ANKARA: US Retreats from Supporting Turkish Cross-Border Operation

Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Feb 23 2007

US Retreats from Supporting Turkish Cross-Border Operation

Friday , 23 February 2007

Fearing that a possible Turkish cross-border limited operation into
northern Iraq to hit the PKK camps there could become another
destabilizing factor with the possibility of civilian casualties, the
US administration has reportedly stepped back from its earlier
assessment that Washington might give backing to a limited Turkish
operation provided that it would be strictly coordinated with the US.

Well informed Turkish intelligence sources speaking to Today’s Zaman
recalled a meeting that took place in Washington on Jan. 24 during
which both senior US intelligence and administration officials got
together to decide on the options available to stop the PKK’s
possible increased infiltration into Turkey as snow started melting
in the region.

Bearing in mind that Turkey has never ruled out a unilateral
operation into northern Iraq (though the US suspects that this
possibility has been used to put pressure on Washington to do
something concrete against the PKK), US top officials examined the
option of allowing Turkey a limited cross-border operation that would
not exceed two weeks and the set geographical boundaries.

But unlike the US military officials, civilians at that meeting
considered the possible collateral damage that such a limited
operation could inflict even if it was coordinated with the US. Thus,
the US dropped the limited cross-border operation option to the
bottom of the list, at least for now.

Some participants at the meeting raised concerns that a Turkish bomb
dropped during an operation, killing civilians even if accidentally,
could turn out to be a serious destabilizing factor in the region,
which is relatively calm compared with the other parts of Iraq.

"No one in the US will undertake such a responsibility. Possible
civilian casualties and their repercussions in the region was
understood to have made the US officials stall the idea of giving
backing to even a limited Turkish cross-border operation," said the
Turkish intelligence sources.

The US’s preference to seek other options to help Turkey’s fight
against the PKK, such as to increase cooperation between Turkey,
Iraqi government and the Iraqi Kurds, have appeared to have gained
priority on the list of options as evident by Tom Casey’s, deputy
spokesperson of the US State Department, remarks on Feb. 21 press
briefing.

Casey said that the Iraqi government adhered to the principle of
working closely with both Washington and Ankara to stop PKK’s
activities.
Casey also went on to say that Iraqi President Jalal Talabani, a
Kurd, as well as the regional Kurdish administration in northern Iraq
have been collaborating with both Ankara and Washington in the fight
against the PKK.

Through Casey, the US administration has also been responding to
General Büyükanýt, Turkish chief of general staff, who said during a
press conference in Washington lately that at least the Turkish
military would not talk to the Iraqi Kurds whom he blamed for
cooperating with the PKK.
Büyükanýt’s statement came soon after Turkish PM Recep Tayyip
Erdoðan’s remarks that if it was going to help for peace he was ready
to have a dialogue with the Iraqi Kurdish administration.

What next?
It has become obvious that there has been a serious rift between the
Turkish political authority and the military over northern Iraq and
on how to deal with the PKK, though the Turkish government’s patience
has also been wearing thin over the US’s failure to take concrete
measures against Turkey’s outlawed terrorist organization i.e. the
PKK.

As Turkey enters into presidential as well as national elections this
year, it was not ruled out that the ruling AK Party government would
like to see a cross-border operation sometime in late March to ease
Turkish ultra-nationalistic sentiments.

Meanwhile, it remains unclear whether the Turkish government, despite
objections from the military, will enter into a dialogue on the PKK
with the Iraqi Kurdish administration recognized by the newly
designed Iraqi Constitution.

Such a collaboration might force Massoud Barzani, leader of the Iraqi
Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) and the head of the Kurdish regional
government to stop the supply of food, ammunition and other sorts of
logistic support to the PKK from northern Iraq while taking over the
control of the Turkish-Iraqi border form the PKK.
Additionally, the US might drop a bomb on a major PKK camp in the
Kandil mountains in northern Iraq bordering Iran and extradite senior
members of the PKK to Turkey.

Such measures, though impossible to know for sure, might satisfy the
Turkish side.
But the adoption of a so-called Armenian resolution by the
Democrat-controlled US Congress sometime in late March or early
April, and a possible major offensive to be launched by the PKK in
Turkey causing severe casualties might be important factors for the
Turkish unilateral operation into Northern Iraq.

The adoption of an Armenian resolution, which is a very emotional
subject for Turkey, might trigger Turkish unilateral action into
northern Iraq, said a Western military analyst.

Zaman

ANKARA: Ottoman Armenians: Who killed who?

Kodadýmedya, Turkey
Feb 23 2007

OTTOMAN ARMENIANS: `WHO KILLED WHO ?’

I. Introduction: `Chronology and History’

These two branches are confused in general; unfortunately, we witness
such confusion initiated by several persons, having studied history.

In fact, while the first of these branches places the events in time
and place, the second branch researches or is obligated to research
reasons and consequences of such events. While the history is making
the research, it shall stick to the time-table presented by the
chronologist, but at the same time evaluate its information on legal,
cultural, geographical, sociological matters and the like.

We will able to get the conclusion only after the examination we
would carry out under the following titles:

II. Reasons Triggering Degeneration of the Ottoman-Armenian Relations

1. Sovereignty Fight Lasted for five (5) Centuries in the Balkans:
`Bogomilism’

When the Ottoman/Turkish Army entered the Balkans in the mid of XIVth
century, both anarchy and despotism existed in the peninsula. The
political power was tyrannically exploiting small principalities
based on territory and the village class people through these
principalities and the village class people were not able to resist
impositions and insistences of the political power and were being
oppressed by the bandits living in the rural areas.

On the other hand, the real victims of the fight between the churches
were the small principalities and the villagers; while the Catholics
on one hand and the Orthodoxies on the other hand were fighting.
Large blocks of people were wildly being exterminated by these two
denominations, as they have strictly believed in Bogomilism.

The Ottoman Empire has benefited such situation by the way of
securing and protecting the oppressed classes; and therefore in a
short period of time, it could find the way to settle in the Balkan
peninsula. In the meantime, Turk tributes continuously and Sufistic
Connoisseurs (`Tasavvuf Erbabý’) migrating from Asia were constantly
being placed in the Balkans. Although this spread was suspended and
even regressed upon lost of Ankara war in the East and dissolution of
the Ottoman Empire, it was going to be completed more strongly than
ever within fifty years and the South and Central Balkans were going
to be Ottomanized/Turkicized. In the mid of the XVth century.
Ottoman-Germen fight was going to continue for one more century in
the North Balkans, constituting the current Hungary. The challenge on
the Balkans was going to continue until the beginning of the XVIIIth
century and until even today. The difference is that Austria,
representing the Germen authority, left its role to the Tsarist
Russia since XVIII.

Russia, which has been more dangerous than the Austrian Empire, has
planned the policy of `sailing along the warm waters’ for
establishing its sovereignty in the territory and considered this as
a matter of life and death. However, this has been considered by
Austria as an economic development area. Then, having eliminated its
powerful neighbor Sweden, it has edged towards the Ottoman Empire
with all of its power but had to divide its power, as Austria could
not have solved its problems in the Western Europe. However, the most
important point is that as Austria was catholic, the Orthodox Church
was on the side of the Ottoman Empire. At that time, Russia usurped
the church. Furthermore, Russia’s being a Slav Country was going to
turn the conflict between the church and the nationalists to its own
pims; so the Ottoman was going to gradually be considered to be a
foreigner or occupier in that territory.

2. Russia and Pan-Slavism: `Küçük Kaynarca Treaty and First Political
Losses’

Nobody should doubt that that the date to be considered to be
milestone in Ottoman-Russian fight was the execution of 1774 Küçük
Kaynarca Treaty. Until this date, Ottoman Empire from time to time
lost or won the wars it entered; but, no records other than border
arrangements and/or commercial matters have been kept to bear
political consequences. However, it was the first time that it was
accepted in this treaty that Russia was the protector of the
orthodoxies in the Ottoman State and they would be able to open a
consulate anywhere they wish.

This situation, considered unimportant by many of our well-known
historians, has been described by Hammer, Austrian Historian as
follows: `…this peace has been the reason for all the troubles of the
Republic of Turkiye (`Turkiye’) since then and has been the
commencement of dissolution of this Empire and was going to cause
disintegration of the same at least in the West’.

Before ending this matter, we should emphasize: `these provisions,
considered to be critical, have been continuously imposed to Turks
thereafter and are still imposed even today.’ We call you to think on
this matter.’

However, we would like to draw attention to the expression of `at
least in the West’. This is because, at that time, Armenians were
still considered `Loyal Nation’ as expressed as `Tebaa-i Sdýka or
Millet-î Sýdýka’ in the Ottoman Turkish and they were not expected to
have contrary acts against the State. Anyhow, there has been no
reason for such a contrary action; this loyal nation has increased
their welfare by conducting the activities of trade and by governing
the foreign relations of the Ottoman Empire.

Upon the execution of Küçük Kaynarca Treaty, the Russians have
increased their activities in the Balkans. They have established
consulates and accordingly, sensitive zones. They have firstly formed
armed committees by sending weapons and ammunition and even rebels;
and afterwards caused rebellions. They had roles in establishment of
independent Romania, Greece and Serbia. However, they could not in
any way rouse the Armenian public mind in the Eastern Anatolia;
because Armenians have preferred to be under the control of the
Ottoman Empire where they have dominant situation in economic terms,
as they had fear for religious sovereignty to possibly be established
by Orthodox Russia. This lasted until the mid of the XIXth century.

3. Events until Paris Imperial Reform Edict: `The Issue of
Minorities’

Russia already seized the Eastern Anatolia in 1828s and has been in
close contact with the Armenian population. A significant change
occurred in the mid of XIXth century. Having expanded, Russia reached
the border of India; and England has suffered from this progress and
France has suffered from availability of Russian navy in the
Mediterranean. In the future these two countries, would on the side
of the Ottoman Empire (in the future the Kingdom of Piedmont would
join to them) declare war against Russia by using Russia’s request of
control of the straits as an excuse.

Although Russia lost the war, the peace settlement was going to cause
dissolution of the Ottoman Empire. However, after England had secured
the Indian border and together with France, settled the matter of
Straits, these two countries put the `Matter of Minorities’ in the
Ottoman Empire on the agenda, as if they won the war together with
Russia against the Ottoman Empire; and thereafter, commenced to
discuss the articles required to be accepted by the Grand
Governorship. Sublime Porte, afraid of such a plot hatched against
it, was obligated to declare in Istanbul a mandate including a series
of arrangement upon recommendation and even intervention of a French
Representative, while Paris Conference was going on. This mandate was
briefly regarding equal rights and liabilities granted to non-Muslims
in the Empire.

It is quite strange that the objection to the provisions of this
mandate was raised by the non-Muslims, who have been granted equal
rights with the Muslims. Moreover, even Fener (`Phanar’) Greek
Patriarch has read the mandate and stated `I hope it would not any
longer come out of its bag’ and replaced it into the bag. The reason
is quite simple: `Equal rights and liabilities as well as the status
of the Muslim Ottoman Society, who spent 20 years of their lives in
the military service and failed to penetrate into the commercial
life, do not suit the purpose of the other societies in the Empire,
who have been exempted from the military service until that time’.
However, Europe has placed pressure on this matter and the
non-Muslims would have been exempted from such duty by the way of
payment of the `cost’ of the military service and would have
maintained their economic superiority.

During all of these arrangements, Armenians were still loyal Ottoman
citizens, who have been stuck to the State. However, this was not
going to last long !..

Due to the influence of the missioners, who have entered from the
borders, opened following Paris Conference, and due to enthusiasm for
the scholarships granted, Armenians were going to be willing to go to
Europe or Russia and start to be organized against the State there.
However, it is not coincidence that committees, which were going to
be, in the future, a great trouble to both Armenians and Turks, have
been established in either Europe or Russia: `Taþnakustyan (`Taþnak’
or `Tashnak’) Committee was established in Tiflis and Hinchak
(`Hýnçak’) Committee was established in Geneva.’

Following the Treaty of Ayastefanos executed on March 3, 1978 after
the war called `93 War’, concluded with great defeat of the Ottoman
Empire and following the Berlin Conference, which is a darned version
of the preceding Treaty in terms of borders; the Ottoman shrinked in
the east; therefore, 800 years of Turkish sovereignty in the
North-East Anatolia ended; and the territories as well as the Muslim
society living thereon were left on the hook of the Armenians
together with whom they have lived for 800 years.
The Ottomans, aware of the aforementioned facts, have been obligated
to ignore a series of agitations in the country due to binding
treaties and in order to prevent any jeopardy to the Muslims left on
the hook of Armenians. Of course, this situation was going to be
considered to be soft spot of the Ottoman Empire and the Armenian
societies were going to aggravate the situation. For instance,
members of Hinchak Committee were going to start consecutive
rebellions.

4. Ottoman – Russian War: `Erzurum Cemetery, Dram and Muslims Force
to Emigrate’

While border arrangement was being made following the Ottoman-Russian
War in 1978, Russian delegates and Ottoman Delegates gathered at the
provincial house. Russians demanded the province of Erzurum in
addition to Kars, Ardahan and Aðrý, they occupied in this war. As
support, or in other terms proof, for such demand, they asserted the
claim that the majority of the population of these territories was
constituted by Armenians. Upon such claim, one of the Ottoman
delegates took the Russian delegate by the arm to the window and
said: `this is the Erzurum Cemetery; this large land from here to
there is the cemetery of the Muslims and this small part is the
cemetery of Armenians. As we know, Armenians bury their corpses as we
do, but don’t eat !..’ This dialogue is in fact quite dramatic.

Then, the idea adopted in the East was: `If a peace negotiation is
held and the population of one of the parties is higher than the
other one’s, the other party is going to loose the relevant
territories’ Therefore, the Muslims on the other side of the border
were forced to emigrate with pressure of any nature. When the war was
started, Armenians on this side of the border were compulsorily being
repressed. We should particularly state that while the oppressions to
the Muslims in the Russian side were wildly being made by Tashnak
Armenian Guerillas, the obligatory emigration on this side of the
border was conducted by the disciplinary gendarme.

5. 1914 Declaration of War against Russia and Armenian Rebellions:
`Obligatory Emigration-Emigrants’

As soon as war was declared against Russia in 1914 autumn, Russia
forced approximately 387,000 Muslims to immediately cross the border
and emigrate into the Ottoman Side. Afterwards, the Sublime Porte
decided that the villages would be evicted excluding Armenians, such
as the doctors, pharmacists and veterinaries, offering public
services in the villages on the borders; and the emigrant Armenians
would be transferred and placed in the South under security; and the
immigrants coming from the Russia would be placed in the evicted
villages.

Three points should be considered in this decision:
i. The decision was made after Russia had forced the Muslim society
to emigrate.
ii. The decision is not related to emigration of Armenians and
members of several occupational group living in the provinces. This
means that this is not a decision made against a group, as they are
Armenians.
iii. The decision has arrangements with respect to that Armenians
would be sent to South for residence and the assets of these
Armenians would be sold and the costs of the same would be delivered
to them or to the Armenian church, in case of failure in finding the
owners of such assets. Documents evidencing such arrangements are
available.

6. Obligatory Emigration Circumstances: `Fatigue, Diseases and
Kurdish Bandits’

At the preliminary stage, 180,000 – 300,000 Armenians were gathered
together and repressed from their villages and collectively caused to
depart towards the South. This departure lasted under quite hard
circumstances and particularly old population died of fatigue and
diseases and young population in considerable number died of the
attacks of the Kurdish Bandits. There are many telegrams filed by the
guardian officers requesting subsidiary forces.

7. Armenian Rebellions: `Yozgat and Tokat’

In the meantime, there has been considerable number of Armenians
stayed. These have been Armenians living in the provinces or those,
succeeded in staying in the villages by hiding or bribing. Those
staying in the territory (Erzurum, Oltu, Erciþ, Van, Malazgirt, Muþ
surrounding, Tekman), occupied by general attacks of the Russian Army
upon Sarýkamýþ Event and in the provinces left to Russia by 1978
Treaty, have put to the torture and killed the Muslim society in the
territory. As for Armenians living in the provinces; the major
evidence that these Armenians have not been forced to emigrate is
1917 Yozgat, 1917 and 1918 Sivas Armenian Rebellions. If these
Armenians had been murdered, it is so hard to understand how they
were up in arms !..

8. The fact of Van: `Paris of the Orient’

We kindly ask you to allow us to disclose a fact, the evidence of
which still exists today, about Van with respect to which we have
talked to the old people:

The city of Van has born the title of `Paris of the Orient’ and the
Muslim or Non-Muslim ladies of Van had been wandering around the lake
by silver embossed phaetons at sundown at the beginning of the last
century according to the claims. The population of Van had consisted
of 1/3 Muslims, 1/3 Armenians and 1/3 Jews.

Well off Muslim society had resided in the quarter on the coast of
the lake in the skirts of the castle, remained from the ancient
Urartu times, and all of the aforementioned societies had lived
together in the skirts of the mountain, 4-5 km far from the lake.

After the Russian Army had arrived, a considerable number of Muslims
left Van together with the Turkish Army falling back towards Edremit.
Afterwards, Armenians of Van set fire to the Turkish quarters and in
their own words `they left not a stick standing’. Relevant evidences
are available.

Even, according to what told by an old native of Van, `Armenians of
Van, who hide their neighbors, have shipped these people in the
vessels for the so-called purpose of missing them, brought them to
Ahdamar Island under the Armenian Control and shot them’. When the
Turkish Army pulled back Van, Armenians of Van, afraid of
retaliation, evicted their quarters together with the Russian Army
falling back. The Turks coming resided in the evicted Armenian
quarters. Then, magnificent city of Van on the coast of the lake
disappeared and today’s Van became a land city.

9. `Armenian State’ and `Armenia’ in Kars

Armenians, surviving compulsory emigration, has put to the North
together with Russian Army falling back in all directions. They have
settled down in the `Kars centered Armenian State’. The life of this
State has been so short and they have been repelled by Kazým
Karabekir Pascha as far as today’s Armenia and left Anatolia.

III. Incrimination of Armenian Genocide: `Malta and Berlin’

1. Malta: `No Evidence’

As mentioned in the first section hereof, Cabinet in London had
difficulties, as no evidence could have been collected about 140 high
officials of the State sent to Malta by English forces, based on a
series of crime regarding massacres against Armenians in South
Caucasus (refers to Eastern Anatolia within the borders of the
Ottoman Empire).

However, the Cabinet in London has called off establishment of courts
as per Article 230 of Sèvres Treaty, as they could not have found any
evidence either in the archives under their possession or in the
archives of the Ottoman. Nevertheless, they have decided to request
from the USA authorities to submit evidences and documents these
authorities have been supposed to possess (!), in order to procure
that those in Malta were going to be arrested to no purpose.

In the meantime, the Chief Public Prosecutor of England, with its
Note dated July 29, 1921, stated that there had been no possibility
to file an action based on the documents submitted to them as
evidences or statements, the reality of which had been impossible to
be believed by any court.’

Having made the situation worse, the response coming from USA has
caused disappointment. Washington Embassy in England (dated 13 July
1921 and by British Ambassador Mr. R.C. Craigie in Washington), in
its Letter issued to Lord CURZON Committee, authorized to prepare
files of the actions against the arrested officials in Malta, has
stated: `There is no evidence available regarding the aforementioned
arrested officials and there are several groundless oral complaints
about two of them. The original of this document is as follows:

‘………. I regret to inform Your Lordship that there was nothing
there in which could be used as evidence against the Turks who are
being detained for trial at Malta…..
Having regards to this stipulation and the fact that the reports in
the possession of the Department do not appear in any case to contain
evidence against these Turks which would be useful even for the
purpose of corroborating information already in the possession of His
Majesty’s Government.’.

We would like to draw attention to one point herein: `No evidence
could have been found against the arrested officials at Malta’. We
would later on return to this matter while evaluating the legal
situation.

When the required evidences could not have been found in USA, the
English Government has waived from all of its claims and converted
the arrested officials into political hostages from the status of
possible offenders and accepted their exchange with the prisoner
Englishmen in the Anatolia on a subsequent date; but this matter is
out of the scope of our matter in respect of its feature.

2. Berlin: `Tayleryan who murdered Talat Pascha’ and `Andonian
Documents’

The second stage of the request of referral of the event to
international platforms has been launched in Berlin.

Talat Pasha, the second important person of the Union and Progress
Government (Ýttihat and Terakki) and the last Grand Vizier of the
Ottoman Vizier, was shot by an Armenian commissioner named
`Tayleryan’ in May 1921. The murderer was caught. At the trial of the
relevant case, it was claimed: Talat Pasha is responsible for
genocide against Armenians (the first pronunciation of the word
`genocide’) and Tayleryan is not a murderer but an executor and he
acted in such a manner under a grievous provocation.’ As evidence for
this case, telegram texts, which were going to be named `Andonian
Documents’ in the future; which have been claimed to have been issued
from Istanbul Internal Affairs Office (Ministry) (to Þam and Halep
Administrations), then handwriting copies of the same were submitted
to the court, as the `originals’, have been burned in a fire, as
claimed. In these documents, expressions ordering eradication of
Armenians brought for imprisonment were used. The Court REJECTED to
take these into consideration as evidence.

These documents have been quite important in claims regarding
Armenian Genocide and have even been known as the only source.

Although the Turkish side has claimed that these documents have been
false; and that neither the style nor the numbers thereon nor the
writing technique has not been compatible; nobody has believed this.
Consequently, 75 years has elapsed from these events and falsity of
these documents has been detected after the archives were opened and
examined.

[* A Technical Matter: A internal affairs telegram may not be deleted
from the archives; this is because it is registered in at least six
books from the Ministry (Office) to the Administrations (Ministry’s
roes, telegram arrival book, telegram acceptance book, receiver
telegram house entry book , telegram delivery roes and
administration’s entry book). Moreover, nobody claims this; but we
wrote for those, who may possibly not know.]

When it was detected that these telegrams were false, came the most
ridiculous defense from the Armenian supporters: They firstly
claimed; `Armenian genocide has been carried out in the past because
Andonian Documents evidence this genocide’, later they started to
claim: `Falsity of the Andonian documents does not change anything,
this is because it is real that these events occurred.’ (Chalian; Les
Armenians).

IV. Sèvres Peace Treaty: `Negotiations’

In the meantime, Sèvres peace negations have been held in Paris. Some
of you may perhaps wonder why Sèvres Peace Treaty Negotiations have
been held in Paris (and signed on August 10, 1920). This is quite
simple; Sèvres Peace Treaty was negotiated by and between the winners
at a hotel room in Paris; furthermore, they have neither accepted the
interview request of Ottoman Grand Vizier, who has begged for being
heard, nor read the letter send by this Grand Vizier.

During these negotiations, any and all opposing groups or ethnic
groups, including but not limited to Armenians, were heard but the
Turks were REJECTED. After issuance of a decision, the Ottoman
delegates were called to Paris and notified of this decision.

Referral of the event to the international platform by Armenians has
not come to naught and they have been granted the Eastern Anatolia by
a treaty.

When during the war of liberation, the Eastern Provinces were taken
back by the 3rd Army, the Armenian events were completely forgotten.

After execution of the Peace Treaty of Gümrü (dated December 3, 1920)
which ended this action, the chief delegates of both sides each
uttered only one but expressive word:

– `Having left the pen, Turkish chief delegate, asked the Armenian
Chief Delegate: `WHY ?.’

– The response of the Armenian Chief Delegate was `WE’VE BEEN DELUDED
!..’.

V. Armenian Diaspora: `ASALA’ and Kurds: `PKK’

Hereafter, deceptions were tended from Armenians to the Kurds. The
requests of Armenians have been forgotten due to the effects of
Dersim and Sheik (`Þeyh’) Sait rebellions, financial crisis of 1930s,
2nd World War, Korean War and Cold War.

Communities of interest, which have considered in 1960s that they
would do nothing with the Kurds, organized the Armenian Diaspora and
founded and supported ASALA.

After each murder by ASALA, the Western Media had repeated the same
sentences and supported Armenians. Then, the public, which has not
been accustomed to ask any questions, has accepted the same as an
`event’. Another update…the number of the lost people, notified by
the Patriarchy as 180-300 thousands in 1920s, was mentioned to be one
(1) million as of 1966 and thereafter as 1.5 – 2 million.

Accordingly, we guess that these Armenians, the only nation whose
population continues to increase although they die, have losses in
1915.

After seriously acting for approximately 15 years, ASALA has
disintegrated officially due to internal conflicts and non-officially
as a result of the efforts of the Turkish Intelligence Service.

Afterwards, somehow, the Kurds were started to be used and `PKK’ was
caused to be established. You know thereafter.

Today, precipitation of PKK, other than small PKK groups, has leaded
the effort to re-agitate Armenians’ or `create a new purpose’. What
would these excitements lead against us in the future ?.

Sometime several games have been intended to be played on `Alevi
society’ and they have started to be organized seriously in Germany
and Belgium; but the majority of the Alevi society disregards such
efforts for the time being

VI. Armenian Emigration and Rebellions

The act of 1915 Armenian forced emigration (obligatory emigration)
was not against a group of a religion or a race.

According to the documents under our possession, the political will
relating to the event was for non-erudite Armenians, supposed to be
Russian comsymps or under the influence of the Russians in the
territories adjacent to the front line and it has been understood
that such forced emigration was conducted particularly for wiping out
of the territory in military terms and making the territory
convenient for a military act. However, at the beginning, erudite
Armenians such as doctors, pharmacists etc., as well as Armenians
living in the cities, Armenians working in the state authorities,
sick and older villager Armenians were exempted;

We have a memory; 2 Turkish officers told how they have been taken
prisoners and how their imprisonments have been. These two officers
could have gone to the 3rd Army in Erzurum from Istanbul in 42 days.
The most important reason for their delay has been interruption of
their travels due to the Armenian gangs or their short laps. These
gangs’ generally being Protestant Armenians might have been taken as
basis for issuance of decision on emigration. However, in our
opinion, the trigger of the event was the intention to clear a field
in the critical zone for about 300,000 Turks, forced to emigrate from
Russian side to Turkish side. In fact, firstly 300,000 Turks were
banished; thereupon 300,000 – 600,000 Armenians were forced to
emigrate to the South.

Has the Armenian population been as mentioned above? No, but I could
not understand the importance of the number of this population;
because the entire of this population has not been forced to
emigrate. The evidences are the rebellions, which have consecutively
broken out after 1915 and particularly upon regression of the Russian
Army after dissolution of the Tsarist Russia in the last years of the
war. Even if, we disregarded the zones under Russian occupation in
1915s such as Kars, Ardahan, Doðu Beyazýt. If there have not been
Armenians in the zones such as Yozgat, Sivas and Merzifon, how would
these rebellions been explained then ? !…

According to what we told in our article relating to lives of the
entire of Armenians in the territory of Van in 1916, how could
general emigration of Armenians be mentioned without any bad faith?
It is hard for a normal person to consider the same! You know that
any single Armenian has not been disturbed in the territories of
Maraþ and Kilikya (`Cilisia’). Moreover, a telegram is regarding
refusal by the Armenians in the relevant zone of the efforts for
placement, in Kilikya, of Armenians forced to emigrate from the East.
We should deem well of the same !..

One day, an Armenian Professor, during his visit to Ani Ruins, told
us: `The worst behavior of you was conscription of the men and
assassination of the women and children in the villages without men’.
We told him that `his knowledge was completely wrong. Regardless of
whether the women and children in these villages have been murdered,
the Armenian men in this zone have established Tashnak gangs and
attacked the Turkish villages or taken shelter of the Russian Army
and constituted Armenian troops’. We told him that `the Armenian
soldiers he mentioned were the aforementioned villagers. He had never
heard something like this !..’. We would like to repeat that it was
calculated that the Armenian men, taken shelter of the Russian Army
and taken part in the newly formed Armenian troops immediately upon
commencement of the war before 1915 events counted at least 70,000.
Moreover, during the Russian occupation, these are the Armenians, who
have caused injustices to the extent these have stroked the Russian
officers the wrong way !..

VII. Conclusions: `Our Specialists and Our Situation’

1. In Terms of Political Will: `False Documents of Lewy Aram
Andonyan’

We told in our article that Armenians’ attitude was so illogical and
extraordinary that the lawyers even could not understand. After the
archives had been opened and the falsification of the Andonian
documents had been understood, Armenians and their supporters, who at
the beginning, made the availability of this political will depend on
completely falsified Andonian documents, wisely and coolly stated:
`This changes nothing; because the Armenian Genocide is anyhow real
and other documents are absolutely available (?!); but, nowadays they
are not accessible !..’.

2. In Legal Terms: `Burden of Proof’

Objective side, contrary to the logic of law, is that the world
public opinion has taken the burden of proof from Armenians asserting
the claim and given the same to us, Turks. They asked us to prove
that such claim is not true instead of asking Armenians to prove
their claim. Moreover, they have even not heard our defense. Let’s
say `c’est de bonne guerre’ in French terms up to that point.
Interests prevail instead of rights and law between the states.

However, the point, which desolates us and which we have difficulty
in understanding is that: WE STILL HOLD OURSELVES RESPONSIBLE FOR
THIS MATTER; AND WE PREFER ACCEPTANCE OF PRESSURE OF THE FOREIGNERS
TO WHAT TOLD BY OUR MEN OF LETTERS AND OUR HISTORIANS.

3. In Other Terms

Yes, this is true; this act has not been conducted without blood. We
guess that approximately 60,000 Armenians have died on the ways and
nearly same number of Armenians in the communication zones due to
climatic conditions in the territory on one hand and their
insufficient supply on the other hand and particularly due to
continuous attacks by the Kurdish Gangs to these public processions,
emigrating with their precious belongings.

However, Istanbul Armenian Patriarchy has firstly mentioned that
300,000 Armenians have died. The figures, claimed today, are not true
and are for the purpose of stirring up disorder in the public
opinion. Those wondering the facts may reach information on census of
population held during the Constitutional Monarchy (`Meþrutiyet’) and
may notice that the population in the territory may not be enough for
this.

We would conclude our article with a current event: A program to
which a Turkish specialist (?!) attended was held in a Belgian-French
Channel. On the matter of acceptance of Armenians by the European
Union and request from Turkiye for recognition of the Armenian
Genocide and if not acceptable, request from EU Parliament for
issuance of a decision on this matter, this Specialist (!) only and
only stated that this is not possible under EU negotiation conditions
and such a condition may not be claimed. He even uttered any other
unfortunate sentences. If we were in his shoes, we would state that
there has been no Armenian Genocide and the claims on this matter are
factitious instead of stating that negotiation of this matter is not
possible.

Do you consider the claim of Armenians that those accepting the
Armenian Genocide has been made are sentenced to imprisonment
according to the Turkish Former Criminal Code? A specialist (!?),
being at the same time a legal advisor, did not state that there is
not such a provision in the Turkish Former Criminal Code; but instead
he stated that there has been no person put in the prison for such
reason. Do you consider our situation ?!..

Mustafa Kemal ATATÜRK, at his speech during the opening of the
Turkish Grand National Assembly, stated: `The problem called as
`Armenian Problem’ and intended to be resolved according to the
economic interests of the world capitalists rather than according to
the requests of the Armenian Nation was resolved by the Treaty of
Kars in the most correct manner. Good faith relations of the two
hardworking societies living together in amity for centuries were
re-established with pleasure.’

Please take into consideration my writings as a knowledge sharing.
How come that everybody informs its studies and such studies are not
considered to be abnormal, we would also like to share our knowledge
as they do.
Kindly submitted…

Hakan HANLI
Attorney at Law
International and EU Law Specialist
Brussels, April 23, 2006 [email protected]

; Catx=hakan_hanli

http://www.kodadimedya.com/yazar.php?id=5473&amp

Armenian Datacom to expand services over converged Alcatel-Lucent

Wireless Design & Development Asia, Singapore
Feb 23 2007

Armenian Datacom to expand service offering over converged
Alcatel-Lucent IP/MPLS backbone

Armenian Datacom Company selected Alcatel-Lucent to supply an IP/MPLS
network to deliver high quality data and Internet services to
business and residential customers. Covering most of the Armenian
capital city of Yerevan, Alcatel-Lucent’s IP/MPLS network will allow
Armenian Datacom to benefit from a wider variety of service offerings
and increased service flexibility. Once deployed, the operator can
provide advanced services such as high speed Internet (HSI) and
virtual private LAN services (VPLS) for corporate customers. By
running all services on a single, next generation IP infrastructure,
Armenian Datacom can achieve significant economies of scale and
maximize profitability of services while streamlined and simplified
network management tools will result in significant operational
savings.

"By leveraging Alcatel-Lucent’s IP portfolio of products, Armenian
Datacom Company can offer advanced business and residential services
for the first time in Armenia," said Harald Grytten, CEO, Armenian
Datacom. "Implementing Alcatel-Lucent’s leading-edge solutions gives
us the business and technology tools we need to compete and to offer
subscribers a variety of converged services."

"As an early supplier of cutting edge IP/MPLS solutions in Armenia,
we are in a position to contribute to further development and
modernization of the data infrastructure in Armenia," said Basil
Alwan, President, Alcatel-Lucent’s IP activities. "Armenian Datacom
is able to leverage the unique features of our IP/MPLS solution to
provide a new generation of services to its customers."

Armenian Datacom joins a list of more than 160 service providers in
over 60 countries who have selected the Alcatel-Lucent IP portfolio,
including massive, multi-year IP network and service transformation
projects at AT&T, BT, Cable & Wireless, and Telstra. According to
Ovum-RHK, Alcatel-Lucent was #2 in the IP/MPLS Edge market segment in
Q4 2006, with 19% market share.

ANKARA: If Armenian resolution passes, Turkish-US coop will suffer

Turkish Press, MI
Feb 23 2007

Press Review

FM GUL: `IF THE ARMENIAN RESOLUTION PASSES, TURKISH-US STRATEGIC
COOPERATION WILL SUFFER’

Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul yesterday received a visiting US
congressional delegation led by Democratic Congressman Norm Dicks,
and they spoke about the resolution on the so-called Armenian
genocide now facing the US House of Representatives. Expressing
Turkey’s frustration over the terrorist PKK presence in northern
Iraq, Gul said that Ankara is running out of patience. /Star/

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Who Knows Turkey’s Balances Best Now?

Turkish Press, MI
Feb 23 2007

Who Knows Turkey’s Balances Best Now?
Published: 2/23/2007

By Murat Yetkin

RADIKAL- Both Mottaki and Mahdi were in Ankara yesterday. We think
that the clear link between Iran’s nuclear program and Iraq’s future
was discussed. All political problems in the region such as the
terrorist PKK, the Turkmen situation in Iraq, the Palestinian-Israeli
dispute, and Lebanon are connected to each other. Political
sensitivity in the region has increased. Everything could go better,
or it could go worse.

Turkey is part of this diplomatic situation, but how?

Do the public and political decision-making mechanisms have enough
information about the policies and measures pursued in this process?

The title of today’s column has this goal in mind. Let’s give a hint
to those who want to answer this question. Who knows best both the
government’s and the Turkish Armed Forces’ (TSK) view on Turkey’s
stance on Iraq’s future, Iran’s nuclear program, what it would do
about energy transportation lines and security, and if the US
Congress will pass the Armenian resolution?

There are people who know firsthand the government’s and TSK’s stance
on these important political-strategic issues prior to May’s
presidential election. These are US Vice President Dick Cheney, US
President George W. Bush’s National Security Advisor Stephen Hadley,
and US Congressman Tom Lantos, who chairs the US House of
Representatives’ Foreign Affairs Committee.

Over the last two weeks, first Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul and
later Chief of General Staff Gen. Yasar Buyukanit conveyed their
views in detail on these important issues to these figures during
their contacts.

We have to assume that President Ahmet Necdet Sezer has information
on these issues owing to his regular weekly meetings.

The Turkish media lacks this information. We journalists know the
issue only from the answers we get to our questions. The debates in
Parliament don’t say enough. For example, we don’t know if Parliament
Speaker Bulent Arinc or main opposition Republican People’s Party
(CHP) leader Deniz Baykal is fully aware of the views of the
government and the TSK. The members of the National Security Council
(NSC) don’t have the latest information on the issue, since it hasn’t
met for about two months now.

Prior to his critical contacts in Washington, Buyukanit visited Gul
at the Foreign Ministry to discuss his visit. During their meeting,
maybe they coordinated what they would tell the US officials. In
fact, when there was a discrepancy in the statements of Buyukanit and
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan on holding direct official
meeting with Iraq’s President Jalal Talabani, Gul said that the
statements weren’t in conflict, but complemented each other.

Turkey has to make decisions which will affect foreign policy this
year, when it will also hold two elections and make important
decisions on domestic matters. So sharing these decisions with the
public would be beneficial.’

ANKARA: Permission for investigation demanded

Sabah, Turkey
Feb 23 2007

Permission for investigation demanded

The chief public prosecutor of Þiþli asked for permission from the
Ministry of Internal Affairs to start an investigation about the
magistrate Sarýgül and the organization committee for the banners
that read, "we are all Armenians."

Demand of permission to investigate the debated banners

The chief public prosecutor of Þiþli asked for permission from the
Ministry of Internal Affairs to start an investigation about the
magistrate Sarýgül and the organization committee for the banners
which read, "we are all Armenians."

An investigation will be started on the banners that say, "we are all
Hrant," "we are all Armenians," held up at the funeral of the
murdered editor-in-chief of Agos newspaper Hrant Dink. The chief
public prosecutor of Þiþli asked for permission from the Ministry of
Internal affairs to start an investigation about mayor Sarýgül and
the organization committee. In the complaint petition, it said that
the Þiþli magistrate Mustafa Sarýgül and the funeral organization
committee invited people to attend the funeral but the banners and
the slogans that were held up there were racist. The petition also
claimed that article 301 of the Turkish Commercial Code was also
insulted with the banner saying "Hrant’s murderer is article 301."

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Does transparency legitimize an illegitimate action?

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 23 2007

Does transparency legitimize an illegitimate action?

by BULENT KENES

We all know that, as with many Turks and Muslims, Turkish Prime
Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoðan is also sensitive toward and upset by
the excavation work around the Al-Aqsa Mosque. Erdoðan himself
conveyed these feelings of discomfort to Israeli Prime Minister Ehud
Olmert last week when Olmert visited Ankara. Dissatisfied with
statements from Olmert and the delegation who accompanied him,
Erdoðan proposed that a Turkish inspection team should be sent to the
region to make their evaluation of the situation on location. It was
enough to stir a political storm in Israel when Olmert abruptly
agreed to the proposal.
Erdoðan’s approach to the situation deserves praise when we look at
it from the viewpoint of the pro-active foreign policy that Turkey
has recently adopted. As a country that has been exposed to endless
mistreatment from both European and American inspectors who looked
for traces of human rights abuses, Turkey ought to feel proud that it
has promoted itself to a level where it inspects from a level where
it used to be inspected. It also has revived our self-esteem and
self-confidence.
If I am not mistaken, a Turkish envoy felt compelled to see on
location alleged abuses of human rights in French prisons at a time
when there was heated discussion on a draft bill that made it a crime
to deny an Armenian genocide in the French parliament. Undoubtedly,
it is possible to see from the desire of Turkey to inspect on
location aberrant modes of behavior in other countries that Turkey
believes in itself and is comfortable with the fact that it managed
to minimize its poor marks on the same subject.
Actually, it is of paramount importance to observe that recent
diplomatic traffic to and from Ankara is not at all meant to be an
inspection of abuses of human rights or aberrant modes of behavior
when compared with earlier diplomatic trips to the capital. All this
is also evidence to the extent to which Turkey has undergone a great
reform, transformation and renovation.
Let’s now discuss the way the Israeli side perceives the matter at
hand. Olmert, who approved of the trip by the Turkish inspectors to
the Al-Aqsa Mosque, is having hard time in his own country. It is
normal that he is having trouble there. Think of it: it must not be
easy for a country to agree to inspection when it has too much
national pride and self-reliance and when it can heedlessly keep
putting into action many policies despite worldwide opposition.
The envoy of inspectors was the main topic of discussion on Wednesday
when Ýstanbul Consul General of Israel Mordehai Amihai and a group of
diplomats who accompanied him visited Today’s Zaman. While Mordehai
mentioned in diplomatic style the discomfort of Israeli people, he
argued that inspection would not make much sense since all work
around the Al-Aqsa Mosque is being carried out in full transparency.
Actually, this is the essence of the problem. Israel is a country
that puts into action many policies in full transparency, decidedly
not in political disguise, although such policies may upset not only
Muslims but also the entire international community. But the question
remains whether illegitimate acts can become legitimate when they are
pursued in transparency and not in disguise. Israel attacked Lebanon
and caused numerous casualties in front of the eyes of the world by
using Hezbollah attacks as a pretext for its incursion into Lebanon.
This is also true for the use of violence in both Ramallah and Gaza.
We will not regard Israel, which made it a doctrine of security to
use methods even worse than terror in order to destroy the kind of
groups that Israel considers as terrorist, as legally right just
because Israel is resorting to excessive use of violence/force in
front of everyone. Neither will we appreciate Israel because Israel
is causing civilian casualties so long as they occur before our eyes.
Then again, it frightens one to think of Israel’s concealed actions
when already it does not refrain from putting into action any kind of
illegitimate policy with the utmost impudence before the eyes the
world.

ANKARA: Lawmakers readying for US trip to lobby

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 23 2007

Lawmakers readying for US trip to lobby

Parliamentarians from the ruling Justice and Development Party (AK
Party) and the opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) are to
travel soon to the United States to convince US congressmen not to
pass a draft resolution recognizing Armenian claims of genocide at
the hands of the late Ottoman Empire.
Three separate delegations will visit Washington in late February and
in March to seek support against the resolution, expected to be
debated at the House of Representatives in April.
The Democratic-controlled Congress is widely expected to back the
draft, even though the White House is opposed to it, wary over the
impact on relations with Turkey, a key Muslim ally and a NATO member.
Foreign Minister Abdullah Gül said after a visit to Washington this
month that passing the draft would "poison" ties and "spoil
everything" between the two countries.
In October 2000, a similar draft was pulled from the House floor
following intervention by then president Bill Clinton.

Disabled man and Armenian wife reunited

icBerkshire, UK
Feb 23 2007

Disabled man and Armenian wife reunited
Feb 23 2007

A DISABLED man and his Armenian carer wife – who faced an uncertain
future separated by thousands of miles – have finally been reunited.

Keith Ackrill, 61, was reunited with wife Svetlana, 50, at Heathrow
Airport on Friday after she returned from Armenia having been granted
a spouse’s visa by the Home Office last week.

The couple are now back together in their St Chad’s Road home in
Maidenhead having endured a turbulent time since January, when
Svetlana returned to Armenia to apply for the visa.

Asked how it felt to be back together Keith – who is paralysed down
one side – told the Express: "Fantastic – it’s how it should have
been in the first place."

He said Svetlana’s return was the end of an ordeal and recalling
picking her up from the airport, he commented: "She looked lovely."

Azerbaijani propaganda’s old lie

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
Feb 23 2007

AZERBAIJANI PROPAGANDA’S OLD LIE

A lot of materials concerning the events in Hojalu have been
published in the Azeri press. The Azeri journalists mention the issue
of February 26 will be discussed in the Turkey’s Parliament.
According to the Azeri mass media, the Turkish Parliament may adopt a
resolution recognizing the events in Hojalu as Genocide.
What aim does Turkey and Azerbaijan pursue?
Talking to KarabakhOpen, the NKR NA Democracy Parliamentarian Faction
leader Vahram Atanesian noted, `’As far as I know, February 27
Azerbaijan’s Milli Majlis will call a special sitting to make a
statement on the events in Hojalu. Naturally, Turkey will take
advantage of the situation to make propaganda parallel in connection
with the Armenian Genocide issue’s discussion at the U. S. Congress.
I think it is a purely propaganda step undertaken by Turkey, though I
do not rule out that we face the Turkish-Azeri Parliamentarians’
solidarity. I do not believe Turkey as a serious country will
recognize the events in Hojalu as Genocide – it would be funny, and
yet will not produce a positive effect in the Turkey’s history”.
According to Vahram Atanesian, the issue’s discussion at such a level
is not serious, as the figures published by the Azeri party are hard
to believe.