Azerbaijan and Iran Face Off Over Armenia, Israel


Czech Republic –

With the South Caucasus still bubbling in the wake of the 2020 war, Tehran is stirring the pot with strategic aims in mind.

Iranian-Azerbaijani relations, or, more precisely, the steady rise in tension between Tehran and Baku, has been a key development in South Caucasus politics for the past two years. As events early in 2023 have shown, this confrontation has reached a fundamentally new level, altering the balance of interests in the region and making it necessary to seriously assess the risk of a new military conflict.

The contradictions between the two countries suddenly reached boiling point on the morning of 27 January, when news broke of an attack on the Azerbaijani Embassy in Tehran. The inaction of the Iranian police and the whitewashed official version – alleging a retaliatory action with family motives – caused a wave of indignation in Azerbaijan. Baku officially dubbed the attack “an act of terror” and demanded its speedy investigation, while also indefinitely suspending operations at the embassy. The continued closure of the embassy (although a consulate in Tabriz still functions) has, in effect, reduced the level of bilateral relations.

Anti-Baku Campaign Breaks Out on Two Fronts

In the following two months, Iranian media connected to the security elite intensified openly anti-Azerbaijani reports. These included denial of Azerbaijan’s history independent of Iran, personal attacks on its leadership, and claims of Iran’s military superiority.

Intriguingly, a rare armed incident of unclear origin occurred in Baku during this time. After an assassination attempt on Fazil Mustafa, a member of the Azerbaijani parliament known for his pro-Turkish views and criticism of Iran, four suspects were detained and accused of carrying out the attack on political orders. This was soon followed by a series of anti-Azerbaijani moves in Iran, including the expulsion of four Iranian diplomats accused of espionage. Verbal exchanges between the two governments resulted in a conversation between their foreign ministers, followed by conciliatory remarks from officials on both sides, including an article by an influential international affairs adviser to Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, Ali Akbar Velayati, calling for good neighborly relations to be maintained.

The fundamental question today is this: why did the Iranian leadership, unlike in numerous previous diplomatic disputes, decide to consistently raise the stakes, while Baku accepted this challenge without apparent difficulties?

Several factors have contributed to this situation. While Moscow and Tehran have a longstanding strategic partnership, Russia’s physical presence in the region has acted as a counterweight to Iranian ambitions in the South Caucasus. However, with Russia’s weakening position due to its involvement in Ukraine, Turkey and Western countries have become more active, potentially loosening Iran’s role in the region. This includes the efforts of the United States and European Union to broker a lasting settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict since Azerbaijan recaptured much of the disputed territory in the 2020 war with Armenia. 

Such engagement in the region concerns Iran’s leadership because of the potential loss of its leverage amid increased Western influence – not to mention possible morale-boosting effects for Iranian Azerbaijanis hoping that Azerbaijan will be able to solidify the gains of the war. This has led to Iran behaving more aggressively, a development that may also be related to the recent achievement of an agreement with Saudi Arabia to restore diplomatic relations and de-escalate tensions, reducing the pressure on Tehran and increasing the potential to act elsewhere.

Tehran Reaches Out to Armenia

Baku is increasingly frustrated with Iran’s hostile rhetoric under the Ebrahim Raisi government, leading to heightened reactions to any misunderstandings. The lack of trust between the leaders is a significant factor in foreign policy, and Azerbaijan is concerned about Iranian activity toward Armenia, particularly as peace negotiations carry on in Washington, Brussels, and to some extent in Moscow.

For these reasons, unambiguous signals sent from Tehran meant for Armenian ears, including statements such as “Iran will not tolerate a change of borders in the region” (by which in Armenia they usually mean the opening of a road linking Azerbaijan with Turkey through Armenian territory in Zangezur) and the opening of an Iranian consulate in the border town of Kapan, did little to calm Azerbaijani nerves. On 9 April, Armenian Security Council Secretary Armen Grigoryan was received in Tehran by his Iranian counterpart Ali Shamkhani (recently dismissed), a man who is considered the main protagonist in the successful negotiations with Saudi Arabia.

Iran’s sale of drones to the Russian army, though inferior to Turkish and Israeli models, also alarmed Baku because of their affordability and the ease of replenishing them, stoking concerns about Iran’s expanding influence in Armenia if it were to provide weapons to Yerevan, a prospect that Armenian supporters of rapprochement with Tehran have raised.

Factoring Israel Into the Equation

The matter of Israel and its strategic partnership with Azerbaijan undoubtedly plays a big role in Iran’s confrontational policy. Even if the ghost of “international Zionism” on the Iranian border plays the role of a convenient bogeyman for the regime’s propaganda, allowing it to significantly increase the popularity of anti-Azerbaijani rhetoric, relations between Azerbaijan and Israel are objectively a bone in Tehran’s throat.

Tehran University professor Ali Bigdeli’s remark in a recent interview that Israel could launch attacks against Iran from Azerbaijani territory echoes the position of most of the Iranian elite. These fears climbed significantly after the January attack by Israeli drones on military installations in Isfahan, a city in central Iran. 

Despite a longstanding friendship with Israel, Azerbaijan has been cautious not to provoke its southern neighbor unless necessary. The Azerbaijani Embassy in Tel Aviv was opened only recently, after Baku grew even more frustrated with Tehran’s more aggressive stance. Israeli President Isaac Herzog’s unambiguous remark about the “common threat” to the two countries during his visit to Baku on 30 May underlined their shared belief that Iran represents the major threat to peace and security in the region.

Domestic factors within Iranian policy, alongside geopolitical considerations, contribute significantly to the rise in tensions. Recent events have intensified the internal struggle among influential groups within Iran’s power elite. The Revolutionary Guard, once a regime watchdog, now operates as an alternative elite with its own interests, often diverging from the Supreme Leader and clergy. This group takes a hawkish stance and exhibits hostility toward Azerbaijan, viewing the country as part of Iran’s rightful hegemony. Despite disagreements, Khamenei’s tacit approval of the Guard’s hardline stance recognizes the force’s crucial role in the conduct of the regime’s foreign policy and its very survival.

Iran’s tightening of policy toward Azerbaijan, up to balancing on the brink of an open conflict, is the expected result of its complex internal dynamics, given Tehran’s historical attitude toward its northern neighbor as a kind of “Iranian Ukraine” (a historically and culturally close country that has chosen a sharply different path of development and pursues an independent foreign policy).

The outlook for the Iranian-Azerbaijani confrontation remains unclear, with concerns of a direct military conflict and Iranian intervention in border areas. Given the full-scale war in Ukraine, such forecasts should be taken seriously. However, there is a high probability of both parties scaling back and avoiding further escalation. Experts suggest that Iran typically acts discreetly rather than following its loud rhetoric. Moreover, considering the significant number of Iranian Azerbaijanis (according to various estimates, they number from 17 to 25 million, far outnumbering the 10 million total population of Azerbaijan, and make up the majority in regions directly adjacent to Azerbaijan) and Iran’s dependence on Azerbaijan in key areas like the “North-South” Eurasian transit corridor, military escalation is highly unlikely.

Iran’s aggressive behavior toward Baku aligns with a global trend seen during the Ukrainian war, where various actors exploit the West’s focus on the conflict to advance their own interests. This pattern can be observed with China, India, Saudi Arabia, Turkey, and others. For Iran, threatening Baku serves as a means to pressure the West, creating a major clash of interests in the South Caucasus that becomes a headache for Western powers. This tactic aims to influence the negotiations on reviving and bringing Washington back on board the stalled 2015 deal for international monitoring of Iran’s nuclear program, prompting a revision of the longstanding policy of isolating Iran.

…

Murad Muradov is the co-founder and deputy director of the Topchubashov Center, a Baku-based international affairs think tank. His areas of expertise cover security and geopolitics in the South Caucasus and post-Soviet countries and international political economy.

https://tol.org/client/article/azerbaijan-and-iran-face-off-over-armenia-israel.html

The Vatican’s other peace mission

ANALYSIS

 . 9:09 PM  

The man sometimes called the Vatican’s “prime minister” is on a peace mission this week. But unlike the Ukraine war initiative led by the Vatican envoy Cardinal Matteo Zuppi, it probably won’t generate many headlines.  

In fact, you may struggle to find any reports on it at all. As of July 11, the Vatican’s in-house media doesn’t seem to have mentioned it. And it doesn’t appear on the Twitter account of the Vatican’s Secretariat of State, the hub of the Holy See’s diplomatic activity. 

But if you comb through government press releases and specialist Italian Catholic websites, you will see that Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin is currently on a trip to Azerbaijan and Armenia.

Azerbaijan and Armenia are located in the Caucasus region, where Europe and Asia meet. But that is where the commonalities between the two countries seem to end. 

Azerbaijan is a majority Muslim country of around 10 million people. It is almost three times larger than the majority Christian Armenia, which has a population of less than three million. 

Since the last years of the Cold War, the two countries have been locked in post-Soviet Eurasia’s most enduring conflict. 

Fighting has broken out periodically since 1998 over the disputed territory of Nagorno-Karabakh, which is situated within Azerbaijan but populated by ethnic Armenians. The area is home to the breakaway state known as the Republic of Artsakh, which is closely tied to Armenia.

A upsurge in violence in 2020, in which both sides used loitering munitions (also known as “kamikaze drones”), is believed to have ushered in a new era of warfare dominated by deadly autonomous machines — as seen in Ukraine today.

Hundreds of soldiers were killed in the most recent major clashes at the Armenia-Azerbaijan border in September 2022, which ended with an uneasy ceasefire. 

Shortly afterward, purported environmental activists blocked the Lachin corridor, the sole road linking Armenia with Nagorno-Karabakh. Human rights groups have said that the blockade is creating a humanitarian crisis in the disputed region. 

Since his election in 2013, Pope Francis has often shown his concern over the ongoing feud between the two nations. His sensitivity to the 35-year conflict possibly dates back to his years as Archbishop of Buenos Aires, when he was said to have maintained close ties with the local Armenian community.

In 2016, Francis visited both nations on separate trips, traveling to Armenia on June 24-26 and Azerbaijan on Oct. 2. In recent months, he has repeatedly expressed his anguish over the deteriorating humanitarian situation connected to the Lachin corridor blockade.

It is against this background that Cardinal Parolin began his five-day trip to the neighboring countries.

On July 10, Parolin met with Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev. According to the president’s website, the two men reviewed the deepening of ties between Azerbaijan in the Holy See in recent years.

Steps forward have included Aliyev’s 2020 visit to the Vatican, the opening of an Azerbaijani embassy to the Holy See in 2021, and the signing that year of a cooperation agreement to restore Rome’s Catacombs of Commodilla between the Vatican and the Heydar Aliyev Foundation, a charitable body led by Azerbaijan’s First Lady Mehriban Aliyeva. 

The cardinal held talks with the country’s foreign minister Jeyhun Bayramov, discussing “the peace process between Azerbaijan and Armenia and the current situation in the region,” according to the Azerbaijan State News Agency.

The agency added that Bayramov told Parolin about the situation following the 2020 conflict, known in Azerbaijan as the “44-day Patriotic War” and by neutrals as the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War (following the first in 1988-1994). The foreign minister highlighted what he called “the crimes, vandalism and destroyed cultural and religious heritage in Azerbaijan’s liberated territories,” as well as “the mine threats and other provocations committed by Armenia.”

On Monday, the cardinal also met with Sheikh Allahshukur Pashazadeh, the Grand Mufti of the Caucasus, who reportedly defended Azerbaijan against accusations that it is destroying Armenian cultural heritage. 

Concerns about the erasure of historic Christian sites in Nagorno-Karabakh have been raised at the European Parliament and the UN’s cultural agency UNESCO.

The Shiite Muslim cleric also decried what he called “Armenian vandalism” of Azerbaijani sites — demonstrating that both sides accuse each other of attacking their patrimony.

In addition, Parolin visited the grave of Heydar Aliyev, Azerbaijan’s president from 1993 to 2003, located in the Alley of Honor, a burial site for distinguished Azerbaijanis in the capital, Baku.

Cardinal Parolin was expected to travel to Armenia July 11 (via neighboring Georgia), remaining there until July 13. He is likely to receive a warm welcome as Armenia — the first country in the world to formally adopt Christianity in 301 A.D. — sees the Vatican as a crucial ally in the preservation of its unique spiritual culture.

As well as meeting with political leaders, the cardinal may be received by Catholicos Karekin II, the head of the ancient Armenian Apostolic Church, which has drawn closer to Rome since 1970 through a series of joint declarations and gestures such as the addition of the Armenian St. Gregory of Narek to the list of Doctors of the Church recognized by Catholics in 2015.

Parolin is also due to lay a wreath at the Armenian Genocide Memorial Complex in the capital, Yerevan, emphasizing the Vatican’s recognition of the systematic destruction of the Armenian community in the Ottoman Empire in 1915-1917. Pope Francis has not hesitated to describe the killing of between 1.2 and 1.5 million Armenians as genocide, despite opposition from Turkey, the republic born out of the ruins of the Ottoman Empire (and a close ally of Azerbaijan).

Parolin is also expected to celebrate a Mass in Gyumri, the country’s second-largest city, which will no doubt be attended by members of the minority Armenian Catholic Church, one of the 23 Eastern Catholic Churches in full communion with the pope.

Even if Parolin’s trip doesn’t produce immediate results, such as an easing of the Lachin corridor crisis, it’s likely to prove a shrewd investment of the Holy See’s diplomatic capital if — or perhaps when— Armenia and Azerbaijan take up arms again.

https://www.pillarcatholic.com/p/the-vaticans-other-peace-mission

Azerbaijan re-blocks crucial road into Nagorno-Karabakh

Al-Mayadeen 

The Azerbaijani authorities add that the border crossing will be closed until the criminal investigation into a smuggling claims is completed.

After Armenia accused Azerbaijan of blocking access to Nagorno-Karabakh, the latter announced on Tuesday that road traffic on the sole road linking Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh has been suspended. 

In a statement, the Azerbaijani border guards said, “Crossing via the Lachin border post is temporarily suspended,” further alleging that the Armenian Red Cross abused the checkpoint for multiple “smuggling attempts”, which the organization denied, insisting that no unauthorized material had been found in its vehicles.

“The ICRC is aware of concerns raised about the transport of unauthorized goods across the Lachin corridor and does not support any such activity,” the Geneva-based organization said in a statement.

“No unauthorized material has been found in any vehicle belonging to ICRC. All cargo is subject to customs checks by the Republic of Azerbaijan.

The Azerbaijani authorities added that the border crossing will be closed until the criminal investigation into the smuggling claims is completed.

Since December, Armenia has consistently accused Azerbaijan of blocking supplies to the Nagorno-Karabakh region and of creating a humanitarian crisis by blocking the Lachin corridor.

Read next: Armenian PM accuses Baku of conducting policy of ethnic cleansing

Back in February, the top UN court, which rules on international disputes, stated that Baku failed to demonstrate that landmines purportedly planted by Yerevan particularly targeted Azerbaijanis and ordered Azerbaijan to open the road after blocking it.

Armenia and Azerbaijan fought two conflicts over the Armenian-populated area of Nagorno-Karabakh, one in 2020 and one in the 1990s, and now are quarreling over the corridor.

Six weeks of violence in the autumn of 2020 claimed over 6,500 lives and ended with a ceasefire accord sponsored by Russia. Russia sent 2,000 peacekeepers to monitor the truce, but tensions remain despite a ceasefire deal.

Nevertheless, Kremlin Spokesperson Dmitry Peskov stressed earlier that there is “no alternative” to the ceasefire deal his country brokered in 2020, while Russia’s Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov added that the Russian peacekeeping units were “clearly fulfilling its tasks” despite operating in “very difficult conditions.”




Obstructing the supply of ICRC humanitarian goods by Azerbaijan is a war crime. Artsakh MFA

 20:09,

YEREVAN, 12 JULY, ARMENPRESS. The Foreign Ministry of Artsakh issued a statement regarding Azerbaijan’s obstruction of the movement of vehicles of the International Committee of the Red Cross through the Lachin Corridor, stressing that Azerbaijan is obliged not to obstruct the delivery of humanitarian goods to the besieged Artsakh. Violation of this obligation is a serious violation of the provisions of the Geneva Conventions and is qualified as a war crime.

ARMENPRESS reports, the statement of the Artsakh Foreign Ministry stated:

“On 11 July, the Azerbaijani side once again blocked the movement of the ICRC vehicles through the illegally established checkpoint in the Lachin Corridor, thereby grossly violating both the norms of international humanitarian law and Azerbaijan’s own obligations under the Trilateral Statement of 9 November 2020 and the ICJ orders of 22 February and 6 July 2023. The fact that Azerbaijan justifies this unlawful and inhumane act by alleging the transportation of “unauthorised items” such as mobile phones, cigarettes and fuel on ICRC vehicles only proves the ongoing transport, food and energy blockade of Artsakh and the acute shortage of essential goods, as well as Baku’s hostile and inhumane attitude towards the people of Artsakh. 
 
We reiterate that in accordance with the norms of international humanitarian law, Azerbaijan has an obligation not to impede the delivery of humanitarian cargo to besieged Artsakh. Violating this obligation constitutes a serious breach of the provisions of the Geneva Conventions and qualifies as a war crime. 
 
While acknowledging the ICRC’s statement of 11 July regarding this matter, it is also necessary to emphasise that Azerbaijan’s actions directly violate the Trilateral Statement signed by the leaders of Armenia, Azerbaijan and Russia, which, among other things, provides for the establishment of the Lachin Corridor regime under the control of Russian peacekeeping forces to ensure a connection between Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia, as well as the security of movement for persons, vehicles and cargo in both directions through the Lachin Corridor. Moreover, the continued blockade of the Lachin Corridor by Azerbaijan constitutes a violation of the two legally binding decisions of the International Court of Justice, which ordered Azerbaijan to ensure the unimpeded movement of persons and goods in both directions through the Lachin Corridor. We emphasise that in their approaches to the issue of the Lachin Corridor, international actors should proceed from the legally binding decisions of the International Court of Justice. 
 
By obstructing the humanitarian operations of the ICRC, including medical evacuations, Azerbaijan not only disregards its international obligations but also exacerbates the already dire humanitarian situation in Artsakh. This ban effectively deprives access to urgent medical assistance for all those who critically need it, which can lead to serious consequences and loss of life. 
 
The disruption of ICRC humanitarian operations, combined with the total blockade in place since 15 June and Azerbaijan’s consistent obstruction of humanitarian outreach to the population of Artsakh, as well as its policy of creating most unbearable conditions in Artsakh, is yet another manifestation of Azerbaijan’s genocidal intentions towards the people of Artsakh. 
 
We believe it is imperative for the international community to condemn Azerbaijan’s unlawful actions, exert pressure on the Azerbaijani authorities to restore the ICRC’s ability to conduct humanitarian transportation and medical evacuations through the Lachin Corridor based on the principle of respect for human dignity, and make collective efforts to protect the rights and security of the people of Artsakh. Once again, we remind of the responsibility of all parties involved in the peace process in lifting the criminal blockade of Artsakh that has been going on for 7 months now and ensuring Azerbaijan’s full compliance with its obligations under the Trilateral Statement of 9 November 2020 and the decisions of the International Court of Justice”.

Armenpress: The Prime Minister hosts Cardinal Pietro Parolin, Secretary of State of the Holy See

 21:30,

YEREVAN, JULY 12, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan hosted Cardinal Pietro Parolin, Secretary of State of the Holy See, ARMENPRESS was infomred from the Office of the Prime Minister. 

First, the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State had a private conversation, then the negotiations continued in an expanded format.

In his speech, Nikol Pashinyan noted “Your Eminence, I am happy to welcome you to the Republic of Armenia. We highly appreciate your contribution to the development of relations between Armenia and the Vatican. We also highly appreciate today’s visit and willingness to give a new boost to the relations between the Republic of Armenia and the Vatican. The Armenian people fondly remember the visits of Pope Francis and Pope John Paul II in 2001 and 2016, but I must also emphasize that this is the first visit of the Secretary of State of the Vatican to Armenia. And it is a great honor for me to receive you. This indicates a new charge in our relationship. You are welcome.”

In his turn, Pietro Parolin noted. “Thank you Mr. Prime Minister, thank you for giving me this opportunity to meet, have a dialogue and exchange ideas with you. I am very happy to be in Armenia, precisely in the context of the friendly relations that already exist. This visit will deeinitely help to develop them further. Recently, a very positive change has taken place, that the Vatican has an Apostolic nuncio, the ambassador, in Armenia. We thank you for this attitude.”

At the meeting, the interlocutors discussed issues related to both bilateral relations and regional processes. In particular, reference was made to the deepening crisis in Nagorno-Karabakh as a result of Azerbaijan’s illegal blocking of the Lachin Corridor, the post-44-day war humanitarian issues, ongoing negotiations on the peace treaty between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Pietro Parolin expressed the readiness of the Holy See to contribute to the establishment of peace and stability in the region, as well as the process of solving humanitarian problems.

Asbarez: Tributes to Prof. Richard Hovannisian

Professor Richard Hovannisian


The passing of Prof. Richard G. Hovannisan on Monday has impacted a broad spectrum of our nation, with institutions and organizations with which he was affiliated expressing their heartfelt tributes.

Asbarez presents the appreciation messages that it has received.

UCLA Richard Hovannisian Endowed Chair in Modern Armenian History
It was with a heavy heart that I learned earlier today of Professor Richard G. Hovannisian’s passing and I wish to express my deepest and most sincere condolences on this very somber occasion to the entire Hovannisian family and to all those who loved and admired him. Professor Hovannisian was a formidable scholar and pathbreaking innovator in the field of Armenian history, and the first holder of the Armenian Educational Foundation’s Chair of Modern Armenian History at UCLA. In recognition of his towering accomplishments, the chair was renamed in his honor upon his retirement in 2011, following a storied, fifty-year career at UCLA. Dr. Hovannisian was a mentor to several generations of scholars and a recipient of numerous awards and prizes, including a distinguished Guggenheim fellowship. As the present holder of the chair, I am profoundly indebted to his distinguished contributions to the teaching of Armenian history and for establishing Armenian Studies in North America on a firm foundation—a legacy that will be carried forward in future generations.

Professor Hovannisian was the author of numerous foundational works, including “Armenia on the Road to Independence” (University of California Press, 1967), the trailblazing and monumental four-volume diplomatic history of the “Republic of Armenia,” a work of profound erudition and painstaking research in multiple languages across numerous archives. The publication of these groundbreaking volumes from 1971 to 1996, traced the long arc of Professor Hovannisian’s biographical trajectory and helped define Armenian Studies as a professional field of scholarly inquiry and research unseen before his intervention in the field. During the last two decades of his tenure at the Department of History at UCLA, Professor Hovannisian tirelessly organized the “Historic Armenian Cities and Provinces” conferences, which not only made complex scholarly findings accessible to a broad audience, but also resulted in fourteen volumes of edited conference proceedings, culminating in the recent volume, “Armenian Communities in Iran” (2021). Especially noteworthy and indispensable, is the landmark two-volume collection of essays by the leading scholars of Armenian history, “The Armenian People: From Ancient to Modern Times” (New York: MacMillan, 1998), an expertly edited work that established a highwater mark for scholarship in the field and serves as a textbook of choice in Armenian Studies and World History courses across universities in the United States, Europe, and Asia.

Professor Hovannisian was not only a monumental figure in Armenian Studies, but he was also a true pioneer in genocide studies in North America, a field that was hardly in existence before the early 1970s and owes an enormous debt to his contributions. His role as an indefatigable champion for the recognition of the Armenian Genocide will be remembered as one of the most meaningful and profound among his many accomplishments. Like many scholars of Armenian history, Professor Hovannisian’s dedication sprang from a deep desire to alleviate the incalculable losses and ineffable trauma caused by the Armenian Genocide of 1915-1918, during which much of the Armenian population of the Ottoman Empire was systematically exterminated. During an interview he gave more than two decades ago, Professor Hovannisian spoke of how his survivor father, Kaspar Hovannisian, never spoke about the genocide. “He didn’t talk about it, but in his sleep he would call for his mother,” Hovannisian recounted. “That’s the way with the aftermath of genocides – it’s not there, but (is) there at all times.”  This silence and grief that was passed down to survivors drove Professor Hovannisian to record as many testimonies of survivors as possible. In the 1970s and ‘80s, more than two decades before Stephen Spielberg’s establishment of the USC Shoah Foundation, Hovannisian worked tirelessly, often with his UCLA students, tape-recording and filming Armenian genocide survivors, aware that the chance to record their narratives was rapidly dwindling.  “Of the 800 interviewees,” he stated in 2001, “no more than 20 or 25 are still alive…so it makes the effort all the more important.” His important collection is now part of the USC Shoah Foundation’s “Richard G. Hovannisian Armenian Genocide Oral History Collection.”

The whole of the Armenian Studies family has suffered an irreplaceable loss and will be forever in Professor Hovannisian’s debt for the many sacrifices he made to build the scholarly foundation of modern Armenian history, a truly magnificent feat, especially since he did so at a time when he was practically alone and had no shoulders to stand on.

May the extended Hovannisian family find consolation in his blessed memory and comfort in this time of mourning. May God keep the soul in light and comfort his relatives with his fatherly love throughout their life.

With deepest respect,

Sebouh David Aslanian
Professor of History and Richard Hovannisian Chair if Modern Armenian History,
UCLA Department of History
Inaugural Director of the Armenian Studies Center at the UCLA Promise Armenian History

USC Dornsife Institute of Armenian Studies
Richard G. Hovannisian was a titan in the field of Armenian Studies – an academic discipline that he shaped with his groundbreaking scholarship and professionalism. He passed away this week, at the age of 90, leaving behind a legacy that is impossible to capture.

He lived the life of a public intellectual. He became a historian with a mission – to promote the study of the Armenian Genocide as a consequential 20th century event. His research and publications cemented the place of the first Republic of Armenia in Armenian history and world history. Yet, he never lost sight of his two other responsibilities, teaching and community building. He was a professor who shaped multiple generations’ ideas and outlook on what it means to be Armenian. He and his life partner, Dr. Vartiter Kotcholosian Hovannisian, were an unrelenting, resolute presence in the developing Armenian-American community of Southern California – which always included the California Central Valley where his genocide survivor father settled.

His name has been omnipresent in academia for nearly seven decades, making space for Armenian scholars at institutions once out of reach. Hovannisian’s time at the University of California Los Angeles birthed new scholars through the graduate program he founded in Armenian history. Hovannisian also provided  opportunities for students of all disciplines to have hands-on experience collecting, transcribing, and translating the invaluable oral histories of Armenian Genocide survivors. In recent years, he was also a presence at the University of Southern California, after entrusting his large collection of oral history interviews to the university for preservation and public access. The interviews were among the first to be conducted with genocide survivors. 

Richard G. Hovannisian’s scholarship, mentorship, publications, and community building have touched the lives and trajectories of innumerable people, including every member of the USC Institute of Armenian Studies. 

Our sincere condolences to his family, peers, friends, students, and the Armenian Studies community worldwide for this enormous loss.

The Promise Armenian Institute at UCLA
Our UCLA Promise Armenian Institute family is deeply saddened by the news of the passing of Dr. Richard G. Hovannisian, professor emeritus of history at UCLA. We send our deepest condolences to his family, friends, colleagues, and students, through whom his work and influence lives on. His passing is a tremendous loss for the UCLA community and the Armenian community worldwide.

Professor Hovannisian was a professor at UCLA for over 50 years and was the first holder of the Armenian Educational Foundation Professorial Chair in Modern Armenian History, now named in his honor. His monumental work includes The Republic of Armenia in four volumes, several volumes on the Armenian Genocide, fifteen volumes in the series Historic Armenian Cities and Provinces, and over one thousand interviews of genocide survivors conducted with his students. His tremendous work and legacy will continue to inspire and guide scholars for many generations.

Rest in peace, dear Professor Hovannisian; you will be so very much missed by our UCLA PAI family.

Armenian Educational Foundation
It is with deep sadness that we acknowledge the passing of a true friend to the Armenian Educational Foundation, Professor Richard G. Hovannisian, Ph.D., a prominent scholar and expert in Armenian and Near Eastern history. Throughout his life, Professor Hovannisian dedicated himself to educating the world about Armenian history, culture, and contemporary issues. Born in Tulare, California, he pursued his education at the University of California, Berkeley, and the University of California, Los Angeles, where he earned his Ph.D.

Professor Hovannisian’s impact as an educator and author was immeasurable. He played a vital role in establishing Armenian history courses and programs at UCLA, where he served as a tenured professor from 1969 and later became a full professor in 1972. Additionally, he made significant contributions as the Associate Director of the Von Grunebaum Center for Near Eastern Studies.

As a prolific author and editor, Professor Hovannisian produced numerous influential publications that delved into various aspects of Armenian history and culture. His contributions included the renowned four-volume archival study, “The Republic of Armenia.” Furthermore, he played a pivotal role in ensuring the permanence of the Armenian History position at UCLA by spearheading efforts to establish an endowed chair through the AEF. This resulted in the establishment of the “AEF Chair in Modern Armenian History” in 1986, with Professor Hovannisian as its first chair holder.

Professor Hovannisian received numerous accolades and honors for his outstanding contributions to Armenian scholarship. His notable achievements include receiving the Medal of Mesrop Mashtots, the Medal of Saints Sahak and Mesrop, and the Knight of Cilicia. In 1990, he became the first social scientist living abroad to be elected to the Armenian Academy of Sciences.

Professor Richard G. Hovannisian’s example and contributions will serve as a guiding light for future generations. His commitment to Armenian education, his fight against genocide denial, and his dedication to preserving Armenian history will be cherished and remembered with the utmost admiration. The loss of Professor Hovannisian is deeply felt, and his significant contributions to the field of Armenian studies will leave an enduring legacy. May his torch of knowledge inspire and guide those who continue the important work he began.

AEF Board and Staff

ABMDR Participates in Two Pan-National Medical Conferences in Armenia

Dr. Mihran Nazaretyan during his presentation at the Medical Congress of Armenia. Photos courtesy of the Armenian Bone Marrow Donor Registry


Events Showcased Latest Medical Advances

LOS ANGELES—The Armenian Bone Marrow Donor Registry took part in two globally-significant medical conferences in July that were held in Yerevan.

The ABMDR participated in the sixth International Medical Congress of Armenia from July 6 to 8.

Speaking at the event were ABMDR Executive Director Dr. Sevak Avagyan, Medical Director Dr. Mihran Nazaretyan, and Senior Lab Technician and Database Manager Alina Sirunyan. The speakers highlighted ABMDR’s latest achievements, not only in terms of matching donors for bone marrow/stem cell transplantation and research, but also in helping patients in Armenia with state-of-the-art molecular testing for diagnosis and treatment.

Main partners of the sixth International Medical Congress of Armenia included the Armenian Medical International Committee and the Armenian American Medical Society. In his remarks, AAMS President Dr. Vicken Sepilian, one of the event’s keynote speakers, stated, “What we’re trying to accomplish through this global conference is to bring the very latest achievements of medical science to the Armenian homeland.”

ABMDR also participated in the third Pan-Armenian Hematology satellite Symposium, which was held on July 5 in Yerevan. Representing ABMDR at the event was Dr. Mihran Nazaretyan, who spoke about the organization’s various areas of expertise and most recent achievements. During the symposium, a number of potential bone marrow donors joined the registry. All event participants also received informative pamphlets about ABMDR activities.

Commenting on the importance of the two medical conferences in Yerevan, ABMDR President Dr. Frieda Jordan said, “With their focus on scientific and technical progress, these events bring the global Armenian medical community together, for the very noble goal of promoting the health and well-being of our nation. It is an honor to take part in these pan-national events.”  

Established in 1999, ABMDR, a nonprofit organization, helps Armenians and non-Armenians worldwide survive life-threatening blood-related illnesses by recruiting and matching donors to those requiring bone marrow stem cell transplants. To date, the registry has recruited over 33,500 donors in 44 countries across four continents, identified over 9,000 patients, and facilitated 40 bone marrow transplants. For more information, call (323) 663-3609 or visit abmdr.am.

Asbarez: Calif. State Senate Unanimously Calls for Protections for Artsakh


SACRAMENTO—The Armenian National Committee of America Western Region welcomed the passage by the California State Senate of a measure that calls for the protection and security of the Armenian population of Artsakh as it faces unrelenting attacks in Azerbaijan’s ongoing genocidal campaign of ethnic cleansing. 

The resolution, known as AJR-1, which was introduced by Assemblymember Chris Holden, passed in the Senate on Monday with a vote of 39-0 on.

The passage in the Senate follows the March 30 passage of the resolution in the State Assembly and becomes a unified position by the State of California calling for those protections for the people of Artsakh.

The Senators of the 25th and 26th California Senate Districts, Anthony Portantino and Maria Elena Durazo, both made impassioned statements on the Senate floor before the resolution was voted on. The resolution condemns Azerbaijan’s ongoing blockade of Artsakh and calls upon the United States Federal Government to use any and all tools to compel Azerbaijan to end the blockade. The resolution also calls on the federal government to end military assistance to Azerbaijan, provide humanitarian aid to the people of Artsakh, establish an international peacekeeping mission to ensure Artsakh’s safety and security, and support Artsakh’s self-determination.

Azerbaijan’s blockade of Artsakh has continued for more than two hundred days. Since December 12, 2022, the Azerbaijani government has blocked the Lachin Corridor, the only road connecting Artsakh to the outside world. One hundred twenty thousand people have been deprived of essential goods, medicine, and food. With schools closed as a direct result of the scarcity of energy and resources caused by the blockade, more than 30,000 children have been deprived of their right to education. The continued terror imposed upon the people of Artsakh by Azerbaijan also extends to intermittent cuts of electricity, gas, water, and communications infrastructure. Further exacerbating the situation, Azerbaijan illegally installed a checkpoint on the Hakari Bridge. More recently, Azerbaijan banned the International Committee of the Red Cross from transporting critically ill patients to Armenia, as Artsakh’s hospitals are unable to provide medical care due to a lack of electricity, gas and medicine. The residents of Artsakh are also subject to daily targeting by Azerbaijani forces, with an ever-growing list of confirmed violations from the Azerbaijani side. The blockade of Artsakh continues to highlight the genocidal ambitions of Azerbaijan’s government in an attempt to force the Armenians of Artsakh from their rightful homeland.

Since the outset of the blockade, the ANCA Western Region has mobilized Armenian-American Community activists across the Western United States through initiatives, including legislative efforts, community campaigns, and town hall meetings. The Save Artsakh initiative was one of the first efforts to draw attention to the humanitarian crisis, which served as a community letter-writing campaign that called on the Biden Administration to take concrete steps to end the blockade immediately. Separately, the ANCA Western Region activated its coalition partners across several communities, who signed onto a similar joint letter, and spearheaded a letter to President Biden, cosigned by members of the California State Legislature, calling for the United States to exert pressure on Azerbaijan to end the blockade. The passage and adoption of AJR1 will help bolster critical amendments to the National Defense Authorization Act regarding the blockade of Artsakh, which are to be heard by Congress in the coming week.

The ANCA Western Region worked closely with Assemblymember Holden on AJR-1, providing research material, issuing formal letters of support, combating misinformation campaigns by the Consulate of Azerbaijan in Los Angeles, and conducting extensive outreach to members of the California State Assembly and Senate to vote in favor of AJR-1.

“We thank Assemblymember Holden for taking the lead on holding Azerbaijan accountable for its illegal blockade of Artsakh, and we are grateful to each of the co-authors in both the State Assembly and Senate who supported the resolution and to Senators Portantino and Durazo for their unwavering support of our community,” said Nora Hovsepian, Esq, Chair of the ANCA Western Region. “The passage and adoption of AJR1 further embodies California’s commitment to the Armenian Diaspora, but more importantly, it illustrates that the people of Artsakh are not alone in their struggle for freedom.”

The Armenian National Committee of America Western Region is the largest and most influential Armenian-American grassroots advocacy organization in the Western United States. Working in coordination with a network of offices, chapters, and supporters throughout the Western United States and affiliated organizations around the country, the ANCA-WR advances the concerns of the Armenian American community on a broad range of issues.

AW: The Folly and Perils of an Armenia-Azerbaijan “Peace Agreement”

Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan, U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov met in Arlington, VA from June 27-29, 2023 (Republic of Azerbaijan Ministry of Foreign Affairs)

Last month, the foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan, Ararat Mirzoyan and Jeyhun Bayramov, descended on Arlington, VA for U.S.-mediated marathon peace talks. The three-day negotiation session aimed to register progress around various thorny issues (i.e., border demarcation, unblocking transportation links and the final status of Artsakh/Nagorno-Karabakh) and lay the groundwork for an eventual normalization accord between the archrivals. Despite ups and downs, Armenia-Azerbaijan negotiations have recently gathered pace with an uptick in summits across Washington D.C., Brussels and Moscow. (Russia—the longtime regional hegemon—maintains a dueling diplomatic track and routinely blasts the mediation efforts of its Western counterparts.) The United States appears resolved to shepherd through a peace deal, eager to expand its clout along Russia’s southern flank. But in their current form, these negotiations are poised to exacerbate the region’s geopolitical fault lines and foster future rounds of armed conflict while entrenching Russian interests.

Essentially Appeasement: Perpetuating Cycles of Violence

Since a catastrophic defeat in the 2020 Artsakh War, Armenia has been embroiled in a protracted security-cum-political crisis. (The Armenian government, helmed by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, has failed to chart a fresh security strategy to extract the country from its existential imbroglio.) Taking advantage of disorientation in Yerevan, Azerbaijan has launched a multi-pronged pressure campaign—marked by a series of armed assaults and hybrid warfare—to extract further concessions and consolidate its recent geopolitical gains via a negotiated settlement. The international community, bereft of policy alternatives, has championed such a process, casting a peace agreement as the region’s best bet for stability and prosperity. Amid Moscow’s preoccupation with its botched invasion of Ukraine—and its flagging credibility as a neutral arbitrator—Washington also sees an opportunity to curtail Russian clout in the Caucasus. 

These prospective accords—products of rushed negotiations and misguided assumptions—are poised to backfire, failing to deliver the intended benefits envisioned by Washington and setting the stage for future bouts of regional conflagration. Recent negotiations— supported by the United States, European Union and Russia alike—are the culmination of a long-running policy of appeasement towards Azerbaijan. Baku’s conduct—including armed incursions and hostage diplomacy—is routinely met with meek condemnation in global capitals. (In recent statements, the United States has also disavowed sanctions as a tool to check Azeri aggression, a further boon to Baku’s designs.) These accords, crafted in the same tepid spirit, are set to handsomely reward Azerbaijan’s insidious pressure campaign, conducted in partnership with Russia and Turkey, at the expense of regional security.

Should this so-called peace agreement—better characterized as a stop-gap measure—materialize, it will almost certainly fail to usher in genuine normalization or stem violence. The arrangement will shift the region’s geopolitical balance firmly in favor of Azerbaijan and expose an enfeebled Armenia to fresh security risks from Azerbaijan and continued assaults on its sovereignty from Russia. An emboldened Baku, eager to reap additional geopolitical gains—and acutely aware of Yerevan’s much-reduced post-war military capabilities—is likely to ratchet up tensions at will, without fear of consequence. (Nationalist militarism is a core ideological plank of Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev’s autocratic regime. Aliyev regularly engages in saber-rattling and spews irredentist remarks, claiming vast swathes of Armenia as Azerbaijani territory.) Premature declarations of Azerbaijan’s reliability and appetite for peace will ring hollow. Azerbaijan often launches incursions into Armenian territory and violates the ceasefire regime in Artsakh. (Baku is also a seasoned practitioner of disinformation, distorting the facts around its aggression via a narrative of false parity.) So instead of its purported goals, the accords are likely to perpetuate—if not, exacerbate—the current cycle of escalation, presaging future rounds of Azeri belligerence and increasing reliance on Russia while prompting criticism of the United States for its facilitating role. As such, the accords will also provide fodder for the next disinformation campaign against American interests and Western norms. Avoiding this trap requires the rejection (and non-legitimization) of territorial gains achieved via wars of aggression in Artsakh—and Ukraine. 

From Pacification to Eradication

The most contentious—and consequential—negotiation portfolio is the final status of Artsakh, the Armenian-majority enclave at the center of the Armenia-Azerbaijan rivalry. The region—artificially integrated into Azerbaijan in 1921 via the whims of Joseph Stalin—has enjoyed self-governance since Armenian forces prevailed in the First Artsakh War (1988-1994). This precarious, yet relatively stable, existence came to a crashing halt amid the 2020 Artsakh War. The conflict saw Azerbaijan capture vast swathes of Artsakh and adjoining territories—including all-important land bridges to Armenia—eroding the viability of the Armenian statelet. In the aftermath of the war—which ended via a woefully enforced Moscow-designed ceasefire—Baku has conducted a creeping takeover of Artsakh, seizing villages, crippling utility networks and kidnapping civilians. (Since December, Azerbaijan has also subjected Artsakh to a wholesale blockade, precipitating a humanitarian crisis.) Azerbaijan’s relentless pacification campaign—compounded by continued international intransigence and a lack of security guarantees—is pushing the beleaguered region toward the precipice, with grim prospects for relief.

Deliberations around Artsakh’s final status remain murky. But concerns abound that Armenia’s leadership—short on capacity and vision—will acquiesce to the absorption of Artsakh into Azerbaijan as the price to seal a peace agreement. The local population views integration with Baku as an existential risk, citing Azerbaijan’s recent conduct: terrorizing civilians, extrajudicial killings of POWs and the demolition of religious monuments. (The Aliyev regime has also embraced Armenophobia as state policy.) In the event of a negotiated takeover, Azerbaijan will continue to chip away at remaining trappings of modern life, rendering the enclave uninhabitable—and precipitating an exodus of its Armenians. (Baku may also opt to pacify the region by force.) Vague security guarantees will fail to assuage a petrified population. (The Russian peacekeeping mission in Artsakh—ostensibly tasked with protecting the region’s Armenian denizens—has actively abetted Azerbaijan’s creeping takeover.) Given Azerbaijan’s violent proclivities and maximalist geopolitical ambitions, a grand bargain around Artsakh will condemn the region’s millennia-old Armenian community to exile—or possible carnage.

Peace Treaty or Trojan Horse

The United States has recently eclipsed Russia, the longtime regional powerbroker, as the chief focal point of Armenia-Azerbaijan negotiations. Washington’s increased engagement is animated in part by a desire to curtail the Kremlin’s regional clout amid Russian entanglement in Ukraine. The United States has stepped up diplomatic activities across the Caucasus and Central Asia, reaching out to counterparts unnerved by an increasingly unhinged and bellicose Russia. (In recent months, a stream of American officials, including Secretary of State Antony Blinken, have traversed the former Soviet bloc, burnishing relationships and exploring areas of mutual interest. Enforcing sanction regimes, imposed on Russia in response to its invasion of Ukraine, is also high on Washington’s regional agenda.) However, these accords, contrary to Washington’s thinking, will perpetuate Moscow’s grip on its near abroad, while rewarding Baku, a Russian ally masquerading as a neutral partner-to-all. 

The prevailing logic around the negotiations—that a normalization deal will foster regional security and narrow Russia’s margin to meddle—ignores the geopolitical realignment roiling the region, including the growing partnership between Azerbaijan and Russia. (Turkey is also a member of this emerging axis. Aliyev and Russian President Vladimir Putin are firm champions of fellow authoritarian, recently reelected Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan.) In recent years, Moscow—driven by political and economic interests including its premeditated confrontation with the West—has cultivated closer ties to an ascendant Baku. (Azerbaijan and Russia cemented their blossoming relationship via an alliance agreement signed days before the Kremlin’s invasion of Ukraine.) And as the Ukraine conflict drags on, Moscow’s dealings with Baku are assuming greater strategic importance.

With the Russian economy languishing, Moscow is growing increasingly reliant on its regional relations to access markets—and skirt sanctions. Russia is building out alternative logistics channels, beyond the reach of the West, to expand trade flows with economic partners. Baku is a critical node in these burgeoning commercial and sanctions-busting networks. (Following the invasion of Ukraine, Moscow reportedly bypassed oil sanctions via Azerbaijan.) Baku hosts a leg of the International North-South Transport Corridor, a new trade route connecting Russia to the Indian Ocean. The corridor, while serving to facilitate Russian access to Asian markets, will also establish a secure channel between Moscow and Tehran, global pariahs turned security partners. Azerbaijan and Russia also aim to carve out the “Zangezur” Corridor—an envisioned extraterritorial, Moscow-managed corridor to Turkey via Armenia’s southern Syunik region. (Yerevan is violently opposed to this proposed scheme, which would involve the expropriation of Armenian territory.) Russia is poised to leverage these links to weather the economic fallout of the Ukraine conflict and circumvent tightening international sanctions regimes. With its stock rising vis-à-vis Moscow, an emboldened Azerbaijan is forging ahead with its geopolitical agenda. 

Amid advantageous conditions, Baku, in alignment with Moscow, is shaping the postwar order in its favor, strong-arming Yerevan into acquiescing to a heavily skewed normalization agreement. The accords, devoid of security guarantees, will thrust Armenia further into the geopolitical wilderness. (And amid sustained Russian pressure, and the specter of Azeri aggression, an already reeling Armenian government will at best struggle in vain to chart the foreign policies and build the alternative security partnerships necessary to foster defense capabilities and deterrence.) In this hostile environment, a beleaguered Armenia will likely seek the familiar embrace of its erstwhile ally Russia, with hollow hopes of security assistance, ensnaring Yerevan in the Russian orbit. 

These normalization accords will also fail to achieve American objectives vis-à-vis Azerbaijan. The argument that ceding Artsakh will steer Baku away from Moscow’s orbit is a hollow gambit, prone to risks and conjecture. In fact, this ploy has already been exhausted. Moscow greenlit—and helped coordinate—the incremental Azerbaijani takeover of Artsakh in exchange for Baku’s strategic cooperation. This arrangement involves Azerbaijan serving as a custodian of Russian interests in the Caucasus—chief among them precluding an expanded Western presence in the region.

Baku is also firmly ensconced in an emerging authoritarian axis along with Ankara and Moscow. This regional triumvirate is linked by common geopolitical interests and shared contempt for Western values. (Aliyev and Putin intervened in the recent Turkish presidential elections in favor of Erdogan.) Therefore, forfeiting Artsakh to coax Azerbaijan out of this strategic bloc will fail to precipitate Washington’s desired geopolitical realignment and counter Russian, or perhaps even Iranian, influence. 

New Path to Normalization

The United States has a historic opportunity to help establish stability and prosperity in the Caucasus. The region—a potential buttress against Russian influence—is at a geopolitical crossroads. Sustained engagement, underpinned by sober policymaking, can swing the pendulum in favor of the United States and its European allies. But the current trajectory of Armenia-Azerbaijan normalization is poised to diminish such prospects. In their present form, Washington-mediated negotiations will buoy a creeping pro-Moscow authoritarian currently stalking the region (i.e., Georgia). They will also compromise the sovereignty of Armenia, foiling the aspiring democracy’s attempt to flee Moscow’s grip. To escape this geopolitical trap, a reset in Yerevan-Baku negotiations is necessary. A fresh approach, one that embraces gradual normalization, is better suited to fostering a more sustainable peace between the archrivals, while checking Moscow’s local sway. 

A real reset would begin with the United States and European Union restoring a modicum of parity between the two opposing parties. Currently, Azerbaijan wields an armed veto over the negotiations. (Gunpoint negotiations rarely foster lasting peace. And Aliyev’s geopolitical gains, achieved via a mix of conventional military might and hybrid warfare, will inspire like-minded tyrants to embrace similar tactics.) To mitigate Azerbaijan’s armed advantage and level the playing field, Washington and its European counterparts should extend security assistance to Armenia. (A potential security package could include professional military education, capability development and defense sector reform initiatives.) This would help Yerevan rebuild its battered armed forces and deterrence capacity. Meanwhile, the international community should support security stabilization measures, including the European Union border monitoring mission and the demilitarization of the Armenia-Azerbaijan border. (Washington should also condition further talks on confidence-building measures from Baku: the release of Armenian POWs and lifting the siege on Artsakh.) With a more level playing field, Armenia and Azerbaijan could build consensus around less contentious issues (i.e., the resumption of economic links), before tackling heftier portfolios. Under these modified conditions, normalization, while difficult to achieve, will be possible. Establishing and nurturing a just peace is the best way to preclude a relapse into conflict and a resurgence of Russian influence. To induce Baku’s cooperation, the United States may also choose to examine Azerbaijan’s prima facie claim of territorial integrity more closely. It may conclude that, unlike other territorial disputes afflicting the former Soviet bloc, Artsakh is more like Kosovo—the majority Albanian enclave that exercised self-determination vis-à-vis Serbia amid mass discrimination and the specter of ethnic cleansing—than previously reckoned.

Sevan Araz is a defense analyst. He previously served as a researcher with the Defense-Industrial Initiatives Group at the Center for Strategic & International Studies. He graduated from George Washington University’s Elliott School of International Affairs with a focus on security policy in 2018.


In Memory of Prof. Richard G. Hovannisian

Prof. Richard G. Hovannisian, 1932-2023

On July 10, the Society for Armenian Studies, the academic world, the field of Armenian Studies and the Armenian nation lost one of the most prominent icons of the modern period: Prof. Richard G. Hovannisian. Hovannisian was a monumental figure in the field of Armenian Studies. Considered as the Dean of Modern Armenian History, he established the field of Modern Armenian History in the western hemisphere. He supported the establishment of some of the most important chairs in Armenian Studies in the United States. Hovannisian was the child of Genocide survivors. His father, Kaspar Gavroian, was born in the village of Bazmashen near Kharpert in 1901. Unlike others, Kaspar survived the Genocide and arrived in the U.S. He changed his last name from Gavroian to Hovannisian after his father Hovannes. In 1928, Kaspar married Siroon Nalbandian, the child of Genocide survivors. They had four sons: John, Ralph, Richard and Vernon. Richard was born in Tulare, California, on November 9, 1932. Being the son of Genocide survivors played an important role in his academic path. In 1957, he married Dr. Vartiter Kotcholosian in Fresno and had four children: Raffi, Armen, Ani and Garo. Raffi would become the first Minister of Foreign Affairs (1991-1992) of the Modern Republic of Armenia. 

Hovannisian began his academic life in 1954 by earning a bachelor of arts in history, followed by a masters degree in history from the University of California, Berkeley. In 1966, he earned his doctorate from the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA). His dissertation was published in 1967 with the title Armenia on the Road to Independence which was the precursor to the four-volume magnum opus The Republic of Armenia. Hovannisian played an important role in establishing the teaching of Armenian history at UCLA. In 1987, he became the first holder of the Armenian Education Foundation Chair in Modern Armenian History at UCLA, which after his retirement was named in his honor as the Richard Hovannisian Endowed Chair in Modern Armenian History, with Prof. Sebouh Aslanian as its first incumbent. 

Hovannisian was a Guggenheim Fellow and received numerous prestigious national and international awards for his service to the field and civic activities. He served on the board of directors of multiple national and international educational institutions and was a member of the Armenian National Academy of Sciences. After finishing his four-volume The Republic of Armenia, he dedicated his research and career to battling denial of the Armenian Genocide, resurrecting the history of Armenian towns and villages of the Armenian provinces of the Ottoman Empire and writing textbooks on modern Armenian history. Although not a scholar of the Armenian Genocide, he contributed more to the discipline than many others in the field. He edited multiple volumes on different facets of the Armenian Genocide, including historical, literary and artistic perspectives. Hovannisian also spearheaded a monumental project to preserve the eyewitness accounts of Armenian Genocide survivors. 

In the 1970s, he launched the Armenian Genocide oral history project. He and his students interviewed more than 1,000 Armenian Genocide survivors in California. In 2018, Hovannisian donated the collection to the USC Shoah Foundation’s Visual History Archive to be available to scholars around the world. He single-handedly edited and published 15 volumes with Mazda Press as part of the UCLA Armenian History & Culture Series. The 15 volumes covered the history of Armenians in Van/Vaspourakan, Cilicia (with Simon Payaslian), Sivas/Sepastia, Trebizond/Trabzon, Baghesh/Bitlis, Taron/Mush, Smyrna/Izmir, Kesaria/Kayseri and Cappadocia, among other places. The final book in the series, The Armenians of Persia/Iran, was published in 2022. Hovannisian also edited the two-volume The Armenian People from Ancient to Modern Times, which is considered a classic Armenian history textbook. 

Hovannisian came from a generation that fought against the stifling of Armenian voices within the fields of Middle Eastern and Ottoman Studies, which had relegated Armenian Studies to second-class status. He fought for the relevance of Armenian Studies within these fields and tirelessly fought against the efforts to marginalize Armenian issues and to deny the Armenian Genocide.

Besides his contributions to the field, Hovannisian also mentored and educated multiple generations of scholars and thousands of students. He was a strict mentor who demanded that his students work to reach their full potential. He wanted to ensure that they would survive and thrive in the tough terrain of the academic job market. 

In his lifetime, Hovannisian was especially influenced by two people: his wife Vartiter and Simon Vratsian (the last Prime Minister of the First Republic of Armenia). Vartiter was his life’s partner for more than half a century. Her dedication to Richard and the field of Armenian Studies played an important role in shaping who he became. Vartiter was an intellectual companion who read and reviewed every piece that he wrote. She was also a constant presence at every conference he planned or attended. In the early 1950s, Vratsian, the author of a major book on the First Republic, became Hovannisian’s mentor when he studied Armenian language at the Hamazkayin Nishan Palanjian Jemaran in Beirut, Lebanon. This influence led Hovannisian to write the first academic work on the First Republic of Armenia and created the first step for his academic career.  

In 1974, Hovannisian, along with Dickran Kouymjian, Nina Garsoïan, Avedis Sanjian and Robert Thomson, spearheaded the project to establish a Society for Armenian Studies (SAS). Considered as the pillars of Armenian Studies, the main objective of this group was the development of Armenian Studies as an academic discipline. With access to very limited resources, this group of scholars was able to establish the foundations of a Society that would play a dominant role in developing Armenian Studies in North America and beyond. From a handful of chairs and programs that supported the initiative at the time, today Armenian Studies as a discipline has flourished in the United States with more than thirteen chairs and programs providing their unconditional support to the Society. Hovannisian was the president of SAS for three terms (1977, 1991-1992, 2006-2009). During his tenure, the Society thrived and achieved major accomplishments in the field. 

In 2019, the Society for Armenian Studies awarded Hovannisian with its “Lifetime Achievement Award” in recognition and appreciation for his outstanding service and contribution to the field of Armenian Studies.

Hovannisian’s legacy will remain for generations to come.

Our hearts go out to his family and beloved ones. 

—Bedross Der Matossian
Past President of SAS (2018-2022)

***

Condolences

The Armenian Revolutionary Federation Eastern USA Central Committee and the editors and staff of the Hairenik Weekly and Armenian Weekly extend their deepest condolences to the family and friends of Prof. Richard G. Hovannisian. 

The Armenian National Committee of America, Eastern Region, also extends deepest sympathies to Dr. Hovannisian’s family and friends.

Dr. Hovannisian’s legacy as the father of Armenian Studies, editor of many volumes, and a renowned scholar and author will continue to reverberate in the global Armenian nation.