Turkiye, Armenia begin to lift physical and mental barriers

ARAB NEWS
March 31 2023
SINEM CENGIZ


For my two past visits to Armenia, I crossed into the country via the border of a third nation, Georgia, despite the fact that Armenia is one of Turkiye’s immediate neighbors. This was due to the fact that the border between the two countries was closed. While crossing the border, my Armenian colleague emphasized the importance of relations between the two nations and said that, even though there are land borders between countries, minds have no borders. He added: “Two nations can still be close, but before opening the closed border we have to open our mental borders.”

In 1993, during the first Nagorno-Karabakh war, Ankara closed the border and cut relations with Armenia out of support for Azerbaijan, Turkiye’s main ally in the Caucasus. The Turkish-Armenian border remained closed until the aftermath of the devastating earthquake that hit southern Turkiye and northern Syria last month.

The sole land border crossing linking the two countries opened for the first time in more than 30 years to allow Armenian aid and rescuers into the disaster zone. This exceptional opening of the border on Feb. 7 was symbolically very important because the two countries still do not have formal relations, although there is an ongoing normalization process. The same border crossing was also used in 1988, when a big earthquake hit Armenia and the Turkish Red Crescent Society moved aid to the affected areas. As part of the recent earthquake diplomacy, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan visited Turkiye to meet with the 27-member Armenian search and rescue team operating in Adiyaman.

However, Turkiye and Armenia now want to go beyond this disaster diplomacy and unlock the border between them permanently. Yerevan announced this week that Turkiye and Armenia plan to allow crossings between the two countries. Mirzoyan said the land border would open only for diplomats and citizens of third countries until the beginning of the tourist season. In early 2023, Turkiye lifted a ban on cargo flights between the two countries.

While both capitals agreed to open the land border, in the meantime there was “football diplomacy 2.0” taking place between Ankara and Yerevan. A UEFA Euro 2024 qualification match between the Armenian and Turkish national teams took place in Yerevan last Saturday. The Turkish sports minister went to Yerevan to attend the match, making him the first Turkish official to visit the Armenian capital in almost two decades.

The two countries want to go beyond disaster diplomacy and unlock the border between them permanently.

Sinem Cengiz

In 2008, ahead of Turkiye’s World Cup qualifier against Armenia, Turkish coach Fatih Terim said: “This is only a football game, it is not a war.” Indeed, it was just a football game, but not an ordinary one.

Back then, it was the first time the two neighboring countries, which have historical animosities toward each other, had come face to face. The Armenian and Turkish presidents visited each other’s capitals to watch the matches played between the two national teams. This move was later described as “football diplomacy,” which served as a bridge between Ankara and Yerevan at that time. This famous football diplomacy paved the way for the signing of the 2009 Zurich Protocols, which were aimed at improving diplomatic relations and reopening the border. However, those protocols were never ratified and they remained as one of the missed opportunities between the two countries.

On Saturday, Armenian football fans gathered at the Republican Stadium, years after the two countries first resorted to football diplomacy, to heal their historical bitterness. Citing security concerns, UEFA had banned Turkish fans from attending the qualifier in Yerevan. The Turkish national anthem was booed by the Armenian fans in the stadium right before the match kicked off. It was a saddening, yet significant, signal, showing that the society is still not ready for normalization, never mind reconciliation.

Normalization and reconciliation are two different processes, which are often confused. While normalization requires the opening of borders and establishment of diplomatic relations between states, reconciliation is a thorough process that requires the establishment of positive relations between two societies. This is tougher than just inking deals at the diplomatic table.

The current phase of normalization between the two countries began with the appointment of special envoys to carry out negotiations, not diplomatic envoys. This itself was a clear indication that normalization will take time. A sincere dialogue based on mutual trust and the necessary confidence-building measures will eventually accelerate the normalization phase, which will be followed by a reconciliation phase. Even if, one day, Turkiye and Armenia do establish diplomatic relations, the tougher task will be the reconciliation of the two nations. While Ankara and Yerevan gradually and reciprocally approach normalization, both leaderships need to pursue successful public diplomacy to consolidate their efforts.

Turkish-Armenian relations are considered to be a “history of missed opportunities.” Both sides should benefit from the ongoing positive climate that has been created, so that history will not repeat itself and the two neighbors can consign their record of missed opportunities to the dusty pages of history.

Although a challenging road lies ahead, a new era appears to be dawning. The change of heart of the two sides could be key to not only unlocking the closed land border, but also the closed mental borders between the two nations.

  • Sinem Cengiz is a Turkish political analyst who specializes in Turkiye’s relations with the Middle East. Twitter: @SinemCngz
Disclaimer: Views expressed by writers in this section are their own and do not necessarily reflect Arab News’ point of view

The War the U.S. Media Ignores

April 31 2023

BY NICK AKGULIAN

 

MAR. 31, 2023

Imagine spending more than three months of this winter with empty grocery store shelves, lack of medicines at the local pharmacy, and a shortage of every other daily basic good needed. Imagine living with no heat for much of the day and night in frigid temperatures, no fuel in the car to travel to a doctor’s appointment or to a place of employment, no internet to perform work and school tasks, or to communicate with loved ones. For one-hundred days and counting, this has been the reality for the 120,000 people living within the borders of a beautiful mountainous territory called Nagorno Karabagh, an historically Armenian populated enclave which lies within the borders of present-day Azerbaijan, adjacent to the country of Armenia.

I had the good fortune to live and work alongside the people of Nagorno Karabagh for several months late last year while engaged in a health care project. They are a hardworking, generous, religious people, many living a traditional mountain village life on a land they have been tied to for centuries. They are a people who have endured two wars since the breakup of the Soviet Union, the last in 2020, when the country of Azerbaijan supported by Turkey and other regional powers, unleashed a 44-day attack on the area that took the lives of over 5000 of their men and women. Each day during our village clinic sessions, stories were told of loved ones lost or badly wounded, displacement from homes or towns, loss of livelihood, and much more. Because Azerbaijan now occupies all the land surrounding Nagorno Karabagh, many of the clinics were conducted within view of Azerbaijan military posts, a source of constant anxiety for the population given the periodic attacks on the villages. Rather than being angry, bitter or desiring revenge, the refrain I heard repeatedly from the people was, “we simply want to live in peace.”

Instead, on Dec. 12, 2022, Azerbaijan began a complete blockade of the only road connecting Nagorno Karabagh to the country of Armenia and the outside world, placing a stranglehold on an entire population in attempt to remove them from their ancestral homeland. During this time, Azerbaijan has also repeatedly disrupted the gas and electricity supply to the area, as well as internet service. As a result, hospitals and clinics cannot supply needed services. Schools have closed. Food is being rationed. Businesses are shuttered. Organizations such as Genocide Watch and the Lemkin Institute have issued repeated warnings of genocide. Our own State Department, along with the European Union, United Nations, the World Council of Churches, the Vatican, Human Rights Watch and many others, have called for an end to the blockade, yet the humanitarian crisis continues.

While the horrific events in Ukraine are rightly covered vigorously by the press and are a regular focus for our politicians, the above story, also taking place in the former Soviet Union, has largely remained out of the media. It also has not triggered actions by our elected officials similar to those taken against Putin and Russia for its gross human rights violations. To make matters worse, the hard-earned tax dollars of every Wisconsin and US worker is flowing into the hands of the Azerbaijan leadership responsible for this attempt at ethnic cleansing. While our country defends democracy and human rights in Ukraine against a brutal dictator, we are in effect doing the opposite in Nagorno Karabagh by using our dollars to support and reward a dictator who inflicts suffering on a people governed by democratic principles.

Our politicians, the media, and the global community can and must do better. We as citizens can do our part by contacting local and national media to request they report on this story, in hopes that shining a light on the blockade will assist in ending it. Likewise, we must relentlessly contact our politicians—including the White House, State Department, Senators Baldwin and Johnson, the Congressional Representative of your district—until they speak up forcefully against Azerbaijan for its conduct, and back those words with all necessary actions to end the blockade and secure a lasting future for these people in their homeland. Our demands should include an immediate end to the handing over of dollars we work so hard for, to a government intent on committing genocide.

Through these actions, we can do our part to end the blockade, bring peace to the people of Nagorno Karabagh, and avoid adding another tragic chapter to human history.

Nick Akgulian, MD, is a long-time family physician in the Racine area who has spent several years abroad on health care projects in Belize, Armenia and most recently Nagorno Karabagh.


How to plan an epic hike through Armenia on the Transcaucasian Trail


April 1 2023
Anna Richards

In Lonely Plan-It, we take you step by step through how we put together some of the most complicated travel adventures. Here, travel writer and outdoors enthusiast Anna Richards explains how she hiked the Armenian section of the under-the-radar Transcaucasian Trail. 

I knew very little about Armenia before deciding to hike the Transcaucasian Trail (TCT), which winds hundreds of miles through this under-explored country. When I told friends of my plans, most knew little more than the scraps I did – a turbulent, tragic recent history; some vague connection to the Kardashians.

But what I found there simply amazed me: millennia-old monasteries, vast volcanic plateaus and rust-colored gorges that crumbled like breadcrumbs as you hiked them. 

Scout new ways to explore the planet’s wildest places with our weekly newsletter delivered to your inbox.

The full TCT spans 932 miles (1500km) across Georgia and Armenia. A separate section is in progress to cross Azerbaijan, which would bring the full trail to almost 1900 miles (3000km). Unfortunately, due to current border conflicts, linking the two sections is a far-off goal. 

Totaling 516 miles (832km), the Armenian segment of the TCT opened to the public this year. I was one of the guinea pigs that got to beta-test it in 2022 ⁠– although the distance I covered over four weeks (360 miles / 580km) made me feel more like a hamster on a wheel. 

Some numbers for context: the USA’s Pacific Crest Trail (PCT) issues more than 7000 hiker permits a year. Around 3000 thru-hikers attempt the Appalachian Trail annually. And in 2022, fewer than 100 hikers completed a multiday section of the TCT – making this a track that is truly…off the beaten track.

In order to (safely) get away from the hiking masses, you’re going to have to plan ahead. Here’s how to plan a trip to hike the Transcaucasian Trail. 

With maps, GPS and careful planning for water

This trail requires a lot of preparation. It should only be hiked between June and September, as outside of this season snow makes parts of the trail inaccessible. (Even when I hiked in August, some snow lingered in the Gegham Mountains.) Yet while the warm summer months clear the trails for hiking, the season brings challenges: in July and August temperatures along much of the route soar to more than 32°C (90°F). Since water is scarce, you’ll need bottles with a few liters’ capacity, as well as a filter-purifier to refill them. 

It’s essential to download route-planning apps. While there are no physical maps of the TCT, GPX files are available through the TCT website (a suggested donation of $100 gets you access to route guides, plus a Slack channel run by trail planners and recent hikers). I’m not exaggerating when I say the trail would be impossible without these resources. 

There will be lots of gear involved – so really think this through

While there were times that I wished I was an ultralight packer, I don’t regret taking with me such “luxuries” as my Kindle and deodorant. As you pack, keep in mind that for the TCT you need to be totally self-sufficient. This means carrying up to seven days’ worth of food for certain areas, as well as the means to prepare it (cooking or cold soaking).

Much of the TCT requires wild camping, so good gear is essential. Where there are guesthouses, you’ll need cash; you’ll find ATMs in larger towns, though I still recommend having a couple of hundred dollars’ worth of Armenian drams when you start the trail. Be prepared for all weather conditions, as the altitude along the way will rise and fall by almost 10,000ft (3000m). A sun hat, a waterproof shell and thermal layers are all musts. 

Send yourself resupply packages via the HIKEArmenia office in Yerevan; most towns will have at least a small shop to receive them. For camping gas and other last-minute supplies, Camp.am in Yerevan is your only option.

An Armenian SIM card (I used UCom) will get you unlimited data for less than $15 per month, and can be renewed at top-up machines in any large town. When you’ve got so much off-road navigation, this is invaluable. Take a copy of your ID to scan.

Set out from different starting points for northbound and southbound journeys

Any great journey begins with a single step – though in the case of the TCT, your initial ones will be on airport escalators and rickety buses, before you set out on the trail itself. Fly into Yerevan, Armenia’s capital, then catch a bus from there to either Meghri, at the southern end of the trail (nine hours), or to Gyumri, from where you’ll take a taxi to Lake Arpi to begin the trail southbound. Since buses fill up, call ahead to book using the number listed on bus companies’ Facebook pages (or ask someone to do this for you if you don’t speak Armenian). The day of your journey, the driver will have a list of passengers who have reserved in advance (there are no tickets). 

Before you set out for Armenia, decide which direction you’ll be hiking. South-to-north is a baptism of fire, with Arevik National Park the toughest, remotest part of the trail. I saw no one for three days and had to carry enough water to satiate a camel on a trans-Saharan odyssey. Yet this is also one of the most spectacular sections I experienced.

Expect near-limitless generosity in the countryside

I took too much food because I hadn’t anticipated the limitless generosity of the nomads, villagers and farmers that I met along the way. Like an army, hungry hikers march on their stomachs, so enjoy it! Hospitality is paramount to Armenians, so when you’re waddling along with a belly as heavy as your backpack, you’ve likely made your hosts very happy. 

As a solo female traveler, I was regularly taken in by families who fed and housed me, and let me shower in their homes (a true luxury). Men may be less likely to be invited to stay, though everyone can expect to be well-fed. While women hiking alone are a common sight in the Armenian countryside, use your best judgment and common sense about accepting hospitality along the way.

You’ll see plenty if you only have a week

Many of us don’t have the luxury of taking months of vacation, and even in four weeks I didn’t complete the full length of the TCT’s Armenian section. If you’ve only got a week, I recommend the Gegham Mountains, a green moonscape of remote lakes in volcanic craters, nomadic, yurt-dwelling shepherd families and frequent violent flash storms. It’s the highest part of the Armenian trail – and its wide-open spaces give you a nice (natural!) high, too.

I’d do it the same way. On a hike of any length here, the trail is your classroom.

Set aside your preconceptions of what it’s like to do a thru-hike. So you’ve done the GR20? Fantastic: since you’re clearly in great physical shape, much of the TCT won’t be so tough on your body. But instead of a well-marked trail expect lots of bushwhacking, and no cold beer afterwards. Hiked the PCT? Wonderful: you’ve got stamina and are accustomed to being self-sufficient. But expect to multiply the solitude you experienced by a huge factor. On the TCT you can go days without seeing a human face – and when you do, you can expect a large language barrier to contend with. 

Most of all, enjoy it. Hiking Armenia is an education about an ancient, rich civilization, and a place that sees comparatively little footfall. A journey here turns you into an explorer.

Art: Uncovering the Photographer Behind Arshile Gorky’s Most Famous Painting

HYPERALLERGIC
March 30 2023
Art

As we pursue photographer Hovhannes Avedaghayan a fascinating picture begins to emerge of him and the world of which he was part.
Shushan and Vostanig Adoian, Van, c. 1911, photographed by uncredited photographer (image courtesy Dr. Bruce Berberian and The Arshile Gorky Foundation)

Around 1911, mother and son Shushan and Vostanig Adoian visited a local photography studio in Van, a heavily Armenian city near the eastern border of the Ottoman Empire. There, they sat for a portrait, one they might send to Setrag Adoian, her husband and his father, in the United States. The absence of that man from the portrait is palpable. It is but the first of many absences and disappearances to disturb a photograph that in time became a memorial object and then artistic source material. Indeed, the portrait seems almost haunted by its own disappearance, its fading as an autonomous object with its own particular orbit and history as it is overtaken by these other narratives. But could autonomy be regained, and a link to its own world reforged? 

In later years Vostanig, by that time a migrant to the United States and an artist using the name Arshile Gorky, was reunited with the photograph and used it as source material for two canvases, monumental pieces that he worked on over a period of decades, and for a great number of drawings that served as studies for the two canvases, as well as navigations of and negotiations with the image of his younger self beside his (by then late) mother. The two canvases are now in major US public art collections: the National Gallery of Art and the Whitney Museum of American Art. The photograph is in a private collection but belongs no less to the world of art, for it has become part of an art historical narrative.  

Hrag Vartanian made just this point at the commencement of Fixed Point Perspective, an ongoing project convening a number of artists to individually and collectively explore the heritage of Ottoman studio photography. As he observed of Gorky’s The Artist and His Mother artworks, “When we discuss the series, we focus on the avant-garde style of the painting and drawing. But what about the photography?” What might we learn, he went on to ask, when we actively contemplate photographs, and indeed search for the photographer responsible for the image of the Adoians? With these key questions, he proposed the Adoian portrait as offering a path into a wider history and culture.  

Of course, a focus on the photographer can often severely circumscribe a photograph. “What was Egypt will become Beato, or du Camp, or Frith,” wrote Douglas Crimp just as the art market was beginning to sink its teeth into photographs, recategorizing and redefining them in the process. Yet the Adoian portrait has not suffered this fate — because an Ottoman Armenian studio photograph does not fit easily into a Eurocentric market-led art history of photography, and because, of course, art has already overtaken it via other means, Gorky the artist now appearing almost as the creator of his own boyhood image. To turn to the photographer in these circumstances has an unusually liberatory potential. It offers the opportunity to untether the photograph from its present moorings, so that it might spiral, in Allan Sekula’s words, not “inward toward the art-system” but “outward toward the world.”

Thus we are faced with both a photograph and a set of questions. Our starting point as we endeavor to spiral outward is the small space of the studio in which the Adoian photograph was made. Identifying the space is hampered by the photograph’s blurred and murky backdrop, and yet with close study, we can begin to match its backdrop with that of contemporaneous studio photographs from Van. Its design is akin to a cloister scene, depicting a series of columns and arches. Most interesting of all is a detail lying outside the frame of the Adoian picture but visible in other photographs, a view of a path — a winding path no less — leading up to a twin-peaked mountain.  

Also found on other photographs is the name of a photographer, Hovhannes Avedaghayan. As we pursue Avedaghayan through his pictures and the scant mentions of him in a variety of sources — from memory books (houshamadyan) to commercial business listings — a fascinating picture begins to emerge of him and the world of which he was part, the world from which the Adoian portrait hailed.

Avedaghayan was born in 1863 in Van, just as change was afoot in the Armenian world. Above the city, at the monastery complex of Varakavank in the foothills of the twin-peaked Mount Varak, Mgrdich Khrimian, the recently appointed vartabed (abbot) was at work on a series of radical teachings and publications that sought to situate Armenian life in a distinct Armenian geography, and to draw attention to the poverty and oppression faced by the largely rural Armenians who dwelt in those lands, as well as the plight of those forced to migrate. Varakavank became a symbol of a new sense of Armenian identity, one based not just in religion but also in a shared language, history, culture, and, perhaps above all, a shared ancestral homeland — a homeland in need of rescue. 

Hovhannes Avedaghayan, Varakavank, Van, c. 1910.; image published in Vasbouragan, Venice: St. Lazzaro Mkhitarian Dparan, 1930 (image public domain)

There is evidence to suggest that Avedaghayan himself saw Varakavank as a kind of spiritual home. The only photograph thus far traced to which he applied his name by hand to the front depicts Varakavank and an assortment of figures: clergy of the monastery, teachers and students of the attached school, and what might be a group of visiting pilgrims. (In other photographs the name appears as a print label on the reverse sides of mounts.) Another handwritten note is in the skies above: “To you, oh my beautiful nest of Varak, I fly across the infinite expanse.” The words are taken from a poem by Khoren Khrimian, Mgrdich Khrimian’s nephew and director of the Varakavank school. The poem expresses the yearnings of a migrant for his home, yearnings that Avedaghayan understood.  

As a young man Avedaghayan left his native Van for the Russian Caucasus, part of a defining pattern of Armenian migrancy. There he became involved with the emergent Armenian Revolutionary Federation, known as the Dashnaktsuthiun (Federation), or simply Dashnaks, founded in Tiflis (now Tbilisi) in 1890. The Dashnaks are thought to have been inspired, in part, by a famous speech in which Mgrdich Khrimian blamed the lack of reforms in the Ottoman East on Armenians’ use of peaceful petitions rather than violent weaponry. Thus revolutionary activity became another defining feature of Armenian life — giving definition, it is important to note, not because revolutionary involvement was widespread among Armenians, but because the activity that did exist would play a decisive part in the unfolding of Armenian history. Avedaghayan’s role in the group at this time is unclear but we do know that he was arrested by the Russian authorities (suggesting that his role was potentially an active one) and exiled along with other political prisoners to the notorious penal colony on the island of Sakhalin, off the Siberian coast.

At some point around the turn of the century, Avedaghayan succeeded in escaping from Sakhalin, returning to his home in Van by way of a long journey through Japan, China, India, and Iran. (Were this the life of a European or American photographer, such as the aforementioned Beato, du Camp, or Frith, this would be the stuff of legend.)

Photograph of Arshile Gorky, “The Artist and His Mother” (c. 1926-42) at the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC (photo © and by Carolina Miranda, used with permission)

Back in Van, Avedaghayan established what appears to be the city’s first photographic studio. Photography came to Van a little later than in other comparable cities of the region, but followed a familiar pattern of arriving via an Armenian with imported technology and techniques, and largely serving the Armenian community. Avedaghayan’s clientele broadly resembled that of other Armenian studios of the Ottoman East. He pictured a cross-section of local society — families, businesspeople, clerics, and students — but wealthier Vanetsis were predominant.

Studios served Armenian communities, responding to their particular needs — those of a dispersed people. A number of Avedaghayan’s photographs relate, like the Adoian portrait, to the migratory phenomenon. The regional migrations of the sort that Avedaghayan had embarked upon had been part of Armenian life for generations. But by the late 19th century, a new global movement had come to dominate, in which Armenians crossed continents in search of economic opportunity and security, and the US was the favored destination. Photographs such as the Adoians’ were threads that tied people together, part of a global exchange between those who had left their ancestral homelands and those who stayed behind. They brought people together in another sense, to gather around them, to look and converse, to tell stories, and to remember loved ones. Photographs were the objects around which families, friends, and communities adhered, in and between the Old and the New World.   

The flower in Vostanig’s hands is a motif repeated across many of Avedaghayan’s migrant photographs, evidently placed there by the photographer to serve as signs and gestures of love and friendship for the photographs’ intended recipients. As photographic technologies and techniques were similar from one city to the next, perhaps only in such small details can we begin to observe a particular individual at work behind the lens.

What did mark Avedaghayan’s studio as different was his involvement in a more unusual, clandestine form of picture-making. He had not entirely left the revolutionary life behind, and served as a photographer for Dashnak activists in the Van region. Revolutionary groups, especially the Dashnaks, specialized in visual propaganda. They understood the role photographs could play in gathering people together as communities — their images of revolutionary heroes can be approached as one large nation-building enterprise. They understood, too, the vast narrative potential of photographs; the one they encouraged was of heroic and righteous struggle against oppressive overlords, and photographs proved instrumental in forging mythic, larger-than-life personas for activists.  

Hovhannes Avedaghayan. Khisarji Kevork’s family, Van, 1910s (image courtesy Armen Shahinian collection)

Such figures, in the end, became all too much the instruments of fantasy. The presence of some revolutionaries in the eastern provinces gave the Ottoman government a pretext for the wholesale removal of Armenian populations in 1915, under the cover of war. It was an utterly violent removal, undertaken via massacre and forced migration to the unforgiving climes of the Syrian desert. And it was the violent removal of not only people but also their culture and history.  

Van was one of the few places where Armenians defended themselves against these machinations. Avedaghayan was certainly involved in defending the city’s Armenian sections — as were practically all Armenians, even the young Vostanig — and there is a distinct probability that he was involved in creating the photographs of that defense. Thousands of Vanetsis were saved — but they would never again dwell in their homeland. More than 100,000 of them subsequently marched eastward on foot; two-thirds reaching their destination in the Caucasus. Though some managed to travel further still, the vast majority stayed, under very difficult conditions. Shushan Adoian died in 1919 in Yerevan amid a sea of starving refugees from the Ottoman Empire; Vostanig sailed for the US in 1920; Hovhannes Avedaghayan lived in Baku, where he died in 1923 at the age of 60.

Thus to uncover the maker of the Adoian photograph is also to uncover part of the often shrouded, ignored, and misrepresented history and visual culture from which it emerged. This is possible because Armenians occupied a highly visual world. Theirs were lives lived with, among, and through photographs and other images.

What can be said of the visual culture of the Ottoman Armenian photographic studio? My own assessment is that it is difficult to make a case for Avedaghayan’s photographs, and indeed those produced by comparable local studios, as formally distinctive or innovative. A globalized medium, photography replicated its forms across the world, its methods being imported into each new place as surely as were its technologies. Studying photographs collectively rather than individually helps to lay bare this essential truth. Ottoman Armenian studio photography required the intervention — and idiosyncratic vision — of a Gorky to turn one of its number from a repetitious or “unoriginal” example into something of interest to the art world.

However, Armenian-made photographs are distinctive in a sense, for they were made in and circulated through a distinctive milieu. Their forms and conventions might have been familiar, prosaic, perhaps even hackneyed at times, and yet they took on new life and meaning when created and deployed in the unique circumstances of the Armenian world.

And they carry the searing mark of unique lives. Take the Adoians. When they posed before Avedaghayan’s lens, Shushan and Vostanig were taking part in the same process as hundreds of others before them. Yet they did so in order to speak of their own lives, to declare their uniqueness. The particularity of the photograph lies not in pose or composition but in those lives. It is an object that not only records life but plays a role and has a force within it. Armenians visiting studios tended to understand this about photographs, their power, their promise, their possibility. 

Aram Jibilian’s limited edition poster project for Fixed Point Perspective, which includes the following images, “Ottoman Armenian Figure in an Empty Landscape”(2017), backdrop painting by Simon Agopyan, 1910, and “Dust in the Bellows” (2017), backdrop photograph by unknown Ottoman Armenian photographer, 1912. (image courtesy the artist)

Today, photographs can possess these qualities still — but only if we allow them. The artists involved in Vartanian’s Fixed Point Perspective project work with Ottoman Armenian photographs. This does not position photographs as passive objects, raw source material (in the way the Adoian portrait is regularly perceived in relation to Gorky’s The Artist and His Mother series). Rather, these contemporary artists work with Ottoman Armenian photographic culture in acts of engagement and renewal, even what we might call collaboration with long-gone studio photographers and their subjects. This is what is frequently misunderstood about Gorky’s works — they were created in partnership and part of their power has its source in the original photograph, and the studio and culture from which it sprang. 

The project’s contemporary artists have produced their artworks in conversation, in solidarity, with their century-old partners. Photographs thus continue to bring people together, to bind the fractured world. One piece in particular has a powerful hold on my mind, Aram Jibilian’s print work “Ottoman Armenian Figure in an Empty Landscape,” in which the studio portrait of an Armenian man becomes his ghostly apparition in the Armenian homelands. It speaks of the disappearance of a people and their culture, their absence from the land and from history, and the way in which that absence can haunt us through photographs. But it also speaks of a return from nothingness — a reappearance. It is the sort of return that can occur only when we open our eyes and both converse and commune with the past.

Tech-oriented Armenia could be lucrative market for Israel

Times of Israel
March 30 2023

YEREVAN, Armenia —After 30 years of bilateral diplomatic relations, Azerbaijan—a predominantly Muslim nation that uses its vast oil wealth to buy Israeli drones and other weaponry—on Wednesday formally established its embassy in Tel Aviv.

Israeli Foreign Minister Eli Cohen and his counterpart from Baku, Jeyhun Bayramov, led the opening ceremony, with Bayramov highlighting their strong relationship built on “dialogue and mutual understanding.”

Yet with far less fanfare, the Jewish state is also quietly restoring its political and economic ties with Azerbaijan’s arch-enemy, Armenia.

Rising interest in this ancient landlocked nation coincides with Armenia’s booming economy, fueled by an influx of software engineers from nearby Russia who are eager to escape deteriorating conditions at home ever since their country invaded Ukraine more than a year ago.

At least 150,000 Russian professionals, and maybe more, have fled here—often with their families in tow—since the war broke out on Feb. 24, 2022. But Russia’s loss is Armenia’s gain. This mountainous, landlocked Caucasus republic of 3 million—an imperfect but lively democracy with an ancient alphabet and a fledgling tech sector—has benefitted handsomely from Russia’s brain drain.

For one thing, the new arrivals have helped push Armenia’s GDP growth to 13% last year, even as it remains mired in a simmering conflict of its own with neighboring Azerbaijan; the last major war between the two ex-Soviet republics erupted in 2020 and killed an estimated 6,000 people on both sides. Meanwhile, Armenian exports to Russia tripled to $2 billion in 2022 compared to a year earlier, and remittances in the other direction quadrupled to $3.2 billion.

“This influx of Russians is a mini-version of what happened in Israel after the Soviet collapse,” said Ashot Arzumanyan, a partner and co-founder at SmartGate VC, a venture capital fund that invests in startups involved in everything from AI and robotics to biotech manufacturing.

“So many scientists and engineers left the USSR and settled in Israel. That set off a very strong wave of talent and initiative,” said Arzumanyan, whose fund is currently seeking $15-30 million from high-net worth individuals, including many in southern California’s large and influential Armenian diaspora. “Something similar is happening in Armenia—lots of really talented people moving here and becoming part of Armenia’s tech scene.”

 

Why Karabakh model only way to resolve Kashmir? [Pakistani Opinion]

Pakistan Today
April 1 2023
Why Karabakh model only way to resolve Kashmir?

By Hilal Ahmad

Experts at the Summit-level meeting of the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) Contact Group in Baku, Azerbaijan discussed whether Karabakh model was the only way to liberate Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir from foreign occupation.

Azerbaijan is a symbol of resilience against foreign aggression and it has succeeded in liberating the Karabakh region under the valiant leadership of President Ilham Aliyev. During the second Nagorno-Karabakh war in 2020, Azerbaijan succeeded in liberating its territories. The war lasted over a month and resulted in Azerbaijan’s victory against the Armenia.

Under the visionary leadership of incumbent President Ilham Aliyev Azerbaijan has achieved tremendous success at the national and international levels. The Republic of Azerbaijan became member of the NAM on May 26, 2011 with the unanimous support of the member states. NAM was established in 1961 and is the largest group of states outside the United Nations.

NAM Summit in Baku on March 02, 2023 provided an important platform for member states to come together and discuss the world’s challenges in the post-pandemic era. During the Summit, President Iham Aliyev highlighted NAM’s contributions to the pandemic response, specifically focusing on developing a database for the pandemic needs of NAM member states.

The meeting was attended by almost 70 heads of states and government representatives including important international organizations. The event was widely covered by local and international media. Journalists belonging to different countries and regions of the world physically covered the Baku moot. After the conclusion of NAM summit, a group of foreign journalists visited the liberated areas of Karabakh.

Pakistan and Azerbaijan have maintained close relations after forming diplomatic relations. Both the countries have closely worked in the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) and the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, Azerbaijan declared its independence and Pakistan was the second country to recognize its liberation.

Moreover, Pakistan had always supported Azerbaijan on the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict with Armenia at all international forums. Pakistan is the only country in the world which does not recognize Armenia. In April 1993, a meeting of the United Nations Security Council led by Pakistan was held which unanimously adopted a resolution concerning the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict.

At the same time, Azerbaijan supports Pakistan’s stance on Kashmir dispute. Azerbaijan had always urged on the peaceful resolution of the Jammu and Kashmir issue in accordance with the UN Security Council resolutions. As per stance of the Azerbaijan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs, guided by its commitments undertaken upon joining the UN, Azerbaijan always supports and stands for implementation of norms and principles of international law and UN Security Council resolutions in settlement of conflicts and maintenance of international peace and security.

This is the firm and principled position of Azerbaijan. Keeping in view this stance, Azerbaijan supports the peaceful resolution of the Jammu and Kashmir issue in accordance with the resolutions of the UN Security Council. It is worth to mention that Azerbaijan is also the member of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) Contact Group on Jammu and Kashmir.

On the invitation of Azeri government, a group of Journalists from across the globe including Pakistan attended the NAM summit in Baku and other places in the first week of March. The media representatives of many countries visited Azerbaijan for the coverage of Summit-level meeting of the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) in Baku and Karabakh region from 02 March to 05 March 2023.

Azerbaijan is presently carrying out the reconstruction process on large scale in the war-torn areas of Nagorno-Karabakh region. The foreign media persons visited different areas which were liberated by Azerbaijan in 2020 from the occupation of Armenia. The Azeri government is also engaged in rehabilitation process in Aghdam, Fazuli Shusha and other liberated areas.

During their visit to Aghdam, journalists also witnessed the ongoing development process in the liberated areas and inspected the civic facilities, religious, cultural and historical monuments destroyed during the occupation, including the Imaret complex, the Alley of Martyrs and the Drama Theater. The delegation of journalists later left for Ganja, the second largest city of Azerbaijan and stayed there for night.

Foreign journalists, who arrived in Azerbaijan to cover the summit of the Non-Aligned Movement’s Contact Group in response to COVID-19, on March 04, visited the places hit by missiles fired by Armenians in Ganja city. Media delegation visited Victory Park in Ganja.

They were briefed by the local authorities that the Armenian Armed Forces deliberately fired on the Azerbaijani civilians and settlements by using heavy artillery. As a result, 26 people were killed in Ganja, including children, women and the elderly people while as 175 people were injured besides many civilian infrastructure and vehicles were damaged. Later the journalists departed to Fuzuli city.

The author is a journalist from Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu & Kashmir but now based in Islamabad. He could be reached at 

‘Intolerable’: Anti-Armenian fliers posted near Glendale church

April 1 2023

Leaflets depicting anti-Armenian sentiment were found near an Armenian church in Glendale on Friday morning. The city’s mayor, Ardy Kassakhian, called the postings “ruthless and intolerable”.

The leaflets, found taped to light poles near St. Mary’s Armenian Apostolic Church, contained messages denying the Armenian Genocide but claiming that Israel “fully supports” its completion. They pointed to Azerbaijan’s ongoing blockade of the Nagorno-Karabakh region, which has turned into a humanitarian crisis.

The region is mainly populated by ethnic Armenians but is within Azerbaijan; Critics say the blockade has cut off the nation’s access to food and medicine.

Anti-Armenian leaflets were found near St Mary’s Armenian Apostolic Church in Glendale.

(Glendale Public Relations Office)

“[We] You will continue to witness the efforts of hate groups that continue to promote the horrific genocide here in the city of Glendale, home to one of the largest Armenian communities in the United States,” Kassakhian said in a statement.

Kassakhian claimed that those responsible for putting up the signs were “undoubtedly emboldened” by Turkey’s continued denial of the Armenian Genocide and by the blockade in Azerbaijan.

California Assemblywoman Laura Friedman (D-Burbank) called the posters “disgusting.”

“Let’s be clear that we will not allow these hateful racists to sow discord between the Jewish and Armenian communities,” Friedman said on Twitter.

The Armenian Genocide resulted in the deaths of an estimated 700,000 to 1.2 million Armenians living in the Ottoman Empire in 1915.

It was not recognized by the United States until 2021 under President Biden.

The Glendale Police Department is investigating the incident as a possible hate crime against the Armenian church and community, the agency said in a statement.

The incident came several months after anti-Armenian leaflets were found taped to poles in Beverly Hills, KTLA reported.

Anti-Armenian Hate Flyers Discovered in Glendale; Investigation Underway

April 1 2023

Officials in Glendale have condemned anti-Armenian Flyers found posted on light poles near St. Mary’s Armenian Apostolic Church and in other areas of the city.

Glendale Mayor Ardy Kassakhian and other officials held a news conference Friday at Glendale City Hall to discuss the discovery of the flyers, which contained language denying the Armenian Genocide and minimizing the suffering of the Armenian people.

“As mayor of Glendale, I’m very disturbed and upset that speech inciting violence against Armenians has visited our city by way of individuals vandalizing our city with hate-filled flyers,” Kassakhian said in a statement. “Our police are taking this issue seriously and will be investigating this as a hate crime. I speak for our residents and our council when I say that Glendale is not a place for hate speech against Armenians or any other group.”

The Armenian National Committee of America Glendale Chapter also denounced the flyers.

“We are extremely concerned by the dissemination of these appalling anti-Armenian flyers in Glendale calling for the continuation of the Armenian Genocide,” ANCA Glendale Chapter Chair Lucy Petrosian said in a statement.

“We are currently working with the Glendale Police Department to ensure this act of hate is investigated, and the perpetrators are brought to justice. This is yet another tragic reminder of how the incitement and institutionalization of anti-Armenian hate by the Azerbaijani government has threatened Armenian lives not only in Artsakh and Armenia, but across the diaspora,” Petrosian said.

“As we approach the 108th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, these hate flyers are a stark reminder that we must remain vigilant against the forces of discrimination, hatred and genocide denial,” Petrosian said. “Promoting the continuation of such atrocities is not only morally repugnant — it also constitutes a direct threat to our community’s safety and well-being.”

The flyers, which were distributed in the heart of the Armenian-American community of Glendale, promoted the “completion of the Armenian Genocide,” according to ANCA.

The incident comes months after similar flyers calling on Turkey and Azerbaijan to “wipe Armenia off the map” were distributed in Beverly Hills prior to a demonstration by the Armenian Youth Federation in protest of Azerbaijan’s blockade of Artsakh, which has deprived the region’s 120,000 Armenians of access to food, fuel, medicine and other vital supplies for more than 100 days, ANCA said.

“The Glendale Police Department and I stand with the entire Glendale community against all incidents of hate,” Glendale police Chief Manuel Cid said in a statement. “We will use all the resources available to us to fully investigate any criminal acts associated with this incident while we work in collaboration with our community leaders moving forward.”

FOX: Anti-Armenian flyers promoting ‘completion of genocide’ appear in Glendale

April 1 2023
Anti-Armenian flyers, promoting the completion of the Armenian Genocide, were spotted in Glendale Friday. 

The flyers were posted on light poles near St. Mary’s Armenian Apostolic Church and other areas of the city. Glendale police say a passerby saw the disturbing flyers and called police to report it. 

“As mayor of Glendale, I’m very disturbed and upset that speech inciting violence against Armenians has visited our city by way of individuals vandalizing our city with hate-filled flyers,” Mayor Ardy Kassakhian said in a statement. “Our police are taking this issue seriously and will be investigating this as a hate crime. I speak for our residents and our council when I say that Glendale is not a place for hate speech against Armenians or any other group.”

The flyer read “NEVER AGAIN does not apply to GOYIM (Armenia) Israel FULLY SUPPORTS our Azeri-Turk Brothers to complete Armenian Genocide.” 

Police are canvassing the area and looking at surveillance video to see who is responsible. 

“So far we do have a surveillance footage of a subject, unfortunately unidentifiable, but he is dressed in all black, carrying a satchel with what appears to be more flyers in his satchel,” said police captain Robert William. Police said they found at least 11 flyers posted throughout the city Friday morning. 

Similar anti-Armenian flyers were posted in Beverly Hills in January. 

The Armenian National Committee Glendale Chapter condemned the hate incident and said the incident in Glendale and Beverly Hills showcases a troubling trend of anti-Armenian sentiment and rise in hate crimes. 

“As an organization dedicated to the well-being and advancement of the Armenian-American community, we are deeply disturbed by these hateful acts, and we call on local authorities to thoroughly investigate these incidents and hold the perpetrators accountable,” the ANCA wrote in a post online. 

On April 24, 1915, 1.5 million Armenians were massacred at the hands of the Ottoman Empire (modern day Turkey). To this day Turkey and their ally, Azerbaijan, deny the genocide. 

In September of 2020, Azerbaijan launched a full scale war on the Republic of Artsakh (also known as Nagorno-Karabakh). Artsakh is occupied by indigenous Armenians and has been under a blockade by Azerbaijan for over 100 days. The Lachin Corridor has been closed by Azerbaijan since December 12, limiting Artsakh’s access to food and medical care. During the blockade, Azerbaijan cut off power to Artsakh, leaving residents without heat in the freezing cold winter. It is the only road connecting Artsakh to Armenia and the rest of the world. 

RELATED: 

  • US political leaders call for end on Azerbaijani blockade as situation in Artsakh intensifies
  • World remains silent as Native Armenians face another humanitarian crisis

Since the war began in 2020, Azerbaijan, with support from Turkey, have been accused of ethnic cleansing. 

In 2021, President Joe Biden became the first US president to formally recognize the genocide.  

The flyers were posted just a day before the start of Armenian History Month. Glendale and Los Angeles have the largest population of Armenians outside of the country itself. 

https://www.foxla.com/news/anti-armenian-flyers-glendale.amp 

WATCH the video report at

https://news.yahoo.com/anti-armenian-flyers-promoting-completion-010914462.html

https://news.yahoo.com/glendale-pd-investigating-anti-armenian-050938494.html

ABC: Police investigating anti-Armenian flyers found in Glendale

April 1 2023
ByJosh Haskell

The discovery of anti-Armenian flyers posted outside St. Mary’s Armenian Apostolic Church in Glendale prompted a condemnation by city officials Friday.

GLENDALE, Calif. (KABC) — The discovery of anti-Armenian flyers posted outside St. Mary’s Armenian Apostolic Church in Glendale prompted a condemnation by city officials Friday.

“Unfortunately, anti-Armenian hate and racism is alive and well, and my community continues to be targeted, harassed and traumatized by these acts that have been taking place across the country,” Glendale city clerk Suzie Abajian said.

Eleven flyers were found, with one that called for Azerbaijan and Turkey to “complete Armenian Genocide.”

The flyer claims to be from supporters of Israel, includes Hebrew, and is signed from a rabbi. The Glendale Police Department, however, said it has no reason to believe the Jewish community has any connection to the flyers.

“The Glendale Police Department and I stand with the entire Glendale community against all incidents of hate,” Glendale police Chief Manuel Cid said in a statement. “We will use all the resources available to us to fully investigate any criminal acts associated with this incident while we work in collaboration with our community leaders moving forward.”

Glendale police Capt. Robert William said during a Friday afternoon news conference that a similar incident happened in Beverly Hills.

Glendale is home to the largest Armenian American population in the U.S. The Armenian community says they’re angry and scared.

“The threat of genocide is not protected speech, but a threat of violence that should be addressed appropriately,” Abajian said. “I do not feel safe walking on the streets of our city with the knowledge that some people would like to see Armenians erased from the face of the planet.”

Glendale police say surveillance video they reviewed showed a person holding a satchel filled with the flyers, and they believe there could be more around the city.

City News Service contributed to this report.


https://abc7.com/glendale-anti-armenian-flyers-police-investigation-racism/13062080/

Watch the video report at