A Tale of Two Dioceses

It is our Achilles heel as a people. We are strong on opinions and weak on collaboration. The politics in Armenia are a classic example. While our enemies threaten our very survival, we choose to engage in internal conflict. In the diaspora, our organizational landscape reflects continuous addition but little subtraction. We add groups at will while legacy groups struggle to survive generational transfer. While the real enemy in the diaspora is assimilation, the reality is we compete against each other for the limited mindshare that our brethren in the diaspora can offer for their faith and heritage. I think you all know what I am referring to. Unless we have been residing on a distant planet, it is clearly visible in our daily American-Armenian life. We have too many redundant organizations, some born out of a desire to keep traditional groups relevant and others launched with new ideas and not enough cooperation. There are many noble attempts by people of goodwill. The lineup has more to do with legacy political affiliations than a core mission. We have the AYF, Hamazkayin, ARF and ARS. In parallel, there is the AGBU, ACYOA and Tekeyan. We have the ANCA and the Assembly. Some organizations have evolved to being non-partisan such as the Knights of Vartan, NAASR or AIWA. Unlike the past, it is rare to see overt conflict between Armenian groups today. Skeptical? Look at the pages of the Baikar and Hairenik publications 40 to 50 years ago. Today’s challenge is that we have become a large conglomerate of groups with no organizational relationships with each other. Looking at the diaspora from the outside illustrates this point. In a corporate environment with a struggling market, we would strategically consolidate to optimize results and enable growth. It’s true we are not a corporation, but we do have limited resources, a target market and core capabilities. The challenge is that we have no mechanism to address this problem. Just keep the lights on. In the 125 years of an active diaspora, we have certainly created division but have little experience in strategic collaboration or alliance building. We live in silos. Thinking of the whole becomes very parochial.

Our beloved church is always a good barometer of community health. The month of May is a time of renewal for the church. The Feast of the Resurrection followed by the period of Eastertide usually occurs during the Diocesan assemblies. I say plural because like most things in our Armenian life we have to have at least two. We have two dioceses, two diocesan primates/prelates and two assemblies (Diocesan and National Representative Assembly, or NRA). I wish we could at least use the same terms. It would make explaining this redundancy to our youth easier. I have tried for many years. Relations are cordial today but still clearly administratively divided. My personal protest to the stain of our continued division has been to ignore its reality. I gladly support all Armenian churches. I spent many years as an NRA delegate and later as a delegate to the Diocesan Assembly. Usually when you remain separate and distinct, there are clear differentiators. There are a few, but generally we all live with the same hopes and challenges. I have often found it interesting that both dioceses constantly complain and are concerned about financial stability, yet they have significant tolerance for the wasteful spending created by the redundancy of separation. Are we looking at the American diaspora as a whole or just our piece of it? It is one of the many reasons why I abhor our division. It clouds our vision and limits our thinking. The diaspora lives under the constant threat of assimilation. We have no room for obvious inefficiencies.

The Catholicos of the Great House of Cilicia Aram I (left) and the Catholicos of All Armenians Karekin II (right) during the canonization of Armenian Martyrs into Sainthood, April 23, 2015

The good news is that both dioceses (Prelacy with Antelias and Diocese with Etchmiadzin) are led by wonderful and deeply spiritual leaders. Archbishop Anoushavan Tanielian from the Eastern Prelacy is a beloved clergyman who has worked tirelessly on behalf of the faithful. If you have not experienced a badarak with His Eminence as the celebrant, please do your spiritual health a favor. His melodious chanting brings us closer to God with spiritual joy. The Antelias seminary has produced excellent clergy for many generations, particularly the celebrated clergy since its revival under Karekin I Hovseptiants of blessed memory. Last year, the Diocese elected a new primate in Hayr Soorp Mesrob Parsamyan. Hayr Soorp has been recovering from a serious car accident last summer and is thankfully now able to re-engage publicly in his duties. I have found him to be warm, approachable and a good listener. His elevation to bishop is scheduled for this fall at Holy Etchmiadzin. Whether you attend the Prelacy or Diocesan parishes, it is important that you give these two elected leaders your full support. Our support to clergy leaders is often clouded with ceremonial patronizing. These men cannot lead us unless we have the knowledge and fortitude to speak frankly and passionately about the future of our church. Too often, our bishops arrive at our parishes and see a false picture of reality. The choirs are full, and Sunday School is vibrant. It is another version of the Christmas and Easter attendance. The following Sunday is the picture they should see. Perhaps “unannounced” visits would be more productive. Only with a firm grasp of reality can we make real and sustainable progress. We can’t be critical of our leaders unless we have given our best in proposing solutions. Our community has many admirable traits, but we must learn to match criticism with commitment. If we could add one dollar to the church endowment fund for every measurement of commitment and subtract for every critical opinion, I am afraid that we would carry a significant deficit. Opinions may be the seeds, but commitment is the fertilizer.

This year, we will have the opportunity to experience the leadership of Hayr Soorp Parsamyan in earnest since he has had to focus on his recovery for much of this past year. Primates are public figures, and their interaction with the faithful is a major part of their ministry. I can’t imagine how difficult it must have been to be elected and then isolated for months after a devastating injury. Thanks to God, he has recovered and now will continue his delayed journey. This fall, Aram I, Catholicos of the Great House of Cilicia, will make a major pontifical visit to the Eastern Prelacy. The intent will be to visit each parish affiliated with the Prelacy. Aram Vehapar is an educated, dynamic and visionary leader who was mentored by Karekin I Catholicos of All Armenians (formerly Karekin II of Cilicia) of blessed memory. On the occasion of his historic visit, I have a request for His Holiness and the Etchmiadzin Eastern Diocese in the United States. It would be both appropriate and inspiring if Aram I was invited to conduct a hrashapar service at St. Vartan’s Cathedral or at a diocesan parish. This, of course, would require an initiative from the host parish. Unprecedented, perhaps…but what a significant message it would be. During the centennial anniversary of the Armenian Genocide in 2015, many Armenians had their first encounter with Aram Vehapar during events in Washington, DC. Most attendees from diocesan parishes did not previously know him because of our divided state and were impressed with this outstanding Armenian clergyman. This would be an opportunity to display a new level of spiritual oneness (avoiding the term unity). We are constantly lectured that it exists, but this would be “walking the talk.”

There is another reason to pursue such an event. We have lost our sense of history and foundation with our administrative separation. Participants from Antelias affiliations don’t know much about Etchmiadzin, and the reverse is also true. The Great House of Cilicia is an ancient hierarchical See of the Armenian church. Unfortunately, many in the United States only understand its presence in the context of the 20th century problem in North America. This is the seat where the Catholicos of All Armenians resided until 1441 and has had a prolific history in historic Cilicia. The story of the survival of the See with its permanent relocation in 1930 to Antelias after the Genocide is an Armenian journey of resilience and survival. It is part of our collective experience. Many diocesan clergymen were trained at the renowned seminary of the Holy See. What an inspiring experience for American Armenians to receive the blessing of the leader of one of our Holy Sees. Frankly, it has been nearly a decade and a half since the Catholicos of All Armenians visited the Eastern Diocese for a pontifical visit. He has traveled here several times during that duration but only for private deliberations. This is quite unfortunate. The faithful deserve the blessings of their leaders. It has been quite frustrating when Karekin II visits America but decides to keep his visits out of public view. During his last visit, he did make a stop in Albany to pray with the Primate at his rehabilitation center and the nearby diocesan camp. When Karekin II Vehapar visited several years ago, a hrashapar at a Prelacy church was advocated, but to no avail. We need our leaders to be among the people, particularly during these times of crisis in the global Armenian nation.

It is quite apparent that our community has lost its vigor for the administrative reunification of the church in America. We have become comfortable with our current level of cooperation, but not sufficiently motivated to finish the job. This is a crisis of leadership. Many will respond that a grassroots approach has been tried, and that the matter can only be resolved by the two vehapars. I would tend to agree, but if it is not on our radar it certainly will not be on theirs. This is not about church administrative unity. It is about Christian love and respect for each other to strengthen the Armenian church. We need to have the courage and vision to tear down the artificial walls and return to a natural state. As Armenian Christians, we should not let an anomaly in the 20th century distort our respect for a hierarchical See from Cilicia that is 1,000 years old. Likewise, we need to honor Holy Etchmiadzin as the seat of Armenian Christendom. If you don’t care for the leadership of individuals, it should never prevent us from respect for the seat and for our greater church. If we lose these gifts because we are blinded by distractions or disrespect, then we become responsible for the decline of our institutions. Our presence and actions do make a difference. Let us pray for the health of our prelate/primate and success in their ministries. Give us the strength to break down the superficial barriers preventing the sustained prosperity of our beloved church.

Columnist
Stepan was raised in the Armenian community of Indian Orchard, MA at the St. Gregory Parish. A former member of the AYF Central Executive and the Eastern Prelacy Executive Council, he also served many years as a delegate to the Eastern Diocesan Assembly. Currently , he serves as a member of the board and executive committee of the National Association for Armenian Studies and Research (NAASR). He also serves on the board of the Armenian Heritage Foundation. Stepan is a retired executive in the computer storage industry and resides in the Boston area with his wife Susan. He has spent many years as a volunteer teacher of Armenian history and contemporary issues to the young generation and adults at schools, camps and churches. His interests include the Armenian diaspora, Armenia, sports and reading


VEM Ensemble to perform in Detroit, Boston and Montreal

The VEM Ensemble

WATERTOWN, Mass. — The VEM Ensemble of the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Armenian Music Program at the Herb Alpert School of Music is coming to Detroit, Boston and Montreal as part of a tour sponsored by the Tekeyan Cultural Association (TCA) of the United States and Canada, with full concerts on, respectively, May 9, 11 and 13, held with local co-sponsoring institutions and organizations.

VEM, which means “rock” in Armenian, has performed throughout North America and Europe, including Armenia, to critical acclaim, and has been featured on various CDs. In its current configuration as a string quartet, the members include Professor Movses Pogossian on violin, master’s student Ela Kodžas on violin, master’s student Damon Zavala on viola, and UCLA alumnus Niall Tarō Ferguson on cello. TCA last brought VEM to the east coast of the US and Canada in 2019 as part of its mission to support the development of Armenian culture, and if not for the pandemic, would have accommodated requests for return performances much earlier.

Pogossian, the initiator of VEM and founder and director of the Armenian Music Program, explained VEM’s mission: “UCLA is the only university in the world that has an Armenian music program. The goal is to introduce [university] students to Armenian music. Almost always, the VEM members are students of non-Armenian descent. They are getting acquainted with this [Armenian] music for the first time, but they fall in love with our art and become great ambassadors for Armenian culture.”

Among the special elements of the current tour are the guest appearance of pianist Lilit Karapetian-Shougarian with VEM in Boston, where two pieces will be dedicated to the memory of her late husband, Ambassador Rouben Shougarian, and the dedication of the Detroit performance to the memory of the late Dickran Toumajan.

In March, VEM performed in Dilijan, Gyumri and Yerevan. “Everywhere we performed, the audiences welcomed us with so much enthusiasm for what we were doing, which created the most special concert atmosphere I’ve personally yet experienced,” said Zavala. “Despite the language barrier, the warmth and support of the Armenian audiences at our performances was visceral and I know we left each concert venue with our cups overflowing with emotion at the end of the night.”

In some instances, reactions were overwhelming. “During our final concert, in Yerevan, I heard an unusual sound behind me,” said Pogossian. “I’ll admit I was a little annoyed, because VEM alumna Danielle Segen was singing the Horzham, the ancient Armenian sharakan, from the balcony. She sounded heavenly, and I didn’t want to be distracted.” But any irritation Pogossian felt evaporated when he turned his head and saw a young woman sobbing uncontrollably. “She was having a powerful reaction to the spiritual impact of that holy music,” said Pogossian. “I think we all were having our own personal reactions. It was beyond words.” 

Among the composers whose works will be performed during the current tour are Komitas, Khachaturian, Mansurian, Shostakovich, Babajanyan, Mirzoyan, Goharik Gazarossian, Khosroviducht and Svendsen. The VEM members were fortunate to receive personal coaching from Tigran Mansurian during their visit to Armenia. 

The concert in Detroit on May 9 is hosted and co-sponsored by St. John Armenian Church at its Cultural Hall (22001 Northwestern Hwy., Southfield MI) with the Cultural Society of Armenians from Istanbul and the AGBU Alex and Marie Manoogian School. It starts at 7 p.m., with complimentary admission.

The May 11 Boston concert is co-sponsored by Holy Trinity Armenian Church in Cambridge, MA (145 Brattle Street) and starts at 7:30 p.m., with complimentary admission.

The May 13 Montreal concert will take place at the Tekeyan Center (825 Manoogian Street, St.-Laurent, Canada). Tickets are $20.

VEM will also have several academic and community outreach events in each of the cities it is touring. On May 12, there will be a lecture by UCLA Armenian Music Program associate director Dr. Melissa Bilal, with a mini VEM performance at MIT Building 4 (Classroom 231) at 12:30 p.m. cosponsored by several MIT departments, the National Association for Armenian Studies and Research (NAASR), and TCA. The program is called “Intertwined Legacies: Gomidas Vartabed (1869-1935) and Koharik Gazarossian (1907-1967).” Dr. Bilal also will be giving a lecture at the Vartan Room, again at St. John Armenian Church on Sunday, May 7, immediately after Divine Liturgy, titled “Unearthing Mihran Toumajan’s Life and Work: A Lecture Dedicated to the Memory of Dickran Toumajan.”

The VEM Performers

Movses Pogossian

Movses Pogossian is a celebrated prize-winning violinist who made his American debut performing the Tchaikovsky Concerto with the Boston Pops at Symphony Hall in 1990. He has since performed extensively in North America and Europe as a soloist, sought-after chamber musician and enthusiastic advocate of new music. Pogossian is the founding director of UCLA’s Armenian Music Program, as well as the artistic director of the critically acclaimed Dilijan Chamber Music Series in Los Angeles. His prolific discography includes “Complete Sonatas and Partitas by J. S. Bach” and solo violin CDs “Inspired by Bach,” “Blooming Sounds,” and “In Nomine.” Most recently, there are “Hommage à Kurtág,” “Modulation Necklace” and “Con Anima,” containing chamber music of Tigran Mansurian, with renowned violist Kim Kashkashian. He has an upcoming four-CD set sequel of new music from Armenia called “Serenade with a Dandelion.”

Pogossian has earned his advanced degrees from the Komitas Conservatory in Armenia and the Tchaikovsky Conservatory of Music in Moscow. He is currently a professor of violin at the UCLA Herb Alpert School of Music. A committed educator and community organizer, he participates in the Music for Food project, which gives the opportunity to experience the powerful role music can play as a catalyst for change.

Ela Kodžas 

Eager to honor and explore a variety of musical traditions, Serbian-American violinist Ela Kodžas, graduated as a Pi Kappa Lambda Scholar from the Eastman School of Music with a bachelor’s degree in violin performance with high distinction under the tutelage of Renée Jolles. She was also the only student in her graduating year to receive a Certificate of Achievement in Performance Practice, under the guidance of Cynthia Roberts, Paul O’Dette and Christel Thielmann. Currently, she is pursuing a master’s in violin performance under the tutelage of Movses Pogossian and Varty Manouelian at UCLA, where she is the teaching assistant for the Early Music Ensemble and was previously a teaching assistant in String Chamber Music. 

Kodžas’ interest in historical performance has led her to study with Amandine Beyer, Enrico Gatti, Robert Mealy, Bruce Dickey and Julia Wedman. Her playing has been featured in the Rochester Early Music Festival, the Boston Early Music Festival Fringe Series and the Berkeley Early Music Festival Fringe Series. She has performed with Publick Musick (Rochester, NY), LA Camerata (Los Angeles, CA) and Musica Angelica Baroque Orchestra (Long Beach, CA). She is a recipient of an Early Music America Summer Scholarship (2022).

Damon Zavala

Growing up, Damon Zavala was always surrounded by music. To his parents and to his family, there was a shared understanding about the importance of music. Throughout his childhood, Zavala’s exposure to music weaved between many genres. Subsequently, he likes to think this early intervention is reflected in his present broad musical interests.

Throughout his high school career, Zavala grew into an emerging young violist and violinist in Oregon and the Pacific Northwest, winning most notably two OSAA state titles in solo viola performance. With a desire to see more of the world and to experience a wider range of the music, Zavala eventually moved 2,000 miles away from home to go to college in Music City.

In Nashville, his principal teachers included Kathryn Plummer and Daniel Reinker. Throughout his time in undergrad, Zavala enjoyed a varied and eclectic musical career. These eclectic interests led Zavala to a variety of artistic collaborations around Nashville including working with singer-songwriters, recording film scores and presenting pop music productions with Listeso Music Group. In May of 2022, Zavala graduated with academic honors from Vanderbilt University with a bachelor’s degree in music.

Zavala is a violist based in Los Angeles, California, studying and instructing part-time at the Herb Alpert School of Music at UCLA. He is hoping to acquire more students to teach, to collaborate within commercial music industry spaces, and to ultimately share with people a diverse range of passion for music.

Niall Tarō Ferguson

A Los Angeles native, Niall Tarō Ferguson is a cellist, composer and orchestrator. He is currently an active freelance musician, contributing in equal capacity to the worlds of concert and commercial music. Ferguson has participated in music festivals such as the Rencontres Musicales Internationales at the International Menuhin Music Academy, Musique à Flaine, and the Borromeo Music Festival in Altdorf, Switzerland. He has studied with cellists Antonio Lysy, Lynn Harrell, Niall Brown, Ben Hong and Timothy Loo. In Los Angeles, Ferguson has performed on many of the city’s premiere contemporary music series, such as Monday Evening Concerts (M.E.C.), Jacaranda Music and the Hear Now Festival. As a session cellist, he records regularly on motion picture and TV soundtracks, record dates and reality shows. Ferguson has performed with artists such as David Foster, Andrea Bocelli, Shawn Mendes, Miley Cyrus, Olivia Rodrigo, Danny Elfman, and many others.

Ferguson has studied music composition with composers Mark Carlson, Ian Krouse and Bruce Broughton. His concert works have been performed throughout California and overseas, in such places as the Walt Disney Concert Hall, Barnum Hall, the Palau de la Música Catalana, the Aratani Theatre at JACCC, among others. In 2021, his piece Scamper was chosen to be performed virtually for the California Orchestra Directors Association’s All-State High School Orchestra.

Ferguson has orchestrated on several films including “Bruised” (2021), “Cat Burglar” (2021), “American Factory” (2020 Academy Awards Best Documentary Feature winner), “Fast and Furious Presents: Hobbs and Shaw” (2019), “Ni No Kuni” (2019), and “Kruimeltje” (2020). He has worked as an orchestrator on two of composer Joe Hisaishi’s concert tours: Kiki’s Delivery Service in 2019, and Porco Rosso in 2022. Niall’s string arrangements have also been featured on a number of commercial recordings, most notably on Lukas Graham’s “3 (The Purple Album),” which was released in October 2018 by Copenhagen Records, “Then We Take the World,” and Warner Bros. Records, and debuted at number one in Denmark.

As of 2019, Ferguson is a program associate with the Asia/America New Music Institute (AANMI), a collective that pursues cultural exchange through modern music. In April 2019, he participated in his first AANMI tour, accompanying founder Chad Cannon and contributing to lectures given at institutions throughout Asia such as the Hong Kong Baptist University, the Central Conservatory of Music in Beijing, and The American School in Japan, among others.

Ferguson received his bachelor’s degree in 2017 from the UCLA Herb Alpert School of Music, where he studied cello performance with Antonio Lysy, and music composition with Ian Krouse and Bruce Broughton. Ferguson is of Japanese descent on his mother’s side, and of Scottish and Irish descent on his father’s. He goes by both his Gaelic and Japanese names, Niall or Tarō respectively.




“It’s Spring…” wins Best Picture and Best Screenplay at BIFF

BOSTON, Mass.—On April 17, the Boston International Film Festival (BIFF) officially announced the winners of this year’s awards at the closing night gala event. Alexander Khachatryan, producer and lead actor in the film “It’s Spring…,” accepted the Best Picture award. Best Original Screenplay was presented to writer Harout Ghukassian. Representatives from more than 30 countries participated in the 21st BIFF with 80 short and feature films which were screened from April 13 until April 17 at the AMC Theatres Boston Common on Tremont Street.

“It’s Spring…,” directed by Roman Musheghyan, is based on the events of the four-day war in April of 2016, when Azerbaijan’s attempts to invade and unprovoked attacks on the Republic of Artsakh were repelled by the Armenian forces.

Khachatryan, with his masterful performance, plays the role of Aram Amatuni, a retired special forces commander who has devoted his entire life to defending his country. The years of his service to his country have taken their toll on Aram’s family life, and especially on his relationship with his son, Gnel (played by Armen Margaryan) who is now a successful businessman. Levon Hakhverdyan plays the grandson, a talented violinist who has been accepted to a prestigious music school in Europe when the war at the front confronts him with choices which will change the course of his life. The director subtly places elements of Armenian culture throughout the movie, which magically serve as a pedestal for the role of the mother, depicted by the incredibly beautiful performance of Mardjan Avetisyan.

The BIFF Best Original Screenplay and Best Picture Awards for “It’s Spring…”

While the movie is centered on patriotism and the struggle of the Armenian people for defending statehood and freedom, it also sheds light on an age-old human dilemma – since the times of Abraham. How can one be ready to sacrifice what is most valuable when the time comes?

As an Armenian watching this powerful movie, I was stirred by how real these existential questions are for us as a nation today. The faces of our heroes who sacrificed their lives defending our homeland came to my mind – brave young men and women, such as Anush Apetyan, Avetis Booloozian, Albert Hovannisyan, Alen Margaryan and thousands of others who not only gave their lives, but their families who gave what is most valuable to them.

Members of the Armenian community in Boston at the second screening of the movie “It’s Spring…” at the BIFF

On the morning of April 18, my wife Isabella and I met with Khachatryan and Ani Simonian, who offered her assistance in promoting the movie in the US. We had the privilege of giving them a little tour of our community in Boston and the Hairenik Building where they met Armenian Weekly editor Pauline Getzoyan and Hairenik Weekly editor Zaven Torigian, as well as ARF Archives director George Aghjayan.

Alexander Khachatryan (right) holding the original May 28, 1918 Declaration of Independence of the First Republic of Armenia housed in the ARF Archives after receiving a tour from ARF Archives director George Aghjayan (left). Also pictured (l. to r.) are Ani Simonian and Isabella and Harmik Avedian

While discussing the festival and the reception of the movie by its audience, Simonian showed us a recorded video of the full house standing ovation after the premiere screening in Boston. Khachatryan was pleasantly surprised with the movie’s ability to connect with the non-Armenian audience.

I asked Khachatryan what sparked the idea of this movie in him, and how long did it take to make? “This movie is the debt that my soul deeply felt the need to pay,” he replied. Then, he went on to say that during Soviet times many good movies were made in Armenia, but because of the oppressive political censorship and communist ideology, none of the movies were allowed to reflect the patriotic feelings of our nation. In early 2016, Khachatryan and Ghukassian, one of the best playwrights in Armenia, were discussing creating a movie about our nation’s victory in the first Artsakh war, while keeping in mind that with public sentiment regarding conditions in the country being low, the willingness of the young generation to enlist to defend the country might have been declining. It was not long before the spring of 2016 arrived and the enemy attacked our homeland. When they saw how countless young men, many of them college students, lined up next to the veterans from the first war at the military commissariat to volunteer as soldiers, they realized this is the story that needs to be told, and the direction of the movie became clear.

Khachatryan shared the challenges of making “It’s Spring…” Some of the production coincided with the pandemic and the 2020 Artsakh War. Despite the near-impossible situation, the production team continued the work. Khachatryan’s decision not to compromise the quality in the making of this motion picture has turned “It’s Spring…” into an homage to fallen soldiers and their families who have set the bar for what it means to love one’s country. I believe this masterpiece will inspire generations to come, much like the works by the great novelist Raffi in the 19th century.

“It’s Spring…” is the winner of multiple awards at 11 international film festivals. There are plans underway for a screening in the community.

Harmik Avedian has been involved in the Armenian communities of Tehran and Boston, serving on the Armenian National Committee of Iran, Council of the Armenian Prelacy of Tehran and the executive body of Hamazkayin Eastern Region of the US. He also has organized multiple tours to Western Armenia by the Center for Historical Studies of Van and Vaspurakan.


Samantha Power continues dodging questions about lack of USAID assistance to Artsakh

WASHINGTON, DC – US Agency for International Development (USAID) administrator Samantha Power has established a two-year pattern of dodging straightforward Congressional inquiries – both in-person during legislative hearings and in writing from dozens of legislators – regarding the lack of USAID programs in Artsakh, a troubling trend that was on display, once again, during her most recent appearance before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, reported the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA).

Asked straightforward questions about the status of US aid for Artsakh by the panel’s chairman, Bob Menendez, Power – who has been in office two years – again deferred, refusing to answer his question or even meaningfully address the senator’s broader point, by saying, “I don’t have that figure off the top of my head.” Power took credit for conducting “two assessment missions to the region,” failing to note that these were only conducted belatedly as a result of a Congressional mandate spearheaded by Congresswoman Barbara Lee (D-CA). Asked to provide the Foreign Relations Committee with these assessments, Power agreed.

“Clever dodges and mumbled deferrals don’t distract anyone from the fact that USAID – under President Biden and Administrator Power – has operated zero U.S. humanitarian assistance programs in Artsakh,” said ANCA executive director Aram Hamparian. “After countless Congressional inquiries during its two years in office, it is all too clear that they lack the will to help Artsakh, the strength to stand up to Azerbaijan, or the courage to take ownership of this deeply flawed policy.”

In his opening remarks at the April 26th Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing, Chairman Menendez complained that at times USAID’s response to crises is “slower than molasses,” noting, “Case in point: The humanitarian crisis for Armenians in Nagorno Karabakh is only getting worse. Where are we? Why aren’t we airlifting humanitarian supplies to those Armenians facing blockade? We need to respond to events quickly and we also need to address root causes.”

With strong support from the ANCA, Congresswoman Lee was successful late last year in including language in the Consolidated Appropriations Act (P.L.117-103) directing that the US Department of State and US Agency for International Development provide Congress with an “assistance strategy for addressing humanitarian and recovery needs arising from the [Artsakh] conflict” that identifies the US “resources and programs,” available for this purpose. The Artsakh provision included a 60-day timeline for the Biden Administration to report back to Congress. The deadline to submit the assistance strategy was March 1st; Senate and House members have yet to gain access to the report.

The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA) is the largest and most influential Armenian-American grassroots organization. Working in coordination with a network of offices, chapters and supporters throughout the United States and affiliated organizations around the world, the ANCA actively advances the concerns of the Armenian American community on a broad range of issues.


Scituate High School teacher awarded 2023 Rhode Island Genocide Educator of the Year

 

SHS teacher Tara Seger (2nd from left) following the award presentation with (from left) GenEd RI Branch co-chairs Esther Kalajian and Pauline Getzoyan and SHS Principal Michael Hassell

SCITUATE, R.I.—On Thursday, April 27, Scituate High School (SHS) teacher Tara Seger was awarded the 2023 Rhode Island Genocide Educator of the Year. She was nominated for the award by Rhode Island educators and was selected as this year’s recipient by the Genocide Education Project’s Rhode Island branch co-chairs Pauline Getzoyan and Esther Kalajian. Getzoyan and Kalajian presented the award to Seger in her classroom in front of her students, several SHS administrators and faculty members, as well as members of her immediate family. 

“I feel so honored to have received this award,” said Seger. “My goal is to provide students with the resources and knowledge to become informed and active citizens and empower them to make a positive impact in the world.”

Tara Seger graciously accepting her award in front of her students as Pauline Getzoyan and Esther Kalajian look on

Seger has been a teacher at SHS for more than 15 years. She currently teaches Modern World History, Current Middle East Conflicts, US History II and US History II Honors. She has spent 16 years researching the Middle East and is also the author of Refugee Realities: Voices from the Middle East. Seger has personally interviewed dozens of refugees from conflict zones and the Middle East. She has also studied at Yad Vashem, the world-renowned Holocaust Museum in Israel, and completed research in the West Bank, Nazareth, Tiberius, Caesarea and Tel Aviv.

“Tara is an incredible teacher and is so deserving of this award,” said SHS principal Michael Hassell. “She has dedicated her time to helping students learn, grow and understand multicultural and global perspectives.”

Seger began including the Armenian Genocide in her curriculum as she incorporated the stages of genocide and felt the importance of explaining the genesis of genocidal acts. This led to teaching the Armenian case as a stand-alone unit and inviting speakers with firsthand knowledge of events through their ancestors to share their stories with her classes. Getzoyan was one of those speakers.

Tara Seger proudly displaying her award with her US History II honors students and their work

“I’m passionate about teaching my students facts,” shared Seger. “I want them to learn how to speak with cultural sensitivity.”

This devotion to cultural sensitivity was one of the guiding principles of her book. “I also wanted to give back because the refugees were so wonderful when they spoke to my classes, and my students learned so much,” shared Seger. This desire to help and her genuine empathy for refugees has led Seger to contribute monthly to Americans Helping Others ProspEr (A Hope RI) from the income generated by Refugee Realities.

Seger’s father Gerald “Jerry” Schiano, Jr. was her “biggest supporter” in her work with refugees and as an educator. He is the one who shared A Hope RI with her which led to her connection to refugees from Afghanistan. Schiano very sadly recently passed away; Seger said that he would have been thrilled with her award. She shared that he would have been especially happy to see that Getzoyan had Refugee Realities with her as she and Kalajian presented the award.

Scituate Superintendent Laurie Andries, award recipient Tara Seger and GenEd RI Branch co-chairs Esther Kalajian and Pauline Getzoyan

The Rhode Island Genocide Educator of the Year is presented by the RI branch of The Genocide Education Project, which is based out of San Francisco, California. The organization was established to broaden the general understanding of genocide, with a focus on the Armenian Genocide.

“GenEd’s mission is to assist educators in teaching about human rights and genocide,” said Getzoyan. “GenEd assists educators by developing and distributing instructional materials, providing access to teaching resources and organizing educational workshops, as well as its Teacher Fellowship program.”

Tara Seger, her proud husband Daniel (right) and sons (left to right) Gavin and Owen

AYF Camp Haiastan announces annual raffle fundraiser

Young day campers at Camp Haiastan, Franklin, MA

FRANKLIN, Mass. — AYF Camp Haiastan is excited to announce its annual raffle fundraiser. This year, there will be three chances to win $5,000. All proceeds from the raffle will go toward fulfilling the mission of Camp Haiastan by funding its activities and programs.

The raffle drawing dates are scheduled on the following Sundays this summer: July 9, July 23 and August 6 (dates are subject to change). Each raffle ticket costs $100.

Camp Haiastan has been a pillar of the Armenian community for over 70 years, providing a fun and educational summer camp experience for Armenian youth. We believe that it’s important to foster a strong sense of Armenian identity and culture in our young people, and we work hard to create a welcoming and inclusive environment where campers can grow, learn and have fun.

Camp relies on donations and fundraising events like this raffle to support its programs and activities.

Raffle tickets can be purchased online, by reaching out to a local seller or sending the donation to the Camp Haiastan Office (PO Box C, Franklin, MA 02038).

Located in Franklin, Massachusetts, AYF Camp Haiastan, was founded in 1951 and is the oldest Armenian camp in the United States. The Camp prides itself on providing a healthy and safe experience to Armenian-American youth to help them foster their Armenian identity and establish lifelong friendships.


Armenian Genocide remembrance events held in Providence, R.I. with Dr. Taner Akçam

Dr. Taner Akçam with the members of the Armenian Martyrs Memorial Committee of RI (Photo: GVK Images)

PROVIDENCE, R.I.— The Armenian Martyrs’ Memorial Committee of Rhode Island hosted two important events commemorating the 108th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide last weekend. 

Stepan Piligian serving as moderator for the panel discussion with (from l. to r.) Hrag Arakelian, George Aghjayan and Dr. Taner Akçam (Photo: GVK Images)

The weekend began with a panel discussion with Dr. Taner Akçam on Saturday at the Providence Marriott Downtown. Dr. Akçam is the inaugural director of the Armenian Genocide Research Program housed at the UCLA Promise Armenian Institute. He was joined by a distinguished group of panelists consisting of Armenian Weekly columnist Stepan Piligian, who also served as moderator; director of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) Archives and member of the ARF Central Committee of the Eastern US George Aghjayan; and chairman of the ARF Providence “Kristapor” Gomideh and member of the Armenian National Committee of RI Hrag Arakelian. The discussion centered on past and present Turkish denial of the Armenian Genocide. 

Dr. Akçam shared a slide presentation and presented a strong and convincing argument that Turkey’s denial on the Genocide fuels the politics of continuing aggression, both inside and outside of Turkey today. One does not have to look too far to see the atrocities taking place today in Artsakh and Armenia by Turkey’s ally Azerbaijan. Following Dr. Akçam’s lecture, the entire panel weighed in on two specific topics of interest: (1) how Turkish denial actively manifests itself today as it relates to the diaspora, Armenia and Artsakh and (2) how to respond to denial campaigns with advocacy and what are the challenges. This proved to be an educational session where the panel was able to bridge the past with current events. The afternoon concluded with a lively question and answer segment with the audience’s participation. Those who attended walked away with a much clearer view of how Turkish denial impacts justice today for the Armenian people and is a central component of the political struggle for greater democracy and peaceful coexistence in the region. 

The procession in Sts. Vartanantz Church at the start of the service for the Holy Martyrs (Photo: GVK Images)

Following church services on Sunday in the sanctuary of Sts. Vartanantz Armenian Apostolic Church, the 108th commemoration of the Armenian Genocide took place with a service of remembrance of the Holy Martyrs. Melanie Zeitounian served as emcee. A large procession commenced with flag bearers, clergy, invited guests and wreath presenters surrounded by able-bodied honor guards as a beautiful hymn was sung by choir members of the three local Armenian churches under the direction of Maestro Konstantin Petrossian. Officiating clergy Rev. Fr. Kapriel Nazarian, Rev. Fr. Shnork Souin, Rev. Dr. Ara Heghinian and Rev. Hagop Manjelikian conducted the service for the Holy Martyrs with the assistance of deacons and service participants from Armenian Evangelical Church, Saints Sahag and Mesrob Armenian Apostolic Church and Sts. Vartanantz Armenian Apostolic Church.

The clergy and altar servers during the service for the Holy Martyrs (Photo: GVK Images)

The service began with “The Lord’s Prayer” (“Hayr Mer”) recited by the clergy and all those present; readings from St. Paul’s Letter to the Hebrews and the Holy Gospel according to St. Paul; the Litany of the Saints and concluding with the singing of “The Lord’s Prayer” by the choir and congregation. In addition, soloist Joanne Mouradjian sang a beautiful rendition of “Hrashatsan Bagootsmamp” to the Holy Martyrs.

Dr. Taner Akçam offering his remarks at the 108th commemoration of the Armenian Genocide at Sts. Vartanantz Armenian Apostolic Church in Providence (Photo: GVK Images)

Dr. Akçam served as the keynote speaker and delivered a riveting speech to an audience of approximately 250 individuals. With President Biden’s statement on Armenian Remembrance Day acknowledging the Armenian Genocide perpetrated by the Ottoman authorities on April 24, 1915, Dr. Akçam stated that now is the time for a movement focusing on reparations and restitution with Turkey, offering the example of Jewish reparations with Germany following the Holocaust. He also drew comparisons of the institutionalized racism ingrained with Turkey’s denial of the Genocide and apartheid in South Africa.

“If American recognition is not to remain a merely symbolic gesture, must there not be certain legal ramification to such recognition?” asked Dr. Akçam before continuing that the Armenian community must move into another realm of justice now. “The main purpose for recognizing historic injustices is for such gestures to potentially bring in their wake at least partial recompense for past injustices. Indeed, if such acknowledgement is not followed by some step in the direction of getting justice for past wrongs, the gesture is truly without any meaning,” he said while outlining the next steps in justice for the Armenian Genocide after US recognition.

Following Dr. Akçam’s remarks, the Armenian school children of Saints Sahag and Mesrob Armenian Church and Sts. Vartanantz Armenian Church sang “Ov Hayots Kacher/Hayer Miatsek” under the direction of director Raffi Rachdouni with accompaniment by Maestro Petrossian. Armenians continue to live through their faith, culture and long standing traditions, and in this case, through the talented voices of our precious youth. 

The school children from the Armenian churches sing for those gathered in remembrance (Photo: GVK Images)

Elected officials who were invited to say a few words at the commemoration included the 39th mayor of Providence Brett Smiley; the Honorable Dan McKee, 76th governor of the state of Rhode Island; and United States Senator Jack Reed. Also present were RI Secretary of State Gregg Amore and the state’s General Treasurer James Diossa. Additional political leaders in the audience were recognized individually, including State Representative Katherine Kazarian and State Senator David Tikoian.

[see video]




Armenia and Azerbaijan discuss agreement on normalizing relations in Washington

Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov meet in Washington on May 1, 2023 (Photo: Twitter/@SecBlinken)

The Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan are in Washington this week to discuss normalizing relations between the two countries.

On May 3, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and his Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov met with US National Security Advisor Jake Sullivan. They discussed “regional security and stability” and the “process of normalizing relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan,” according to a statement from Armenia’s Foreign Ministry. The foreign ministers previously met with US Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Monday. Several days of negotiations are scheduled to end on May 4. 

The high-level delegations are hammering out a document titled “Agreement on normalization of relations,” according to anonymous US officials cited by Voice of America. The officials also said they are discussing the “rights and security of ethnic minorities.” 

“The question of the rights and security of the population of Nagorno-Karabakh is central to the conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan,” another anonymous spokesperson from the US State Department said in written comments to RFE/RL on May 2. 

“Ultimately ensuring that this population can feel secure in their homes and have their rights protected is the only way to guarantee a lasting settlement to a conflict that has lasted too long and cost too many lives,” the spokesperson continued. 

The spokesperson said that the scope and nature of the final agreement on normalizing relations will be determined by Armenia and Azerbaijan. 

Addressing the Armenian parliament on May 3, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan confirmed that the Armenian and Azerbaijani delegations are negotiating over a specific document. He said the document does not contain any new information that he has not already shared publicly. 

These are the first face-to-face meetings between high-level officials from Armenia and Azerbaijan since the start of the blockade of Artsakh in December 2022. In a brief statement on Monday, Armenia’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs said that the “humanitarian situation resulting from the illegal blockade of the Lachin corridor by Azerbaijan was touched upon” during the day’s meetings. 

“We have not parsed our words about the need for the free flow of traffic and people and commerce through the Lachin corridor,” US State Department deputy spokesperson Vedant Patel said on May 1 while announcing this week’s meetings. “That continues to be the case, and it’s something that we will continue to raise directly with our Armenian counterparts.”

Blinken held phone calls with both Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev prior to this week’s negotiations. During his call with Aliyev, Blinken “expressed the United States’ deep concern that Azerbaijan’s establishment of a checkpoint on the Lachin corridor undermines efforts to establish confidence in the peace process, and emphasized the importance of reopening the Lachin corridor to commercial and private vehicles as soon as possible,” according to a readout from the US State Department. 

The United States and the European Union have increased their diplomatic engagement in the South Caucasus since the 2020 Artsakh War. During the latest meeting hosted by the EU in Prague on October 6, attended by Pashinyan and Aliyev, Armenia and Azerbaijan recognized each other’s territorial integrity and sovereignty. 

Pashinyan reiterated his commitment to recognizing Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity during his comments to the Armenian parliament on April 18. 

“A peace treaty between Armenia and Azerbaijan will become real if the two countries clearly, without ambiguities and pitfalls, recognize each other’s territorial integrity and agree on never having territorial disputes in the future,” Pashinyan said.

Russia has been critical of Western diplomacy in the Artsakh conflict, accusing the West of attempting to displace its role as the primary mediator in the conflict. Commenting on the ongoing meetings in Washington, Kremlin spokesperson Dmitry Peskov said that there are “no alternatives” to trilateral documents signed together with Russia. He welcomed “any assistance that could help the settlement on this basis.” Yet he also suggested that Western mediation could “dilute the basis for the settlement, which may not work at all in the long run.”

In the past, Russian officials have accused the West of pushing for a settlement that would recognize Azerbaijan’s sovereignty over Artsakh. They have suggested that the Russian negotiation track would maintain the status quo in Artsakh. Western officials have denied this claim. 

“We remain committed to promoting a peaceful future for the South Caucasus region. We believe that direct dialogue is key to reaching a lasting peace, and we believe that peace is possible between these two countries,” Patel said on May 3rd.

The US-mediated meetings come a week after Azerbaijan installed a checkpoint at the entrance to the Berdzor (Lachin) Corridor from Armenia. 

Azerbaijani protesters claiming to be environmental activists closed the Berdzor Corridor for over four months starting on December 12, 2022, placing Artsakh under blockade and cutting the region off from imports of food and medicine. The Berdzor Corridor is the sole route connecting Artsakh with Armenia and the rest of the world. 

On April 28, following the installation of the military checkpoint five days earlier, the activists announced that they were suspending their protest. In an identical article published across Azerbaijani pro-government media, the protesters announced that the establishment of the checkpoint “caused us a sense of pride and joy.” 

“The creation of a border control mechanism is aimed at preventing any provocations by ensuring traffic transparency on the road, the rule of law and road safety,” the protesters said in a joint statement. 

The statement continues that the protesters “reserve the right to renew the action” if the Russian peacekeepers do not “stop the illegal exploitation of mineral deposits” in Artsakh. 

The installation of a military checkpoint violates the trilateral ceasefire agreement signed by Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia ending the 2020 Artsakh War. Under the terms of the agreement, Russian peacekeepers were deployed to the Berdzor Corridor to ensure the connection between Armenia and Artsakh. The agreement states that “Azerbaijan guarantees traffic safety along the Lachin Corridor of citizens, vehicles and goods in both directions.” 

Artsakh authorities have said that, while protests along the Berdzor Corridor have ended, Artsakh is still under blockade due to the checkpoint. 

On April 30, an Azerbaijani public broadcast service shared a video of Armenian vehicles crossing the checkpoint. Azerbaijani border guards are seen searching the vehicles and inspecting travelers’ documents.

“As can be seen from the presented footage, people’s border crossing is organized in a neat and polite manner,” the broadcast service said. “Thus, the claims of the Armenian officials regarding the ‘ethnic cleansing’ of the Karabakh Armenians and the ‘blockade’ of the Lachin road are nothing more than another false propaganda.”

Yet Artsakh authorities said that the travelers had been forced to participate in filming the video. They had been assured by Russian peacekeepers that Azerbaijani guards would not intervene in their journey, according to Artsakh officials.

The four Armenian residents of Artsakh had been stuck in Goris, a city in Armenia’s southernmost province Syunik, due to the blockade. They had appealed to the Russian peacekeepers for assistance returning home, who agreed to transport them in private cars without inspection. Yet they were unexpectedly stopped by Azerbaijani officers at the checkpoint. 

The group was returning to their homes in Mets Shen, Hin Shen, Lisagor and Yeghtsahogh, villages in the Shushi region of Artsakh. The villages, located along the Berdzor Corridor, were cut off from the rest of Artsakh by the closure of the corridor by Azerbaijani activists. They have been cut off from Armenia by the checkpoint, placing them under a double blockade.

Artsakh State Minister Gurgen Nersisyan said that the humanitarian situation in these villages is deteriorating. 

“An attempt was made to supply food and medicine to these communities through the Artsakh office of the Red Cross, but these efforts were unsuccessful,” Nersisyan said. 

Lillian Avedian is a staff writer for the Armenian Weekly. Her writing has also been published in the Los Angeles Review of Books, Hetq and the Daily Californian. She is pursuing master’s degrees in journalism and Near Eastern Studies at New York University. A human rights journalist and feminist poet, Lillian’s first poetry collection Journey to Tatev was released with Girls on Key Press in spring of 2021.


RFE?RL Armenian Report – 05/03/2023

                                        Wednesday, May 3, 2023
Pashinian Confirms Armenia, Azerbaijan Negotiating Over Specific Document
        • Karlen Aslanian
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian speaks in parliament. May 3, 2023.
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian has confirmed that there is a specific 
document on the table in Washington where Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and 
his Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov are having marathon talks these days 
in an attempt to hammer out a normalization agreement.
But speaking in parliament on Wednesday, the Armenian leader stressed that there 
was nothing in that document that he did not speak about publicly.
“You won’t find in this document anything new, because I publicly talked about 
this document from this very podium,” he said.
Pashinian added that he would not go into details now since “any positive or 
negative interpretation will affect the course of the negotiations.”
Pashinian also publicly shared the instructions he gave to the Armenian 
delegation conducting negotiations in Washington: “I said, remember, it is I who 
will be signing the document around which you are negotiating. So, negotiate 
freely, within the framework of our political course and within the framework of 
our publicly expressed opinions.”
Speaking in parliament on April 18 Pashinian said that a peace treaty between 
Armenia and Azerbaijan will become realistic “if the two countries recognize 
clearly, without ambiguities and pitfalls, each other’s territorial integrity 
and undertake not to ever submit territorial claims to each other.”
He also highlighted the importance of an internationally visible mechanism for a 
dialogue between Baku and Stepanakert on the rights and security of the 
Armenians of Nagorno-Karabakh.
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev also stressed on Wednesday the need for 
Armenia to fully recognize Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity.
“I recently said that they [Armenians] just need to say the last word. They said 
A, and now they have to say B. They should say what I said, that Karabakh is 
Azerbaijan. I am waiting for it. I hope that the time for that will come,” he 
said, speaking at an international event in Shushi (Susa), a Karabakh town that 
Azerbaijan gained control of during a 2020 war.
The Armenian premier again stressed the need for having mutually recognized 
borders as he addressed parliament today. He said that having no territorial 
claims to neighbors now and in the future was key to preserving Armenian 
statehood.
Armenia’s Foreign Ministry said on Wednesday that negotiations between the 
Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers were scheduled to end on May 4.
Turkey Cites ‘Provocative’ Monument In Yerevan As Reason For Banning Overflights 
From Armenia
        • Lilit Harutiunian
Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu (file photo)
Turkey has closed its airspace for flights operated by Armenian airlines toward 
third countries because of Armenia’s provocations, Turkish Foreign Minister 
Mevlut Cavusoglu said, speaking on Turkish television on Wednesday.
A Flyone Armenia plane operating a flight from Paris to Yerevan had to land in 
Chisinau, Moldova, on April 29 after Turkey’s aviation authorities banned it 
from entering the country’s airspace. Flyone Armenia, which has been flying into 
and over Turkey since last year, said it had not been informed about the ban in 
advance.
Speaking on NTV Channel, Cavusoglu said: “If necessary, we will allow planes 
into our country, but we will not allow airplanes and private planes to fly 
through our airspace while the provocations [of Armenia against Turkey and 
Azerbaijan] continue. If they do not stop doing this, we will also take other 
steps.”
The top Turkish diplomat, in particular, referred to the recent erection of a 
monument in Yerevan to participants in Operation Nemesis, a 1920s program of 
assassinations of Ottoman perpetrators of the 1915 Armenian genocide and 
Azerbaijani figures responsible for 1918 massacres of Armenians in Baku.
Yerevan’s Deputy Mayor Tigran Avinian speaks at the unveiling ceremony for a 
monument to Operation Nemesis participants, Yerevan, Armenia, April 25, 2023.
While Operation Nemesis participants are widely regarded by Armenians as 
“avengers”, Turkey and Azerbaijan view them as terrorists.
In statements following the unveiling of the monument in the center in Yerevan 
on April 25, one day after Armenians in Armenia and around the world marked the 
108th anniversary of the Ottoman-era Genocide vehemently denied by Turkey, the 
Turkish and Azerbaijani foreign ministries condemned the event that was also 
attended by Yerevan’s deputy mayor.
Ankara also warned that the “shameful monument” in Yerevan only damages the 
normalization process that Turkey and Armenia embarked upon in early 2022.
“Turkey is sincere in its desire to normalize relations with Armenia, but the 
installation of the Nemesis monument in Armenia is unacceptable,” Cavusoglu said.
“I can’t accept it. Armenia’s statements on this issue are also insincere. We 
closed the airspace as an adequate response. If necessary, we can also take 
other steps,” he added, urging Armenia to “stop attempts to deceive Turkey.”
The Turkish minister’s remarks came as Armenian Parliament Speaker Alen Simonian 
was heading to Turkey to attend a meeting of the Parliamentary Assembly of the 
Black Sea Economic Cooperation. Cavusoglu said that the Armenian official was 
allowed to use Turkish airspace since he was arriving for an international event 
held in Ankara.
Official Yerevan did not immediately comment on Turkey’s condemnation of the 
Operation Nemesis monument inauguration in the Armenian capital and its ban on 
overflights for Armenian airlines.
In remarks in parliament on Wednesday Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian 
acknowledged that the closure of Turkish airspace for Armenian planes was a 
problem. “But whose problem is it? It is our problem. Those who block our roads 
have no problems at all,” he said.
Pashinian said that when the issue of opening the monument was being discussed 
in 2020-2021, months after the end of the war in Nagorno-Karabakh, the decision 
was made to have it erected in order to “avoid being labeled traitors.”
“Being always guided by the logic of doing so as not to be called traitors we 
actually keep betraying the state and national interests of our country,” he 
said.
New Poll Reflects Armenia’s Souring Relations With Russia
Armenia - A view of capital Yerevan against the background of Mount Ararat (file 
photo)
A new international survey in Armenia shows a continuing trend of 
“deteriorating” relations with Russia since the 2020 Armenian-Azerbaijani war in 
Nagorno-Karabakh, with most Armenians placing Tehran and Paris higher than 
Moscow as their main security partners.
The public opinion polls conducted on behalf of the International Republican 
Institute (IRI) in Armenia among over 1,500 permanent residents of the country 
aged above 18 in January-March 2023 reveal that while as many as 93 percent of 
Armenians in 2019 considered relations with Russia to be “good” and only 6 
percent viewed them as “bad”, that ratio has changed to 50 and 49 percent, 
respectively, this year.
The trend of the perception of “deteriorating relations” with Russia began after 
the 2020 war in Nagorno-Karabakh in which, according to observers, Armenians 
largely felt Russia should have provided more support to Armenia, its strategic 
political and military ally in the region. The IRI poll shows that it continued 
in 2022, the year when Russia invaded Ukraine, as Armenians began to look more 
to other countries as their main security partners.
According to the latest survey, while 54 and 52 percent of Armenians, 
respectively, consider Iran and France as their “most important security 
partners”, only half of them now view Russia as such.
France, Iran and the United States are also viewed as the top three “most 
important political partners for Armenia” by 75, 67 and 52 percent of 
respondents, accordingly, while Russia is only fourth in the list with 50 
percent.
Interestingly, while Azerbaijan and Turkey, with which Armenia has had bad 
relations for decades because of Nagorno-Karabakh wars and other historical 
feuds, are still viewed as the “greatest political threat” to Armenia by most 
Armenians (93 and 89 percent, respectively), as many as 24 percent of Armenians 
said they also consider Russia, a formal ally, as such a threat.
In contrast, according to the poll, only 3 and 2 percent of Armenians called the 
United States and the European Union, respectively, as the “greatest political 
threat” to their country, while 7 percent said that Ukraine posed such a threat.
While 5 percent of Armenians viewed relations with Turkey as “good” and 91 
percent viewed them as “bad” in December 2021, a month before Yerevan and Ankara 
formally embarked on their latest attempt to normalize relations, the current 
ratio, according to the IRI poll, stands at 23 to 75 percent, respectively.
Generally, 52 percent of respondents in the poll said that they believed Armenia 
is heading in the “wrong direction,” while 36 percent said the country was on 
the right track.
A total of 60 percent of respondents in the poll named “national security” and 
“border issues” as the main problems Armenia is currently facing. Economy and 
unemployment was mentioned by only 27 percent of the respondents.
The survey also shows that the level of support for Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian and his ruling Civil Contract party remains almost as strong as a year 
ago.
A total of 14 percent of respondents named Pashinian as the most trusted 
politician in Armenia, with only 2 percent naming ex-President Robert Kocharian, 
Pashinian’s top rival in the 2021 early parliamentary elections, as such.
A total of 21 percent of respondents, compared to 25 percent in June 2022, said 
that they would vote for Civil Contract if national parliamentary elections were 
held next Sunday. The number of those ready to vote for Kocharian’s Hayastan 
(Armenia) Alliance has dropped from 8 percent last year to 5 percent today.
According to respondents of the poll, the biggest successes of the Pashinian 
government during the last six months were “development of diplomatic relations” 
and “improvement of roads”, while the biggest failures in the same period were 
the closure by Azerbaijan of the Lachin Corridor that links Nagorno-Karabakh 
with Armenia and the “foiling of the Karabakh issue.”
Washington Asks Baku, Yerevan ‘To Consider How Best To Protect Rights And 
Security’ Of Karabakh People
        • Siranuysh Gevorgian
U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken (in the center) hosting 
Armenian-Azerbaijani talks in Washington, May 1, 2023.
Official Washington has asked Baku and Yerevan “to consider how best to protect 
the rights and security” of people in Nagorno-Karabakh, a State Department 
spokesperson told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service, answering a question on whether 
issues related to Nagorno-Karabakh are being discussed in the U.S.-hosted 
Armenian-Azerbaijani talks.
Bilateral negotiations between Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and his 
Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov aimed at hammering out an agreement to 
normalize relations between the two South Caucasus nations opened in Washington 
on Monday after the two top diplomats met separately with U.S. Secretary of 
State Antony Blinken and then had a meeting all together.
As Mirzoyan and Bayramov went into talks that officials in Washington said could 
last “a few days” Blinken stressed the importance of dialogue for “reaching a 
lasting peace in the South Caucasus region.”
In written comments to RFE/RL’s Armenian Service on May 2 the State Department 
spokesperson stressed that “the question of the rights and security of the 
population of Nagorno-Karabakh is central to the conflict between Armenia and 
Azerbaijan.”
“Ultimately ensuring that this population can feel secure in their homes and 
have their rights protected is the only way to guarantee a lasting settlement to 
a conflict that has lasted too long and cost too many lives,” the official said, 
adding that the United States supports an agreement that is “durable, 
sustainable, and lays the foundations for peace.”
At the same time, the State Department emphasized that “the scope and nature of 
the agreement to normalize relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan is between 
the two parties.”
“We are honored to host the foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan as they 
work toward peace. The United States remains committed to promoting a peaceful 
future for the South Caucasus region. Direct dialogue is key to resolving issues 
and reaching a lasting peace,” the spokesperson said.
“The scope and nature of the agreement to normalize relations between Armenia 
and Azerbaijan is between the two parties. Our goal is to provide a location 
where there can be bilateral discussions and the parties can undertake the real 
hard work together to make progress on lasting peace. Specifics on what is – and 
is not – part of their agreement is a question for the parties,” the U.S. 
official added.
Armenia’s Foreign Ministry said on Wednesday that negotiations between Mirzoyan 
and Bayramov continued today and were scheduled to end on May 4.
According to Azerbaijan’s Turan news agency, Blinken is expected to join the 
Armenian and Azerbaijani ministers for final negotiations on Thursday.
A spokesperson at Armenia’s Foreign Ministry said that information on the U.S. 
participation and other details will be reported tomorrow.
Armenia Explains Vote On ‘Anti-Russian’ Resolution At UN
        • Nane Sahakian
A UN Assembly (file photo)
Official Yerevan has refuted reports in the media that Armenia supported an 
“anti-Russian” paragraph when it voted in favor of a United Nations resolution 
last week.
The vote on the resolution on cooperation between the UN and the Council of 
Europe took place on April 26, with 122 nations, including Armenia, voting to 
support it, 18 nations abstaining and only five voting against it.
Armenia’s Foreign Ministry explained to RFE/RL’s Armenian Service that “Armenia 
did not support the controversial paragraph of the resolution, but voted in 
favor of the resolution itself.”
A press release posted on the UN website confirms that while compromises were 
reached on lots of issues, no consensus was reached on paragraph 9. This is 
exactly the paragraph that speaks about “Russian aggression against Ukraine and 
Georgia” and calls for “providing redress to victims and bringing to justice all 
those responsible for the violations of international law.”
Eventually, it was decided to hold a separate vote on this paragraph, in which 
Armenia abstained.
Thus, by its April 26 vote at the UN Armenia showed no change in its neutral 
position on the Russian-Ukrainian war, again avoiding calling Moscow an 
aggressor.
Against the background of media reports that several key partners of Russia, 
including Armenia, Kazakhstan, China, India, Turkey and others voted in favor of 
an “anti-Russian resolution”, Deputy Permanent Representative of Russia to the 
United Nations Dmitry Polyansky said that “we are talking about an ordinary 
resolution of cooperation between the United Nations and the Council of Europe, 
and many of Russia’s partners did not support the controversial paragraph.”
In the separate vote on paragraph 9, only 81 countries voted in favor of calling 
Russia an aggressor, while 48 countries, including Armenia, abstained and 10 
voted against it.
Sargis Khandanian, chairman of the Armenian National Assembly’s Foreign 
Relations Committee, said that Armenia could not have voted otherwise on the 
general resolution on strengthening cooperation between the UN and the Council 
of Europe that talks about such key things as promotion of the rule of law and 
democracy, freedom of speech and thought, fight against terrorism, trafficking, 
etc.
“Armenia is a member of the Council of Europe, and a number of institutions that 
operate within the Council of Europe are very important for Armenia in terms of 
the protection of human rights, the development of democracy. And that 
resolution also pursues such goals and has such emphasis. So it would be strange 
if Armenia did not join the adoption of this resolution,” Khandanian said.
“As a matter of fact, Armenia joined the entire resolution, and one should 
consider the resolution as a whole and not focus on one paragraph, which 
contains different emphases,” the pro-government lawmaker concluded.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

AW: The Hairenik in conversation with ARF leader Ishkhan Saghatelyan

Ishkhan Saghatelyan speaking to fellow ARF members, April 15, 2023

“Change of power in Armenia will change the current situation… And for that reason, Armenians should not be dismayed.” — Ishkhan Saghatelyan

Ishkhan Saghatelyan, representative of the Supreme Body of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (ARF) of Armenia and representative of the “Armenia Alliance” opposition faction of the National Assembly of Armenia, visited the Greater Boston community last month and was interviewed at the Hairenik Building. The text of the interview, translated from Armenian by Weekly contributor Ara Nazarian, appears below.

Hairenik Staff (H.S.): Welcome to the editorial office of the Hairenik, which has been in publication since 1899. For the last five years, our homeland has been facing a series of troubles. How does the opposition evaluate the situation before and after the war?

Ishkhan Saghatelyan (I.S.): The Hairenik is one of our oldest publications, and it has played a very important role in the Diaspora in preserving Armenian identity and maintaining our political direction. I am very pleased to participate in this interview.

In 2018, a colorful revolution took place in Armenia, more precisely, a change of power. The new cadre who came to power promised love, tolerance, justice, security, well-being, but within a short period of time, they demonstrated only the opposite. Today, we are witnessing a period of profound hatred and division in Armenia. From a security perspective, we have been a complete failure; the enemy is within the territory of Armenia, 75-percent of Artsakh is under enemy occupation and what remains of Artsakh has been under siege for the past four months. And it is unnecessary to talk about democracy and justice, because they do not actually exist.

With those mottos, people assumed power; however, they moved away from their declared goals. But even so, there was excitement in Armenia and the Diaspora regarding the change of power, given the promises that were made and the widespread belief on part of the population. There is great disappointment now. What did the opposition do? The work of the opposition before the war was very difficult, because people unconditionally believed in the authorities, where no criticism or any dissenting views registered with the population.

In 2019, the ARF was the first entity to organize a public rally against these authorities. The rally was dedicated to Artsakh and carried the slogan “Develop without compromising,” during which time, the threats emanating from the Armenian authorities were voiced in public.

That rally was held on May 23, 2019, when an alert was issued against the Armenian authorities. However, this did not resonate with the public, given the prevailing euphoria surrounding the authorities.

The situation changed after the war. It was clear that the ruling elite needed to leave, to end the cycle of defeat and have a chance to recover, regain our dignity and change the nation’s course.

Unfortunately, the government did not have the foresight to relinquish power. We opted to get on the streets with the people. In that regard, we implemented three initiatives. First, we initiated the “Homeland Salvation Movement,” which was the consolidation of 17 opposition parties and the nomination of a unified candidate for the post of prime minister. Second, during the elections, we turned to the Armenia Alliance and considered the possibility of removing the prime minister, and third, we established the resistance movement, the people’s movement.

The resistance movement is one of the largest and longest-running movements in the modern history of Armenia. The resistance movement addressed important problems: that the current government has no right to lead the country to new concessions; that the surrender of Artsakh is unacceptable to our people; and that there is a resistance movement in the country. However, the resistance movement did not achieve its most important goal, which was to change the government and prevent all this. The opposition must reevaluate its previous path and start fighting anew with more effective means.

H.S.: During the first weeks of the war, was there really an expectation that the authorities of the day would extend a hand of cooperation? Because after the unleashing of the war, an announcement was made that there was no more opposition, simply because the country was at war and there was a protest against the issue of life and death. Did you feel any change during that period, or was it the same situation that continued?

I.S.: During the war, the opposition’s position was very clear. On the first day, all the opposition forces confirmed that they would put aside all differences and stand in solidarity with the state. The opposition showed exceptional unity and solidarity in those days. On October 16, we held a meeting with the initiative to create an emergency response center with the participation of former presidents, prime ministers, defense ministers and foreign ministers of the republic to unite their forces and fight for our homeland with a united front. In other words, the opposition demonstrated an exemplary attitude, but unfortunately its outstretched hand was not met by the government.

H.S.: Does the Supreme Body of the ARF, having reviewed the events in the past three years after the war, believe that different results could have been achieved should there have been other authorities leading the homeland during the war, having demonstrated a different approach and managed the affairs of the nation differently?

I.S.: Definitely. Nikol Pashinyan will always say that regardless of who was in power, the outcome of the war would have been the same. Even after the war, whoever was in power would not have had the opportunity to change anything. Of course, Mr. Pashinyan has been engaged in deception. Had we had a national government, we would not have been saddled with the results of the war, as we are today, and had Mr. Pashinyan been removed from power and replaced with a normal government, then we would not have had the losses of the past two and a half years. The defeated government is unable, and at times does not even have the desire, to organize the security of our country and its citizens.

H.S.: Is there a difference in the attitudes and mentality between the population of Yerevan and the border villages regarding the developments that have happened in Armenia and Artsakh?

I.S.: Border residents with the enemy in close proximity feel the danger on their skin. In Yerevan, there is a significant conscious segment of the society that understands the dangers, but there is also an indifferent segment that does not believe any misfortune will befall them. The population in the regions who have already lost their pastures and have shown resistance against the enemy and have survived certainly feel that danger.

H.S.: Recently, some Azerbaijani soldiers reached the vicinity of Sisian. They have moved kilometers into Armenia, and no one has noticed. Fortunately, no harm was done to the family whose door the infiltrators knocked on, but the concern is whether we have come to a point where our borders are unprotected, and the residents of Yerevan, happily enjoying life, do not realize what is happening.

I.S.: Unfortunately, this government has abandoned its mission to protect the borders of the Republic of Armenia and asks the people to meet all the wishes of the enemy in order to achieve peace. Of course, the enemy is not coming in peace, rather planning a new genocide.

We referenced this during the days of the resistance movement in July. Since then, we continuously discussed that if the Berdzor region is surrendered to the enemy again, then they will reach Tegh village, where a new frontline needs to be built.

It is necessary to be ready for that day. To begin with, the lands should not be handed over, and if they must be handed over, then the border line should be fixed, whereas the government of the day has done nothing to that effect. That is why the enemy has strolled into Armenian territory, for which only the government of the day is guilty and responsible.

H.S.: The western world has gradually started to show more interest in Armenia and Artsakh and wants to enter the political process at any cost. We are also informed that you will have meetings with major states, especially the ambassadors of France and other key countries. Do we expect any tangible results from these meetings?

I.S.: The purpose of these meetings is to present our points of view and listen to theirs. In the course of our foreign relations, we present our views and ideas in detail. However, in this situation, it is very important that the state leads the state policy. We present an alternative point of view and fight for it; however, they must be followed by the state, and unfortunately, the points of view between us and the state or the government of the day are vastly different.

H.S.: How do you imagine the ARF’s participation in the current government and after?

I.S.: The ARF has ruled out becoming a part of the Pashinyan government, as this is impossible. At one time, in 2018, we did that experiment. We emphasized that the people have a demand and an expectation, and that’s why we decided to be a part of the government, and we tried to fulfill those demands with our capabilities. That mission lasted only four months, and it became clear to us that Mr. Pashinyan had a very different agenda.

Now, it is impossible, as our ideas are completely different, especially in terms of the future of the country; therefore, we will not be able to work with this government.

I confirm the statements that it is necessary to unite; however, it is impossible to do so with Mr. Pashinyan, as he has shown no desire to fight for our country. This is a Turkophile government, and in this situation, it is impossible for us to be a part of this government.

H.S.: The latest incidents in Yerevan serve to obfuscate the main issue. Do the recent issues with Mher Sahakyan, Karen Mkrticyan and the despicable behavior of the Speaker of the Armenian Parliament Alen Simonyan resonate with the population? Do they not realize that the current government needs to be removed from power?

I.S.: These people always talk about democracy and the need for government officials to behave with proper decorum, yet their behavior has breached all boundaries of decency and normal, dignified behavior. Their arrogance has no bounds. This government has demonstrated brazen disregard, for in its behavior and glory, it has brought calamity and loss of life to Armenia, yet it continues to remain in power. They are not spitting in the face of a single soul, but in the face of a millennia-old people. 

H.S.: We probably have the youngest yet lifeless district in the world in Yerablur. The families of those in this lifeless district are alive and number in the thousands. Would they come together to express their anger and demand justice?

I.S.: This is a profound question. Not everyone in Armenia thinks Mr. Pashinyan is the cause of these misfortunes and disasters and that there will be an opportunity to solve these problems after removing the current regime. The trouble is that he has been able to deceive people with his propaganda machine, falsifications and fraud that he has done everything within his powers. He has convinced the people that he is not guilty and that the war would have had no other outcome, in the sense that whoever was in power would have gotten the same result.

In other words, there is an extremist segment of the population that strongly believes in Mr. Pashinyan. Additionally, the whole society is still not of the opinion that he is the one who has brought this level of loss and tragedy to Armenia. Therefore, we have a responsibility to inform the people.

H.S.: Armenia has turned into a police state where the police are stronger and better paid than the army. Do you think you are being followed at all times?

I.S.: Opposition figures in Armenia are subjected to serious pressure from the authorities. The government is working against us and our families, friends and the party. However, none of this will hinder us. We know who we are dealing with and what we are fighting for. Therefore, those pressures are transitory and will not last long.

H.S.: How big is this externally orchestrated conspiracy against Armenia, and how can we dismantle this and address our issues?

I.S.: The first step to call the hands of all the players is to change the government. These external forces make their calculations in coordination with the current government in Armenia. Once there is a change of power in Armenia, everyone’s playing cards will be reshuffled, and the prevailing atmosphere will also change.

I repeat again that the government continuously tries to convince the people that they are weak, incapable, defenseless, that the world is against them and they should acquiesce to the enemy, meet all their demands and hand over everything they demand.

We reject this approach and propose to fight. We are not alone in our struggle. We have allies and sources, and we also believe that the only way to achieve peace is to fight for it.

If there is a change of power in Armenia, the agreement between external forces and Mr. Pashinyan will be null and void, and the situation will change in favor of our state and our people. 

H.S.: Besides financial support, how else can the Diaspora establish close ties with Armenia?

I.S.: The Diaspora has great potential, and today Armenia is consistently pushing the Diaspora away from it. You hear the _expression_ that they are responsible only for the Republic of Armenia and the citizens of the Republic of Armenia; that is, they have put aside the pan-Armenian spirit and the Armenian nation. The Diaspora should respond and confirm that it stands up for its homeland, that this homeland belongs to them as well, not just the citizens of the Republic of Armenia living in Armenia, but also for 10 million Armenians worldwide. Of course, this assumes both rights and duties. The Diaspora should have full access to those rights and obligations. There are many ways to help the homeland: political, economic and the defense of the nation. It is necessary to work on all these fronts.

H.S.: In light of your current visit, what do you have to convey to American Armenians?

I.S.: I had an interesting and full agenda during this visit to the eastern and western US in 10 short days. I had meetings in all regions; the most important were meetings with my fellow party members, where I had the opportunity to reflect and explain the current situation in Armenia and Artsakh, as well as listen and answer questions.

I held important public meetings, as well as political meetings with the ANCA. I try not to be away from Armenia for more than two or three days, but America was an exception. The Diaspora’s work is important to me and part of my visit agenda: how we should consolidate our forces, how we should focus and how we should take control of our homeland.

There is a question of re-evaluating the Diaspora after the war with a new vision, because the Diaspora is very different before and after the war. The Commissioner of the Diaspora is entrusted with the duty of dividing the Diaspora and not to carry out real work in the Diaspora. The Diaspora has serious work ahead and a number of difficulties to overcome.

Armenia and its Diaspora should strengthen each other. Together, with 10 million Armenians, we must move forward with the vision of restoring the trinity of Armenia-Artsakh-Diaspora.

I would like to thank our compatriots in the Diaspora and repeat that the authorities in Armenia do not represent the nation, and given the prevailing situation, we should not be disappointed in Armenia. We should not lose hope, as these are all temporary, and we must support the homeland.

Ishkhan Saghatelyan with ARF-ER Central Committee members and ARF members from New England, April 15, 2023