likewise charged with a breach of Article 301 of
the Criminal Code. The theory has been advanced that the men behind
these crimes are active members of political parties and also
maintain links with elements of the security forces.

The second theory is that the killers are gangs of youths who have
been fanaticised through the Internet. Initial indications suggest
that these youths are linked in a Web network and communicate with
other ultra-nationalist circles. This scenario would make the
situation even more dangerous since it may be supposed that there are
hundreds of these youth gangs throughout Turkey.

Whichever is the true scenario, it spells danger for all critical
journalists, writers and politicians who have been charged or
convicted under Article 301. Almost all of the journalists and
writers who have been charged under Article 301 are given police
protection – and rightly so, for the last article by Hrant Dink,[3]
which was published in two parts in Agos on 12 and 19 January,
reveals how that provision has been putting journalists’ lives at
risk.

In his article, Hrant bemoans the fact that, in spite of the expert
reports obtained by the court and contrary to the statement made by
the public prosecutor, his accusers secured his conviction, and he
was sentenced to six months in prison. This judgment, he said, hurt
him, because it meant that he had been wrongly convicted of
‘denigrating Turkishness’. He went on to describe how the trial had
made him a target for ultra-nationalist factions. This frequent
pattern in cases involving Article 301 is an important factor in the
present debate, and for this reason we shall briefly focus on it.

On 6 February 2004, Hrant had stated in a newspaper article that
Sabiha Gökçen, the adopted daughter of Kemal Atatürk, had been of
Armenian descent and that Atatürk had adopted her from an orphanage.
As evidence, he accompanied the article with excerpts from his own
conversations with members of Sabiha Gökçen’s family. A report on
this article made front-page headlines in one of the major national
newspapers on 21 February 2004, triggering both a chorus of praise
and a hail of condemnation. The fiercest criticism came from the
general staff of the armed forces, who called Hrant’s article a
criminal act. As a result, he was called to the office of the
provincial governor and given a formal warning. Hrant Dink tried to
point out that for him, as a journalist, discovering that Kemal
Atatürk’s adopted daughter was an Armenian girl was a big news story.
For that reason, ‘instead of only discussing the Armenian question
through the dead’, he had sought to discuss it ‘through living people
and survivors too’. Hrant Dink concluded that it was even more
difficult to involve survivors in the discussion.

In the days that followed, Agos became the target of
ultra-nationalist demonstrations. Hrant Dink’s speeches and writings
were scrutinised. The Turkish "Great Lawyers’ Association", another
ultra-nationalist body, initiated proceedings against him on the
basis of a sentence taken out of context from an article that had
appeared in Agos on 13 February 2004. The public prosecutor
instituted proceedings under Article 301 of the Criminal Code.
Contrary to all judicial logic, Hrant Dink was found guilty at every
stage of the proceedings.

The succession of trials and appeals and the fact that he had to
resort to the European Court of Human Rights weighed heavily on Hrant
Dink. He felt persecuted and even threatened. He told his friends
that he was afraid. His final article conveys a vivid impression of
how he must have felt during the last months of his life.

Hrant Dink’s death has brought two important issues into the public
spotlight in Turkey, namely the threat to freedom of expression and
the Armenian question. The outpouring of sympathy and the throngs of
people who paid their last respects to Hrant Dink mean that we must
ensure that these two issues are high on our agenda in the coming
months and years.

_____

[1] Hélène Flautre, chair of the Subcommittee on Human Rights, also
travelled to Istanbul for the funeral.

[2] See annex.

[3] See annex, ‘The "pigeon skittishness" of my soul’ – Agos, 12 and
19 January 2007.

BAKU: USA to Send Pro-armenian Message to Turkey

Ïðàî ûáîðà, Azerbaijan
Democratic Azerbaijan
Feb 9 2007

USA to Send Pro-armenian Message to Turkey
09.02.2007

Daniel Fried: `Ankara should establish relations with Yerevan’
US government send message to official Ankara in connection with
situation in Turkey, assassination of Grant Dink, well-known article
¹301and relations between Turkey and Armenia. US Secretary of State
Assistant on Europe and Asia, Danial Fried, in interview for
`Milliyat’ newspaper expressed his solidarity with Turks advocating
removal of `article ¹301′. Accordingly to D. Fried this article seems
like historical mistake.
D. Fried also touched upon assassination of journalist of Armenian
origin, Grant Dink: `Dink didn’t humiliate Turks he represented the
best parts of Turkish history. No murder can be taken as
demonstration of nationalism. This quality is peculiar to small
nations, not great nation’.
D. Fried informed that Turks represents great nation, having added
that this nation doesn’t need `article ¹301′: `All nations undergo
nationalism. And Turkey’s being nationalistic state or not is not the
case, the case is whether leaders will undertake any steps in
connection with this issue. At the same time all leaders of our
country declared that America can’t exist within such conditions.
However to do so availability of moral leaders is needed’.
D. Fried underlined that against background of recent developments
normalization of relations between Turkey and Armenia is possible.
Accordingly to diplomat Ankara should stretch helping hand to
Yerevan: `I guess that Dink’s will rejoice if relations of Ankara and
Yerevan normalize’.
D. Fried expressed his view concerning discussion of draft bill on
`Armenian genocide’ by US House of Representatives. He thinks that US
government will explain Congress that this document will bring no
positive results for Turkish and Armenian relations. At the same time
D. Fried stressed that Turkey should stand its ground not deviating
from historical facts.
In turn authoritative representative of US Secretary of State, M.
Bryza, also expressed his view in connection with the so-called
`genocide of Armenians’. Accordingly to him adoption of the said
draft bill may seriously blow on relations between USA and Turkey. As
M. Bryza said White House representatives are working with Congress
representatives to prevent adoption of the said document.