Defense Ministry reports ‘relatively stable’ situation on border

 17:51, 1 September 2023

YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 1, ARMENPRESS. The situation on the border has stabilized, the Armenian Ministry of Defense said after a day of intense gunfire from Azerbaijan.

“As of 17:30, the situation on the frontline was relatively stable,” the Defense Ministry said, adding that it would provide updates in case of any changes in the situation.

4 Armenian soldiers were killed and one was wounded when Azerbaijani armed forces opened small arms fire, and launched mortar and UAV strikes at Armenian border outposts in Gegharkunik province.

Four Armenian soldiers killed in clash with Azerbaijan

POLITICO
Sept 1 2023

EU-funded project in Armenia organises camp for children from mine-affected families

Sept 1 2023

This August, an EU-supported summer camp for children from mine-affected families and communities was held in Armenia. The activity was organised in Dilijan (Tavush marz) within the framework of the project on ‘Strengthening National Mine Action Capacity in Armenia’, funded by the European Union and implemented by the UNDP. 

Sixty children from Gegharkunik, Tavush, Syunik, and Vayots Dzor marzes, aged 12 to 15, took part in the camp. They were selected mainly from mine and explosive ordnance (EO) affected border communities, from families with direct mine/EO victims. 

The aim of the initiative was to educate children about the risks of mines/EOs and safe behaviour and to improve their physical, mental and psychological well-being. 

Children learnt about mine action, were taught first aid and safety rules for shelling and shooting, received critical thinking training, and participated in other activities. 

Find out more

Press release

https://www.einnews.com/pr_news/653276420/eu-funded-project-in-armenia-organises-camp-for-children-from-mine-affected-families

Commentary: Armenians are starving at Azerbaijan’s hands. Why isn’t Biden doing more to help?

The Brunswick News
Sept 1 2023

Last year on World Food Day, President Joe Biden reaffirmed his commitment to a world where “no child has to go to bed hungry, no parent has to worry about how to feed their family, and no one has to face food insecurity.” In that same speech, Biden highlighted how the United States had that year alone committed more than $9 billion in lifesaving humanitarian assistance to vulnerable communities around the world.

Sadly, Biden’s pledge is not reaching the Armenians living in Nagorno-Karabakh, who have been locked in a conflict over their homeland with Azerbaijan since the fall of the Soviet Union.

In this latest chapter, since last December the government of Azerbaijan, under the leadership of its petro-dictator Ilham Aliyev, has implemented an illegal blockade of the only road linking more than 120,000 Armenians, including 30,000 children, in Nagorno-Karabakh to the outside world. It is one of the world’s most overlooked and underreported humanitarian crises taking place today.

By limiting access to food, medicine, gas, electricity and other critical supplies to be delivered by the Lachin Corridor, Azerbaijan is on its way to making living conditions so unbearable that Armenians are forced to leave the region.

In August, a 40-year-old resident of Stepanakert, the capital of Nagorno-Karabakh, died of starvation, becoming the region’s first reported victim of chronic malnutrition and protein deficiency. The lack of food has also contributed to the number of early-stage miscarriages, which reportedly have nearly tripled this summer.

Using food as a weapon has become a popular tool for autocrats to disrupt the lives of innocent people while trying to force concessions that benefit their interests. Russia’s Vladimir Putin has effectively held the global food supply hostage by attacking Ukraine’s ports and crippling grain exports via the Black Sea, as together the two countries export 30% of the world’s wheat, 60% of the world’s sunflower oil and 20% of the world’s corn.

Azerbaijan is turning to a similar playbook in trying to force its will on the Armenian people by attempting to break their spirit and resolve through food. Biden has steadfastly held Russia accountable for its egregious behavior, and the State Department has been working with European Union officials to attempt to reopen the Lachin Corridor. But those efforts have so far failed.

The lack of leadership from the White House has led other actors on the world stage to fill that void. In August, Luis Moreno Ocampo, former chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, released an explosive report stating that when assessing the Azerbaijani blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh, “there is a reasonable basis to believe that a genocide is being committed.” And, the report states, “Without immediate dramatic change, this group of Armenians will be destroyed in a few weeks.”

Having been victims of genocide in the 20th century, Armenians know all too well the horrors of such crimes against humanity and feel their voices and concerns are once again being ignored and sacrificed at the altar of realpolitik.

That type of international gamesmanship was evident at the United Nations last month when the Security Council held an emergency meeting to discuss the worsening humanitarian situation after Armenia urged the global community to help end the blockade. While France and other countries used the opportunity to highlight the principles of international law and humanitarianism as reasons to lift the blockade, other delegations — such as Great Britain, which has significant oil investments in the country — held back on condemning Azerbaijan.

And despite the evidence on the ground, Azerbaijan’s U.N. representative claimed that Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh were happy and well-fed by sharing printouts of Instagram posts that allegedly showed Armenians getting married and celebrating birthdays.

For Biden, as a president who took office claiming that human rights would be central to his foreign policy, this tragedy threatens to stain his legacy.

So, what can he do? For starters, he can begin by unequivocally calling for an immediate end to the blockade and apply pressure on Azerbaijan through sanctions, as Rep. Adam B. Schiff has called for. He can enforce Section 907 of the Freedom Support Act that bans U.S. aid to the Azerbaijani government — restrictions that he, like presidents before him, has waived each year since becoming president. And he can direct Samantha Power, the administrator of the United States Agency for International Development, to allocate more resources and money toward helping Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh.

The U.S. enabling of Azerbaijan’s authoritarianism is now costing lives and giving Azerbaijan cover to do what it wants with impunity. Time is running out for the Armenian people living in Nagorno-Karabakh. If Biden truly believes that no child should go to sleep hungry, then he’ll need to act with far greater urgency to break Azerbaijan’s blockade.

____

ABOUT THE WRITER

Stephan Pechdimaldji is a communications strategist living in the San Francisco Bay Area. He is a first-generation Armenian American and grandson of survivors of the Armenian genocide.

https://thebrunswicknews.com/news/world_news/commentary-armenians-are-starving-at-azerbaijan-s-hands-why-isn-t-biden-doing-more-to/article_87b0880e-1d3f-5e4a-88ee-ddf740a970f9.html


Opinion | Is Armenians’ Ethnic Cleansing Happening Once More?

VIGOUR TIMES
Sept 2 2023

The war in Ukraine is already horrifying, with Russian torture chambers and the slaughter of civilians. However, there is another country taking advantage of the chaos to commit its own crimes against humanity.

Allow me to introduce Azerbaijan.

You may not be familiar with Azerbaijan’s brutality towards the ethnic Armenian enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh, but it definitely deserves our attention. Luis Moreno Ocampo, the former chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, who I’ve known since he sought accountability for the genocide in Sudan’s Darfur region, now compares the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh to a genocide.

In a recent report, Ocampo wrote, “There is an ongoing genocide against 120,000 Armenians living in Nagorno-Karabakh.”

When we think of genocide, we typically imagine mass killings. However, according to the 1948 Genocide Convention, it encompasses a broader definition that includes “acts committed with intent to destroy” a specific ethnic, racial, or religious group, even without mass killings.

Ocampo argues that Azerbaijan is carrying out this genocide by blockading Nagorno-Karabakh, causing people to die or flee and effectively erasing an ancient community. Starvation, he emphasizes, is the invisible weapon of genocide. Without immediate intervention, he warns that this group of Armenians will be destroyed within weeks.

Labeling this as genocide is of critical importance, according to Ocampo. It is crucial for the United States, Britain, and other world powers to step up pressure on Azerbaijan.

The concept of genocide emerged in response to the mass killings of Armenians by the Ottoman Empire in 1915 and 1916, making Azerbaijan’s starvation tactics a chilling echo of history. Organizations like Genocide Watch, the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention, and the International Association of Genocide Scholars have all issued warnings about the risk of genocide and called for Azerbaijan to be held accountable for its crimes against humanity.

The crisis began when Azerbaijanis began blockading the only road into Nagorno-Karabakh, the Lachin corridor to Armenia, which is essential for the territory’s supply of food and medicine.

Reports from Nagorno-Karabakh paint a bleak picture. “People are fainting in the bread queues,” says a local journalist quoted by the BBC. The Halo Trust, a nonprofit dedicated to clearing minefields, had to suspend operations because its staff were too exhausted from queuing for bread all night and returning home empty-handed. A third of deaths in Nagorno-Karabakh are attributed to malnutrition, according to local authorities. While I cannot independently verify these reports, the evidence suggests a dire situation that is worsening day by day.

Unfortunately, it seems that the West is fatigued and focused on its own internal issues. It has shown little attention to global crises beyond Ukraine, from atrocities in Ethiopia to Sudan’s warlords slaughtering civilians. Dictators find this to be an opportune time to commit war crimes.

To understand the conflict, it’s essential to note that authoritarian Azerbaijan has a predominantly Muslim population speaking a Turkic language, while Nagorno-Karabakh has a mostly Christian population that speaks Armenian. When the Soviet Union collapsed, Nagorno-Karabakh sought independence. A war ensued, ending with a stalemate where the enclave operated autonomously but maintained close ties with neighboring Armenia. In 2020, Azerbaijan waged a brief war, retaking most of the enclave and now aiming to reclaim the rest, likely intending to displace much of the ethnic Armenian population.

While the world, including Armenia’s prime minister, recognizes that Nagorno-Karabakh’s sovereignty belongs to Azerbaijan, Azerbaijan argues for the political and economic integration of the territory with the rest of the country. However, what Azerbaijan is doing is not integration; it is starvation. Both the United States and Russia agree that Azerbaijan should reopen the Lachin corridor and end the suffering.

One potential compromise is outlined by Benyamin Poghosyan of the Applied Policy Research Institute of Armenia. Azerbaijan would open the Lachin road while Nagorno-Karabakh simultaneously opens one or more roads into Azerbaijan. The U.S. State Department hinted at this approach in a statement condemning the blockade. As part of the compromise, Azerbaijan would guarantee the freedom of Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh.

Admittedly, this compromise is unsatisfactory, as it rewards Azerbaijan for starving civilians, and there is skepticism about Azerbaijan’s promises. However, diplomats often have to devise flawed agreements that are preferable to the alternatives. In this case, a defective deal is better than mass starvation and ethnic cleansing of Armenians.

https://vigourtimes.com/opinion-is-armenians-ethnic-cleansing-happening-once-more/

The Armenian Defense Ministry accused the Azerbaijani Armed Forces of shelling positions on the border.

Sept 2 2023

On Saturday, the Armenian Defense Ministry accused the Azerbaijani side of shelling the positions of the Armenian army located in the direction of the settlement of Norabak (Gegharkunik region of Armenia), the Azerbaijani defense ministry denied this information.

⠀

Earlier on Friday, Yerevan announced four dead soldiers due to shelling on the border, Baku – two wounded. Later, the Armenian Defense Ministry reported that it had received a new medical opinion, according to which, as a result of intensive resuscitation, one of the four servicemen who were considered dead, Narek Poghosyan, had a heartbeat restored. The Ministry of Defense removed him from the list of the dead.

⠀

“On September 2, from 16:00 to 16:10, units of the Azerbaijani Armed Forces opened fire from small arms on Armenian positions located in the Norabak region,” the press service of the Armenian Defense Ministry said.

⠀

In turn, the Azerbaijani Defense Ministry denied this information.

⠀

“The information spread by the Armenian side about the alleged shelling of the units of the Armenian armed forces on the border by the units of the Azerbaijani army on September 2 from 16:00 to 16:10 does not correspond to reality. We categorically refute the information spread by the Armenian Ministry of Defense,” the press service of Azerbaijani Defense Ministry reports.

⠀
Skirmishes periodically take place on the border between Armenia and Azerbaijan. The last serious aggravation occurred on the night of September 13, 2022.

⠀
Last year, Yerevan and Baku, mediated by Russia, the United States and the European Union, began discussing a future peace treaty. At the end of May 2023, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan announced that his country would recognize the sovereignty of Azerbaijan along with the territory of Karabakh, on a total area of 86.6 thousand square kilometers. Azerbaijani leader Ilham Aliyev said that Azerbaijan and Armenia may sign a peace treaty in the near future if Yerevan does not change its position.

https://www.politicallore.com/the-armenian-defense-ministry-accused-the-azerbaijani-armed-forces-of-shelling-positions-on-the-border/37364

Inside the forgotten conflict that threatens to end in mass starvation and genocide

UK – Sept 2 2023
By JOHN VARGA

A resident of the blockaded Armenian enclave in Nagorno-Karanach has told Express.co.uk that people are facing “mass starvation and total hunger” as food supplies run low.

She said that the only readily available food item was bread and that people were fainting from hunger and exhaustion while queuing for up to six hours to buy it.

The Republic of Artsakh is a breakaway state in the South Caucasus, whose territory is internationally recognised as part of Azerbaijan. Its population consists of around 120,000 Armenians who are insisting on the right to self-determination and independence from Baku.

The disputed territory has been at the centre of a decades long conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan, resulting in two major wars that have resulted in the deaths of tens of thousands of people.

In the war of 2020, Azerbaijan recaptured most of the territory it lost in 1994, leaving the Republic of Artsakh with just a fraction of the land it once controlled and isolated from mainland Armenia.

As a part of a trilateral peace agreement, a land corridor was established that connected the Republic of Artsakh with Armenia. Known as the Lachin Road corridor, this route was intended to allow humanitarian aid and food to reach the Armenian enclave in Nagorno-Karabakh.

However, the Azerbaijanis started to blockade the road in December of last year, initially by using environmental activists who claimed they were protesting against ecological damage caused by gold and copper mining in Artsakh.

Despite the protests, the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) was still able to deliver limited supplies of aid, that included food and medication. But in April the Azeris installed checkpoints on their side of the border and since June 15 no humanitarian supplies have been able to get through along the road, leaving the residents of Artsakh in a desperate plight.

Mary Asatryan works as an assistant to the Human Rights Defender of Artsakh in the enclave’s capital Stepanakert. She told Express.co.uk that all spheres of life had been paralysed by the blockade and that hundreds of people were facing starvation.

With most shops and supermarkets closed, the only products readily available to buy are bread, as well as some seasonal vegetables and fruit that local farmers and villagers are able to grow on their land. However once the summer is over, the situation could become even more critical.

“In a few weeks when the growing season is over – and I am talking about tomatoes, cucumbers and potatoes which are staple food products – when those products run out and the growing season ends we will face mass starvation and total hunger,” she said.

Deaths from starvation are already starting to happen. In one recent incident a 40-year-old man from Stepanakert died as a result of chronic malnutrition, protein and energy deficiency.

Ms Asatryan said people were living from day to day as regards food and were having to queue for up to six hours just to buy bread.

“People are fainting a lot, especially while queueing,” she explained. “There is widespread exhaustion and depression – people are stressed and anxious because they don’t know what to expect tomorrow.”

The Azeris have also targeted critical civilian infrastructure, cutting off gas and electricity supplies, as well as access to the internet. More than 80 per cent of the population rely on gas to heat their homes and for cooking.

The Armenians are still able to produce some electricity locally through the Sarsang Hydro Power Plant, but it is not enough to meet all the demands of the population, meaning there are daily rolling blackouts.

Water supplies have also been disrupted, resulting in households going without for over a week in some instances.

“Two weeks ago the water supply to my neighbourhood was cut and I didn’t have water for 6 to 7 days,” Ms Asatryan said.

“I had to get water from my friends. On one occasion my entire day – it was a Sunday – was spent finding water and then queuing for bread. The organisation of normal life, of meeting one’s basic needs takes so much effort now, people don’t have any time for other things – so people are struggling all day long just to meet their most basic needs.”

Ms Asatryan’s organisation closely monitors the health and wellbeing of expectant mothers, who have been disproportionately affected by the blockade.

“Basically we have 2,000 pregnant women in Artsakh – all of them lack proper nutrition, they don’t have rich vitamin diets,” she explained. “It’s not enough to provide for a healthy child and miscarriages have tripled in number through the period.”

The Azeris insist that Artsakh is a part of Azerbaijan and cannot be regarded as an independent state. They say the Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh must accept that reality and live under the direct rule of Baku.

The Armenians, however, believe they will be persecuted by the Azeris if they are forced to give up their right to self-determination, given their long history of ethnic conflict. And that this persecution could have catastrophic consequences.

“The red line for people here would be becoming part of Azerbaijan which they would definitely not tolerate,” Ms Asatryan said. “The level of Armeno-phobia in Azerbaijan is unimaginable and it’s unrealistic to speak of co-existence. Nobody guarantees the security of Armenians under the rule of Azerbaijan given their openly Armeno-phobic rhetoric which has been documented by the European Court for Human Rights.

“How can you place a population of Armenian origin under the rule of an Armeno-phobic regime? There is a clear road to ethnic cleansing and genocide here – that’s what will happen if we think of this scenario.”

Hikmet Hajiyev, a special adviser to Azerbaijan’s President, told the BBC that Armenians would enjoy the same rights as any other Azeri citizen living in the country. He said they would have equal “linguistic, cultural, religious, including municipal rights”.

Azerbaijan also denies that a humanitarian crisis is unfolding. It says it has offered an alternative supply route via the town of Agdam.

“Then afterwards the Lachin road will be opened in 24 hours as well. More roads are better for everybody,” Mr Hajiyev said.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/world/1808294/armenia-azerbaijan-conflict-lachin-road-blockade-starvation-genocide

Turkish Press: Azerbaijani authorities warn Armenia over Lachin: Sources

Sept 2 2023
World  

2023-09-02 14:27:26 | Son Güncelleme : 2023-09-02 17:41:37

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian allows his country to provoke provocations despite its heavy defeat in the Second Karabakh War in 2020, Azerbaijani National Assembly Speaker Adil Aliyev said.

“Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian is playing with fire, on the one hand declaring that he recognizes the territorial integrity of Azerbaijan, including Karabakh, and on the other hand delaying the formalization of his words. Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev has repeatedly emphasized the importance of Nikol Pashinian’s signing the peace agreement,” Aliyev added.

“Armenia’s refusal to recognize Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity is at the root of the current problems. If this does not happen, the demarcation of borders will be protracted. In fact, Armenia should be more concerned about the lack of normalization of relations with its neighboring country,” he stated.

In addition, Aliyev stressed that some international circles still prefer to express the whims of Armenians.

“For 30 years, these groups preferred to keep silent, turning a blind eye to the occupation of Azerbaijani territories and refraining from telling the truth. However, as soon as the occupation of Karabakh ended, they began to openly hide their anti-Azerbaijani policies,” he said.

“This was nothing but a double standard. France’s policy is obvious. In the past years, this state did not hide its sympathies for the occupying Armenia and at least tried to create a certain image of balance. With the election of Emmanuel Macron as President, they completely forgot about the balance,” Aliyev emphasized.

“France completely sided with Armenia during and after the Second Karabakh War. Macron’s unilateral statements, provocative statements by a group of mayors of French cities at the beginning of the Lachin road are steps to promote separatism in Azerbaijan,” he added.

Adil Aliyev also drew attention to the food problems of Armenians in Karabakh. He reminded that two trucks carrying 40 tonnes of flour sent to the region by the Azerbaijani Red Crescent were prevented from entering the region via the Agdam-Kankendi road.

“Armenian authorities and separatists demand the opening of the Lachin road. This is impossible. During the occupation, they used the Lachin road as they knew how, transporting weapons, and laying mines on the roads. The Azerbaijani army put an end to this and a border crossing point was established at the beginning of the Lachin road,” Aliyev said.

“Currently, Karabakh Armenians are using this road and are getting used to being controlled by Azerbaijani border guards at the border crossing point. Now Karabakh Armenians have to make a choice. Either they will live according to Azerbaijani laws or they will leave Azerbaijan,” he stressed.

Tensions in the region increased after the Armenian armed forces opened fire from their positions in the village of Zod in the Basarkecher region on August 31-September 4 on the positions of the Azerbaijani army in Kalbajar.

After Azerbaijan responded to the attack, 4 Armenian soldiers were killed and 1 Armenian soldier was wounded. Azerbaijan’s Ministry of Defence announced that 3 soldiers were wounded in Armenia’s provocation.

Source: Ihlas News Agency

https://www.turkiyenewspaper.com/world/16249

Book: The Righteous and People of Conscience of the Armenian Genocide

HURST: An independent publisher since 1969
Sept 1 2023

The Righteous and People of Conscience of the Armenian Genocide

Gérard Dédéyan
Ago Demirdjian
Nabil Saleh

Shines long-overdue light on the heroic individuals who took action in the face of the Armenian genocide.

This book tells the stories of the Muslims, Christians, Jews and others who made a courageous stand against the mass slaughter of Ottoman Armenians in 1915, the first modern genocide. Foreigners and Ottomans alike ran considerable risks to bear witness and rescue victims, sometimes sacrificing their lives.

Diplomats, humanitarians, missionaries, lawyers and other visitors to the Empire stood up, including Tolstoy’s daughter, Alexandra; Raphael Lemkin, the jurist who first established genocide as an international crime; and the polar explorer Fridtjof Nansen, who recognised and relieved the plight of stateless Armenian refugees. Ottoman subjects—from officials and officers to ordinary townspeople and villagers—faced near-certain death for their entire family by resisting orders and helping Armenians.

Unlike the Righteous of the Holocaust, these heroes have been systematically ignored and erased—a major injustice. Based on fresh research, and hoping to repay a moral debt to Ottoman Muslims who braved everything to rescue the authors’ forebears, this book is an important, moving testament to a grievously overlooked aspect of the Armenian tragedy.

‘[This book] has a real contemporary importance.’ – Labour Hub

Gérard Dédéyan is Professor of Medieval History at the University Paul-Valéry Montpellier III. His many publications include Histoire des Arméniens, which was awarded the Biguet Prize by the Académie française.

Ago Demirdjian is an entrepreneur–philanthropist, born in Lebanon to Armenian parents who escaped the genocide only through the altruism of the Righteous. He is a patron of Tate, The Guggenheim and the Musée d’Art Moderne de Paris.

Nabil Saleh was a novelist and international lawyer, born in Lebanon to an Armenian mother whose parents survived the genocide. His published works include Unlawful Gain and Legitimate Profit in Islamic Law. He died in London in November 2022.

Another Ethnic Cleansing Could Be Underway — and We’re Not Paying Attention

The New York Times
Sept 2 2023
OPINION

NICHOLAS KRISTOF

With its Russian torture chambers and slaughter of civilians, the war in Ukraine is horrifying enough. But what if another country is taking advantage of the distraction to commit its own crimes against humanity?

Meet Azerbaijan.

You probably haven’t heard of Azerbaijan’s brutality toward an ethnic Armenian enclave called Nagorno-Karabakh, but it deserves scrutiny. The former chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Luis Moreno Ocampo, whom I got to know years ago when he sought accountability for the genocide in Sudan’s Darfur region, now describes what is happening in Nagorno-Karabakh in a similar fashion.

“There is an ongoing genocide against 120,000 Armenians living in Nagorno-Karabakh,” he wrote in a recent report.

We tend to think of genocide as the slaughter of an ethnic group. But the legal definition in the 1948 Genocide Convention is broader and doesn’t require mass killing, so long as there are certain “acts committed with intent to destroy” a particular ethnic, racial or religious group.

That is what Azerbaijan is doing, Moreno Ocampo argued, by blockading Nagorno-Karabakh so that people die or flee, thus destroying an ancient community.

“Starvation is the invisible genocide weapon,” he wrote. “Without immediate dramatic change, this group of Armenians will be destroyed in a few weeks.”

“It is critically important to label this as genocide,” Moreno Ocampo told me, and also crucial that the United States and other world powers — including Britain, which has been too quiet — step up pressure on Azerbaijan.

The concept of genocide was developed in part as a reaction to the Ottoman Empire’s mass killing of Armenians in 1915 and 1916, so Azerbaijan’s starvation of Armenians today suggests that history risks coming full circle. The group Genocide Watch has declared a “genocide emergency,” the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention recently issued an “active genocide alert,” and the International Association of Genocide Scholars warned of “the risk of genocide” and called for Azerbaijan to be held accountable for crimes against humanity.

The current crisis began late last year, when Azerbaijanis began blockading the only road into Nagorno-Karabakh, the Lachin corridor to Armenia, on which the territory depends for food and medicine.

The International Court of Justice ordered Azerbaijan to remove the blockade. Instead, the Azerbaijani government established a checkpoint on the road and began blocking even humanitarian aid carried by the International Committee of the Red Cross.


“People are fainting in the bread queues,” the BBC quoted a local journalist as saying from Nagorno-Karabakh. The report added that the Halo Trust, a nonprofit that works to clear minefields, has had to suspend operations “because its staff are too exhausted to work after queuing for bread all night and returning home empty-handed.”

A third of deaths in Nagorno-Karabakh are attributed by the local authorities to malnutrition, the BBC said. I have no way of verifying these reports, but every indication is that the situation is dire — and getting worse by the day.

Yet I fear that the West is fatigued and looking inward, for it has likewise paid little attention to other global crises other than Ukraine, from horrendous atrocities in Ethiopia to Sudan’s warlords’ slaughtering of civilians. For dictators, tragically, this isn’t a bad time to commit war crimes.

The backdrop is that authoritarian Azerbaijan has a mostly Muslim population speaking a Turkic language, while Nagorno-Karabakh has a mostly Christian population that speaks Armenian. When the Soviet Union collapsed, Nagorno-Karabakh sought independence; a war ended with a stalemate in which the enclave operated autonomously but with close links to neighboring Armenia. In 2020, Azerbaijan fought a brief war in which it reclaimed most of the enclave, and it now wants to recover the rest — and, I suspect, to push out much of the ethnic Armenian population.


The world, including Armenia’s prime minister, acknowledges that sovereignty of Nagorno-Karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan. Azerbaijan feels it has a right to integrate Nagorno-Karabakh politically and economically with the rest of the country. Though this is not integration but starvation, and the one point even countries as far apart as the United States and Russia agree on is that Azerbaijan should reopen the Lachin corridor and end the suffering.

One possible compromise to end the looming catastrophe is outlined by Benyamin Poghosyan of the Applied Policy Research Institute of Armenia: Azerbaijan would open the Lachin road and Nagorno-Karabakh would simultaneously open one or more roads into Azerbaijan (which Azerbaijan seeks). The U.S. State Department hinted at this approach in a statement denouncing the blockade. As part of that compromise, Azerbaijan would guarantee the freedom of Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh.

This would be unsatisfying, for it rewards Azerbaijan for starving civilians, and no one could much trust promises from Azerbaijan. But the sad job of diplomats is to devise flawed, much-hated agreements that are better than any alternative outcome, and in this case a defective deal is preferable to the mass starvation and ethnic cleansing of Armenians, again.