Deadly Nationalism

DEADLY NATIONALISM
By Annette Grossbongardt in Istanbul

SPIEGEL ONLINE
URL: ,1518 ,465046,00.html
February 10, 2007, 05:53 PM

The Struggle of Orhan Pamuk and Turkey’s Intellectuals

The culture war in Turkey against critical authors and journalists
is intensifying, as murderous nationalists agitate against dissidents.

Many liberals are under threat, including Nobel Prize winner Orhan
Pamuk, who has now left the country.

Orhan Pamuk flew to the Cairo International Book Fair on the day of
the funeral of his friend Hrant Dink. There is "great interest in
all aspects of Turkish literature and culture" in the Arab world,
the winner of the 2006 Nobel Prize in Literature said, but it sounded
as if he were attempting to justify his trip abroad, now that the
situation in Turkey has become precarious for him and other liberal
writers and journalists.

By that point, Pamuk’s moves were apparently prompted by fears for
his own life. He did not attend the morning funeral procession two
weeks ago for Dink, a Turkish-Armenian journalist who was murdered
by ultra-nationalists. More than just a funeral procession, the
event turned into a protest march of demonstrators who chanted "We
are all Armenians," making a strong impression on Europeans. But
despite his absence from the procession, Pamuk did not hesitate to
publicly criticize the Turkish government, judiciary and society,
which he held partly responsible for Dink’s death. "The murder of my
courageous, golden-hearted friend has soured my life," Pamuk confessed,
"I am furious at everyone and everything, and I feel boundless shame."

As if to reinforce his words, Turkey was in an uproar last Friday over
images of several police officers who were photographed in a chummy
pose with the young murder suspect. The officers were suspended from
duty, but not before the newspaper Sabah condemned the incident,
writing that a nationalist murderer was being treated like a hero.

By then Pamuk, who has become the most prominent advocate of a modern,
liberal, cosmopolitan Turkey, had already left Istanbul for the United
States, where he plans to stay, for the time being, and give lectures
at several universities. He cancelled a reading tour in Germany
last week and ceremonies at the Free University of Berlin and the
Catholic University of Brussels. Both institutions had planned to
award Pamuk honorary doctorates, but the author simply declined to
attend without so much as offering an explanation. The Carl Hanser
Publishing Company, which has published his books in German, including
"The White Fortress," "Snow" and, most recently, "Istanbul," received
nothing but a blunt fax to explain Pamuk’s absence. The answering
machine at his house in Istanbul was switched off, and whenever
journalists did manage to reach him, he would hang up the phone.

"More will die"

"Tell Orhan Pamuk to wise up!" one of the principal suspects in the
Dink murder, right-wing extremist Yasin Hayal, a man with a criminal
record, said publicly. The threat must have made a strong impression
on the author.

Last week the self-proclaimed "Turkish Revenge Brigade" (TIT) posted
a video on YouTube depicting Dink’s corpse next to photos of Pamuk.

The lyrics of a song that accompanied the images read: "We cannot
be friends with them." The video ended with a shot of a Turkish flag
and the head of a wolf — the symbol of Turkish ultra-nationalists,
and the threat: "More will die."

Pamuk, Turkey’s most famous writer and a man who ought to be the pride
of this country as it seeks European Union membership, has been pursued
by hate-mongering nationalists for some time, and he is not the only
one. About a dozen Turkish writers, journalists and academics are
currently the targets of hate-spewing, fanatical right-wing extremists.

Pamuk’s hasty departure shines a spotlight on the clash of cultures and
the climate of agitation, intimidation and fear dissidents in Turkey
currently face, especially those who dare to tackle national taboos —
of which there are many, including the 1915 genocide of Armenians in
the Ottoman Empire, which the Turkish government continues to dispute,
Christian minorities, the Kurds and the PKK (Kurdish Workers’ Party)
and, of course, Kemal Ataturk, the founder of the modern Turkish state.

According to statistics compiled by the Turkish Human Rights
Foundation, close to 100 intellectuals have already been hauled before
courts for voicing their critical opinions. Most have been charged
with the crime of "insulting Turkishness," or disparaging national
institutions. Reactionary prosecutors use a notorious Turkish law
known as Article 301 to persecute critical thinkers.

Elif Shafak, 35, a popular and courageous female author, had done
nothing more threatening than write a novel ("The Bastard of Istanbul")
that tells the interweaving stories of a Turkish and an Armenian
family in the United States and Istanbul. Her novel prompted a group
of nationalist lawyers to take Shafak to court in 2006, merely because
one of her characters says: "I am the grandchild of genocide survivors
who lost all their lives to the hands of Turkish butchers in 1915."

Shafak was acquitted, but she confesses that she felt "quite shaken"
by the "ordeal" of the trial. As happens in all of these trials,
angry nationalist activists gathered outside the court house. The
same brand of activists threw eggs at Pamuk, who was also accused of
"insulting Turkishness," and berated Perihan Magden, a journalist who
had written an article defending conscientious objectors, as a "whore
of the PKK." Shafak was well into a pregnancy when her trial began.

She had been receiving threatening letters for some time, but only
after the Dink murder did the government finally acknowledge the
danger she and other journalists faced. Turkish Prime Minister Recep
Tayyip Erdogan has now assigned government bodyguards to writers and
intellectuals considered in danger.

Grassroots snitches

Ideologically obsessed citizens often act as informers, such as the
attorney from Izmir who filed a complaint against Muazzez Ilmiye Cig,
a 92-year-old female archeologist. The case against Cig revolved around
the religious headscarf, one of the central symbols of conflict in
Muslim but highly secular Turkey. Cig, an expert in the history of
the Sumerians, had written that headscarves were originally worn by
Sumerian priestesses to initiate young men into sex. Cig was accused of
"inciting hatred" but was acquitted.

The portrait of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the founder of the modern
Turkish nation, hangs in every Turkish government office, every
business and every classroom. He has been dead 70 years, and yet
criticizing him as a historic figure remains taboo. When Atilla Yayla,
an Istanbul political scientist, dared to describe the first few years
of Ataturk’s government as a "step backwards, not a period of progress"
and criticized the official cult of hero worship surrounding Ataturk,
he was promptly suspended from his job.

When journalist Ipek Calislar wrote about an episode in which Ataturk
dressed in women’s clothing to escape an assassination attempt,
she was accused of having tarnished Ataturk’s reputation. "Ataturk
was an incredibly brave man and would never have done such a thing,"
wrote an angry reader who filed a complaint against the author with
the public prosecutor’s office. If Calislar had been found guilty,
she could have faced up to four and a half years in prison.

Even translators of undesirable books are not safe against persecution,
nor are publishers like Fatih Tas, who published a study by an American
professor on "the human costs of the US arms trade."

Turkey, a US ally, is criticized in the report.

"A wave of nationalism"

For the European Union the trials, which seek to muzzle the
freedom of speech, are a barometer for Turkey’s suitability for EU
membership. Each new trial creates fresh doubts as to whether the
country is in fact succeeding in transforming itself into an open,
pluralistic society.

The roots of the problem are deeply embedded in a highly traditional,
conservative society, large segments of which have suddenly chosen
to obstruct the country’s efforts to become integrated into the West.

"The Turkey of today harbors a smaller modern society and a vast
pre-modern society that live side by side, but not in the same era,"
says sociologist Dogu Ergil.

Nationalists who prefer to drive their country into isolation rather
than deliver it to "imperialistic enemies" in the West currently
dominate the pre-modern segment of Turkish society.

The country has been seized by "a wave of nationalism of unprecedented
scope," complains political scientist Baskin Oran, who was also once
put on trial, in his case for writing a critical report about the
situation of Turkish minorities. The Erdogan administration, which
campaigned on a reform platform but is now eager to gain reelection,
does little to stem the country’s reactionary mood.

The other camp, the modern segment of Turkish society, is embodied by
the 100,000 people who took to the streets to mourn murdered journalist
Dink, but also by the country’s economic elite, who know that Turkey
can only have a future as part of the West. But the nationalists have
met the show of solidarity with the country’s Armenian minority with
renewed attempts to wrest public opinion away from the demonstrators,
and they are now holding up banners that read: "We are all Turks,
our names are Mehmet, Hasan and Huseyin, not Hrant Dink." A bitter
fight has erupted over the future direction of Turkey, waged on one
side in parts with murderous fervor. Which side will emerge victorious
is still undecided.

Constant threats

The day Ismet Berkan, editor-in-chief of the liberal newspaper Radical,
had to be accompanied by bodyguards to leave his office was the day
he began thinking about leaving the country. "But that’s exactly what
they want," he says, "and that’s why we must stay and raise our voices
against those who want to cut Turkey off from the rest of the world."

This requires courage, especially for someone who receives up to
50 threatening anonymous letters a day, letters that read: "We will
get rid of you, we will kill you." A year ago, Berkan and four other
journalists were put on trial for having criticized a court decision
banning a conference on the Armenian question.

Baskin Oran also refuses to be driven out. The 62-year-old political
science professor perseveres in his small row house in Ankara,
clinging to the conviction that Turkey "is getting better every day,
even if we are passing through hell on the road to paradise." He
solicits understanding for his country, which he says is rushing
through a development process in a matter of decades that lasted
for centuries in Europe. Oran regularly receives e-mails, telephone
calls and faxes in which fanatics disparage him as a "bastard" and
"traitor," messages peppered with threats like "we will fuck your
mother" and "we will kill you." In a report he wrote on Turkish
minorities, Oran proposed the use of the term "citizens of Turkey"
instead of the ethnically defining word "Turks."

Prosecutors accused Oran of "inciting hatred" and, with his ideas,
of promoting "chaos" and jeopardizing the "fundamental elements
of the Turkish Republic." Oran defended himself with a 40-page
"counter-accusation," which he said he owed to his students, "whom I
have been teaching, for the past 37 years, to take a stand against
anti-democratic positions." His efforts were successful — for the
time being. But he nevertheless requires police protection every time
he leaves his home.

"I live in a country that celebrates and honors its generals,
police officers and statesman, even while they are still alive,
but persecutes its writers with court trials and prison sentences,"
Pamuk said last year, when he was still embroiled in his own trial.

A difficult relationship with intellectuals

The hostile mood in Turkey reflects the country’s difficult
relationship with its intellectuals and its deep distrust of its
pro-Western authors who criticize the system from within.

"We are always seen as potential runaways, if not potential traitors,"
says writer Shafak. "Criticizing the country is considered practically
the equivalent of hating it." In a recent television interview, she was
asked: "Did you ever say that you were not feeling at home in Turkey?"

When Pamuk was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in October,
a first for Turkey, his otherwise staunchly nationalist fellow Turks
were restrained in their praise for the author. To this day many are
convinced that the only reason Pamuk received the prize was that he
openly criticized the Armenian genocide.

Pamuk has toned down his rhetoric since then. "Especially now that
I am a Nobel Prize winner," he says, "I am no longer interested in
talking about minor political matters as much," he admits.

Nevertheless, he adds, he sometimes becomes so furious that he is
unable to hold his tongue. It seems that there are currently plenty
of reasons for Pamuk to begin talking again.

Translated from the German by Christopher Sultan

SPIEGEL ONLINE 2007 All Rights Reserved Reproduction only allowed
with the permission of SPIEGELnet GmbH

http://www.spiegel.de/international/spiegel/0

Georgia: An Important State For The Stability In The Caucasus

GEORGIA: AN IMPORTANT STATE FOR THE STABILITY IN THE CAUCASUS
View by Kamer KASIM, PhD (USAK)

Journal of Turkish Weekly

JTW 10 February 2007

After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Georgia became an independent
state, however, since its independence Georgia faced severe internal
crisis and security problems, which were the great obstacle for
the implementation of reforms and the success of the state-building
process. Having border with Russia, Turkey, Azerbaijan and Armenia
and access to the Black Sea make Georgia important transit routes to
the Europe and Central Asia. Internal conflicts and lack of stability
prevented Georgia to utilize its location in the Caucasus and delayed
the possible regional cooperation, which would be beneficial for all
the countries in the region. Given the fact that Georgia has lack of
natural resources and weak economic structure, it is very difficult
for Georgia to exploit its geographical location without support from
the regional powers and the United States. In fact, Georgia is the
one of the biggest beneficiary of the US aid in the world. Georgia
has received approximately $ 800 million aid from the US.

Turkey, the United Kingdom, Germany and the Netherlands are also
important donors for Georgia. To analyze the roots of Georgia’s
continuing problems and its difficulty to solve them despite the
financial and political support from the outside world; we need to
look at Georgia’s frozen conflicts and Russian role in the region.

After the collapse of the Soviet Union, the Russian Federation has
emerged with 60 percent of the population and 76 percent of the
territory of the former Soviet Union and followed the policy of
domination in the former Soviet territories. The Soviet Union was
a multinational empire and its foreign policy agenda was designed
accordingly. The foreign policy of the Russian Federation had to
be different than the Soviet Union. Internal discussing about the
direction of the Russian foreign policy produced the two main groups:
Atlanticists and Eurasianists. Atlanticists considered Russia as
a Western nation and according to them cooperation with the Western
states would help Russia to absorb Western values, including democracy
and human rights. Atlanticists believed that Russia must avoid
assuming a leading role in the Commonwealth of Independent States
(CIS). Russia’s active role in the CIS would slow down Russia’s
integration with Western economic institutions. Until the end of 1992
Atlanticist view was dominant in Russian foreign policy and they aimed
to liberate the Russian Federation from the burdens of the empire
and to make Russia a part of community of democratic states. In that
period, Russia’s administration was concerned with transforming of
the Russian economy into a genuine market and to integrate Russia with
the Western system. As a result, Russia showed a lack of interest in
its relations with the new Caucasian and Central Asian republics.

Eurasianists criticized Atlanticist view and they emphasized Russia’s
distinctive identity from the West. The Eurasianist approach affected
Russia’s foreign policy after 1992, and produced the policy of ‘Near
Abroad’ (blizhneezarubezhe) promoting Russia’s relations with the CIS.

Eurasianists believed that the security of Russia and its "Near
Abroad" was inseparable and Russia should not ignore the Caucasus
and Central Asia. As an indication of the change in Russian foreign
policy, the "foreign policy concept" was introduced in 1993, which
emphasized actual and potential conflicts of interests with the West
and envisaged a more active role for Russia in security and economic
affairs in the "Near Abroad". After that Russia used every tool to
restore its dominance in the Caucasus and small states in the region
were severely affected by that policy. Georgia was one of the worst
affected states with the Russian policy in the region.

Georgia was rejected became a part of the CIS and Russian military
presence in the country. Russia showed its ability to use internal
dispute in regional states in order to exert its influence and to
keep its military presence in newly independent states. Georgia was an
easy target for the Russian foreign policy, since Georgia has diverse
minority groups and fragile political and economic structures. As a
result Georgia faced internal turmoil and conflict with Abkhazia and
Ossetia. Abkhazia was an autonomous republic within Georgia and the
conflict, erupted between Georgians and Abkhazians.

The Russian forces played a role in supplying arms, training and
assisting Abkhazian units in direct combat. The main reason for the
Russian support of Abkhazia was to put pressure on Georgia to enter the
CIS and allow Russian troops to be deployed on the Turkish-Georgian
border. Abkhazia’s strategic position along the Black Sea coast was
probably another reason for the Russian support of Abkhazia. In fact,
the conflict forced Georgia to enter the CIS.

Russia got four military bases in Georgia. The Russian bases were
in the most sensitive areas. One was in Abkhazia and was believed
to be a support point for the Abkhazian separatists. Another was in
the southwestern region of Adjara, which was also in rebel hands. A
third one was at Akhalkalaki; the heart of a region populated mainly
by Armenians. The fourth one was on the outskirts of Tbilisi where
there is also an air base.

On April 4, 1994, the "Declaration on Measures for a Political
Settlement of the Georgian-Abkhazian Conflict" was signed,
even though the resumption of armed conflict remained a future
possibility. According to this document, Abkhazia would have its
own constitution, parliament and government and appropriate state
symbols, such as an anthem, emblem and flag, and would maintain
its own internal sovereignty. Georgian officials complained about
the agreement and Deputy Prime Minister, Nadareishvili, said that
"agreements signed between Georgia and Abkhazia had no legal basis
and were harmful for Georgia".

Georgia also faced Ossetia problem just after the independence. Some
south Ossetians wanted to unite with North Ossetia and become part of
Russia. Having used Abkhazians and Ossetians, Russia had the chance
to meddle Georgia. After Ossetians’ declaration of sovereignty,
Georgian Parliament abolished Ossetia’s autonomous status.

100,000 people became refugee as a result of the fighting in Ossetia.

In 1992 a Russian-Georgian-Ossetian peacekeeping force was created in
South Ossetia. Crisis gave Russia a chance to intervene the internal
affair of Georgia. It might be argued that unification of south and
north Ossetia was not Russia’s interest. Therefore Russia benefited
from the crisis, but it did not also want Ossetians to reach their
final objective.

Dispute between Russia and Georgia continued about the Russian
military bases in Georgia. In 1995, the treaty was signed between
Georgia and Russia about permission to the Russian military bases
in Georgia. The Treaty was in effect for 25 years, and automatically
extent five years at a time if the parties did not agree otherwise.

However, the treaty was not ratified. In 1999, Georgian Foreign
Minister Menegarashvili stated that the reason for the non-ratification
of the 1995 treaty was that it was in fact breaching the limits of
the original Conventional Forces in Europe (CFE) treaty. In March
2005 the Georgian parliament passed a resolution ordering Russia
to withdraw from Georgia no later than 2006 and allowing Georgia
to exercise its right to take measures against the bases before May
2005.12 According to the recent deal the withdrawal of the Russian
military bases from Georgia will be completed within 2008.

The developments after the 11th of September 2001 terrorist attacks
have a great impact in the Caucasus. The US military presence in
the region increased the US influence and in this aspect, together
with Azerbaijan, Georgia became an important state to fight against
terrorism. The stability in Georgia became more important for the US.

First, Georgia provides air link for the US troops to Central Asia
and important check point in the Caucasus. Second after 11 September
and the War in Iraq in 2003 made crucial to the realization of the
East-West energy corridor and particularly the transportation of
Caspian oil to the world markets. Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline
became partly operational on 25th of May 2005.

Therefore, the US will not want any destabilization of Georgia,
which might prevent the flow of oil from the pipeline. Despite the
fact that Georgia was benefited from the international environment
after the 11 September 2001, Russia also used this environment for
its benefit, which to some extent put Georgia in a difficult situation.

Russia imposed more assertive policy towards the Chechen conflict
and blamed Georgia to provide shelter for terrorists in Pankisi Valley.

Russia argued that Pankisi Valley became the area as a training ground
and arms smuggling route for the Chechen rebels. The area also became
home for approximately 7.000 Chechen refugees and full control of the
region is beyond the Georgia’s capacity. Russia aimed to established
anti-terror centers in Georgia. However, Georgia considered this
suggestion as a Russian strategy to re-label its military bases in
Georgia as anti-Terror centers.

Georgia faced also tension in Javakheti province and its capital
Ahalkelek, where was home for Ahiska Turks and currently Armenian
minority lives there. The return of the Ahiska Turks to Georgia was
discussed in the Council of Europe within the framework of Georgian
membership to the Council of Europe. Ahiska Turks’ return to Georgia
has not been realized yet. The province is adjacent to Turkey and on
the important transit route between Turkey and Georgia.

Separatist tendencies of the Armenian minority of the province might
destabilize Georgia and even the potential danger exists for the
creation of second "Karabakh". During the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict,
Armenians in Javakheti aided to the Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians and
Nagorno-Karabakh problem is stimulated Armenian nationalism.13 After
11th September 2001 increased importance of Georgia in the region
and the US military presence in Georgia reduced the risk of possible
conflict in Javakheti province.

After the completion of the Baku-Tbilisi-Cayhan pipeline Georgia
became a key state for Turkey, Azerbaijan and the US. Georgia’s
relations with Turkey improved on the political and economic front.

The project to construct railway link between Turkish city
Kars to Georgian city Ahalkelek would be important for improve
the transportation in the region. However, Armenia objected the
Kars-Ahalkelek railway link. Armenia argued that proposed railway line
would contribute the isolation of Armenia. The construction of the
Kars-Ahalkelek railway line and the rehabilitation of the existing
Tbilisi-Ahalkelek line need approximately $ 400 million.

Georgia’s significance will grow in the region and the US and Turkey’s
assistance will continue in the future. Political stability in the
Caucasus will be very difficult to achieve in the near future. The
increase of political and economic stability in Caucasus countries
will contribute the regional stability. After the "velvet revolution",
the positive atmosphere emerged for the stability of Georgia and
stability will create the suitable atmosphere for the solution of
Georgia’s "Frozen Disputes".

Kamer KASIM: Assoc. Prof. Dr. & USAK (International Strategic Research
Organization) Caucasus Expert. BA (University of Ankara), MA and PhD
(University of Manchester)

http://www.turkishweekly.net/

"A Trip To Karabakh" Film To Be Presented At Berlinale 2007

"A TRIP TO KARABAKH" FILM TO BE PRESENTED AT BERLINALE 2007

ArmRadio.am
12.02.2007 17:59

"A Trip to Karabakh" – a film of Georgian director Levan Tutberidze,
will be presented at the 57th Berlin International Film Festival. It
will be screened in the CinemaxX on 14 February.

This is the first time that a Georgian film has been presented in
the international cinema market.

The 57th Berlin International Film Festivalwas launched on February
8 and will continue till 18 February. 350 films will be screened in
the framework of the festival.

Masis Mayilyan: Discussion Of The Karabakh Issue Outside The OSCE Ca

MASIS MAYILYAN: DISCUSSION OF THE KARABAKH ISSUE OUTSIDE THE OSCE CAN PRODUCE THE OPPOSITE EFFECT

ArmRadio.am
12.02.2007 17:32

"We welcome every action that could be helpful for the peace settlement
of the conflict. However, in the past few years we saw that discussion
of the Karabakh issue in different international organizations other
than the OSCE were not productive, moreover, they can produce the
opposite effect, NKR Deputy Foreign Minister Masis Mayilyan said in
an interview with the "Karabakh Open."

The Deputy Foreign Minister said that as a rule, Azerbaijan is up for
reporting the conflict to different international organizations to
intensify information and psychological confrontation in the region
and pressure on the both Armenian parties.

The misinterpretation of the essence of the conflict may also do harm
to the settlement of the conflict, which was the case with the report
of the PACE reporter on the Karabakh conflict. Therefore, to avoid
this, the actors of these discussions should mind in their efforts to
promote the settlement of the conflict not to get the parties ramble
away from the resolution of the conflict," he noted.

As for the report of the Rapporteur on the missing persons in
Nagorno Karabakh Leo Platvoet, Masis Mayilyan expressed regret that
the Rapporteur used unchecked data received from Baku. "The Karabakh
party has pointed to the fact that the Azerbaijani data on the missing
people are false. The Azerbaijani government hides the real number
of its losses in the period of the military actions by multiplying
this number. Moreover, it is highly probable that part of the people
mentioned in the Azerbaijani records of the missing deserted in the
midst of the war and are now living in Russia and other countries.

According to the International Committee of the Red Cross, in 1997 the
total number of the missing in the area of the conflict, both Armenian
and Azerbaijani, was 2229. Considering that the ICRC collected these
data within the three years following the cease-fire, they could not
undergo major changes later. At the same time, it should be noted
that the recommendations of the report by Leo Platvoet include several
statements set forward by the Karabakh side, namely criticism against
politicization of the issue of the missing, as well as the necessity
for setting up contacts between the state commission of NKR and its
Azerbaijani counterpart for productive cooperation over the given
issue," said Masis Mayilyan.

Turning to the frequent cases of crossing the border by Azeri soldiers
the Deputy Foreign Minister said the NKR government, which committed
to the Geneva Conventions, reports immediately to the Stepanakert
offices of the International Committee of the Red Cross and the OSCE,
then the prisoners are returned to the Azerbaijani side through the
ICRC. "As a member of the NKR State Commission on the POWs and the
missing, I state that presently there are no POWs and missing people
in the territory of our republic.

As to the fact that recently more Azerbaijani soldiers have been
imprisoned, the reasons may differ. According to the Azerbaijani
military experts, the reason might be bad treatment in the Azerbaijani
military units located at the front line, corruption among commissioned
officers, as well as the low morale and weak preparation of the
Azerbaijani soldiers," said the Deputy Foreign Minister.

As for the negotiation process son the Karabakh conflict settlement,
Masis Mayilyan said that obviously, the upcoming elections in Armenia
and NKR will affect the pace of the negotiations. Next autumn the
talks are expected to become more active.

ANKARA: Turkish Press Ponders Purpose Of "Military Build-Up" In Nort

TURKISH PRESS PONDERS PURPOSE OF "MILITARY BUILD-UP" IN NORTH IRAQ

Yeni Safak website, Istanbul
2 Feb 07

Text of report by Turkish newspaper Yeni Safak website on 2 February

[Column by Ibrahim Karagul: "The PKK Reportedly Has Airplanes; What
About These Allegations?"]

Britain’s International Institute for Strategic Studies reports
interesting findings in its "Military Balances" report for 2007. The
most dramatic of these is related to Turkey. It is so dramatic that
if any individual, any reporter, or any writer in this country made
that same claim, he or she would be the subject of ridicule. The
allegation made is as substantial as the one about a "suicide attack
on Ataturk’s Mausoleum with an airplane."

For example, I wonder what we would hear if I came out with a similar
charge. There would be no sound from the circles that are supposed
to take the allegation seriously. After all, no one remembers the
allegation when they come out to be true. However, the allegation of
this institute was certainly taken seriously.

The report alleges that "the PKK is planning terrorist attacks on
selected targets using remotely controlled model airplanes." The
allegation is based on information obtained from Turkish intelligence
agencies. That means Turkish intelligence have raised the same
allegation as the institute. However, is it true? Is this allegation
well-founded? For now, we do not know.

What I am trying to say here is this: Why are not allegations at
least as important as the PKK airplanes not taken seriously? Are
those allegations more far-fetched? What were they? Let me recall
some of the allegations I reported at different times.

"Special operations squads are entering northern Iraq from Sirnak.

Peshmergas are being deployed in large numbers in regions near the
Turkish border. Specifically, 6,000 peshmergas have been deployed in
Kirkuk, 2,000 in Mosul, and 3,000 along the Turkish border.

Interestingly, US and Israeli commanders are in charge of the
peshmergas here. Military equipment is being moved to the region.

Weapons for short-range combat are being moved into the area.

Peshmergas will also be reportedly moved from Baghdad to the Turkish
border in the near future. The Kurds are being driven to the fireline
in the civil war in Iraq and against Iran and Turkey."

"Certain persons from Turkish special squads went to Israel.

Subsequently, missiles and weapons were sent from Israel to northern
Iraq. Israel and peshmergas are known to have stockpiled missiles in
northern Iraq, but nothing is done about them."

Here is one from another article:

"Turkish special operations units have been conducting cross-border
operations and monitoring developments, but the military build-up
continues in the same regions. Three days ago, missiles, night-vision
binoculars, thermal cameras, and weapons were delivered to the
Kurdish units in the region. Who delivered them? The United States
and Israel. These materials are also being distributed to [Kurdish]
units Kirkuk, Mosul, Arbil, and other areas. Soon, new missiles and
heavy weapons will arrive and be distributed."

Here is another:

"A military build-up has begun on the northern Iraqi side. Foreign
forces have been airlifted to the area around the Turkish border and
they have taken up positions. Indeed, foreign military units were
dropped just on the border in the Altintepe area of Sirnak a few days
ago. Actually, not on the border, but on the Turkish side. In other
words, on Turkish soil. Let us say that this is a joint operation
between Turkey and the United States and Israel. Then, why the
military build-up?"

Let me go on:

"The increased agitation in northern Iraq, deliveries of heavy
weapons, deliveries of missiles, construction of missile launching
sites and military bases, US soldiers airlifted to Turkey’s border,
various land surveys and explorations conducted in the border area –
are these preparations for Turkey’s intervention in the region?"

"What should we think when we see Ankara’s two allies airlift
military units to the Turkish border, conduct land survey operations,
determine the coordinates of certain locations, pinpoint targets
using satellites, and report the information back to their countries?"

"Is there a connection between the units airlifted around Cukurca and
Senoba and the sham US inspection of the Makhmur Camp? Conversely,
is the United States trying to mollify Turkey?"

Now let me make a few additions. Were US troops and peshmergas
airlifted with helicopters to a location near the Zap River two nights
ago? Land survey operations are under way in the region. Some people
need to answer certain questions. It is not just the Turkish-Iraq
border. What is the purpose of the border measurements and land survey
operations conducted by the United States and Israel from Iraq as
far as the Armenian border? Are these reports true or false? Why as
far as the Armenian border?

The northern Iraqi side of Turkey’s border with Iraq is being
fortified with missiles. Why are these heavy weapons moving to these
areas? Why are peshmerga units and US troops deployed in regions near
the border? For what purpose are peshmergas given satellite control
over these regions with technical support from Israel and the United
States? Why are high-technology satellite devices being installed
in these regions? If this continues, Turkey cannot intervene in the
region even if it wants to. Are some circles scheming to start a war
between Turks and Kurds? Or are there other scenarios?

There was only one question that Joseph W. Ralston, the PKK coordinator
of the United States, should have been asked when he came to Ankara:
What is the purpose of this military build-up and preparations? What
is the purpose of these weapon deliveries and against whom will they
be used?

It seems that there is nothing we can do. We have to wait until these
allegations are published in US or British media.

"Ways Of Armenia" Exhibition To Open In Paris

"WAYS OF ARMENIA" EXHIBITION TO OPEN IN PARIS

ArmRadio.am
12.02.2007 12:51

The collection of the Armenian Museum of France will be exhibited
February 28-April 22. after a break of 14 years the collection of
this Paris museum will be presented to the broad society as part of
the Year of Armenia in France.

About 500 items of the museum founded in 1949 will picture various
sides of the three thousand years of Armenian cultural history. The
main objective of the museum is to preserve the cultural legacy for
generations to come. Part of Armenian manuscripts of the museum are
currently on display in Louvre. The collection includes pictures
by Edgar Shahin, Grigor Shldyan, Arshak Fetvachyan, Jasmine, Sargis
Khachatryan, Panos Terlemezyan, Zakar Zakaryan, Hovhannes Ayvazovski
and others.

BAKU: Visiting US Defence Official, Azeri Minister Discuss Karabakh,

VISITING US DEFENCE OFFICIAL, AZERI MINISTER DISCUSS KARABAKH, TIES

Day.az website, Baku
12 Feb 07

Azerbaijani Defence Minister Safar Abiyev has met Peter Rodman, the
US assistant secretary of defence for international security affairs.

"The time has come to decisively demand that Armenia, which has
violated norms of international law and occupied Azerbaijani
territories, pull out of the captured lands," the minister said.

Abiyev said that neither the talks conducted between the Azerbaijani
and Armenian presidents, Ilham Aliyev and Robert Kocharyan, nor
the efforts of the co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group to resolve the
Nagornyy Karabakh conflict peacefully have yielded positive results
so far.

Rodman said that the USA supports Azerbaijan’s sovereignty, territorial
integrity and independence.

The sides also discussed Azerbaijan’s relations with NATO and the
USA. Aliyev said that he wanted the Minsk Group co-chairs to intensify
their efforts to resolve the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict peacefully.

Rodman, who is in Baku on a visit, will also meet Azerbaijani Foreign
Minister Elmar Mammadyarov today, said Tahir Tagizada, the head of
the ministry’s press and information policy department.

Biggest Exhibition Of S.Parajanov’s Works To Open At Higher Art Acad

BIGGEST EXHIBITION OF S.PARAJANOV’S WORKS TO OPEN AT HIGHER ART ACADEMY OF PARIS

Noyan Tapan
Feb 12 2007

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 12, NOYAN TAPAN. The "Glorious Parajanov" biggest
exhibition will open on February 12 at the Higher Art Academy of
Paris. Armenian great artist Sergey Parajanov’s 72 works will be
presented there. It will last till April 8 after what the works will
be moved to the Modern Art Museum Saint Etienne where they will be
exhibited from April 25 to May 20. Zaven Sargsian, the S.Parajanov’s
Museum Director informed the Noyan Tapan correspondent about it. In the
museum director’s words, different exhibitions presenting S.Parajanov’s
heritage opened and continue being opened in different cities within
the framework of events of the Year of Armenia in France. "The year
of Armenia in France is an excellent possibility for the French
spectators to get acquainted or to remember works of cinematography,
painting, finally of the great philosopher which gave the brightest
colours to exhibitions of the Year of Armenia to France," Zaven
Sargsian said. The first of the exhibitions opened on January 9 in the
Cinemateque of Toulouse, presenting great master’s 30 film sketches
and illustrations to staged performances. The festival of Parajanov’s
films to be held in Boubini suburb of Paris on March 9-25 will also
be accompanied by the exhibition of canvases painted by him. Films
of Tarkovski, Fellini, Pasolini established spiritual sincerity with
Armenian directors will also be presented besides the master’s films
during those days. A retrospective show of Parajanov’s films will
be held. The French side also prepares for publication of a 170-page
big illustrated book dedicated to Parajanov.

Armenian Boxing Youth Championship To Start On February 13

ARMENIAN BOXING YOUTH CHAMPIONSHIP TO START ON FEBRUARY 13

Noyan Tapan
Feb 12 2007

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 12, NOYAN TAPAN. Armenian Boxing Youth Championship
will start on February 13 at Yerevan’s Dinamo sport hall. 157 sportsmen
of 13 weight categories will take part in the championship. The
winners will become known on February 17. As Noyan Tapan was informed
by principal coach of Armenian national team, honorable trainer
Febia Alexanian, the championship is of elimination character. The
national team to be formed by the results of the championship will
hold teaching and training gatherings in Yerevan, Tsakhkadzor and
Moscow. And in June the national team will leave for Hungary to take
part in Europe Youth Championship.

Armenian Judoists Receive No Medals In Paris

ARMENIAN JUDOISTS RECEIVE NO MEDALS IN PARIS

Noyan Tapan
Feb 12 2007

PARIS, FEBRUARY 12, NOYAN TAPAN. A regular tour of Judo World
Supercup ended on February 11 in Paris. Hovhannes Davtian (60 kg,
Gyumri) among four Armenian judoists shared 5-6th places. Another
three Armenian sportsmen, including Armen Nazarian, medal-winner at
previous four championships of Europe, were not among the first six
participants. Tournament’s next tour will be held on February 22-25
in the German city of Hamburg.