Armenia, Azerbaijan won’t sign peace treaty on June 1

MEHR News Agency, Iran

TEHRAN, May 29 (MNA) – Armenia and Azerbaijan haven’t yet agreed on a peace treaty that could be signed on the sidelines of the European Political Community summit in Chisinau on June 1, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan said.

Nikol Pashinyan made the remarks at the country’s parliament on Monday.

There was a discussion if the peace treaty could be signed when the European Council president, the French president, the German chancellor, the Azerbaijani president and Pashinyan meet in Chisinau, according to the Armenian prime minister.

“I must say we haven’t received answers to the fourth package of our proposals to Azerbaijan. To date, there’s no agreed package that could be signed,” he said.

The Armenian prime minister also said that he was dissatisfied with the results of talks with Russia that took place in Moscow on May 25 regarding the lifting of the Lachin corridor blockade.

“I would like to note that one of the issues of the discussion was related to the humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh and the illegal blockade of the Lachin corridor. We discussed this issue with our colleagues from Russia. I cannot say that the results of this discussion are satisfactory. It is a very sad situation that the closure of the Lachin corridor occurred in the presence of Russian peacekeepers. We will continue negotiations with our Russian partners to resolve this situation,” TASS quoted him as saying.

Pashinyan also commented on some statements by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, adding that Yerevan was starting to doubt Baku’s commitment to the agreements that were reached in Brussels on May 14.

MP/PR

https://en.mehrnews.com/news/201347/Armenia-Azerbaijan-won-t-sign-peace-treaty-on-June-1

Normalizing relations with Turkey high on Armenia’s agenda

MEHR News Agency, Iran

TEHRAN, May 29 (MNA) – Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has said he is hoping to normalize relations with Turkey after the Turkish presidential election.

“Hopefully, we will be able to normalize Armenian-Turkish relations after the presidential election in Turkey. I also hope we can carry on with normalizing our relations with Turkey in a natural way. This is high on our agenda,” Pashinyan said in parliament on Monday, Interfax News reported.

Peace is the only guarantee of external security, Pashinyan said. “There is no other way to guarantee external security,” he said.

Pashinyan congratulated Recep Tayyip Erdogan on winning the Turkish presidential election on Sunday.

“We congratulate President Erdogan on reelection. I am looking forward to continuing our joint work until full normalization of relations between our countries,” Pashinyan said on a social network.

RHM/PR

Two Armenian soldiers detained after allegedly crossing into Azerbaijan

 

Armenian and Azerbaijani posts by the Sotk gold mine. Image via TASS.

Baku accused two Armenian soldiers of crossing the border into Azerbaijan on Friday to mount ‘sabotage’ operations. Following the soldiers’ detention, Yerevan accused Baku of abducting the two soldiers inside Armenian territory.

On 26 May, Azerbaijan’s State Border Service announced that they had detained two Armenian servicemen, Harut Hovagimyan and Karen Ghazaryan, in Azerbaijan’s southwestern district of Zangilan.

The border service has claimed that the two soldiers were members of a larger ‘sabotage group’ whose other members were able to avoid capture by taking advantage of the local terrain.

The following day, the state border service and the General Prosecutor’s Office stated that Hovagimyan and Ghazaryan were charged with illegal smuggling of arms and ammunition, illegal possession of weapons, terrorism, participating in actions aimed at inciting national enmity, and illegal border-crossing.

Armenia’s Ministry of Defence was quick to deny carrying out sabotage operations in Azerbaijan, stating that the two soldiers were transporting food to combat positions on Armenia’s southern border with Azerbaijan. 

Armenia’s Investigative Committee accused Azerbaijan of abducting the two servicemen from Armenian territory.

Last month, two Azerbaijani soldiers entered Armenia after reportedly getting lost due to poor visibility near the country’s border with Nakhchivan.

The two Azerbaijani soldiers were detained a week apart and stand accused of illegally crossing into Armenia. One of the two soldiers is additionally accused of murdering a 56-year-old security guard in Syunik.

https://oc-media.org/two-armenian-soldiers-detained-after-allegedly-crossing-into-azerbaijan/

​Armenia PM Dissatisfied with Results of Talks with Russia on Lachin Corridor

TASNIM News Agency, Iran

Armenia PM Dissatisfied with Results of Talks with Russia on Lachin Corridor

May, 29, 2023 

TEHRAN (Tasnim) – Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan is not satisfied with the results of the May 25 talks with his Russian counterparts in Moscow on unblocking the Lachin corridor.

“I note that one of the topics of discussion was related to the current humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh and the illegal blockade of the Lachin corridor. We’ve discussed this issue with our Russian colleagues,” he said on Monday, speaking in parliament.

“I can’t say that the results of this discussion are satisfactory. It is very sad that the closure of the Lachin corridor took place in the presence of Russian peacekeepers,” he added, TASS reported.

“We will continue to negotiate with our Russian partners in order to resolve this situation,” he stated.

The Azerbaijan-Armenia peace talks: Lessons from Israel and Egypt.

GERALD M. STEINBERG

On a recent visit to Azerbaijan to participate in an academic conference organized by Ada University in Baku, Azerbaijan, I heard echoes of Israeli-Egyptian history.

Coincidentally, our conference took place at the same time that unprecedented direct talks between officials from Azerbaijan and Armenia were being conducted in Washington.

The meeting between the foreign ministers of the two countries, hosted by U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, marked an important preliminary step towards ending the conflict between them. At the end of the meeting, Blinken declared, “The two sides have discussed some very tough issues over the last few days, and they’ve made tangible progress on a durable peace agreement.”

In addition, and perhaps more importantly, Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev and Armenia’s Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan met in Brussels on May 14 under the auspices of the European Union. A summit between the two leaders suggests a readiness to proceed to serious negotiations.

Although every international conflict has unique characteristics, there are important similarities between the Azerbaijan-Armenia and the Israeli-Egyptian conflicts, including ancient animosities, religious and cultural differences, and contested territory. In addition, the involvement of outside powers with their own interests is a complicating factor.

In both conflicts, the exploration of the potential for a negotiated resolution that satisfies the vital interests of the two parties followed a series of very costly wars and, in the language of conflict management, “a mutually hurting stalemate.”

For Israel and Egypt, exhaustion after the bitter war of 1973 (following earlier clashes in 1948, 1956 and 1967) led both countries to cooperate with U.S. Secretary of State Henry Kissinger in the first direct talks between officials from Cairo and Jerusalem. These talks produced two disengagement agreements that opened the door for broader peace negotiations.

In 2020, the 44-day war between Azerbaijan and Armenia, which followed over 30 years of conflict, ended with Baku recapturing much of the Karabakh region following a successful campaign based on heavy use of drones and other advanced technology.

However, the ceasefire lines left the countries dependent on one another for access to areas where citizens from the other side continue to live. This aspect, as well as ongoing military incidents mainly targeting Azerbaijanis, highlights the fragility of the situation and the need to go further. In many ways, this is similar to the Egyptian-Israeli status quo after the ceasefire and disengagement agreements.

The process of turning a fragile ceasefire into a permanent and cooperative peace treaty was launched by Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin and Egyptian President Anwar Sadat.

As I documented in a recent book on the topic, shortly after the Israeli elections in 1977 that brought Begin to power after three decades in opposition, he and Sadat began to exchange exploratory messages and sent emissaries to explore the potential for finding common ground sufficient to reach an agreement.

When these assurances were received, Sadat decided to come to Israel to meet directly with Begin, and less than 18 months later, the terms of the treaty were finalized. Based on the framework of “land for peace,” Israel agreed to dismantle settlements in the Sinai as an interim measure, and Egypt agreed to end the state of war that had existed since 1948, normalize relations with Israel and establish cooperative security measures.

On the territorial issue, the legal status of the Sinai Peninsula and Karabakh are somewhat similar. In 1967, in a defensive war, Israel captured the Sinai from Egypt, but internationally as well as in Israel, the area was considered Egyptian sovereign territory. The Armenian conquest of Karabakh during the collapse of the Soviet Union (not in a defensive military operation) and its recovery by Azerbaijan in the 2020 war did not result in a change in the recognition of this region as part of Azerbaijan, including by the U.S.

Throughout the detailed negotiations, Begin and Sadat demonstrated the importance of leadership in overcoming obstacles, including from domestic opponents who highlighted the risks and downplayed the benefits of reaching an agreement.

Begin’s perception of the issues and his strategy of negotiation, as reflected in Israeli documents and transcripts from the negotiations, highlight his political realism, placing the national interest over the ideological emphasis for which he was known before becoming prime minister.

No peace process is without significant costs, and at each stage of the discussions with the Egyptian leader, Begin and his advisors carefully weighed the potential risks and benefits of the different options, particularly towards the end, when the most difficult decisions were taken.

A major concern was that Egypt would use the gains from the peace agreement, including American weapons, to prepare for another war, but Begin viewed this scenario as unlikely and exceeded by the gains for Israel resulting from a peace agreement.

For Azerbaijan and Armenia, the current geostrategic status points to the logic of moving towards a peace process and winding down the conflict. For Armenia to overcome its isolation and dire economic situation, a rapprochement with Azerbaijan is vital. For Azerbaijan, while the threat from Armenia has decreased following the 2020 war, the threat from Iran and efforts to undermine its security and independence are increasing.

At the Ada University conference, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev described relations with Iran as “at the lowest level ever,” as reflected by a series of terror attacks “organized on a governmental level” (rejecting the Iranian regime’s claims that these were the acts of individuals). In this environment, Baku needs to focus on countering the Iranian threat.

The Israel-Egypt case also provides important insights on the roles of third-party facilitators and mediators as well as “spoilers” who seek to disrupt the negotiations. At times, the U.S. government, led by President Jimmy Carter, provided assistance in overcoming obstacles, first at the Camp David summit where the framework for a treaty was negotiated, and then a few months later, when the details were finalized.

American security guarantees and financial aid packages gave Sadat and Begin additional side-benefits to offset the risks they were taking in making concessions. But at other times, Carter and other American officials created obstacles, such as when they sought to involve the Soviet Union and PLO leader Yasser Arafat under the illusion that with them, a “comprehensive agreement” was feasible.

After expelling thousands of Soviet “military advisors” from Egypt a few years earlier, Sadat had no interest in inviting the Kremlin to return, and both he and Begin understood that spoilers would create divisiveness to promote their own agendas.

In response, Israel and Egypt detoured around the White House, opening their own direct channels of communication and keeping the spoilers out.

The circumstances for Azerbaijan and Armenia are different, but the leaders will need to watch the American and European mediation efforts for agendas that divert the focus from the shared objectives.

Like the Soviet Union 40 years ago, Russia under Vladimir Putin can be expected to act as a spoiler, using force and threats to maintain influence. At the end of the 2020 war, an Iskander missile was launched against Baku to coerce Azerbaijan into accepting a Russian “peacekeeping force” stationed strategically in Karabakh. (The missile was reportedly intercepted by an Israeli-made defense system.)

Russia continues to be directly involved in supporting and arming Armenia, including maintaining bases in its territory and moving invisible arms shipments overland from Iran through this area. However, Russia’s power has been reduced by the morass in Ukraine and the failures of its weapons in the 2020 conflict with Azerbaijan, giving Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan room to maneuver.

When two countries enter negotiations following difficult wars, there are never any guarantees regarding the outcome. Around the world, numerous peace efforts have failed when one or more of the leaders was either unable or unwilling to make concessions and take the calculated risks necessary to satisfy the basic requirements of the other side. Attempts to duplicate the successful Israel-Egypt negotiations in the cases of Syria and between Palestinians and Israel have collapsed repeatedly, in large part reflecting the absence of leadership.

After decades of bitter conflict, the obstacles to an agreement between Azerbaijan and Armenia should not be underestimated. Success depends on the ability of the leaders to negotiate an agreement that would benefit both countries. Four decades ago, Begin and Sadat demonstrated that this was possible.

Originally published by the .

Lessons from Israeli-Egyptian Peace Talks for Azerbaijan-Armenia Conflict

Egypt –
By Ahmad El-Assasy

The Israeli-Egyptian peace treaty signed in 1979 can serve as an example for resolving the Azerbaijan-Armenia conflict that has lasted for over 30 years. 

The peace process between Israel and Egypt, which ended the state of war that existed since 1948, normalized relations, established embassies, and transportation links, can provide insights for resolving the territorial issue between Azerbaijan and Armenia. 

A recent meeting between foreign ministers of the two countries hosted by the US Secretary of State marked an important preliminary step towards ending the conflict. Leadership, third-party facilitators, and mediators played crucial roles in the Israeli-Egyptian peace talks, but spoilers can disrupt negotiations.

 The leaders of Azerbaijan and Armenia must focus on the shared objectives and watch out for agendas that divert attention. 

Success depends on their ability to negotiate an agreement that benefits both countries.

New EU-funded ‘Maestro’ application in Armenia makes classical music education more accessible

‘Maestro’, a new application to make learning classical music more attractive and enjoyable has been launched in Armenia, developed by professional musicians Lucy Bichakhchyan and Arus Nazaryan as part of the EU-funded Artbox programme.

“Traditional methods of music education can sometimes seem dry and unappealing. These methods discourage young people, and they lose interest in music over time. That is why, while developing the application, we strived to create a game through which people can easily connect with the history and basics of classical music,” say the app’s creators.

The ‘Artbox’ programme helped the musicians fully visualise their idea and turn it into a business, understand its shortcomings, and find the best possible solutions.

The app offers many opportunities to enhance the user’s musical knowledge, including conversations with famous musicians, interactive games, music theory lessons and ear training exercises. The app is designed for anyone who loves music and wants to learn more about it, from beginners to experienced musicians. It will soon be available for the visually and hearing impaired, with text-to-speech and closed captioning options.

The ‘Artbox’ programme was developed by ‘Creative Armenia’ and is implemented in Armenia with funding from the European Union and in cooperation with AGBU Armenia within the framework of the ‘Katapult’ creative acceleration programme.

Find out more

Press release

Armenia, Azerbaijan won’t sign peace treaty in Chisinau on June 1 — Pashinyan

 TASS 
Russia –
Nikol Pashinyan also commented on some statements by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, adding that Yerevan was starting to doubt Baku’s commitment to the agreements that were reached in Brussels on May 14

YEREVAN, May 29. /TASS/. Armenia and Azerbaijan haven’t yet agreed on a peace treaty that could be signed on the sidelines of the European Political Community summit in Chisinau on June 1, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan said at the country’s parliament on Monday.

There was a discussion if the peace treaty could be signed when the European Council president, the French president, the German chancellor, the Azerbaijani president and Pashinyan meet in Chisinau, the Armenian prime minister said.

“I must say we haven’t received answers to the fourth package of our proposals to Azerbaijan. To date, there’s no agreed package that could be signed,” he said.

The Armenian prime minister also said that he was dissatisfied with the results of talks with Russia that took place in Moscow on May 25 regarding the lifting of the Lachin corridor blockade.

“I would like to note that one of the issues of the discussion was related to the humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh and the illegal blockade of the Lachin corridor. We discussed this issue with our colleagues from Russia. I cannot say that the results of this discussion are satisfactory. It is a very sad situation that the closure of the Lachin corridor occurred in the presence of Russian peacekeepers. We will continue negotiations with our Russian partners to resolve this situation,” he said.

Pashinyan also commented on some statements by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, adding that Yerevan was starting to doubt Baku’s commitment to the agreements that were reached in Brussels on May 14.

Armenia doesn’t have territorial claims against any neighbor, including Azerbaijan – Vice Speaker

Save

Share

 14:03, 24 May 2023

YEREVAN, MAY 24, ARMENPRESS. Armenia has no territorial claims against any of its neighbors, including Azerbaijan, the Vice Speaker of Parliament of Armenia Hakob Arshakyan has said.

“Armenia proceeds from the position that we don’t have any territorial demand from any neighbor, including Azerbaijan, This means that we need to clarify the state borders and the territories which belong to our states. The issue is about the approaches of the logic of the peace treaty, the issue is about clarifying the principles. When we speak about numbers, we speak about exactness,” Arshakyan said. 

He added that in this context the Nagorno Karabakh issue is perceived within these approaches in a way that an international format must be created around the rights and security of the Armenians of Nagorno Karabakh and Stepanakert and Baku must launch dialogue.

“When the people of Artsakh [Nagorno Karabakh] speak about their rights and security, it means that they are present around the negotiation table, and our entire negotiation logic in this regard changed when they were absent from the negotiation table. The moment President Robert Kocharyan started negotiating not only on behalf of Armenia but also Artsakh, it indirectly turned out that Armenia has a territorial dispute which Azerbaijan. Now we are saying that we don’t have a territorial dispute with Azerbaijan. Meaning, we reciprocally recognize each other’s territorial integrity, and then international mechanisms are launched, which are responsible for coordinating dialogue between Nagorno Karabakh and Azerbaijan and guarantees of the rights and security of the Armenians of Nagorno Karabakh,” Arshakyan said.