ANKARA: Shaw: ICJ’s Serbian Genocide Verdict Does Not Improve The St

SHAW: ICJ’S SERBIAN GENOCIDE VERDICT DOES NOT IMPROVE THE STANDING OF THE COURT
Selcuk GultaªLi Brussels

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
March 10 2007

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling on Bosnia has created
waves of intense debate, not only in Bosnia and Serbia but all over
the world.

As the ICJ cleared Serbian state of genocide, both Bosnian victims
and many scholars criticized the verdict as being political.

Professor Martin Shaw of Sussex University, one of the leading
experts of the issue, has strongly condemned the decision and
accused the ICJ of "engaging in the systematic denial of the Bosnian
Genocide." Professor Shaw answered our questions:

In your article "The International Court of Justice: Serbia, Bosnia
and Genocide," posted on the opendemocracy.net Web site, you argue:
"It is not too strong to say that in this case, the International
Court of Justice has engaged in systematic denial of the Bosnian
genocide." It is quite a tough statement.

Clearly the International Court of Justice did recognize that
genocide occurred at Srebrenica and indicted Serbia with its failure
to prevent the massacre there. This is important. However, while the
court recognized that acts that could constitute genocide had been
committed by Serbian nationalists across Bosnia throughout the years
1992-1995, it produced unconvincing, inconsistent legal reasons for
saying that genocide had not generally occurred. Thus I argue that
the court denied the full scale of the Bosnian genocide — because
it recognized genocide at Srebenica, this was a partial denial of
the Bosnian genocide, but a serious failure nonetheless.

Is this verdict a purely technical one or a political one? How one
can make that distinction?

The court argued its verdict in legal terms. However, because of the
unconvincing character of its legal arguments, one is bound to ask
whether political factors influenced the verdict.

If the decision was not taken not on purely legal grounds, what are
the other considerations?

Clearly the court could have wanted to avoid a verdict that would
have provoked further political conflict inside Serbia, where the
situation is currently delicate. But we cannot be certain that this
sort of consideration influenced the verdict.

Anthony Dworkin, also writing for opendemocracy.net, has criticized
your approach and implies that genocide is something serious and
cannot be applied wherever you like. He also argues that the Serbs’
intentions regarding the Bosnians were far from clear.

I agree that genocide is a serious charge. This is why it must not
be applied lightly — nor must it be rejected or minimized without
good reason. I think the Serbian intentions to destroy the Bosnian
Muslim and Croat communities, in the areas of Bosnia-Herzegovina that
the Serbian nationalists controlled or conquered, were very clear and
consistent from the widespread policies of expulsion, murder and rape
that they adopted from 1992 onwards. And they were, and still are,
largely successful — only a small number of non-Serbs remain in the
so-called Republika Srpska inside Bosnia.

As you said in your article: "Yet in relation to the Srebrenica
massacre, the ICJ ‘sees no reason to disagree’ with the finding of
the [International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia] that
these acts constituted genocide." How can one possibly explain this?

It seems to me that this is a compromise verdict. The court upheld
the Bosnian claim that genocide was committed at Srebrenica, but in
other respects upheld the Serbian view that genocide had not been
committed. So both sides gained something.

Do you think the confidence in the court will now be in jeopardy with
the latest verdict?

This kind of verdict does not improve the standing of the court.

How do you think the verdict will contribute to the healing process
in the region?

I think the verdict will not help much since it is inconsistent and
enables both sides to stick to their original positions, saying they
have won something.

Do you think this verdict has once more punished Bosnians who were
victims and rewards the Serbian state by clearing it from the "crime
of crimes," i.e., genocide?

It is too strong to say that this has rewarded Serbia, since clearly
there are some serious indictments of it and there is more pressure to
yield Ratko Mladic to the Hague. But the Serbian state has certainly
escaped the more serious consequences that could have followed if
Bosnia’s case had been fully successful.

Have Bosnian Muslims interpreted the verdict as yet another decision of
the West against Muslims? How do you react to the Bosnians’ evaluation?

I think this is too simple. This was an international court with judges
drawn from a wide range of countries. And it does still reinforce
the prevailing view that the Serbians were the main criminals in the
Bosnian war and the Muslims the main victims.

Muslims in Europe, citing the cartoons of the Prophet of Islam
and the war in Iraq, argue that this verdict will not help in the
dialogue between civilizations. Do you think the verdict can have
such implications?

Genocide should not be an issue between civilizations. Muslims were
victims in Bosnia, but they were also victims in Iraq when Saddam’s
regimes massacred Kurds, and they are victims there today when Sunni
militias kill Shia, and Shia militias kill Sunnis. Muslims can be
perpetrators of genocide as well as victims; Christians can be victims
as well as perpetrators. From a human point of view we have to stop
all genocide — whoever commits it and whoever is the victim.

Another popular question among Muslims is if the Bosnians were
Christians and the Serbs Muslims, would the verdict be the same?

International courts and authorities often avoid recognizing genocide
whoever the victims are — look at Rwanda, where the UN turned away
from helping the Tutsis, who were mostly Christians. This weakness
of international institutions is not to do with anti-Muslim ideas.

Turkey has been accused of the Armenian "genocide" with no court
decision and you have referred to the events of 1915 as genocide in
your book "War and Genocide: Organized Killing in Modern Society?" Do
you think the court decision can create a jurisprudence for similar
cases? If Turkey goes to international arbitration, for example,
do you think it can be exonerated?

The International Court of Justice decision arose because Bosnia took
a case against Serbia to the court. In relation to the events of 1915,
no such case can now arise: this is now a matter for history rather
than law. However, just as Serbia will not be a healthy society until
it recognizes the Serbian state’s responsibility for genocide in Bosnia
and Kosovo, so Turkey will not be a healthy society until it abandons
the denial of the Ottoman genocide against the Armenians. Nearly
a century on, it should be possible for modern Turkish democracy to
fully acknowledge that this crime was committed, and to say that Turkey
today is a society in which this kind of policy will never again arise.

I don’t think I can answer your question about international
arbitration, as I don’t know enough about it. I’m not sure in any case
that the issues arising from the Armenian genocide are necessarily
issues between modern Turkey and modern Armenia, although if both sides
favored that, it could help. The ICJ decision by itself is only one
decision in the international jurisprudence of genocide, and needs
to be seen with other decisions by the tribunals and the new ICC.

Do you think it is wise to legislate laws to punish the deniers of
genocides or to legislate on historical events?

No, in general I think that it is better to deal with genocide denial
through argument and education than through law.

–Boundary_(ID_YMYzSXTIe+Nts2zLQwb26A)–

Turkish Leader Guilty Of Genocide Denial

TURKISH LEADER GUILTY OF GENOCIDE DENIAL

The News – International, Pakistan
March 10 2007

GENEVA: A Swiss court on Friday found a Turkish leader guilty of
denying the Armenian genocide, the first time Switzerland’s anti-racism
law has been applied to the World War I slaughter.

Turkish Workers’ Party leader Dogu Perincek received a suspended jail
sentence of 90 days or an equivalent fine from the Lausanne court as
well as a fine of 3,000 Swiss francs (1,900 euros).

Perincek had described the Armenian genocide under the Ottoman Empire
as an "international lie" at a Turkish rally in the Swiss city in 2005.

The Turkish government also fiercely rejects the genocide label and
the issue has sparked diplomatic tensions with Switzerland in the past.

Judge Pierre-Henri Winzap called Perincek an "arrogant provocateur"
in his ruling at the end of a week-long trial, adding that he had
"racist and nationalist motives".

Lausanne was also the site of the international conference and treaty
signed in 1923 which sealed the break-up of the Ottoman Empire and
the birth of the modern Turkish state.

Winzap said the Armenian genocide was "a proven historical fact
according to Swiss public opinion" and the fact that it was not listed
as a genocide by an international court did not rule out its reality.

He also ruled that Perincek made two speeches in May 2005 in the full
knowledge that he would be breaking the law.

Charges against Perincek were pressed under Swiss anti-racism law,
which includes an offence of denial of genocide or crimes against
humanity, following a complaint by a Swiss-Armenian group.

The verdict marks the first time that the 1995 law was applied to
the massacre of Armenians, said Doris Angst of Switzerland’s official
anti-racism watchdog.

"The commission welcomes the fact that the issue has been clarified
in a certain way with this ruling," the secretary of the Federal
Commission Against Racism told AFP.

Perincek said afterwards that he would appeal the verdict of
Lausanne’s magistrates court. "I will appeal this decision. I still
have confidence in Swiss justice. We will take it to the end to the
European Court of Human Rights if necessary," he told the Anatolian
news agency.

"This decision reflects in a concrete manner the Swiss judge’s hatred
for Turkey and the Turkish nation," he added.

In 2001, a court in the capital Bern acquitted 12 Turks facing
similar charges.

However, two years later the Swiss lower house of parliament formally
recognised the massacre of Armenians during World War I as genocide,
despite fierce protests from Turkey.

Perincek argued in court that he had not committed an offence with
his statements during the rally, insisting there had been no genocide
in 1915.

Swiss anti-racism law was not applicable in the Armenian case while
it was fully justified for the Holocaust in World War II, claimed
the Turkey-based militant.

ANKARA: Two Turks Fined For Insulting, Threatening Armenian Patriarc

TWO TURKS FINED FOR INSULTING, THREATENING ARMENIAN PATRIARCH

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
March 10 2007

A Turkish court fined two men for insulting and threatening Patriarch
Mesrob II, the spiritual leader of the Turkey’s small Armenian
community yesterday.

Gokmen Akman was given a fine of YTL 1,287 ($910 dollars) on charges
of both insulting and threatening the patriarch, while Hasan Ezer
was sentenced to pay YTL 77 Turkish ($55) for just insulting Mesrob
II, the Anatolia news agency reported. According to the indictment,
the two men sent e-mails to the patriarch in October 2004 which read
"We will finish you off" and "We will drive you crazy."

Turkey’s 80,000-strong Armenian community, which lives mainly in
Ýstanbul, generally keeps a low profile for fear of becoming a
target for ultra-nationalists in light of the alleged World War I
massacres of Armenians under the Ottoman Empire. Armenians describe the
1915-1918 massacres as genocide, a label that the Republic of Turkey
— the Ottoman Empire’s successor — fiercely rejects. In January,
ethnic Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, criticized for his views on
the alleged Armenian massacres, was shot dead outside his office in
a murder which prosecutors believe was the work of ultra-nationalists.

Since then, anxiety has engulfed the Armenian community, and in
recent interviews Mesrob II has said that his office had been
receiving threats.

–Boundary_(ID_Q4fVkQR2cP82MWrdlf+JcA)–

TEHRAN: Armenia Rejects U.S. Missile Plan

ARMENIA REJECTS U.S. MISSILE PLAN

PRESS TV, Iran
March 9 2007

Amidst rumors of U.S. interest to deploy a missile defense system
in Armenia, Armenian deputy foreign minister Arman Kirakosyan has
announced that he will not welcome the plan in his country.

"I would like to make an official statement that we have not received
any inquiries or proposals on that score from the U.S. or NATO
commanders," Kirakosyan said.

However, on 1st March, a senior Pentagon official announced interest
in approaching ex-Soviet republics like Georgia and Azerbaijan on
U.S.’s missile plan, with Armenia now added to the list.

Both Georgia and Azerbaijan have stated they are not aware of any
such plans nor have they been approached by the United States.

Russia is vehemently against any deployment of a U.S. missile defense
system, especially in any ex-Soviet states, stating that it will
jeopardize national security in the region.

Washington claims the system will counter any possible missile
threat from countries such as North Korea and Iran while Russian army
officials who do not believe them, advise the United States to look
at the maps to see how far Iran and Korea are to Europe.

Presidential spokesman: opposition used airtime for poll campaign

Armenian presidential spokesman says opposition used airtime for poll
campaign

Hayots Ashkharh, Yerevan
10 Mar 07, p3

Armenian presidential spokesman Viktor Sogomonyan has said that there
are not serious problems with freedom of speech in the country. In an
interview with the Armenian newspaper Hayots Ashkharh Sogomonyan
denied media reports which allege that opposition was not given
airtime ahead of the parliamentary election. He said that monitoring
funded by the Council of Europe showed that opposition members were
given airtime, and if need be they could provide recording of those TV
programmes as a proof. The presidential spokesman also said that the
authorities were not to blame for internal disagreements within the
opposition. The following is an excerpt from Sogomonyan’s interview
with the newspaper on 10 March; subheadings inserted editorially:
Various politicians and certain international organizations
occasionally say that in Armenia the opposition is deprived of an
opportunity to express its views from television and radical leaders
are not given airtime on private TV companies.
The office of the presidential spokesperson has been monitoring this
sphere since 1 April 2006. The results of the monitoring were posted
at the website of the Foreign Ministry.
[Viktor Sogomonyan] We watched private TV broadcasts to keep a record
of which politicians appeared on TV and how many times they
participated in this or that political broadcast. We then asked these
companies to give us video of the mentioned broadcasts and compared it
with our data. We mainly watched such TV companies as Kentron, Shant,
Yerkir Media, etc. that actively broadcast political programmes and
added other companies, which also occasionally broadcast political
programmes, to their list.
Those who speak about the suppression of freedom of speech in Armenia
can look at the results of the monitoring. We are ready to give them
video copies if they do not believe. Our monitoring mainly focused on
opposition leaders and opposition MPs.
Monitoring shows opposition given airtime
[Correspondent] Did representatives of the authorities or the
pro-government politicians use the private TV air more than others?
[Sogomonyan] To be honest, we did not count. The point is that the
results of the monitoring absolutely refute the "rumours" that the
opposition is denied airtime in the private TV companies since all the
TV channels are controlled by the presidential
administration. Incidentally, the Caucasus Mass Media Institute also
held this kind of monitoring using the grant from the Council of
Europe and registered almost the same results. That is to say, it saw
that a fairly wide spectrum of pluralism is provided in Armenia.
Let me note that we did not watch news bulletins which also regularly
covered various episodes of the activity of the opposition leaders
and political forces – news conferences, debates, round tables,
etc. In that case a "contradictory" question could arise: Have you
seen foreign private TV companies broadcast news conferences of all
opposition members? I watched TV programmes of various foreign
companies but did not see broadcasts of this kind.
Certainly, I do not pretend to say that our private TV companies are
freer than foreign TV companies are. It is clear that there are
standards here too and they are mainly connected with journalists’
professionalism. Anyway, it is obvious that there are not serious
problems connected with freedom of speech in Armenia. I should say
that we held this monitoring just to have a common view. And we think
that the results of the monitoring should be made public so that
people know the situation.
"Black PR" against authorities
[Correspondent] As I know, the results of the monitoring of Radio
Liberty’s broadcasts were also presented. Is the information balanced
in this case too? [Sogomonyan] Yes, we monitored Radio Liberty too,
and its top leadership as well as the US Embassy are aware of the
results. Here the situation is absolutely different – the opposition
emphasized "privilege" in the news broadcasting of Radio Liberty. We
also noticed that there was an open black PR against the authorities
and pro-power parties here.
I should say that it is difficult to find any positive programme in
the Armenian service of Radio Liberty which tells about any positive
event taking place in Armenia. No comment.
[Correspondent] Your opponents say that there is freedom of speech in
Armenia but only within the "mentioned" limits and not for everybody.
[Sogomonyan] If this or that politician is not seen on TV, it is TV
companies not you or me who should be asked about why they do not
invite this politician but invite that one. I can only assume that
perhaps these people are of no interest to the public. We do not
assess or comment on this, we just recorded what happened.
Authorities not to blame for opposition’s internal problems
[Correspondent] The opposition leaders say that with your help the
presidential administration is negotiating with false oppositionists
and it played an active role in the fact the opposition failed to
unite. What can you say about this?
[Sogomonyan] I am afraid that in this case as well they are trying to
blame the authorities for problems and disagreements within the
opposition. I prefer not to comment on this. Let them settle their
relations. It is not the first time that this accusation is voiced
against the authorities, and I do not think that it will be the last
one. There is the political development which the authorities treat
very calmly. As for the process of this development and its
peculiarities, it is society but not the authorities or the opposition
who will determine it.
[Passage omitted: the results of the monitoring are presented]

Armenian opposition movement stages another election rally

Armenian opposition movement stages another election rally

Arminfo
9 Mar 07

Yerevan, 9 March: Leaders of the Alternative public movement and the
Impeachment bloc intend to continue rallies in central Yerevan until
the number of their participants reaches at least 50,000.

"I am happy that I am not alone on this square. The power of skinheads
forces to make Armenians feel alone in their homeland. We will stand
on this square until all people who consider themselves worthy
citizens and feel responsibility for the future of the country will
leave their armchairs and join us," the editor of Haykakan Zhamanak
newspaper and one of the leaders of the Impeachment bloc has said from
the rostrum of Alternative’s rally.

He said that he had made a mistake by not interfering when 150,000
people went to opposition rallies in 2003 but some opposition leaders
went to drink tea. "It was necessary to say then ‘go wherever you
like, we will take over the rostrum ourselves’," [Haykakan Zhamanak
editor Nikol] Pashinyan said.

Vahagn Khachatryan, former mayor of Yerevan when the Armenian
Pan-National Movement was in power, said that Armenian authorities
will not manage to infringe the freedom of speech in the country. "We
realize that the management and employees of TV channels do not act on
their will. The regime dictates to them . There is no need to conduct
any monitoring of the media. Taking into account air time given to the
Republican Party of Armenia, the Prosperous Armenia Party and the
People’s Party, the forthcoming parliamentary election can be declared
rigged," Khachatryan said.

[Passage omitted: other speakers]

About 500 participants attended today’s rally of the Alternative
movement which was the third of the kind. This is more than twice less
than the number of participants in the previous rally.

Tehran: Farhat composed 10th symphony to repay debt to war martyrs

Mehr News Agency, Iran
March 11 2007

Farhat composed tenth symphony to repay his debt to war martyrs

TEHRAN, March 11 (MNA) — Iranian musician Shahin Farhat said on Sunday that
he composed his tenth symphony, entitled Martyrs, as a way to repay part of
his debt to the martyrs of the 1980-1988 Iran-Iraq war.

`The work is the best of the 11 symphonies I have composed over my career,’
he told the Persian service of IRNA.

The Art Bureau of the Islamic Ideology Dissemination Organization (IIDO)
recently released a CD of a performance of the 41-minute symphony by the
Ukraine National Symphony Orchestra, conducted by Vladimir Sirenco.

The symphony had originally been scheduled to be recorded by the Armenian
Philharmonic Orchestra with Iranian conductor Loris Tjeknavorian.

Farhat recently completed the Muhammad (S) Symphony and previously composed
the Iran, Iranian Lady, Damavand, and Persian Gulf symphonies.

Military’s media `Black List’ prompts probe

Al-Arab online, UK
March 11 2007

Military’s media `Black List’ prompts probe

A revelation by a Turkish magazine of the existence of a list that
classified journalists on the basis of their perceived attitude towards
Turkey’s powerful military establishment has prompted a judicial inquiry as
well as widespread outrage in the country’s media.

The 17-page report listing journalists depending on their alleged
‘pro-military’ or ‘anti-military’ bias was published on Thursday by the
magazine Nokta.

The Turkish military has not denied the existence of the document and has
launched a judicial probe to discover who leaked the ‘black list’ to the
magazine.

The document, dated November 2006, was prepared by the Office of the Chief
of General Staff Public and Press Relations Bureau and is entitled ‘A
reassessment of accredited press and media organs’.

Journalists and media organisations that want to follow the activities of
the Office of the Chief of General Staff need to be accredited by the
office.

The document lists all the country’s mainstream national broadcast and print
media outlets and journalists, categorising them according to their comments
and reports on the Turkish military.

It also includes comments and recommendations on whether the media
accreditation handed out to individuals should be granted, denied or
revoked.

"The report is a shame for our democracy. It is a new obstacle for freedom
of expression and freedom of press," the main body representing journalists
in the country, the Turkish Journalists Association, said in its response.

Umur Talu, a veteran columnist for the daily Sabah and a renowned critic of
the influence of the military in Turkey asked Friday why he is described as
"treacherous" on the list.

"Is it ‘normal’ for a 21-year-old junior officer to commit suicide in his
military unit because he was being humiliated? No, then why should I be
described as ‘treacherous’ for having reported on it," Talu asked in his
column.

Other famous journalists and columnists that appear on the list in the
‘anti-military’ category include Murat Belge, Mehmet Ali Birand and Can
Dundar. Murdered Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink and his weekly Agos
are not included in the document.

Another prominent journalist, Mehmet Altan from the Star daily, said that
while he was scandalised by the existence of the list "there is at least a
group of high-ranking military officials who think that this report is a
serious mistake and that’s why they’ve leaked it."

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan and other government officials have not
commented on the report.

Media outlets with more radical positions, such as the socialist and
Islamist newspapers and television stations are not given accreditation to
follow the Office of the Chief of General Staff and hence do not are already
not accredited to military’s media events and are not included in the ‘black
list.’

Turkey Asks Israeli Businessmen For Help vs Adoption of Armenian Res

TURKEY ASKS ISRAELI BUSINESSMEN FOR HELP IN COUNTERACTING TO ADOPTION
OF ARMENIAN RESOLUTION IN CONGRESS

ANKARA, MARCH 7, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. Turkish State Minister
of Trade Kursad Tuzmen asked Israeli businessmen for help in the issue
of hampering adoption of the resolution on recognition of Armenian
Genocide in U.S. Congress. "Now we expect your support in this
issue," the Turkish Minister declared at the seminar under the title
"Turkish-Israeli Economic and Trade Cooperation."

According to the New Anatolian Turkish newspaper, Tuzmen said that
relations between his country and Israel come not only from early
past. "Turkey is the country, which after U.S. receives the greatest
number of Israeli tourists," he declared.

To recap, trade circulation between the two countries amounted to 2.1
bln USD in 2006.

Turk PM, talks profusely about Territorial Integrity

Prime Minister of Turkey, having occupied part of Cyprus talks profusely
about territorial integrity

Arminfo
2007-03-10 14:05:00

"Turkish Azeri brotherhood is eternal and indissoluble!" – Turkish
Premier Recep Tayyip Erdogan once again made the peculiar statement at
the Baku 1st Forum of Azeri and Turkish Diaspora World Organizations.

Then the Premier made another "fresh" statement – "Turkey and
Azerbaijan are states of one nation." Having talked enough about
fraternal ties of Turkish and Azeri nations and the role of Turks in
the world civilization, Erdogan passed over to accusations towards
Armenia. As it came out, the "lasting occupation of Azeri lands,
banishment of a million of people from their homeland, the presence of
refugees and migrants – is a bleeding wound of Turks."

"Last year, Armenians held the so called ‘referendum’. Has the world
recognize it? It hasn’t. Why? Because it was a figment, a wrong and
false step that couldn’t be accepted," Erdogan went on without being
confused about the inconsistencies of his arguments like – "it can’t
be because it can never be".

Alike statements hit Armenia’s efforts for recognition of Armenian
Genocide. "No one will recognize it. Turkey and Turks will never
acknowledge this!" declared Erdogan.

The Turkish Prime Minister was troubled by "the violation of
fundamental principles of the international law – the principles of
the countries’ territorial integrity and inadmissibility of forced
change of the borders". To remind, this statement belongs to the Prime
Minister of a country which has occupied a part of Cyprus. Apparently,
he considers that the principles of the international law aim to
protect only the interests of his own country and Azerbaijan. Erdogan
went further. He stated that Turkey opened its historical archives,
applied to Armenia and third countries to open the archives too. First
and foremost, it is not the affair of politicians, Erdogan said. Let
historians, political scientists, archaeologists, and lawyers examine
this issue. If there is any unfairness, Turkey will do all the things
needed, the Turkish Prime Minister stated. Is it also for historians
to officially recognize the Armenian Genocide?