Why Armenia seeks a ‘peace coach’ [Azeri Opinion]

Malaysia – Sept 3 2022

WARFARE is a tough business. However, peace-building efforts around the table of diplomacy are not less tough than waging a war on the battlefield. It is not an idea that belongs to me. But, anyway, it is mostly a verifiable fact.

What is happening between neighbouring Azerbaijan and Armenia in these days after the 44-Day War (2020) is and must be a very educating case study for scholars and diplomats in this framework.

Keeping 20 per cent of territories of Azerbaijan under its military occupation almost 30 years from the beginning of 1990s, Armenia never was willing to develop its peaceful negotiation skills.

Enjoying advantageous of the land-grab and attempting to demonstrate upper-hand position in the diplomatic talks with Azerbaijan and international mediators like co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group, Armenia’s political and military leadership not only consolidated its domestic authority till 2020 but also severely crippled rationality and common-sense of the Armenian people about peaceful coexistence over the course of decades.

When Armenia launched a new wave of military invasion against Azerbaijan on Sept 27, 2020, there was no option for Azerbaijan except to conduct a counterattack to liberate its lands. Following the Trilateral Statement that was brokered by Russia and ended armed clashes, a new phase of talks emerged between Azerbaijan and Armenia.

To avoid wasting time, Azerbaijan immediately declared its commitment to peaceful settlement by initiating massive restoration and reconstruction projects, returning Armenian PoWs and detainees, or facilitating Russian natural gas transportation to Armenia in order to strengthen the establishment of mutually trustful communication with Armenia.

However, Armenia seems to have adopted a revisionist and uncooperative attitude in the post-war period. Political leadership in Armenia has been complicating the initial environment of reconciliation, let alone showing any trust-building gestures. Just a few cases from the last two years speak out per se.

First, Armenia has rejected sharing maps of mines that were massively contaminated in the territories of Azerbaijan before the 44-Day War. This attitude is not only against the spirit of the Trilateral Statement that ended the war, but also keeps causing superfluous injuries and fatal results to civilians.

Another hostile attitude was observed when the illegally settled Armenians left Kalbajar or Lachin districts of Azerbaijan, which were under the occupation of Armenia. According to the numerous international reports, Armenians departing the liberated territories of Azerbaijan burned houses, set fire to forests, and apparently damaged the natural, cultural and historical environment.

Furthermore, a new political-diplomatic attempt by Armenia in the last few months is detrimental as much as the abovementioned provocations to the ongoing peacebuilding efforts. Nowadays, Armenian leadership at its full capacity declares the need to resume talks with Baku within the OSCE Minsk Group, chaired by France, Russia, and the United States, which has been unsuccessful in finding a peaceful solution since its establishment in 1992.

In his speech on April 12 this year, Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev stated that the Minsk Group had been active for 28 years before the Second Karabakh War. The co-chair countries have probably made hundreds of visits to Azerbaijan and Armenia over the years.

The result was zero. The president of Azerbaijan, referring to the Russia-Ukraine War, mentioned that the mandate given to the Minsk Group to resolve the conflict is de jure in force and can already be considered invalid de facto under the current circumstances.

Instead of the Minsk Group, President Aliyev advised that the OSCE could play a role as a credible international organisation, which would be able to host representatives of civil society, the media, and other influential public figures to contribute to the normalisation of relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

As can be seen, the expected communication and joint working capability among the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs (France, Russia, and the United States) has deteriorated due to the ongoing armed conflict between Russia and Ukraine. So, the question is: what is Armenia’s real agenda in doing so?

Since the Trilateral Statement signed on Nov 10, 2020, Armenia has been lacking in consistency to prove itself as a committed partner in initiating peace negotiations. Of course, the political leadership of Armenia is, in most cases, not able to declare publicly its revisionist attitude towards the obligations of the Trilateral Statement.

Therefore, in order to impede and strike a blow at peace talks or at least to kill time for its real agenda, Armenia seems to exploit the current tense contradictions in the realm of international security.

Another expected political yield for the Armenian leadership to announce the OSCE Minsk Group as a peace coach is domestic. To wit, by summoning the OSCE Minsk Group, the Armenian decision-makers appear to be attempting to shift their own responsibility to an outsider in order to appease hard pressure from Armenian society, which harshly blames the government for its defeat in the war with Azerbaijan.

Armenian leaders must be so watchful as to think that it will not be easy to defend biased arguments on the table of diplomacy in the upcoming period.

Anyway, recent noises in Yerevan about the revival of the OSCE Minsk Group within a fake agenda may not only wear down the problem-solver images of co-chair countries as a side effect, but also may have been supposed to serve as a lifebelt for the Armenian leadership in dealing with the looming bushy problems of domestic and foreign policy.

The writer is Counselor at the Embassy of Azerbaijan


Billionaire Ruben Vardanyan announced the renunciation of Russian citizenship and moving to Artsakh

Sept 3 2022

Billionaire Ruben Vardanyan published a video message on his social networks in which he announced the renunciation of Russian citizenship and moving to the unrecognized Nagorno-Karabakh Republic (NKR) against the backdrop of aggravation between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Recall that the countries have not yet signed a peace agreement, despite the end of the active phase of the Second Karabakh War in November 2020.

I made a decision, realizing the risks I was taking, to renounce Russian citizenship and move to Artsakh (the self-name of the NKR — Note ed.). This decision was very difficult, but so right. I hope my Russian partners and friends will accept this decision of mine as the decision of their friend.

Vardanyan explained his move with a desire to support local residents. He noted that the conflicting parties must go through “a gradual way to reduce the degree of hatred.” He also expressed gratitude to Russia for the presence of peacekeepers on the territory of the unrecognized republic and appealed to the world community to pay attention to the conflict between Yerevan and Baku.

The news was commented on by former Tatler columnist Yunia Pugacheva in her telegram channel.

Perhaps we are also observing optimization to preserve assets and fortunes, because it is known that Ruben Karlenovich created holder structures not only for himself, but also for a very large group of Russian officials and oligarchs just from the time of Troika. And maybe we’re watching the — “the new president of Armenia/prime minister”, since it is obvious that the current political situation in Armenia is unstable and its pro-Russian position is due to the hopelessness of both the geographical position and the material. And, apparently, the Kremlin does not see a reliable comrade in any of the current Armenian politicians. But Ruben Karlenovich — It’s another matter, your man.

It is quite obvious that simply going to Artsakh to protect the interests of Armenia did not require at all to give up a Russian passport. Unlike Ukraine, there are no problems with dual citizenship in Armenia. Since it is almost impossible to get out of Russian citizenship (it takes years), it is clear that Vardanyan had support in this matter. (author’s spelling and punctuation preserved. — Ed.)

Ruben Vardanyan — Russian billionaire of Armenian origin, one of the founders of the Troika Dialog brokerage company, which was bought by Sberbank in 2011. Forbes estimates his fortune at $1 billion. In 2021, Vardanyan took 116th place in the list of the richest people in Russia according to the publication.

Azerbaijani forces open fire at Armenian military vehicle

Panorama
Armenia – Sept 3 2022

Azerbaijani troops opened fire at an Armenian army vehicle in the eastern border section late on Friday, the Armenian Defense Ministry said in a statement.

No casualties were reported on the Armenian side.

The ministry also denied the Azerbaijani accusations of cross-border shooting.

“At the same time, the Azerbaijani Defense Ministry spread disinformation, claiming that the Armenian army units opened fire at the Azerbaijani positions and military vehicles in the eastern section of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border,” the statement said.

Opposition MP: Impossible to prevent fall of Armenia and Artsakh without regime change

Panorama
Armenia – Sept 3 2022

Armenian MP Tigran Abrahamyan of the opposition Pativ Unem faction reiterated the need for regime change to prevent the fall of Armenia and Artsakh.

“One of the main problems of Artsakh in the post-war period is that despite the current difficult situation the government agencies have no action plan to deal with a particular scenario,” he wrote on Facebook on Saturday.

“To say nothing of the fact that there is no shortage of figures holding key government positions who are unable to handle a crisis. Given Azerbaijan’s dangerous policies, systemic problems and the crisis of viability further aggravates the situation.

“Much depends on how quickly the incumbent Armenian authorities will be removed, because it is impossible to prevent the fall of Artsakh and Armenia without it.

“Our biggest problems are inside the country, ranging from ideological breakdown to the rule of a government which doesn’t serve Armenia’s interests. Other issues, even Azerbaijan’s threats, are not as dangerous as the political landscape in Armenia,” he stated.

Ombudswoman attends opening of ‘safe space’ for LGBTQI community in Yerevan

Panorama
Armenia – Sept 3 2022

A new office, a Safe Space for Trans LGBTQI Community opened in Yerevan by the Right Side Human Rights Defender NGO on Friday in attendance of Armenia’s Human Rights Defender Kristine Grigoryan, the Embassy of Sweden in Yerevan reported.

“Now the LGBTQI community, their family members, and community supporters have the opportunity to receive legal and psychological consultations and assistance,” it said.

“Ambassador Svensson was present at the opening ceremony to support the initiative together with the ambassadors of the Netherlands, the United Kingdom and the Human Rights Defender of Armenia (Ombudsperson),” reads the statement.

Armenian parliament releases MPs’ attendance data

Panorama
Armenia – Sept 3 2022

The Armenian National Assembly on Saturday released data on MPs’ attendance at the 3rd session.

The figures show that the opposition Hayastan faction had the lowest attendance. Hayastan’s Ishkhan Saghatelyan had 198 unexcused absences, Anna Grigoryan – 158, Vahe Hakobyan – 194, Armen Gevorgyan – 150 and Seyran Ohanyan – 149.

Lawmakers from the other opposition faction, Pativ Unem, also had unexcused absences. In particular, Taron Margaryan had 150 absences, Hayk Mamijanyan – 151, Taguhi Tovmasyan – 88, Tigran Abrahamyan – 148, etc.

Ruling Civil Contract faction MPs Khachatur Sukiasyan and Gurgen Melkonyan had 38 and 54 unexcused absences, respectively.

Speaker Alen Simonyan had 3 unexcused absences.

The two opposition blocs were boycotting parliament sittings to attend street protests.

Congressional leaders demand U.S. humanitarian aid to Artsakh

Panorama
Armenia – Sept 3 2022

Congressional Armenian Caucus Co-Chair Frank Pallone (D-NJ) and Nevada Congresswoman Dina Titus (D-NV) were joined by a bi-partisan group of over 45 Members of Congress in calling on Secretary of State Antony Blinken and U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) Administrator Samantha Power to “take immediate steps dedicating significant resources” to support the at-risk Armenian population of Artsakh, reported the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA).

“Our American blockade on U.S. humanitarian aid to Artsakh – as a practical matter – effectively abets Azerbaijan’s attempts to strangle Artsakh’s population, ethnically cleansing the indigenous population of a region at the very core of the ancient Armenian homeland,” said ANCA Executive Director Aram Hamparian. “It’s wrong. Our government knows it’s wrong. It has to stop – and, with sufficient Congressional leadership, it will.”

The Congressional letter, sent on the thirty-first anniversary of the Republic of Artsakh’s declaration of independence, notes that, “the people of Artsakh continue to face severe hardships caused both by the deadly 44-day war that Azerbaijani forces provoked in 2020 and the ongoing aggressions committed against innocent civilians.” The letter specifically calls on the State Department and USAID to “to significantly increase funding that will directly assist the Armenian population in Nagorno-Karabakh, including assistance for housing, food security, water and sanitation, health care, rehabilitation, and demining and UXO clearance services they need to safely rebuild their lives, homes, and communities. We also urge you to take every action possible to protect the historic and cultural Armenian sites in territory held by Azerbaijan, which many reports indicate are currently under threat.”

Members of Congress also asked for an update on Biden Administration efforts to assist the people of Artsakh and to conduct an updated needs assessment on the humanitarian crisis there, to be shared with Congress to best determine Fiscal Year 2023 U.S. assistance levels.

Joining Representatives Pallone and Titus in cosigning the Congressional letter on Artsakh assistance are Representatives: Nanette Barragan (D-CA), Earl Blumenauer (D-OR), Tony Cardenas (D-CA), Andre Carson (D-IN), Judy Chu (D-CA), David Cicilline (D-RI), Katherine Clark (D-MA), Lou Correa (D-CA), Jim Costa (D-CA), Jason Crow (D-CO), Lloyd Doggett (D-TX), Anna Eshoo (D-CA), Adriano Espaillat (D-NY), Josh Gottheimer (D-NJ), Jim Himes (D-CT), William Keating (D-MA), Ro Khanna (D-CA), Andy Kim (D-NJ), Raja Krishnamoorthi (D-IL), James Langevin (D-RI), John Larson (D-CT), Rick Larsen (D-WA), Brenda Lawrence (D-MI), Susie Lee (D-NV), Mike Levin (D-CA), Ted Lieu (D-CA), Zoe Lofgren (D-CA), Alan Lowenthal (D-CA), Tom Malinowski (D-NJ), Carolyn Maloney (D-NY), James McGovern (D-MA), Grace Meng (D-NY), Joseph Morelle (D-NY), Grace Napolitano (D-CA), Donald Norcross (D-NJ), Chris Pappas (D-NH), Scott Peters (D-CA), Chellie Pingree (D-ME), Katie Porter (D-CA), John Sarbanes (D-MD), Janice Schakowsky (D-IL), Adam Schiff (D-CA), Brad Sherman (D-CA), Albio Sires (D-NJ), Jackie Speier (D-CA), David Trone (D-MD), and David Valadao (R-CA).

On August 22nd, ANCA Chairman Raffi Hamparian, in letters sent to Congressional leadership and rank and file U.S. Senate and House members, called for Congressional inquiries into the Biden administration’s effective blockade on humanitarian aid to Armenian families of Artsakh. “America must not be complicit in the ethnic-cleansing of Artsakh by Azerbaijan,” stressed Hamparian.

Arbitrary interpretation of negotiations creates an impression that Azerbaijan intends to undermine the peace process, Armenian FM says

Public Radio of Armenia
Armenia – Sept 3 2022

The position of the Armenian side regarding the five provisions proposed by Azerbaijan remains unchanged, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan has said.

“As we have stated before, we find nothing unacceptable in the proposals forwarded by Azerbaijan on March 10, 2022. Another thing is that these proposals do not address all issues of the Armenia-Azerbaijan comprehensive peace agenda. With our response forwarded to the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chair countries, we completed the agenda, and therefore, on that basis, we are ready for the continuation of peace negotiations,” the Foreign Minister said in a statement as he responded to speculations on the Brussels meeting of August 31st.

This was once again confirmed by Prime Minister Pashinyan during the recent discussions held in Brussels.

“Not listening or trying not to listen to this position gives the Armenian side a reason to question the sincerity of Azerbaijan’s intention in achieving peace. Moreover, the continued arbitrary, false interpretations of the negotiations and the avoidance to implement the agreements make an impression that Azerbaijan intends to undermine the peace process and continue its policy of ethnic cleansing through the use of force,” FM Mirzoyan stated.

Chair of Armenian Studies to be opened at Tabriz State University

ARMINFO
Armenia – Sept 3 2022
Alina Hovhannisyan

ArmInfo. Yerevan State University and Tabriz State University came to a preliminary  agreement to open a chair of Armenian Studies at the Iranian  University.  YSU Rector Hovhannes Hovhannisyan said summarizing the  results of his meeting with Chancellor of Tabriz State University  Safar Nasrollahzadeh.

In turn, Yerevan State University expressed its readiness to  establish the Atropatene Research Center (a historical region and an  ancient state in the north-west of modern Iran) at the Department of  Iranian Studies of Yerevan State University, which will become an  important platform for regional studies.  “We attach importance to  the development of relations with Iranian universities, not only in  the educational and scientific fields, but also in the context of  deepening and strengthening bilateral relations,” Hovhannisyan said.

At the same time, he said that following the meeting with the head of  the State University of Tabriz, an agreement was also reached on the  implementation of student and specialist exchange programs, the  implementation of joint research projects, and various academic and  cultural initiatives. 

US Congressman: I look forward to the day when Artsakh can finally enjoy the international recognition

NEWS.am
Armenia – Sept 2 2022

U.S. Congressman Adam Schiff issued a statement on the occasion of the 31st anniversary of the proclamation of the Republic of Artsakh.  

“Artsakh’s Independence Day is a time to celebrate the unbreakable spirit of the people of Artsakh, who 31 years ago declared their independence from the Soviet Union. However, as the atrocities of the past two years have proven, independence is just the beginning of the struggle for liberation – and the fight to protect Artsakh from Turkey and Azerbaijan continues to demand our full attention and support.

While Artsakh’s path has never been an easy one, the war waged by Azerbaijan over the past two years against Artsakh’s people, its cultural sites, and its sovereignty has tested the nation in unimaginable ways. Armenian soldiers continue to be killed, dozens are being illegally detained as prisoners of war, and thousands of innocent civilians live in fear of the next attack or invasion. The United States must take immediate action to hold the Aliyev regime accountable and condemn Azerbaijan’s unprovoked aggression.

Today, we urgently renew our calls for the State Department to use its diplomatic power to reduce tensions and show America’s unwavering support for Artsakh’s sovereignty. In Congress, I will continue to push for the immediate release of Armenian prisoners of war, robust humanitarian and economic aid for Artsakh, and a full prohibition on U.S. security assistance to Azerbaijan. These actions are critical to helping Artsakh enjoy peace and self-determination.

I will always stand with Armenia and the people of Artsakh, and look forward to the day when Artsakh can finally enjoy the international recognition it has been deprived of for too long,” said the Congressman.