YSU chief refuses to meet with opposition MPs

Panorama
Armenia – May 31 2022

Rector of the Yerevan State University (YSU) Hovhannes Hovhannisyan on Tuesday locked his office door from the inside, avoiding a meeting with the opposition lawmakers who entered the university building during daily anti-government protests in Yerevan.

The MPs wanted to talk to the YSU chief about the issues raised by them, including Artsakh’s status and Armenian-Turkish relations.

Hovhannisyan’s spokesperson told the lawmakers that the rector was not in the building.

“We went up to the rector’s office and the male rector, seeing that the deputies were going up, locked the door from the inside,” Hayastan bloc MP Anna Grigoryan said after coming out of the building.

“Mr. Hovhannisyan, you can now open the door and windows for some fresh air. We have come down,” she said.

The MPs wanted to meet with ministers earlier in the day, but the latter also avoided a meeting.

FM: If there was no Artsakh, geopolitical landscape of South Caucasus would radically change

Panorama
Armenia – May 31 2022

Artsakh plays a key role in maintaining the geopolitical balance, Artsakh’s Foreign Minister David Babayan said on Tuesday.

“Artsakh, its very existence, is among the most important factors in maintaining the regional and even global geopolitical balance. If there was no Artsakh, the geopolitical landscape of Transcaucasia would radically change, and after that the same would take place also in the adjacent regions,” he wrote on Facebook.

“This would lead to the situation where maintaining the geopolitical balance by traditional means (a system of geostrategic checks and balances, etc.) will be practically impossible. This will lead to an open, tough and direct confrontation between the centers of power. And what can happen when it is impossible to maintain the geopolitical balance by traditional means and when the great global and regional powers will openly clash with each other? I think the answer is very clear. The world may even be on the brink of nuclear war,” the minister said.

Judge denies request to release oppositionist Avetik Chalabyan

Panorama
Armenia – May 31 2022

Judge Armen Danielyan of the Yerevan Court of Criminal Appeals on Tuesday refused to release opposition activist Avetik Chalabyan from prison, upholding a lower court ruling.

“Naturally, such a decision by Armen Danielyan could be expected,” his lawyer Varazdat Harutyunyan said.

Chalabyan was arrested on May 12 for allegedly trying to pay students of the Armenian National Agrarian University to participate in ongoing anti-government protests in Yerevan. He has denied the charges as politically motivated.

Chalabyan is a co-founder of Arar Foundation, a charity supporting the Armenian army as well as border villages in Armenia and Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh).

The Artsakh president, parliament speaker, MPs and religious leader have called for his release.

Artsakh important factor in maintaining regional, global geopolitical balance – David Babayan

ARMINFO
Armenia – May 31 2022
Marianna Mkrtchyan

ArmInfo.Artsakh, its very existence, is among the most important factors in maintaining regional and even global geopolitical balance, Artsakh Foreign  Minister David Babayan believes.  

“If there was no Artsakh, the geopolitical landscape of Transcaucasia  would radically change, and after that the same would take place also  in the adjacent regions. This would lead to the situation where  maintaining the geopolitical balance by traditional means (a system  of geostrategic checks and balances, etc.) will be practically  impossible. 

“This will lead to an open, tough and direct confrontation between  the centers of power. And what can happen when it is impossible  maintain the geopolitical balance by traditional means and when the  great global and regional powers will openly clash with each other? I  think the answer is very clear. The world may even be on the brink of  nuclear war,” Mr Babayan’s statement reads. 

Police received incentive payments amounting to AMD 6.5mln this month – opposition MP

ARMINFO
Armenia – May 31 2022
Marianna Mkrtchyan

ArmInfo. Police received incentive payments amounting to AMD 6.5mln this month from the taxes paid by Armenia’s taxpayers, Artur Ghazinyan, a member of the  opposition parliamentary faction Armenia, wrote on a Facebook post. 

“Medical workers and teachers did not receive incentive payments, but  policemen did. Nikol [Pashinyan, Armenia’s premier] does not care a  bit about doctors or teachers now. He received their votes last year,  did he not? And police are much more important for him now as  policemen are mercenaries helping him retain power,” Mr Ghazinyan  said. 

According to him, Armenia’s premier will once more deceive teachers  and doctors by speaking of “the former ones and plunder” during the  next election and receive their votes. 

However, the RA Police reports that incentive were paid both before  and after the adoption of the Law on Payments to Public Officers in  2014.

Opposition Armenian MP critical of Armenia`s defense office over soldier`s death

ARMINFO
Armenia – May 31 2022
Marianna Mkrtchyan

ArmInfo. “What decision served as a basis for putting up a tent of the Armenian armed forces on a site vulnerable to the enemy fire?” asks Tigran Abrahamyan of the  opposition parliamentary faction With Honor. 

Azerbaijani mass media have posted pictures allegedly showing the  site where Armenian soldier David Vardanyan was mortally wounded. 

“The pictures show a tent where our servicemen allegedly live. When I  was told that our serviceman was inside when he was shot – and our  servicemen spend the nights in tends in that section – I recalled the  authorities’ assurances that the last section was provided with all  necessary living facilities. 

“Even if the tent had been put up, what decisions were the basis for  putting it up on a site vulnerable to the enemy fire?” Mr Abrahamyan  wrote in a Facebook post.  “Just recall the incentive payments to  police and violence used against citizens and tents and vulnerable  sites on the border. The law-enforcement system is for them an  instrument and the defense of borders has been left at Azerbaijan’s  whim,” the MP wrote. 

According to the official report by the RA Ministry of Defense, on  May 28, at around 10:40 am, units of the Azerbaijani Armed Forces  opened fire from various caliber firearms, including sniper rifles,  at Armenian positions in the southeastern part of the  Armenian-Azerbaijani border, as a result of which conscript, Private  David Vahan Vardanyan received a gunshot wound. He was hospitalized  but died later. 

In its turn, the Azerbaijani defense office is giving assurances that  the Azerbaijani side has nothing to do with the Armenian soldier’s  death. His death was the result of personal conflict. Armenia’s  defense office did not respond to the Azerbaijani side’s claims or to  Armenian mass media inquiries.

Armenian parliament holding discussions of 2021 state budget implementation

NEWS.am
Armenia – May 31 2022

The National Assembly of Armenia is hosting a joint session of standing parliamentary commissions on Tuesday.

The agenda includes a preliminary discussion of the implementation of the state budget for 2021.

The meeting is attended by the Prime Minister of the Republic Nikol Pashinyan, NA Speaker Alen Simonyan, deputies, members of the government.

Pashinyan: Armenia provides and will continue to support Nagorno-Karabakh

NEWS.am
Armenia – May 31 2022

Armenia will transfer 20 billion drams to Nagorno-Karabakh in 2022. The funds will go towards housing construction. Prime Minister of the Republic Nikol Pashinyan stated this at the National Assembly during a preliminary discussion of the execution of the state budget for 2021 on May 31.

Armenia, according to the leader, renders and will continue to render support to Nagorno-Karabakh.

“In particular, in 2021, all utility payments of the population of Karabakh, within a certain amount for each, as well as all salaries in the public sector, were paid from the state budget of the Republic of Armenia. In general, since November 2020, we have provided support in the amount of 136 billion drams, and we do not intend to stop there,” Pashinyan said.

He noted that in 2019 the state budget of Karabakh amounted to about 118 billion drams. Of these, approximately 58 billion drams were transferred from Armenia. In 2021, the state budget has already amounted to 174 billion drams. Of these, 128 billion drams were provided by Armenia.

“In 2022, these payments will increase to 144 billion drams. In particular, pensions and benefits in Karabakh increased by 20% in 2022,” the PM added.

In addition to current expenses, about 20 billion drams will be allocated for the needs of housing construction. In total, 50 billion drams will be allocated for this in the coming years.

Israel Fails Once Again to Recognize Armenian Genocide but We Make Some Progress including Editorial Support of the Jerusalem Post

From the Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide Jerusalem and Israel W. Charny:

INSTITUTE ON THE HOLOCAUST AND GENOCIDE JERUSALEM FAILS TO
GAIN ISRAEL’S RECOGNITION OF ARMENIAN GENOCIDE FOR APRIL 24, 2022; JERUSALEM
POST 
EDITORAL SUPPORTS RECOGNITION

We want to sum up for you that the several-months campaign of the Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide Jerusalem to influence the Israeli government to recognize the Armenian Genocide as of April 24, 2022 failed to achieve its goal, but we can hope nonetheless that it left some positive influences which will yet be helpful in the future. We are pleased to share with you that we were supported – though a few days after April 24 – by a strong editorial in the Jerusalem Post whose full text follows here.
JERUSALEM POST EDITORIAL (April 30, 2022).
TIME FOR ISRAEL TO NOT FEAR TURKEY AND RUSSIA AND RECOGNIZE GENOCIDE: 
ISRAEL’S APPROACH TO THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE IS TOO SIMILAR TO THE WAY IT HAS MANAGED ITS POSITION 
ON THE RUSSIAN INVASION OF UKRAINE. https://www.jpost.com/opinion/article-705543

Last week, Israel marked Yom Hashoah, Holocaust Remembrance Day, to commemorate the genocide and murder of six million Jews by the Nazis.

Newspapers, TV shows and radio airwaves were filled with stories of the survivors – and the country paid attention.

It makes sense. The story of the establishment of the State of Israel is intertwined with the Holocaust. Survivors flocked to the country after the war, helped build it, fought for it in subsequent wars and deserve a large deal of credit for Israel’s spectacular success.

Last Sunday, though, a day was marked around the world, that went largely unnoticed in Israel. It was the 107th anniversary of the start of the Armenian Genocide that commemorates the 1.5 million Armenians who were deported, massacred or marched to their deaths in a campaign of extermination by the Ottoman Empire.

US President Joe Biden issued a statement to commemorate the massacre, which he termed a “genocide” for the first time last year, in line with a promise he made on the campaign trail.

“We renew our pledge to remain vigilant against the corrosive influence of hate in all its forms,” the president said. “We recommit ourselves to speaking out and stopping atrocities that leave lasting scars on the world.”

Turkey, as expected, responded angrily, calling Biden’s remarks “statements that are incompatible with historical facts and international law.”

Israel was noticeably quiet, and it is a silence that is a stain on the Jewish state. It shows how once again Jerusalem is preferring diplomatic and security interests over standing up for what is true and right, especially being a people that knows genocide firsthand.

As Prof. Israel Charney, one of the founders of the International Association of Genocide Scholars, wrote in these pages last month, Israel should not fear Turkey.

“Is it so beyond our imagination as Israelis to be able to say to Turkey at this time, ‘We have every respect for you as an important country and are happy to work closely with you, but we owe our own culture the clear cut responsibility to identify with a people whose historical record shows that they were subject to governmental extermination’?” Charney asked.

The continued Israeli refusal to recognize the Armenian genocide comes as Jerusalem is renewing diplomatic ties with Turkey. President Isaac Herzog recently visited Ankara and Israel obviously does not want to undermine those efforts.

What makes this wrong is that even when Israel’s ties with Turkey had hit rock bottom due to Erdogan’s vile antisemitism, the government also refused to recognize the Armenian genocide then. The reason was that it was better not to do something that would derail the chance for rapprochement. In other words, when ties are bad the timing is bad – and when ties are better the timing is also bad.

In 2019, after the US Senate recognized the genocide, Yair Lapid – then in the opposition – called on Israel to follow suit. He even proposed a bill that would obligate Israel to mark the day.

“It’s time to stop being afraid of the Sultan in Turkey and do what is morally right,” he tweeted at the time.

If it’s time to stop being afraid of the “Sultan in Turkey,” then why did Lapid not put out a statement last week? Why did he not order the Foreign Ministry to publicly mark the day?

Is doing “what is morally right” no longer the right thing to do?

The answer is obvious. What is easy to push for in the opposition is harder to do when you are foreign minister.

This is wrong. Israel’s approach to the Armenian genocide is too similar to the way it has managed its position on the Russian invasion of Ukraine, on the one hand offering support to Kyiv but on the other hand holding back from sanctions against Russia and public condemnations of President Vladimir Putin.

Policy on Ukraine has been dictated by security interests and the need to be able to continue operating in coordination with Russia in Syria. With the Armenian genocide, Israel is again letting diplomatic and security interests get in the way of what is the right and moral stance to take.

It is time for Israel to stop being afraid of Turkey and Russia. Standing up for what is moral and right strengthens nations. It is Israel’s time to do so.

__________________________

Enclosed please find an up to date flyer (see the attached CANCEL ALL LECTURES ON THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE! DO NOT ALLOW ARMENIANS TO PARTICIPATE AS LECTURERS!) and order form for ISRAEL’S FAILED RESPONSE TO THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE. 

The book has received powerful reviews and recognition around the world.  Thus, a review by the Catholic University in Lile, France hails the “exemplary courage” with which we stood up to government efforts to prevent lectures on the Armenian Genocide or by Armenian scholars at the famous First International Conference on the Holocaust and Genocide.  The Conference has also been hailed in an article in the Yale Review as a milestone in the battle for academic freedom.  We also anticipate shortly the completion of a contract with a publisher in Armenia for an edition in Armenian.

Prof. Israel W. Charny, Ph.D.
Clinical Psychologist & Family Therapist; Executive Director, Institute on
the Holocaust & Genocide, Jerusalem.  Residence &
Office: Yefe Nof 1/832, Moshav Shoresh 9086000 Israel   
Tel: 972-2-672-0424   
Hebrew University of Jerusalem & Tel Aviv University; Past
Founding President Israel Family Therapy Association; Past President
International Family Therapy Association; Co-Founder & Past
President International Association Genocide Scholars (IAGS);
Awarded Armenia’s Presidential Prize

Israel’s Failed Response to the Armenian Genocide, by Israel W. Charny.Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2021, 288 pages; $26.95. “Charny is one of the
founders of the modern study of genocide and a strong fighter for the Armenians
against the denial of their genocide by the Turks. This is a brilliant book by
a scholar and activist that tells a tale full of flame and fury but with a
wisdom accumulated over nearly a century of living the ethics that he upholds –
Charny is indefatigable, relentless and humanitarian.”  -Jack Nusan Porter,
Harvard University, Review in Jerusalem Post & Jerusalem
Report
 .
“With exemplary courage.” -Catholic University, Lile, France
 

 

Prof. Israel W. Charny, Ph.D.
Clinical Psychologist & Family Therapist; Executive Director, Institute on
the Holocaust & Genocide, Jerusalem.  Residence &
Office: Yefe Nof 1/832, Moshav Shoresh 9086000 Israel   
Tel: 972-2-672-0424   
Hebrew University of Jerusalem & Tel Aviv University; Past
Founding President Israel Family Therapy Association; Past President
International Family Therapy Association; Co-Founder & Past
President International Association Genocide Scholars (IAGS);
Awarded Armenia’s Presidential Prize

Israel’s Failed Response to the Armenian Genocide, by Israel W. Charny.Boston: Academic Studies Press, 2021, 288 pages; $26.95. “Charny is one of the
founders of the modern study of genocide and a strong fighter for the Armenians
against the denial of their genocide by the Turks. This is a brilliant book by
a scholar and activist that tells a tale full of flame and fury but with a
wisdom accumulated over nearly a century of living the ethics that he upholds –
Charny is indefatigable, relentless and humanitarian.”  -Jack Nusan Porter,
Harvard University, Review in Jerusalem Post & Jerusalem
Report
 .
“With exemplary courage.” -Catholic University, Lile, France
 

 



Keeping Armenian History Alive

Babson College. MA
May 31 2022

To remember history, especially the dark and troubling moments from the past, is a responsibility. The weight of that responsibility, says Eileen Melkonian ’23, falls particularly hard on Armenians.

“If history is forgotten, it is doomed to be repeated again,” Melkonian says.

Making sure the Armenian genocide, one of the most horrific events of the 20th century, is not forgotten is important to Armenians such as Melkonian. As many as 1.2 million people lost their lives, and many thousands of others were exiled, in a systematic campaign of killing and deportation that began in 1915 by the old Ottoman Empire.

Today, the horrors of the genocide can often feel lost to time and overshadowed by the other genocides that have tragically followed, and Turkey, the modern-day successor to the Ottoman Empire, refuses to recognize what happened. The United States only formally recognized the Armenian genocide last year.

The genocide, however, is not something Armenians will allow to fade into the past. “God forbid, no one will know our history,” Melkonian says. “We spread as much information as we can. Every Armenian has a duty to do this. They have a duty to spread awareness on behalf of the culture.”

Eileen Melkonian ’23, co-president and co-founder of the Armenian Student Association at Babson

Melkonian and her friend, Nairi Enright ’24, are the co-presidents and co-founders of the Armenian Student Association at Babson. The small but active student group, which has roughly 10 members, is, in part, a social organization. It organizes events and networks with other Armenian student groups. “It’s always great to meet other Armenians,” Melkonian says. “There are not a lot of Armenians in the world, unfortunately.”

But, raising awareness about Armenian culture and history, particularly the genocide, is a main concern, one that has led Melkonian and Enright to petition Babson to include more about the genocide in appropriate College coursework.

“It leaves you with a sick feeling that your history is being left out. It’s upsetting. It’s sad. You don’t understand why,” Enright says. “We want to limit that. The genocide is a big part of history. People need to be educated about this.”

The importance of Armenian culture and history was instilled in Melkonian and Enright as they were growing up. Melkonian was born in the U.S. to Armenian immigrants, her mother a refugee from Baku, the capital of Azerbaijan, a country where a number of anti-Armenian attacks broke out in the late 1980s. In 1990, in what’s known as the Baku pogroms, seven days of attacks were aimed at Baku’s Armenian residents, essentially clearing them from the city. “She came here (to the U.S.), with $10 in her pocket and started a life,” Melkonian says.

Melkonian grew up in a traditional household eating lots of Armenian food. Her parents were strict, a direct result of their experiences. “I was watched over very closely,” she says. “My parents went through a lot of hardships. The mentality they came to America with was, you always have to be safe. They saw the world by what events happened to Armenians back then.”

Nairi Enright ’24, co-president and co-founder of the Armenian Student Association at Babson

Learning that history left an impression on Melkonian. “That inspired me to fight for Armenian rights and education,” she says.

Enright was born in Armenia and immigrated to the U.S. as a baby. Her grandmother taught her how to cook Armenian foods, and her grandfather founded the Armenian elementary school she attended. From an early age, Enright attended genocide remembrance events. Held annually on April 24, those events typically bring together the entire Armenian community. “We march together,” Enright says. “It’s really powerful and really emotional.”

Enright learned that being an Armenian came with an obligation. “If you don’t know the history and the culture, then who will keep the language alive? Who will keep Armenia alive?” she says. “Growing up, it was stressed to me to have ties to Armenian family, to always speak the language.”

Enright and Melkonian first met while attending Lexington High School in suburban Boston, and then reconnected at Babson, where they carried with them a need to tell the Armenian story.

That story, unfortunately, can sometimes seem missing. At Babson, Melkonian grew frustrated when the Armenian genocide wasn’t mentioned in several courses (in history, human rights, and law) where she felt it was a natural fit. “Those topics are relevant when talking about the Armenian genocide,” she says. “I was upset and disappointed. I didn’t know what to do.”

“Babson is making a big effort to support us and make our voices heard.”

Eileen Melkonian ’23

Sharing her concerns with Enright, the two then reached out to Babson administration and eventually met with Lawrence P. Ward, vice president and dean of campus life. “He took the time,” Enright says. “I can’t begin to describe how helpful he was.”

Ward connected Enright and Melkonian to professors and leaders on campus, which allowed them to offer input on how the genocide can be presented in the classroom. Enright and Melkonian already have spoken about the Armenian genocide before a class studying the Cambodian genocide of the 1970s, and they partnered with the College’s Office of Religious and Spiritual Life to put on a community peace circle this past April 24. “Babson is making a big effort to support us and make our voices heard,” Melkonian says.

Melkonian hopes that Armenian students at other colleges will attempt similar actions. “People aren’t as educated about it as other genocides. That is disappointing,” she says. “I hope Armenian students get inspired to bring this to light at their own schools.”