Opinion | Who benefits from dragging out the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict?

Aug 11 2022
 


With sporadic violence being met by a constant stream of mutual recriminations, peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan can seem like a murky prospect. But while both sides need to do more to reach a lasting peace, who benefits most from the continuation of the conflict is clear.

On 22 May, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev met in Brussels through the mediation of EU President Charles Michel. According to Michel, the parties productively discussed humanitarian issues, delimitation of borders, and demining of territories.

Upon their return, the heads of Azerbaijan and Armenia signed decrees establishing border delimitation commissions, which met shortly after for the first time.

After 30 years of conflict and two wars, some media and experts said, peace seemed to be on the horizon.

It didn’t take long for reality to assert itself. 

Almost immediately after his return from Brussels, Ilham Aliyev announced that the issue of opening the ‘Zangezur corridor’, connecting Azerbaijan with its exclave Nakhchivan, had been resolved in Brussels. Such rhetoric frequently sparks outrage in Armenia — where the government has steadfastly denied that Azerbaijan would receive any sovereign ‘corridor’ through Armenian territory. Commenting on recent anti-Pashinyan protests in Armenia, he also threatened a new war.

‘They [the opposition] think that if they come to power they can achieve something. Absolutely not!’ the Azerbaijani President said. ‘On the contrary, if they do not want to have their heads crushed again, they should sit tight and look away.’ 

On 28 May, a day after Aliyev’s comments, another skirmish took place on the border between Armenia and Azerbaijan, during which an Armenian soldier was killed.

Why does this animosity endure, even when peace seems so possible, and so close at hand? The answer is simple: Ilham Aliyev does not want it. 

The Armenian authorities need peace at almost any cost because they understand that, after their crushing military defeat in 2020, Azerbaijan speaks from a position of power. 

Ilham Aliyev, on the other, does not need a full-fledged peace deal, because he does not know what to do with it. The war and the consequent victory, for the first time, brought Aliyev immense popularity among his people. Previously, his power rested on weak authority, the police, and the suppression of free media and the opposition.

Then, he could not get rid of the image of being a ‘pale shadow of his father’ — the previous president of Azerbaijan, the late Heydar Aliyev, who is still greatly respected in the country. As time went on, the younger Aliyev’s authority declined as the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict remained frozen and the standards of living in the country fell steadily.

Before the war, Aliyev did not often appear in public, rarely gave interviews, and could most often be seen at yet another formal opening of a factory, museum, or even an overpass.

During and after the war, however, the president eagerly took on the role of a victorious leader and bringer of good news about newly liberated settlements. He eagerly gave interviews to foreign media and started to act confidently, knowing that the world would do little to stop the Azerbaijani army’s advance.

Aliyev does desire a peace treaty on paper in order to consolidate territorial gains, so long as in that treaty, Armenia recognises Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan. But even if such a treaty does come to pass, the peace it brings is unlikely to last.

Aliyev may be moved to violate it at any moment, if discontent again begins to grow in the country, as he has seen that it is only through war that he has been able to reliably increase his ratings.

In this vein, Aliyev has only continued to reinforce the nationalistic and militaristic mood of his population — including by making new territorial claims on Armenia. Since the end of the war, Aliyev has often said that Armenia’s Syunik Province, which he now refers to as ‘Western Zangezur’, and the city of Yerevan itself are ancestral Azerbaijani lands. 

Nor has fighting on the line of contact in Nagorno-Karabakh and on the interstate border stopped. Only a few months ago, Azerbaijani troops briefly crossed the line of contact and took control of an Armenian-inhabited village, only vacating after the intervention of Russian peacekeepers.

Finally, should a fullfledged peace be concluded, Ilham Aliyev would have nothing to replace his ideology with. The whole national-patriotic idea in the country was based on the return of Karabakh and confrontation with Armenia. 

The authorities probably still do not know how to explain to the population a possible peace with the ‘eternal enemy’, or how to distract people from the problems in the country in the absence of the frozen conflict.

Armenia and the Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians declare that the conflict is a matter of rights to self-determination, life, and security. For Azerbaijan, this is a matter of territorial integrity and national pride. While Azerbaijan also promotes the issue of IDPs publicly to motivate support for war, the authorities have shown little interest in their situation.

In spite of repeated statements, the Azerbaijani authorities have so far done nothing to prove to Armenians that their rights would be protected. On the contrary, the Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh sees that even Azerbaijanis themselves lack basic democratic rights — with rights and democratic metrics at the level of countries like Myanmar or Sudan — and both society and the state are extremely hostile toward Armenians. 

The simple fact is that Armenia, and even Nagorno-Karabakh are reported to perform much better in terms of democracy and human rights than Azerbaijan.

Nor has Baku presented a plan for the integration of Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians or given any indication that they would have any different form of governance. This is in line with the policies Azerbaijan has towards other ethnic minorities in the country, who are severly underrepresented in local or state government institutions.

Azerbaijani troops have even used mobile loudspeakers to psychologically pressure local residents and apparently cut off the gas supply to Nagorno-Karabakh in the dead of winter. 

Azerbaijan also continues to deny any Armenian cultural heritage on the territory of Karabakh. Churches and other cultural and religious sites, recognised globally as part of Armenian cultural heritage are recognised by Azerbaijan as the heritage of the ancient state “Caucasian Albania”.

The question of how the Karabakh Armenians would receive an education has also not been raised. In Azerbaijan, national minorities, except for Russians and Georgians, do not study in their own language. As a result, the languages of ethnic minorities inhabiting Azerbaijan are slowly dying out. When representatives of national minorities complain about their problems, they are called separatists.

Is there any possibility of peace? Unlikely as it may be, I think, yes.

For that Armenia needs to continue its current course, not allowing the nationalist opposition, playing on the traumas of people from the last war, to return to power, and then build legitimacy on a hatred of Azerbaijan and Azerbaijanis.

In Azerbaijan, however, it is much more difficult. For a peaceful and lasting resolution of the conflict, the current authorities have to go, because it is plainly against their interests to have a meaningful and lasting peace.

Azerbaijan needs a new, democratic government, reforms in education, the economy, as well as the rule of law. Only if the state renounces nationalist and militaristic rhetoric, combats it and then ensures a fair representation of national minorities, will space for a proper peace emerge.

The onus for changing the narrative of historical memory is on both countries. Both Armenia and Azerbaijan need to acknowledge the war crimes they have committed against each other and the suffering that they have caused. If this is done, then the sort of nationalist propaganda, based on a denialist one-sided narrative of pure victims and pure perpetrators, and resulting calls for revenge, will shrink.

As for the integration of Karabakh Armenians into Azerbaijan, I believe that is also possible based on the model which emerged from the Dayton Accords that ended the Bosnian War in 1995.

There is no president in Bosnia, where three previously conflicting nationalities (Bosnians, Serbs, and Croats) live. Instead, the country is ruled by a presidium of three people from each of the peoples and each with veto power. The parliament consists of an equal number of deputies from each nation. Today, though the country certainly still has its problems, the conflict has not reared its head again, and the country even seeks to join the European Union.

All the peoples living in Azerbaijan will equally benefit from decentralisation according to the Bosnian scenario. There will be less opportunity to concentrate power in the hands of one person or group of people with common interests and the potential for a new dictatorship will decrease.

Residents of the regions will be able to both choose their representatives in Baku and the local authorities who will be accountable to them. The peoples living in Azerbaijan will be able to freely learn their own language along with the state language, and the culture of these peoples will not be subjected to forced assimilation and oppression.

With the guarantee of the rights of Armenians to life, language, and with their representation in state institutions, along with the preservation of Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan and the resettlement of Azerbaijani and Armenian refugees who want to return to their homes, the conflict will finally be resolved. And just to be sure, a contingent of UN peacekeepers could be deployed in the region to prevent conflicts between two nations that have been separated from each other by barbed wire for so very long.

The opinions expressed and place names and terminology used in this article are the words of the author alone, and may not necessarily reflect the views of OC Media’s editorial board.

Karabakh Residents Question Russian Peacekeepers’ Effectiveness

Aug 11 2022

All along the road connecting Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia, there are billboards erected by the Russian peacekeeping mission there: “Where there are Russians, there is peace.” “The Russian peacekeeping contingent is guarding the peace.”

But after recent escalations in tensions here, many Karabakh Armenians are doubting those promises.

An outbreak of violence in early August saw two Armenian soldiers killed, at least 19 injured, and allowed Azerbaijan to take a strategic height just north of that road. 

The escalation has led to an unprecedented level of criticism of the peacekeeping mission, which after Armenians’ defeat in the 2020 war against Azerbaijan is the only force keeping Baku from continuing its assault.

“Armenians returned [after fleeing in the 2020 war] because the Russians guaranteed them safety. But if they are here, they need to fulfill all their obligations,” Gayane Arstamyan, one Stepanakert resident, told Eurasianet. “Their main job is to protect our lives in our homes, which they are not doing. If they won’t do it, let other international peacekeepers come to Karabakh; we will agree as long as they actually protect and secure us.”

At a cabinet meeting just after the violence this month, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan recalled several other episodes in which Russian peacekeepers stood by as Azerbaijan violated the ceasefire, and gave a stronger reproach to the peacekeeping mission than he ever had before. 

“The December 11, 2020, capture of the villages of Khtsaberd and Hin Tagher and Armenian servicemen by Azerbaijan in the presence and connivance of Russian peacekeepers, the March 24, 2022, seizure of the village of Parukh in Nagorno-Karabakh again in the presence of Russian peacekeepers, the constant and increasing ceasefire violations along the line of contact, the cases of physical and psychological terror against the Armenians of Artsakh in the presence of peacekeepers are simply unacceptable,” Pashinyan said, using an alternative name for Karabakh.

Following the flareup, Russia’s Foreign Ministry said the peacekeepers were “making all necessary efforts to stabilize the situation.”

But many were unconvinced.

Most of the Armenian soldiers injured in the recent violence were wounded by drone attacks, officials in Karabakh’s de facto government said, and to many it called into question Russia’s promises to control the airspace over Karabakh. 

One Stepanakert resident, Hasmik Arushanyan, wrote on Facebook, “I am addressing [commander of the peacekeeping contingent Major General Andrey] Volkov personally. At one of your checkpoints, you [the peacekeepers] hung a poster: “Clear skies above Karabakh.” Do drone strikes fall from a clear sky? How can I believe and trust you after that?” 

The day after the violence peaked, Volkov met with several Karabakh political leaders and activists to discuss the situation, in an apparent admission of the sensitivity of local public opinion. The meeting was not public but afterwards, some of the Karabakhi participants told media that they weren’t satisfied with assurances from the Russians that the incidents would not be repeated. 

The Russians explained they did not have enough resources and power to resist Azerbaijani attacks, said one participant, Arthur Osipyan, the head of the Artsakh Revolutionary Party. The next day, a group of Karabakhis, including some of those who were at the meeting, organized a protest in front of the de facto government headquarters in Stepanakert. They carried banners reading “Peacekeepers, where is the peace you promised?”, “Stop Azerbaijani aggression”, and “Return Parukh and Khtsaberd.”

Most Karabakhis have little contact with the peacekeepers, save for the checkpoints the Russians have set up on the Lachin corridor, the only road connecting Karabakh to the outside world. 

“I don’t understand what the peacekeepers are supposed to be doing,” Arstamyan, the Stepanakert resident, said. “I only see how they stop us at every checkpoint to see our documents on our way home. I, a 60-year-old woman, have to show my passport five times to be able to get home. This is certainly not what they were deployed for.”

Many in Karabakh welcomed the peacekeepers when they deployed immediately following the 2020 war with Azerbaijan. The Russians have provided various services to the Armenian residents of Karabakh: handing out aid, supporting reconstruction of destroyed infrastructure, helping secure farmland in areas near the line of contact with Azerbaijani forces, and helping negotiate the return of livestock that stray into Azerbaijani-controlled areas. 

But the Russians’ effectiveness appears to have waned following the start of the war in Ukraine, some say.

“Everyone understands that Russia is weaker than ever before in the international arena,” one official in the de facto government told a researcher for the think tank Crisis Group.

“With Baku’s increased importance to Russia, Azerbaijan feels more confident and understands that its boundaries are now wider than before the Russian-Ukrainian conflict,” Tigran Grigoryan, a Karabakhi political analyst, said in a recent interview with RFE/RL. “And we can say that Azerbaijan is also probing some ‘red lines’ of the Russian side, wants to understand when Russia will seriously react to the issue.” 

But even as the peacekeepers fail to stop Azerbaijan from repeatedly taking small slices of territory, others argue that it is still only the peacekeepers’ presence that prevents a larger Azerbaijani offensive.

The presence of a 2,000-member Russian peacekeeping mission was stipulated in the ceasefire agreement that ended the 2020 war. Another provision is the withdrawal of Armenia’s own armed forces, and while the Armenian side has given mixed messages on that recently, that withdrawal is either entirely or nearly complete.

“The Russians and Armenians have a common interest in this situation – we need them as a guarantee of safety, and they need us to keep their forces in the Caucasus,” Kristina Balayan, who owns a cafe in the territory’s main city, Stepanakert, and ran for the de facto presidency in 2020, told Eurasianet. “If they do not protect our security and the Armenian residents leave, they [the Russians] will also leave. We need to cooperate to protect our common interests.”

https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2022/08/11/karabakh-residents-question-russian-peacekeepers-effectiveness-a78557

Residents of Akhavno and Berdzor reproach authorities for demanding urgent evacuation

Caucasian Knot
Aug 11 2022
After being resettled from the Lachin corridor, residents of the communities of Akhavno and Berdzor will receive apartments in Nagorno-Karabakh or certificates for housing in Armenia, the authorities promise. Residents themselves are dissatisfied with the requirement to evacuate in a short time.

The “Caucasian Knot” has reported that on August 5, residents of the communities of Akhavno, Sous, and the city of Berdzor (the Azerbaijani name is Lachin, – note of the “Caucasian Knot”) were required to leave their houses by August 25, since the Lachin corridor would be handed over to Azerbaijan. The residents of the community of Akhavno opposed the resettlement.

Aida Avakyan, a mother of many children from Akhavno, hopes that the authorities will fulfil their promise and issue compensation on time, and her family will not be huddled in rented apartments for a long time.

“During the war, we did not run away, as many did, but lived here with pride in order to save our village, the place where our children were born. And now our authorities are rushing us, evicting us, instead of fighting for us,” the mother of many children said.

Similar opinions were expressed by other residents of Akhavno. “I don’t understand why there is such a rush, why no one defends our rights to a peaceful life in their home?” Rita Smbatyan expresses her bewilderment.

Anush Gogchyan, a resident of the village, expressed her indignation at being forced to leave her house and land. The woman said that her family would go to Armenia and try to use the financial assistance promised by the authorities to settle there and start a farm.

This article was originally published on the Russian page of 24/7 Internet agency ‘Caucasian Knot’ on at 03:58 pm MSK. To access the full text of the article, click here.

See earlier reports:
Demand to resettle outrages Akhavno villagers, Baku analysts assess prospects for return of Lachin under Azerbaijan’s control, Forced migrants from Nagorno-Karabakh call for easier allocation of housing in Armenia.
Source: Caucasian Knot

Debris of Armenian military helicopter found in Karabakh

Caucasian Knot
Aug 12 2022
Wreckage of a military helicopter of the Armenian Armed Forces, shot down during the autumn 2020 war, was found in Nagorno-Karabakh.

After the above war, the remains and bodies of 1711 persons were found in the territories that came under Azerbaijan’s control, the Nagorno-Karabakh’s Emergency Service reported on February 23. The searches began after the end of hostilities, and were interrupted several times, including due to Azerbaijan’s refusal to allow Karabakh rescuers to continue their searches.

Today, fragments of an MI-8 helicopter of the Armenian Armed Forces were found in the territory of the village of Tug of the Khodjavend District (the Armenian name is the Martuni District, – note of the “Caucasian Knot”), the Azerbaijani Ministry of Defence (MoD) has reported.

It was established that these are the debris of the MI-8 helicopter with the crew of the Armenian Armed Forces, shot down by units of the Azerbaijani Air Forces on October 18, 2020, in the vicinity of the village of Tug, the Khodjavend District.

This article was originally published on the Russian page of 24/7 Internet agency ‘Caucasian Knot’ on at 09:21 pm MSK. To access the full text of the article, click here.

See earlier reports:
Investigators report details of case on Mi-24 shot down in Armenia, Azerbaijani MFA apologizes to Russia for downed helicopter, Russian helicopter shot down in Armenia.

Author: Faik Medjid Source: СK correspondent
Source:
© Caucasian Knot

Azerbaijani MoD announces work at key heights in Karabakh

Caucasian Knot
Aug 11 2022
Engineering work and road construction are underway on Mount Buzdukh and other heights that came under the control of Azerbaijan as a result of the “Retribution” operation, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) of Azerbaijan reports.

The “Caucasian Knot” has reported that following the results of the fighting on August 3, Azerbaijan occupied the Sarybaba height in the Shusha District and Gyrkhgyz height in the Khodjaly District. According to analysts, that gave Azerbaijan a tactical advantage. On August 6, Azerbaijan also announced the capture of the strategic height of Buzdukh (Buzukh).

The control over the Buzdukh height creates a springboard for new military operations in Karabakh, if such a need arises, Baku analysts say. “Today, the Azerbaijani army occupies dominant positions almost along the entire perimeter of Karabakh,” noted Telman Abilov, the head of the “Military Officers” NGO.

The control over the Gyrkhgyz height allows the Azerbaijani army strengthening the security of the city of Shusha and the Azerbaijani villages of the Shusha District when the forced migrants return there, expert Azad Isazade believes. The occupation of the heights of Sarybaba and Gyrkhgyz allowed Azerbaijan significantly strengthening control over the Lachin corridor, emphasizes Shakhin Gadjiev, an observer for the “Turan” agency.

This article was originally published on the Russian page of 24/7 Internet agency ‘Caucasian Knot’ on at 06:01 pm MSK. To access the full text of the article, click here.

See earlier reports:
Russian MFA rejects criticism of peacekeepers in Karabakh conflict zone, Azerbaijan announces completion of road bypassing Lachin, Wording of agreement on Nagorno-Karabakh gives rise to conflict escalation.

Source: Caucasian Knot
Source:
© Caucasian Knot

In Armenia, Red Cross counts 303 persons missing after Karabakh war

Caucasian Knot
Aug 12 2022
A total of 303 residents of Armenia are listed as missing after the war in Nagorno-Karabakh, the republican delegation of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) has informed.

The “Caucasian Knot” has reported that on March 21, the Armenian Investigating Committee reported that overall 3822 people perished in the course of hostilities in the fall of 2020 in Nagorno-Karabakh; other 208 people, including 21 civilians, were reported missing.

After the 2020 Karabakh war, 303 residents of Armenia are reported missing, the “NEWS.am” reports with reference to the press service of the Armenian delegation of the ICRC.

The delegation also reported that it had received more than 1450 appeals from family members of missing persons. In particular, four families turned to the ICRC to find out the fate of their missing relatives; other 12 families managed to get information about their relatives, the “Erkramas” informs.

This article was originally published on the Russian page of 24/7 Internet agency ‘Caucasian Knot’ on at 09:40 am MSK. To access the full text of the article, click here.

See earlier reports:
Armenian Ombudsperson accuses Azerbaijan of hiding POWs number, Supporters of Armenian POWs detained in Moscow, In Yerevan, participants of “Action of Silence” demand more active return of POWs from Azerbaijan.

Author: The Caucasian Knot
Source:
© Caucasian Knot

People with disabilities in Armenia will be provided with personal assistants


Aug 11 2022



  • JAMnews
  • Yerevan

Personal assistants for those with disabilities

The government of Armenia will provide personal assistants to people with disabilities to help them integrate into society and “realize their right to an independent life.”

For now, helpers will be provided only to those who need it most, about 2,450 people living in socially disadvantaged families.

Before the government’s decision goes into effect in 2024, the support of international partners will be sought in a pilot phase of the project. The Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs states that the final decision may be amended based on the results of the pilot program.

Everything currently known about the project to help people with disabilities.


  • Armenia’s adoption fraud: foreigners pay up to 25 thousand euros for a kid
  • Employement of Karabakh war veterans – how the issue is resolved in Armenia
  • What problems are facing children with disabilities and their parents. Videoblog from Armenia

According to the Law on the Rights of People with Disabilities, adopted by the Armenian Parliament on May 5, 2021, a personal assistant is someone who

  • “cares for a person with a disability within the limits of the functions assigned to them by law,
  • supports a person with a disability in overcoming obstacles (including movement and communication).”

The project will begin on January 1, 2024. Prior to that, a new system for assessing a person’s functional capabilities will be developed.

Rights of people with disabilities in Armenia: personal stories of people who face discrimination from the government and in every day life

According to official statistics, about 200,000 people with disabilities live in Armenia. The government will provide personal assistants to the most vulnerable, classified as socially insecure and registered as such.

It is planned to provide assistants to people with serious functional limitations – musculoskeletal, visual and psychological problems.

According to Deputy Minister Anna Zhamakochyan, at first only 2,450 people will have personal assistants. More than 5 billion drams (approximately $12.2 million) will be allocated for this purpose.

In 2010, Armenia ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities, committing itself to bring legislation and public policy in line with its requirements. The right to an independent life and integration into society is enshrined in article 19 of the convention.

Provisions on the exclusion of discrimination on the basis of disability and ensuring the independent life of people with disabilities are also included in the program of the Armenian government for 2021-2026.

On May 5, 2021, the Parliament of Armenia adopted the Law on the Rights of People with Disabilities, which establishes the function of personal assistants as part of services to ensure an independent life.

According to the Deputy Minister of Labor and Social Affairs, any adult who has received the appropriate training and certificate can become a personal assistant.

“A family member can also be a personal assistant. This is very important, especially in cases where a person with a disability needs more than ten hours of service,” says Anna Zhamakochyan.

The assistant will be paid for hours worked, 1050 drams per hour ($2.5 at the current exchange rate).

The government thus intends to

  • expand the system of services aimed at independent living,
  • introduce mechanisms to ensure and protect independent living and the right to integration into society of those with disabilities, including children.

Karabakh residents increasingly questioning Russian peacekeepers’ effectiveness

Aug 11 2022
Lilit Shahverdyan Aug 11, 2022
A Russian peacekeeper at an outreach event in Karabakh. (Russian government handout)

All along the road connecting Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia, there are billboards erected by the Russian peacekeeping mission there: “Where there are Russians, there is peace.” “The Russian peacekeeping contingent is guarding the peace.”

But after recent escalations in tensions here, many Karabakh Armenians are doubting those promises.

An outbreak of violence in early August saw two Armenian soldiers killed, at least 19 injured, and allowed Azerbaijan to take a strategic height just north of that road. 

The escalation has led to an unprecedented level of criticism of the peacekeeping mission, which after Armenians’ defeat in the 2020 war against Azerbaijan is the only force keeping Baku from continuing its assault.

“Armenians returned [after fleeing in the 2020 war] because the Russians guaranteed them safety. But if they are here, they need to fulfill all their obligations,” Gayane Arstamyan, one Stepanakert resident, told Eurasianet. “Their main job is to protect our lives in our homes, which they are not doing. If they won’t do it, let other international peacekeepers come to Karabakh; we will agree as long as they actually protect and secure us.”

At a cabinet meeting just after the violence this month, Armenia Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan recalled several other episodes in which Russian peacekeepers stood by as Azerbaijan violated the ceasefire, and gave a stronger reproach to the peacekeeping mission than he ever had before. 

“The December 11, 2020, capture of the villages of Khtsaberd and Hin Tagher and Armenian servicemen by Azerbaijan in the presence and connivance of Russian peacekeepers, the March 24, 2022, seizure of the village of Parukh in Nagorno-Karabakh again in the presence of Russian peacekeepers, the constant and increasing ceasefire violations along the line of contact, the cases of physical and psychological terror against the Armenians of Artsakh in the presence of peacekeepers are simply unacceptable,” Pashinyan said, using an alternative name for Karabakh.

Following the flareup, Russia’s Foreign Ministry said the peacekeepers were “making all necessary efforts to stabilize the situation.”

But many here were unconvinced.

Most of the Armenian soldiers injured in the recent violence were wounded by drone attacks, officials in Karabakh’s de facto government said, and to many it called into question Russia’s promises to control the airspace over Karabakh. 

One Stepanakert resident, Hasmik Arushanyan, wrote on Facebook, “I am addressing [commander of the peacekeeping contingent Major General Andrey] Volkov personally. At one of your checkpoints, you [the peacekeepers] hung a poster: “Clear skies above Karabakh.” Do drone strikes fall from a clear sky? How can I believe and trust you after that?” 

The day after the violence peaked, Volkov met with several Karabakh political leaders and activists to discuss the situation, in an apparent admission of the sensitivity of local public opinion. The meeting was not public but afterwards, some of the Karabakhi participants told media that they weren’t satisfied with assurances from the Russians that the incidents would not be repeated. 

The Russians explained they did not have enough resources and power to resist Azerbaijani attacks, said one participant, Arthur Osipyan, the head of the Artsakh Revolutionary Party. The next day, a group of Karabakhis, including some of those who were at the meeting, organized a protest in front of the de facto government headquarters in Stepanakert. They carried banners reading “Peacekeepers, where is the peace you promised?”, “Stop Azerbaijani aggression”, and “Return Parukh and Khtsaberd.”

Most Karabakhis have little contact with the peacekeepers, save for the checkpoints the Russians have set up on the Lachin corridor, the only road connecting Karabakh to the outside world. 

“I don’t understand what the peacekeepers are supposed to be doing,” Arstamyan, the Stepanakert resident, said. “I only see how they stop us at every checkpoint to see our documents on our way home. I, a 60-year-old woman, have to show my passport five times to be able to get home. This is certainly not what they were deployed for.”

Many in Karabakh welcomed the peacekeepers when they deployed immediately following the 2020 war with Azerbaijan. The Russians have provided various services to the Armenian residents of Karabakh: handing out aid, supporting reconstruction of destroyed infrastructure, helping secure farmland in areas near the line of contact with Azerbaijani forces, and helping negotiate the return of livestock that stray into Azerbaijani-controlled areas. 

But the Russians’ effectiveness appears to have waned following the start of the war in Ukraine, some say.

“Everyone understands that Russia is weaker than ever before in the international arena,” one official in the de facto government told a researcher for the think tank Crisis Group.

“With Baku’s increased importance to Russia, Azerbaijan feels more confident and understands that its boundaries are now wider than before the Russian-Ukrainian conflict,” Tigran Grigoryan, a Karabakhi political analyst, said in a recent interview with RFE/RL. “And we can say that Azerbaijan is also probing some ‘red lines’ of the Russian side, wants to understand when Russia will seriously react to the issue.” 

But even as the peacekeepers fail to stop Azerbaijan from repeatedly taking small slices of territory, others argue that it is still only the peacekeepers’ presence that prevents a larger Azerbaijani offensive.

The presence of a 2,000-member Russian peacekeeping mission was stipulated in the ceasefire agreement that ended the 2020 war. Another provision is the withdrawal of Armenia’s own armed forces, and while the Armenian side has given mixed messages on that recently, that withdrawal is either entirely or nearly complete.

“The Russians and Armenians have a common interest in this situation – we need them as a guarantee of safety, and they need us to keep their forces in the Caucasus,” Kristina Balayan, who owns a cafe in the territory’s main city, Stepanakert, and ran for the de facto presidency in 2020, told Eurasianet. “If they do not protect our security and the Armenian residents leave, they [the Russians] will also leave. We need to cooperate to protect our common interests.”

Lilit Shahverdyan is a journalist based in Stepanakert. 

Turkey ready to move Armenia normalisation talks to Yerevan and Ankara


Aug 11 2022
Source says taking negotiations from third-party countries would be a positive confidence-building step, but it is unclear whether the Armenians agree
By 

Ragip Soylu

 in 

Ankara

Turkey wants to move normalisation talks with Armenia to their respective capitals after conducting previous discussions in third countries.

A Turkish diplomatic source told journalists on Wednesday that Turkey’s special representative to Armenia, Serdar Kilic, was ready to visit Yerevan and there meet his counterpart, Ruben Rubinyan.

Ankara and Yerevan launched a dialogue on normalisation last year and have so far held four meetings in cities such as Moscow and Vienna.

Last month, Turkey and Armenia decided to begin direct air-cargo trade and open their land borders to third-country citizens as soon as possible.

The two countries don’t have a formal diplomatic relationship, and Turkey  sealed its border to Armenia in the early 90s after the latter’s seizure of nominally Azerbaijan territory of Nagorno-Karabakh. They also disagree over the Armenian genocide, with Turkey rejecting the term for the 1915 Ottoman mass killings and insisting there were deaths on both sides.

Ankara and Yerevan are holding direct talks for the first time after a normalization attempt under Swiss mediation failed in 2009. Azerbaijan’s recapture of most of Nagorno-Karabakh in 2020 enabled Ankara to start a new initiative, which was welcomed by the Armenian government.

The source underlined that Azerbaijan wasn’t part of the talks, and the conversations were strictly between Armenia and Turkey. Yet, the source said that they cannot completely ignore the tensions and developments between Armenia and Azerbaijan, which can directly impact the parties’ mentality going into talks.

Armenian and Azerbaijani forces have both been accused of breaking a Russian-brokered ceasefire in recent days.

The Turkish diplomatic source said Armenia doesn’t appear to be willing to move the talks to Ankara and Yerevan unless there is a significant breakthrough in discussions. The source added that moving talks to the respective countries would itself be a breakthrough, and they should do so to progress talks in a more positive environment. 

The promise of wealth brings Iran and Azerbaijan together after Armenia tensions

Read More »

Middle East Eye has asked the Armenian foreign ministry for comment.

Ankara is in favour of developing normalisation with concrete confidence-building steps that will prepare public opinion in both countries for greater steps. Turkey is prioritizing measures that will not lead to excessive expectations on both sides and that are welcomed in both countries and will be taken “step by step”. 

The source said there were unexpected challenges in opening the land border for third countries due to insufficient infrastructure at crossings, which may delay the step.

For example, the physical conditions at the Alican and Akyaka border crossings, which have not been used for more than 30 years, need to be improved. Kilic, Turkey’s special representative for the normalisation process with Armenia, went to the border after the last meeting with Rubinyan and made inspections at the crossings.

That is why Turkey and Armenia will first need to hold technical talks among the relevant bureaucrats to resolve the infrastructure issues in September. The special envoys may then hold another round of talks in Ankara or Yerevan, if Armenia agrees.

The source described the atmosphere between Kilic and Rubinyan as a very cordial and friendly, with them frequently calling each other to resolve minor issues. The source said there might have been hundreds of calls between the two.

The source said Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s phone call with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan last month was also very positive.

While confidence-building measures were prioritized in the talks, “difficult” issues between the two countries, especially the Armenian genocide, were not brought up. 

Ankara believes that it would not be “rational” to discuss the “difficult” issues between the two countries at this stage. However, the Turkish source appreciated that Armenia publicly restated that it doesn’t have any land demands from Turkey.  

Local reports last month suggested that Turkey had been clearing mines on the Armenian border, which triggered speculation that Ankara was readying itself to fully open the border. However, the Turkish diplomatic source said the mine clearance wasn’t related to the diplomatic talks, but to the multinational Ottawa Convention, which mandates Turkey to clear its borders of land mines.

https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/turkey-armenia-normalisation-talks-ankara-ready 

Armenia Banking Market 2022 | Growth Demand, Opportunities, Revenue and Forecast To 2030

Digital Journal
Aug 12 2022

Allied Market Research published a report, titled, “Armenia Banking Market by Sector (Retail Banking, Corporate Banking, and Investment Banking) and Type (Closed Joint-Stock Company [CJSC] and Open Joint-Stock Company [OJSC]): Opportunity Analysis and Industry Forecast, 2019–2026”.

𝐆𝐞𝐭 𝐚 𝐒𝐚𝐦𝐩𝐥𝐞 𝐂𝐨𝐩𝐲 𝐨𝐟 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐑𝐞𝐩𝐨𝐫𝐭 @ https://www.alliedmarketresearch.com/request-sample/6274

The report offers an extensive analysis of changing market dynamics, key investment pockets, major segments, value chain analysis, competitive landscape, and investment feasibility. The research offers a detailed analysis of drivers, restraints, and opportunities of the Armenia banking market. These insights provide necessary guidance to determine driving factors and implement strategies to gain a sustainable growth and tap on opportunities to explore the potential of the market.

The research provides a comprehensive analysis of driving factors, restraining factors, and opportunities of the Armenia banking market. This analysis is helpful in identifying driving forces, achieving maximum growth, and adopting strategies to sustain in the market. Furthermore, investors, market players, and new entrants are able to gain insights to explore the Armenia banking market potential, avail new opportunities, and gain the competitive advantage. Detailed elaboration of each factor is mentioned in the report to help market players in thorough understanding.

Extensive Segmentation

• By Type
o Closed Joint-Stock Company (CJSC)
o Open Joint-Stock Company (OJSC)

• By Sector
o Retail Banking
o Corporate Banking
o Investment Banking

For Full TOC check out the Report@ https://www.alliedmarketresearch.com/armenia-banking-market

An extensive analysis of each segment and sub-segment is offered in the research with in graphical and tabular formats. This analysis is helpful in determining the highest revenue generating and fastest growing segments and implementing different strategies to achieve the growth during the forecast period.        

For More Information or Query or Customization Before Buying, Visit @ https://www.alliedmarketresearch.com/request-for-customization/6274?reqfor=covid

Covid-19 impact Analysis

  • Manufacturing activities of Armenia banking market halted due to lockdown measures taken place across many countries. Moreover, supply chain disruptions and shortage of raw materials created challenges in carrying out manufacturing in full capacity.
  • The demand from end use industries reduced significantly due to halt in day-to-day operations during lockdown. However, the demand would grow steadily during post-lockdown as daily operations get back on track.
  • The ban on import-export activities led to supply chain disruption and supply-demand gap. As the restrictions are lifted off, the supply chain will be restored.

The report offers a detailed scenario of the Armenia banking market during the Covid-19 pandemic. These insights are helpful for market players, investors, startups, and others to revise their strategies and minimize the impact on their businesses. The impact mentioned in the report is the result of thorough research.

Competitive Landscape

The report offers a detailed analysis of major market players operating in the Armenia banking market. The leading market players profiled in the report are Ameriabank CJSC, ARARATBANK OJSC, ArmSwissBank CJSC, Converse Bank CJSC, HSBC Armenia, ID Bank, ACBA-CREDIT AGRICOLE BANK CJSC, ArmBusinessBank CJSC, Ardshinbank CJSC, and Inecobank CJSC. The competitive landscaope and the strategies adopted by market players are mentioned in the report.  These Armenia banking market players have adopted various strategies such as new product launches, partnerships, joint ventures, collaborations, mergers and acquisitions, expansion, and others to avail sustainable growth and strengthen their presence in the Armenia banking market.

Inquiry Before Purchase @ https://www.alliedmarketresearch.com/purchase-enquiry/6274

About Us

Allied Market Research (AMR) is a full-service market research and business-consulting wing of Allied Analytics LLP based in Portland, Oregon. Allied Market Research provides global enterprises as well as medium and small businesses with unmatched quality of “Market Research Reports” and “Business Intelligence Solutions.” AMR has a targeted view to provide business insights and consulting to assist its clients to make strategic business decisions and achieve sustainable growth in their respective market domain.

Pawan Kumar, the CEO of Allied Market Research, is leading the organization toward providing high-quality data and insights. We are in professional corporate relations with various companies and this helps us in digging out market data that helps us generate accurate research data tables and confirms utmost accuracy in our market forecasting. Each and every data presented in the reports published by us is extracted through primary interviews with top officials from leading companies of domain concerned. Our secondary data procurement methodology includes deep online and offline research and discussion with knowledgeable professionals and analysts in the industry.

Contact Us

David Correa

Portland, OR, United States

USA/Canada (Toll Free): +1-800-792-5285, +1-503-894-6022, +1-503-446-1141

UK: +44-845-528-1300

Hong Kong: +852-301-84916

India (Pune): +91-20-66346060

Fax: +1(855)550-5975

[email protected]

Web: https://www.alliedmarketresearch.com

Follow Us on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/allied-market-research