Documenting A ‘Shameful Act’: Turkish Emigre Historian Writes On Arm

DOCUMENTING A ‘SHAMEFUL ACT’: TURKISH EMIGRE HISTORIAN WRITES ON ARMENIAN GENOCIDE
By Holger Herwig, Freelance

The Gazette (Montreal)
February 10, 2007 Saturday
Final Edition

A Shameful Act: The Armenian Genocide and the Question of Turkish Responsibility
By Taner Akcam
Metropolitan Books, 483 pages, $40

"What we are dealing with here," Ottoman Minister of the Interior Talat
Pasha stated in June 1915, "is the annihilation of the Armenians."

His colleague Cemal Pasha set the number of Armenians slaughtered
at 800,000; other estimates run as low as 200,000 or as high as 1
million. Mustafa Kemal, father of modern Turkey, accepted Cemal’s
figure for what he termed a "shameful act" carried out by a small
clique in the ruling Committee of Union and Progress (CUP).

Of the original Ottoman Armenian population of 2 million, between
200,000 and 600,000 survived. Ankara today acknowledges that between
300,000 and 600,000 non-Muslims died in 1915, but insists that this
was a "justifiable" act of state necessity. Its refusal to acknowledge
the genocide is a major stain on its bid to enter the European Union.

Taner Akcam, an eminent Turkish emigre historian who today teaches
at the Centre for Holocaust and Genocide Studies at the University of
Minnesota, has spent years putting the story of the Armenian genocide
together. It has not been easy. The CUP Central Committee and the
notorious Special Organization it established to carry out its policy
systematically purged the records to hide their roles in the genocide;
numerous records of trials of perpetrators of the "massacre" have
either been destroyed or scattered; and a general amnesty issued as
part of the Treaty of Lausanne (1922-23) effectively covered up any
follow-up trials in the 1920s. By then, Kemal’s central objective
was Turkish independence rather than justice for past acts.

Still, Akcam has put together a convincing case of central,
state-planned genocide on the basis of thousands of records that
escaped the official censors: eyewitness accounts from European
doctors, nurses and missionaries; diplomatic reports from neutral and
allied ambassadors, consuls and military officers; and some surviving
trial records.

Three attempts were made to bring those responsible to justice.

First, the Ottoman government set up a series of special courts-martial
to try the guilty in order to obtain more lenient terms at the Paris
Peace Conference. Second, under Articles 226 to 230 of the Treaty of
Sevres (1920), the Allied Powers tried to establish a legal corpus for
"crimes against humanity" and to seek prosecution in an international
court. And third, Britain took many of the suspects under custody
and removed them to Malta for trial.

This, too, failed, largely because Kemal threatened to execute one
British prisoner of war for every CUP official hanged.

The author rejects the standard view that the Armenian genocide was
an "isolated aberration." Instead, he places it within the context of
the turbulent years following the Balkan Wars of 1912-13. Stunned not
only by its unexpected military defeat, but also by the loss of 60 per
cent of its European territory, the Ottoman government set out under a
program of official "Pan-Turkism" or "Pan-Turanism" to "homogenize" the
population of Anatolia – and, in the words of War Minister Enver Pasha,
to extend it "from the Adriatic Sea to the waters of India." This
was done by dispersing and relocating non-Turkish Muslims like Kurds
and Arabs, and by expelling some 2 million non-Muslim, non-Turkish
peoples like Armenians, Assyrians and Greeks from the region.

Especially the Armenians, the "world’s oldest Christian people," were
"resettled" in what are today the Syrian and Iraqi deserts. En route,
hundreds of thousands were starved, beaten, shot and drowned, mainly
by the CUP’s Special Organization, but also by the Ottoman Third Army,
its irregular Kurdish Hamidiye cavalry, jailed convicts and the Muslim
refugees only recently forced out of European Turkey. The Armenians’
wealth was confiscated and their property destroyed or parcelled
out to create a new Muslim bourgeoisie. American, Austrian, German
and Scandinavian diplomats reported the genocide; none of their
governments took action to stop it.

The book is not a one-sided tale of Ottoman blood lust. Akcam also
chronicles the slaughter and dispossession of the Muslim populations
in the Empire’s Christian areas, the forced Muslim migrations after
the Crimean War (1854-56) and the banditry of the Armenian volunteers
who in 1914-15 joined Russian forces in the Caucasus and committed
countless atrocities against Muslims.

But what made the Armenian genocide so particularly appalling is not
only its scale, but also the fact that it was sponsored by a central
state government. And that its planners and practitioners used the
cold terminology – "total extirpation," "complete annihilation,"
"racial homogeneity" – of a later genocide. Interestingly, Max von
Scheubner-Richter as German vice-consul at Erzerum in 1915 reported the
Ottoman policy of "annihilation" of the Armenians to his government;
as a Nazi ideologue, he died at Adolf Hitler’s side during the infamous
"Beer Hall putsch" of November 1923.

Genocide has no borders.

Taner Akcam speaks Friday at 5 p.m. at Chancellor Day Hall of McGill
University, 3644 Peel St. Holger H. Herwig is a professor of history
at the University of Calgary.

GRAPHIC: Photo: METROPOLITAN BOOKS; Taner Akcam describes the Armenian
genocide as state-planned, he also chronicles atrocities against
Muslims. ;

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Turkish Minister Says Armenian Bill In USA Will Cause Lastin

TURKISH MINISTER SAYS ARMENIAN BILL IN USA WILL CAUSE LASTING DAMAGE TO RELATIONS

NTV, Turkey
Feb 10 2007

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul has declared that if the Armenian
genocide bill is approved by the US Congress, Turkish-US strategic
relations will sustain a lasting blow.

Gul concluded his contacts in the USA and returned to Ankara.

Commenting on his visit in a statement at Ankara’s Esenboga Airport,
Gul said that Turkey had fulfilled its task of issuing a warning
before the bill pertaining to the Armenian genocide allegations was
debated at the US Congress. Pointing out that there were efforts to
present the bill as a local problem, the minister stated: A local
issue does not have the right to poison a strategic matter.

Gul said that Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the US House of Representatives,
avoided meeting him on the grounds that she was not ready.

Also emphasizing importance of cooperation with regard to combating
the terrorist organization, Gul said: The patience of the Turkish
people has run out. The United States should place itself in our
position. If it does, it would also not tolerate this. We have tangible
expectations, not just words.

ANKARA: Turkish Minister Says Some Using Cyprus Problem To Hamper Tu

TURKISH MINISTER SAYS SOME USING CYPRUS PROBLEM TO HAMPER TURKEY’S EU PROCESS

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Feb 9 2007

Text of report in English by Turkish news agency Anatolia

New York, 9 February: "Annan Plan is the plan of the UN and it was
supported by UN Security Council, as well as the EU," said Turkish
Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul, who took the floor at think tank
organization Council of Foreign Relations in New York on Friday
[9 February].

"If Greek Cypriots had accepted the plan, today there would not be
Turkish soldiers in the island," he added.

Upon a question about Cyprus within the scope of Turkey-EU relations,
Gul said, "Some EU countries are using Cyprus problem as an excuse
artificially during Turkey’s EU negotiation process." He recalled
that Turkish Cypriots – by accepting Annan Plan – proved their good
will but Greek Cypriots voted against the plan.

Gul said that Greek Cypriot administration joined EU in a way against
valid agreements and principles in the island. "Greek Cypriots carried
Cyprus problem to the EU," he stressed.

Gul said, "There are two separate societies, religions and democracy
in the island. We support a comprehensive solution for the Cyprus
question."

Article 301 and Hrant Dink

Upon a question about murder of Armenian journalist Hrant Dink and
whether Article 301 of Turkish Penal Code (TCK) will be lifted,
Gul said, "We have wanted to amend Article 301 for a long time.

Government had launched initiatives a long time before murder of
Dink. These activities are still continuing. I want this article to
be amended because it overshadows our reform process."

Noting that other countries – just because of this article – think that
there is no freedom of expression in Turkey and people are imprisoned
because of their thoughts, Gul said that Turkey does not deserve such
an image and it wants to change this.

"In fact, Turkey took this article from laws of EU countries but we
had some difficulties while implementing the article," he added.

Windows Of The World: A Former Fresno Ad Designer Finds A New Career

WINDOWS OF THE WORLD: A FORMER FRESNO AD DESIGNER FINDS A NEW CAREER AND A WORLDWIDE REPUTATION IN RELIGIOUS ARTWORK
Ron Orozco

The Fresno Bee – California – KRTBN
Published: Feb 10, 2007

Corky Normart is king of religious art in the central San Joaquin
Valley.

At St. Columba Episcopal Church’s parish hall in northwest Fresno,
his stained-glass window, "Biblical Creation," features a gold cross
glowing with hundreds of red, purple, blue and gold rays.

At the California Armenian Home chapel in east Fresno, Normart’s "Tree
of Life" stained-glass window bears fruit in white, yellow and blue.

At St. Mary’s Episcopal Church in east Fresno, his stained-glass
window "The Annunciation of Mary" depicts the mother of Jesus with
a halo of orange, red and yellow.

Sixteen Valley churches and chapels, including some at hospitals and
retirement homes, display Normart’s religious art, making him a local
artist with a big impact on the faith community.

"He’s everywhere," says the Rev. James Snell, pastor of St. Columba
Church.

"He’s been a local icon for artists, and not just his stained glass,
but for his creativity."

After a long career as an art designer in advertising, Normart, 77,
has developed a second career with his religious art. His first work
was in 1983: a stained-glass window of an angel, "The Third Day,"
for the St. Columba chapel.

Normart is in demand in the Valley, but he also has an international
reputation. More than 10 years ago, he designed and oversaw the
restoration of the dome of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in
Jerusalem, the church traditionally believed to be built on the site
where Jesus was entombed.

In the Valley, Normart’s art is going to be showing up in more places,
including College Community Congregational Church in north Fresno.

In September, Zion Congregational Church in Fresno closed, and the
40 members decided to combine with College Community Congregational
Church. The former Zion members are bringing the stained-glass windows
that Normart made in 1999 with them.

Normart dubbed seven of the windows "The Seven Days," one for each
day in the account in Genesis, in which God creates the world.

These days, Normart is busy installing the windows portraying the
first six days — and creating a new window for the seventh day —
behind the altar at College Community Congregational Church.

At the rear of the sanctuary, Normart is installing the original
seventh-day window in the middle of two other windows he previously
had made for Zion.

"The windows are so special to us," former Zion member Eileen White
says.

Parishioners at St. Mary’s on East Kings Canyon Road also will see
more stained-glass windows by Normart.

In addition to "The Annunciation of Mary," which Normart shows in two
window panels, he also created two more window panels on the other
side of the worship hall, depicting the Annunciation of Joseph.

"They’re especially striking in the morning, when the sun comes
through at the 8 o’clock service," says the Rev. Michael Fry, pastor
of St. Mary’s.

Those four windows no sooner went up than parishioners agreed they
needed more of Normart’s religious art.

Normart is currently planning four more windows to continue the themes
of Mary and Joseph. He is toying with the idea of new windows next
to Mary with roses, the flower traditionally linked to her. Next
to Joseph’s windows, Normart is thinking about new windows with
lilies. ("He often is depicted in art with them," Normart says.)

Normart says he also is planning windows with Canterbury and Celtic
crosses because they symbolize the Anglican heritage of St. Mary’s
and other Episcopal churches.

"He’s done a lot of work with Episcopal churches in the area," Frye
says of Normart. "We’re glad to be associated with him."

Normart also has religious art displayed at Episcopal churches in
Los Banos (St. Alban’s) and Riverbank (Christ The King Parish). The
Episcopal Conference Center of Oakhurst also has Normart’s art.

Regardless of the denomination, Normart says he begins each religious
art project the same way.

He talks with clergy members, administrators and others to determine
what they want and offers his suggestions. Then, after coming to a
preliminary agreement, Normart prays and seeks inspiration by reading
scriptural passages.

"I’ve done more Bible readings since I’ve done the windows,"
Normart says.

Normart says he won’t ever forget his first religious art.

In 1983, a family member had a serious illness, and Normart had a hard
time dealing with it. A friend advised him to go to the St. Columba
chapel, where he would be able to gather his thoughts.

Normart got down on his knees, wept and prayed.

Out of that experience, Normart says he began to feel a sense of
peace and new insight into his feelings.

Maybe it was Normart’s artistic eye, but he also noticed the chapel
had a window that reminded him of a shower door — nothing inspiring.

So Normart got permission to create a stained-glass window in place of
the existing window. Normart had never crafted a stained-glass window,
but he went for it.

He created the angel, trumpeting Jesus’ Resurrection and Ascension
to heaven. He dubbed the window "The Third Day," based on the account
in the Gospel of Luke 24:21.

Normart says he just wanted to "give back" to St. Columba for what
its chapel meant to him. He also says he wanted to help others coming
to the chapel in similar desperation.

In 1995, Normart’s abilities became internationally known when he was
commissioned to return a sense of awe to the dome of the Church of
the Holy Sepulchre. The dome had fallen into disrepair from neglect
by its caretakers, representing Greeks, Armenians and Roman Catholic
Christians.

Normart’s idea was 23-carat gold-leafing for the dome’s 12 rays —
one for each of Jesus’ apostles — and the heavenly stars.

For nearly three years, Normart made dozens of trips to the
project. Then, one day, Normart linked his first religious artwork
in Fresno, "The Third Day," to the dome of the Church of the Holy
Sepulchre.

"On the third day, Jesus rose again and ascended into heaven,"
Normart says.

"I realized he rose from this tomb, which is the tomb under the dome
that I designed."

In 2002, Normart was commissioned to return to St. Columba, where
expansion plans were in the works for the parish hall and chapel.

Normart nearly tripled the size of "The Third Day" window and created
another new window for the chapel. He also created a 12-foot by 15-foot
stained-glass window, the "Biblical Creation," for the parish hall.

Normart says he feels satisfaction that his religious art helps people
to feel a sense of pleasure or deeper spiritual understanding.

In 1998, for example, Normart was in a corridor just outside the
California Armenian Home chapel. He was on a ladder, cleaning a
stained-glass window of Mount Ararat, which is dear to many residents
of Armenian descent.

Normart remembers the "click, click, click" sound of a woman resident
using a walker to enter the chapel. She was unaware Normart was nearby.

She looked into the chapel. And, upon seeing Normart’s stained-glass
windows, including "The Tree of Life," she said, "Oh, my."

Normart says the woman continued clicking her way into the chapel —
and she started singing the traditional hymn, "The Old Rugged Cross."

Normart remembers: "She sang the whole thing. I don’t know who she
was. She must have been in her 90s. She knew all of the words. She
just went right through them."

Normart’s friend, the Rev. Donald Mansir, who helped Normart land
the job in Jerusalem, says people appreciate Normart’s art because
it both inspires and educates them. When that happens, people also
experience a sense of closeness with God.

"Corky prays, so he is receiving an inspired instruction because of
the kind of man he is," Mansir, a Franciscan priest and chairman of
the Bishop John S. Cummins Institute for Catholic Thought, Culture
and Action at St. Mary’s College in Moraga.

"Both our intellect and heart have to be involved," Mansir says.

Normart says, "There are 10,000 artists who can do as well, if not
better, artistically, than me. I’ve been given the chance, so I say,
‘Thank you very much.’"

The reporter can be reached at [email protected]
(mailto:[email protected] m) or (559) 441-6304

Karabakh Leader Trying To Get Moscow’s Approval For Third Term – Arm

KARABAKH LEADER TRYING TO GET MOSCOW’S APPROVAL FOR THIRD TERM – ARMENIAN PAPER

Haykakan Zhamanak, Yerevan
10 Feb 07

Text of Kristine Khanumyan’s report by Armenian newspaper Haykakan
Zhamanak on 10 February headlined "Get your ‘approval’ from Kocharyan"

The president of the Nagornyy Karabakh republic [NKR], Arkadi
Ghukasyan, went to Moscow at the beginning of February. According
to our information, he went there to get approval to run for a third
term in office.

Usually, if the president goes somewhere, even if he goes to Yerevan,
his press secretary sends a press release to journalists saying
where the president has gone. But this time, the press secretary
kept quiet. This shows that Ghukasyan had gone off to Moscow
secretly. According to our Moscow sources, when the press reported
Ghukasyan’s visit, the Russians organized an information leak that in
Moscow, Ghukasyan met the head of the culture and regional relations
department of the Russian presidential administration, Modest Kolerov.

Kolerov told Ghukasyan that the Russian leadership fully trusts
[Armenian President] Robert Kocharyan and he is the one who should
solve such problems. In fact, Ghukasyan did not get the expected
"approval" from the Russians. As for Kocharyan, in an ordinary
situation he would do everything possible to make Ghukasyan NKR
president for a third time, but today the situation is different.

It should be recalled that for two years already Kocharyan has
not taken part in celebrations in Karabakh. He did not even go to
Stepanakert to take part in ceremonies to mark the 15th anniversary
of the NKR’s independence, though he should have been there as the
first president of the NKR. It is obvious that Kocharyan-Ghukasyan
relations are not as they used to be. Moreover, Ghukasyan went to
Moscow bypassing Kocharyan, but he was made to understand there that
"my vassal’s vassal is not my vassal". If Ghukasyan goes to Yerevan in
the near future, this will mean that he has decided to meet Kocharyan
to discuss everything with him. But if not, this will mean that he
has decided to wait for the results of the parliamentary election in
Armenia, or to be more precise, he has decided to wait for [Defence
Minister] Serzh Sargsyan to become Armenian prime minister. They say
Sargsyan had given serious promises to Ghukasyan. We shall soon learn
Ghukasyan’s strategy. As for the NKR president’s press secretary,
Mr Eduard Atanesyan, he is still keeping quiet about Ghukasyan’s
visit to Moscow, although we would still like him to comment on it.

Armenian Paper Sees Regional Railway As Blow To National Security

ARMENIAN PAPER SEES REGIONAL RAILWAY AS BLOW TO NATIONAL SECURITY

Haykakan Zhamanak, Yerevan
9 Feb 07

Excerpt from report by Hayk Gevorkyan in Armenian newspaper Haykakan
Zhamanak on 9 February headlined "It would not be the other way round"

As the saying goes, there are no coincidences in big politics. On
7 February, in Tbilisi the presidents of Georgia and Azerbaijan,
[Mikheil] Saakashvili and [Ilham] Aliyev, and Turkey’s Prime Minister
[Recep Tayyip] Erdogan signed a contract on the Kars-Akhalkalak
[Akhalkalaki]-Tbilisi-Baku railway. On the same day, Armenian President
Robert Kocharyan signed a decree on national security strategy. Is
that a coincidence? This is in fact a regular occasion.

Moreover, it would not be the other way round.

The point is that the Kars-Akhalkalak-Tbilisi-Baku railway is an open
blow to national security of Armenia, and the Armenian authorities
are not seemingly disproving this. What was an action of the Armenian
authorities when the project was being prepared? They were building
the state headed by Kocharyan, attacking ballot stations and voting
"for" the constitutional reforms, developing our economy by means of
tiger jumps, celebrating our regular diplomatic victories etc.

Over this period of time Kocharyan has used to meet students and
tell them

that the railway does not have economic prospects and, for this
reason, it will not be constructed. Defence Minister Serzh Sargsyan
has been drafting our national security strategy. In other words,
when Turkey and Azerbaijan have been taking serious steps for the
railway construction, our authorities have been writing fairy tales
and telling society about them. This is absolutely normal that the
contract on the railway construction and the decree on national
security strategy were signed on the same day, i.e. 7 February.

When two parties are at war, victory of one of them unavoidably means
defeat of another one. In the modern world, a war does not only mean
attacking each other with tanks. We have lost the aforementioned war
without reservation. Incidentally, we lost not because the enemy is
strong but because we turned to be very weak. We are weak because
until today Kocharyan and [Foreign Minister Vardan] Oskanyan have
been trying to persuade people that only "the return of Karabakh"
may hinder the construction of the railway, that nothing in the region
depends on Armenia, that time works in favour of Armenia etc.

[Passage omitted: the railway is commercially viable]

Turkish Minister Says Armenian Bill In USA Will Cause Lasting Damage

TURKISH MINISTER SAYS ARMENIAN BILL IN USA WILL CAUSE LASTING DAMAGE TO RELATIONS

NTV television, Istanbul
10 Feb 07

Text of report by Turkish commercial NTV television on 10 February

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul has declared that if the Armenian
genocide bill is approved by the US Congress, Turkish-US strategic
relations will sustain a lasting blow.

Gul concluded his contacts in the USA and returned to
Ankara. Commenting on his visit in a statement at Ankara’s Esenboga
Airport, Gul said that Turkey had fulfilled its task of issuing a
warning before the bill pertaining to the Armenian genocide allegations
was debated at the US Congress. Pointing out that there were efforts
to present the bill as a local problem, the minister stated: A local
issue does not have the right to poison a strategic matter.

Gul said that Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the US House of Representatives,
avoided meeting him on the grounds that she was not ready.

Also emphasizing importance of cooperation with regard to combating
the terrorist organization, Gul said: The patience of the Turkish
people has run out.

The United States should place itself in our position. If it does,
it would also not tolerate this. We have tangible expectations,
not just words.

The Number Of "ArmenTel" Subscribers Reached 450 Thousand, Vice-Pres

THE NUMBER OF "ARMENTEL" SUBSCRIBERS REACHED 450 THOUSAND, VICE-PRESIDENT OF "VIMPELCOM" STATED

Mediamax
Feb 09 2007

Yerevan, February 9 /Mediamax/. The number of mobile subscribers of
the "ArmenTel" Company reached 450 thousand.

Mediamax reports referring Prime-Tass that "VimpelCom" Vice-President
for Business Development in the CIS states Sergey Avdeev said this.

In November 2006, when "VimpelCom" purchased 90% share of "ArmenTel"
from the Greek OTE, the number of the mobile subscribers of the
Company was 400 thousand.

Mediamax recalls that in late December 2006, Sergey Avdeev stated that
"ArmenTel" had lost the position of a leader on the market of mobile
communication of Armenia.

"We should understand the account policy and the way they count
the subscribers in Armenia. However, judging from the accounting,
during 2006 VivaCell managed to leave behind the mobile division
of "ArmenTel". Today, the ration is about 600 thousand to 450
thousand. But the given fact does not at all confuse us. This is
where we know how to work", the Vice-President of "VimpelCom" was
saying in an interview to the RBC Daily newspaper.

BAKU: Azeri Expert Says Armenians May Attack Regional Railway

AZERI EXPERT SAYS ARMENIANS MAY ATTACK REGIONAL RAILWAY

Day.az website, Baku,
10 Feb 07

Text of report by Azerbaijani website Day.az on 10 February

10 February: "Armenians might resort to consistent
military intervention to prevent the construction of the
Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku railway," Mubariz Ahmadoglu, director
of the Centre for Political Innovations and Technologies, said while
commenting on possible problems in the construction of the railway.

"Yerevan has already made statements that it will use all political
means to prevent the construction of the Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku
railway. Such a statement can be described as terrorism," the political
expert said.

He said that Azerbaijan and Georgia had earlier managed to prevent
threats to the construction of pipelines. "Now that the two countries
have become stronger both politically and economically, they will be
able to eliminate any attacks from outside."

In the view of the political expert, in this situation the problem
is related to Akhalkalaki Armenians. Although they will make money
on the construction of the railway, they oppose this project because
it bypasses Armenia.

"While the obstacles were political, financial and geopolitical
in nature during the construction of the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil
pipeline, in this case there is a threat of an armed confrontation,"
Ahmadoglu said, adding that "not terrorist acts, but consistent armed
attacks are possible. Terrorism and a consistent armed fighting are
different things".

"My" Coverage Of The Armenian Genocide Of 1915

"MY" COVERAGE OF THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE OF 1915
by Martin Waller

The Times (London)
February 10, 2007, Saturday

To the large number of angry Turks who have been e-mailing me about
"my" coverage of the Armenian genocide of 1915, I think you want Time
magazine. Enough, please.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress