Why deepening Russia-Azerbaijan ties should worry the United States

By Sheila Paylan

Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine has left it with few friends, but Azerbaijan is an important exception. In fact, Moscow and Baku are effectively allies now. Just two days before the February 2022 invasion, Russian President Vladimir Putin and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev signed a wide-ranging political-military agreement, following which Aliyev declared that the pact “brings our relations to the level of an alliance.” A few months later, Azerbaijan signed an intelligence-sharing agreement with Russia.

This has proven catastrophic for Armenia, which has maintained close security ties with Russia since joining the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) in 1992. In September 2022, Azerbaijan launched what the European Parliament called a “large-scale military aggression” against Armenia and, according to Armenia’s foreign minister, took over 150 square kilometers of Armenian territory. But the CSTO—to which Azerbaijan does not belong—refused to intervene on Armenia’s behalf. Washington stepped in to broker a ceasefire, and the European Union (EU) followed suit by sending a monitoring mission to the Armenian-Azerbaijani border, much to Russia’s and Azerbaijan’s discontent.

The Putin-Aliyev partnership has also spelled disaster for the breakaway republic of Nagorno-Karabakh, whose remaining 120,000 ethnic Armenians live under Russian protection after Azerbaijan’s 2020 offensive to reclaim the territory. Forty-four days and thousands of deaths later, Russia brokered a ceasefire stipulating the five-year deployment of 1,960 Russian armed peacekeepers along the line of contact in Nagorno-Karabakh and in control of the “Lachin Corridor,” the only road linking it to Armenia. At the time, analysts opined that Putin’s imposition had cemented Russia’s role in the region. According to the decree authorizing the deployment, Russia’s reason for sending peacekeeping troops was to “prevent the mass death of the civilian population of Nagorno-Karabakh.”

But the deployment has not prevented Azerbaijan from continuing to try to expel ethnic Armenians from what’s left of Nagorno-Karabakh. Last December, a group of Azerbaijanis set up a roadblock along the Lachin Corridor claiming to advocate for environmental rights in the region. But the roadblock in effect slowed the flow of goods into Nagorno-Karabakh, creating a humanitarian crisis. The United States and the EU, as well as Human Rights Watch and others, have called for Azerbaijan to unblock the Lachin Corridor. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has ordered Azerbaijan to do the same.

Instead, Azerbaijan solidified the blockade by installing an armed checkpoint at the mouth of the Lachin Corridor, thus effectively seizing control over it. The move was further condemned by the United States and EU, and led Armenia to seek renewed intervention from the ICJ. Russia issued tepid statements and then replaced its peacekeeping force commander in Nagorno-Karabakh. But such a fundamental change in the regime over the Lachin Corridor could not possibly exist without approval—however tacit—from the Kremlin. Video footage taken last month purports to show Russian peacekeepers accompanying Azerbaijani forces to install a concrete barrier near the checkpoint and hoist an Azerbaijani flag in adjacent Armenian territory.

Since the blockade began, traffic along the Lachin Corridor has been reduced to an all-time low. This makes it more difficult for essential humanitarian aid to pass into Nagorno-Karabakh. In the last seven months, Nagorno-Karabakh has turned into an open-air prison, with ethnic Armenian inhabitants increasingly deprived of food and medicine, and energy resources almost entirely drained. They may soon be forced to flee their ancestral homeland for good just to survive.

In May, Aliyev demanded the surrender of Nagorno-Karabakh authorities, suggesting that he might offer them amnesty should they accept Azerbaijani rule. Oddly, the US State Department praised Aliyev’s remarks on amnesty, glossing over other parts of his speech in which he threatened violence if the authorities did not surrender: “[E]veryone knows perfectly well that we have all the opportunities to carry out any operation in that region today… Either they will bend their necks and come themselves or things will develop differently now.”

But Washington’s seemingly tactful acquiescence to Azerbaijan’s growing aggression against Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh in fact hurts US efforts to curb malign Russian influence and end Moscow’s war on Ukraine. The Russo-Azeri pact provides for enhanced economic ties, including in the gas and energy sectors, and has proven successful in helping preemptively circumvent Western sanctions against Russia. A deal between Baku and Brussels in July 2022 to double the flow of gas to Europe to wean it off Russian gas was soon followed by a deal in November 2022 between Baku and Moscow to increase gas imports from Russia to enable Azerbaijan to meet its new obligations to Europe.

In May, Russia and Iran agreed to complete a railroad that would link Russia to the Persian Gulf through Azerbaijan, thus providing a route through which Iran can directly send Russia more weapons and drones. One week later, during a summit of the Eurasian Economic Union, in which Aliyev participated as a guest for the first time, Putin stated that cooperation on developing this North-South railway is carried out “in close partnership with Azerbaijan.” Baku knows it can play both sides because it has backing from Moscow, while the West is blinded by non-Russian energy imports and dreams of regional stability.

If the West seeks to reduce tensions in the South Caucasus, it needs to step up its pressure on Azerbaijan. In the short term, this might include the threat of sanctions in response to further military action against Armenia and the continued refusal to unblock the Lachin Corridor, as well as lending support to Russia. By law, Azerbaijan cannot receive US military or foreign assistance unless it eschews military force to solve its disputes with Armenia, but the White House keeps letting Azerbaijan off the hook by waiving Section 907 of the Freedom Support Act and sending millions of dollars in military aid to Baku. Washington should treat Baku’s actions against Armenia as attempts at coercion, just as it does with Russian aggression against Ukraine.

For its part, Armenia has sought to unwind some of its security arrangements with Russia. Yerevan has refused to host CSTO military drills, send a representative to serve as CSTO deputy secretary general, sign a CSTO declaration to provide defense aid to Armenia, or accept the deployment of a CSTO monitoring mission in lieu of the EU-led mission. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has even threatened to terminate or freeze Armenia’s CSTO membership.

Even so, the West cannot reasonably expect Armenia to leave the CSTO and break with Russia without significantly helping Armenia diversify and mitigate its security, energy, and economic reliance on the Kremlin. As part of this, the United States may want to consider inviting Armenia to become a Major Non-NATO Ally. Washington should provide training and equipment to enhance Armenia’s defense capabilities and help it develop a more robust and independent security apparatus. The United States could also push forward on the prospect of building a small modular nuclear power plant in Armenia, providing an incentive for Armenia to decide against partnering with Russia on energy.

The West has stepped up its diplomatic efforts to facilitate a peace treaty between Armenia and Azerbaijan, which is good, but these efforts should not come at the cost of abetting the unfolding humanitarian disaster in Nagorno-Karabakh. Now is the time to compel Baku to cease its bellicose rhetoric and consent to an international presence in Nagorno-Karabakh to mediate dialogue with residents there and promote a more meaningful transition from war to lasting peace.


Sheila Paylan is a human rights lawyer and former legal advisor to the United Nations. She is currently a senior fellow in international law at the Applied Policy Research Institute of Armenia.


Visa-Free Travel Agreement Between Georgia and Armenia Enters into Force

Civil Georgia

According to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MFA), the agreement “On bilateral visa-free movement of citizens between the Republic of Georgia and the Republic of Armenia” has officially entered into force. The agreement had been signed by the Prime Minister of Georgia Irakli Garibashvili and the Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan on January 12, 2023.

According to Foreign Ministry, the purpose of the agreement is to create more favorable conditions for the mutual movement of Georgian and Armenian citizens. It grants citizens of both countries the right to travel from Georgia to Armenia and vice versa through authorized border crossing points for international travel using a biometric identity card. This agreement replaces the previous agreement on visa-free travel “On visa-free travel for citizens of the Republic of Georgia and the Republic of Armenia in their territories” signed on May 19, 1993.

https://civil.ge/archives/552118

Armenia condemns Karabakh ‘blockade’ ahead of peace talks

Al Arabiya, UAE

AFP – Armenia’s Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Thursday urged international unity against Azerbaijan’s “illegal blockade” of the Armenian-populated region of Nagorno-Karabakh, and announced fresh EU-mediated peace talks with Baku.

Azerbaijan said this week it was temporarily shutting the only road linking its breakaway region to Armenia, accusing the Armenian branch of the Red Cross of smuggling.

For the latest headlines, follow our Google News channel online or via the app.

The move sparked concerns over a humanitarian crisis in the restive enclave, which is experiencing food shortages and where locals lack access to health services, according to separatist authorities.

Pashinyan on Thursday denounced what he said was an “illegal blockade” of Karabakh, saying it contradicts a ruling of the International Court of Justice (ICJ).

The UN’s top judicial body ordered Azerbaijan in February to ensure free movement along the Lachin Corridor, Karabakh’s sole land link with Armenia.

“As far as the illegal blockade of the Lachin Corridor and the deepening humanitarian crisis are concerned, the binding ruling of the ICJ creates a possibility for a greater international consolidation to prevent Azerbaijan’s policy of ethnic cleansing in Karabakh,” Pashinyan said.

Speaking at a cabinet meeting, he also announced the next round of peace talks with Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev would be held on Saturday in Brussels under the mediation of European Council President Charles Michel.

“I confirmed my participation in the meeting, and I hope we will achieve progress in our talks on a peace treaty.”

The two former Soviet republics have fought two wars for control of Karabakh, in the 1990s and again in 2020.

Six weeks of fighting in autumn 2020 ended with a Russian-sponsored ceasefire agreement that saw Armenia cede swathes of territories it had controlled for decades.

Under the deal, the five-kilometer-wide Lachin Corridor was to be manned by Russian peacekeepers to ensure free passage between Armenia and Karabakh.

Pashinyan has complained about “problems” with Russian peacekeepers in Karabakh.

https://english.alarabiya.net/News/world/2023/07/13/Armenia-condemns-Karabakh-blockade-ahead-of-peace-talks

Karabakh Separatist Official Urges Russia To Open Corridor To Armenia

BARRON’S

A separatist official in Armenian-populated Nagorno-Karabakh in Azerbaijan on Thursday called on Russia to allow movement on the only road linking the breakaway region to Armenia.

“I appeal to the Russian Federation… to ensure unimpeded movement, transportation of people and goods along the corridor,” State Minister Gurgen Nersisyan said on social media, warning that “the situation is terrible, in a few days we will have irreversible consequences.”

bur/gw

https://www.barrons.com/news/karabakh-separatist-official-urges-russia-to-open-corridor-to-armenia-b6664c80


US Calls For Armenia, Azerbaijan Dialogue After Road Closure

BARRON’S

The United States called Wednesday for the reopening of the only road linking Armenia with the breakaway region of Nagorno-Karabakh.

It also called on both Armenia and Azerbaijan to continue dialogue on ending their long-running conflict over Karabakh.

Secretary of State Anthony Blinken spoke with Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev, the State Department said, one day after the country closed the so-called Lachin Corridor.

Blinken “underscored the need for free transit of commercial, humanitarian, and private vehicles through the Lachin corridor,” the department said in a statement.

On Tuesday, Azerbaijan said it was shutting the road, accusing the Armenian branch of the Red Cross of smuggling.

Karabakh has been at the center of a decades-long territorial dispute between Azerbaijan and Armenia, which have fought two wars over the mountainous territory, mainly populated by Armenians.

Since December Armenia has been warning of the risk of a humanitarian crisis in the territory as food and medicine run short due to restrictions on use of the Lachin route.

Blinken also spoke with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and expressed his support for peace talks between the two countries and the need for direct dialogue between them, the department said.

In late June Blinken met in Washington with his counterparts from Armenia and Azerbaijan and reported progress toward ending the dispute but no agreement.

More talks are scheduled for this month under mediation by the European Union.

lb/dax/dw/bfm

Call from Blinken to Aliyev! Support for peace talks with Armenia

India –

In a written statement, US Department of State Spokesperson Matthew Miller said that Blinken reiterated the US “support for the negotiations” between the two countries and emphasized the “need for creativity, flexibility and reconciliation” in the talks.

In the statement, “Minister Blinken underlined the need for free passage of commercial, humanitarian and private vehicles through the Lachin corridor. He emphasized that both sides should maintain the positive momentum in the negotiations for a lasting and dignified peace.” statements were included.

Foreign Minister Blinken stated on Twitter that he had also met with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan.

Blinken shared, “Yesterday I spoke with Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashian to reiterate my strong support for the ongoing efforts to achieve peace with Azerbaijan. The only way to a lasting peace in the South Caucasus is through direct dialogue and diplomacy, and I am determined to help facilitate it.” had used the words.

https://morningexpress.in/call-from-blinken-to-aliyev-support-for-peace-talks-with-armenia/

US Department Of State Believes Armenia, Azerbaijan Narrowed Differences On Peace Deal

URDUPOINT

 (@FahadShabbir) 

The US Department of State believes that a peace pact between Armenia and Azerbaijan is “within reach” after they narrowed the number of issues that remain to be resolved, Spokesperson Matthew Miller said

MOSCOW (UrduPoint News / Sputnik – 13th July, 2023) The US Department of State believes that a peace pact between Armenia and Azerbaijan is “within reach” after they narrowed the number of issues that remain to be resolved, Spokesperson Matthew Miller said.

Miller was asked Wednesday to clarify what his Department meant by saying that “the peace is within reach,” “agreement is within reach” following the June talks between the foreign ministers of the two rival nations in Arlington.

“We have meant when we say it’s within reach is that they have made significant progress on a number of issues. Even in the last meeting, they narrowed the number of issues that remain unresolved,” he told a news briefing.

“And so we think with a dwindling number of issues to resolve, the agreement’s within reach, but that involves � that of course would involve both parties being willing to compromise,” Miller added.

Secretary of State Antony Blinken spoke separately with Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan this week to express continued US support for the Armenia-Azerbaijan talks and stress the need to keep up the positive momentum toward a durable peace in the South Caucasus.

Armenia and Azerbaijan have fought two wars over Nagorno-Karabakh, an Armenian-majority region wedged in between the two countries where both have a military presence. The decades-long conflict reignited in fall 2020, marking the worst escalation since the 1990s. Hostilities ended in a Russia-brokered ceasefire and deployment of Russian peacekeepers to the region.

https://www.urdupoint.com/en/world/us-department-of-state-believes-armenia-azer-1722905.html

Armenian Airline Operates First Flight to IKIA

Financial Tribune, Iran

Fly Arna Airlines operated its first flight from Armenia to Imam Khomeini International Airport on July 11, according to Mohammad Reza Fardi, the acting deputy head of Imam Khomeini International Airport.

Fardi added that the airline will operate the flights twice a week.

Fly Arna is the third Armenian airline that operates flights from Armenia to IKIA, the news portal of the Ministry of Roads and Urban Development reported.

https://financialtribune.com/articles/domestic-economy/119153/armenian-airline-operates-first-flight-to-ikia

We Remember Dr. Richard Hovannisian, 90, an Esteemed Historian and Chronicler of the Armenian Genocide

Wed, 07/12/2023 – 12:10pm

The USC Shoah Foundation mourns the passing of our friend Dr. Richard Gable Hovannisian, a scholar who devoted his life to chronicling the 1915 Armenian Genocide and donated the more than 1,000 survivor and witness testimonies he amassed to the USC Shoah Foundation. He was 90.

Born to Armenian Genocide survivors in Tulare, California, in 1932, Dr. Hovannisian was initially discouraged from learning his parents’ language and knew little about Armenian history.

After receiving a B.A. in History from UC Berkeley and an M.A. and Ph.D. from UCLA, Dr. Hovannisian joined the UCLA faculty in 1962 and later—inspired by his travels to the Middle East—founded the university’s first Armenian history programs.

In 1969 he created the UCLA Armenian Genocide Oral History Project, an initiative for his students to record and transcribe audio interviews with Armenian Genocide survivors, primarily in the Los Angeles area. Over the next 50 years, Dr. Hovannisian and his students amassed more than 1,000 testimonies in what is believed to be the largest collection of its kind in the world.

In a 2011 interview with the UCLA Daily Bruin, Dr. Hovannisian described his motivation in capturing the experiences of as many Armenian Genocide survivors as possible.

“I grew up with that generation of survivors, and I thought they’d be around forever,” he said. “Then I looked left, and I looked right, and they were disappearing.”

In 2018, Dr. Hovannisian entrusted the Armenian Genocide Oral History Collection to the USC Shoah Foundation in order that the interviews be preserved and made publicly available in perpetuity. The collection consists primarily of full-life histories which illuminate Ottoman-Armenian life, the Genocide and post-Genocide era, and the diaspora experience. Survivors are from all over the Ottoman Empire, and many interviewees are from the former Russian and Persian empires. Testimonies are mostly in Armenian and English, with some in Turkish and Spanish.

To date, more than 600 testimonies have been integrated into the Visual History Archive (VHA), where they are searchable with keywords at access sites around the world.  Indexers are currently working to integrate the remaining testimonies into the archive.

Speaking at a USC event in 2019, the esteemed academic described the cumulative force of the 1,040 testimonies he and his students recorded.

“The quality of these interviews is mixed. One interview may not be that great, but when you put them together, it’s in the collectivity of the testimony that you have the strength of it. It’s with the collectivity of it that you feel the real horror, the terror, of what genocide is, and how extensive it can be from one end of a country to another. And how cruel it can be. Cruelty after cruelty after cruelty.”

The Armenian Genocide Oral History Collection joined the 330 testimonies that had been donated to the USC Shoah Foundation by filmmaker J. Michael Hagopian and the Armenian Film Foundation in 2010. Together they constitute the largest non-Holocaust-related collection in the USC Shoah Foundation’s 56,000-strong VHA.

USC Shoah Foundation Finci-Viterbi Executive Director Chair Dr. Robert J. Williams spoke of the importance of Dr. Hovannisian’s donation and his contribution towards the understanding of the Armenian Genocide.

“Dr. Hovannisian’s illustrious career as a historian bequeathed an important and unparalleled legacy,” Dr. Williams said. “Thanks to his foresight, and the significant partnership he developed with the USC Shoah Foundation, the Visual History Archive now contains more than 600 Armenian testimonies that scholars, researchers, and others around the world can use in their work for many years to come.”

The USC Institute of Armenian Studies issued a statement Tuesday praising a man they described as “a titan in the field of Armenian Studies.”

“[Dr. Hovannisian] lived the life of a public intellectual,” the statement said. “He became a historian with a mission—to promote the study of the Armenian Genocide as a consequential 20th-century event. His research and publications cemented the place of the first Republic of Armenia in Armenian history and world history…His name has been omnipresent in academia for nearly seven decades, making space for Armenian scholars at institutions once out of reach.”

Over the course of his distinguished career, Dr. Hovannisan authored a number of books including Armenia on the Road to Independence (1967), The Republic of Armenia, Volumes I-IV (1971-1996), and The Armenian Holocaust (1980).

He was a Guggenheim Fellow and served on the board of directors of organizations including Facing History and Ourselves, the International Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide, and the Society for Armenian Studies, which he co-founded.

In 1998 Dr. Hovannisian was honored by the president of the Republic of Armenia with the Movses Khorenatsi medal and in 2002 received the Republic’s Medal of St. Mesrop Mashtots. He was also highly active in political commentary and a voice for the Armenian diaspora in Los Angeles and across the United States.

Dr. Hovannisian is survived by his children, Raffi, Armen, Ani, and Garo, all of whom are active in the Armenian community. Raffi is a politician in Armenia and the country’s first foreign minister and Ani produced The Hidden Map, a documentary about her journey to her ancestral homeland, which aired on PBS in 2021.

In this clip from a 2015 interview, Dr. Hovannisian discusses the emotions expressed by Armenian genocide witnesses in their testimonies

https://sfi.usc.edu/news/2023/07/35336-we-remember-dr-richard-hovannisian-90-esteemed-historian-and-chronicler-armenian

​Dmitry Trenin: “Russia ready for a new format of relations with Armenia”

Armenia –

Dmitry Trenin: “Russia ready for a new format of relations with Armenia”


Dmitry Trenin

Mediamax’s interview with Dmitry Trenin, research professor of the Faculty of World Economy and World Politics at the Higher School of Economics and leading researcher at the Center for International Security of the National Research Institute of World Economy and International Relations of the Russian Academy of Sciences.

 

Dmitry Trenin was Director of the Carnegie Moscow Center from 2008-2022.

 

– In your article “Russia’s allied policy: What to do and what to change?” published in late August 2020, about a month before the war, you wrote that Armenia’s value for Russia is not too big. Can we say that after the defeat in the 2020 war, Armenia’s value has further decreased?

 

– I think, first of all, it is not that Armenia has changed, but the general situation in the region. The changes inside Armenia were rather a consequence of what happened during the war and what changed the balance of power in the South Caucasus.

 

Today, Russia’s position has changed not only towards Armenia but the South Caucasus in general.

 

I will not say that a disaster occurred for Russia, but in any case, the changes are serious. Today, Turkey is probably a more significant player in the South Caucasus than Russia. In addition, in the context of the war in Ukraine, Western countries, primarily the United States and partly the United Kingdom, began to attach much more importance to the post-Soviet space in case when they distanced themselves from the 2020 war. In general, this war was very peripheral for the Western political class and, in general, for Western society – little was written about it, little was said or thought about it. But now, after Russia’s involvement in the Ukrainian developments, the West thinks there is an opportunity and a need to expand the geopolitical pressure with access to the Caucasus, Middle and Central Asia.

 

– In the same article you wrote: “The main value of the position on Armenia is in the possibility of maintaining relative stability in Transcaucasia, the balance between Azerbaijan and Armenia, and deterring Turkey’s ambitions. Today, this balance no longer exists.

 

– Actually, Russia cannot play this game anymore. For many years it had the opportunity to act as a balancer and believed that it could – as the Americans do in the Middle East – sell weapons to one and the other, control the situation in the zone of extinguished or frozen conflict and thus maintain its position in the South Caucasus, not allowing regional powers such as Turkey and world powers such as the United States or even China enter the region. Now Russia does not have such an opportunity, so there can be no talk of any balance between Azerbaijan and Armenia.

 

At the same time, Russia is interested that a solution be found to the problem of Armenian-Azerbaijani relations. Peace creates more opportunities for Russia than war. If earlier it was possible to say that Russia benefited from this conflict, although I think this is not quite true, now it hopes that a peaceful settlement will create some conditions: first of all, by intensification of economic relations, creation of new transport opportunities, including through the territory of Armenia. We should also keep in mind that the relations between Russia and Georgia have warmed up a bit recently. This is also an interesting factor.

 

– How fair is the opinion that the fate of the South Caucasus is decided not in the region itself, but in Ukraine? In the sense that after the outbreak of war in Ukraine, Russia does not want or is unable to play the role it had in the first post-war phase.

 

– I agree with that point of view. But when we say that everything depends on the outcome, we assume that the outcome is somewhere close. But the outcome is very far away, we are probably talking about years. The conflict in Ukraine may freeze on some point for a while, but it will not change the state of hybrid war between Russia and the West. The situation will remain in limbo without a clear final outcome for a long time.

Dmitry Trenin

 

Obviously, priorities have now changed a lot, and we have to mobilize resources in the most important areas. The luxury that Russian foreign policy used to have will no longer exist.

 

– And the need for Russia to take into account Turkey’s interests in the region will only grow?

 

– Of course, Turkey remains a very important country for Russia, and the need to take Turkish interests into account, of course, remains. I would also add that Russia has obvious interests in Azerbaijan, and these interests have grown: I mean the North-South corridor which is also one of the connecting threads between Russia and the economies of the Near and Middle East, India, Iran. This is also of strategic importance for Russia. With Europe no longer being Russia’s main economic partner, there is a need to interact more closely with Azerbaijan. The importance of Armenia as a military outpost in relation to Turkey is much smaller in the current conditions. This does not mean that Russia has stopped being interested in Armenia and would like to close this “unpromising direction”. There is nothing of the sort. There is a willingness to work with the government that exists in Armenia, understanding its aspirations and its limitations.

 

– Many people in Yerevan ask: in light of the difficult situation Armenia is in, and the growing importance of Turkey and Azerbaijan for Moscow, what can Armenia do, to gain competitive advantages and become more interesting for Russia?

 

– I repeat that Russia has no wish to reduce its presence in Armenia. Armenia today is not a “burden” or “ballast”. In the current circumstances, it is important for Russia to maintain allied relations with Armenia through the CSTO and the EAEU. For this, the relations should be more pragmatic. There is a thing which, if does not disturb the Russian side but somewhat annoys it. This is the resentment against Russia in Armenian society. I believe that Russia does not deserve such criticism. Russia is being asked to, so to speak, harness for Armenia, while Armenia is not going to harness for Russia. Such moments of tension, in my opinion, can be significantly reduced in the case of more pragmatic, more open and more honest relations. I think that Russia is ready for such a new format of relations, which would not be the relations of boss and client, as it was seen by many in Moscow and Yerevan, but the relations of two countries linked by common interests, historical and demographic ties.

Dmitry Trenin

 

You talk about Armenia’s difficult situation. Russia is also in a very difficult situation, with a huge number of sanctions and other forms of pressure from the West. The situation in Russia is quite difficult. It has to wage a hybrid war against the collective West, and I would like Russian partners and allies to understand this, just as Russia understands Armenia. Russia did not obstruct the choice of the Armenian people in 2018, it agreed to live with the government the Armenian people chose. Whatever Putin thinks of the notorious “Sorosians”, he is working with Nikol Pashinyan and quite closely.

 

– You mentioned the CSTO, which, instead of acting as a guarantor of Armenia’s security, today is actually one of the main irritants in Armenian-Russian relations.

 

– I would partly argue with this, saying that the CSTO is of little use to Armenia, but the CSTO does not force Armenia to do anything. CSTO members are Russia’s formal allies, but now when Russia is actually at war with the collective West, they take a neutral position. And Russia accepts this as a fact; no one is demanding that the CSTO be dissolved and no one calls on the CSTO to consolidate around Russia. In this sense Russia acts very adaptively and understands what it can demand from its allies and what it cannot. It is not an ideal tool, of course, but it is a burden that at least does not pull you down. Right, it does not help much either. But leaving the CSTO will bring forth unnecessary losses that will not be compensated. Let’s say Armenia withdraws from the CSTO, what does it mean? Will it become a member of NATO? No, it will not. Will it abandon bilateral military relations with Russia? As I understand it, no, although obviously there are circles that demand the withdrawal of Russian forces. No good alternative is seen for Armenia. Of course, Armenia is the one that determines its own fate, its military-political status, but we should look at the situation from different sides and refrain from emotions. We in Russia also have a lot of emotions not related to the Caucasus and Armenia. This should also be kept in mind.    

 

Ara Tadevosyan spoke with Dmitry Trenin

 

This interview has been prepared as part of a joint project with the Tufenkian Foundation.