Lavrov says Yerevan, Baku and Moscow have made progress in reaching agreements

Public Radio of Armenia
Armenia – Aug 31 2022

The trilateral working group consisting of representatives of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia has made significant progress in reaching agreements on the unblocking transport links in the South Caucasus, Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov said at a press conference following talks with his Iranian counterpart Hossein Amir Abdollahian, TASS reports.

“The issues of unblocking trade, economic, transport ties in the South Caucasus are being handled by a trilateral group chaired by the Deputy Prime Ministers of Russia, Azerbaijan and Armenia. It is working rhythmically, contacts on delimitation of the border between Azerbaijan and Armenia were held recently. This trilateral working group, established by the decision of the three presidents of November 9, 2020, has made significant progress in reaching agreements. I hope they will be formalized in the very near future. What is especially important s that this work is not carried out in a vacuum, not in isolation, but in close coordination with broader transport projects, including the North-South corridor project, which our Iranian partners are also interested in,” he said.

Abdollahian noted, in turn, that Iran has a very privileged geopolitical position. ” We see the strengthening of transit routes, including the diversified North-South routes, s an important factor for development, as well as for food security in this region,” he added. The Iranian Foreign Minister also expressed the country’s readiness to complete the construction of the unfinished section of Rasht – Astara.

Armenia, Azerbaijan leaders agree to continue substantive negotiations on drafting of the peace treaty

Public Radio of Armenia
Armenia – Aug 31 2022

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev met in Brussels on August 31 under the mediation of European Council President Charles Michel.

Issues related to the release of prisoners and the clarification of the fate of the missing, border delimitation and border security, de-blocking the region, the normalization of Armenia-Azerbaijan relations, and the Nagorno Karabakh issue were discussed.

An agreement was reached to continue substantive negotiations at the level of foreign ministers on the drafting of the peace treaty. The meeting of the foreign ministers will take place within a month.

The next meeting of the Commission on Delimitation and Border Security will take place in Brussels in November.

The next meeting of the leadsers of the countries will take place in November.

EU’s Michel stresses the importance of release of Armenian detainees by Azerbaijan

Public Radio of Armenia
Armenia – Aug 31 2022

Our discussions focused on recent developments in the South Caucasus and the relations between the EU and both countries, President of the EU Council Charles Michel said after taljs with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev.

Below are Charles Michrl’s remarks in full:

Our exchanges were open and productive – and I would like to thank both leaders for that. We reviewed the entire set of issues on our agenda.

It is positive to see that quite a few steps have been taken to take forward the agreements reached during our last meeting.

Peace Agreement

Today we agree to step up substantive work to advance on the peace treaty governing inter-state relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan and tasked the Foreign Ministers to meet within one month to work on draft texts.

Humanitarian issues

We also had a detailed discussion on humanitarian issues, including demining, detainees and the fate of missing persons.

President Michel stressed to Azerbaijan the importance of further release of Armenian detainees.

The EU will continue to be engaged in these questions.

Border issues

We reviewed progress on all questions related to the delimitation of the border and how best to ensure a stable situation.

We agreed that the next meeting of the Border Commissions will take place in Brussels in November.

Connectivity 

We reviewed progress of discussions on the modalities for unblocking the transport links.

With all these discussions, I would like to underline that it is important to take the population along on both sides and prepare them for a long-term sustainable peace.

Public messaging is critical in this regard – in a sensitive situation like this every word spoken in public is obviously listened to by the other side and weighed.

The EU is ready to further step up its support towards a long-term sustainable peace. The EU will also continue to push for the advancement of economic development for the benefit of both countries and their populations.

We have agreed to meet again in this format by the end of November.

Artsakh’s international recognition ‘has matured’, ombudsman says

Panorama
Armenia – Aug 31 2022

The concluding observations of the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination include cases of gross human rights violations committed by Azerbaijan during the aggression against Artsakh in 2020 and beyond, Artsakh’s Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) Gegham Stepanyan said on Wednesday.

“We note with satisfaction that the concluding observations of the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination on the fulfillment of the obligations undertaken by Azerbaijan under the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination include cases of gross human rights violations committed by Azerbaijan during the aggression against Artsakh in 2020 and beyond,” he said in a statement.

“Concerns voiced by the Committee regarding the incitement of racial hatred and propagation of racist stereotypes against persons of Armenian national or ethnic origin, including by Azerbaijani government officials, as well as the lack of proper investigation, are the best evidence that discriminatory policies in Azerbaijan are implemented at the state level.

“All the other cases pointed out by the Committee, such as grave human rights violations committed by the Azerbaijani military forces against prisoners of war and civilians, including extrajudicial killings, torture, ill-treatment, and arbitrary detentions, as well as the destruction of Armenian cultural and religious heritage are carried out in accordance with and in furtherance of the discriminatory state policy of Azerbaijan.

“The observations presented by the Committee are part of the systematic and large-scale discriminatory policy of Azerbaijan against the people of Artsakh pursued for decades. The implementation of the discriminatory policy of Azerbaijan at the state level indicates that the path chosen by the people of Artsakh and the independent state-building have no alternative. We believe that the international recognition of Artsakh has matured as manifestation of fulfillment of the international community’s obligation to take effective measures to prevent gross human rights violations,” reads the statement.

Another imitation: Economist comments on 7% rise in pensions and benefits in Armenia

Panorama
Armenia – Aug 31 2022

Pensions and benefits in Armenia will increase by 2,000-3,000 drams starting from September 1. Will the government decision help mitigate the impact of inflation on socially vulnerable citizens?

Economist Suren Parsyan, who heads the economic research office at the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) Armenia Bureau, believes that the government will once again “squander” public funds without achieving any serious social impact due to its untargeted social policy.

In an interview to Panorama.am on Tuesday, the economist recalled that last year the food prices grew by about 12%, while in January-July 2022 the food inflation ran at 13.2%. The government now plans to increase the basic pension by 7% which won’t even cover this year’s inflation, he states.

Thus, the economist believes no significant changes in pensioners’ living standards should be expected.

“Extreme poverty in Armenia has deepened this year, and raising pensions by this amount will not help reduce the poverty rate. Though this step, the government once again tries to imitate implementation of social programs without assessing their effectiveness. I think we need a more targeted and proportional social policy,” Parsyan noted.

The economist believes that the increase of pensions and other benefits is solely aimed at alleviating the growing public discontent, but it won’t be of much use because the food inflation rate is rather high.

He highlighted that this year Russia has indexed pensions twice to tackle rising inflation. Whereas, the Armenian government takes belated steps, slightly increasing pensions eight months later.

“It won’t ease the overall situation. In general, the government is pursuing a political goal by this step to show that they have done something,” added the economist.

Touching on state wages, Suren Parsyan underscored that they have not changed for 5-6 years, while the government mainly tries to solve the problem by paying monthly or quarterly bonuses to employees. According to him, the government has turned the bonuses into a tool in its hands to win the sympathy of civil servants or to punish them.

He also noted that the number of people leaving the country has grown because of social problems, adding illegal immigration to the U.S., in particular, has dramatically increased.

“People are selling their homes and belongings to enter the United States illegally. Naturally, this is not done out of a life of leisure. In fact, people are leaving the country because of social and security problems,” Parsyan said.

Seyran Ohanyan: Together we can still save Artsakh, kick Azeri troops out of Armenia

Panorama
Armenia – Aug 31 2022

Hayastan bloc MP Seyran Ohanyan urged all to join the opposition rally in support of Artsakh in central Yerevan on Friday.

“At 7pm on September 2, a rally will be held on France Square in Yerevan,” he wrote on Facebook on Wednesday.

“I urge my comrades-in-arms, like-minded people, all our supporters, pro-state and conscious forces to come to France Square and join the struggle.

“Let’s stand with Artsakh. Together we can still save Artsakh and kick the Azerbaijani troops out of the sovereign territory of the Republic of Armenia, restoring the fighting spirit of the Armenian people, the foundations of security and dignity,” the lawmaker said.

Armenian Trade With Russia Raises Re-Export Questions By Ani Mejlumyan

Aug 31 2022

As international sanctions bite Russia and many Western companies have stopped doing business in the country, Moscow has tried to fill the gaps with a program it calls “parallel imports.”

Armenia has reported a nearly 50 percent increase in trade with Russia, raising questions about what part Armenia is playing in supplying Russia with the foreign goods its economy needs.

While the data are inconclusive about whether Armenian companies are in fact engaging in parallel exports, or re-exports, the raw trade numbers have caught the attention of Western diplomats in Yerevan.

Armenian exports to Russia, its largest trade partner, grew 49 percent in the first half of 2022 compared with the same period last year, the country’s official statistics agency reported at the beginning of August. Imports grew 42 percent.

That suggests a heavy level of re-export, independent economist Suren Parsyan told Eurasianet.

“There is no data that would specifically measure re-export, but there are clear economic indicators that help us understand that the volume is high,” he said. One example: that manufacturing has only grown 2.7 percent, compared to an overall export growth of over 50 percent.

Still, authoritative data are difficult to come by. The Armenian customs authorities release statistics only twice a year, and the last they have published are for 2021. Russia, meanwhile, has stopped publishing data. Russia’s customs service had previously published foreign trade numbers monthly, but the last such update came in January, the month before Russian tanks rolled into Ukraine.

Without those figures, it is impossible to know whether the increased exports from Armenia originated there or in a third country. 

Western embassies in Yerevan are trying to determine whether the growth in exports to Russia is “natural” or “unfavorable,” one diplomat told Eurasianet on condition of anonymity.

Among the “natural” explanations: a rising dram has made Armenian exports to Europe comparatively unfavorable and exporters have shifted to Russia; Armenian companies can be trying to take advantage of the new paucity of Western goods in Russian markets; and Russian emigres to Armenia have set up businesses there and do business with Russia.

“However we don’t know, and we have doubts, if these three natural causes would explain such an upswing in trade,” the diplomat said.

There are varying levels of concern about what may be happening, the diplomat said: “Sanctions evasion is the center of our attention, but we don’t have enough data yet. But re-exports are of course a concern, too.”

Sanctions against Russia and a potential economic crisis in that country are fraught with consequences for Armenia’s own economy, which depends heavily on Russia. But Armenian officials also have emphasized the positive of the new environment. Russian “companies under restrictions can enter the international markets in other ways, including through Armenian territory,” Minister of Economy Vahan Kerobyan told Shant TV shortly after the war in Ukraine started. “Along with many problems, there are also small opportunities.”

The ministry did not respond to queries from Eurasianet by the time this story was posted.

Armenia’s main export is heavy metals, which saw only a 4 percent increase in the first half of 2022 compared to the same period last year. But processed food exports increased 36 percent, and the fastest growing sector of exports was land, air, and water vehicles, which increased 2.3 times and is now the second-largest category of exports. That pattern suggests that the increase in exports is due to re-exports, wrote commentator Hakob Kocharyan on the news website 168.am. 

While Western diplomats have expressed concern about similar patterns of re-export to Russia via Turkey, the volume of Armenian trade is so much lower that it is not as much of an issue, the diplomat said.

Given Armenia’s geopolitical situation, Western governments have long been lenient when it comes to economic relations with Yerevan’s anti-Western partners. 

Now, Armenia finds itself more dependent on Russia than at any time in its post-independence history. Meetings between Armenian and Russian officials have become ever more frequent since the end of the 2020 war with Azerbaijan; Russia brokered the ceasefire to that war and Russian peacekeepers now protect the Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh. 

Armenia, in turn, has abstained from many anti-Russia votes in international fora, has agreed to buy Russian gas in rubles and even plans to subsidize Black Sea ferry connections from Georgia to boost trade with Russia. 

As long as Armenia is not abetting sanctions evasion, “I don’t believe this will seriously impact the West’s relations with Armenia,” analyst Benyamin Poghosyan told Eurasianet. “The U.S. is interested in weakening Russia’s positions in Armenia,” he said. But they also don’t want to weaken the position of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, he said.

“They know very well that they can’t find better candidates for leadership, so I don’t believe that the U.S. is interested in making economic life in Armenia even harder, thus putting pressure on Pashinyan.” 

“We understand the impact sanctions against Russia have on the Armenian economy,” a spokesperson from the U.S. embassy in Yerevan told Eurasianet. “We appreciate the government’s continued commitment to comply with these sanctions.”


Armenian, Azeri officials discuss ‘organizational issues’ on border delimitation

Panorama
Armenia – Aug 31 2022

The second session of the commission on delimitation and border security between Armenia and Azerbaijan was held in Moscow on Tuesday, chaired by Armenia’s Deputy Prime Minister Mher Grigoryan and Deputy Prime Minister of Azerbaijan Shahin Mustafayev, the Armenian Foreign Ministry reported.

Ahead of the meeting, Russian Deputy Prime Minister of Russia Aleksey Overchuk held meetings with Mher Grigoryan and Shahin Mustafayev and welcomed the continuity of the commission’s works.

“The sides discussed organizational and procedural issues, exchanged detailed views on the regulation of the joint activity and further workings of the commissions. They expressed gratitude to the Russian side for organizing the meeting at a high level,” reads the statement.

An agreement was reached regarding the holding of the third meeting within the agreed terms, the ministry said.

Russian peacekeepers` presence along Lachin corridor purely symbolic – Russian expert

ARMINFO
Armenia – Aug 31 2022
David Stepanyan

ArmInfo.The Russian peacekeepers’ presence along the Lachin corridor was purely symbolic before as well. And now that the corridor has been surrendered, this  symbolism is excessive, Alexey Malashenko, Senior Researcher at the  Institute of World Economy and International Relations, said in an  interview with ArmInfo.

The Shushi-Berdzor-Goris road section of the interstate highway  connecting Artsakh with Armenia will function until August 31, the  Artsakh Ministry of Interior said in a  statement. After August 31, a  new corridor via Berdadzor, Shushi district, will be put into  operation. The Russian peacekeepers will be redeployed. 

In fact, however, after the surrender of the Lachin corridor,  Azerbaijan will no longer feel the need for Russian peacekeepers,  which is most important for Ilham Aliyev to show during his meeting  with Armenia’s Premier Nikol Pashinyan in Brussels. 

The Armenian premier, Azerbaijani president and President of the  European Council Charles Michel are holding a meeting in Brussels, on  August 31, to discuss the formation of a group for an Armenian-  Azerbaijani peace agreement. 

The Russian peacekeepers’ presence is no longer of fundamental  importance for ensuring safe land communication between Armenia and  Nagorno-Karabakh. And after gaining victory in the 44-day war, Baku  will hardly put obstacle to the movement along the new highway  constructed by Azerbaijan itself. 

“I think ensuring safe movement is now more a problem for Armenia  though the peacekeepers will be present there as it is important for  Moscow and, perhaps, for Yerevan. As to Baku, regaining control of  Lachin is one more step toward a final solution to the Karabakh  problem,” Mr Malashenko said. 

United States, its western allies to continue opposing Russia`s Eurasian policy and Turkey`s neo-Ottoman policy – Robert Gevondyan

ARMINFO
Armenia – Aug 31 2022
David Stepanyan

ArmInfo. The appointment of Philip Thomas Reeker as U.S. Co- Chair of the OSCE Minsk Group and refusal of the U.S. and French ambassadors to Azerbaijan to visit  occupied Shushi are rather strong evidence of substantial  disagreement of Washington and Paris with the post-war realities in  the region, political scientist Robert Gevondyan said in an interview  with ArmInfo.

“Amid the absence of a mutual deterrence system in the South  Caucasus, such confrontation between the Collective West and the main  beneficiaries of the 44-day war, Russia and Turkey, means both  opportunities and new challenges for Armenia. In other words, it is  rather ample room for Armenia to advance its interests by comparing  them with the major external actors’ interests,” he said. 

Any error in this game could result in rather grave consequences for  Armenia, whereas any success could be of crucial importance. At  present, the “post-war affiliation” of Armenia and Azerbaijan to  Russia has not so far undergone any substantial changes. However, the  actual inactivity of the OSCE Minsk Group Co- Chairs in the wake of  the war resulted in Moscow and Brussels replacing them as venues for  the talks. 

Brussels is representing Washington as well. Thus, the EU is serving  as the focus for two of the three MG co-chairs. The effectiveness of  the simultaneous activities of the Moscow and Brussels venues can  only be assessed after a relative balance of forces in the  conflict-affected region has been established, while all the major  and minor actors are accumulating political capital. 

“As to the United States, it has been resuming its activity in the  South Caucasus since Joe Biden was elected president. The appointment  of a new OSCE co-chair by the U.S. and the ‘Shushi demarche’ are part  of this process. And in this particular case, these actions are a  response to the long-term disregard for Washington’s interests by  Russia in partnership with Turkey,” Mr Gevordyan said. 

In the foreseeable future, the United States and its western allies  will continue actively opposing Russia’s Eurasian policy and Turkey’s  neo-Ottoman policy. The regional policy Ankara and Moscow are  pursuing now is aimed at dividing the region between themselves, Mr  Gevordyan said.