Der Matossian Publishes New Book on ‘Denial of Genocides in the Twenty-First Century’

“Denial of Genocides in the Twenty-First Century” book cover


The University of Nebraska Press announced the publication of “Denial of Genocides in the Twenty-First Century,” an edited volume on denial of genocides by Bedross Der Matossian.

The edited volume is the first book that analyzes the nature of denial of genocides in the twenty-first century from an interdisciplinary and comparative perspective.  While the denial of the Armenian Genocide represents the classic case of genocide denial in the modern period, other genocides of both the premodern and the modern periods have seen their share of denialism.

This edited volume discusses the ongoing denial mechanisms of some of the most horrendous genocides of the premodern and modern periods. There is no genocide in the course of history that has not been denied by states or non-state actors, often including “professional” historians and pseudo-historians.

Throughout the twenty-first century, genocide denial has evolved and adapted with new strategies to augment and complement established modes of denial. In addition to outright negation, denial of genocide encompasses a range of techniques, including dispute over numbers, contestation of legal definitions, blaming the victim, and various modes of intimidation, such as threats of legal action. Arguably the most effective strategy has been denial through employing intentional misinformation.

“Denial of Genocides in the Twenty-First Century” brings together leading scholars from across disciplines to add to the body of genocide scholarship that is challenged by denialist literature. By concentrating on factors such as the role of communications and news media, global and national social networks, the weaponization of information by authoritarian regimes and political parties, court cases in the United States and Europe, freedom of speech, and postmodernist thought, this volume discusses how genocide denial is becoming a fact of daily life in the twenty-first century. The volume covers the denial of the indigenous, Armenian, Cambodian, Guatemalan, Rwandan, Bosnian, and Syrian genocides as well as the Holocaust.

“I think this is a unique opportunity to bring together the leading experts of genocide in order to understand what makes the twenty-first century denial of genocides different from those of the earlier period. Despite that fact that other examples of the denial of genocide in this volume are not as sophisticated as the mechanisms used by the Turkish state in denying the Armenian Genocide, nevertheless they use similar techniques in pursing their shameful actions. The techniques include, but are not limited to, using social media, academic platforms, intimidation through legal actions, and disguising denial under the cloak of legitimate scholarship among others. I am sure that the reader will appreciate and benefit from the wide range of cases covered in this volume.” stated editor Bedross Der Matossian.

The list of contributors in the order of their contribution are Bedross Der Matossian, “Introduction: Genocide Denial in the Twenty-First Century”; Robert K. Hitchcock, “Denial of Genocide of Indigenous People in the United States”; Talin Suciyan, “Armenian Genocide and Its Denial: A Comprehensive Tool of Supremacism?”; Marc A. Mamigonian, “Weaponizing the First Amendment: Denial of the Armenian Genocide and the U.S. Courts,”; Eldad Ben Aharon “Coalition Politics and Parliamentary Paralysis: The Armenian Genocide Bill during the Netanyahu Administration, 2009–2021”; Gerald J. Steinacher, “Denying the Shoah: Distorting History in the Twenty-First Century”; Ben Kiernan, “Aversions to Acknowledging the Khmer Rouge Genocides in Cambodia, 1990–2021”; Samuel Totten, “Denial of the Guatemalan Genocide, 1981–2020”; Jelena Subotić, “Regional Political Implications of Bosnian Genocide Denial”; Roland Moerland, “Mainstreaming the Denial of the Genocide against the Tutsi”; Uğur Ümit Üngör and Annsar Shahhoud “A Multifront War of Narratives: The Assad Regime’s Emerging Denialism”; and Israel W. Charny, “Epilogue: Denials of Reality Remove the Capacity to Think Straight and Logically in Order to Feel Protected and Safe.”

Copies of “Denial of Genocides in the Twenty-First Century” are available for purchase from the University of Nebraska Press website. Use code: 6AS23 to receive a 40 percent discount.

Bedross Der Matossian

Bedross Der Matossian is the vice-chair, professor of Modern Middle East History, and Hymen Rosenberg Professor in Judaic Studies at the Department of History at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln (UNL). He is the past president of the Society for Armenian Studies. He is the author, co-editor, and editor of six volumes including his latest “The Horrors of Adana: Revolution and Violence in the Early Twentieth Century” (Stanford University Press, 2022).

Asbarez: Assemblymember Holden’s Legislation Condemning Azerbaijan’s Blockade of Artsakh Clears Policy Committee

Assemblymember Chris Holden


SACRAMENTO—Assemblymember Chris Holden’s bill, Assembly Joint Resolution 1 (AJR 1), which condemns Azerbaijan’s blockade of Artsakh on Tuesday passed the Assembly Committee on Judiciary. The bill calls on the Biden Administration to recognize the independence of Artsakh and to hold Azerbaijan accountable for its actions. 

“It has been over 100 days since this blockade began.  During this unconscionable act, over 120,000 Armenians, including women, children, the elderly and disabled, have been cut off from essential supplies, such as food, fuel, and medicine.  It is imperative that California and the Biden Administration speak with one voice that the Lachin Corridor must be opened, emergency humanitarian assistance must be provided, and Azerbaijan must face the consequences of its aggression,” said Assemblymember Holden.

AJR 1 reaffirms California’s support for the continuing efforts of Armenians of Artsakh to develop as a free and independent nation, urges the President and Congress of the United States to support the self-determination of the Armenians of Artsakh, and calls on the President of the United States and the United States Department of State to engage proactively in multilateral conflict resolution efforts to reach a lasting resolution to this conflict.

“The ANCA Western Region has worked diligently with Assemblymember Holden to garner broad-based support for AJR1 to ensure that during this time of existential threat facing the Armenian Nation, California reaffirms its long-standing unequivocal support for the self-determination and safety of the people of Artsakh. We are grateful to Assemblymember Holden for taking the lead on this issue, and we will continue to do everything we can to ensure full passage of this important resolution,” said Armenian National Committee of America-Western Region chair Nora Hovsepian.

AW: Armenian pianists win top prizes at Chopin International Piano Competition in Hartford

Left to right: Vartan Arakelian and Seiran Tozlian

HARTFORD, CT – Local high-school student and pianist Vartan Arakelian and pianist Seiran Tozlian of Armenia received second prize at this year’s Chopin International Piano Competition.

Arakelian, a ninth grade student at Buckingham, Browne and Nichols, won the silver medal in the “Young Artists” category among 24 pianists ages 13 to 17. He performed works by Bach, Chopin and Janacek. Arakelian is a student of Lilit Karapetian-Shougarian. He was awarded a cash prize, as well as an invitation to participate in the International Chopin Festival for young artists in Busko-Zdroj in Poland this summer. Arakelian was also the first prize winner in last year’s Mildred Freiberg Middle School Competition, sponsored by the New England Piano Teachers Association in collaboration with M. Steinert & Sons of Boston.

Following his performance in the “Professional” category, Tozlian also received a cash prize and an invitation for performances in Poland. The 20 year-old pianist presented a wide range of compositions by Chopin, Debussy, Prokofiev, Rachmaninoff and Ligeti in the preliminary and final rounds of the competition. Seiran was also a prize winner at the Anselmo Academy of Music’s Fifth International Competition in New York and a semi-finalist at the 2023 Boesendorfer-Yamaha International Piano Competition.

The annual Chopin International Piano Competition is sponsored by the Hartford Chopin Foundation. Now in its 14th year, the four-day event, which took place from March 8-12, drew 85 aspiring pianists of various ages. This year’s edition saw participating pianists representing the US, Canada, Indonesia, Japan, China, South Korea and Armenia.

The international jury consisted of pianists Krystian Tkaczewski of Poland and USA, Josephine Koh of Singapore, Philippe Raskin of Belgium, Adolfe Vidal of Venezuela, Mina Perry of Japan, Michael Bulychev-Okser of the United States, and Mikhail Voskresensky of Russia.

Both Arakelian and Tozlian appeared in the Winners’ Gala concert on March 12 at the Asylum Hill Congregational Church in Hartford.




Local AYF, ANC chapters announce second annual NYC Spring Vernissage

NEW YORK, NY — The AYF New York “Hyortik,” Manhattan “Moush,” and ANC-NY Chapters will be hosting their second annual NYC Spring Vernissage on Saturday May 6, 2023 from 1 p.m. to 5 p.m. at St. Illuminator’s Armenian Apostolic Cathedral (221 E 27th Street, New York, NY 10016). 

This event serves as an opportunity to acknowledge the cultural achievements of Armenians today. NYC Spring Vernissage will spotlight the success of local Armenian businesses and the resilience of the Armenian Diaspora through art, food, clothing and accessories. 

“Last year’s NYC Spring Vernissage was not only a success, but a liberating event seeing how far Diasporan Armenians have come with their endeavors. Everyone had an amazing time supporting local Armenian businesses and learning about each of their backgrounds,” said AYF New York “Hyortik” member Arev Ebrimian. “I look forward to seeing these businesses strive and succeed even more than they already have.” 

Interested vendors are asked to contact [email protected]. All proceeds will be donated to ARS’ Camp Javakhk.

Founded in 2016, the Manhattan “Moush” Chapter works to unite Armenian youth and organize activities in the New York City area. The chapter has a Senior and Junior chapter. The Manhattan “Moush” Chapter sets out to achieve its goals and objectives throughout the year, including events such as April 24th protest in NYC, social networking events, and preparation for regional athletic events. The AYF-YOARF’s five pillars (athletic, cultural, educational, political, social) guide this chapter and help keep its membership active and at the forefront of the Armenian Cause at all times.
The AYF-YOARF New York “Hyortik” Chapter existed even before the AYF was founded in 1933 and works to unite Armenian youth and organize activities in Queens and Long Island. The chapter has a Senior and Junior chapter. The New York “Hyortik” Chapter sets out to achieve its goals and objectives throughout the year with events such as commemorating the Armenian Genocide every April 24th in NYC; fundraising for our homeland; hosting a fall festival and Christmas dinner with juniors; annual Super Bowl parties; and ski trips. The AYF-YOARF’s five pillars (athletic, cultural, educational, political, social) guide this chapter and help to keep its membership active and at the forefront of the Armenian cause at all times.


AW: AYF Camp Haiastan travels to Canada

Kenar Charchaflian with the badanis of the Toronto community

TORONTO and MONTREAL, Canada — AYF Camp Haiastan spent quality time with the Armenian communities of Toronto and Montreal this past weekend, hosting informational meetings for AYF juniors and their families.

Executive Director Kenar Charchaflian addressed over 40 of the “Krisdapor Mikaelian” and “Rosdom” Toronto AYF juniors on Friday. The presentation was held in the library of the Armenian Community Center of Toronto. The audience was also filled with eager parents, who will hopefully send their children to camp this summer.

Kenar Charchaflian presenting at the Armenian Community Centre in Toronto, March 24

On Saturday, Charchaflian addressed the Montreal “Tro” and Laval “Kedashen” Junior Chapters. AYF members asked questions and participated in the discussion during which they received some free camp merchandise. Afterwards, a parent-specific Q&A session was held, which covered more of the logistics and safety protocols.

Kenar Charchaflian presenting at Sourp Hagop Armenian School, Montreal, March 25

“I want to thank the ARF Central Committees of the Eastern Region and Canada for helping to coordinate these events,” said Charchaflian. “It has been quite some time since Camp Haiastan has shown a presence in these communities, and I consider this past weekend the first stepping stone in strengthening our relations with the Canada-hye communities.”

During this off-season tour, AYF Camp Haiastan also visited Chicago and Detroit. More community visits will be announced soon.

Located in Franklin, Massachusetts, AYF Camp Haiastan, was founded in 1951 and is the oldest Armenian camp in the United States. The Camp prides itself on providing a healthy and safe experience to Armenian-American youth to help them foster their Armenian identity and establish lifelong friendships.


RFE/RL Armenian Report – 03/28/2023

                                        Tuesday, 
Russia, Armenia Discuss Defense Cooperation Amid Tensions
Armenia - Russian members of a Russian-Armenian commission on defense 
cooperation attend its session in Yerevan, .
A Russian-Armenian intergovernmental commission on bilateral defense cooperation 
began a regular session in Yerevan on Tuesday amid growing friction between 
Moscow and Yerevan.
The commission is specifically tasked with furthering “military-technical 
cooperation,” which mainly involves supplies of weapons and/or their joint 
manufacturing.
Opening the annual meeting, Armenian Deputy Defense Minister Karen Brutian 
stressed the importance of deepening Russian-Armenian relations in this area. 
Brutian expressed hope that the members of the joint task force will hold 
“productive discussions” over the next few days.
The Armenian Defense Ministry reported no other details of the meeting.
Russia has long been the principal supplier of weapons and other military 
equipment to Armenia.
In an apparent reference to Russia, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian complained 
last September that “our allies” have failed to deliver weapons to Armenia 
despite contracts worth “hundreds of millions of dollars” signed in the last two 
years. He did not shed light on those contracts.
Pashinian responded to opposition claims that his government has done little to 
rebuild the Armenian armed forces after the 2020 war with Azerbaijan.
Brutian visited Moscow and met with his Russian counterpart Alexander Fomin in 
November. No concrete agreements between the Russian and Armenian militaries 
were announced as a result of that trip.
Russian-Armenian relations have deteriorated since then because of what the 
Armenian government sees as a lack of Russian support in the conflict with 
Azerbaijan.
Pashinian suggested in January that the close military ties with Russia may be 
putting Armenia’s security and territorial integrity at greater risk. The 
Russian Foreign Ministry dismissed the claim as “absurd.”
The unprecedented tensions between the two allied states rose further late last 
week after Armenia’s Constitutional Court gave the green light for parliamentary 
ratification of the International Criminal Court’s founding treaty. The ruling 
came one week after the ICC issued an arrest warrant for Russian President 
Vladimir Putin over war crimes allegedly committed by Russia in Ukraine.
Moscow warned on Monday that Yerevan’s recognition of The Hague tribunal’s 
jurisdiction would have “extremely negative” consequences for Russian-Armenian 
relations. The Armenian government did not publicly react to the stern warning 
as of Tuesday evening.
Some Armenian opposition figures claimed that Pashinian engineered the 
Constitutional Court ruling to score points among the Western powers at 
loggerheads with Russia.
Karabakh Armenians Again Reject ‘Reintegration’ Talks In Baku
        • Ruzanna Stepanian
Nagorno-Karabakh - President Arayik Harutiunian chairs a meeting in Stepanakert, 
..
Nagorno-Karabakh’s leadership dismissed on Tuesday a fresh Azerbaijani offer to 
send its representatives to Baku for talks on the Armenian-populated region’s 
“reintegration” into Azerbaijan.
It reiterated that Azerbaijani and Karabakh officials should continue to meet at 
the Karabakh headquarters of Russian peacekeeping forces and discuss, first and 
foremost, humanitarian issues such as the reopening of the Lachin corridor 
blocked by Baku for more than three months.
A statement released by the Karabakh foreign ministry also insisted on an 
“internationally recognized negotiation format” for discussing with Baku a 
broader political settlement of the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict.
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev’s office made the offer on Monday two days 
after Azerbaijani troops seized a hill overlooking a dirt road that bypasses the 
blocked section of the Lachin corridor. The authorities in Stepanakert as well 
as the Russian peacekeepers accused Baku of violating the Russian-brokered 
ceasefire that stopped the 2020 war in Karabakh.
The Karabakh statement said the timing of Aliyev’s latest offer shows that Baku 
is keen to impose solutions on the Karabakh Armenians, rather than negotiate 
with them in good faith.
Arayik Harutiunian, the Karabakh president, held on Monday an emergency meeting 
with local officials and political leaders in Stepanakert. Harutiunian said the 
Karabakh leaders need to “soberly assess” the worsening security and 
humanitarian situation and “draw necessary conclusions.” The crisis can still be 
resolved through “prudent steps,” he said in his publicized remarks.
A senior Karabakh lawmaker, Artur Harutiunian, said on Tuesday that those steps 
depend on the outcome of the Russian peacekeepers’ continuing negotiations with 
the Azerbaijani side aimed at ensuring their withdrawal from the occupied hill.
“After the negotiations are over and their results clear we will have to decide 
our next steps,” he told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service.
Azerbaijani and Karabakh officials most recently met at the peacekeepers’ 
headquarters near Stepanakert on March 1. According to Karabakh’s leadership, 
they discussed the restoration of “unimpeded” traffic thorough the Lachin 
corridor and Armenia’s energy supplies to Karabakh.
An official Azerbaijani readout of the talks said, however, that they focused on 
the Karabakh Armenians’ “integration into Azerbaijan.”
Arayik Harutiunian insisted afterwards that his representatives refused to 
engage in such a discussion. He said Baku responded by threatening to take 
“tougher and more drastic steps.” The Karabakh leader linked that to the March 5 
shootout that left three Karabakh police officers and two Azerbaijani soldiers 
dead.
U.S. Concerned About Azeri ‘Military Movements’ In Karabakh
Armenia - U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs 
Karen Donfried speaks to RFE/RL in Yerevan, June 20, 2022.
The United States has expressed concern about Azerbaijan’s weekend “military 
movements” that further tightened its blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh’s land link 
with Armenia.
Azerbaijani troops seized on Saturday a hill overlooking a dirt road that 
bypasses a section of the Lachin corridor blocked by Baku for more than three 
months.
Karen Donfried, the outgoing U.S. assistant secretary of state for Europe and 
Eurasia, appeared to have discussed the development with Azerbaijani Foreign 
Minister Jeyhun Bayramov in a phone call on Monday. The U.S. State Department 
said she “expressed concern over Azerbaijani military movements.”
The Azerbaijani military claimed that it took “necessary measures” to stop 
Armenia’s arms supplies to Karabakh.
The Armenian government and Karabakh’s leadership have flatly denied such 
supplies repeatedly alleged by Baku in recent weeks. They say that the 
Azerbaijani advance in Karabakh constitutes a serious breach of the 
Russian-brokered that stopped the 2020 war.
The Russian Defense Ministry also accused Azerbaijan of violating the ceasefire. 
It said later on Saturday that Russian peacekeepers demanded that the 
Azerbaijani troops return to “their previously occupied positions.” Baku has 
ignored the demand so far.
A State Department spokesman, Vedant Patel, said Donfried also reaffirmed 
Washington’s “commitment to Armenia-Azerbaijan peace negotiations” and called 
for “direct dialogue” between the conflicting parties.
“There is not a military solution to this conflict,” Patel told a news briefing 
in Washington.
According to the Azerbaijani readout of the phone call, Bayramov accused Armenia 
of adopting an “unconstructive position” in ongoing negotiations on an 
Armenian-Azerbaijani peace treaty.
The United States has repeatedly called on the Azerbaijani side to lift the 
blockade that has caused a serious humanitarian crisis in Karabakh. The U.S. 
ambassador to Armenia, Kristina Kvien, made a point of visiting an Armenian 
border checkpoint leading to the Lachin corridor earlier this month. Another 
senior U.S. diplomat made clear, however, that Washington is not considering 
imposing sanctions on Baku because of the blockade.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

CivilNet: Trauma has shaped me to commit to doing something useful: Noubar Afeyan

CIVILNET.AM

28 Mar, 2023 07:03

Noubar Afeyan sat down with Lara Tcholakian to share his historical narratives and the role that his great aunt Armenouhi had on him and his brothers as children. The Armenian genocide has helped him better understand his place in the world and shaped the degree to which he has become committed to doing something useful for the world. To that effect, Afeyan explained the role that the Aurora Humanitarian Initiative has had over the past eight years, and the reasons why the initiative will continue to expand worldwide. Afeyan shared his views on why it’s important to think and build toward the future, and the attributes required to be destination-oriented, to reach goals, and to drive transformation, whether nationally or in a corporate setting. As the founder of Flagship Pioneering, he also discussed the ways in which he and his team work to make breakthrough companies through breakthrough innovations, including the creation of the COVID-19 vaccine. Finally, the discussion turned to the role of collective healing, education, the meaning in life, and the connection between Armenian spiritual rituals and life in general.

About Dr. Noubar Afeyan

Noubar Afeyan is founder and CEO of Flagship Pioneering. As part of the spinoffs of Flagship Pioneering, he co-founded Moderna the pioneering messenger RNA medicines company, for which he is Board Chairman. He is also co-founder and Board Chairman of Omega Therapeutics, Generate Biomedicines, Tessera Therapeutics, Alltrna, Apriori Bio, and ProFound Therapeutics. Throughout his career, Afeyan has cofounded and helped build over 70 life science and technology startups. Born in Beirut, he completed his undergraduate degree at McGill University in Montreal and his PhD in biochemical engineering at MIT. He has written numerous scientific publications and is the inventor of over 100 patents. He was a senior lecturer at MIT’s Sloan School of Management and a lecturer at Harvard Business School. Together with his partners, he has launched philanthropic projects including the Aurora Humanitarian Initiative, FAST Foundation, and the UWC Dilijan School. Afeyan is a member of the Corporation of MIT (the Institute’s governing body) and a member of the board of trustees for the Boston Symphony Orchestra. Afeyan was awarded a Great Immigrant honor from the Carnegie Corporation in 2016, received a Technology Pioneer award from the World Economic Forum in 2012, and was presented with the Ellis Island Medal of Honor in 2008. In 2022, Noubar was elected to the National Academy of Engineering.

Program overview

In a new, open setting, Lara deconstructs inherited cultural and historical narratives, memories, life lessons and experiences from change catalysts. Her guests reflect on the stories, people, events and mindsets that have shaped their professional and personal lives, enabling them to create a more mindful life.

CivilNet: Stepanakert calls for dialogue, Baku insists on ‘reintegration’ agenda

CIVILNET.AM

28 Mar, 2023 10:03

  • An unnamed source in Russia’s Foreign Ministry told the Russian state-run news agency TASS that Moscow has warned Yerevan of “extremely severe” consequences if Armenia becomes a member of the International Criminal Court.
  • The authorities in Nagorno-Karabakh have responded to Azerbaijan’s proposal for “reintegration talks.”
  • U.S. Assistant Secretary of State Karen Donfried expressed concern over Azerbaijan’s recent military advances in Nagorno-Karabakh in a phone conversation with Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov.

Attorney Mark Geragos Sues L.A. Times For Libel Over Armenian Genocide Settlement Reports

The defense attorney has filed a complaint over stories he says included false statements about his role in the disbursement of funds to victims’ families

Defense attorney Mark Geragos filed a lawsuit against The Los Angeles Times and three of its Pulitzer-prize-winning investigative reporters on Friday for libel, “false light” invasion of privacy and intentional infliction of emotional distress.

Geragos alleges that a series of stories published in 2022 falsely imply that 15 years ago, he and his then-co-counsel were involved in the already-established fraud involving the disbursement of settlement funds to a small subset of the victims of the Armenian genocide and related charities. In a 45-page complaint, Geragos contends that he and his co-counsel had actually helped to uncover and prosecute the fraud and worked to deepen the investigation, and the Times reporters ignored those facts.

“I’m a big boy,” Geragos tells LAMag. “I’ve been doing this for 40 years, I understand reporters have their job and I have great respect for the role of journalism and reporters.” (Disclosure: In December, Geragos co-founded Engine Vision Media, which owns Los Angeles magazine.)

The Times story at the heart of the libel accusation looks back at a series of lawsuits brought against New York Life and then French insurance giant AXA in 1999 and 2002, respectively, filed by Armenian-American lawyer Vartkes Yeghiayan over life insurance policies held by victims of the 1915 Armenian genocide that were not honored by the companies. 

Kabateck, and then Geragos, joined the case in 2001; in addition to obtaining funds for victims’ families, the case is widely seen as having served as a means to force the judicial branch of the U.S. government to acknowledge the Armenian genocide occurred at all.

The cases ended with New York Life settling for $20 million in 2004. AXA, the French company,  settled for $17.5 million the following year. In addition to paying legal fees and court costs, the settlement funds were to be distributed to families of victims who could prove their ancestors had taken out life insurance policies from those companies before the genocide. The remainder was agreed to be delivered to Armenian diaspora charities and churches.

By all accounts, the disbursement of funds from the New York Life settlement—overseen by a claims administrator recommended by Yeghiayan, who reported to a board appointed by the California State Insurance Commission—ran smoothly. And by all accounts, the disbursement of funds from the AXA Settlement, overseen by the same claims administrator in Los Angeles reporting to a three-member board of prominent French Armenians in France, did not.

The claims administrator, Parsegh Kartalian, was reported to the courts by Geragos and Kabateck for fraud, for diverting $2.5 million to an account only he controlled. Local lawyer Berj Boyajian was discovered to have diverted nearly $600,000 to accounts under his sole control and was prosecuted for false statements to the State Bar of California; he lost his law license and returned most of the funds after the fraud was revealed to the court). Yeghiayan and his wife, Rita Mahdessian, were brought up on State Bar of California charges for allegedly diverting money from the settlement fund; Yeghiayan died in 2017 before the charges could be heard and Mahdessian’s case was thrown out after she told the Bar it was her husband’s doing. 

The Times reporting on the subject has implied that Geragos played a role in the malfeasance and mismanagement that accompanied the disbursement of the French funds. Geragos strongly disputes this implication, pointing out that three State Bar of California investigations into the case before 2022 absolved him and Kabateck of any wrongdoing.

“This case is the single most investigated case by every single agency up and down the state,” Geragos tells LAMag. “I referred it to the D.A.’s office. Brian was the one who referred it to the State Bar. Brian and I wrote a letter to the Attorney General. I had not only State Bar investigators, but D.A. investigators looking into it; I gave them full, unfettered access to all of these documents. The people who the Times tried to lionize… all invoked the Fifth Amendment; I cooperated with every agency.”

In the initial investigative piece and subsequent articles, however, the Times repeatedly invokes Geragos’ and Kabateck’s names. All of the 2022 reports further accuse the two of somehow improperly funding “pet charities”—including the Loyola School of Law’s Center for the Study of Law and Genocide and a local Armenian church; it also repeats claims that some charitable organizations said they never received the money. Geragos says he provided the Times reporters with bank statements and other records showing the churches did receive that money more than a decade prior, but the reporters refused to accept the records as a refutation of the claims. (Geragos’s lawsuit also contains a long memo from Kabateck’s lawyer refuting many of the claims point-by-point.)

Hillary Manning, a spokesperson for the L.A. Times, denied Geragos’ allegations and defended the reporting. 

“We performed a public service by publishing this story,” she said in a statement to LAMag. “We encourage people to read the reporting for themselves to get a better understanding of the difficulties that Armenian people encountered when trying to access settlement money related to the Armenian genocide. We will vigorously defend the Los Angeles Times and our journalists against this baseless litigation.”

In an interview with LAMag on Sept. 27, Geragos also took issue with the Times calling the Center for the Study of Law and Genocide at Loyola—his alma mater— a pet charity.

“Can you imagine you’re a Jewish lawyer and they call the Lowenstein Center at Fordham a ‘pet charity’?” he asked LAMag in September. “It smacks of racism.”

In the lawsuit, Geragos notes that subsequent reporting—even on stories unrelated to the Armenian settlement—repeated claims about the case. Geragos’ and Kabateck’s pictures and boilerplate copy about the investigation accompanied multiple stories, including articles about convicted lawyer Tom Girardi and the Bar’s tendency to crack down harder on Black lawyers than white ones.

Geragos also claims the paper appeared to be attempting to pressure the State Bar of California to open a fourth investigation into the case. The Bar did ultimately open an investigation in September, despite an email provided in the lawsuit that suggests the body knew there was no new information in the Times story and the case had been fully investigated before it was published.

“At a certain point, it was what I considered to be the most outrageous breach of journalism–I don’t even call it ethics,” he says. “Combined with this kind of malicious campaign to try to take me down and try to get the State Bar to investigate, and everything else, it’s beyond the pale. That’s not journalism. That’s something else. That’s more of what more people would say is the opposition research in a political campaign.”

In the lawsuit, Geragos also alleges that his relationship with the reporters deteriorated after his clients—one of whom was at the center of the paper’s news-breaking 2017 story about the drug-fueled escapades of then-USC Medical School Dean Carmen Puliafito—withdrew their cooperation in the wake of a settlement he negotiated with Puliafito and the university on their behalf.

That settlement became the subject of a September 2021 Times story that implies Geragos and his clients destroyed potential evidence in an ongoing criminal investigation. 

“This whole idea that somehow evidence was destroyed: Evidence was not destroyed,” he said. “It is a very common practice to have the plaintiff—as distinguished from the lawyers—turn over everything that they have. That doesn’t mean that the lawyer doesn’t maintain it. It doesn’t mean that law enforcement doesn’t get access to it.”

Both law enforcement and the reporters had a copy of the evidence in question at the time of the settlement in 2018, Geragos notes. The Times’s own reporting indicates that the D.A. declined to press charges in the case before the settlement was finalized and his clients destroyed their personal electronic records.

He said he believes that the bad blood generated by the Puliafito story, as well as an apparent desire to find another “Tom Girardi story” after being scooped led to the reporters pursuing stories about him in bad faith—and ones in which their own reporting did not justify the explicit and implicit allegations against him.

“They had an agenda. They had conclusions. They weren’t going to be deterred by the facts,” he says. “The one thing that they’re going to be deterred by is a lawsuit.”

But he’s not looking for a payout.

“I want the Times to acknowledge that what they did was wrong, and I want the record corrected, and I’ll go on my merry way,” he says. “If I don’t do it—if I don’t take a stand as a lawyer who fortunately has the resources to pursue something like this—then who’s going to?”

[Editor’s note: Mark Geragos is a co-founder of Engine Vision Media, which owns Los Angeles as well as other properties. The company’s owners play no part in our journalism. We first reported on this story in September 2022, months prior to the magazine’s sale to Engine.]


Food: Food truck offers flavors of DavAni Armenian BBQ in Carmel Drive parking lot

 

Armen Abrahamyan and Seda Arzumanyan are co-owners of DavAni Armenian BBQ. (Photo courtesy of Seda Arzumanyan)

Gariy Ambartsumyan said he was thrilled when he learned an Armenian BBQ food truck was opening for business not far from his Noblesville home.

“It’s not like you can go just anywhere and get Armenian,” said Ambartsumyan, a 45-year-old truck driver of Armenian descent.

Ambartsumyan has become a regular at DavAni Armenian BBQ, open for takeout or delivery in a parking lot at 105 W. Carmel Dr. and laying claim to being the only takeout restaurant specializing in Armenian cuisine in the state. Armen Abrahamyan, a native of Armenia, opened the business in October and is the head chef. He operates the food truck, with a business model that more closely resembles a takeout restaurant, with help from his family, including his wife Seda Arzumanyan.

Customers have been receptive to DavAni’s distinctive offerings.

“So far, we’ve received a lot of positive feedback about our Armenian BBQ,” Arzumanyan said. “Many people are not familiar with Armenian cuisine and culture, but as they try our food, they fall in love with the flavors and unique tastes.”

Abrahamyan learned to prepare Armenian dishes at a young age. When he moved to Indiana six years ago, he noticed there was a scarcity of Armenian cuisine offered locally. He catered for small events and gatherings before opening DavAni – which offers hefty portions of pork, lamb, chicken and beef kebabs and wraps, along with sides including grilled vegetable salad, tahini sauce and hummus – in the fall.

“For Armen, cooking Armenian BBQ and kebab is more than just a job. It’s a passion that he loves to share with the people of Indiana,” Arzumanyan said.

Cuisine in Armenia, a nation of less than 3 million people in the mountainous Caucasus region between Asia and Europe, is defined by a blend of flavors and ingredients that reflect the country’s rich history and cultural influences.

The meat, often cut into large chunks, is marinated in a mixture of herbs and spices for several hours before Armen cooks it to just the right tenderness in the truck, sometimes chatting with customers as he does his work. Visitors to DavAni are liable to catch a whiff of the aroma of barbecued meats even before noticing the food truck’s bright red paint scheme.

DavAni is open Tuesday through Friday from 11 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. and from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Saturdays. Wraps start at $9.50, BBQ kebabs start at $11.50, and plates including sides range from $16 to $20. Customers can order at the window, utilize DoorDash or UberEats, or order ahead online for takeout at davanibbq.com. 

Ambartsumyan and his wife, Elena, get food from DavAni most Saturdays, usually through DoorDash, though sometimes Gariy parks his big rig in a nearby parking lot to pick up his meals in-person. His favorite is the beef lula kebab, and he raves about Abrahamyan’s way of preparing DavAni’s meats.

“No one can make it the way Armen does,” Ambartsumyan said. “He knows how to make it right. Everything’s perfect.” 

https://www.youarecurrent.com/2023/03/27/food-truck-offers-flavors-of-davani-armenian-bbq-in-carmel-drive-parking-lot/