Massis Weekly Online – Volume 27, NO. 7 (1307)

Massis Weekly Online

VOLUME 27, NO. 7 (1307)
SATURDAY, MARCH 10, 2007
—————
– S. D. Hunchakian Party To Contest the May 12 Parliamentary Elections
Separately
– Free Vote ?Key to EU-Armenia Ties?
– SDHP "Sarkis Dkhrouni" Union Presents Results of Corruption Survey
– More Congressmen Sign on HR 106
– ACA Announces Endorsements For Glendale Elections
– Glendale HOMENMEN Chapter Ladies Auxiliary Open House
– Hrant Dink and Armenians in Turkey
– Letter to the Editor of Asbarez
————-

– S. D. Hunchakian Party To Contest the May 12 Parliamentary Elections
Separately

YEREVAN — In an internet web conference organized by the Social
Democrat Hunchakian party?s central board and joined by S.D.H.P
regional board members from six continents, S.D.H.P Armenia
chairwoman, Lyudmila Sargsian, notified the participants that the
Social Democrat Hunchakian Party has registered with RA Central
Electoral Commission and will partake in a proportional system of
the upcoming May parliamentary elections.
Sargsian also addressed the lack of opposition forces to agree upon a
united front against the ruling regime. The S.D.H.P. has been
preparing and organizing throughout Armenia for the past three years
and has chosen to conform itself to the proportional system and not to
take part in the single mandate electoral system. This decision was
made by the party to insure that it does not clash with other
oppositional like-minded individuals and dilute the oppositional votes.
During the elections, Sargsian stated that the 120 year strong S.D.H.P
will adhere to the platform that was agreed upon in the 18th General
Assembly of S.D.H.P World Congress. With the existing situation of
corruption in Armenia, economic electoral oligarchical system,
distrust in judicial bodies, and based on the S. D. H. Party?s
socialist and democratic ideology, the party has concluded that the
establishment of true democracy in Armenia is the most important
endeavor. To achieve economic and social justice in Armenia there must
be democracy, the foundation of which is the peaceful change of
authority through free and just elections.
S.D.H.P considers the principle of the free self-determination of
nations the basis for the resolution of the Artsakh question. The S.
D. Hunchakian Party considers the unification of Mountainous Karabakh
with Armenia or its acquisition of independent status as appropriate.
During negotiations, any land belonging to Armenia cannot be subject
to deals or exchange, either in the form of area, nor as ?passageway?
or ?route.? Any agreement on the resolution of the Artsakh issue must
bear the signature of the legitimate authorities in Artsakh and merit
the consent of Artsakh?s populace.
S.D.H.P considers the duty of the next parliament to focus on
preserving and enhancing national, educational and cultural programs
within the State and the maintaining of an unrelenting stance in the
pursuance of the Armenian Cause.
Official Armenian-Turkish discussion must be conditional on the
recognition of the Genocide.
The future parliament must better extend its national-spiritual
mission, and operate to ensure that Armenian religious centers are
within a non-partisan and non-political existence.
The social, economic, civic and educational demands of the Javakhk
Armenians are just and legitimate. These demands must become a
national concern and be insured and addressed by the Armenian
government.
With the confines of a free and fair electoral process, Sargsian
insured that the 120 year old Social Democrat Hunchakian party will
make great inroads within the next parliament. Twenty nine parties are
competing for 90 proportial-based seats and 173 politicians are
running for the remaining 41 seats that are awarded to individual
candidates.

– Free Vote ?Key to EU-Armenia Ties?

YEREVAN — Armenia will miss an important opportunity to deepen its
relationship with the European Union if it fails to ensure the freedom
and fairness of its parliamentary elections, a visiting senior EU
diplomat warned on Friday.
?It will mean that an opportunity has been lost to build, in the short
and medium terms, a firm relationship based on mutual values and
mutual trust,? Peter Semneby, the EU?s special representative to the
South Caucasus, said of a possible repeat of serious irregularities in
the elections slated for May 12.
Preparations for the crucial polls dominated the agenda of Semneby
latest trip to Yerevan, which involved talks with Prime Minister
Andranik Markarian and other Armenian officials.
Markarian?s office quoted the Brussels-based diplomat as saying that
their proper conduct will be ?critical? for Armenia?s democratization
and European integration. Markarian was reported to assure him that
his government has ?the desire and the will? to hold a first-ever
Armenian election recognized as democratic by the West.
?I haven?t gotten any guarantees, but I have a very strong sense that
the authorities are aware of the importance of the elections,? Semneby
told RFE/RL after the talks. He stressed the fact that it will be the
first major ballot since Armenia?s and neighboring Azerbaijan?s and
Georgia?s inclusion in the EU?s European Neighborhood Policy (ENP)
framework.

– SDHP "Sarkis Dkhrouni" Union Presents Results of Corruption Survey

YEREVAN –In response to the denial of corruption at Universities in
Armenia, the Social Democrat Hunchakian party ?Sarkis Dkhrouni? youth
association conducted a press conference on Tuesday, March 6
presenting evidence disproving the claims made by University leaders.
The youth organization brought forth the rsults of anonymous survey
they conducted which was distributed to students several months ago.
Five percent, about 2000 students, responded to the survey which asked
whether they thought their institution engaged in corrupt practices.
Of every 20 students, 19 admit that corruption is prevalent in their
University. Five percent of those students were from Film and Drama
Universities, 18 percent from Cultural Universities, 42 percent from
Yerevan State University, 75 percent from Linguistics Universities, 79
percent from Teaching Universities, Public Universities made up 81
percent, Medical Universities were 86 percent and Agricultural
Universities made up 96 percent.
The Sarkis Dkhrouni youth association presented these findings to
Levon Lazarian, Minister of Education who has since accepted the
claims. Nareg Sarkissian, Chairman of the youth association stated
that the Minister has called for a formation of an independent board
to investigate the matter closely. Yet the students are once again
facing the denial of the truth.
The first press conference regarding this issue was held on Dec. 10,
2006. Although the Minister of Education has cooperated with the
Sarkis Dkhrouni youth association, board members the Yerevan State
Institution of higher education have yet to accept that corruption is
lurking on university campuses in Armenia.

– More Congressmen Sign on HR 106

The Armenian Council of America Ohio and Texas branchs have expressed
gratitude to heir respective members of Congress for sponsoring House
Resolution 106. The Resolution calls upon the President to ensure that
the foreign policy of the United States reflects appropriate
understanding and sensitivity concerning issues related to human
rights, ethnic cleansing, and genocide documented in the U.S. record
relating to the Armenian Genocide.
On March 1 Congressman Al Green of Texas co-sponsored H.R. 106
becoming the eighth congressman from Texas to do so. On the very same
day Congressman Steven LaTourette from Ohio co-sponsored H.R. 106,
becoming the fourth congressman from Ohio sponsor the House Resolution.
In a statement issued by the Armenian Council of America, the Texas
chapter thanked Congressman Green for co-sponsoring the current
legislation. ?We have been good friends of the congressman and thank
him for his deeds towards H.R. 106.? stated Sarkis Ohanian, chairman
of Texas chapter of the ACA.
Dr. Avedis Kazanjian, Chairman of the ACA mid east states, also
conveyed his enthusiasm in gaining the support of Congressman
LaTourette towards the legislation.
Both recognized that gaining the support of congressional members with
little or no Armenian American constituency has proven to be
increasingly challenging.
?Currently there are only eight out of 32 members of Congress from
Texas who have signed on to H.R. 106,?stated Ohanian. ?With the
increasing pressure of the Turkish government and the fact that the
current administration is headed by a Texan, it has become a
tremendously difficult uphill battle in confronting our (Texas)
legislators to do the right thing,? he added. Dr. Kazanjian also
confirmed that currently there are only four out of 18 members of
Congress from Ohio who have signed on to the legislation. ?Yes it is
an uphill battle, yet we as Armenians have gone through fiercer
struggles and have prevailed.?
?As stated before, the Armenian Genocide resolution will not pass
without the full support of congressional members that do not have a
substantial constituency of Armenian Americans,?
declared Peter Darakjian, Executive Director of the ACA. ?The Armenian
Cause is continuously facing obstacles from all directions. The
current administration is against our Cause, the State Department is
stuck in the cold war mentality adhering to the needs of Turkey, the
Turkish government and its well funded lobbying firms along with the
Turkish media are decimating false information to combat the truth and
our legislation.?
Darakjian expects set backs facing Armenian related legislation in
Congress, such us the delay within the Foreign Relations Committee due
to committee ranking member Richard Lugar?s request that consideration
of S. Res. 65 be held over until the next committee business meeting
will be overcome.
?With the perseverance of Armenian Americans exposing historical truth
we can overcome all obstacles placed against us.? conveyed Darakjian.

– ACA Announces Endorsements For Glendale Elections

GLENDALE — For the upcoming Glendale City Municipal elections on
April 3, the Armenian Council of America-PAC on March 6 announced its
endorsement of current Glendale Unified School Board member Greg
Krikorian and Glendale community activist and former Public
Information Officer for the Glendale Police Department, Chahe
Keuroghelian, for the two City Council seats.
The ACA also announced its endorsement of Elizabeth Manasserian for
one of the two open seats in the Glendale Unified School District
Governing Board.
As for the Glendale Community College Board of Trustees elections, the
ACA is endorsing Tony Tartaglia, a current member of the GCC Board of
Trustees.
?After carefully reviewing the backgrounds of these candidates and
analyzing their views on certain issues relevant to the
Armenian-American community, we can wholeheartedly say that they are
the most qualified candidates,? stated ACA Executive Director Peter
Darakjian. ?We encourage everyone in the community to vote for our
endorsed candidates because we believe they will best represent our
interests as a whole.?
Additionally, ACA board chairman Vasken Khodanian stated, ?Having
worked with these candidates at different capacities in the past and
knowing them on a personal level gives us the confidence we need to
make a sound judgement on their performance in the future.?
Besides endorsing the above officials, ACA is also actively engaged in
educating the Armenian-American community about the importance of
voting including conducting voter registration and urging every
citizen to fulfill their civic duty.
The Armenian Council of America-PAC is a non-partisan federally
registered political action committee dedicated to educating the
Armenian-American community in local political affairs,
as well as actively pursuing Armenian-American participation in their
respective local governments, to support political candidates who
share the values of the Armenian American community.

– Glendale HOMENMEN Chapter Ladies Auxiliary Open House

GLENDALE — The Armenian Athletic Association ?Homenmen? women?s
auxiliary Glendale chapter organized an open house for Homenmen
athletes and their parents on Sunday March 4 at the Glendale central
library auditorium. The event was was attended by young athletes and
parents who wanted to learn more about the organization and its
direction.
Seta Khodanian, master of ceremonies, briefly discussed the 86 year
old history of Homenmen in general and more specifically talked about
Homenmen?s activities in the greater southern California area and in
particular the city of Glendale. She also addressed some of the short
and long range plans of the organization.
Homenmen Glendale chairman Vartan Kojababian addressed the hardship
that parents, community leaders and the youth have gone through in the
past to make Homenmen not only a successful athletic organization, but
also a learning step for youth to partake in professionalism. He
stated that Homenmen creates a platform for discussion in activity
giving youth the necessary skills to become well-informed, active
members and leaders of their community.
Armenian Athletic Association ?Homenmen? women?s auxiliary Glendale
chapter chairwomen Rozin DerTavitian addressed the audience on the
meaning of being a Homenmen member, and following its credo ?Sound
Body, and a Sound Mind.? She added that those who have participated in
Homenmen throughout their youth and into their adulthood have achieved
a higher level of success and happiness in both their personal and
professional lives. Everyone was encouraged to proactively recruit
their friends and family into the organization.

– Hrant Dink and Armenians in Turkey
By Hratch Tchilingirian

The assassination of the Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink on 19
January 2007 and its aftermath highlighted both change and resistance
to change in Turkish society. To understand how far Turkey has
travelled in the past generation, Hratch Tchilingirian examines the
role of Hrant Dink himself in the context of the Armenian community of
which he was voice, critic, and emblem.

On 18 October 1994 a press conference called by the then Patriarch of
the Armenian Church, Karekin Kazanjian, was held at the Armenian
patriarchate in Kumkapi, Istanbul. It was organised to correct what
the church saw as misinformation amounting to a slander campaign
against the Armenian church in particular and the Armenian community
in Turkey in general. The ?highlight? of this campaign was an attempt
by the patriarchate to voice protest against false, even lethal,
accusations in Turkish media and political circles that Armenian
clergymen were supporting Kurdish Workers? Party (PKK) terrorists in
their secessionist struggle against the Turkish state.
A photograph allegedly depicting an Armenian priest in the company of
PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan, widely distributed on posters, was a key
instrument of these accusations. Indeed, shouted slogans such as Apo,
Ermeni pici (?Apo [Öcalan?s nickname], Armenian bastard?) were at the
time commonly heard during nationalist demonstrations and street
protests.
The patriarchate?s communiqué on the matter categorically denied the
existence of any ties between the Armenian community in Turkey and any
terrorist organisation, and explained that the priest in the relevant
photo was not a cleric of the Armenian church. The document went on to
condemn such anti-Armenian insinuations in both print and broadcast
media, expressing the serious concern that such false rumours,
assumptions and misrepresentations were endangering the Armenian
community in Turkey and making the lives of individual Armenians
difficult.
The press conference ? attended by some seventy Turkish and foreign
journalists – was a tense affair. Several journalists harassed the
patriarch with presumptuous questions laced with innuendo about
contentious issues, including the PKK and the Armenian Secret Army for
the Liberation of Armenia
(Asala) – a small, Lebanon-based terrorist group that had killed
thirty-four Turks (mainly diplomats) between 1975 and 1983, mainly in
western Europe. (Asala had no presence, links or any type of backing
among Armenians in Turkey, and minimal support even among diaspora
Armenians).
As the interrogators became increasingly belligerent, a tall figure
forced himself into the heart of the journalistic melèe. ?As a member
of the patriarchate?s press office, I would like to answer that
question?, Hrant Dink announced. He continued: ?Respectable
representatives of the press, we are trying to shake off from our
shoulders a discomfort which causes pressure. It is for this reason
that we are trying to voice our protest against a false claim. Apart
from that, all your questions have been answered many times before.
The Armenians of Turkey are not terrorists and they have never
provided aid to terrorism, from whichever direction that may come.
From now on too, this is the way it is going to be. Armenians will
never support terrorism.
As citizens of this country, we would like to live in peace and
tranquility. This is the message of this press conference. … The
Armenians, all Armenians in the world, especially Armenians in Turkey,
at this moment have only one preoccupation: peace, peace, and peace?
(see Marmara [Istanbul], 19 October 1994).
This was the moment Hrant Dink fully entered public life. The
occasion, the pressure, the times themselves were such that he chose –
publicly, confidently and courageously – to address the ?discomforts?
and ?burdens? put upon his community by the state and a highly
politicised media. It was the moment Hrant Dink openly began to deal
with the dilemma of being simultaneously a citizen
of one country, Turkey, while being part of another nation, Armenia.

A time of silence
It was never going to be easy, for the challenge was at once
institutional, legal, and political. The Armenian community, like that
of other minorities in Turkey, experienced shame, humiliation,
harassment and intimidation across the long decades from the 1950s to
the 1990s without being able to speak up in its defence ? and in a
very different atmosphere to later controversies over Article 301 and
even minimal debate about the genocide of 1915. The Armenian community
in Turkey in this period was characterised by its reclusive existence
and collective silence.
The defining institutions of the Armenian community in Turkey were and
are the church and the school. Both faced (and face) perennial
problems that kept Hrant Dink and his colleagues awake at night. The
interference and heavy handedness of the Turkish government in the
Armenian community?s process of electing a patriarch (in 1990, and
again in 1998) were among the arduous legal problems enmeshing this
key Armenian body. On the second occasion Hrant wrote: ?We are sad …
The (Armenian) community is deeply hurt by the uncertainty created by
the escalation of the senseless crisis about the election of an acting
patriarch. These are trying days … We are observing with shame? (see
?Uzgunuz?, Agos, 21 August 1998).
The situation with the Armenian schools was (and is) no better. Hrant
wrote many columns about the state of Armenian schools in Turkey, and
took special interest in their administration. While criticising his
own community for its shortcomings, he also berated the Turkish
government for imposing numerous administrative restrictions on
minority (and not only Armenian) schools.
Hrant passionately recorded the constant indignities experienced by
Armenian educators. In August 1998 he wrote: ?If I am not mistaken,
it was three years ago … One of the vice-directors of the ministry
of national education?s Istanbul office – who was later convicted of
corruption and bribe-taking – said the following to the
?vice-principals? he appointed (whom the minority schools call
?Turkish vice-principals?): ?You are our eyes and ears … You are to
inform us of even the minutest mistakes that these people make.? He
said this in the presence of the minority school principals, with
total disregard for their dignity and common courtesy.
?… And what was I fantasising all these years … With my
45-year-old brain, I was thinking: ?would, one day, a minister of
national education start the ceremony for the new school year in a
minority school?? Sweet thoughts … My naïveté … Sorry …? (see
?Kinkel ve Valilik?, Agos, 21 August 1998 ? translated excerpts posted
on ).

A voice of dignity
Hrant Dink and his colleagues were symbols as well as agents of change
in relation to the Armenian community in Turkey. They were determined
to express the indignation and resentment they experienced as citizens
of the Republic of Turkey. If society and the political system did not
allow them to voice their fears, concerns, and hopes for their
community and for Turkey, the silence surrounding them – they
believed – must be made audible.
It was to a large extent this combination – of the hunger to speak and
the desire to address the ?existential? problems surrounding the
Armenian church and educational establishments – that sparked the
creation of the bilingual weekly newspaper Agos in April 1996.
The five colleagues who founded Agos were: Diran Bakar, a lawyer; Luiz
Bakar, also a lawyer and (since 1994) the spokesperson of the
patriarchate; Harutiun Sesetian, a businessman; Anna Turay, a
public-relations professional; and Hrant Dink, who at the time owned a
bookshop.
The founding members – as is the case with any equivalent innovative
project – were to have their differences in subsequent years. But at
its heart, Agos (and Hrant in particular) remained consistent in the
effort to open channels of communication and dialogue between the
reclusive – and at times isolated – Armenian community and Turkish
society.
Hrant defined one of the newspaper?s purposes as ?(trying) to identify
and explain our problems to the government and to Turkish society?,
while acknowledging that ?because of this, we sometimes have problems?
(Armenia International Magazine, 11/3, March 2000). His core belief
was that prejudices could be overcome by education and dialogue.
The target of this education and dialogue was not just
misunderstanding and prejudice in Turkish society, but the Armenian
community itself. Hrant?s critical discourse about the Armenian
community, and especially the Armenian patriarchate, was unpopular,
costing him supporters and even friends.
In June 2001, for example, on the occasion of the 1,700th anniversary
of Armenian Christianity, he wrote: ?The Armenian church has suffered
divisions throughout history and it is evident that it has not learned
from its own history.
The ?one nation – one church? rule, which has been repeated almost
everywhere during these last years, is nothing but a slogan void of
content? (see ?Spiritual Chess?, Agos, 1 June 2004 – translated from
Turkish by Anahit Dagci). At the same time, many found his passion,
genuine concern and sincerity disarming. Most people in the Armenian
community saw Agos as a courageous publication where issues related to
Armenian identity and community were discussed with refreshing
openness, reason and a genuine desire to build bridges across large
divides – whether within Turkey, with Armenia or with the diaspora.
In the course of this work, Hrant came to a profound realisation: that
the resolution of the problems of the Armenian community in Turkey was
intimately related to the progress of tolerance, democracy and freedom
in Turkey.

Armenians, here and there
Dogu Ergil observed after Hrant?s death that he had ?aimed to promote
the idea that there are other ethnic-cultural groups in Turkey than
Turks and Muslims, and (that) they can very well blend into the nation
cleansed of stereotypes and biases?. Hrant wanted, said Ergil, to
?defend Armenians against majority fanaticism in Turkey and to defend
Turks/ Turkey against the fanaticism and hypocrisy of foreigners and
diaspora Armenians? (see ??, EU Turkey Civic Commission, 25 January
2007).
In recent years, the ?Armenian issue? – as the problem of the genocide
is referred to in Turkey – had indeed become a central theme in
Hrant?s public discourse. The centrality of the ?Armenian issue?, in
fact, has come to cast a shadow over the other problems of the
Armenian community in Turkey: ownership of property, community
foundations, education of clergy, school administration,
and church elections among them. (Why, for example, should the affairs
of minorities in Turkey still be ?administered? by Turkey?s council of
ministers, interior ministry, the security and intelligence agencies,
and the foreign ministry?).
If the central, heated question of genocide came to dominate
discussion of Armenians and Turkey, it is one that Hrant Dink and a
considerable segment of the Armenian Diaspora could not agree on. On
the eve of the 24 April commemorations in 2002, for example, he
addressed members of the Armenian
diaspora in France in an interview with L?Express newspaper.
?Do not seek Armenian identity among the 1915 graves?, he advised. ?I
am ready to discuss all issues with you … I am proud to be a Turkish
Armenian. I want to represent, with my newspaper, the rebirth of this
society. Armenia will never be safe unless Turkey achieves
democratization. I believe Turkey may be a chance for that young state
which is on the brink of drowning. Tomorrow, thanks to Turkey, Armenia
will get the chance to become neighbors with the European Union.
Turkey is Armenia?s only chance? (Turkish Daily News, 23 April 2002).
More than the semantics of the issue, Hrant?s approach to the issue of
1915 and Turkey-Armenia relations focused on the substance of
reconciliation.
?I know what happened to my grandparents?, he told AFP. ?It does not
matter what you called it: genocide, massacres or deportation? (Agence
France Presse, 8 October 2000). Hrant strongly believed – to the
dismay of many in the diaspora – that the more essential thing was to
influence Turkish public opinion. ?The winning of the empathy and
compassion of the Turkish population is far more important than the
adoption of Armenian resolutions in hundreds of parliaments
elsewhere?. Hrant spent considerable time and energy in seeking to
persuade the diaspora that there is a new dynamic and a new openness
in Turkey, involving an unprecedented interest in and discussion of
Armenian issues. He said that ?this process has been developing very
slowly, just like the democratisation of Turkey?, in a way that
encouraged him to believe that ?the taboo (of 1915) too will be broken?.
Yet anyone who is familiar with ?breaking taboos? in Turkey knows the
extreme dangers involved in such a process.
Hrant himself was well aware of the possible consequences: ?We never
deny our own history. But Armenians (in Turkey) are unable to discuss
it for fear it will harm the community?s existence?
(see Ayla Jean Yackley, ?Turks confront dark chapter of Armenian
massacres?, Reuters, 26 April 2005).
In his response to this predicament, Hrant displayed one of his
largest virtues: courage. As he wrote in open Democracy in 2005:
?Where fear is dominant, it produces symptoms of resistance to change
at all levels of society. The more some people yearn and work for
openness and enlightenment, the more others who are afraid of such
changes struggle to keep society closed. In Turkey, the legal cases
against Hrant Dink, Orhan Pamuk, Ragip Zarakolu or Murat Belge are
examples of how the breaking of every taboo causes panic in the end.
This is especially true of the Armenian issue: the greatest of all
taboos in Turkey, one that was present at the creation of the state
and which represents the principal ?other? of Turkish national
identity? (??, 13 December 2005).
Hrant Dink ?was Turkey in its complexity?, wrote Dogu Ergil. ?He was a
Turk against Armenian extremism and an Armenian against Turkish
extremism.?
The day of Hrant Dink?s funeral was the evidence of how far Turkey had
travelled since that press conference at Istanbul?s Patriarchate in
1994. More than twelve years on, the Ermeni pic epithet hurled by
nationalists was overtaken by the cries of Hepimiz Ermeniz (?We are
all Armenians!?) in the throats of tens of thousands of Turks. Hrant
himself, in his life as much as his death, had played an enormous role
in bringing about that change. He opened the door to a future that
Armenians and Turks must find together.

OpenDemocracy.net

Hratch Tchilingirian is associate
director of the Eurasia Research
Programme at the Judge Business
School, Cambridge University

– Letter to the Editor of Asbarez

After centuries of being subjugated by foreigners, for the past 15
years we have finally become the masters of our own domain, capable of
shaping our own common destiny. Needless to say, the many centuries of
subjugation should serve as a powerful lesson for us to work closer
with each other, in order shape a worthwhile future for ourselves and
generations to come.
Thus, it is utterly incomprehensible as to why an Armenian would label
his fellow kin, who do not share his views, as ?a?holes?, ?idiots?,
?traitors?, who are ?rife with absurdity?, exhibit ?shameless style?,
?emit moribund rales? and who ?ought to be in rehab?. Unfortunately,
that is what Mr. Garen Yegparian has stated in his article published
in the February 24, 2007 issue of your publication. It truly saddens
us to find out that on the very same day of Hrant Dink?s
assassination, a man who championed dialogue even between enemies, Mr.
Yegparian has gone to the vigil not to pay his respects to the fallen
martyr, but to count how many people were in attendance.
The history of human civilization has shown that real progress is
achievable only through the clash of differing opinions and not by the
imposition of one?s views over others.
While we strongly condemn Mr. Yegparian?s vitriolic diatribes and
disagree with his views, we would not call for him to be put into
rehab, but rather be showcased as a role model. To achieve progress,
some role models ought to be followed, while others should be avoided
at all cost. Mr. Yegparian falls in the latter category.

Respectfully,
Gaidz Youth Organization

—
Massis Weekly Online
MassisWeekly.com
1060 N. Allen Ave, Suite 203
Pasadena, CA 91104
Tel. 626.797.7680
Fax. 626.797.6863

http://MassisWeekly.com

Catholicos of All Armenians Meets with Chief Minister of West Bengal

PRESS RELEASE
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin, Information Services
Address:  Vagharshapat, Republic of Armenia
Contact:  Rev. Fr. Ktrij Devejian
Tel:  +374-10-517163
Fax:  +374-10-517301
E-Mail:  [email protected]
Website: 
March 9, 2007

Catholicos of All Armenians Meets with Chief Minister of West Bengal

Reception Held in Honor of His Holiness Karekin II

On the afternoon of February 28, as part of his continuing Pontifical Visit
to India, His Holiness Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos of All
Armenians, met with the Chief Minister of the State of West Bengal, the
Honorable Buddhadeb Bhattacharya.  The Chief Minister welcomed His Holiness
to West Bengal, and reflected on the great role the Armenian community of
India has had in the social, cultural and economic development of Kolkata. 
He spoke of the high esteem and admiration with which the Armenians of India
are regarded and expressed hope that the once large population, which has
diminished in recent years, would once again grow and flourish.

The Catholicos of All Armenians expressed his appreciation to the Chief
Minister for his kind words and spoke of the centuries-old relationship
between Armenia and India.  The Armenian Pontiff also highly evaluated the
friendship between the two peoples and expressed his pleasure at the number
of Indian students currently studying in Yerevan.  His Holiness thanked the
Chief Minister and all state authorities of India for the careful attention
that is accorded to all religious and ethnic minorities, among them the
Armenians, allowing them to prosper and create, thereby becoming worthy
citizens of the Indian Republic, and contributing members of the societal,
national and cultural life of India.

Also discussed during the meeting were the spheres of cooperation between
the Republics of Armenia and India and the current status of the Armenian
College and Philanthropic Academy and the Armenian churches, cemeteries and
monuments in the State of West Bengal.

Accompanying His Holiness during the visit with the Chief Minister were His
Eminence Abp. Aghan Baliozian, His Excellency Ambassador Ashot Kocharian,
Very Rev. Fr. Oshagan Gulgulian, Rev. Fr. Ktrij Devejian, and local Armenian
Church Committee members Haik Sookias, Jr., Susan Reuben and Sunil Sobti.

* * *

That same evening, a reception was hosted in honor of His Holiness by the
Church Committee.  Among the invitees were members of the Armenian
community, as well as representatives of Indian society who are associated
with the Armenian College and Philanthropic Academy and the Armenian
churches and community of India.

During the program, Church Committee Chairman Haik Sookias, Jr. welcomed His
Holiness to Calcutta and thanked the Catholicos of All Armenians for
blessing the Armenians of India with his historic visit, noting that they
have greatly yearned for the visit of the Armenian Pontiff for more than 40
years, since Catholicos Vasken I came to India in 1963.

Ambassador Kocharian also addressed the guests and spoke of the growing ties
and developing relationship between the Republics of Armenia and India, and
mentioned the increasing levels of collaboration between the two countries
in economic and educational spheres.  The ambassador also noted the great
honor he has enjoyed in accompanying the worldwide head of the Armenian
Church throughout the course of his visit to this remarkable Armenian
community.

Following the ambassador’s remarks, in his introduction of the Catholicos of
All Armenian, Rev. Fr. Ktrij Devejian spoke of the current activities of the
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin since independence and specifically during
the pontificate of His Holiness Karekin II.  He stressed the importance
placed by His Holiness on the spheres of Christian education and ministry,
social services, the preparation of a new generation of clergy, and cultural
and youth programs.

The Catholicos of All Armenians extended his pontifical blessings and love
to all of the gathered guests and thanked them for their devotion to the
faith of their forefathers and their fidelity to the Mother See of Holy
Etchmiadzin.  His Holiness exhorted those present to keep the Armenian
College and Philanthropic Academy as a priority in their community life,
stressing that the only future for the Armenians of India are the children
currently enrolled and studying a the Academy.  He also expressed his
appreciation to the organizers of this working pontifical visit and his
thanks to the Indian people for their warm hospitality and welcoming nature
which has allowed Armenians to live their creative and worthy lives in India
for more than 500 years.

The evening concluded with His Holiness offering a prayer of praise and
thanksgiving for the friendship and brotherhood between the Armenian and
Indian peoples, and asking Almighty God to grant peace to the entire world,
reconciliation to all nations and love and charity to all of His children.

www.armenianchurch.org

Pamuk to receive honorary doctorate from Berlin’s Free University

PanARMENIAN.Net

Pamuk to receive honorary doctorate from Berlin’s Free University
09.03.2007 12:45 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Turkish Nobel literature laureate Orhan Pamuk’s
German publisher said on Thursday he would visit Germany in May for a
reading tour which was planned for February but reportedly cancelled
for security reasons. "We are delighted that Orhan Pamuk is prepared
so soon already to carry out the visit cancelled on short notice in
February," Carl Hanser Publishing said. German newspapers had said the
writer called off the trip because he feared for his life after the
murder in January of ethnic Armenian journalist Hrant Dink in
Istanbul, but Pamuk did not confirm the reports. Dink is believed to
have been killed by ultra-nationalists in revenge for remarks he made
about the massacre of Armenians under the Ottoman empire, reports the
AFP.

Pamuk, the author of "Snow" and other novels mulling Turkey’s clash
between Muslim and Western culture, has angered Turkish authorities
with similar remarks. He was prosecuted for telling a Swiss magazine
that 30,000 Kurds and a million Armenians had been killed during World
War I under the Ottoman Turks, but the case was dropped on a
technicality. Pamuk’s tour of Germany will begin in Hamburg on May 2
and will also take in Berlin, Cologne, Munich and Stuttgart. He will
receive an honorary doctorate from Berlin’s Free University on May 4.

Turkish nationalists were going to kill Archbishop Mutafyan?

PanARMENIAN.Net

Turkish nationalists were going to kill Archbishop Mutafyan?
09.03.2007 12:52 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ A Turkish man accused of firing in the air outside
an Armenian church claimed Wednesday his real target had been
Patriarch Mesrob II, the spiritual leader of the tiny Armenian
community. "I had prepared it for (Mesrob) Mutafyan II," Volkan Karova
shouted to reporters here as he and fellow suspect Yilmaz Can Ozalp
were being escorted to the prosecutor’s office to give their
testimony, the agency reported. It was not clear whether he had
intended to physically attack the patriarch or scare him.

Later Wednesday, a court charged the two men with "threatening by
firing shots" and "carrying an unlicensed gun" and sent them to jail
pending trial, the agency said. The pair had been arrested late Sunday
just hours after two men fired a shot in the air outside a church in
the city’s Kumkapi district. At the time, a ceremony was being held
there for slain ethnic Armenian journalist Hrant Dink. The ceremony at
the church, on the European side of Istanbul, was to mark the 40th day
since Dink, the 52-year-old ethnic Armenian editor of the bilingual
Agos weekly, was shot dead outside his office. It was led by Patriarch
Mesrob II, who represents the 80,000 Armenians in Turkey. Anxiety has
engulfed the Armenian community and intellectuals since Dink’s murder
on Januray 19, and in recent interviews Mesrob II has said that his
office had been receiving threats. Dink had angered nationalist
circles and the courts for describing the World War I massacres of
Armenians under the Ottoman Empire as genocide, a label that Ankara
fiercely rejects. Nine people have so far been charged over his
murder, which prosecutors believe was the work of ultra-nationalists,
reports the AFP.

Azerbaijan-Armenia matches will probably take place in neutral field

PanARMENIAN.Net

Azerbaijan-Armenia matches will probably take place in neutral field
09.03.2007 12:57 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ UEFA President Michel Platini has completed his
two-day business visit to Georgia. At a press conference Platini took
a stance on the Azerbaijan-Armenia match in Group A of European
championship qualifying. `Azerbaijan-Armenia matches will probably
take place in a neutral field’, he said. UEFA president stated that
he had acquainted himself with the positions of Azerbaijan and
Armenia. `We have received proposals by Azerbaijani and Armenian
National Associations. The issue will be solved in near future in
Geneva’, he underscored.

Azerbaijani and Armenian national teams are to meet on Sep. 8 in Baku
and Sep. 12 in Yerevan, reports APA-Sport.

Euro Parliament refused to condemn French bill on Armenian Genocide

PanARMENIAN.Net

European Parliament refused to condemn French bill on Armenian Genocide
09.03.2007 13:41 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ The European Parliament has refused to condemn the
French bill making it a crime to deny the Armenian Genocide. As
reported by the Armenian European Federation (EAFJD), November 13,
2006 three European parliamentarians introduced a statement `On the
passage of the French bill criminalizing denial of the Armenian
Genocide of 1915′. Late February the statement was signed by 38 out of
785 parliamentarians and the document wasn’t consequently put on the
agenda. The statement reads regret at the adoption of the bill that
`doesn’t contribute to the activities of those who struggle for
respect for freedom of speech and expression in Turkey.’ The authors
of the statement consider that the passing of the French bill `will
have a negative impact on the Turkish-Armenian relations and will
create a dangerous precedent in the form of punishment for the events
not officially recognized by all interested sides. EAFJD Executive
director Loran Leylekian said that Hrant Dink’s murder should be a
lesson for those who fight against recognition of the Armenian
Genocide and adoption of the bill criminalizing its denial. These
people are responsible for creation of atmosphere of hatred for
Armenians, according to him.

US radars in Europe, Caucasus don’t pose technical threat to Russia

PanARMENIAN.Net

The US radar stations in Europe and the Caucasus don’t pose any
technical threat to Russia

Countries in the Southern Caucasus, and even Georgia, displayed rare
unanimity and cautiousness towards the issue
04.03.2007 GMT+04:00

The Caucasus is in turmoil and the possible reason is Iran and in some
way Russia. Talks about `the new cold war’, which have lately become
more frequent, and the challenges the USA has to face regarding the
failures in Iraqi war, may indeed change the power balance not in the
region only, but in Europe too. The USA’s intentions to locate radar
stations in the Caucasus and in the Central Europe have become a
suitable ground for recurrent loud announcements made by Russian
military men and diplomats.

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Announcements, if they are appropriate at all in
this case, must be made by the countries on which territories the
radar station is planned to be establishment, which by the way is the
pleasure not any country can afford. But the Russian Federation, on
account of the imperial ambitions left, has decided to take the lead
over the rest and to once again give `an adequate answer’. It should
be reminded, that the Pentagon, according to the announcement made by
the Director of the Missile Defense Agency Lieutenant General Henry
Obering, would like to have a radar station in the frames of the
establishing missile defense system in the Caucasus. As for the
countries in the Southern Caucasus, and even Georgia, they all
displayed rare unanimity and cautiousness towards the issue. According
to the representative of the Armenian Ministry of Foreign Affairs,
Armenia hasn’t received any official calls from the USA regarding the
establishment of missile defense system in the territory of the
republic. It was also announced in the RA Ministry of Defense that the
issue of locating missile defense system isn’t discussed.

The Georgian Ministry of Defense refrains from making any comments
about the possibility of emplacing US missile defense radar system in
one of the countries in the Southern Caucasus. `We will not make any
comments on this issue yet. Perhaps something will change and we will
make official announcement’, said the public relations officer of the
Georgian Ministry of Defense in answer to the question whether or not
Georgia conducts negotiations with the USA on the issue of the radar
system establishment in the territory. In its turn the Ministry of
Defense of Azerbaijan denied the information about the possibility of
emplacing radars of the US missile defense in the territory of their
republic. By the way, three radar stations – one Russian and two
American – already exist in the territory of Azerbaijan. And if the US
radar station in Azerbaijan covers only the Middle East and the
Persian Gulf, the Russian radar station is considered one of the
largest ones in the world. In essence, the stations should be
established in Georgia. Armenia falls out for several reasons;
basically it is the availability of Russian military base and the
relief. The most interesting part of the whole story is that the
missile defense system is by no means against Russia. According to
research specialist at Paris-based Strategic Research Foundation Bruno
Grusselle the system aims at defense against Iran. In his interview he
states, `The shortest way between Tehran and Washington runs through
Central Europe. The planisphere distorts the distance that is why it
gives a quite different result.’ As for the supposed competence Russia
may face, the French expert thinks that the missile defense system,
which the Americans are establishing in California, Alaska and in
Europe, can’t pose any technical threat to the Russian systems, which
are distinguished with their large number and their high
manufacturability. `It cannot represent any technical threat, at least
because it is not situated in the right place. The missiles that
Russia may fire at the United States will be headed to north across
the Arctic, that’s why the American radar station in Tula and
Greenland is of great significance. Missile defense system aims at
protecting the American territory from any threats coming from Iran
and North Korea. Only ten interceptors will be emplaced in
Poland. Quite enough to intercept antediluvian missile’, emphasized
Gruselle. In a word the whole matter is in Iran. Iran is supposed to
be placing missiles with the range of 2 – 3000 kilometers. A missile
launched by Iran must be of range of 9 – 10000 kilometers to reach the
territory of the United States. Iran doesn’t possess such missiles and
it is very unlikely to have one of the mentioned ranges by the year of
2020. But in any case the American missile defense system will not be
put in operation by the year of 2012. As for Armenia, though it may
sound rather paradoxical, it will only benefit from the given
situation, since its safety is provided not only by the Russian
military base, but by NATO as well. True, this is only a supposition,
but it may turn out to be very close to the reality.

PanARMENIAN.Net» analytical department

Has "Jermuk Group" Overstepped the Limits?

A1+

HAS "JERMUK GROUP" OVERSTEPPED THE LIMITS?
[02:08 pm] 09 March, 2007

The U.S. food and medicine agency has disseminated information that
`Jermuk’ mineral water (imported from Armenia) contains arsenic which
is dangerous for health.

Edgar Ghazaryan, adviser to the president of `Jermuk’ Group, claims
they have been exporting mineral water to the U.S. market since 2000
and haven’t countered any problems so far. He says `Jermuk’ Group has
received no written notification by the U.S. officials.

According to the data of the agency, each liters of Jermuk contains
500-600- microgram arsenic. To remind, under the criteria of the
agency, the arsenic mustn’t surpass 10 micrograms in each liter.

«Arsenic exists in all mineral waters produced in Armenia and it
provides the curing quality of the water. We haven’t exceeded the
permissible bounds’ states Edgar Ghazaryan and adds that the
announcement hasn’t named any concrete Armenian company.

Armenian Residents of Tsalka Keep Decreasing

A1+

ARMENIAN RESIDENTS OF TSALKA KEEP DECREASING
[12:30 pm] 09 March, 2007

According to the statistic data of 2006, the population of Tsalka was
22600, among them 11000 Armenians, 8000 Georgians, 1500 Greeks, 1800
Azeris and 300 representatives of other nationalities, `Bagin-Info’
News Agency reports.

Prior to the collapse of the USSR, Greeks formed 75 percent of the
population. The census of 1979 revealed that there were 31000 Greeks
in Tsalka.

In 1979 – 2006 the Georgian residents of Tsalka increased by 7000
whereas the Armenians decreased by 3000 and the Greeks – by 30 000.

The increase of the Georgian population is determined by the policy of
the Georgian authorities. The point is that the Georgian residents of
Ajaria and Svanetia have been migrating to Tsalka since 1990 to find
shelter from natural calamities.

To note, most of the immigrants are not registered. According to some
non-official sources, there are currently 12000 Georgian residents in
Tsalka.

It is noteworthy that over the past 27 years the population of Tsalka
has increased in favor of the Georgians who outnumber the local Greeks
and Armenians.

Ernest Sogomonyan Is Not the Leader of SDHP

A1+

ERNEST SOGOMONYAN IS NOT THE LEADER OF SDHP
[12:50 pm] 09 March, 2007

Ernest Sogomonyan is the 13th in the proportional ticket of the
`Prosperous Armenia’ Party. To note, he is introduced as the leader of
the Social-Democratic Hnchakian Party (SDHP) and an associate
professor of the RA Academy of Management.

Ludmila Sargsyan, leader of central board of the SDHP, made an
announcement in this respect. `There is a rumor that Ernest
Sogomonyan, `leader’ of the SDHP, will run for the parliamentary
elections under the proportional ticket of the `Prosperous Armenia’
Party. I want to refute the rumor that Ernest Sogomonyan is the
leader of the SDHP. The party has exiled him; Mr. Sogomonyan is not a
SDHP member either in Armenia or in the Diaspora’, Mrs. Sargsyan
states.

To remind; Ernest Sogomonyan is the father of Viktor Sogomonyan,
spokesman for Armenian President Robert Kocharyan.