ANKARA: Despite ups and downs, Turkish-Israeli ties strengthening

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 15 2007

Despite ups and downs, Turkish-Israeli ties still strengthening

"It is like a smokescreen. While criticizing Israel over Tel Aviv’s
approval of construction near a disputed holy site in Jerusalem,
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoðan also talked about the
peace that should prevail between Palestinians and Israel. While
Erdoðan created the image of a chilly reception to Israel’s Prime
Minister Ehud Olmert just ahead of his visit to Ankara Wednesday
evening, he also gave signals of a strong Turkish interest in playing
a role in the Middle East peace," said a senior Turkish diplomat.
It is true that Turkish-Israeli relations have been witnessing ups
and downs since the Islamic-based conservative Justice and
Development Party (AK Party) government came to power in November
2002, at least at the level of rhetoric. In real life, however, we
witness real politics at work in relations between the regions’ two
non-Arab countries.
Evidence of this is the ongoing military and trade ties between the
two.
As of 2005, Israel became Turkey’s largest trade partner in the
Middle East. Israeli imports to Turkey $900 million and Israel earned
$1.2 billion from Turkish exports to Israel
In the News Blaze daily, journalist Calev Ben-David outlines both the
economic and the military agreements signed between the two countries
since the AK Party came to power in 2002. They vary from cooperation
in water projects, agro-technology, Israel becoming a possible
transit route via Turkey for Black Sea-Red Sea gas, oil and water
pipelines to Ankara brokering the first official talks between Israel
and Pakistan in Ýstanbul in 2005.
Additionally, Turkish-Israeli military cooperation continues in every
sphere, from cooperation in intelligence sharing, mutual high-level
visits to joint arms production.
It was no coincidence that back in 2002 and in 2005 then-Turkish
Chief of General Staff Gen. Hilmi Özkök and Turkish Air Force
Commander Gen. Faruk Cömert paid unpublicized visits to Israel. Both
sought increased cooperation in intelligence sharing concerning the
Middle East.
But unlike what the Arabs think, despite the value attached to the
military cooperation with Israel, the Turkish military does not allow
Israel to hold joint exercises with Ankara that will involve
live-fire tests. It also doesn’t agree to turn the trilateral
(Turkey, US, Israel) navy exercises, code-named Reliant Mermaid, to
extend its operations from the current search and rescue to war
games, which was told to me by a retired navy officer who was among
the team initiating the Turkish-Israeli military and defense industry
cooperation in 1996 and 1997.
It is also worth mentioning that Turkey’s powerful armed forces have
been standing as an important driving force in boosting
Turkish-Israeli military ties.
In the meantime, it is not expected that a pending meeting between
the visiting Turkish Chief of General Staff Gen. Yaþar Büyükanýt and
Rep. Tom Lantos, head of the US House of Representatives Committee on
Foreign Affairs and a pro-Israel congressman, would make a serious
contribution to prevent the Armenian genocide resolution from being
passed by Congress some time in April, but it is for sure that
Büyükanýt is expected to considerably ease concerns of the strong
Jewish lobby that Turkish-Israeli military ties will continue as
usual.
With the Republicans having lost control of Congress, Turkey has got
a strong Jewish lobby in its hands that could play its card to stop
the Armenian genocide resolution from being passed, although the
Jewish lobby’s involvement is reportedly inadequate to prevent the
adoption of the resolution.
Meanwhile, we should also realize that Turkey as a Muslim nation has
never been indifferent to the fellow Palestinians’ grievances in the
region. Thus, it would be wrong to assume that under the AK Party
government, the future of Turkish-Israeli relations were questioned.

It was not only Erdoðan who branded, rightly or wrongly, Israeli
actions against the Palestinians as a state terrorism, but also the
late Prime Minister Bülent Ecevit, back in 2002, who described the
Israeli army’s attacks against Palestinians as genocide.
But at the end of the day both Turkey and Israel, the only democratic
nations in the Middle East, can help democracy flourish in the region
if they join forces, regardless of ups and downs in their relations
depending on the conjuncture.

Armenia report TBD at joint meeting of FATF, MoneyVal in Strasbourg

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Feb 14 2007

ARMENIA’S REPORT TO BE DISCUSSED AT JOINT MEETING OF FATF, MONEYVAL
IN STRASBOURG

YEREVAN, February 14. /ARKA/. Armenia’s report is to be discussed at
the joint meeting of FATF and MONEYVAL in the CE Headquarters in
Strasbourg on February 21-23.
The CE press office reported that about 400 leading experts from all
over the world will participate in the first joint meeting of
Financial Action Task Force (FATF) and the Committee of Experts on
the Evaluation of Anti-Money Laundering Measures (MONEYVAL).
The event is held to strengthen the international cooperation in the
fight against money laundering and terrorism financing. In
particular, the meeting participants will discuss the FATF report on
Turkey and the evaluation report of MONEYVAL on Georgia, as well as
the report made by Cyprus. MONEYVAL will also discuss the report of
Armenia and Azerbaijan, the press release says.
Issues on abuses in VAT system and the problem of money laundering in
the South Africa are also on the agenda.
The CE Secretary-General Terry Davis will open the meeting. The Head
of FATF Frank Sverdlov, the Chairman of MONEYVAL Vasil Kirov and the
CE General Director for Legal Issues Philippe Buayatte will give
press conferences.
46 CE countries are members of MONEYVAL. FATF has 33 country-members.
N.V. -0–

ANKARA: General vows to counter attempts to divide Turkey

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 15 2007

Büyükanýt vows to counter attempts to divide Turkey

Turkey’s top military commander has vowed to forcefully counter any
attempts at the division of Turkey. "As long as the dynamic forces
exist, those who dream of dividing Turkey will wake up to a
nightmare," Büyükanýt told a meeting of Turks living in the United
States during a visit.

"They will get their lesson. We must have faith in this. No one can
dare to divide Turkey." Büyükanýt did not name any specific sources
threatening the division of Turkey but his comments were interpreted
as targeting the outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and Iraqi
Kurds. The PKK has bases in the mountains of northern Iraq and Turkey
is pressing the United States and Iraq to take measures to deal with
the problem.

The government has recently intensified it rhetoric, saying Turkey
might consider a cross-border operation into Iraq if its demands for
action against the PKK go unheeded.
Ankara is also worried about the fate of Kirkuk, the disputed
oil-rich city in northern Iraq which is home to an ethnically-mixed
population of Turkmens, Kurds and Arabs. Turkish officials say a
referendum on status of the city, slated for the end of this year,
should be postponed because Kurds have migrated to the city over the
past few years in what Ankara sees as a systematic effort to change
the demographic structure of Kirkuk ahead of the vote.
Büyükanýt said the problems of the PKK presence in Iraq and the issue
of protecting Iraq’s territorial integrity were interrelated. He
added Turkey should go ahead with a `consistent and future-looking’
policy while it deals with those problems.
The top military commander was expected to raise Turkey’s concerns
with the situation in Iraq in talks with US Vice President Dick
Cheney and Stephen Hadley, the national security advisor for
President George W. Bush.
Büyükanýt’s visit to the United States comes just days after Foreign
Minister Abdullah Gül voiced Turkish concerns during a week-long
visit. The United States has appointed a special envoy in charge of
coordinating US efforts to counter the PKK threat, but Prime Minister
Recep Tayyip Erdoðan expressed unease about the measure, saying it
has not produced visible outcomes.

Serious threats
In a speech frequently interrupted by cheers, Büyükanýt also
reiterated that Turkey was faced with serious problems and threats
stemming from instability in its region, citing the volatile
situation in Iraq, the Caucasus and Cyprus.
`As I said before, the Republic of Turkey has never faced threats,
risks and difficulties of this magnitude since 1923,’ the date of the
republic’s founding, said Büyükanýt. `Turkey has never had that many
problems at the same time since its founding.’
He urged the nation not to lose faith. `We have fears that we need to
overcome. Who can divide Turkey?’ he said.
He also said Turkish democracy and secularism would remain intact.
`Turkey is a democratic, secular and unified state. There is and will
be no power that can change this.’
Büyükanýt is also expected to raise the issue of an Armenian
resolution in the US Congress in his talks with US officials. The
House of Representatives is expected to vote on the resolution soon
which urges the US administration to recognize Armenian genocide
claims.
He said the resolution saddened Turkey but added that he would not
start a `polemic’ by pledging retaliation. `We as the Turkish Armed
Forces do not talk like that. We work together with the United
States,’ he said. `But I believe the citizens of the United States
would avoid moves that would hurt Turkey.’

Scientific reforms in Armenia need revision

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Feb 14 2007

SCIENTIFIC REFORMS IN ARMENIA NEED REVISION

YEREVAN, February 14. /ARKA/. The concept of scientific reforms in
Armenia needs revision, said Radik Martirosyan, the President of the
RA National Academy of Sciences, presenting the concept of scientific
reforms and the Government’s 2007-2010 development program.
"The concept of reforms in the Armenian science sector needs
revision. Today, in this concept there exist certain flaws and norms,
with which not all the interested authorities agree," he said.
According to the concept and the 2007-2010 program, it is proposed by
2010 to finish the elaboration and adoption of laws and by-laws on
the scientific development.
A special inter-departmental commission of four working groups has
been set up to work on the above-mentioned documents.
Martirosyan said that the working groups operate in the spheres of
reforming legislative field, finding approaches to financing science,
elaborating priority directions for scientific works and conducting
independent expert examinations.
RA President Robert Kocharyan and RA Minister of Education and
Science Levon Lazarian adopted the decision of implementing
scientific reforms in Armenia on July 24, 2006.
On August 18, the RA Government approved the rule of events under the
reforms program. On November 15, 2006, the Concept of scientific
reforms was brought up for public discussions. L.M. -0–

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Turkey aide foresees revisions to Article 301

International Herald Tribune, France
Feb 15 2007

Turkey aide foresees revisions to Article 301

By Dan Bilefsky Published: February 15, 2007

BRUSSELS: Turkey plans to revise a controversial law that makes
insulting Turkishness a crime by the end of this year, Ankara’s chief
European Union negotiator said Thursday.

The law – Article 301 of the Turkish penal code – has resulted in
prosecutions against leading Turkish intellectuals, including the
Nobel author Orhan Pamuk and Hrant Dink, an Armenian- Turkish
journalist killed last month in Istanbul.

Ali Babacan, a leading member of the governing Justice and
Development Party and a minister in the cabinet, said the law was
causing harm to Turkey.

Asked if Ankara would abandon the law, he said: "That is not going to
happen. Article 301 will stay." But he said the government was
looking at ways to change the way the law was being implemented and
said his hope was that it could be altered before elections in
November.

Turkish analysts said such a change would most likely entail
narrowing the legal definition of what constitutes an insult to
Turkishness and amending the law to make it compatible with the
European Court of Human Rights.

"As a government, we have indicated we are not happy with what is
going on in Turkey with regard to that law," Babacan said. "When
novelists, columnists and Nobel Prize winners go back and forth from
the courtroom, this is not good for Turkey."

The European Commission, the EU’s executive branch, has been
particularly concerned by the law, which attracted global criticism
last year when Pamuk was put on trial for telling a Swiss newspaper
that more than a million Armenians were massacred by Ottoman Turks
during World War I. Critics of the law also say that it contributed
to a nationalistic political climate in Turkey that led to the murder
of Dink, an outspoken proponent of free speech who had criticized the
law.

"A strong signal is needed to change the way the law is being
implemented," Babacan said.

He said Turkey was going through a difficult period in its relations
with the EU following the decision late last year by Union leaders to
partially suspend entry negotiations over Ankara’s refusal to open
its ports to Cyprus, an EU member. Babacan said the intensifying
animosity toward Turkey in Europe was making headlines in Turkey and
risked spurring an anti-EU backlash.

"There has been severe damage to the credibility of the EU process in
Turkish eyes," he said. "Until now the question was when is Turkey
going to be ready for the EU. But after the events of 2006, what will
be more important is whether the EU will be ready for Turkey."

Babacan said that despite the EU’s decision to freeze Turkey’s EU
talks in eight areas, including some trade matters, Ankara was
progressing in other areas like economic and monetary policy. But he
said that there had been little if any progress on the Cyprus issue.
The northern part of the island is controlled by a government
recognized by Ankara but not the EU.

"We are trying everything we can do to find a way out," he said. "But
we have made so many gestures and we are seeing no reciprocity."

Babacan added that Ankara believed that Cyprus was intent on
prolonging the crisis because it had no interest in seeing Turkey
gain the economic and political privileges of EU membership.

ANCA: Support Growing for Armenian Genocide Resolution

Armenian National Committee of America
1711 N Street NW
Washington, DC 20036
Tel. (202) 775-1918
Fax. (202) 775-5648
Email [email protected]
Internet

PRESS RELEASE
February 15, 2007
Contact: Elizabeth S. Chouldjian
Tel: (202) 775-1918

SUPPORT GROWING FOR ARMENIAN GENOCIDE RESOLUTION

— Over 175 Representatives from Thirty-Four U.S. States
Already Cosponsoring Human Rights Legislation

WASHINGTON, DC – Bipartisan support for the adoption of the
Armenian Genocide Resolution, H.Res.106, continues to grow, with
new cosponsors joining this measure over the past week from
Colorado, Georgia, Maine, Minnesota, Oregon, and Texas, reported
the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA).

Over the past week, more than a dozen new U.S. Representatives have
cosponsored the resolution, among them: Diana DeGette (D-CO),
Keith Ellison (D-MN), Gene Green (D-TX), Jane Harman (D-CA), Henry
"Hank" Johnson (D-GA), Doug Lamborn (R-CO), Kenny Marchant (R-TX),
Kevin McCarthy (R-CA), Jerry McNerney (D-CA), Michael Michaud (D-
ME), Nydia Velazquez (D-NY), James Walsh (R-NY), and David Wu (D-
OR). All told, the more than 175 cosponsors for the anti-genocide
measure have come from thirty-four states and the District of
Columbia.

Speaking at a Capitol Hill press conference last month, Congressmen
Adam Schiff (D-CA), George Radanovich (R-CA) and Congressional
Armenian Caucus Co-Chairs Frank Pallone (D-NJ) and Joe Knollenberg
(R-MI) joined together in announcing the introduction of the
Armenian Genocide Resolution. Joining with the four legislators as
original cosponsors of the Armenian Genocide Resolution (H.Res.106)
were Congressmen Brad Sherman (D-CA) and Thaddeus McCotter (R-MI),
both strong supporters of Armenian Genocide recognition as well as
senior members of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, the
influential panel which will first consider this legislation prior
to a vote on the House floor.

The resolution is identical to legislation introduced in the
previous session of Congress, which was overwhelmingly approved in
the International Relations Committee (now called the Foreign
Affairs Committee), only to be blocked from final passage by the
House leadership.

In a related matter, Rep. Joseph Crowley (D-NY) this week
reintroduced legislation honoring the memory of outspoken slain
journalist Hrant Dink, calling on Turkey to repeal Article 301 of
its penal code, an anti-free speech law under which Dink was
prosecuted and convicted for "insulting Turkishness". This new
resolution is similar to H.Res.102, which the New York legislator
introduced on January 29th, except that the revised text,
H.Res.155, removes mention of the Armenian Genocide.

"We appreciate Congressman’s Crowley’s intentions in honoring Hrant
Dink’s memory, but are troubled by the removal of any mention of
the Armenian Genocide in his revised and newly reintroduced
legislation," said Aram Hamparian, Executive Director of the ANCA.
"As Americans, we neither accurately nor appropriately pay tribute
to Hrant Dink’s proud legacy if we do not openly and honestly honor
his struggle – witnessed by all the world – to end Turkey’s denial
of the Armenian Genocide, a struggle for which he paid the ultimate
price."

"The circumstances surrounding this resolution’s reintroduction –
namely the continued heavy-handed pressure by the Turkish
government against any mention of the Armenian Genocide – clearly
speak to the pressing need for the passage of the Armenian Genocide
Resolution," added Hamparian.

Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Joseph Biden (D-DE)
introduced similar legislation in the Senate on February 1st. His
measure refers to the criminal prosecution Dink faced because of
his speech on the Armenian Genocide. Hrant Dink, editor of the
bilingual Armenian/Turkish "Agos" newspaper, was gunned down
outside his office in Istanbul on January 19th – sparking worldwide
protests and renewed scrutiny of Turkey’s repression of free speech
and international campaign of Armenian Genocide denial.

In another related development, Rep. Frank Pallone, in a February
13th statement on the House floor, condemned Turkish government
threats to cut off U.S. supply routes to American troops serving in
Iraq if the Armenian Genocide legislation is even considered by
Congress. Rep. Pallone stressed that, "such a brazen threat to
interfere in U.S. military operations is absolutely unacceptable.
I am outraged that the Turkish government would put the lives of
soldiers at risk in the pursuit of its desperate campaign to deny
the systematic slaughter of 1.5 million Armenians. This extremist
behavior is known as blackmail and it should be publicly and
forcefully rejected as such. Clearly, Turkey is no friend of the
U.S."

www.anca.org

ANKARA: Mass grave outside of Mardin to be opened by intl delegation

Hürriyet
Friday, February 16, 2007

Mass grave outside of Mardin to be opened by international delegation

Assertions made in an article in the Turkish magazine "Nokta" last year that
mass Armenian graves could be found in the town of Nusaybin outside of the
city of Mardin were taken up by Swedish professor David Gaunt, who then
brought these assertions to the attention of the Swedish Parliament.

Gaunt’s accusations have elicited a response from the head of the Turkish
History Foundation (TTK), Professor Yusuf Halacoglu, who has invited all
interested parties to come to Turkey and participate together in an opening
up the gravesite in question. Professor Halacoglu, who subsequently received
an affirmative answer from Professor Gaunt, said the following regarding the
situation:

"Professor Gaunt has said that he would be pleased to cooperate in the
opening up of the gravesite in the Mardin area town of Nusaybin. However, he
has some preconditions: During digging, he wants complete freedom in the
region. In addition, he is requesting the opportunity to speak with anyone
in the area who claims to know something about these mass graves….We have
naturally accepted all of these demands. In fact, we have said that we are
prepared to meet any needs that his delegation may have while in Turkey. We
suggested that March would be a good time, as the weather would be perfect.
Now we are waiting for the confirmation that they will in fact come."
Professor Halacoglu noted that if the mass grave in question does in fact
turn out to hold the bodies of Armenians and/or Suryanis, he will be
prepared to apologize in a public press conference, but if not, he is
expecting that Professor Gaunt will apologize.

AYF-WR Now Accepting "Nanor Krikorian" Scholarship Applications

Armenian Youth Federation – Western United States
104 N. Belmont St. Suite 206 Glendale, CA 91206
Tel. (818) 507-1933 * Fax. (818) 240-3442 * [email protected]

PRESS RELEASE
2-10-2007
Contact: Mary Ashdjian – 818.507.1933

AYF-WR Now Accepting "Nanor Krikorian" Scholarship Applications

The Armenian Youth Federation Western Region (AYF-WR) is now accepting
applications for the `Nanor Krikorian’ Scholarship.

All high school seniors of Armenian decent who will be attending a
college or university are encouraged to apply for the scholarship.
The scholarship not only looks at how well the student did in their
high school career, but it also focuses on community service and extra
curricular activities that help benefit the Armenian community.

Seven applicants will receive a scholarship totaling $3,500.

`The scholarship is now in its fifth year of existence and each year
the amount of applications received has increased’ said Saro Haroun,
chairperson of the AYF-WR Central Educational Committee.

The scholarship is named after a young AYF activist, Nanor Krikorian,
whose life was cut short by cancer.

You may download the application by visiting The
deadline is April 1, 2007

The Armenian Youth Federation of Western United States strives to
serve Armenian American Communities west of the Mississippi through
education, athletics, political activism, cultural activities and
social settings.

For further questions please do not hesitate to contact our offices at
818.507.1933

####

www.ayfwest.org.

Massis Weekly Online – Volume 27, NO. 4 (1304)

Massis Weekly Online

VOLUME 27, NO. 4 (1304)
SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 17, 2007

—————
— Private TVs Stations Set Artificially High Prices For Campaign Ads
— Youth Wings of Opposition Parties Sign a Statement of Cooperation
— Armenia’s Hunchakian Party Youth Address Embassy’s Inability to
Protect Armenians in Russia
— Armenian Community of Louisiana Mobilized for Passage of HR 106
— City of Los Angeles Calls on the Government To Recognize The
Armenian Genocide
— Italian Produced Armenian Genocide Documentary ?The Lark Farm?
Featured at the Berlin Film Festival
— Vazgen Manukyan Attends Round Table Forum
— Near East Foundation Elects First Chair Of Armenian Ancestry In 91
Year History

—————
– Private TVs Stations Set Artificially High Prices For Campaign Ads

Armenia?s leading private broadcasters under pressure form the regime
have set artificially high prices for political advertisements to be
aired during the unfolding election campaign. Opposition leaders have
claimed the prohibitive cost of such adverts is aimed at effectively
barring opposition parties from using the electronic media in the
run-up to the May parliamentary elections. Armenian law guarantees
them only 60 minutes of free airtime on state television and 120
minutes on state radio.
?The prices were set for progovernment parties,? said Grigor
Harutiunian, a leading member of the People?s Party of Armenia. ?Only
political forces with dirty money can afford them.?
?They are driving us to the streets,? warned Smbat Ayvazian of the
radical Hanrapetutyun party.
Some representatives of the governing coalition agreed that the
campaign ad rates, varying from 80,000 drams to 130,000 drams ($365)
per minute, are disproportionately high for a country like Armenia.
In another blow to the opposition, it emerged on Tuesday that 18 out
of the 29 local TV stations across Armenia have mysteriously decided
not to run any pre-election advertising. Opposition politicians and
some media experts believe that this will not keep them from promoting
pro-government candidates in their news programs.
The opposition complaints, meanwhile, were echoed by a top
representative of Reporters Sans Frontiers (RSF), a Paris-based media
watchdog. ?It?s a very crude way of preventing an opponent from
addressing the country?s population,? Elsa Vidal, the RSF director for
Europe and the former Soviet Union, told RFE/RL.
?It?s old and useless method. It just underlines that the authorities
are afraid,? charged Vidal.

– Youth Wings of Opposition Parties Sign a Statement of Cooperation

Led by the Social Democrat Hunchakian Party ?Sarkis Dkhrouni? youth
and student union, the youth wings of seven opposition political
parties signed a statement of cooperate, pledging to use all their
resources to ensure a free and fair parliamentary election this coming
May.
The youth wings set aside difference of ideology in hopes of
establishing a truly democratic republic, represented by the people,
and not oligarchical system. ?We have not gathered here to decide
whether to tend to the needs of Russia or to the USA. We have a
greater problem facing our country and
Armenian Nation as a whole?, mentioned author of the initiative, head
of ?Sargis Tkhrouni? youth union Narek Galstyan. ?A transparent
democratic system is imperative for the people of the country to
address the needs and concerns of the people.? Galstyan continued.
The statement authored by the Social Democrat Hunchakian Party ?Sarkis
Dkhrouni? youth union was signed by the representatives of the youth
wings of ?New Times? Party, National League of Young Democrats,
Armenian Pan-National Movement, ?Republic? Party, National Democratic
Alliance, and National Self-Determination Union. They expect other
parties and NGOs to also sign the statement of cooperate in the near
future.

Armenia’s Hunchakian Party Youth Address Embassy’s Inability to
Protect Armenians in Russia

The ?Sarkis Dkhrouni? youth and student association of the
Social-Democrat Hunchakian Party addressed Foreign Minister Vartan
Oskanian in an open letter on Feb. 12 in Yerevan accusing the Armenian
Embassy of indifference towards the hate crimes committed against
local Armenians in Russia.
The letter is a call to action for all representatives of the Embassy
including the Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Armen
Smbatyan. A series of attacks and murders committed against Armenians
has prompted the youth association of the Hunchaks to ask for a more
vigorous actions by the foreign ministry to end the bloodshed through
diplomatic means. The youth stated that the Embassy does not serve its
intended purpose of a diplomatic office, rather it acts as a ?trade
organization.? The open letter also urged the Foreign Ministry of the
Republic of Armenia to be proactive towards the situation rather than
the reactive or in some instances non-active approach towards the
situation.
Commenting on the accusations of negligence and lack of concern,
Smbatyan responded to the ?Sarkis
Dkhruni? youth branch of Huchakian Social-Democratic party in Armenia
stating that every ethnic hate crime is treated with high importance
and swift measures are taken to curtail further instances of such
criminal acts. Additionally, he claims that all crimes are
communicated within the Ministries of Internal and Foreign Affairs and
the Plenipotentiary of Russia.
Although Smbatyan agrees that there might be some dissatisfaction
among the people with the Consul?s services, he is assured that the
Armenian Embassy in Russia does everything possible to protect
Armenians from the violence which has been reported in the media. He
added that the causes of these attacks on Armenians have been cases of
xenophobia and that they are not particularly geared towards Armenians
but to all people living in Russia who are of non-Slavic backgrounds.

– Armenian Community of Louisiana Mobilized for Passage of HR 106

Louisiana branch of the Armenian Council of America strongly urged
members of the Congress from Louisiana to sponsor House Resolution
106. House Resolution 106 calls upon the President to ensure that the
foreign policy of the United States reflects appropriate understanding
and sensitivity concerning issues related to human rights, ethnic
cleansing, and genocide documented in the United States record
relating to the Armenian Genocide.
On February 11, the Armenian Council of America of Louisiana in
cooperation with St. Garabed Armenian Church of Louisiana organized a
signing petition advocating their respective members of congress to
cosponsor the Armenian Genocide resolution H.R. 106, as well as House
Resolution 102; condemning the assassination of human rights advocate
and outspoken defender of freedom of the press, Turkish-Armenian
journalist Hrant Dink on January 19, 2007.
In a letter addressed to the Congressional legislators of Louisiana
accompanied with the petition, Louisiana?s chapter of the Armenian
Council of America stated that the Armenian Genocide is an irrefutable
historical fact and the Armenian Council of America along with
Armenian Americans of Louisiana urge the Congressional representatives
to act insuring the recognition of the Armenian Genocide so that the
cycle of genocide and its denial are ended, and this human tragedy is
never repeated.
Currently only 1 out of the 7 Louisiana Congressmen have signed on to
the current legislation. Due to outside pressure, as well as from the
administration, Representative Bobby Jindal withdrew his
co-sponsorship of H.R. 106.
?Even though at some points it seems to be an uphill battle, we must
continue to strife and persevere for our cause.? stated Vasken
Kaltakdjian, chairman of Armenian Council of America Louisiana
chapter. He emphasized that the Turkish government is also actively
pursuing the legislators. ?We are good friends with Congressman
Jindal, urging him to reconsider his decision and not to succumb to
political threats from the Turkish government and the current
administration.? added Kaltakdjian.
?Currently the Armenian Council of America is actively utilizing its
strengths in advocating members of Congress in regions that are not
known for a history of being proactive for Armenian American issues?
stated Darakjian, Director of the Armenian Council of America.
Armenian Council of America is greatly encouraging Armenian Americans
to contact their respective members of Congress and
urge them to support H.R. 106. ?Louisiana is just one example of the
difficulty that the Armenian American community is facing. Despite
popular belief the Armenian Genocide resolution will not pass without
the support of members of congress that do not have a substantial
constituency of Armenian Americans.? stressed Darakjian.
Currently the support for H.R. 106 has included over 175 members of
the House. Key Congressional supporters include Congressmen Adam
Schiff (DCA), George Radanovich (R-CA) and Congressional Armenian
Caucus Co-Chairs Frank Pallone (D-NJ) and Joe Knollenberg (R-MI).

– City of Los Angeles Calls on the Government To Recognize The
Armenian Genocide

The Los Angeles City Council went on record Wednesday in support of a
proposed federal resolution asking the U.S. government to recognize
the Armenian genocide, which resulted in deaths of 1.5 million people
in 1915.
Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Pasadena, introduced HR 106 on Jan. 30, asking
President Bush to recognize the killings committed by Turkey?s Ottoman
Empire during World War I.
?This crime against humanity succeeded in the elimination of 3,000
years of cultural history in Ottoman, Turkey, and it was something
(Adolf) Hitler cited when he began the Holocaust of the Jews,?
Councilman Eric Garcetti said just before the council unanimously
voted to support the resolution. ?He said, `After all, who remembers
the Armenians???
?These atrocities occurred a long time ago, and we?re still fighting
for the first condition of justice, the recognition of the gravity of
the evil done,? Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa said during a news
conference in front of City Hall. ?It is time we honored the Armenian
people by taking the first step toward justice.?
In other action, the City Council?s Arts, Parks, Health and Aging
Committee agreed that Los Angeles should adopt Yerevan as a sister city.

– Italian Produced Armenian Genocide Documentary ?The Lark Farm?
Featured at the Berlin Film Festival

A film depicting the tragedy of a rich family almost wiped out in the
mass killings of Armenians by Ottoman Turks in 1915 is not meant to be
anti-Turkish, the directors said on Wednesday. Italy?s Taviani
brothers say ?The Lark Farm?, featuring at the Berlin film festival,
has a broad message about the human catastrophe of modern conflict.
Sparing little detail, the drama shows Ottoman Turks decapitating,
castrating and dismembering the men of the Armenian family in front of
their wives and children, who are themselves sent on a punishing
forced march towards the desert.
?This movie is not against Turks,? director Paolo Taviani told Reuters
in an interview, pointing out a Turkish man is instrumental in saving
some of the family?s children. ?It is not the Turks who kill ? it is
the Young Turks ? a political movement. It is exactly the same as what
happened in Italy with the Fascists and in Germany under Nazism.?
At the end of the press screening, the audience sat in stunned silence.
Ahead of the film?s public release, the Taviani brothers said they
were unaware of any adverse reaction from Turkey. Berlin?s Turkish
embassy said it had received no response to the film from Ankara.
Although a love story between an Armenian and Turk is a major part of
the film and some Ottoman soldiers are portrayed as being reluctant to
carry out orders to kill their friends, the focus is firmly on the
suffering of the Armenian family.
?We wanted to comment on current events like Kosovo, and Rwanda,? said
Paolo Taviani?s brother Vittorio. ?We thought we should look at one of
the most horrifying tragedies of mankind
because there is nothing worse than a war between people who know each
other well.?
The brothers say they are sure Turkey should join the EU. ?(But) we
are convinced … of the necessity that it publicly recognizes the
historical truth of the Armenian tragedy, in the same way as Germany
and Italy have come to terms with their criminal past,? they said in a
statement.
Actress Arsinee Khanjian, who plays a major character in ?The
LarkFarm?, says Turkey still has a way to go.?Turkey must change its
approach to theArmenian genocide but it also has big human rights
problems with many other minorities,? the actress of Armenian descent
told Reuters.

– Vazgen Manukyan Attends Round Table Forum

The Social Democrat Hunchakian Party ?Sarkis Dkhrouni? youth and
student union on February 10th continued its series of round table
forums. The panelist of this month?s forum was Mr. Vazgen Manukyan.
Mr. Manukyan was a member of the Karabakh committee and as a result
was arrested in December 1988 along with other members of the Karabakh
committee and spent six months in the Matrosskaya Tishina prison in
Moscow. Mr. Manukyan has served as prime minister and acting defense
minister of the Republic Armenia. Currently he is a member of
parliament and the chairman of the National Democratic Union Party.
The topic of the forum was the independence and establishment of the
Republic of Armenia, and the establishment and development of the
Armenian army.
Mr. Manukyan was able to provide insight of the establishment of the
Armenian Republic and the trials and tribulations associated with it
to the 30 plus young intellectuals of all educational backgrounds
attending the forum. Using specific examples, Mr. Manukyan also
addressed the hardships the Republic went through while he was
Minister of Defense in establishing a viable armed
forces while in the midst of the war of liberation of Artsakh. He also
touched upon reasoning?s and consequences of certain operations during
the war. Mr. Manukyan also thanked the young organizers of the forum,
which he considers a valuable tool for the future intellectuals and
leaders of Armenia.

– Near East Foundation Elects First Chair Of Armenian Ancestry In 91
Year History

As the newly-elected Chair of NEF (Near East Foundation) it is my high
honor to join the leadership ranks of this 91-year-old organization
which has had so profound an impact on me.
As an American of Armenian descent, NEF has brought me in touch with
my past…the past in which many Armenians? like my grandparents?were
saved by orphanages such as those established by Near East Relief
during the aftermath of the Armenian Genocide.
During the five years of my involvement and now as the first Chair of
Armenian ancestry, I feel an obligation to give back to this
organization that has given so much, to so many, over its long history.
Like the men and women who have preceded me in this role, the
challenges are great. Poverty continues to dominate most of the world,
contributing to despair, political instability and resentment. War
rages on in the Middle East and parts of Africa, where long-standing,
unresolved conflicts fester. Genocide has become all too common a
term?and the slogan ?Never Again? has lost its meaning.
Religion still divides rather than unites the peoples of the world.
But never have the challenges barred NEF?s way.
The selfless dedication of NEF?s staff and supporters have always
succeeded in accomplishing a great deal despite limited resources.
Ironically, our past has brought us back to Armenia. I recently
returned from my second trip to further expand NEF?s role and presence
there once again. Given our historical connection, NEF was
enthusiastically received by several Armenian government ministries
and local nongovernmental organizations; we also reintroduced
ourselves to the local offices of USAID and the World Bank. You can
expect to hear more about new NEF programs in Armenia shortly.
NEF also returned to its roots in relief work by responding to the
humanitarian crisis in Lebanon (my birthplace) this past summer. We
have established a microcredit program that promotes the resettlement
of those who were displaced during the recent conflict. In short, the
future holds new and exciting opportunities for NEF.
With our newly-formed subsidiary NEFdev, we are uniquely positioned to
qualify as a small business thereby giving NEF an advantage when
bidding on U.S. government contracts.
As with everything in life, it is our past that makes us what we are
today. What we are today helps shape what we want to become in the
future. What we become in the future is a reminder of who we were in
the past. So may the memory of all those who gave so much before us,
reinvigorate the reasons we all give to this noble cause now. Please
join me as we embark upon NEF?s next phase. There is much work to be
done.
Shant Mardirossian

—
Massis Weekly Online
MassisWeekly.com
1060 N. Allen Ave, Suite 203
Pasadena, CA 91104
Tel. 626.797.7680
Fax. 626.797.6863

http://MassisWeekly.com

Radioactive, unprotected: A `dirty bomb’ nightmare

-0702150125feb15,1,6578821.story?coll=3Dchi-news-h ed

Radioactive, unprotected: A `dirty bomb’ nightmare
Soviet-era nuclear material is a target for smugglers willing to sell to
anyone
By Alex Rodriguez
Tribune foreign correspondent

February 15, 2007

YEREVAN, Armenia — Jobless for two years, Gagik Tovmasyan believed
escape from poverty lay in a cardboard box on his kitchen floor.

Inside the box, a blue, lead-lined vessel held the right type and
amount of radioactive cesium to make a "dirty bomb." The material was
given to him by an unemployed Armenian Catholic priest who promised a
cut if Tovmasyan could find a buyer.

He found one in 2004, but the man turned out to be an undercover
agent. Tovmasyan spent a year behind bars on a charge of illegally
storing and trying to sell 4 grams of cesium-137.

Today the chain-smoking Armenian cabdriver says his actions amounted
to simple survival. "That’s just the way it was back then," said
Tovmasyan, 48, who insisted he had no idea of the danger the material
presented. "I was selling all my belongings just to get by."

At a time when the U.S. is grappling with the specter of nuclear
weapons in North Korea and Iran, security experts warn that a vast
supply of radioactive materials–enough to make hundreds of so-called
dirty bombs–lies virtually unprotected in former Soviet military
bases and ruined factories.

Desperately poor scavengers looking for scrap metal already have
raided many of those sites, fueling an ever-growing concern in the war
on terrorism.

There were 662 confirmed cases of radioactive materials smuggling
around the world from 1993 to 2004, according to the International
Atomic Energy Agency. More than 400 involved substances that could be
used to make a dirty bomb, a weapon that would spew radioactivity
across a broad area. Experts say even these alarming numbers do not
reflect the magnitude of the smuggling.

The risk has grown despite tens of millions of dollars spent by the
United States to provide radiation detection equipment and security
training in former Soviet republics. Tracking how the money is spent
by opaque, often-corrupt governments has proved especially difficult.

The problem is wider in scope than often acknowledged, and the stakes
are enormous: It takes only a few grams of a deadly radioactive
substance suchas cesium-137 or strontium-90 to make a dirty bomb.

Along Russia’s barren, jagged coastline on the Barents Sea, enough
strontium-90 to make hundreds of dirty bombs can be found in dozens of
unguarded lighthouses and navigational beacons. In Semipalatinsk in
eastern Kazakhstan, once the site of Soviet nuclear weapons testing,
scavengers routinely slip through breaches in tunnels where poorly
secured strontium-90, cesium-137, plutonium and uranium waste is
stored alongside scrap metal, the site’s director says.

In the small mountainous republic of Georgia, the director of a former
Soviet laboratory in the breakaway province of Abkhazia says
separatist leaders have prevented IAEA inspectors from adequately
surveying the institute, where stockpiles of uranium, cesium-137,
strontium-90 and other radioactive materials cannot be accounted for.

Many cases undetected

Many former Soviet republics do a poor job of maintaining reliable
inventories of radioactive material, according to Lyudmila Zaitseva, a
radioactive materials trafficking researcher at the University of
Salzburg in Austria. Former Soviet borders are porous, and corruption
is rife at border guard posts.

When it comes to protecting radioactive materials, the countries that
once made up the Soviet Union are "the weakest and most dangerous link
in the whole chain," said Igor Khripunov, a U.S.-based expert in
nuclear and radioactive materials security at the University of
Georgia.

Zaitseva and her research colleague Friedrich Steinhausler, who log
radioactive materials trafficking cases into a database at the
University of Salzburg, estimate that roughly 3 of every 5 cases of
radioactive materials smuggling go undetected. "I am far more
concerned with what we don’t see than with what we see," Steinhausler
said.

The U.S. government has been slow to gird its ports and border
checkpoints with enough detection capability to prevent smuggled
radioactive materials from entering the country. In December 2005,
congressional investigators smuggled enough cesium-137 across
U.S. checkpoints on the Canadian and Mexican borders to produce two
dirty bombs, according to a 2006 Government Accountability Office
report.

Testifying before a Senate homeland security subcommittee in March,
GAO officials said they doubted that the Department of Homeland
Security couldhit its deadline of placing more than 3,000 radiation
detectors at border crossings, seaports and mail facilities by
2009. It was likelier, said the GAO’s Eugene Aloise, that the
department would not finish until 2014.

"Four and a half years after Sept. 11, and less than 40 percent of our
seaports have basic radiation equipment," said Sen. Norm Coleman
(R-Minn.), the subcommittee chairman at the time during a
congressional hearing last March. "This is a massive blind spot."

Lure for terrorists

No one has ever detonated a dirty bomb, but terrorists have made it
clear they have the means and desire to do so.

In November 1995, Chechen separatists buried a canister of cesium-137
under the snow in Moscow’s Izmailovo Park and told a Russian
television network where to find it. Last year, a British court
sentenced Dhiren Barot, a London resident linked to Al Qaeda, to 40
years in prison for planning a series of terrorist attacks in London
and the U.S. that would have included a dirty bomb.

In the dense stands of birch and pine in Russia’s far north, special
generators used to power lighthouses represent one of the most
vulnerable sources of material. Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generators
create electricity through the decay of strontium-90. A single RTG can
house enough strontium-90 for 40 dirty bombs.

Russia has more than 600 RTGs scattered across its 11 time zones.
Lighthouses and navigational beacons equipped with them are largely
unguarded, at times lacking even a chain-link fence for protection.

In the Murmansk and Arkhangelsk regions along the Barents coastline,
scrap metal hunters have broken into six RTGs in recent years, said
Vladimir Kozlovsky, a local official involved in a Russian-Norwegian
project to replace the aging RTGs with safer technology.

In March, scrap metal hunters broke into a deserted military base
above the Arctic Circle and ripped apart four RTGs, according to
Bellona, a Norwegian environmental watchdog organization.

While there are no reports of strontium being taken from an RTG, the
scavenging highlights the risks.

Radioactive materials transported in Russia by rail are also
alarmingly vulnerable.

Last year Greenpeace activists staked out a train depot in a village
near St. Petersburg, Russia, to monitor trainloads of uranium from
Western Europe that had been stopping on their way to Siberia for
disposal.

50,000 tons shipped yearly

"There were no police, no guards, no armed personnel around," said
Greenpeace activist Georgy Timofeyev. "The first time we noticed this
in May, we called authorities. They said, `If there aren’t any guards,
then there’s no danger.’

"But anyone can walk up and open them because there are no serious
locks on the containers," Timofeyev said.

Greenpeace activists say Russian authorities confirmed that the
shipments were being handled by Izotop, a state-owned nuclear
materials transport company. The firm handles roughly 50,000 tons of
nuclear material shipped through St. Petersburg each year, according
to Bellona. Izotop officials declined to comment.

In Kazakhstan, once a hub for Soviet nuclear production and research
because of its remoteness in the steppes of Central Asia, vast
networks of tunnels and boreholes used for nuclear weapons testing
pose a unique problem.

For four decades, the treeless stretches of scrub outside
Semipalatinsk in eastern Kazakhstan served as the Soviet Union’s
ground zero. The Soviet military machine conducted 458 nuclear weapons
tests at the 7,200-square mile site. Most of the blasts occurred in
181 iron-lined tunnels a half-mile below the ground, or in the site’s
60 boreholes.

After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, Kazakhstan
relinquished its entire nuclear arsenal and sealed Semipalatinsk’s
tunnels and boreholes with concrete.

Those seals have failed to deter impoverished Kazakhs, who fashion
propane tanks into makeshift bombs to blast their way into the
tunnels. Their quarry is scrap metal, but local authorities worry that
the vast amounts of strontium, cesium, plutonium and uranium waste
still inside the tunnels could attract those intent on building a
dirty bomb.

"Anyone who wants to make a dirty bomb can target by-products of the
blasts," said Kayrat Kadyrzhanov, director general of the Kazakhstan
National Nuclear Center, which oversees the site. "When test blasts
were done, not all of the particles burned out. Even taking soil
samples would be of value to a terrorist or rogue state.

"When people get into the tunnels, we assume it’s for iron. But that’s
our assumption," Kadyrzhanov said.

Only 4 patrol teams

The U.S. government has given Kazakhstan more than $20 million to seal
up tunnel and borehole entrances, Kadyrzhanov said, "but the problem
is still there." Kazakh authorities deploy only four patrol
teams–made up of a local police officer, a radiation detector
specialist and a driver–to cover 181 tunnels and a tract of steppe
the size of New Jersey.

"The scrap hunters are well-equipped," Kadyrzhanov said. "They’ve got
cell phones and warn each other about approaching patrols."

Radioactive flotsam left behind by the Soviets in Georgia is just as
worrisome. Canisters of cesium-137 and other radioactive materials
have been routinely found at abandoned military bases, research
laboratories–even in farmhouses, according to nuclear safety
specialists with the Georgian government.

Last summer, inspectors found cesium-137 amid a pile of nuts and bolts
in a soap container at a farmer’s house in the village of Likhauri.

"We came across many cases where radioactive material was found in the
street, in a forest, or in fields," said Grigol Basilia, a scientist
with Georgia’s Nuclear Radiation Safety Service.

Georgia’s biggest worry is the rebellious province of Abkhazia on the
Black Sea coast, where a separatist government defies Tbilisi with the
political and military backing of Russia.

Abkhazia is home to the Sukhumi Institute of Physics and Technology,
or SIPT, founded in 1945 as a cog in the effort to build the Soviet
Union’s first atomic bomb. In 1992, civil war broke out in
Abkhazia. Abkhaz separatists drove out Georgian troops in a year of
fighting that claimed 17,000 lives. Georgian scientists at the
institute fled, leaving the laboratory and its storehouse of uranium,
plutonium and other radioactive materials in the hands of Abkhaz
separatists.

No information on materials

Today, those Georgian scientists have no control over the fate of
SIPT’s deadly array of radioactive substances. Guram Bokuchava, the
institute’s director, operates out of a small office in downtown
Tbilisi, not knowing how those materials are guarded or even how much
are left.

In 2002, when IAEA inspectors flew to Sukhumi to check on uranium
stored at the institute, Abkhaz authorities would not let them inspect
the storage site, Bokuchava said.

"It’s not known how much uranium is there," Bokuchava said. "And it’s
not known how much cesium-137 and strontium-90 is there. Of course,
we’re concerned about what happened to these materials … but the
Abkhaz side is not giving any information about this."

Georgia also continues to be a major transit nation for radioactive
materials smugglers. In the most recent case, Oleg Khinsagov, a
50-year-old Russian trader, was caught trying to smuggle 100 grams of
highly enriched uranium through Georgia last year. He was convicted of
nuclear materials trafficking and sentenced to 8 1/2 years in
prison. Georgian authorities believe the uranium originated in Russia.

Khinsagov fits the profile of the opportunistic radioactive materials
smuggler working the Caucasus region: He was a simple trader, with no
criminal background and no known connections to organized crime or
terrorists.

Tovmasyan, the Armenian cabdriver, and the other men arrested with him
fit the same profile.

The man who gave Tovmasyan the cesium, Asokhik Aristakesyan, was a
priest and also unemployed, said Vahe Papoyan, an investigator with
the Armenian National Security Service. So was another man who tried
to sell the cesium, Sarkis Mikaelyan, a jobless economist. They each
were convicted and also sentenced to a year in jail

"Especially in countries with low standards of living," Khripunov
said, "people can be very enterprising."

Big challenge: Corruption

The U.S. has aggressively tried to shore up border checkpoints in
Georgia and other former Soviet republics to stem the flow of
radioactive materials smuggling. From 1994 to 2005, Washington spent
$178 million to provide radiation detection equipment for border posts
in 36 countries, many of them former Soviet nations.

A March 2006 GAO report acknowledged that the new equipment helps, but
the bigger challenge is corruption.

"Border guards often don’t know what they’re dealing with," Zaitseva
said. "They’re bribed to switch off their detection equipment. They
don’t know what’s being smuggled, and they really don’t care."

———-

[email protected]
Copyright © 2007, _Chicago Tribune_ ()

http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi
http://www.chicagotribune.com/