The High Costs of India’s INSTC Ambitions

The country risks being pulled into the middle of ongoing tensions between the West and Israel on the one hand and Iran on the other. 

On April 20, the first trilateral political consultations between the Ministries of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Armenia, the Islamic Republic of Iran and the Republic of India were held in Yerevan.

Credit: Ministry of Foreign Affairs, ArmeniaADVERTISEMENT

Last week, officials from Iran, India, and Armenia met for the first trilateral meeting between the countries. Although formally the meeting was a discussion of possible avenues of economic cooperation, such a summit comes with greater context. In early March, while the Armenian foreign minister was visiting India, a delegation of senior officials from the country emphasized Armenia’s importance in helping complete the International North-South Transportation Corridor (INSTC), a project India has been developing for almost a quarter century to more closely link itself to the markets of Europe. Although India has been pursuing this avenue of potential cooperation for several years now, this dialogue represents a new step in India’s pursuit of this relationship.

However, India’s interests here cannot be merely restricted to the strengthening of economic ties between the three countries. With the route of any Iran-Armenia transport connection crossing the Zanzegur corridor in the far south of Armenia, a subject of dispute between Azerbaijan, Turkey, and Armenia in the ongoing siege of Nagorno-Karabakh, India has not been shy in supporting Armenia with limited arms imports. India’s plans for the completion of the INSTC in fact hinge on such support. Without a robust defense of Armenia’s borders in the face of increasingly stiff outside pressure, India would likely have to complete the INSTC with the help of Pakistan-allied Azerbaijan. Even if India could swallow that bitter pill, it is not entirely clear that its partner Iran could. Thus, for India, the current orientation of its policy in the South Caucasus is relatively inflexible.

Left in this position, India’s pursuit of the INSTC forces them into an economic and security relationship with the other trilateral participants, Armenia and Iran. Although the INSTC may be an important goal for New Delhi, the question arises as to whether the rigid means by which India may accomplish this objective are really worth the costs associated with them.

Naming aside, the INSTC is not merely a transportation link, but the integration of the manufacturing base of the region. This is hardly a facet of the INSTC that India ignores, either. In the construction of the Chabahar port in the Sistan-Baluchistan province of southeastern Iran, a key link in the project, India has developed manufacturing facilities right alongside the extensive multimodal transport facilities there.

Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month.

For Iran, there is no expectation that India will merely use the country for transshipment. The Foreign Ministry in Iran has been careful to pursue the development of manufacturing relationships between the two countries. Although these particular projects are largely oriented toward the Indian Ocean, and not European markets, the overall aim of the initiative is to link the manufacturing base of India, and by extension Iran, to that of Europe. The INSTC, therefore, implies the exchange of goods between Europe and Iran, a fact that requires a relatively liberal trade regime.

Given the ongoing Western sanctions on Iran related to the protests there last year, as well as Iran’s further enrichment of uranium, India’s vision for integrating the two countries’ manufacturing industries with European markets is limited at best. It is possible that India could decide to repurpose the corridor to instead link it to Russia, providing a sanctions-proof means of reaching global markets, but this seems unlikely. India’s evasion of Western sanctions since the onset of the Ukraine invasion has been routinely condemned by both Brussels and Washington. Considering that this comes at a time when New Delhi is negotiating a trade agreement with the former and cooperating with the latter to contain China, deepening trade partnerships with Moscow could irreparably harm India’s relations with both.

All of this is to point out that for the INSTC to be successfully realized, India needs the EU to be relatively sanguine about removing Iranian sanctions, an outcome that currently looks unlikely.

U.S. Security Concerns

Even if India were able to persuade European leaders to remove Iranian sanctions, the existing SWIFT sanctions, which limit Iran’s access to dollar-denominated markets, would still be a major barrier to trade. The SWIFT sanctions on Iran were quite significant, amounting to nearly $60.4 billion, or more than 16 percent of Iran’s annual GDP. With these sanctions still in place, Iran’s ability to contribute constructively to the manufacturing supply chain along the INSTC would be severely dampened.

Even with the removal of EU restrictions on Iran, this would do little to counteract the effect of the sanctions, as the trade frictions would be too costly. Unfortunately, these sanctions are not the exclusive purview of EU leaders, but require the additional assent of the United States. That is to say, for the INSTC to actually accomplish its objective, it would need Washington’s support.

To that end, India would have to address concerns on both sides of the aisle in the United States that Iran’s regional ambitions, as much a justification for the current sanctions regime as its nuclear program, do not pose a threat. Although earlier attempts have been made by the Biden administration to revive the Iran nuclear deal, which might eliminate the SWIFT sanctions, the White House has since walked back these efforts. In light of the earlier strikes on a U.S. base in Syria, as well as the declining popularity of the nuclear deal, the prospect of Washington reversing its position on Iranian sanctions appears to be an unlikely outcome. Without such support, the successful implementation of India’s INSTC is again questionable.

Israel’s Iran Strategy

Presuming that India could secure the necessary prerequisites for the INSTC’s success by persuading Western regimes to remove sanctions on Iran, India’s Armenian policy would still be challenged by a potent regional power: Israel.

Israel has a vital interest in preserving its relationship with Azerbaijan, especially as a means of undermining Iran. This long-standing diplomatic and military relationship with the regime in Baku poses a direct threat to the continued stability of neighboring Armenia – stability that, as noted previously, is crucial to the completion of the existing INSTC. Should Israel feel isolated by some hypothetical detente between the West and Iran, it is likely that its impetus to undermine a regime in Tehran that opposes Israel’s very existence would be even stronger.

Given how important Azerbaijan’s interests are to Israel’s Iran strategy, a divergence of the interests of Israel and India in the South Caucasus would have further diplomatic impacts. Outside of the direct threat that an isolated Israel could pose to the INSTC, India’s relationship with Israel is hardly one that it can afford to cast aside. The arms trade between the two countries has amounted to over $2.4 billion over the last seven years, helping India develop new defense relationships away from an isolated Russia. The increasing business and diplomatic ties between the two countries, especially through the new I2U2 grouping, could give India an important set of allies in the Middle East at a time when China is expanding its influence in the region. Jeopardizing this important source of cooperation in the name of the INSTC, a project that faces many roadblocks, does not seem to be a cost commensurate with the likely benefits of India’s policies.

Conclusion

India’s policies in the South Caucasus threaten to place New Delhi both directly and indirectly in the middle of the ongoing tensions between the West and Israel alliance on the one hand and Iran on the other. Putting aside the technical difficulties of actually completing the INSTC link through Armenia, the diplomatic gauntlet that New Delhi would have to maneuver to realize the project fully are incredibly high.

This is not to say that the entire policy within the South Caucasus needs to be scrapped, as India has been able to capitalize on the discontent in Yerevan with its previous security partner, Russia. Rather, it is to say that absent a policy absolutely committed to the realization of the INSTC, New Delhi’s policies going forward in the region do not have to be as confined as they have been over the last several years.

Russia urges Armenia not to distance itself from the situation around the Lachin corridor

Zakharova said this at a briefing on April 27, commenting on the statements of the Secretary of the Security Council of Armenia Armen Grigoryan that “the Lachin corridor belongs to Russia,” and that Russia is responsible for the developments taking place there.

 

“Currently, both through the Russian peacekeeping contingent and at the political level, the necessary efforts are being made to resolve the situation around the Lachin corridor and return it to the track of the trilateral agreements of November 9, 2020. We consider it fundamentally important for the official Yerevan to contribute to the search for mutually acceptable solutions,” Zakharova said.


https://mediamax.am/en/news/foreignpolicy/51122/







Armenia seeks enhanced capacity for EU monitoring mission

Save

Share

 13:24,

YEREVAN, APRIL 28, ARMENPRESS. Armenia proposes to enhance the capacity of the EU monitoring mission in Armenia, Secretary of the Security Council Armen Grigoryan has said.

He said that the number of observers is insufficient for monitoring Armenia’s international borders with Azerbaijan. “We are proposing all our partners to increase both the number of personnel and other capacities, in order for the observers to be able to carry out monitoring more properly,” Grigoryan told reporters in Jermuk.

[see video]

Armenian military works to gain advantage over Azeri troops near Tegh village

Save

Share

 13:43,

 

 

YEREVAN, APRIL 28, ARMENPRESS. Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Armenia Major-general Edward Asryan said Friday that the situation in the Armenian-Azerbaijani border is “relatively stable”, but ceasefire violations by Azerbaijan are taking place in the direction of Syunik and Gegharkunik.

“The goal behind these ceasefire violations is to keep the situation constantly tense, but the situation is under our control,” the Major-general told reporters.

Asked on cooperation with the EU observers, Major-general Edward Asryan said he highly appreciates the cooperation and that all issues are being resolved properly. “First of all, we ensure their military security, both during their work on the ground as well as during their transit. We also cooperate around other issues set before us, I highly appreciate the cooperation. I can also say that they are fulfilling their objectives,” Asryan said.

Speaking about the situation in the section of the Tegh village, the Chief of the General Staff said the Armenian troops there already have a frontline and the positions are being improved. “Every day we are carrying out the relevant work to gain advantage over the adversary in some directions. In all other parts the military is fulfilling its objectives too,” he said.

Defense Minister meets new Commander of Russian peacekeepers in Nagorno Karabakh, calls for efforts to lift blockade

Save

Share

 13:55,

YEREVAN, APRIL 28, ARMENPRESS. Minister of Defense of Armenia Suren Papikyan held a meeting on April 28 with Colonel-general Alexander Lentsov, the new Commander of the Russian peacekeeping forces in Nagorno Karabakh.

“I welcomed Colonel-general Alexander Lentsov on assuming his new position and wished him successes during the peacekeeping mission. We discussed the operative situation and existing problems around Nagorno Karabakh and in the area of responsibility of the peacekeeping contingent and a number of issues aimed at increasing the effectiveness of the Russian peacekeeping mission in Nagorno Karabakh. I emphasized the need for steady implementation of all terms of the 9 November 2020 trilateral statement and attached importance to efforts aimed at swiftly lifting the blockade of the Lachin Corridor,” Papikyan said on social media.

The Russian Ambassador to Armenia Sergey Kopyrkin, military attaché Colonel Igor Shcherbakov, and the former Commander of the Russian peacekeeping forces in Nagorno Karabakh Major-general Andrei Volkov attended the meeting.

[see video]

French Foreign Minister visits Yerablur military cemetery in Yerevan

Save

Share

 14:06,

YEREVAN, APRIL 28, ARMENPRESS. French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna visited the Yerablur Pantheon military cemetery in Yerevan, Armenia on April 28.

Colonna placed a wreath at the monument commemorating Armenian fallen troops in the Nagorno Karabakh wars.

[see video]

Secretary of the Security Council Armen Grigoryan accompanied the French Foreign Minister during the visit.

Photos by Hayk Badalyan




Nagorno Karabakh Foreign Minister interviewed by Brazilian news media

Save

Share

 14:28,

YEREVAN, APRIL 28, ARMENPRESS. On 27 April, at the Permanent Representation of Artsakh (Nagorno Karabakh) in the Republic of Armenia, Minister of Foreign Affairs of Artsakh Sergey Ghazaryan received a group of journalists from leading Brazilian media who arrived in Armenia on an exploratory visit. 

The Foreign Minister presented the situation around Artsakh, touched upon the challenges facing the Artsakh Armenians, as well as answered questions raised by the journalists, the Artsakh foreign ministry said in a press release. 

Sergey Ghazaryan thanked the media representatives for their interest for Artsakh and emphasised that such meetings are of great importance in raising international awareness of besieged Artsakh.




Armenia, France reiterate readiness to enrich special relations

Save

Share

 15:29,

YEREVAN, APRIL 28, ARMENPRESS. Armenia and France reiterated readiness to further expand the comprehensive agenda between the two countries and enrich the special relations in various sectors.

Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna delivered a joint press conference on April 28 after holding a meeting in Yerevan.

“The highest level of political dialogue between Armenia and France and the mutual determination to strengthen it is evident, which was reiterated with the participation of the leaders of the two countries in the Ambitions: France-Armenia forum last year, as well as with the signing of the 2021-2026 Armenian-French Economic Cooperation roadmap. We agreed to ensure the implementation of the roadmap with practical steps, it is our mutual keenness to have tangible results in this sector which will match our political dialogue,” Mirzoyan said.

He pointed out the productive cooperation with the French Development Agency as an important factor for promoting the economic agenda.

“We attached high importance to close cooperation in a number of other areas, such as education, science, culture and healthcare. I shared our satisfaction on how France shares Armenia’s successes, for example the opening of the Tumo centers in Paris and Lyon,” Mirzoyan said.

Mirzoyan said they also discussed the operations of the educational institutions encompassing all French educational circles in Armenia.

He said that every year Armenia holds the Days of La Francophonie events.

“We were pleased to note the inter-parliamentary cooperation both bilaterally and multilaterally in parliamentary platforms which has a special place in our bilateral comprehensive agenda. We underscored the importance of strengthening de-centralized cooperation, which is rapidly developing and has significant potential for expansion,” the Armenian FM said.

France expresses full support to negotiations between Armenia and Azerbaijan

Save

Share

 15:52,

YEREVAN, APRIL 28, ARMENPRESS. French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna has reiterated France’s support to Armenia given the challenges the country is facing.

Colonna said that it is an honor for France to be one of the countries that stand by Armenia to support it in overcoming the challenges.

Speaking at a joint press conference with Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan, FM Colonna said that the main issue discussed during their meeting was the peace talks with Azerbaijan.

“We had a lengthy discussion about the regional situation. France expresses its full support to the negotiations between Armenia and Azerbaijan. France is not alone in this, France does this with the EU and the US, naturally by maintaining contact with the OSCE and the UN, which can have a useful role in this process. We all know that the path to peace is difficult and often long. I am saying this in Yerevan, like I said in Baku, this is the only path that will allow to achieve fair and sustainable peace, create new prospects for the future of the two countries. We encourage everyone to join that path. Fair and sustainable peace means peace which is based on respect for international law. In Prague, the President of France and the President of the European Council made efforts in order for Armenia and Azerbaijan to make an important step and reiterate their commitment to the 1991 Alma-Ata Declaration, by which they mutually recognize each other’s territorial integrity and sovereignty. We believe that is important to strengthen this achievement, perhaps by carrying out the delimitation works as a priority,” FM Colonna said.

At the same time, the French FM said that respect for the principle of territorial integrity is important and said that the Azerbaijani military advance into the sovereign territory of Armenia is unacceptable.

“Respect for territorial integrity means refraining from any kind of use of force. I’ve said this in Baku as well,” she said.

“International law must be respected, therefore we can’t accept the unilateral steps made by Azerbaijan,” she said.

French FM visits Armenia in difficult period of time – Mirzoyan

Save

Share

 16:20,

YEREVAN, APRIL 28, ARMENPRESS. French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna is visiting Armenia in a difficult period of time when the country is facing serious challenges and threats to regional security, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan said at a joint press conference with his French counterpart.

“Today during our meeting I expressed gratitude for France’s principled positions expressed on all levels in various formats. Including in the direction of eliminating the consequences of the Azerbaijani aggression against the sovereign territory of the Republic of Armenia, and in advancing the peaceful settlement process of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict as an OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairing country,” FM Mirzoyan said.

FM Mirzoyan attached special importance to French President Emmanuel Macron’s involvement in establishing peace and stability in South Caucasus.

The Armenian FM said that Azerbaijan, disregarding the criticism by the international community and ignoring the February 22 ruling of the International Court of Justice, has now already officially blocked the Lachin Corridor in gross violation of the clause 6 of the 2020 trilateral statement, by installing a checkpoint in the Lachin Corridor which is the area of responsibility of the Russian peacekeepers. “This is yet another, but perhaps with its consequences an extremely dangerous and explicit violation of the trilateral statement. It is impossible not to see the real threat of ethnic cleansing in Nagorno Karabakh behind the explicit calls by the Azerbaijani authorities aimed at achieving exodus in Nagorno Karabakh, the hate speech and this violation. This must be clear for the international community as well.  In this context I once again emphasize the imperative of practical steps by UN member states having international security mandate, including by ensuring the deployment of an international mission to NK and Lachin Corridor and unimpeded access of international humanitarian organizations,” FM Mirzoyan said.