Censorship

CENSORSHIP
Boyd Tonkin

The Independent – United Kingdom
Feb 22, 2007

George Bernard Shaw once wrote that assassination is the ultimate form
of censorship. That hardly counted as a joke 100 years ago. Now, it
sounds like no more than a footnote to today’s headlines. A month ago,
the Turkish-Armenian editor Hrant Dink died at an ultra-nationalist
assassin’s hands. His murder came after a sustained, high-level
campaign to vilify and prosecute those writers – such as Dink, or
Turkey’s Nobel laureate Orhan Pamuk – who dare openly to debate the
Ottoman massacres of a million or more Armenians in 1915.

Just three months earlier, the author and journalist Anna Politkovskaya
paid the same price, shot in the lift of her Moscow apartment block
after her dogged and fearless research into the underside of Putin’s
regime had made her one ruthless foe too many. As for the grotesque
public killing, so far unsolved, of Alexander Litvinenko in London
last November: remember that the former KGB agent’s chief offence, in
the eyes of his Russian enemies, was to publish a book that denounced
the alleged terror tactics of his ex-employers in provoking the
second Chechen war. That book, Blowing Up Russia, was promptly and
permanently banned in his native land.

At home, freedom of expression hardly looks in better shape. Last year,
only a concerted campaign by what one minister once sneeringly called
"the comics’ lobby" – in fact, a very broad coalition of writers,
artists, lawyers, parliamentarians and (yes) entertainers – reined
in an ill-drafted catch-all law against the incitement to so-called
"religious hatred". The same government that devised that measure
looked on in silence as several existing laws were broken when a
hooligan gang claiming to act for the Sikh community forcibly shut
down the Birmingham Rep’s production of Behzti ( Dishonour) by the
young British writer Gurpreet Kaur Bhatti. "No one from the Home
Office was prepared to defend the playwright," noted the National
Theatre’s director Nicholas Hytner, "even after she was threatened."

Our politicians seem to have concluded that there are no votes in
artistic freedom, or even upholding the law, but many in pandering
to every angry cry of "offence".

Almost two decades ago, British publishers stood firm against the
Ayatollah Khomeini’s fatwa and issued a joint paperback edition of
The Satanic Verses in solidarity with Salman Rushdie. Would the same
collective support take shape now? Much of the media has decided to
indulge in "responsible" self-censorship that often feels not too
far from cowardice. No UK publication, channel or station (save for
a couple of rapidly squashed student magazines) allowed its readers
or viewers to make up their own minds about the Danish cartoons
of Mohamed.

In many cultures, free expression remains truly a matter of life and
death, quite as risky as it ever was. So The Independent’s collection
of once-banned books arrives at a crucial moment. From Vladimir
Nabokov’s Lolita, to Hubert Selby’s Last Exit to Brooklyn, from Henry
Miller’s Tropic of Cancer to William Burroughs’ The Naked Lunch, it
brings together 25 landmark works that still have the power to disturb
and to confront that led to their initial battles with authority.

Recall ( just for starters) that Nabokov’s "nymphet" is not around 14,
as many people think, when she catches the predatory eye of Humbert
Humbert. In fact, she is 12. Anthony Burgess’s A Clockwork Orange
satiris-es the currents in modern society that give rise to the random
violence of disaffected kids. At the time, some read his critique as
an endorsement of thugs. Many might still do so today.

Champions of patriotic warfare will still be affronted by Erich Maria
Re-marque’s All Quiet on the Western Front. Haters of political spin
and guile will be appalled by Machiavelli’s The Prince. Believers in
the spotless innocence of youth will be disgusted by Edmund White’s
A Boy’s Own Story. Partisans of Castro’s just and equal Cuba will be
outraged by Reinaldo Arenas’ Singing from the Well. Islamic patriarchs
will be repelled by Taslima Nasrin’s Shame. Feminist puritans will
be distressed by DH Lawrence’s Lady Chatterley’s Lover – and so,
explosively, on.

"Literature", as the poet Ezra Pound put it (and his own flaky Fascist
tendencies have expelled his work from many college courses over
recent years), "is news that stays news". This selection of fearless
and visionary works has stood the test of time. They retain the right
to shock – and awe.

Some readers may indulge in a little superior scorn when they
consider the bourgeois prudery that sought to suppress Madame Bovary’s
adulterous passion, or the apartheid-era racism that tried to crush
the compassion and solidarity of Alan Paton’s Cry, the Beloved Country.

But, of course, we all approve of censorship in one form or
another. Modern politicians in fragile multicultural societies seek
control over material that "offends" organised blocs of voters. Many
liberally minded people feel glad that British laws passed over recent
decades forbid inflammatory racist speech, writing and images. The
casual clubland asides of a generation back can now lead straight
into court – as the BNP’s Nick Griffin recently found out. Fresh
legislation against the "glorification" of terrorism, aimed at
jihadi hotheads but couched in terms that could have ensnared 1980s
supporters of the ANC, has few vocal or visible opponents. Those for
whom Holocaust denial represents a uniquely vile assault on truth
welcome the legal shaming of David Irving – though not, to be fair,
his jailing in a hypocritical Austria.

Not even extreme libertarians will raise a finger or a voice against
the extension of surveillance powers of the law-enforcement agencies
who aim to eradicate child pornography via large-scale trawls such
as Operation Ore.

Here is a vast network of hi-tech censorship that all but violent
criminals support. Overall, it seems as if everyone in Britain now
agrees with the provocative US critic Stanley Fish, who in the 1990s
wrote an influential anti-liberal tract entitled There’s no such thing
as free speech – and it’s a good thing too. For Fish, as for other
radicals who make common cause with conservatives, all expression takes
place within a contested set of rules and constraints – psychological,
verbal, social, economic. And only fantasists ignorant of history
and humanity ever believe in a blank slate.

Look at the history of our current "culture wars", and you find that
even the bravest standard-bearers of liberty had their blind spots
when it came to censorship. John Milton’s 1644 pamphlet Areopagitica
remains the most forceful English blast in favour of the unsupervised
freedom to publish. It claims that killing a book is as bad as killing
a man, for "who kills a man kills a reasonable creature, God’s image;
but he who destroys a good book kills reason itself, kills the image
of God, as it were, in the eye". Note Milton’s qualification, "good":
the first in a long line of provisos with which free-speech champions
sought to head off the menace of proscription via an appeal to moral
or artistic merit. Fast-forward to 1960: the successful arguments
of Penguin Books in the Lady Chatterley trial still turned on the
"literary value" defence allowed by the Obscene Publications Act.

As many fair-weather libertarians do today, Milton also had a
sticking-point: Roman Catholicism. Catholic propaganda, he thought,
exempted itself from the protection that the state ought to offer
authorship because it amounted to treason: a deep-rooted attack on
the values of the nation and its culture. So, too, for many liberals
now. The fascist or the racist puts himself outside the free-speech
pale, and so deserves ostracism or punishment. American mainstream
thinkers said the same of Communists in the Mc-Carthy era. Now, a
young Islamist radical who holds up a scrawled banner calling for the
beheading of some infidel may face a charge of incitement to murder.

Only in one disputed territory – the depiction in print of sexual
acts – does the early 21st-century in the West seem significantly
more permissive an age than those preceding it. Even here, anomalies
and arguments abound.

Christian campaigners, not long ago, tried to enforce the removal
of mass-market British editions of books by the Marquis de Sade. If
filmed, many of Sade’s more grossly sadistic scenes (which sometimes
involve children) would be instantly deleted once the BBFC had taken a
look. Why, protesters asked, are legislators sure that images can harm
but words do not? And even words can still run foul of British law. One
maverick Manchester publisher, Savoy Books, endured a tireless 17-year
campaign of legal harassment by local police and magistrates. Their
onslaught culminated in the confiscation and destruction of David
Brit-ton’s gruesome satirical fantasy, Lord Horror. This was the last
major suppression of a British printed work for supposed obscenity,
overturned only after a long process of appeal in 1992.

Besides, authoritarian societies – from the Rome of Augustus to
the Cuba of Castro – have often bothered much less about escapist
erotica than about literary challenges to the power of the state and
the person of its leaders.

George Orwell knew his history when he filled the "Airstrip One"
of Nineteen Eighty-Four with cheap gin and cheap porn to pacify
the proles.

Trend-setters of the 1960s liked to believe in the "subversive" power
of sexuality on page, screen or stage. A century earlier, they would
have had a point: witness the scandal of Baudelaire’s Les Fleurs du
Mal, and, indeed, the prosecution of Madame Bovary. In the interwar
years, British law still proudly made an ass of itself by, absurdly,
putting works such as Radclyffe Hall’s tortured lesbian romance The
Well of Loneliness in the dock.

After the Lady Chatterley trial, the floodgates formally opened – but
the creative well dried up. In fast-buck mass culture, the "sexual
intercourse" that began for Philip Larkin "in 1963" soon felt more
like a cheap trick than a new dawn. Only among gay authors in the
West did written sex hang on to its edge of danger and defiance –
from Edmund White in the US and Reinaldo Arenas in Cuba to Jean Genet
in France. The Old Bailey conviction of Last Exit to Brooklyn in 1967
(overturned after an appeal led by John Mortimer) surely bucked the
Sixties liberal trend because of the gay and transsexual milieu of
much of Selby’s novel. Meanwhile, in the 1970s, James Kirkup’s poem
for Gay News – in which a Roman soldier erotically contemplates the
crucified Jesus – brought the laws of blasphemous libel out of their
ancient mothballs. That case, too, resulted in a conviction.

Reading the great banned books of other times and other climes will
hardly sort out the dilemmas and contradictions that recur in the
history of public speech. It might, though, help us to understand
that the sands of taboo and transgression, of heresy and blasphemy,
are forever shifting under our feet.

Within a generation (to take just two obvious examples), Joyce’s
Ulysses and Lawrence’s The Rainbow moved from being pro-scribed
to being prescribed – from the magistrates’ court to the seminar
room. Other novels travel in the contrary direction. In 1900, Harriet
Beecher Stowe’s anti-slavery saga Uncle Tom’s Cabin seemed to millions
one of the noblest, most influential books since the Bible. By 2000,
it had become a byword for pa-tronising ignorance.

Our shibboleths and scapegoats will no doubt look as bizarre to future
critics as the passions of the past so often do to us.

So read these formidable literary pariahs with an eye on our age, as
well as theirs. In olden days a glimpse of stocking was looked on as
something shocking – but, otherwise, Cole Porter got it wrong. Heaven
knows, anything definitely doesn’t go these days. The prudes and
persecutors have simply changed tack and chosen different ground,
as they always have.

"Let there be light," say writers. In answer, the powers that be
treat them not as the salt of the earth but as a law unto themselves,
merely concerned with filthy lucre. All those phrases, as it happens,
come from a much-censored author: from William Tyndale’s magnificent
English translations of the Old and New Testaments, which have left a
deeper mark on everyday English speech than any other text. And what
happened to Tyndale?

The Catholic authorities, not content with burning his heretical work,
burned him at the stake in Flanders in 1536. In cultures where the
written word is banned and burned – even forbidden versions of the
Bible – then living men and women will often follow. Ask the grieving
family and colleagues of Hrant Dink.

STARTING THIS SATURDAY IN THE INDEPENDENT: BANNED BOOKS

An exclusive collection of 25 cutting-edge titles, censored classics
and literary landmarks have been specially published for Independent
readers.

These books are a triumph of independent thought over the forces of
repression, and a reminder of how exhilarating fiction can be. We
start with Anthony Burgess’s acclaimed A Clockwork Orange, which will
come free with every copy of this Saturday’s paper. Over the following
weeks 24 other special edition works will be available to readers for
just pounds 3.45. For details visit

THE COLLECTION, WEEK BY WEEK: 24 February: A Clockwork Orange,
Anthony Burgess; 3 March: A Farewell to Arms, Ernest Hemingway; 10
March: Lolita, Vladimir Nabokov; 17 March: Brave New World, Aldous
Huxley; 24 March: Metamorphosis, Franz Kafka; 31 March: Borstal Boy,
Brendan Behan; 7 April: Madame Bovary, Gustave Flaubert; 14 April:
One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich, Alexander Solzhenitsyn;
21 April: All Quiet on the Western Front, Erich Maria Remarque;
28 April: Beautiful Losers, Leonard Cohen; 5 May: Cry, the Beloved
Country, Alan Paton; 12 May: I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings, Maya
Angelou; 19 May: Lady Chatterley’s Lover, DH Lawrence; 26 May: Naked
Lunch, William Burroughs; 2 June: A Boy’s Own Story, Edmund White;
9 June: The Ginger Man, JP Donleavy; 16 June: Slaughterhouse-Five,
Kurt Vonnegut; 23 June: The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, Mark Twain; 30
June: Last Exit to Brooklyn, Hubert Selby, Jnr; 7 July: The Prince,
NiccolA Machiavelli; 14 July: Singing from the Well, Reinaldo Arenas;
21 July: The Vatican Cellars, Andre Gide; 28 July: Tropic of Cancer,
Henry Miller; 4 August: Shame, Taslima Nasrin; 11 August: Fahrenheit
451, Ray Bradbury

Censuring the censors: writers speak out

‘Many a man lives a burden to the earth; but a good book is the
precious life-blood of a master spirit, embalmed and treasured up on
a purpose beyond life . . . We should be wary therefore . . . how we
spill the seasoned life of man preserved and stored up in books; since
we see a kind of homicide may be thus committed, sometimes a martyrdom,
and if it extend to the whole impression, a kind of massacre.’

JOHN MILTON, ‘AREOPAGITICA’, 1644

‘Nature knows no indecencies; man invents them.’

MARK TWAIN, ‘NOTEBOOK’, 1896

‘If we don’t believe in freedom of expression for people we despise,
we don’t believe in it at all.’

NOAM CHOMSKY

‘The peculiar evil of silencing the expression of opinion is, that
it is robbing the human race; posterity as well as the existing
generation; those who dissent from the opinion, still more than
those who hold it. If the opinion is right, they are deprived of the
opportunity of exchanging error for truth; if wrong, they lose what
is almost as great a benefit, the clearer perception and livelier
impression of truth, produced by its collision with error.’

JOHN STUART MILL, ‘ON LIBERTY’, 1859

‘The dirtiest book of all is the expurgated book.’

WALT WHITMAN

‘The fact is that we are willing enough to praise freedom when she
is safely tucked away in the past. In the present … we get nervous
about her, and admit censorship.’

EM FORSTER, ‘THE TERCENTENARY OF THE "AREOPAGITICA"’, 1944

‘Censorship is never over for those who have experienced it. It is a
brand on the imagination that affects the individual who has suffered
it, for ever.’

NADINE GORDIMER, ‘CENSORSHIP AND ITS AFTERMATH", 1990

‘Wherever they burn books they will also, in the end, burn human
beings.’

HEINRICH HEINE, ‘ALMANSOR’, 1821

‘A censor pronouncing a ban, whether on an obscene spectacle or
a derisive imitation, is like a man trying to stop his penis from
standing up . . . The spectacle is ridiculous, so ridiculous that
he is soon a victim not only of his unruly member but of pointing
fingers, laughing voices. That is why the institution of censorship
has to surround itself with secondary bans on the infringement of
its dignity.’

JM COETZEE, ‘GIVING OFFENCE: ESSAYS ON CENSORSHIP’, 1994

‘Books won’t stay banned. They won’t burn. Ideas won’t go to jail.

In the long run of history, the censor and the inquisitor have
always lost.

The only weapon against bad ideas is better ideas.’

ALFRED WHITNEY GRISWOLD, ‘THE NEW YORK TIMES’, 1959

‘All censorships exist to prevent anyone from challenging current
conceptions and existing institutions. All progress is initiated by
challenging current conceptions, and executed by supplanting existing
institutions. Consequently, the first condition of progress is the
removal of censorships’

GEORGE BERNARD SHAW, ANNAJANSKA, 1919

‘We have a natural right to make use of our pens as of our tongue,
at our peril, risk and hazard.’

VOLTAIRE, ‘DICTIONNAIRE PHILOSOPHIQUE’, 1764

‘Woe to that nation whose literature is cut short by force.

This is not merely interference with freedom of the press but the
sealing up of a nation’s heart, the excision of its memory.’

ALEXANDER SOLZHENITSYN, NOBEL PRIZE ACCEPTANCE SPEECH, 1972

‘You can never know what your words may turn out to mean for yourself
or someone else; or what the world they make will be like. Anything
could happen. The problem with silence is that we know exactly what
it will be like.’

HANIF KUREISHI, ‘LOOSE TONGUES’, 2003

‘If some books are deemed most baneful and their sale forbid, how
then with deadlier facts, not dreams of doting men? Those whom books
will hurt will not be proof against events. Events, not books should
be banned.’

HERMAN MELVILLE, ‘THE ENCANTADAS’, 1856

‘If a man is a fool the best thing to do is to encourage him to
advertise the fact by speaking.’

WOODROW WILSON, ADDRESS TO THE INSTITUTE OF FRANCE, 1919

‘Free speech is the whole thing, the whole ball game. Free speech is
life itself.’

SALMAN RUSHDIE, ‘THE GUARDIAN’, 1990

‘The liberty of the press is a blessing when we are inclined to write
against others, and a calamity when we find ourselves overborne by
the multitude of our assailants.’

SAMUEL JOHNSON, ‘THE LIVES OF THE POETS’, 1781

‘Our liberty depends on the freedom of the press, and that cannot be
limited without being lost.’

THOMAS JEFFERSON, LETTER TO JAMES CURRIE, 1786

‘The press is not only free, it is powerful. That power is ours. It
is the proudest that man can enjoy.’

BENJAMIN DISRAELI

‘He that would make his own liberty secure, must guard even his
enemy from opposition; for if he violates this duty he establishes
a precedent that will reach himself.’

THOMAS PAINE, ‘COMMON SENSE’ 1776

‘I believe there are more instances of the abridgment of the freedom
of the people by gradual and silent encroachments of those in power
than by violent and sudden usurpations.’

JAMES MADISON

www.independent.co.uk/bannedbooks

Armenian Leader Sees No Achievements In Karabakh Peace Talks

ARMENIAN LEADER SEES NO ACHIEVEMENTS IN KARABAKH PEACE TALKS

Arminfo
20 Feb 07

Yerevan, 20 February: One cannot not speak about serious achievements
in the issue of the Nagornyy Karabakh settlement process, however,
neither Armenia, nor Nagornyy Karabakh doubt that the problem can
have some "other" solution.

President Robert Kocharyan said this at a meeting with representatives
of the Armenian diaspora in France.

He pointed out that the Armenian people has already solved the
Karabakh problem, and a task now is to make the Karabakh republic as a
fully-fledge entity. The aim of the negotiations today is to legitimate
the current situation in the "Karabakh land", Kocharyan said.

Armenian Genocide Resolution Is Under Consideration Of House Committ

ARMENIAN GENOCIDE RESOLUTION IS UNDER CONSIDERATION OF HOUSE COMMITTEE ON FOREIGN AFFAIRS

Arminfo
2007-02-22 13:36:00

The resolution is now before the House Committee on Foreign Affairs,
whose chairman, Rep. Tom Lantos of California, has supported the
Armenian genocide resolution in recent sessions, though he opposed
it in the past.

Turkey was so alarmed by a proposed House resolution calling the
mass slaughter of Armenians by Turks during World War I a "genocide"
that it dispatched its foreign minister to persuade American Jewish
leaders to lobby against it. At a suite at the Willard Hotel in
Washington on February 5, Abdullah Gul met with representatives
of the Anti-Defamation League, American Jewish Committee, American
Jewish Congress, American Israel Public Affairs Committee, Friends
of Lubavitch, Jewish Institute for National Security Affairs, and
United Jewish Communities.

According to one participant in the meeting, the Turkish foreign
minister "made a hard sell," against House resolution 106, whose short
title is "Affirmation of the United States Record on the Armenian
Genocide Resolution." This participant, who asked not to be named,
said Mr. Gul appealed to the assembled Jewish representatives by noting
the singularity of the German genocide against the Jews and warning
that the House resolution, if passed, would rupture American-Turkish
relations.

The Turks have reason to be worried. Although the resolution has
faced opposition from the House leadership in previous congressional
sessions, the current speaker of the House, Rep. Nancy Pelosi of
California, is said to support it. Indeed, Ms. Pelosi has supported
similar resolutions in the past.

The Content Is More Important Than The Name: Chief Editor Of Iravunk

THE CONTENT IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN THE NAME: CHIEF EDITOR OF IRAVUNK NEWSPAPER

Arminfo
2007-02-21 20:44:00

The content is more important than the name, says chief editor of
Iravunk newspaper Hovhannes Galajyan.

He says that after the Feb 20 seizure of its office the newspaper is
searching for new office. "We will try to publish our next issue this
Friday. It doesn’t matter at all how we will be called," says Galajyan.

To remind, Iravunk is the newspaper of the Constitutional Right
Union party.

During the conflict between the leader of the party Hrant Khachatryan
and his deputy Hayk Babukhanyan most of the newspaper’s employees
supported the latter. Khachatryan appealed to the court and seized the
newspaper’s office Feb 20. Now most the employes have gone on strike.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Editors Of Pakagits And Iravunk Newspapers Accuse Armenian Authoriti

EDITORS OF PAKAGITS AND IRAVUNK NEWSPAPERS ACCUSE ARMENIAN AUTHORITIES OF SETTING UP A PRE-ELECTION TERROR ON OPPOSITION MASS MEDIA

Arminfo
2007-02-21 20:42:00

At the joint press conference today, editors of Pakagits and Iravunk
Agapi Haykazuni and Hovannes Galadzhyan accused Armenian authorities
of setting up a terror on opposition Mass Media.

"The faked criminal acts against Editor-in-Chief of Zhamanak Yerevan
Arman Babadjanyan, Agap-grat Ltd that published Pakagits paper,
as well as the fuss round Iravunk paper – are parts of one chain of
action aimed to ban popular newspapers. These papers openly speak out
that criminal-oligarchy regime reigns the country," A. Haykazuni said.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Historian Ara Sarafian’s Proposal To Research Ottaman Archives Accep

HISTORIAN ARA SARAFIAN’S PROPOSAL TO RESEARCH OTTAMAN ARCHIVES ACCEPTED BY HISTORY ACADEMY OF TURKEY

Noyan Tapan
Armenians Today
Feb 22 2007

ANKARA, FEBRUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. Ara Sarafian,
a historian, specialist of the Armenian Genocide issue started a
dialogue recently with Yusuf Halacoglu, the Chairman of the History
Academy of Turkey, historian. Ara Sarafian participated in March 16,
2006 in the conference organized in the Istanbul University and spoke
about the Armenian Genocide. After Ara Sarafian’s speech historian
Yusuf Halacoglu proposed him to work together for discussion of the
1915 events. Ara Sarafian received the proposal. In the interview
given to the "Nokta" weekly in February, 2007, Ara Sarafian said that
no work has been done with Yusuf Halacoglu by now but it does not
mean that no public program may be worked out, Marmara states. Ara
Sarafian, who works at the Komitas Istitute of Great Britain, now
presented an interesting proposal to the History Academy of Turkey. He
proposed that a joint research is implemented on the occasion of some
events. For example, according to the Turkish viewpoint, all the
reports concerning the exile are kept in the Ottaman archives. So,
names of exiled people must be found in those archives, it must
be fixed in those lists when and from where the mentioned people
were exiled, where they were sent and settled and what organization
work was done in that place of exile, what compensations were paid
for the territories and the property the exiled Armenians left. Ara
Sarafian proposes the following: "Let’s choose the region of Kharberd
as a place for discussion of some events. Let’s historians in Turkey
put on discussion all those documents which are about the Armenians
exiled from Kharberd. Let’s see if it is written in those documents
what fate the exiled people had. How many Armenians were exiled?

How many people were allowed to stay in the place of their
settlement? What happened with those who stayed? Let’s find out
which the strong or weak sides of the documents are. I, from my side,
will put on the table documents which brought me to the conclusion
that Armenians lived in that region were not only exiled but also
were carried on policy of the worst attitude and slaughter. Let’s
together examine which the strong or weak sides of those documents
are. Ara Sarafian explained that Kharberd was just chosen as there is
much information abroad about that place and Kharberd had not been in
a war situation like Van or Erzrum. Consequently, discussion of some
events in Kharberd must be a transparent and scientific work. In Ara
Sarafian’s words, if the work is done, historians of other regions will
also be invited and similar researches will be carried out concerning
other regions as well. The Turkish "Sabah" daily states that Turkish
History Academy Chairman Yusuf Halacoglu stated in response to Ara
Sarafian’s above-mentioned proposal that the proposal is accepted:
"I officially state that we accept Ara Sarafian’s proposal." Halacoglu
mentioned that Ara Sarafian has a brave posture as it may put him in
difficult situation, and he may be put on different pressures.

Samvel Karapetian: Turkish Specialists Restore Surb Khach Church Wit

SAMVEL KARAPETIAN: TURKISH SPECIALISTS RESTORE SURB KHACH CHURCH WITH MASTERY AND SKILL EXCITING ENVY

Noyan Tapan
Armenians Today
Feb 22 2007

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. The restoration
works of the Surb Khach (Saint Cross) Church of the Akhtamar Island
were done at high level. Stating about it at the meeting with
journalists, specialist on monuments Samvel Karapetian emphasized
that Turk specialists restored the church "with mastery and skill
exciting envy," by using every removed or pulled down stone. Opening
of the Surb Khach Church will take place on April 15. According to
the rumours being in circulation, the RA Minister of Culture and
Youth Issues will also be invited to it. In S.Karapetian’s words,
there is yet no official information about the invitation.

S.Karapetian expressed confidence that restoration of this church
by the Turkish government has political and economic interest:
in the first case this state wants to look like as civilized one,
in the second case, it has clear economic accounting: this place
is one of tourism points. "If I am mistaken why the Nareka vank
(Narek monastery) which is just near the Surb Khach Church and other
lakeside monasteries which were blown up in 60-70s are not restored,"
the speaker said. S.Karapetian, again touching upon destruction
of the Jugha graveyard, inflexibly mentioned that Armenians also
have their part of guilt in it: in his words, Europeans as well
accused Armenians of this issue, saying that it was necessary to take
adequate steps in time. The specialist on monuments also facted that
preservation of monuments being in the territory of Armenia is also
in poor state today.

During the Soviet years, the Committee on Preservation of Monuments was
among the structures attached to government, but today it decreased
and became an agency with 7 employees. "This is an obvious state
ill-will towards our monuments, and we speak about strangers’
attitude," he emphasized.

RA NA Makes In First Reading Amendments To Law "On Television And Ra

RA NA MAKES IN FIRST READING AMENDMENTS TO LAW "ON TELEVISION AND RADIO"

Noyan Tapan
Feb 22 2007

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN. The RA National Assembly adopted
in the first reading at the February 21 special sitting the package
envisaging amendments and additions to the laws "On Television
and Radio" and "On Regulations of Television and Radio National
Committee." It arises of the necessity to bring in correspondence
with the constitutional amendments connected with the orders of
formation of the Television and Radio National Committee (TRNA) and
stopping members’ commissions. According to it, it is fixed that the
TRNA is an independent coordinating state body, a half of members
of which is elected by the NA for 6-year term, and the other half is
appointed by the RA president for the same term. The TRNC functioning
at present is formed of 9 members appointed by the RA President. It
is envisaged by the transitional principles of the draft that the
present members of the committee will continue officiating till the
end of the term of their commissions until the committee staff becomes
8 members. Until the committee staff becomes 8 members, no new member
will be appointed or elected in the case if a vacant place appears. In
the case of existence of a vacant place at the committee in future,
appointments will be made according to the sequence, once by the NA
decision, then by the RA President’s decree.

Inhabitants Of Streets Siding With Myasnikian Avenue Can Not Get Cer

INHABITANTS OF STREETS SIDING WITH MYASNIKIAN AVENUE CAN NOT GET CERTIFICATES FOR PROPERTY RIGHT

Noyan Tapan
Feb 22 2007

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN. Inhabitants of the Yerevan
Myasnikian avenue, Upper and Inner Forest streets as well as of
the districts of Kond and Kozern organized an action of protest at
the RA Government’s building on February 22 with the following and
similar slogans: "Do not violate our rights," "The law must arise
of the people’s interests," "We are owners of our property." They
demanded to recognize their property right towards places of residence
occupied by them. Samvel Mkrtchian, the Chairman of the "Community
and Right" public organization, lawyer mentioned that 7 generations
of inhabitants today live on the Myasnikian avenue, but till now they
have no certificates affirming their property right. In his words,
though territories siding with the avenue were never considered a
zone for sale, local inhabitants are not given the property right
just with that reasoning. In S.Mkrtchian’s words, "those inhabitants
are refused who attempted to solve this problem in the legal way,
but ones who chose another way, managed to privatize their real
property." S.Mkrtchian stated and they presented numerous notes to
the government and expect active discussion on the arisen problems.

Levon Aronian Plays Drawn Game With Leko At 4th Stage Of Morelia Tou

LEVON ARONIAN PLAYS DRAWN GAME WITH LEKO AT 4th STAGE OF MORELIA TOURNAMENT

Noyan Tapan
Feb 22 2007

MORELIA, FEBRUARY 22, NOYAN TAPAN. The 4th stage meetings took place on
February 21 at the chess super tournament being held with participation
of 8 grand masters in the city of Morelia, Mexico. Levon Aronian
with blacks played a drawn game with Peter Leko (Hungary). He has 2
points from the 4 possible ones and shares the 3rd-6th places. And
Viswanathan Anand (India) heads the tournament table with 3 points.