Death In Turkey: Exotic Istanbul In Denial About Armenian Genocide

DEATH IN TURKEY: EXOTIC ISTANBUL IN DENIAL ABOUT ARMENIAN GENOCIDE
by John Warner

Charleston Gazette (West Virginia)
February 8, 2007, Thursday

Surely, of all the cities of the world, Istanbul is the most exotic.

Gateway to Asia. Eastern capital of the Roman Empire. City of Emperor
Constantine. City astride two continents. Religious capital of the
Eastern Orthodox Church. City of sultans and harems, belly dancers
in diaphanous costume. Turkish baths. The Topkapi Palace and the
Dolmabace Palace. Armenian genocide. The Hagia Sophia. The Blue
Mosque. Bektashi and Whirling Dervishs. The Sufis. The Grand Souk.

Byzantium. The mythological Jason passed this way in search of the
Golden Fleece.

Here are minarets and calls to prayer and fine Turkish carpets. Here
Xerxes led his Persian armies into Greece. Here later Alexander
crossed to Asia in his quest to subdue the world. Ataturk. The Ottoman
Empire. Janissaries. "It’s Istanbul, not Constantinople now," we used
to sing. The name was changed in 1453 – the year that city fell to
the Turks. A few miles to the south is the site of the tragic battle
of Gallipoli in 1915.

Earlier this year the city of Istanbul was rocked by the murder of a
noted Armenian journalist, Hrant Dink, the 52-year-old editor of the
Turkish-Armenian newspaper, Agos. Dink was gunned down by a teenage
boy, apparently in reprisal for claiming that the death of 1 million
Turkish Armenians was genocide. You are not allowed to say that in
Turkey. You are not allowed to speak of the killing of a million
Armenians in the second decade of the 20th century. And for some
strange reason, the fact of that genocide has never been officially
recognized even by our own government.

I would not mention this, except that it has become an issue in
American foreign policy. There is a push, more on the Democratic
side of the aisle, to assert an official recognition of the Armenian
genocide, sometimes called the first Holocaust of the Twentieth
Century. But in Turkey there is complete denial of that fact, and to
recognize the event in Congress will threaten U.S.-Turkish relations.

The story is told many times over in the dusty books on back shelves
of libraries all across America. It is told a hundred times over on
the World Wide Web. Just go to any search engine and type the words
"Armenian Genocide." Hundreds of grizzly photographs will make your
stomach turn. Starvation. Decapitation. Death marches and macabre
train rides. Pyramids of human skulls. Massacre. Still, it is verboten.

Perhaps you can picture, in your mind’s eye, the region in and around
eastern Turkey, defined on the north by the Caucasus Mountains,
particularly by the tall Mount Ararat – where, according to the
book of Genesis, Noah’s ark first found dry land. Here, between the
Caspian and the Black Seas, dwell dozens of competing ethnic and
language groups. Here today meet the modern nations of Armenia,
Georgia, Azerbaijan, Russia, Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Turkey. Here
dwell the Kurds and the Armenians, Muslims and Christians, struggling
throughout the 20th century for statehood, land and recognition.

Caught in the vortex between Russia and the Ottoman Empire.

For centuries the Armenians, Kurds and Turks got along OK. The
Armenians were considered loyal to the Ottoman Empire, accepting with
little protest their second-class citizenship. But with the rise of
nationalism in the 19th century and the demise and "decrepitude" of the
old Ottoman Empire – called the "Sick Man of Europe" first by Russian
Tsar Nicholas I – Armenians began to suffer. While the Turks wanted
to expand their dominion east into what is today known as Turkistan,
Armenians demanded their own independence and national state. They
were an obstruction to Turkish ambitions. In the Russo-Turkish War of
1877-78, Armenians sided with Russia, and Christian Russians supported
their religious brothers. After that war, the Armenians were blamed
for the defeat of Turks at the hands of "Christian" Russia.

On April 24, 1915, hundreds of Armenians were rounded up and gunned
down in the city of Istanbul. One million Armenians are said to have
died in the next three years. But one must never speak of this within
the confines of modern Turkey. It simply did not happen.

Hrank Dink, the Armenian editor, dared to say what could not be said.

He paid the high price for those words. And today there is a renewed
call for recognition of the Armenian Genocide.

I was the first guest to be seated in the coffee shop at the Nippon
Hotel in downtown Istanbul one morning in January more than a dozen
years ago. Seven o’clock. I ordered my coffee and read an English
language newspaper. And out of the window I saw a big black bear on
the city street, leashed to a fellow out for his morning walk. I asked
the waitress. "Gypsy and dancing bear," she said in her pretty-good
English. Surely this is an exotic city.

Dr. Warner, professor emeritus at West Virginia Wesleyan College,
is a Gazette contributing columnist.

Old World Charm: Ken Davitian Makes Laughter For Make Benefit Gratef

OLD WORLD CHARM: KEN DAVITIAN MAKES LAUGHTER FOR MAKE BENEFIT GRATEFUL MOVIEGOERS OF AMERICA
By Robert Abele

New Times Broward-Palm Beach (Florida)
February 8, 2007 Thursday

As we’ve seen from British comedian Sacha Baron Cohen’s guerrilla-style
comedy hit Borat: Cultural Learnings of America for Make Benefit
Glorious Nation of Kazakhstan one actor’s deadpan dedication to
heavily accented cultural naivete in the face of unsuspecting victims
can do wonders. Actor Ken Davitian who played Borat’s bearded and
oversized film producer, confidante and combatant Azamat Bagatov,
knows this well. "I didn’t break character," says Davitian, 53 of
his audition for Borat. The breakdown called for a "frumpy eastern
European" man who didn’t understand English. But instead of showing
up as his needy American bit-player self and then performing the
role for a casting camera, Davitian arrived a bewildered foreigner
sporting baggy threads, a gruff demeanor, and a parlance inspired by
his Armenian relatives. Outside the audition, among fellow actors he
recognized from the ethnic-part circuit, all dressed as themselves,
he kept up the act. "One of the guys came up and said, ‘You really
want this part. ‘"

Inside Davitian didn’t even hand over a real resume. "I had a white
eight-by-ten that was folded in my jacket pocket," he says. "I took
it out straightened the creases, and gave it to them, and you could
see in their eyes, ‘How did this guy get in?’ From what I understand,
they thought, ‘This is so sad. Let’s just go through with it a little
bit and ask him to leave. ‘"

But Davitian made Cohen laugh and afterward, the L.A. native brought
out his regular voice and actual resume – a 15-year Hollywood grinder’s
menu of one-line cabdrivers and shop owners named Igor and Ramon an
ER here and a Boston Legal there, a Vin Diesel movie and something
called Frogtown II. (He got his SAG card for Albert Brooks’ Real
Life but was cut out of the film.) A Curb Your Enthusiasm audition
years ago didn’t pan out, but Borat director Larry Charles, a Curb
executive producer, had a cosmic take on it for Davitian: "He told me,
‘If you had gotten it, when you walked into this room, we would have
known you were an actor. ‘"

Of course in a comedy that upends our notions of role-playing,
Davitian comes across as more than a mere actor or sidekick. With his
determined waddle, non-English dialogue (he responded in Armenian to
Cohen’s Hebrew) and bearish, floppy-suited countenance, his Azamat
is arguably the movie’s true center of Old World verisimilitude. We
know Cohen’s a fake as he spotlights bigoted America, but unless
you’re a regular at L.A.’s the Dip – the delicious sandwich joint
Davitian owns and has used to pay the bills – why wouldn’t you think
that roly-poly tagalong was the genuine article?

Davitian a good-natured, gregarious sort in person, is certainly one
kind of reality: the struggling performer who juggled his dream with
the demands of raising a family (he and wife of 30 years Ellen, have
two grown sons) until the breakthrough role came. When asked about his
reaction to the Borat juggernaut-controversy promotional appearances,
awards season parties – he offers a Borscht Belt-timed response that’s
also achingly personal. "I have been preparing for this for 53 years,"
he says. "I’m really thrilled. I’ve gotten offers. For the first time
I actually passed on a project, and I’ve never passed. I’ve been the
guy who would be shooting a commercial in Fresno, drive to L.A. to
shoot something there, and then go back to Fresno, and the amount of
money made would be nothing. But that’s your job. And I want to work."

OK but most actors outside the world of porn aren’t asked to flout
public decency laws, wrestle nude, and park their nuts on a co-star’s
chin. Already a cinema classic – the homo-unerotic extreme version
of a Laurel & Hardy bit – Cohen and Davitian’s grapplefest inspired
a memorable Golden Globes acceptance speech from Cohen who thanked
Davitian for providing him a "rancid bubble" of trapped air with
which to stay alive.

But how did Davitian feel having to stare down genitalia himself?

"Thank you, thank you, thank you," he says, grateful to have his side
heard. Of his costar, he notes, "One, he had a very good mohel. And
two, that big black [censor] bar was a bit of an exaggeration."

Music: Jazz Is Closing, But The Parish Is Not

MUSIC: JAZZ IS CLOSING, BUT THE PARISH IS NOT
By Joe Gross

Austin 360 , TX
Feb 11 2007

Jazz restaurant owner Matt Reppert confirmed Friday that the 19-year
Sixth Street Cajun fixture is closing March 18, but the upstairs
Parish club will continue.

"I want to get everyone in here to eat their last meal before I turn
it over," Reppert said. "Austin is a very progressive city, so it’s
time to update the concept."

A new Cajun restaurant called Roux, owned by Dan Janjigian and
Chad Elton, is slated to open in May; they will lease the space
from Reppert.

Reppert said the new owners plan to keep the Parish open, though there
may be a period of inactivity. "There may be some type of gap in the
liquor license," Reppert said.

The Parish will participate in South By Southwest. At Jazz, pianist
Matt Wilson will host "Broadway on Sixth" Thursdays through Saturdays
until March 10.

Janjigian, who participated in the 2002 Olympics as part of the
Armenian two-man bobsled team, is a Web designer and part owner of
the Geisha House in Los Angeles. Elton has worked with House of Blues,
Carlos ‘n’ Charlie’s, Nola and Kingfish. Both live in Austin.

ared-gen/blogs/austin/whatsgood/entries/2007/02/10 /music_jazz_is_c.html

http://www.austin360.com/blogs/content/sh

U.S. Debates ‘Genocide’; Term For Armenian Deaths Affects Diplomatic

U.S. DEBATES ‘GENOCIDE’; TERM FOR ARMENIAN DEATHS AFFECTS DIPLOMATIC TIES
by Staff

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Main Edition
February 4, 2007 Sunday

The touchy subject of the deaths of 1.5 million Armenians at the end
of World War I is back in the news again, as a bipartisan group of
lawmakers in the U.S. House of Representatives last week introduced
the latest version of an Armenian genocide resolution.

After years of trying, members of Congress and their politically
active Armenian American allies now think they can prevail over the
Bush administration’s strong opposition to a measure that is guaranteed
to incite controversy with Turkey, a key U.S. ally.

The 10-page resolution, whose chief sponsor is Rep. Adam Schiff
(D-Calif.), is being called the "affirmation of the United States
record on the Armenian Genocide."

Essentially, it would put the House on the side of Armenians and many
historians who have studied the period between 1915 and 1923.

Some 1.5 million Armenians were killed as part of a policy of
extermination conducted during the final days of the Ottoman Empire,
the resolution asserts. The nonbinding resolution further calls upon
President Bush to use the word "genocide" in his annual April message
commemorating the horrific events.

Bush and preceding presidents, attentive to the concerns of Turkey
and the State Department, have delicately avoided using the term
when referring to Armenia. Turkey has adamantly denied claims by
scholars that its predecessor state, the Ottoman government, caused
the Armenian deaths in a genocide.

The Turkish government has said the toll is wildly inflated, and
Armenians were killed or displaced in civil unrest during the disarray
surrounding the empire’s collapse.

"Armenian Americans have attempted to extricate and isolate their
history from the complex circumstances in which their ancestors were
embroiled," the Turkish Embassy declared in a statement last week.

"In so doing, they describe a world populated only by white-hatted
heroes and black-hatted villains."

In Turkey, it is a crime to use the word "genocide" to describe the
deaths, and people have been prosecuted for it.

Turkey has no diplomatic relations with Armenia.

Diplomatically, it’s an acutely sensitive issue. The Bush
administration has warned that even congressional debate on the matter
could damage relations with Turkey.

After French lawmakers voted in October to make it a crime to deny
that the killings were genocide, Turkey said it would suspend military
relations with France.

Turkey provides vital support to U.S. military operations. Incirlik
Air Force Base, a major base in southern Turkey, has been used by
the United States to launch operations into Iraq and Afghanistan
and was a center for U.S. fighters that enforced the "no-fly zones"
that kept the Iraqi air force bottled up after the 1991 Gulf War.

A member of NATO now hoping to join the European Union, Turkey
enjoys its own Capitol Hill clout with the assistance of well-placed
lobbyists, including one-time congressman Bob Livingston.

"I do think we have the best opportunity in a decade to succeed,"
said Schiff, "but no one should be under the illusion that this will
be easy."

Data On Escherichia Coli Therapy Published By Researchers At Yerevan

DATA ON ESCHERICHIA COLI THERAPY PUBLISHED BY RESEARCHERS AT YEREVAN STATE UNIVERSITY, DEPARTMENT OF BIOPHYSICS

Drug Law Weekly
February 13, 2007

ESCHERICHIA COLI THERAPY;

Data detailed in "Redox sensing by Escherichia coli: effects of
copper ions as oxidizers on proton-coupled membrane transport" have
been presented. According to recent research from Yerevan, Armenia,
"Escherichia coli is able to grow under anaerobic fermentation
conditions upon a decrease in redox potential (E(h)). Indeed, upon a
transition of E. coli MC4100 wild-type culture to stationary growth
phase a decrease in E(h) from the positive values (approximately
+100 mV) to the negative ones (approximately -520 mV) was observed,
the acidification of the medium and the H(2) production were obtained."

"An oxidizer, copper ions (Cu(2+)) affected a bacterial growth in a
concentration-dependent manner (of 0.1 mM to 10 mM) increasing latent
(lag) growth phase duration, delaying logarithmic (log) growth phase
and decreasing specific growth rate. Acidification of the medium
and the N,N’-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD)-and azide-sensitive
proton-potassium exchange by bacteria were inhibited, H(2) production
upon growth and under assays disappeared with Cu(2+) (0.1 mM). These
effects were observed with hycE but not hyfR and hyc(A-H) mutants
and under aerobic conditions. Cu(2+) also increased membrane proton
conductance. Copper ions are suggested to affect directly the
F(0)F(1)-ATPase associated with potassium uptake transport system
and/or formate hydrogenlyase composed with hydrogenase 4," wrote G.

Kirakosyan and colleagues, Yerevan State University, Department
of Biophysics.

The researchers concluded: "A role of the F(0)F(1)-ATPase in redox
sensing under fermentation is proposed."

Kirakosyan and colleagues published their study in Bioelectrochemistry
(Redox sensing by Escherichia coli: effects of copper ions as oxidizers
on proton-coupled membrane transport.

Bioelectrochemistry, 2007;70(1):58-63).

For additional information, contact G. Kirakosyan, Biological Faculty,
Dept. of Biophysics, Yerevan State University, 1 Alex Manoukian Str,
375025 Yerevan, Armenia.

Publisher contact information for the journal Bioelectrochemistry is:
Elsevier Science SA, PO Box 564, 1001 Lausanne, Switzerland.

Keywords: Armenia, Yerevan, Escherichia coli Therapy, Copper, Drugs,
Escherichia coli, Pharmaceuticals, Therapy, Treatment.

This article was prepared by Drug Law Week editors from staff and
other reports. Copyright 2007, Drug Law Week via NewsRx.com.

U. Texas Community Mourns Journalist Slain In Turkey

U. TEXAS COMMUNITY MOURNS JOURNALIST SLAIN IN TURKEY
By Lindsey Mullikin, Daily Texan; SOURCE: Univ. of Texas

Daily Texan via U-Wire
University Wire
January 24, 2007 Wednesday

Mourners were given red carnations and copies of Armenian journalist
Hrant Dink’s last article as they entered the memorial service held
for him in the Sinclair Suite at the Texas Union at the University
of Texas Tuesday night. Dink was shot to death in Turkey on Jan. 19.

Various university organizations sponsored the memorial service,
including the Armenian Cultural Association.

Students were invited to share the importance Dink’s work had in
their lives.

"It was one of the last things I expected to happen in my country,"
said graduate student Emrah Zarifoglu. "He was always talking about
unity."

Dink was the editor of an Armenian-Turkish publication, Agos.

Actively involved in the furtherance of democratization in Turkey,
he utilized his paper to help unify the Armenian and Turkish peoples
by bridging communication gaps between the two cultures.

Over time, however, tensions began to rise between Dink and the
Turkish community. In May 2006, he was charged by the Turkish court
with "insulting Turkishness."

After being convicted, matters got worse for Dink. In a later interview
with The Associated Press, Dink revealed that he had been receiving
numerous threatening messages. In what was to be his last article
in Agos, the journalist expressed severe concerns for his personal
safety. The day that article was published, he was assassinated
outside of his newspaper’s office building.

The response to his death has been overwhelming. Tuesday in Turkey,
more than 100,000 citizens paid tribute to the journalist by marching
five miles. At the University of Texas, students celebrated the life
that Dink led.

"He was a voice of freedom and unity," said Taleen Asadourian, Plan
II senior and president of the Armenian Cultural Association. She
and others were glad that representatives from the Turkish University
Students Association and Armenian Cultural Association attended the
vigil. "It’s symbolic to bring these groups together who historically
haven’t been," she said. Nearly all in attendance agreed.

Dink was only 53 when he died, but his dream of unification will
perhaps continue for generations to come.

Diving Coach Sarkisian Brings Tradition-Rich Past To NU

DIVING COACH SARKISIAN BRINGS TRADITION-RICH PAST TO NU
By Brian Regan, Daily Northwestern; SOURCE: Northwestern University. EVANSTON, Ill.

Daily Northwestern via U-Wire
University Wire
January 19, 2007 Friday

If Alik Sarkisian had his way, the Norris Aquatics Center would
extend into North Beach and would house the best and newest diving
and gymnastics equipment. But as the first-year NU diving coach is
learning, donors need results to justify coaches’ dreams.

After former diving coach Tom Michael left for Wisconsin, Northwestern
hired Sarkisian away from the Victory Diving Club in Oklahoma City.

Sarkisian is the former head coach of the USSR, Armenian and U.S.
national diving teams, which he left to pursue more glory as an NCAA
head coach.

"If you want to be a respectable coach in the United States," Sarkisian
said, "you have to be a university coach. The best facilities are
at the universities and colleges, but there is very little at the
Olympic level, which is different from the USSR."

This is his first head coaching gig at the collegiate level after
serving as an assistant at the University of Southern California.

With a wealth of coaching experience, Sarkisian has tried to motivate
his divers into becoming even better performers, even though his
style maybe different than his American athletes are used to.

"The transition made me nervous that the team would not know me or my
style, which is very different than theirs," he said. "But it didn’t
matter because the team knew diving and they are all very smart."

His personality and the Wildcats’ willingness to learn has bridged
the gap and each party is succeeding so far this season.

"He has something about him that is very encouraging," sophomore Alex
Kiaie said. "Something innate that makes you want to work hard that
I really like. He wants to make you be the best you can be."

Kiaie, whose scores have gone up almost 10 percent this season,
credits some of that success to Sarkisian.

Even though, Michael’s laid-back practices are gone and instead
replaced with Sarkisian’s up-tempo workouts, the team’s morale is
high and meet performances are improving.

"We’ve been a lot sorer than we’ve ever been, but we’re doing very
well," senior Leanne Dumais said. "The team has bonded much more than
in the past this season."

The squad has been putting up good numbers all season, helping the
whole swim and dive team get more points at meets, which they are
trying to do again Saturday at No. 16 Notre Dame.

Now that he has implemented his system, Sarkisian is aiming for bigger
goals and accolades.

"In the future I am expecting to coach an Olympic champion and an
NCAA champion," he said.

But now he can feel satisfied knowing that the team respects him and
his ways in just his first season as coach.

"You can see the kids have responded well to him," NU swimming coach
Bob Groseth said. "They are working harder and with more smiles on
their faces."

After Deadly ’06, Journalists Need Protection

AFTER DEADLY ’06, JOURNALISTS NEED PROTECTION
By Adam Himmelberger, The Daily Campus; SOURCE: Univ. of Connecticut STORRS, Conn.

The Daily Campus via U-Wire
University Wire
January 25, 2007 Thursday

The recent assassination of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink is
another tragic case of violence against the media and the silencing
of journalists who produce controversial work unpopular with certain
groups or governments. Dink’s murder is a somber reminder that the
liberal degree of free speech often taken for granted in America is
not universal. It further highlights the dangers journalists face
around the world, from reporting in hazardous environments to extreme
punitive measures for attempting to uncover the truth.

2006 was the deadliest year for journalists and media workers. The
International Federation of Journalists (IFJ) reported "at least 155
murders, assassinations and unexplained deaths." Some were accidental
at the hands of U.S. soldiers, others were politically motivated hits
and still others were committed by gangsters or warring factions,
according to the IFJ report.

The majority of news media deaths have taken place in Iraq, which has
become the deadliest war for journalists and the most dangerous place
to work over the course of American involvement in the region. But
even outside of classifiable conflict zones, there still lies danger
for those seeking to report, convey, uncover or express an idea.

The Turkish-Armenian editor was often the target of prosecution and
threats due to his "iconoclastic journalism, particularly on the
mass killings of Armenians in the early 20th century," according to
the Committee to Protect Journalists’ (CPJ) Web site. The Turkish
government does not acknowledge these World War I killings as
genocide, which continues to cause great tension between Turks and
Armenians. Dink’s friend Andrew Finkel said Dink "was in favor of
Turkish and Armenian neighbors being able to look each other in their
face and recognize their past histories," according to CNN.

Dink’s murder is reminiscent of numerous other journalists’ deaths,
including the high profile murder of Russian journalist, Anna
Politkovskaya, in October 2006. Many strongly believe she was murdered
because of her outspoken criticism of the Kremlin and its policies
toward Chechnya. Tuesday, the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ)
reported Russian officials announced Chechen police might have been
behind Politkovskaya’s murder because she was going to publish an
article about the polices’ alleged involvement in torture. A caveat
at the end of the story reminded this is only one of several theories
behind the murder. Free thinkers and journalists have encountered
hardships in both Russia and Turkey. Article 301 of Turkish law
makes it a crime to "insult Turkishness," a charge many writers in
Turkey have been accused of, including Dink. Intellectuals all over
the world have called for it to be repealed. In Russia, the Kremlin
has drawn harsh criticism from the U.S. and other countries for its
tight control and censorship of the media.

The suppression of free speech, as well as journalistic pursuits,
is not unique to these two countries by any stretch of the imagination.

The Philippines has some of the strictest libel laws in the world,
through which politicians often invoke in order to squash bad press and
punish writers. Mexico has surpassed Columbia has the deadliest country
in the Americas for journalists, a sign of the illegal drug industry
and other criminal activities shifting, or more accurately, expanding
closer to the markets. Even the United States, the quintessential
example of Constitutionally-protected freedom of speech and the press,
is far from perfect.

Needless to say, despite the inherent dangers of reporting or speaking
one’s mind in certain countries, more needs to be done to protect
these courageous individuals whose work is vital to the citizens of
the world. Non-profit, international non-government organizations
such as the CPJ and the IJF, lobby governments to ensure the safety
of journalists, raise money for victim’s families and publicize and
condemn the deaths or censorship of news media workers around the
globe. The United Nations was finally persuaded on Dec. 23, 2006
to issue resolution 1738, condemning attacks against journalists
in conflict situations. The resolution demanded all parties and
states in armed conflict treat journalists as civilians, comply with
international law in protecting journalists and prosecute those who
violate this, according to the U.N.’s Web site.

However, as is the case with international law, there are limitations
to what NGOs and resolutions can accomplish. Sadly, so long as there
are those working to uncover the truth, check the privileged or expose
the ruthless, there will be the privileged, powerful and ruthless
working to kill the story — even if it means killing the writer. And
so long as there is armed conflict, there will be civilian killings,
no matter what international law may say. A more modern way of looking
at the increasing violence against the media across the globe is to
realize many simply do not like what the general media have come to
represent. There is a stigma attached to the general news coverage
of bias, unfairness and propaganda. If groups in some regions of
the world do not want to be written about, or take issue with their
coverage, they may resort to eliminating the source of their concern —
the writer.

In Dink’s case, he used his columns appearing in his newspaper to
write about a tense history between two ethnic groups with the hope
that one day they could peacefully come to terms with the past and
harmoniously exist together as neighbors. For this, he was shot by
someone who disagreed. Even in death however, the work of journalists
and other free-thinkers endures. Their missions must be taken up by
others. If this fails to happen, the stories will die.

ANKARA: Baykal Lashes Out At Police In Dink Murder Case

BAYKAL LASHES OUT AT POLICE IN DINK MURDER CASE

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 10 2007

Leader of the main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) Deniz
Baykal criticized the police for mishandling the investigation of
the murder of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink and said the
Ýstanbul police chief should be removed from office.

"Why is the chief of Ýstanbul police still in office? Is it possible
that an investigation conducted in this manner can yield healthy
results?" Baykal asked as he spoke to reporters in Munich, Germany.

"I want a proper police chief," he exclaimed.

Dink was murdered on Jan. 19 by 17-year-old Ogun Samast, outside
his newspaper office in Ýstanbul. As the investigation continued,
the police came under fire for mishandling the case with revelations
that they had failed to follow up on an earlier tip-off about a plot
to murder Dink.

The criticism deepened when video footage showing members of the
police and the gendarmerie posing for souvenir photos with Samast at
a police station in Samsun appeared on national television. Samast is
from the Trabzon region of the Black Sea and was captured in nearby
Samsun after a nationwide manhunt. The scandalous pictures were taken
some time after his arrest when he was remanded into custody pending
a trial. The police and gendarmerie are two separate organizations but
share internal security duties in Turkey. Early reports said that the
footage had been shot at a gendarmerie station, but the gendarmerie
angrily denied it, saying the leak of the footage was a deliberate
plot. Inspectors have requested permission to launch a preliminary
investigation into Ýstanbul Police Chief Celalettin Cerrah. He may face
a full investigation according to the results of the preliminary probe.

Baykal said the Dink murder probe put the police under the spotlight
and added that Turkey should dig deep into what is happening inside
the police services.

In an interview broadcast on CNN Turk television, Baykal said the
police department was plagued by "religious sectarian elements"
and called for efforts to restructure the department.

"There is dangerous nepotism in the police department. If we don’t take
measures to tackle this, there could be bigger incidents," he said.

In comments published in the daily Milliyet yesterday, Baykal claimed
that the murder had "official links," saying it would be difficult
to believe that the murder had been planned by a small group without
knowledge of the police.

The opposition leader also dismissed talk of the "deep state,"
a term used to refer to elements within the state working together
with criminal gangs in secret unsanctioned operations for the "high
interests" of the state.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoðan has suggested that the murder
could have a linkage with the deep state and said Turkey has paid a
heavy price for its failure to dismantle it.

"This is empty talk," Baykal said of the deep state debate and stressed
that the Dink murder once again brought to the surface a rift between
the police and the gendarmerie.

"I have never seen the gendarmerie accuse the police of any
wrongdoing… It has always been the opposite," Baykal said. "Those
who do not fulfill their duties blame those who do."

The CHP leader also reiterated his call for the dismissal of Interior
Minister Abdulkadir Aksu in connection with the handling of the Dink
murder case. "The responsibility for this incident lies with the
interior minister and the prime minister… A security policy promoted
by them is being pursued at the moment and this policy is wrong."

–Boundary_(ID_VQlGHebunfJ+9H1HZ0d9G Q)–

Opinion: A Breeding Ground For Anger And Intolerance

OPINION: A BREEDING GROUND FOR ANGER AND INTOLERANCE

New Straits Times, Malaysia
Feb 10 2007

The Dink killing has thrown new light on the social conditions
that nurture ultra-nationalists and ethnic hatred in Turkey, writes
SEBNEM ARSU.

WITH fishing boats pouring in and out of a busy harbour, white
minibuses criss-crossing in all directions and shopping streets
bustling, the regional capital of Trabzon in Turkey, nestled on the
Black Sea, appears to be a vibrant city.

But beneath the colourful shopping malls filled with trendy clothes
and chic cafes, the poverty, unemployment and lack of opportunity
that afflicts many of Turkey’s cities is crushing – especially for
young people.

All eight suspects in the plot to kill Hrant Dink, a nationally
prominent editor, came from nearby, and links to other ultranationalist
crimes here are beginning to emerge.

Dink, an Armenian Turk who was an outspoken commentator on the
country’s handling of minority rights and was once convicted of
insulting the Turkish identity for an article he wrote, was killed on
Jan 19 in Istanbul. Ogun Samast, 17, a high school dropout, who has
confessed to the killing, was arrested with seven others in connection
with the crime.

The attack has caused a harsh examination in Trabzon of how the
authorities handled early hints of this and similar crimes. The
government dismissed Trabzon’s provincial governor and police chief in
the wake of Dink’s killing, and the Interior Ministry is investigating
what might have gone wrong in the handling of an informant’s tips
before the crime was committed.

According to NTV television, the informant, Erhan Tuncel, told the
police about plots to kill Dink on four occasions in the last year.

The first tip was passed along to Istanbul, where the police made
inquiries, but the later tips were not, the television report said.

Other prominent crimes here have had a common motivation of extremism
in upholding nationalist values. A local McDonald’s restaurant
was bombed in 2004, chosen as a Western target, and there was an
attempted lynching of a group of leftist protesters and killings of two
professors from the local university and of a Roman Catholic priest,
the Rev Andreas Santaro.

But it was not until the police found personal links between Samast,
the confessed killer of Dink, and Yasin Hayal, an ultranationalist
convicted of the McDonald’s bombing, that a web of connections between
various crimes came to light. Hayal is being charged with inciting
the Dink killing.

Tuncel is a mysterious figure. He was implicated in the McDonald’s
bombing but then was given his freedom to act as an informer. There
are reports that he tipped off the police four times to the threat
to Dink, but he is also being held as a suspect.

In addition, the fact that Samast and the killer of Father Santaro,
a 16-year-old high school dropout, were both under age at the times of
their crimes suggests that someone may have been urging young people
to commit crimes, knowing that they would escape harsher penalties
if caught.

But so far the police have not arrested any older or more established
figures in these crimes.

For some of the city’s youth, the region’s culture of bravado and
machismo seems to make a breeding ground for anger.

"Black Sea people are dynamic, restless, energetic and have strong
heroic feelings," said Adem Solak, a prison therapist who works with
the youth who killed Father Santaro.

"Their environment, built on a single culture without interaction
with diverse ethnicities, creates a greater potential for reaction
to social issues."

Expressions of anger are easy to come by, as are defences of Samast
and the killing of Dink.

"I don’t think brother Ogun did wrong," said Murat, 19, a university
dropout who, like many interviewed, refused to give his last name,
saying he feared police harassment.

"We heard that the Armenian cursed our blood, which we cannot accept."

He and his friend Hasan, 18, chain-smoking at a cafe near the town
centre, said they had known Samast for years in Pelitli, the suburb
where all three grew up. They praised nationalism with a religious
undertone.

But Murat hesitated before saying whether Dink deserved to die. "If
television earlier had said what a good person he was, like they do
now, no, actually," he said after a moment of reflection.

In Pelitli, a young man giving his name as Serkan said Samast was a
troublemaker, but one who would have needed guidance to commit such
a crime.

"I bet he had no idea who Hrant Dink was," Serkan said, "because he
had nothing to do with newspapers or politics, but loved stirring up
violence, starting fights on small matters."

A colleague, who gave his name as Hamdi and said he was 21, went
on from there. "What would you expect in a town where there are no
social activities for young people, no job opportunities, and everyone
around you loves to cause trouble?" he said. The problem with Samast
was not his politics, they said, but his failure to leave it to the
government to defend the nation.

The city was populated by Greeks, Armenians and Abkhazians when it
was a trading centre, but after Turkish independence in the 1920s,
the Greeks left, and Trabzon became overwhelmingly Muslim and
Turkish. Since then, the people here have been seen as having strong
nationalist and religious values.

Nationalism "embraces intolerance towards the other, superiority over
minorities and not only fear but also hatred toward the foreigner",
said Professor Ali Carkoglu of Sabanci University in Istanbul.

The feeling is stirred up by global events like the war in Iraq, the
Danish cartoons satirising Prophet Muhammad and the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict. Then there is Turkey’s ambition to join the European Union,
which has brought many changes.

That long process has its ups and downs, said Melek Goregenli, a
professor of political psychology at Ege University in Izmir. She
said that it "helped bring unspoken thoughts to the fore, made them
more visible, but at the same time made those who spoke out as targets
for those who couldn’t tolerate free expression of thought and equal
rights for everyone".

But even in this city, there are people who try to revive the feeling
of unity among ethnic groups that lived together for centuries. In
a historic building once used as a prison, a local theatre company
performed an Armenian comedy classic the weekend after Dink was
killed. There had been several sold-out shows, and the seats were sold
out for that performance too. But because of fears about security,
the theatre was empty, Necati Zengin, the director of the play,
said in a sad and frustrated tone.

"What we have to understand is that if Ogun and others had been
theatregoers, Hrant would have been still alive," he said.