ANKARA: Court Of Justice And Genocide Law (I)

COURT OF JUSTICE AND GENOCIDE LAW (I)
Gunduz Aktan

The New Anatolian, Turkey
March 7 2007

The International Court of Justice at the Hague late last month
concluded a case filed in 1993 by Bosnia against Serbia.

In the war that broke out in early 1992, Bosnian Serbs, with personnel
and weapons provided by the Serbian Army, carried out an appalling
"ethnic cleansing" against Bosnians and Croats. Since there was an
arms embargo on Yugoslavia, arming Bosnians was impossible.

The United Nations "peace" force UNPROFOR either failed to protect
the Bosnians or did not want to do so.

Under these circumstances, Turkey in December 1992 asked the Human
Rights Commission to convene an extraordinary meeting and secured
the insertion of the term "genocide" into the resolution adopted
by the commission. Turkey’s aim was to put pressure on Serbia and,
if necessary, push the international community toward an armed
intervention in Bosnia under Article 1 of the Genocide Convention
(1948) which makes it a state responsibility to prevent genocide.

This resolution later led to the establishment of the International
Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) by the UN Security
Council and the prosecution of perpetrators on charges of genocide
and other crimes.

Turkey also encouraged Bosnia to initiate court proceedings against
the Republic of Yugoslav Federation of the time in the framework
of Article 9 of the Genocide Convention. This is the case that was
finalized last month.

At that time some argued that Turkey’s pursuing an active role
over genocide would cause counter-claims due to the so-called
Armenian genocide claims. We dismissed them. The tragedy in Bosnia,
however serious it was, was outside of the genocide definition of
the convention. Should the court remain within the limits of law,
it would not broaden the definition of genocide to include Armenian
relocation, which had nothing to do with genocide. The judgment of
the court proved Turkey’s position to be right.

The court’s ruling says the terrible atrocities in Bosnia-Herzegovina
were not genocide. The only exception was the Srebrenica massacre
of June 12-13, 1995. The ICTY ruled that this massacre amounted to
genocide in the cases of Krstic and Blagojevich. Had there been no
decision of the ICTY, probably the court would not have characterized
the Srebrenica massacre as genocide.

When the court’s judgment is analyzed, the legal reasons underlying
the court’s attitude, which at first sight provokes resentment,
are understood. The court said the first three acts out of five
proscribed under Article 2 of the convention are relevant to this
case. Regarding the first act, i.e. killing members of the group,
the court admitted that grave massacres were committed in Bosnia.

Regarding the second, i.e. serious bodily and mental harm to the
members of the group, it agreed that incidences of mass torture
and rapes occurred. And concerning the third act, i.e. deliberately
inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about
its physical destruction, the court said this crime was committed,
particularly in detention camps where inhuman conditions prevailed.

However, the court also ruled that the commission of these criminal
acts as defined in the genocide convention doesn’t necessarily
amount to genocide, inasmuch as the Serbians didn’t have the intent
to destroy the Bosnians in committing these acts. That is to say,
the court rules that massacres, mass torture and rape, and the
extermination of thousands of people as a result of the inhuman
conditions of detention camps, do not amount to genocide, unless
there is special intent to destroy the group.

The court underlines that the acts of crime committed with the aim
of homogenizing the population of a region per se may not be deemed
genocide. It stipulates that in addition to displacing a group,
there should be the intent to destroy it as well. In other words, it
says that "ethnic cleansing" carried out in Bosnia is not necessarily
genocide.

To prove the "intent" to destroy a people, the claims that "the Blue
Book says so," "Right Hon. Henry Morgenthau or Vicar Priest Johannes
Lepsius testify this," "world historians and sociologists already
made up their mind," or "20 parliaments have recognized the genocide
anyway" are no more than rumors.

The court’s verdict is not an extraordinary development to reinforce
Turkey’s stance vis-a-vis Armenian genocide allegations. But it proves
how valid our legal attitude is. There has been no legal thesis of
the Armenians anyway. This decision explains the reasons why not.

Ara Sarafian, who must have predicted the verdict, is late in his
proposal. The problem cannot be reduced to a particular region of
Turkey, namely Harput. On the other hand, neither intellectuals nor
historians can pass judgment on it.

>From now on, legal settlement is the only way.

US Department Of State: Prison And Detention Center Conditions In Ar

US DEPARTMENT OF STATE: PRISON AND DETENTION CENTER CONDITIONS IN ARMENIA REMAIN POOR AND POSE A THREAT TO HEALTH

Arminfo
2007-03-07 15:06:00

Prison and detention center conditions in Armenia remained poor and
posed a threat to health, the US State Department’s report on Human
Rights Practices in Armenia for 2006 says.

According to the web-site of the US State Department, the document
says that Civil Society Monitoring Board (CSMB), an organization
established by government initiative involving prison monitoring by NGO
personnel, reported some improvements as authorities began to renovate
old prisons. However, problems remained: cells were overcrowded,
most did not have adequate facilities, prison authorities did not
provide most inmates with basic hygiene supplies, and food quality
remained extremely poor. The CSMB reported in 2005 that prisoners
were at high risk of contracting tuberculosis, and adolescents held
in juvenile facilities rarely received the schooling required by
law. The CSMB reported other chronic problems, including denial of
visitor privileges, medical neglect, and in the most extreme cases,
physical abuse.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: First Day Of Perincek Trial In Lausanne; Turkish Supporters

FIRST DAY OF PERINCEK TRIAL IN LAUSANNE; TURKISH SUPPORTERS DENIED ENTRY

Hurriyet, Turkey
March 7 2007

The first hearing in the trial of Dogu Perincek, the leader of the
Turkish Workers’ Party who has been charged by Swiss prosecutors
with publicly denying the Armenian genocide allegations, took place
yesterday in Lausanne, Switzerland.

A large contingency of Perincek supporters who left Turkey 2 days
ago to show support for Perincek during his trial were not allowed by
Swiss authorities into the courtroom yesterday. Turkish journalists
were also barred by security from entered the Lausanne Courthouse,
on grounds that written accreditation had not been received beforehand.

It is expected that Perincek’s trial will continue until March 9. If
found guilty, Perincek is to serve 3 years in prison and pay a heavy
financial fine.

In statements made earlier this week to the Swiss newspaper "Le
Matin," Perincek asserted that he had come prepared with many WWI-era
documents from various countries, and that he would prove in court
that what occured in Turkey during those contested years was not in
fact genocide.

ANKARA: Mehmet Y. Yilmaz: Propoganda For Turks, By Turks

MEHMET Y. YILMAZ: PROPOGANDA FOR TURKS, BY TURKS

Hurriyet, Turkey
March 7 2007

I read recently in the papers that a documentary aimed at disproving
Armenian allegations of genocide was being filmed in Turkey. The film
reportedly starts with shots of images of the death of the Provincial
Governor of Bogazliyan, Kemal Bey, who was executed as punishment
for his mistreatment of Armenians during the forced emmigrations.

News has gotten out too that this film is being translated into
foreign languages. Now, I don’t want to cause disappointment here,
but I think this entire effort is one which is not going to serve
anyone’s purposes.

Until today, none of the efforts at trying to disprove the Armenian
allegations of genocide have found a place for themselves in the
Western media. In fact, we even know that the Armenian lobby places so
much pressure on any publishing houses which move to print books that
might aim at disproving these allegations that the publishing houses
later decide not to publish them. And for as long as the various
parliaments of foreign nations continue to pass official decisions
that "the Armenian genocide took place," this is just the way it is
going to be for us.

In the end, we will watch this film, and either get more angry,
or relax a bit. But there can be no real results which come from
"Propoganda for Turks by Turks." I have worn out the keys on my
computer from writing this over and over, but here goes one more time:

"We still have no serious organization to fight the Armenian genocide
allegations on the international platform."

What we really need is a strong platform which utilizes different
methods of reaching the masses. But instead, we still haven’t been
able to gather all our documents in reference to the WWI Armenian
emmigration period under one roof, opening them up this way to
research. All we seem to know is how to expose ourselves to our own
propoganda. And that, unfortunately, is not getting us anywhere.

We’re All Armenians

WE’RE ALL ARMENIANS
By Gwynne Dyer

Egypt Today
March 7 2007

The assassination of the editor of the only Turkish-Armenian newspaper
underscores Turkey’s battle between its past and future

When they buried Hrant Dink in Istanbul at the end of January, more
than 100,000 Turks came to his funeral, filling the streets and
chanting, "We are all Armenians!" There is a war going on for the
soul of Turkey, but at least a lot of Turks are on the right side.

Dink, who called himself "an Armenian from Turkey and a good Turkish
citizen," was murdered because he insisted on talking about the great
crime that happened in the country 92 years ago: the mass murder
of most of Turkey’s Armenian population in eastern Anatolia. The
newspaper he founded and edited, a bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly
called Agos, had only a small circulation, but his outspoken editorials
had made him one of Turkey’s most famous journalists – and a target
for assassination.

His killer, 17-year-old Ogun Samast, was a semi-educated thug from
Trabzon in the far northeast of Anatolia. He was allegedly given the
gun by a group of older ultra-nationalists including Yusuf Hayal, who
was convicted of bombing a McDonald’s restaurant in Trabzon in 2004.

But these marginal characters are just pawns in the larger war between
those who want a more democratic, more tolerant Turkey and those
who are desperately defending the power and privileges of the old
"republican" elite.

Samast shot Dink from behind in the street in front of his
newspaper office. "I feel no remorse," the killer reportedly told
investigators. "He said that Turkish blood was dirty blood." Of course,
Dink never said any such thing. What he actually said, in a newspaper
article addressed to his fellow Armenians, was that their obsession
with the massacres of 1915-17 was having "a poisonous effect on
your blood."

But it’s easy to see how a useful idiot like Samast could have believed
that Hrant Dink was an enemy of the Turks, because just over a year ago
a Turkish court took that same phrase out of context, found Dink guilty
of "insulting Turkishness" and gave him a six-month suspended sentence
under Article 301 of the criminal code. A number of other Turkish
citizens -including Nobel Prize-winning author Orhan Pamuk -have been
prosecuted under the same law for daring to discuss what happened to
the Armenians, and most of them have received death threats, too.

It really is a kind of war, and the villains of the piece are precisely
the army officers, judges and senior civil servants who were once
seen as the guardians of the republican tradition, the people who
were going to modernize and democratize Turkey.

Unfortunately, "republican" doesn’t really mean the same as
"democratic."

When Mustafa Kemal Ataturk put the Ottoman Empire out of its misery
and declared a Turkish republic in 1923, his model was the democracies
of Western Europe, but his own countrymen were still largely sunk in
feudal obscurantism. Literacy was about 20 percent, and most rural
people still saw themselves as Muslim subjects of the Caliphate (which
Ataturk abolished in the following year), not as Turkish citizens.

The forms of the Turkish republic were democratic from the start,
but for a very long time the reality was a mass of illiterate
peasants under the harsh tutelage of a narrow educated elite who were
determined to Westernize the country. The republican elite rewrote
history (including the denial of the Armenian massacres) to mold a
new Turkish national consciousness and saw religion as a retrograde
force that must be banned from politics.

The decades passed, and much of the elite’s dream came to pass.

Turkey today has a per-capita income higher than Romania or Bulgaria,
the most recent countries to join the European Union. Democracy is
a reality, and the current prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan,
leads a party whose members openly refer to themselves as "Muslim
Democrats." Under Erdogan, there has been a wave of legal and
administrative reforms designed to qualify Turkey for EU membership.

But all this threatens both the rigidly secular ideology and the
autocratic privileges of the old republican elite.

>>From their powerful positions in the army, the judiciary and the
bureaucracy, the old republican elite work to undermine the reforms and
to wreck Turkey’s chances of joining the EU. In de facto alliance with
ultra-nationalist right-wing parties that also oppose EU membership,
they incite hatred of minorities, bring false prosecutions against
the advocates of a more open and democratic Turkish society and pursue
the long-term goal of destabilizing the democratic order.

It was they who smuggled the notorious Article 301 into the Criminal
Code when it was being reformed to align Turkish law with EU standards;
they who brought false prosecutions for "insulting Turkishness" against
Hrant Dink, Orhan Pamuk, and other well-known writers, journalists and
scholars; they who spread the lies about what Dink had actually said.

It is they, not some ignorant, angry teenager, who are really
responsible for his death.

But the war is not over yet, and the good guys have not lost. Foreign
Minister Abdullah Gul vowed last November to change or abolish Article
301, and recently 100,000 Turks thronged the streets of Istanbul to
mourn the country’s best-known Armenian and condemn his murderers. et

Gwynne Dyer, an award-winning journalist and documentary maker based
in London, is a regular Egypt Today columnist.>

NKR PM Commissioned To Accelerate Process Of Formation Of Commission

NKR PM COMMISSIONED TO ACCELERATE PROCESS OF FORMATION OF COMMISSION ON COORDINATION OF HYPOTHEC CREDITS’ GRANTING

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
March 7 2007

March 6, in the course of the Nagorno-Karabagh Republic government
sitting PM Anoushavan Danielian commissioned the ministers, chairs
of departments and administrations to submit reports on the spheres
they headed for 2006.

According to the information DE FACTO received at the NKR government’s
Press Office, Anoushavan Danielian had underscored the importance of
strict implementation of long-term, short-term, regional (territorial)
and perspective programs for economy’s development and improving
population’s social conditions.

The government’s head also stated it was necessary to undertake
measures on formation of the NKR state budget for 2008 and urged to
be actively involved in the work. Anoushavan Danielian commissioned
the Ministry of Territorial Administration and Development of
Infrastructures to accelerate the process of formation of the
commission on coordinating the work on hypothec credits’ granting.

At the sitting it was proposed to made modifications and amendments
to the NKR Electoral Code to bring it in line with the Republic
Constitution adopted last December. The corresponding bill, which
was presented by the NKR CEC head Sergey Nasibian, will be placed
for the Parliament’s consideration.

Senate Panel Delays Consideration Of Resolution Condemning Hrant Din

SENATE PANEL DELAYS CONSIDERATION OF RESOLUTION CONDEMNING HRANT DINK ASSASSINATION

DeFacto Agency, Armenia
March 7 2007

The Senate Foreign Relations Committee today delayed the discussion
of a measure, authored by the panel’s chairman Joe Biden (D-DE),
condemning the brutal murder of journalist and human rights activist
Hrant Dink, reported the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA).

The Committee’s top Republican, Richard Lugar (R-IN), called for
the delay in the consideration of S.Res.65 amid heavy pressure from
the Administration to remove references to Dink’s prosecution "under
Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code for speaking about the Armenian
Genocide." The legislation also urges the Turkish government to repeal
this anti-free speech law. The resolution will now be scheduled for
discussion at the Committee’s next business meeting.

"We are troubled that Senator Lugar – apparently acting at the request
of the Administration – has delayed the U.S. Senate’s tribute to the
life and memory of Hrant Dink," said ANCA Executive Director Aram
Hamparian. "We look forward to the panel, at the next opportunity,
rejecting any efforts to block or water down this measure, and passing
it in the form it was introduced."

Following the delay, Senate Foreign Relations Committee Member Chris
Dodd (D-CT) stated, "It is unfortunate that the committee deferred
action on this important resolution. I look forward to voting in
support of the resolution, when the committee considers it at the
next business meeting."

Chairman Biden noted that, "Hrant Dink was a leading voice in Turkey’s
Armenian community and an eloquent advocate for human rights, press
freedom, and reconciliation. His assassination was an outrage and
a tragedy. Hrant’s legacy deserves our respect and his death, our
condemnation."

"Hrant Dink spoke out for tolerance in an era, when voices like his
need to be heard," stated Massachusetts Senator John Kerry. "His
assassination was a terrible crime, which warrants the strong
condemnation of the Congress and the entire international community."

The Government Tries To Ban The ‘Umbrella Commercials’

THE GOVERNMENT TRIES TO BAN THE ‘UMBRELLA COMMERCIALS’

Arminfo
2007-03-07 16:37:00

Armenian Government adopted the amendment to the law on advertisement
banning "umbrella commercials" of brands.

The so-called "umbrella commercials" (UC) is mostly focused against
producers of strong alcoholic drinks and tobacco products – which
advertise their products by means of the goods that do not have
advertising limits. Armenia’s Government says that companies using
UC can mislead consumers and harm health.

US State Department: Corruption Remains Significant Problem In Polic

US STATE DEPARTMENT: CORRUPTION REMAINS SIGNIFICANT PROBLEM IN POLICE AND SECURITY SERVICE OF ARMENIA

Arminfo
2007-03-07 15:10:00

"Corruption remains a significant problem in the police force and
security service of Armenia", it is said in the report of the US
State Department with human rights in Armenia in 2006.

As the State Department’s site reports, the police officers
routinely stopped motorists at roadside checkpoints to extort illegal
"fees." Motorists reported that traffic police generally demanded
approximately $2.80 (1000 drams) to pass a checkpoint. Investigative
journalists alleged that police inspectors and superiors received
a portion of the proceeds from each traffic stop. As a result,
there were no incentives to curb the practice and no efforts by the
government during the year to do so.

There was no dedicated mechanism for investigating police abuse. By law
citizens may sue police in court as they would sue any person against
whom they had an adjudicable complaint. The government reported that
during the year citizens lodged 69 civil complaints against police
in court. Judges decided 26 of those cases in favor of the citizens
and dismissed the remaining 43.

Demirchian Aide Admits Key Condition For Opposition Bloc

DEMIRCHIAN AIDE ADMITS KEY CONDITION FOR OPPOSITION BLOC
By Hovannes Shoghikian

Radio Liberty, Czech Rep.
March 7 2007

A top aide to Stepan Demirchian admitted on Wednesday that
disagreements over who should run for president next year were a
key reason why he refused to form an electoral alliance with several
other opposition leaders.

Demirchian’s talks with them broke down late last month due to a
number of preconditions that were reportedly set by President Robert
Kocharian’s main challenger during the 2003 presidential ballot.

According to opposition sources cited by the media, the chairman
of the People’s Party of Armenia (HZhK) demanded that the would-be
opposition bloc endorse his 2008 presidential run.

Grigor Harutiunian, the number two figure in the HZhK, essentially
confirmed this. "I am stating officially that no specific names
were discussed in connection with 2008," he told reporters. "Stepan
Demirchian’s approaches were as follows: the 2007 parliamentary
elections will be followed by the presidential election of 2008,
and it would be illogical if leaders making up the alliance contest
the presidential election separately."

Harutiunian insisted that this did not constitute an explicit demand
to nominate Demirchian for the presidency. Still, the would-be bloc’s
single presidential candidate would presumably be the man topping
the list of its candidates for the May 12 parliamentary elections.

Demirchian has made no secret of his desire to occupy the top spot,
something which did not sit well with his opposition partners who
also plan presidential runs. At least one of them, Vazgen Manukian,
wanted the bloc to have a collective leadership.

Harutiunian acknowledged that the HZhK also demanded that at least
half of the bloc’s electoral slate be reserved for members of his
party, another reason why the opposition deal fell through. "We could
have demanded more than 50 percent," he said. "During all these years
the HZhK has strengthened its structures, while others have not. Why
should it have been otherwise?"

Manukian’s National Democratic Union (AZhM) and three other parties
failed to cut a deal even without the HZhK, reportedly for similar
reasons. The opposition discord is expected to play into the hands
of Kocharian and his loyalists on election day.