RFE/RL Armenian Report – 04/03/2023

                                        Monday, April 3, 2023
Azeri Troops Hold On To ‘Newly Occupied Armenian Territory’
        • Susan Badalian
Armenia - Azerbaijani troops dig trenches outside Tegh village.
Azerbaijani troops have not withdrawn from community lands of an Armenian border 
village occupied by them last week, local residents insisted on Monday, denying 
the Armenian government’s implicit claims to the contrary.
Azerbaijani army units redeployed by Thursday morning to more parts of the 
Lachin district sandwiched between Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh, completing a 
change in the route of the Lachin corridor which began last August. Armenia’s 
National Security Service (NSS) said hours later that they advanced up to 300 
meters into Armenian territory at five local sections of the 
Armenian-Azerbaijani border adjacent to the village of Tegh.
Local government officials and farmers said Tegh lost a large part of its 
agricultural land and pastures. Some of them said that the Azerbaijani military 
made bigger territorial gains than is admitted by official Yerevan.
The Azerbaijani advance also caused an uproar in Yerevan, with Armenian 
opposition leaders blaming Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian for the loss of yet 
another part of Armenia’s internationally recognized territory.
In another statement released on Saturday, the NSS claimed that the situation in 
that border area “improved significantly” as a result of negotiations held by 
Armenian and Azerbaijani officials. It did not elaborate.
Tegh residents said afterwards, however, that the Azerbaijani troops remain 
stationed in the newly occupied positions just outside the village.
“They keep digging in … and haven’t retreated a single inch,” said Masis 
Zeynalian, a member of the local council who no longer access to his wheat field.
“They’re staying put and continuing fortification works,” said another Tegh 
councilor, Argam Hovsepian. “Is this what they [the NSS] call an improvement?”
Armenia’s Deputy Defense Minister Arman Sargsian refused to comment on that 
“improvement” when he was approached by journalists on Monday.
“The Defense Ministry has a press service that periodically and promptly reacts 
to any issue,” Sargsian said vaguely.
The ministry has made no statements on the situation around Tegh so far. 
Speaking right after the Azerbaijani advance on Thursday, Pashinian said that 
from now on the area will be patrolled and protected by border guards 
subordinate to the NSS, rather than the Armenian army.
Opposition leaders also blamed Pashinian’s government for much bigger 
territorial losses suffered by Armenia during border clashes with Azerbaijan in 
May 2021 and September 2022. They regularly charge that it cannot defend the 
country and rebuild its armed forces after mishandling the disastrous 2020 war 
in Karabakh. Pashinian and his political allies deny this.
Opposition Lawmaker Freed For Now
        • Gayane Saribekian
Armenia - Opposition deputy Mher Sahakian (left) is released from custody, Aprl 
3, 2023.
An opposition member of Armenia’s parliament was released from custody on Monday 
three days after punching a pro-government colleague during an ill-tempered 
meeting of a National Assembly committee.
It remained unclear whether prosecutors will move to indict Mher Sahakian of the 
main opposition Hayastan alliance.
The violence reportedly followed a shouting match between Vladimir Vartanian, 
the chairman of the parliament committee on legal affairs, and Sahakian and 
other opposition lawmakers. Vartanian, who represents the ruling Civil Contract 
party, suffered an injury to his left eyebrow and was taken to hospital before 
police detained Sahakian.
Sahakian received a hero’s welcome from other Hayastan deputies and activists as 
he walked out of a police detention center in Yerevan. Echoing their statements 
made on Friday, he claimed that he hit Vartanian because the latter stood up and 
walked menacingly towards him.
“I resorted to necessary self-defense,” Sahakian told journalists.
Vartanian insisted, however, that he did not charge at Sahakian. He again blamed 
opposition members of the panel for bitter exchanges that marred the meeting 
held behind the closed doors.
Under Armenian law, law-enforcement authorities cannot hold a parliament deputy 
in detention without a charge and without the National Assembly’s permission for 
more than three days. The Office of the Prosecutor-General did not say whether 
it will ask the parliament controlled by Civil Contract to lift Sahakian’s 
immunity from prosecution.
“If the investigating body reckons that I crossed that line [of self-defense] 
I’m ready to answer,” Sahakian said in this regard.
The ruling party’s parliamentary group has strongly condemned the 35-year-old 
oppositionist’s actions, saying that he must be held accountable. Some of its 
members themselves assaulted opposition colleagues on the parliament floor in 
2021. They were not prosecuted for that.
Armenian Parliament Speaker Accused Of Spitting At Heckler
        • Artak Khulian
Armenia - Parliament speaker Alen SImonian chairs a session of the National 
Assembly, November 24, 2022.
Parliament speaker Alen Simonian has caused another scandal after allegedly 
spitting on Sunday at an opposition activist who branded him a “traitor.”
Garen Megerdichian, a member of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation 
(Dashnaktsutyun) party, shouted the insult at Simonian as the latter visited a 
popular pedestrian area in downtown Yerevan.
Megerdichian claimed that Simonian responded by ordering his bodyguards to grab 
his hands before swearing at him and spitting in his face. He said he was then 
briefly detained by police.
Simonian did not deny spitting at the Canadian-born activist highly critical of 
Armenia’s government when he commented on the incident later on Sunday. In a 
Facebook post, he said that Megerdichian already publicly insulted him earlier 
this year.
“I ignored him during the first incident a month ago. During the second one, I 
countered his right to free speech and insults with my opinion about him and my 
freedom,” he wrote, adding that anyone offending the Armenian authorities will 
get a “legal response.”
Speaking to 1in.am on Monday, Simonian claimed that his bodyguards caught the 
heckler “so that he doesn’t attack me.” He refused to speak to other media 
outlets.
Opposition lawmakers condemned the speaker and demanded criminal proceedings 
against him, saying that his alleged behavior amounted to “hooliganism,” a 
criminal offense in Armenia.
Ishkhan Saghatelian, a Dashnaktsutyun leader, shrugged off Simonian’s remark 
that he is a “Yerevan guy” from whom oppositionists “will always run away.”
“As far as I know, good fellows of Yerevan and real men in general don’t behave 
like that,” he told journalists.
Saghatelian also defended Megerdichian. “This is a fight between patriots and 
people who say we can live without a homeland,” he said.
Two other opposition lawmakers visited Megerdichian in police custody and warned 
law-enforcement authorities against prosecuting him.
As of Monday evening the authorities did not say whether they will launch a 
formal investigation into the incident.
Simonian, who is a senior member of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian’s Civil 
Contract party, is no stranger to controversy. In 2020 he brawled with an 
outspoken anti-government activist who insulted him on a street in Yerevan.
In late 2021, Simonian angered the families of Armenian soldiers taken prisoner 
during the 2020 war with Azerbaijan. He was caught on camera labeling many of 
those POWs as deserters who “laid down their weapons and ran away” during 
fighting with Azerbaijani forces.
A few weeks later, he reportedly told journalists that they must stand up every 
time they see him in the parliament building. Simonian imposed unprecedented 
restrictions on press coverage of the National Assembly immediately after 
becoming its speaker in August 2021.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

Fwd: The California Courier Online, April 6, 2023

The California
Courier Online, April 6, 2023

 

1-         Ottoman
Parliament and Senate in 1918

            Acknowledged
‘the Armenian Massacres’

            By Harut
Sassounian

            Publisher,
The California
Courier

           
www.TheCaliforniaCourier.com

2-         At Mount
Davidson, 90-year-old time capsule unearthed

3-         In San Diego, George
Kirazian’s ‘Book of Ruth’ Ballet to Premiere in April

4-         Sassounian,
Markarian, Armenian to Discuss

            ‘Collective
Unity: Armenia-Artsakh-Diaspora’

************************************************************************************************************************************************

 

1-         Ottoman
Parliament and Senate in 1918

            Acknowledged
‘the Armenian Massacres’

            By Harut
Sassounian

            Publisher,
The California
Courier

            www.TheCaliforniaCourier.com

 

I wrote an article in January 2016, titled: “Turkey
was first country to recognize the Armenian Genocide in 1918.” However, most
people are still unaware that ‘the Armenian Massacres’ were discussed and
acknowledged by the Ottoman Parliament and Senate in 1918.

More recently, two Armenian members of the Turkish
Parliament, Selina Dogan and Garo Paylan, raised the issue of the Armenian
Genocide in the Parliament on January 14, 2016. Earlier, in November 2014,
Parliament member Sebahat Tuncel submitted a resolution on the Armenian
Genocide to the Turkish Parliament, asking Erdogan to issue an apology, declare
April 24 as an official Day of Mourning, make public the documents in the
Turkish archives about this mass crime, and pay material and moral restitution
to the descendants of the victims. The proposed resolution was ignored by the
Turkish Parliament.

Since writing my 2016 article, I came across a detailed
analysis written by Prof. Ayhan Aktar in the History Workshop Journal, titled:
“Debating the Armenian Massacres in the Last Ottoman Parliament, November –
December 1918.” That debate took place following the defeat of the Ottoman
Empire in WWI and occupation of Constantinople (Istanbul) by the victorious allied countries.

In the last two months of 1918, the Ottoman Parliament
discussed over several days the Armenian Genocide, described at the time as
massacres. A motion was presented which stated: “A population of 1 million
people guilty of nothing except belonging to the Armenian nation were massacred
and exterminated, including even women and children.” In response, Interior
Minister Ali Fethi Okyar declared: “It is the intention of the government to
cure every single injustice done up until now, as far as the means allow, to
make possible the return to their homes of those sent into exile, and to
compensate for their material loss as far as possible…. Yes, Gentlemen, I
also say that our officials butchered many Armenians, including women and
children and that their properties were plundered.”

A Parliamentary Investigative Committee was set up to
collect all relevant documents showing the actions of those responsible for the
‘Armenian deportations and massacres.’ The evidence was turned over to the
Turkish Military Tribunal, and those found guilty were hanged or given lengthy
prison sentences.

Here are some excerpts from Aktar’s article: “Discussion of
the Armenian massacres in the Ottoman Parliament began with motions calling the
Union and Progress governments to account. When
on November 4, 1918 the Ottoman Parliament convened in Istanbul the political attempts to find the
perpetrators started with the first motion, tabled by Baghdat-Divaniye Deputy
Fuat Bey a few days earlier. This demanded that members of the Sait Halim Pasha
and Talaat Pasha cabinets be tried by the High Court…. Clause 10 [of the
motion] made direct reference to the Armenian deportations and to the
Teshkilat-i Mahsusa (the Special Organization), an irregular military force
organized by the CUP [Committee of Union and Progress] leadership that had
carried out deportations and massacres.”

Some of the parliamentarians who belonged to the old guard
of Unionists, which were the majority in the parliament, without denying the
Armenian massacres, made excuses similar to today’s Turkish Government, stating
that Turks were also killed during this period.

Six Armenian deputies of the parliament submitted a motion
demanding that “the deportation decision of May 27, 1915 and the decree of
September 27, 1915 concerning expropriation of abandoned properties and real
estate should be revoked, and that those deported from their native land be
permitted to return. It further asserted that the administrative measures
facilitating the sharing out among local notables of properties which had
belonged to deported Armenians went absolutely against the spirit of the
Ottoman Constitution of 1876.”

In response to accusations that some Armenians on the
Eastern front had rebelled against the Ottoman Empire,
Armenian Deputy Matyos Nalbandian responded: Even if some Armenians had
committed illegal acts, it does that justify “the removal and extermination of
all Armenians” and “the confiscation and plunder of their properties.”
Nalbandian also made a distinction between the Turks killed at the warfront and
the innocent Armenian civilians who were massacred.

A similar discussion took place in the Ottoman Senate on
Nov. 21, 1918. Ahmet Riza Bey made a motion demanding that “‘the atrocities
committed under the name of deportation’ be investigated; that the negative
impact throughout the country be determined; and that those involved in these
affairs be prosecuted.”

Former Governor and Minister of Interior, Reshit Akif Pasha,
stated that his investigation indicated that “these orders of deportation had
been given by the well-known Minister of Interior [Talaat Pasha] and officially
communicated to [governors in] the provinces.”

On December 9, 1918, Minister of Justice Haydar Molla told
the Ottoman Senate that the crimes against Armenians were committed by state
officials, politicians and ordinary Turks.

Importantly, none of the deputies, regardless of their party
affiliation or background, denied the occurrence of the deportation and
massacres of Armenians.

On December 21, 1918, the Ottoman Parliament was dissolved
by Mehmed Vahdettin, the last Sultan of the Ottoman Empire.
“When the Parliament finally reconvened with the newly-elected deputies on
January 12, 1920, it was dominated by supporters of the resistance movement
which had developed in Anatolia, under the leadership of Mustafa Kemal Pasha
(later Ataturk),” wrote Aktar.

The Turkish Military Tribunals in 1919–20 tried and
sentenced to death in absentia the masterminds of the Armenian massacres,
Enver, Djemal and Talaat, the Young Turk leaders who had fled the country.

 

************************************************************************************************************************************************
2-         At Mount Davidson, 90-year-old
time capsule unearthed

By Megan Rose Dickey

 

(Axios News)—San Francisco’s
community leaders dug up a 90-year-old time capsule buried near the base of Mount Davidson’s
towering cross on Saturday, April 1.

 The Council of
Armenian Americans of Northern California unearthed a time capsule that a Boy
Scout troop buried at the cross in on April 1, 1933 to commemorate the site’s
inaugural Easter sunrise service.

The time capsule held old editions of the Bible, gospel
tracts, water from the Jordan River, city and
telephone directories from 1933, and issues of the leading newspapers of the
time, including the San Francisco News and the San Francisco Chronicle.

The cross atop Mount
Davidson has a long, complicated
history in San Francisco
involving legal battles and ballot measures.

Despite threats to its existence, the cross has served as a
community-gathering place since the Great Depression, including for Easter
services and to commemorate the 1915 Armenian genocide.

Between 1923 and 1934, the cross evolved from a 40-foot
wooden structure to the 103-foot-high concrete structure with reinforced steel
you see today.

The first cross was built for the 1923 ceremony, which
attracted about 5,000 attendees, Friends of Mount Davidson Conservancy
co-founder Jacqueline Proctor told Axios.

In 1934, President Franklin D. Roosevelt pressed a button in
D.C. that lit the permanent cross atop Mount Davidson
for the first time. More than 50,000 people attended that event.

Proctor noted that the concrete version of the cross was
built in the middle of the Great Depression, when “people were feeling pretty
hopeless. But they came together to be together and to find hope.”

In 1992, the American Civil Liberties Union, along with
other plaintiffs, sued the city, arguing it was illegal to have a religious
symbol on public property. The city lost the suit and was required to either
remove or sell the cross.

In 1997, the Council of Armenian Americans of Northern
California became the legal owner of the cross, following a voter-approved
measure allowing the sale.

San Francisco
became a refuge for Armenians who were able to escape the genocide nearly a
century ago, Roxanne Makasdjian, the executive director of The Genocide
Education Project, told Axios.

Armenians in San
Francisco wanted to become custodians of the cross as
a thank you to the city for providing the Armenian community with a haven,
Makasdjian explained.

The time capsule from 1923 was replaced with a new time
capsule, featuring an iPhone, an Armenian Bible, an Armenian khachkar
(cross-stone), a face mask, issues of the San Francisco Chronicle, The
California Courier, and other items that reflect current events and
information.

The San Francisco Historical Society and the members of the
Mt. Davidson Cross Armenian Council placed the new time capsule in the hopes
that it, too, will be unearthed in a centennial ceremony.

 

************************************************************************************************************************************************
3-         In San Diego, George Kirazian’s
‘Book of Ruth’ Ballet to Premiere in April

 

SAN DIEGO—Armenian Composer
George Kirazian’s new ballet based on the Book of Ruth will be produced by
Mojalet Dance Collective and premiering in San Diego on April 29 to 30, 2023. The
performances will be combined with three other original dance pieces,
Aftermath, Tainted, and a New Solo. A reception will be held in between each
day’s performances, as well as a brief Q&A after each show.

The Book of Ruth: A Ballet, will be choreographed by Faith
Jensen-Ismay, Mojalet’s Founder and Artistic Director. Based on the Old
Testament story of the Hebrew woman Ruth and her family, the new work will
combine traditional and modern dance components, choreographed by Jensen-Ismay
to Kirazian’s music, recorded by The Parnassus Ensemble of San Diego.

Mojalet Dance Collective has been entertaining and inspiring
San Diego
audiences for more than 30 years with traditional, modern and contemporary
dance productions, including many world premieres, as they are dedicated to
developing new and groundbreaking work. They are also developing The Book of
Ruth: A Ballet, for a larger-scale production in Fall 2023.

The Book of Ruth in the Old Testament might well be the
world’s first short story. When the elder Jewish woman Naomi loses her husband
and both her sons, she implores both her widowed daughters-in-law to go back to
their native land
of Moab. One of them,
Orpah, leaves. The other, Ruth, insists on staying with her mother-in-law
Naomi, to embrace her people and her God. They go to Judah, where after a period of
poverty, they meet a generous landowner named Boaz, who changes their lives.
The story teaches its audience that love and devotion can heal after great
losses and enable us to rise above our harmful prejudices against others.
Although Ruth’s story has often been retold and depicted in films, it has never
been set to music as a ballet. 

A longtime member of the Armenian community who helped
establish the first Armenian Church in San Diego, composer George Kirazian is a
retired college instructor of Humanities, Composition, and Opera Appreciation.
Born and raised in New Jersey, he completed
his undergraduate and graduate studies at New York
University and taught English
Literature and Composition at Grossmont
College for nearly 40
years, and served as Chairman of the English Department. He also taught Opera
and Music Appreciation at San
Diego State University. He is a longtime resident of
San Diego with
his wife Dikranouhi. They have three daughters: Yvette (husband John
Harpootian), Andrea (husband Steven Urrutia) and Lisa (husband Steve Kradjian),
and six grandchildren: Mark, Eric, Zari, Dante, Ani and Mari.

Kirazian’s musical compositions include The Book of Ruth: A
Ballet, various art songs, hymns, and a new version of The Divine Liturgy of
the Armenian Apostolic Church,
which has been performed and recorded by Pacific Camerata of San Diego, the
Paros Chamber Choir of Armenia, and also performed by members of the Armenian
Church of San Diego. He has also published fiction and non-fiction: Easy
Writing: A Practical Guide for Practically Everybody; A Time for Fathers (short
novel), and five young reader books: The Sleeping Violet, Perry the Peacock,
Beyond the Koala Kingdom, Leo and the Mulberry Flute, and The Princess of
December.

For more information, visit georgekirazian.com

**********************************************************************************************************************************************
4-         Sassounian, Markarian, Armenian
to Discuss

            ‘Collective
Unity: Armenia-Artsakh-Diaspora’

 

On Tuesday April 11, the Educational Committee of the
Crescenta Valley Meher & Satig Der Ohanessian Youth Center (2633 Honolulu
Ave., Montrose, CA. 91020
) will organize a panel discussion: “Collective Unity:
Armenia-Artsakh-Diaspora”, presented by Dr. Haroutune Armenian, Harut
Sassounian and Robert Markarian. This will be followed by a question and answer
session from audience members. The presentation will begin at 7:30 p.m.

The event will cover current issues and challenges
confronting the Armenian nation in Armenia, Artsakh and Diaspora.
Brief presentations by the panelists will offer historical overviews of the
current situation, existing problems and future visionary outlook. The
presentation will consider using analytic methods from public health sciences
to present diagnostic and process approaches that may be useful in developing a
collective vigor in the Armenian reality.

Dr. Haroutune K. Armenian was trained at the Johns Hopkins
Bloomberg School of Public Health where he received his MPH & DrPH degrees,
and also at the American University of Beirut
for his MD specializing in internal medicine. Dr. Armenian’s extensive academic
and development leadership includes systems and services development at the
Ministry of Health in Bahrain,
Dean of the Faculty of Health Sciences at the American
University of Beirut,
Dean of the College of Health Sciences at the American
University of Armenia and President of the American University
of Armenia (AUA) for 14 years.

Armenian was Editor-in-Chief of Epidemiologic Reviews for 14
years and has served on the editorial board of a number of professional
journals and publications. He has published over 100 scientific papers and many
peer reviewed chapters, as well as edited or published 20 books. He has
published 3 collections of his watercolors and prose-poetry in Armenian and
English. Currently he leads the Turpanjian Rural Development Program as well as
the Entrepreneurship in Medicine projects of AUA in Armenia.

Harut Sassounian is the Publisher of The California Courier,
founded in 1958. His weekly editorials, translated into several languages, are
reprinted in scores of U.S.
and overseas publications and posted on countless websites. He is the author of
“The Armenian Genocide: The World Speaks Out, 1915-2015, Documents and Declarations.”

As President of the Armenia Artsakh Fund, he has
administered the procurement and delivery of $970 million of humanitarian
assistance to Armenia
and Artsakh during the past 34 years. As Senior Vice President of Kirk
Kerkorian’s Lincy Foundation, he oversaw $240 million of infrastructure
projects in Armenia.

From 1978 to 1982, Sassounian worked as an international
marketing executive for Procter & Gamble in Geneva, Switzerland.
As a human rights delegate at the United Nations for 10 years, he played a
leading role in the recognition of the Armenian Genocide by the U.N.
Sub-Commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection of Minorities in
1985. Sassounian has a Master’s Degree in International Affairs from Columbia University,
and a Master’s in Business Administration from Pepperdine University.

Robert Markarian received his higher education in the fields
of physics and law. For about 25 years, before moving to the USA, he worked at the Armenian-language radio
station in Tehran
as a presenter, commentator and translator.

He cooperates with the Armenian mass media in political
analyses. His analytical articles on the topics of Armenia and Artsakh were published
on Armenian and Persian websites as well as in different newspapers.

 

***********************************************************************************************************************************************
************************************************************************************************************************************************

California Courier Online provides readers of the Armenian News News Service with a
few of the articles in this week’s issue of The California Courier. Letters to
the editor are encouraged through our e-mail address, .
Letters are published with the author’s name and location; authors are required
to disclose their identity to the editorial staff (name, address, and/or
telephone numbers for verification purposes).
California Courier subscribers can change or modify mailing addresses by
emailing .

Large-scale potato planting carried out in Artsakh’s Berdashen

Panorama
Armenia – March 31 2023

A large-scale potato planting has been carried out in the Berdashen community of the Martunu region in the Republic of Artsakh, the head of the community, Georgi Poghosyan, told Artsakhpress, adding that in Berdashen potatoes have been sown on such a scale for the first time.

“As a part of a charity program, 6 kilograms of seeds were provided to a family. In addition, the villagers also benefited from the appropriate state support and programs of the Hayastan All-Armenian Fund,” the head of the community said.

The arable lands of the community are mainly irrigated with artesian water, but problems arise during power outages. According to the official, only 12-13 percent of the community’s arable land is irrigated.

“If we increase the artesian wells, then we can get enough harvest, which we can even export,” Pogosyan said.

He noted with satisfaction that in 2022, a reservoir was built in accordance with modern standards, thanks to which an intensive garden of about 200 hectares is being established in the village.

“We have already planted and are growing pineapple, pomegranate, as well as persimmon tress,” the head of the Berdashen community said, noting that spring sowing continues. In addition, they have already planted vegetable crops, in particular, cucumber, watermelon and onion.

CSTO warns of risks of destabilization on Armenian-Azeri border, in Nagorno-Karabakh

Panorama
Armenia – March 31 2023

The chief of the Moscow-led Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) on Friday warned of high risks of destabilization on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border and in the Nagorno-Karabakh (Artsakh) conflict zone, TASS reported.

According to CSTO Secretary General Imangali Tasmagambetov, the situation in the South Caucasus “remains fraught with serious destabilization”.

“The risks related to the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh and on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border remain high,” he told an enlarged meeting of the security bloc’s Secretariat and Joint Staff.

Tensions between Armenia and Azerbaijan in the Caucasus region persist as a result of the many years of disputes, he stated.

Armenian expert reveals key messages of Erdogan’s latest statement

Panorama
Armenia – March 31 2023

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who is seeking a third consecutive term in office in presidential elections in May, unveiled his party’s policies in case of winning the upcoming elections. In particular, Erdogan said the authorities in Ankara “will not allow the country to be dragged into a war.”

Panorama.am has talked to Doctor of History, Professor Ruben Melkonyan, who heads the YSU Faculty of Oriental Studies, about Erdogan’s statement, Turkey’s presidential and parliamentary elections scheduled for May 14, as well as the candidates favored by the Turkish Armenian community.

Panorama.am: Turkey has been involved in all wars so far, from using mercenaries, providing officers and military equipment, to launching military offensives, and now, if re-elected, Erdogan says he will not allow Turkey to be dragged into a war. What does Erdogan have in mind when he makes such statements? Does he simply want to please the people, or are his challengers more radical and make calls for war at an election period?

Ruben Melkonyan: Erdogan’s statement can be viewed from at least three perspectives and, of course, in the light of historical background.

Turkey joined NATO in 1952 and took part in the Korean War, where 2,500 people were killed. This Korean War has left a negative impact on Turkish society in terms of undue involvement in the wars of others. The participation in this “senseless” war has a certain perception in Turkish society and political life. Erdogan’s statement is primarily addressed to his domestic audience, claiming that Turkey is on an equal footing with the West and will no longer participate in wars not directly related to it sought by the West and will not suffer casualties as a result of participation in other wars.

The next observation is that Turkey distinguishes between its “own wars” and “foreign wars.” Turkey’s own wars include attacks on Syria, Iraq or Cyprus, but those wars fought by NATO or its Western allies are considered foreign, and Turkey avoids direct involvement in them as much as possible.

I guess Erdogan’s statement also refers to the Russian-Ukrainian war and is a response to Western pressure on Turkey to step up its military support for Ukraine. And, of course, we can also consider this as a sign of reverence, a positive message to Russia. Erdogan’s statement is absolutely clear and acceptable to Turkish society.

Turkey, indeed, has always tried to fight through mercenaries or other means, but as far away from its borders as possible. Even when Turkey helped the U.S. in the war with Iraq or, even earlier, with Egypt and others, it tried to be as careful as possible. For example, it allowed the use of its airports, but avoided deploying Turkish troops to a place where the U.S. or NATO waged a war.

Given Iran’s active efforts in the recent period, Erdogan’s statement could also include a message to Iran, since Iran’s statements about Azerbaijan and, for example, a possible clash between Iran and Azerbaijan, imply Turkey’s direct involvement in it to support its ally Azerbaijan. Consequently, Erdogan’s position is that he will try to prevent an escalation of tensions between Iran and Azerbaijan and a possible war.

Nor can we overlook the special Turkish-Israeli relations and the tensions between Iran and Israel in this light.

In other words, Erdogan’s statement can be called multi-vector, addressed both to foreign and domestic audiences. At the same time, it is aimed at strengthening Turkey’s vital interests once again. In essence, the statement is addressed to the United States, the West, Russia, Iran and Turkey’s domestic audience. This is a highly saturated message.

Panorama.am: Is Erdogan more belligerent or more radical compared to other candidates?

Ruben Melkonian: This is an extremely important question. His main challenger, opposition candidate Kemal Kilicdaroglu is considered to be a more understandable and acceptable candidate for the West and the United States. Erdogan’s message to his domestic audience is that if Kilicdaroglu were to win the elections, Turkey could be involved into various wars by the order of the United States as he is “so weak and unable to resist the U.S.”

The message is as follows: if the opposition wins, Turkey will more easily comply with U.S. orders to join a war, but now Turkey, led by Erdogan, is resisting it and even after strong calls from his NATO partners will not step up its participation in various conflicts far from itself.

The other side of the coin is that his rhetoric is more bellicose than that of the other candidates when it comes to attacks on Artsakh, Iraq, Syria, but it should be realized that these are Turkish wars and fought for Turkey’s interests.

In other words, Erdogan’s rhetoric is bellicose in those wars that are considered “their own, Turkish,” and more restrained in those wars that are considered “foreign”, i.e. the wars involving NATO and the United States. Meanwhile, he accuses the opposition of being meek and succumbing to the calls of the United States and NATO to join other wars.

Panorama.am: I guess none of the candidates is preferable for Armenia.

Ruben Melkonyan: Of course, no Turkish authorities, president or political force can have a different stance on Armenia and the country continues to be targeted by Turkey, with all ensuing consequences.

Panorama.am: So, whoever is the president, they will stick to the same policy?

Ruben Melkonyan: Presumably yes, except for some minor changes. I believe the general policy line will remain unchanged for Armenia, including the military aggressive conduct.

Panorama.am: Do the Armenians living in Turkey have a favorite candidate?

Ruben Melkonyan: The approaches of the Armenians in Turkey are traditional, even somewhat predictable. The more active part of the community will vote for the left-wing Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP) which Garo Paylan members. Journalists and those rallying around the Agos daily will most likely support and vote for the left-wing forces, primarily Garo Paylan’s party.

A part of the Armenian community supports the government and always votes for the ruling team, in this case for candidate Erdogan and his alliance. They make up the so-called oligarchy of the community rallying around the Armenian Patriarchate.

The other part of the community may vote for the opposition Republican People’s Party, especially since its leader is taking some steps to address the minorities and ethnic communities in Turkey.

The distribution of votes in the Armenian community has almost always been like this.

Panorama.am: Thank you.

Opposition MP slams ‘provocation’ by pro-government colleagues

Panorama
Armenia – March 31 2023

ARF Armenia chair Ishkhan Saghatelyan, an MP from the opposition Hayastan faction, took to Facebook on Friday to condemn the detention of his fellow MP Mher Sahakyan following a conflict with Vladimir Vardanyan, a senior MP from the ruling Civil Contract party.

A scuffle erupted between the lawmakers at a closed meeting of the parliament’s Standing Committee on State and Legal Affairs on Friday morning. Sahakyan was detained shortly after the incident.

Saghatelyan blamed his pro-government colleague for the conflict and accused the police of using excessive force to detain the opposition MP. He denounced the incident as a “provocation” by the ruling faction MPs.

“The provocation by the Civil Contract faction MPs is aimed at diverting the people’s attention from the Azerbaijani advance into Armenian territory,” the deputy stated.

EU4Environment invites a consultant to develop recommendations for deforestation- and illegal logging-free trade in Armenia, Georgia and Moldova

March 31 2023

EU4Environment is looking for a consultant to provide analytical and advisory support to governments and stakeholders on key topics related to sustainable forest management, no deforestation and legal trade in timber products in Armenia, Georgia and Moldova.

The Consultant will undertake regional awareness raising and knowledge sharing, advisory support for improving deforestation-free trade control systems, and identification of areas of innovation and technology to strengthen export and trade controls over timber/wood and other relevant commodities.

EU4Environment encourages an experienced Consultant with expertise in sustainable forest management and legal timber trade, and experience of work in the EU and the EU’s Eastern Partner countries to apply.

The deadline for applications is 17 April.

Find out more

Press release

April 17, 2023
Calls for proposals
https://euneighbourseast.eu/opportunities/eu4environment-invites-a-consultant-to-develop-recommendations-for-deforestation-and-illegal-logging-free-trade-in-armenia-georgia-and-moldova/

Greece, Armenia Work Out Military Cooperation Pact, Training Drills

The National Herald, Greece
March 31 2023
March 31, 2023
By The National Herald

ATHENS – After being defeated by Azerbaijan in the 2020 conflict over the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh region and surrounding territories, Armenia has signed a military cooperation agreement with Greece.

The agreement was signed by Levon Ayvazyan, the head of the Department for Defense Policy and International Cooperation under the Armenian Defense Ministry, and Vasilios Tsami, the Director of the International Relations Department of the Greek General Staff, according to Azer News.

The cooperation plan includes 21 events, with 15 planned to be held in Greece and 6 in Armenia. The program features joint drills and an exchange of experiences among special forces, air defense units, cyber unit training, and peacekeeping forces, the report stated.

A component of the agreement will involve cooperation between the intelligence communities of the two countries. Before the current easing of tensions, Greece was at times close to a conflict point with Turkey, which supplied Azerbaijan with drones that proved decisive against Armenia in battle.

Greece is one of Armenia’s major military partners. A similar document, the Tripartite Defense Cooperation Program for 2022-2023, was signed between Cyprus, Greece, and Armenia on August 31, 2021, the report noted.

During a conversation with the Greek Ambassador to Azerbaijan, President Ilham Aliyev expressed his concerns about Greece working with Armenia, stating that it “poses an existential threat to Azerbaijan because, by using these weapons, they kill our military servicemen and civilians.”

CSTO chief sees ongoing tensions between Armenia, Azerbaijan

 TASS 
Russia – March 31 2023
On Thursday, Azerbaijan’s top brass said that the republic’s forces had taken control of heights and areas in the Lachin District near the border with Armenia ahead of the commissioning of a new motor road that would connect Karabakh to Armenia

MOSCOW, March 31. /TASS/. Tensions stemming from years of disputes are ongoing between Armenia and Azerbaijan in the Caucasus, General Secretary of the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) Imangali Tasmagambetov said on Friday.

“Tensions that stem from the long years of disputes between Armenia and Azerbaijan remain in the Caucasus,” the CSTO chief told an expanded meeting of the leaders of the organization’s Secretariat and United Staff.

On Thursday, Azerbaijan’s top brass said that the republic’s forces had taken control of heights and areas in the Lachin District near the border with Armenia ahead of the commissioning of a new motor road that would connect Karabakh to Armenia.

The situation around Nagorno-Karabakh escalated on September 27, 2020. On the night of November 9, 2020, Russian President Vladimir Putin, his Azerbaijani counterpart Ilham Aliyev and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan signed a joint statement on the full cessation of hostilities. The sides stopped at their positions at that moment, a number of districts went under Baku’s control, and Russian peacekeepers were deployed at the contact line and at the so-called Lachin corridor.

Armenia Is A Loyal Russian Ally, Not The West’s Partner – [Ukrainian] OpEd

March 31 2023

By Taras Kuzio

Some Europeans, Americans, and Canadians do not want to accept the fact that Armenia is second only to Belarus in being a Russian satellite state. Instead, they treat Armenia as a budding and prospective candidate for European integration, ignoring the impossibility of Armenia being allowed by the Kremlin to do a ‘Brexit’ from Russian-led and controlled organisations in Eurasia.

This month the Economist published a breakdown of Russia’s friends describing them as a ‘motley – and shrinking – crew.’ The table of what the Economist called ‘Putin’s Pals’ was compiled using 11 different measures of support and potential for pressure in the military, diplomatic and energy and economic fields. Armenia came a close second to Belarus as ‘Putin’s Pals.’ 

Belarus, Armenia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan are what the Economist call the ‘B Team’ and the ‘the coalition of the failing.’ All five are members of the Russian-led CSTO (Collective Security Treaty) meaning they are bound by treaty to assist each other if attacked. Yet none of them has supported Russia’s war in Ukraine with troops and all – except Belarus – have abstained in UN votes condemning Russia’s invasion and annexation of Ukrainian territory. Belarus has allowed its territory to be used as an invasion staging area and for missile attacks against Ukraine but has resisted sending its troops into battle against Ukraine. Self-declared president Alexander Lukashenka is afraid his troops would surrender or defect to Belarusian battalions fighting against his regime as soon as the cross the border into Ukraine.

The Economist drew up ‘Putin’s Pals’ by investigating treaties Armenia has with Russia, if they have Russian troops on their soil and do they use Russian arms.  The answer to all three questions is yes for Armenia. Russia and Armenia have signed military agreements since the early 1990s when Soviet and then Russian troops assisted it in defeating Azerbaijan in the First Karabakh War and occupying twenty percent of its territory. Based on August 1992 and March 1995 treaties, Russia has two bases in Gyumri and at Yerevan airport. Armenian officers train at Russian military academies and most of Armenia’s military equipment is Russian.

Prior to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine there were rumoured to be plans to expand the number of Russian bases in Armenia. In February 2021, Armenian Defence Minister Vagharshak Harutyunyan raised the possibility of ‘redeploying some military formation of the [102nd] Russian base to the eastern part of Armenia.’ The possible location was the Vardenis region, southeast of Lake Sevan. This was an area with Azerbaijani forces based nearby in the Kalbajar district which was returned in accordance with the November 2020 ceasefire agreement.

Russian military bases in Armenia are de facto permanent. In August 2010, Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan and Russian President Dmitry Medvedev signed an agreement extending these Russian military bases for 49 years from 1995-2044. It is interesting that 2044 was also the date that pro-Russian President of Ukraine Viktor Yanukovych extended the base of the Black Sea Fleet in Sevastopol in the 2010 ‘Kharkiv Accords.’

Armenia is a founding member of Russia’s alternative to NATO, the CSTO, which it joined in 1992 in the year it won its victory in the First Karabakh War with Russian military assistance. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan is unhappy with the CSTO for not intervening on Armenia’s side in the Second Karabakh War, ignoring the fact the war was fought on occupied Azerbaijani territory and Armenia’s territorial integrity was never threatened. Pashinyan is also unhappy with Russian peacekeeping forces because they have not intervened on Armenia’s side in border disputes, forgetting there would be no need for these forces and no military clashes if Yerevan agreed to sign a post-conflict peace treaty with Azerbaijan. Yerevan has been unwilling to sign a treaty because most Armenians refuse to accept the former Soviet republican boundary as an international border, a step that would include accepting Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan.

Unusually, and uniquely in the former USSR, Armenia’s borders are controlled by Russian border guard troops based on a treaty signed in September 1992. Russian border guard troops are based in Gyumri, Armavir, Artashat, Meghri and at Zvartnots airport. Russia’s border guard troops are under the control of the FSB, Russia’s Federal Security Service whose responsibility is internal Russian security but also stretches to cover the entire former USSR. In the USSR, the border guards came under the control of the KGB. R 

After the 2020 ceasefire, Russia expanded the presence of FSB border guard troops to five locations in Armenia, including two on the border with Nakhichevan (Yeraskh, Paruyr Sevak), two on the border with Iran (Meghri, Sghrt), and one in Tegh. The FSB expanded the number of FSB officers to the Armenia-Azerbaijan border. Russian border guard troops were also stationed in the villages of Vorotan and Shurnukh, on a 21 km section of the Goris-Kapan highway, in Kapan (near the newly built airport) and the Meghri region on the Armenian-Iranian border. 

In the latter phase of the Second Karabakh War, Russia transferred some military forces to two locations near Armenia’s border with Azerbaijan. The first was near the village of Tegh on the highway linking Armenia and Karabakh and the second was a reinforcement of existing Russian forces in Meghri. A second expansion was the creation of a Russian military outpost in Yeraskh, near the border with Azerbaijan’s Nakhichevan region, close to Tigranashen.

Again, unusually in the former USSR, Russian military police are deployed in and patrol Gyumri and Yerevan. Russia’s Alpha counter-terrorism special forces (spetsnaz) group, part of the FSB, are stationed at the military police headquarters in Yerevan. Aplha spetsnaz reinforcements have been flown into Armenia during crises, such as in October 1999 when five terrorists entered parliament and assassinated Prime Minister Vazgen Sargsyan, Parliament Speaker Karen Demirchyan and several other Armenian politicians.

In addition to Russia, Armenia has developed close political, diplomatic and military ties with Iran whose drones it has assisted in delivering to Russia that the Kremlin uses to attack critical infrastructure and innocent civilians. Iran regularly holds large military exercises on the border with Azerbaijan to pressure Baku over its relations with Armenia. In January, Iranian terrorists attacked the Azerbaijani embassy in Tehran leading to one fatality and two wounded. 

The Economist looked at diplomatic ties to determine if countries were ‘Putin’s friends.’ Armenia has very close diplomatic ties with Russia and Iran in what is a Moscow-Yerevan-Tehran axis.  After Russia’s 2014 invasion of Crimea, Armenia voted against UN resolutions denouncing the annexation. Armenian diplomats and politicians argued that ‘self-determination’ for Crimea should be the basis for the ‘self-determination’ of Karabakh (or what Armenian nationalists call Artsakh). This had no basis in international law because the UN definition of ‘self-determination’ only applies to states and not to parts of countries. If ‘self-determination’ was applied across the board, there would be chaos across the globe; indeed, many regions of the Russian Federation would claim the right to break away from Moscow.

Armenia has abstained on UN votes that condemned Russia’s 24 February 2022 invasion of Ukraine and Russia’s 30 September 2022 annexation of four Ukrainian regions. Georgia and Moldova voted in favour of UN resolutions condemning Russia’s invasion and annexation while most Eurasian states like Armenia chose to abstain. Of the 12 Eurasian states outside NATO and the EU, only Belarus supported Russia in these two votes at the UN.

Finally, the Economist investigated close energy and economic ties to Russia. Armenia’s energy structure, including gas pipelines are under Russian control. Russia supplies most of the gas used by Armenia. Russia raised gas prices to pressure Armenia to not sign an Association Agreement with the EU from which it withdrew in September 2013. Armenia’s two nuclear power plants were built in the USSR and are therefore reliant on Russia for fuel and repairs. If Armenia normalised relations with Turkey, which would lead to a reopening of their border, and signed a peace treaty with Azerbaijan, Armenia would be in a position – like Georgia – to benefit from gas pipelines flowing westwards from Azerbaijan. 

Armenia relies heavily on trade with Russia with whom it is in the Eurasian Economic Union’s (EEU) customs union. In 2013, President Sargsyan opted to withdraw from European integration and instead join Putin’s alternative, the EEU, two years later. Remittances sent back to Armenia by two million Armenians living and working in Russia are a vital injection of finances into the economy. Armenia exports to Russia make up nearly half of the country’s total export revenue. 

Numerous sources testify to a major increase in Armenian-Russian trade since early 2022. Most analysts believe this is not trade in real commodities but the re-export of goods through Armenia to Russia to bypass Western sanctions. While not supporting Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and annexation of Ukrainian lands at the UN, Armenia is nevertheless assisting Russia to bypass Western sanctions and receive Iranian drones.

Armenia is second only to Belarus in the top two of what the Economist describes as ‘Putin’s Pal’s.’  Western policymakers should drop their illusions as to this changing anytime soon because Armenia is too closely integrated with the Russian military and through diplomatic, trade, and energy ties. Brussels and Washington will not be seeing any Armenian ‘Brexit’s’ from Russia’s sphere of influence anytime soon.

Taras Kuzio is a professor of political science at the National University of Kyiv Mohyla Academy and author of the just published Fascism and Genocide. Russia’s War Against Ukrainians