Morning Star, UK Syria’s Kurdish administration calls for talks with Damascus in pivot away from pro-US strategy By Steve Sweeney Nov. 1, 2021 KURDISH leaders in northern Syria issued an appeal for talks with Damascus today indicating a dramatic U-turn from its previous pivot toward the United States. Democratic Union Party (PYD) co-chair Aldar Khalil said talks should take place in the Syrian capital however, without the need to travel to Geneva. “What is wrong with us sitting and deliberating as Syrians and proposing possible solutions to reach a formula…to all issues in Syria,” he said in an interview with Rojava TV. The party, which dominates the Autonomous Administration of North East Syria (AANES) as the Rojava government is formally known, insists that the system operated under its control could be applied to the whole of Syria. Mr Khalil’s pronouncement comes days after Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) second-in-command Cemil Bayik pressed the case for Syrian unity, saying that the future for Kurds lay with Damascus. In an interview with the al-Nahar newspaper last week he said the Syrian government’s demand for all occupying forces to leave the country was “legitimate.” And he welcomed President Bashar al-Assad’s plans for decentralisation announced in April, saying it “opened the door to reconciliation.” It was viewed by many as an attempt to distance the PKK from the Kurdish-led administration in northern Syria and its strategy of seeking recognition from the US and other imperialist powers. But a tour by Syrian Democratic Council co-chair Ilham Ahmed received a lukewarm response, with little in terms of concrete results for the Kurdish administration. The strategy was criticised by a number of sources close to the movement who feared that what was initially badged as a short-term military alliance to defeat Isis was developing into a longer-term political alliance. Ms Ahmed came under fire earlier this year for comments made at a virtual meeting of the US-based Newlines Institute – a CIA cut-out supporting US regime change operations across the world – in which she called for the US to maintain its presence in northern Syria. Kurdish officials have previously stated their desire for talks with Damascus, insisting dialogue has stalled on a number of key issues. Today’s about-turn comes as Kurdish forces fear an imminent invasion by Turkey which has amassed hundreds of military vehicles and hardware in areas under its occupation. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan met US President Joe Biden at the G20 in Rome on Sunday amid fears he was seeking the green light for a new offensive. Last week Damascus mobilised Syrian Arab Army units to the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF)-held Tel Rifaat in anticipation of an attack by Ankara’s forces. T-90 battle tanks and BMP-2 infantry vehicles bearing the Syrian flag were positioned in south-eastern Aleppo as part of defensive build-up.
Category: 2021
Pressure on Turkmen Nationals in Turkey Must Be Stopped.
Human Rights Watch
Nov. 2, 2021
[Their Rights and Freedoms Must Be Secured.]
Statement by Nongovernmental Organizations
02 November 2021
We, representatives of nongovernmental organizations, would like to
express our grave concern over the deteriorating situation for Turkmen
migrants in Turkey – primarily those who criticize Turkmen government
policies. Over the past few weeks many of them have been subjected to
threats, presumably as a result of pressure from the Turkmen
authorities on the law enforcement authorities of Turkey as well as
physical attacks. We call on the Turkmen government to stop this
harassment and call on the authorities of Turkey to uphold their
international legal obligations and ensure the protection of rights
and freedoms of Turkmen nationals residing in Turkey. We urge the
international community to closely monitor this worrying situation and
assist in resolving it. Turkey is one of very few countries to which Turkmen citizens can
travel without a visa and where they may apply and obtain a residence
permit that is renewable on an annual basis. Similar languages and
culture foster auspicious conditions for employment, education, and
successful integration into local communities. According to some
sources, over a million Turkmen nationals reside in Turkey, including
migrant workers, students, and their family members. In recent years, officials in Turkmenistan’s consulates abroad, in
violation of Turkmen law, have refused to renew and replace Turkmen
citizens’ passports, and force Turkmen residents to return to
Turkmenistan in order to renew their Turkmen identity documents. As a
result of this refusal, many Turkmen migrants cannot conform to
migration laws of the countries where they reside, including Turkey. In the past eighteen months the situation has been exacerbated by the
Covid-19 pandemic: due to travel restrictions the number of Turkmen
nationals who are experiencing problems with their documents and are
unable to return to their home country has considerably increased. As
a result, thousands of Turkmen migrants with expired passports in
Turkey cannot exercise their rights to employment, education, health
care, and freedom of movement. They cannot register marriages, births,
and other civic acts. This appalling situation has forced Turkmen migrants in Turkey to
organize a group of civil activists, who requested that the Consulate
fulfill their obligations under the Turkmen and international law to
renew passports. They also criticized the government’s refusal to
acknowledge the presence of Covid-19 infections in Turkmenistan, its
inadequate response to the country’s economic crisis, and the
authorities’ suppression of free speech. People started taking to the
streets to participate in peaceful rallies and sharing their problems
on social media. Many Turkmen nationals and human rights defenders
have repeatedly urged the Turkmen authorities to assist migrants in
legalizing their documents. To the credit of the Turkish migration authorities, for a long time
they had been sympathetic towards Turkmen migrants and had not
penalized them because of expired passports. However, the situation
recently changed: in the course of preparations for the meeting of the
Cooperation Council of Turkic Speaking States, scheduled for 12
November in Istanbul, there has been an increasing number of reports
of arbitrary detention of Turkmen civil activists by the Turkish
police, their placement in deportation facilities and threats of their
immediate deportation to Turkmenistan. Experts[1] believe that the
Turkish authorities are trying to convince Turkmenistan to join the
Council and are making efforts to ensure this happens during the
upcoming session. Changes in the policy pursued by the Turkish
authorities towards Turkey-based Turkmen activists have occurred,
apparently, in response to requests by the Turkmen government, which
seeks to put an end to its nationals’ civic activities abroad. Taking into account that Turkmenistan has a long record of severely
punishing peaceful critics of its government, forcibly returning
activists to Turkmenistan would place them at grave risk of
persecution, including a high risk of arbitrary arrest, torture, and
even enforced disappearance in prisons. A number of recent cases illustrate this dramatic situation. This is
not a comprehensive list because not everyone is willing to disclose
their situation out of concern for the safety of their families in
Turkmenistan. Turkmen authorities are pressuring family members of
Turkey-based activists because of their civic activism. *
When detaining Turkmen migrants, Turkish police reportedly refer to a
list of 25 individuals, which was allegedly handed over to them by
Turkmenistan’s Consulate with a request for their detention and
deportation. Neither the detained activists nor Turkish lawyers
representing them have been able to see the list of 25 activists and
learn about the legal grounds for their detention. Turkmen human
rights defenders have on file a list of 13 individuals (№44/05-5490
dated 1 August), which the Turkmen Consulate sent to the Turkish
police. Despite statements of Turkmen activists and international human rights
defenders, the Turkish authorities have continued to side with staff
of the Turkmenistan’s Consulate. The latter, in turn, are engaged in
creating false and arbitrary complaints against their fellow
countrymen, based on which the Turkish police arbitrarily and
illegally detain Turkmen migrants and threaten to deport them. In addition, there are numerous alarming reports that Turkmen
nationals – supporters of Berdymukhammedov’s government – regularly
attack Turkmen civil activists in Turkey and threaten reprisals
against them and their family members. The complaints that these
activists have filed with Turkish law enforcement and judicial
authorities did not result in effective investigations or
prosecutions, which contributes to impunity and new assaults. **
There is also evidence that supporters of the Turkmen authorities have
routinely threatened and harassed activists in Turkey, and regularly
intimidate young activists on the phone and on the Internet. They
intimidate activists and their relatives with serious threats,
including murder, both in Turkey and Turkmenistan. Activists have
repeatedly filed reports with the Turkish police presenting
screenshots of the threats and giving names of perpetrators, but the
police do not undertake any effective action. These attacks and threats are egregious examples of foreign nationals
persecuting Turkmen activists in Turkey. Inaction by the Turkish law
enforcement authorities in connection with this criminal wrongdoing
cannot be justified and contradicts Turkish and international law. We call on the Turkish authorities:
to halt any plans to deport detained Turkmen activists to
Turkmenistan, ensure they have access to a lawyer, immediately release
them from deportation custody, and allow them to continue with their
steps to regularize their status in Turkey;
to promptly carry out an effective investigation of incidents of
attacks on and intimidation of Turkmen activists in Turkey and hold
those responsible accountable. We hope that Turkey will abide by the rule of law and will not, in
order to advance geopolitical interests, pressure Turkmen activists
and cover up for those violating the law on its territory, at the
behest of illegal demands of Turkmen authorities. The Turkish
authorities must abide by its international obligations and the
fundamental principle of nonrefoulement, which obliges states to
ensure that they do not send anyone to a place where they face a real
risk of torture or other ill-treatment. Turkey is bound by its
obligations to protect fundamental rights and freedoms of people on
its territory and ensure they are not persecuted, and should not be
complicit in gross violations of human rights. We urge intergovernmental organizations and Turkey’s international
partners to draw their attention to this acute situation and call on
Ankara to abide by its obligations under international law and prevent
deportation of Turkmen civil activists to Turkmenistan, including
those who are now in custody. Annadurdy Khadjiev, Turkmen Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights (Bulgaria)
Farid Tukhbatullin, Turkmen Initiative for Human Rights (Austria)
Yuri Dzhibladze, Centre for the Development of Democracy and Human
Rights (Russia)
Adaem Çevik, Adalet Human Rights Platform (Turkey)
Vyacheslav Mamedov, Turkmen Civil Democratic Union (the Netherlands)
Ruslan Myatiyev, Turkmen.News (the Netherlands)
Тimur Misrikhanov, Turkmenistan’s Independent Lawyers Association
(the Netherlands)
Kate Watters, Crude Accountability (USA)
Ivar Dale, Norwegian Helsinki Committee (Norway)
Olga Zakharova, Freedom Files (Poland)
Krassimir Kanev, Bulgarian Helsinki Committee (Bulgaria)
Valentin Gefter, expert with the Presidential Council for the
Development of Civil Society and Human Rights under the President of
the Russian Federation (Russia)
Rachel Denber, Human Rights Watch (international)
Alexander Cherkasov, Human Rights Centre “Memorial”, included by
the Ministry of Justice of Russia in the list stipulated by p. 10 art. 13.1 of the Federal Law “On NGOs” (Russia)
Gerald Staberok, OMCT (World Organisation Against Torture) (international)
Svetlana Gannushkina, Civic Assistance Committee (Russia),
included by the Ministry of Justice of Russia in the list stipulated
by p. 10 art. 13.1 of the Federal Law “On NGOs”
Oleksandra Matviichuk, Center for Civil Liberties (Ukraine)
Artur Sakunts, Helsinki Citizens Assembly – Vanadzor office (Armenia)
Tolekan Ismailova, Human Rights Movement “Bir Duino – Kyrgyzstan”
(Kyrgyzstan)
Eldar Zeynalov, Human Rights Center of Azerbaijan (Azerbaijan)
Lenur Kerymov, Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights (Poland)
Natalia Taubina, Public Verdict Foundation, included by the
Ministry of Justice of Russia in the list stipulated by p. 10 art. 13.1 of the Federal Law “On NGOs” (Russia)
Evgeny Zhovtis, Kazakhstan International Bureau for Human Rights
and Rule of Law (Kazakhstan)
Anara Ibraeva, NGO “Kadyr-Kasiet” (Kazakhstan)
Elena Shakhova, Human rights NGO "Citizens' Watch", St. Petersburg, included by the Ministry of Justice of Russia in the list
stipulated by p. 10 art. 13.1 of the Federal Law “On NGOs” (Russia)
Ucha Nanuashvili, Human Rights Center (Georgia)
Vadim Pivovarov, Association UMDPL (Ukraine)
Alex Postica, Promo LEX (Moldova)
Giorgi Marjanishvili, Center for Participation and Development (Georgia)
Anders Bjurner, Swedish OSCE Network (Sweden)
Sabuhi Gafarov, Human Rights Club (Azerbaijan)
Matthias Hui, humanrights.ch (Switzerland)
Matthew Schaaf, Freedom Now (USA)
Examples of persecution of Turkmen activists in Turkey
* On 27 September a civic activist, Dursoltan Taganova, was detained
and placed in a deportation centre, allegedly because the Migration
Office did not have a document confirming that she holds temporary
refugee status legalizing her stay in Turkey, despite the fact that
the Migration Office had previously granted her this status. Only on
12 October, after publication of appeals by human rights defenders and
the interference of a lawyer, Taganova was released under the pretext
of “a misunderstanding”. In mid-October she was again summoned to the
Migration Office, where officials tried to convince her to revoke her
refugee application which guarantees that she will not be deported. In September 2021, in the presence of witnesses, activist Aziz Mamedov
submitted his passport to the Turkmen Consulate for extension. Since
then he has visited the Consulate three times, but diplomats have not
returned the document, claiming it has been lost. His lawyer is denied
access to the Consulate. Furthermore, every time the activist appears
at the Consulate, diplomats call the police. On 18 October, 2021 47-year-old Akhmed Rakhmanov was sent to a
deportation centre soon after he had visited the Migration Office in
Antalya to extend his residence permit. Rakhmanov, the administrator
of an online chat group for a Turkmen political opposition
group-in-exile, Democratic Choice of Turkmenistan, has repeatedly
criticized the Turkmen regime on YouTube and TikTok and gave comments
to the Turkmen Service of Radio Liberty. He was kept in the Tuzla
deportation facility, where he went on hunger strike on 22 October,
2021. Later on 18 October, 35-year-old Kamil Abulov was taken from his
apartment in Istanbul. Abulov’s spouse was informed by law enforcement
officers that the Turkish authorities have a list of 25 names of
Turkmen activists in Turkey who are at risk of detention at the behest
of the Turkmenistan’s Consulate. Abulov was also placed in the Tuzla
deportation centre. He is known to be one of the Turkmen activists who
had previously been detained by the Turkish police after a failed
rally attempt in front of Turkmenistan’s Consulate in Istanbul on 1
August. On 26 and 27 October 2021, after HRW’s appeal and the lawyer’s
interference, both were released. Police officers were looking for three other Turkmen activists,
including Merdan Badrov, at their registered place of residence in
Istanbul on 20 October 2021, in order to detain them. Fortunately,
they were not at home. On 22 October 2021, Bayram Allalyev was detained in a migration office
in Istanbul, to which he had been summoned to file for a renewal of
his residence permit. While he was filling in the documents, law
enforcement officers detained him. On 1 November, Allalyev was
released from the Pendik deportation centre. ** On 1 August 2021, with the collusion of employees of Turkmenistan’s
Consulate, a violent incident occurred when several activists were
beaten in front of the Consulate by unidentified officials. Two of the
victims had to seek medical help because one of them sustained an
injury to his head with a heavy object. There are solid grounds to
believe that the attackers are connected to Consulate staff because
when asked to return a telephone confiscated from the beaten activist
Aziz Mamedov, the attackers said that they could collect it in the
Consulate. The victims recognized the assailant on dashboard camera
footage. In addition, activist Farkhad Durdyev told human rights
defenders that during the incident he was tricked into entering the
Consulate area and was beaten. In connection with these attacks the
activists are working with lawyers and intend to resolve this issue by
legal means. On 11 October 2021, two activists and a visitor to the office of the
Association of Oghuz Culture, Cooperation and Education in Istanbul,
were attacked by unidentified individuals. This happened after
activists had given an interview to a British journalist. A bag with a
telephone and documents was stolen from the Chairperson of the
Association of Oghuz Culture Nurmukhamed Annayev. Civic activist Aziz
Mamedov was severely punched in the face. First aid was rendered to
the assault’s victims. The activists claim that one of the attackers
resembles a person, who had assaulted Turkmen protesters in Istanbul
on 1 August 2021. This time, according to them, he had “an implement
which looked like a metal knuckle duster” in his hands. The activists
believe that the assault is related to the planned trip of Nurmukhamed
Annayev to the ODIHR/OSCE event scheduled to take place in Warsaw on
14-15 October, where he was going to give a speech criticizing the
Turkmen regime. *****
[1] [What is behind the attacks on Turkmen activists in Istanbul? In
Russian] Что стоит за нападениями на туркменских активистов в
Стамбуле? Radio Azatlyk – Turkmen Service of Radio Liberty, 14.10.2021
; [A Turkmen wheel in a
Turkish cart. Ankara insists on Ashgabat's joining the Turkic Union. In Russian] Туркменское колесо в турецкой телеге. Ankara insists on
Ashgabat's entry into the Turkic Union. Serdar Aitakov, Nezavisimaya
Gazeta, 03.10.2021
AZERBAIJANI press: Armenia tried to appropriate Albanian churches – head of Albanian-Udi community
By Trend
Armenia tried to Armenianize Albanian churches, Chairman of the Albanian-Udi Christian religious community of Azerbaijan Robert Mobili told Trend’s Karabakh bureau during his visit to the Albanian churches in the Chinarli village of the Khojavand district.
According to Mobili, the village has a very rich Albanian cultural heritage.
“The district has two Albanian churches. The largest of them is located in the village of Chinarli, which is part of the administrative territory of Hadrut, and today we visited it. This territory was under Armenian occupation for about 30 years and has been liberated for a year already. Hadrut is a holy place for us, it has several ancient Albanian churches, one of which is in Chinarli,” Mobili said.
“Armenia tried to present them as their own, but the elements of the Albanian church remained on the churches. Thanks to our martyrs and ghazis, today we can safely visit our temples. We will pray for our martyrs, whom we will never forget. Armenia occupied not only our lands but also destroyed most of the monuments of cultural heritage. Our main task today is to restore the Albanian Christian heritage in these territories,” he added.
Turkish press: Azerbaijani president calls for fair distribution of COVID-19 vaccines
BAKU, Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan’s president on Thursday reiterated his call for “equal and universal access to vaccines” as the world continues to fight the coronavirus pandemic.
“We launched the initiative in the United Nations Human Rights Council with respect to equal and universal access to vaccines and fair distribution of vaccines,” said Ilham Aliyev, addressing the 8th Global Baku Forum, titled The World after COVID-19, in the Azerbaijani capital Baku.
“We are one of the countries that openly speaks about issues like vaccine nationalism and unfair distribution of vaccines on a global scale,” he added.
While some countries have already moved to giving out third booster shots, others still have a very low rate of vaccination, he noted.
“Therefore, we need to address this issue in order to create equal opportunities,” he added.
‘Conflict resolved’
On the conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia, Aliyev said that today “the conflict is resolved.”
“Azerbaijan resolves the conflict itself,” he added. “Azerbaijan itself implemented the UN Security Council resolutions adopted in 1993, which demanded the immediate, unconditional withdrawal of Armenian troops from the occupied territories of Azerbaijan.”
“Unfortunately, this resolution remained on paper for 27 years, and probably would have remained on paper for another 27 years if Azerbaijan did not itself restore its territorial integrity using chapter 51 of UN Charter which provides the right to self-defense,” he added.
Relations between the former Soviet republics have been tense since 1991, when the Armenian military occupied Nagorno-Karabakh, also known as Upper Karabakh, a territory internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan, and seven adjacent regions.
New clashes erupted on Sept. 27 last year, with the Armenian army attacking civilians and Azerbaijani forces and violating several humanitarian cease-fire agreements.
During the 44-day conflict, Azerbaijan liberated several cities and some 300 settlements and villages that were occupied by Armenia for almost 30 years.
Prior to this, about 20% of Azerbaijan’s territory was under illegal occupation.
The fighting ended with a Russian-brokered agreement on Nov. 10, 2020 with the cease-fire seen as a victory for Azerbaijan and a defeat for Armenia.
Two months later, the leaders of Russia, Azerbaijan and Armenia signed a pact to develop economic ties and infrastructure to benefit the entire region. It also included the establishment of a trilateral working group on Karabakh.
Energy security
On the completion of the construction of the Southern Gas Corridor, Aliyev said the last segment of the Trans Adriatic Pipeline (TAP) was commissioned on Dec. 31 last year.
“This is a really historical achievement for Azerbaijan, for our neighbors, for Europe because it is an important factor of European energy security, it is an important instrument of diversification,” he said.
He added that Azerbaijan exported more than 14 billion cubic meters of natural gas to five countries, including Turkey, Georgia, Italy, Greece, Bulgaria.
“Almost half of this volume was consumed by consumers of European Union,” he said, adding: “Southern Gas Corridor is a project of energy security of Europe.”
According to a statement from the Azerbaijani presidency, the 8th Global Baku Forum brings together top representatives, including former heads of state and government and officials of international and non-governmental groups from more than 40 countries to discuss issues of global importance.
“The forum will feature panel discussions on topics such as ‘New world order after COVID-19’, ‘New world economy’, ‘In a new era: peace, security and human rights’, ‘Combatting climate change and meeting global energy demand’, ‘Healthcare and vaccination’, ‘Promoting food security’, ‘Eastern partnership and its opportunities’, including the situation in the EU, the Balkans, and the South Caucasus,” it added.
Asbarez: Artak Beglaryan Discusses Artsakh’s Current State of Affairs at Public Forum
Artsakh State Minister Artak Beglaryan (center) with his special advisor Davit Akopyan (right) and attorney Garo Ghazarian during a press conference on Oct. 25
Artak Beglaryan, the State Minister of the Republic of Artsakh, on October 25 held a press conference followed by a keynote address at a public forum organized by the Pan-Armenian Council of Western United States, at the Armenian Society of Los Angeles Center, located in Glendale.
At the press conference, Beglaryan fielded questions from members of the print and television media. He was joined during the conference and public forum by Davit Akopyan, Chief Advisor to Beglaryan.
Zaven Khanjian, Executive Director and CEO of the Armenian Missionary Association of America, which had invited Beglaryan to the United States as the keynote speaker of its annual meeting and banquet, provided introductory remarks welcoming the State Minister, and explained his vital role during Artsakh’s recent history, particularly during the 2020 war of aggression brought on by Azerbaijan, and its aftermath.
- Artak Beglaryan with State Senator Anthony Portantino and Glendale City Councilmember Ardy Kassakhian
- Artak Beglaryan with Glendale Police Chief Carl Povilaitis and the entire command staff of the Glendale Police Department
During the hour-long press conference, moderated by Garo Ghazarian, attorney and co-host of the “Frontlines-Artsakh” program, Minister Beglaryan addressed a broad range of inquiries ranging from the plight of Armenian refugees and prisoners of war to accountability for the funds raised in the diaspora for humanitarian assistance to the Artsakh people.
From 2018 to 2020, Beglaryan served as the Human Rights Ombudsman of Artsakh, before being appointed to his current post as State Minister of the Republic.
- Artak Beglaryan with members of the press
- The Pan-Armenian Council event organizing committee
- Community members attend public forum
Immediately following the press conference, invited guests gathered for a private reception in honor of Minister Beglaryan.
Among those in attendance were Armenia’s Consul General to Los Angeles, Ambassador Dr. Armen Baibourtian, Glendale Police Chief Carl Povilaitis and the entire command staff of the Glendale Police Department, Lena Bozoyan, Chairwoman of the Pan-Armenian Council, and the leadership of the respective PAC members. The attendees toasted in honor of Minister Beglaryan, applauding his exemplary service to the Armenian people of Artsakh, and to the Armenian nation.
The program then continued in the grand hall of the Armenian Society Center where a capacity audience came to listen to Mr. Beglaryan’s remarks. Dr. Vahram Shemmassian, Director and Professor of the Armenian Studies Program at California State University, Northridge, opened the public forum by welcoming the audience and asking them to stand for the playing of the national anthems of the United States of America and the Republics of Armenia and Artsakh.
- Dr. Vahan Shemmasian
- Lena Bozoyan
- Garo Ghazarian
This was followed by a moment of silence in honor of all those who lost their lives last year during the war. Bozoyan then provided an inspiring welcoming address where she emphasized that the struggle for the liberation of Artsakh continues through Beglaryan’s tireless service and his fellow Artsakh citizens toward achievement of the national aspirations of the Armenian people.
In a moving presentation, Ghazarian then introduced Beglaryan by reciting a beautifully penned letter by his daughter Ani, who three years ago, at 17, had described the profound impact Beglaryan had on her and others of her generation, motivating her to seek a career devoted to public service and human rights.
Beglaryan then made his presentation. During the hour-long address, he offered the attendees an outline of his well-developed five-point plan for the future of Artsakh. He emphasized his vision as follows: Security of Artsakh’s borders and its people, education, economic development, repatriation and engagement in the civic life of Artsakh.
He emphasized that if someone calls themselves an Armenian, they must become a part of Artsakh’s life by living there or by offering their particular expertise in service to Artsakh. It is through such full engagement in Artsakh that internationally recognized statehood for the Republic will be achieved.
Beglaryan elaborated on each of these five points covering a broad range of topics from the role of Russian peacekeepers to the legal status of Artsakh. At the conclusion of his formal remarks, Beglaryan responded to approximately twenty questions from audience members, moderated by Ghazarian.
Beglaryan lost his eyesight as a child in 1995, when a landmine he found in his family’s yard exploded. His father had died in battle during the first Artsakh War of Liberation just two years earlier. He then lost his mother at the age of 16 and, it was then that Minister Beglaryan found his life’s purpose and mission.
Beglaryan had studied in Yerevan, at a school for the visually impaired from 1995-2006. Coming home during summer breaks, he had attended the AMAA Camp in Stepanakert and credits his Christian education there as the bedrock of his commitment to public service. He graduated from Yerevan State University in 2010, subsequently studied business management in Thessaloniki, Greece as part of a student exchange program, and took part in international programs and research fellowships in the Czech Republic and Switzerland. He holds a Master’s Degree from the University College London in political science, security, and integration, and he has completed a public policy and administration program in the U.S., at Tufts University, Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy.
“We are so grateful to our very distinguished guest, Minister Artak Beglaryan, who gave our community a frank and thorough analysis of the developments in Artsakh during the past year and his plans for Artsakh going forward. We look forward with great anticipation to continue our work and support of Minister Beglaryan and the Armenians of Artsakh,” said Bozoyan.
The event was followed by a reception.
Menendez Introduces Amendment to Revoke Presidential Waiver of Aid Restrictions on Azerbaijan
Padilla Amendment Calls for Report on Azerbaijani War Crimes; Use of Foreign Mercenaries in 2020 Artsakh Attacks; Menendez Also Calls for Report on U.S. Technology Discovered in Turkish Drones Used Against Armenia/Artsakh
WASHINGTON—Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Robert Menendez (D-NJ) on Thursday introduced a powerful amendment that would end U.S. presidential waiver authority of Section 907 of the FREEDOM Support Act, an Armenian National Committee of America-backed measure that would effectively block U.S. military aid to Azerbaijan.
The amendment (#4177) is one of three amendments to the Senate version of the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) that deals with U.S. aid to Azerbaijan as well as Azerbaijani and Turkish war crimes committed against Artsakh and Armenia during the 2020 war. The amendment removes all references to presidential waiver authority of Section 907, a provision first put in place in 2001, and utilized by successive U.S. presidents – including President Biden, even in the wake of Azerbaijan’s 2020 brutal aggression against Artsakh in Armenia. Since 2016, the U.S. has provided over $120 million in U.S. military assistance to Azerbaijan, in the face of objections by Members of Congress and the ANCA, which has long raised alarms about the Aliyev regime’s belligerence in the region.
Senator Menendez also offered a second amendment (#4150) to the NDAA which calls for a joint State Department and Defense Department report on Turkey’s use of U.S. technology in its Bayrakdar drones, with a special focus on whether their sale to third countries, like Azerbaijan, violates U.S. export laws. The ANCA has identified a number of U.S. parts used in Bayrakdar drones that targeted Artsakh and Armenian civilians during the 2020 Artsakh war. In addition to the ANCA, Amendment #4150 also has the support of a coalition of ethnic, civic, and faith-based groups including the Hellenic American Leadership Council, American Friends of Kurdistan, the Hindu American Foundation, and the Middle East Forum.
A third amendment (#4251) introduced by California Senator Alex Padilla (D) calls for a joint State Department and Defense Department report, in response to Azerbaijani war crimes during the 2020 Artsakh war, including the use of U.S. technology during the attacks; the use of white phosphorous, cluster bombs, and other prohibited munitions; and the hiring of foreign mercenaries.
“We thank Senators Menendez and Padilla for their principled leadership in holding Azerbaijan and Turkey accountable,” said ANCA Executive Director Aram Hamparian. “We are working – in Washington, DC and across each of our fifty states – to secure the adoption of their ANCA-backed amendments enforcing Section 907, investigating Azerbaijani war crimes, and demanding answers about the U.S. parts discovered in the Turkish drones deployed by Azerbaijan against Artsakh.”
Additional Armenian-related amendments to the NDAA may be introduced in the next several days. A Senate vote on the Menendez and Padilla amendments can come as early as next week.
Earlier this year, the U.S. House adopted five ANCA-backed amendments to its version of the National Defense Authorization Act (H.R.4350), which demanded Baku’s release of Armenian prisoners of war (POWs), called for investigations into Azerbaijani war crimes, supported expanded U.S. aid to Artsakh, and urged Turkey’s Grey Wolves be designated a foreign terrorist organization.
Azerbaijan Violated Armenian Captives’ Right to Life, Rules European Court
The European Court of Human Rights
In two judgments issued on Thursday the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Azerbaijan has violated the rights of two Armenian citizens to life and has obliged the country to pay 40,000 euros in each case.
The case of Petrosyan v. Azerbaijan concerns the death of the applicant’s son while in Azerbaijani captivity.
The applicant’s son Karen Petrosyan, was born in 1981 and was living with the applicant and other members of the family in Chinari, close to the border to Azerbaijan. On August 7, 2014 he crossed the border into Azerbaijan and was captured by the Azerbaijani armed forces.
On the same day two video recordings of Petrosyan were broadcast by Azerbaijani media. In the first one, he was seen being offered tea by a local resident of the village of Aghbulag and having a conversation with some of the other villagers. In the second recording, he was being interrogated, while standing on his knees with his hands cuffed and being restrained by soldiers. The interrogating army general accused him of being a soldier, having killed civilians, incited hatred and caused aggression.
Being shown photographs of him in military uniform, allegedly found on his mobile phone together with phone numbers of his military commanders, he stated that he was a military serviceman.
On August 8, 2014 the Azerbaijani Ministry of Defense announced in a news report that Petrosyan had died unexpectedly, according to preliminary information due to “acute cardio-pulmonary and myocardial failure.”
Efforts were made by Armenia and the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) to have Petrosyan’s body returned. Representatives of the US State Department and the French Ministry for Foreign Affairs expressed their concern about the failure to return the body and give information on the circumstances surrounding the death.
On October 10, 2014, Petrosyan’s body was repatriated in a severely decomposed state.
The Court found that the respondent Government have not convincingly accounted for the circumstances of the death of Karen Petrosyan. On the basis of the information available to it, it is not possible for the Court to establish exactly what happened to Karen Petrosyan while in detention. In the light of the injuries that were identified and the lack of plausible explanations as to how they had been inflicted on him, the Court finds however that it has been sufficiently proved that he was victim of severe physical violence prior to his death, to a degree that amounted to a violation of Article 3 of the Convention in respect of him.
Article 3 of the Convention prohibits in absolute terms torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. The Court also held that there has been a violation of Article 2 (right to life).
The case of Khojoyan and Vardanyan v. Azerbaijan concerns the captivity and treatment of the applicants’ father in Azerbaijan.
On the morning of January 28, 2014 the applicants’ father, Mamikon Khojoyan, born in 1937 and a resident of the village of Verin Karmiraghbyur in the Tavush region of Armenia, close to the border to Azerbaijan, left his home. Later the same day, he appeared in a video online, surrounded by a group of people in civilian clothes and a person in Azerbaijani military uniform. On 30 January he was interviewed by Azerbaijani ANS TV. The Azerbaijani online news agency News.az reported the same day that Khojoyan was in detention and that the Ministry of National Security had stated that he was a guide of an Armenian sabotage group and had held a gun when he was apprehended.
On January 31, Khojoyan appeared in another Azerbaijani TV broadcast which was uploaded on Youtube. The Court has received the three videos and links to their appearance on Youtube from the applicants.5. On March 4, 2014, through the mediation of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), Khojoyan was handed over to the Armenian authorities.
On March 5, 2014 Azerbaijani TV relayed an official statement from Azerbaijani authorities that Khojoyan had been injured while captured as an armed guide of an Armenian subversive group and had been taken to Baku where he had received medical treatment, including the removal of a bullet from his arm.
No criminal investigation was undertaken by the Azerbaijani authorities, either in relation to the events surrounding Khojoyan’s crossing of the border and his alleged subversive motives or with regard to his treatment in detention.
The Court declared by majority that the complaint under Article 2 (right to life), Article 3 (prohibition of torture) and Article 5 (right to liberty and security) admissible.
In both cases the Court obliged Azerbaijan to pay 40,000 euros to the applicants.
Asbarez: Armenians of Artsakh Will Face Annihilation Under Azerbaijani Control, Says Deputy Foreign Minister
Armenia’s Deputy Foreign Minister Vahe Gevorgyan briefs lawmakers on Nov. 4
What happened during the first and second Artsakh wars clearly showed that the Armenians of Artsakh cannot live under Azerbaijani control, and will face eventual annihilation, Armenia’s Deputy Foreign Minister Vahe Gevorgyan told lawmakers on Thursday.
“What happened during both the first and second Artsakh wars clearly shows that the Armenians of Artsakh cannot live under Azerbaijani control. That is, because [Azerbaijan] is in fact engaged in a policy of extermination. The best proof of this is the total absence of Armenians in the territories presently controlled by Azerbaijan,” said Gevorgyan.
Armen Rustamyan, a member of the parliament’s Armenia bloc asked Gevorgyan whether there were plans for Armenia to give Artsakh “remedial recognition” under the principle of people’s right to self-determination.
In response to Rustamyan’s inquiry, Gevorgyan said that stated principle “is getting firm substantiation.”
“And I think that this approach, that the Armenians of Artsakh are facing annihilation under Azerbaijani control—this truthful, reliable and accurate narrativ—is being advanced by us in both our discourse and during negotiations,” added Gevorgyan, who added that Armenia will be consistent in restoring and protecting the rights of the people of Artsakh and will make every effort to guarantee their right to live safely and with dignity in their homeland.
He said that in relation to the Azerbaijan’s aggression against Artsakh in 2020 and Baku’s aspirations toward the sovereign territories of the Republic of Armenia, the foreign policy priorities remain the ensuring of the security of Armenia and Artsakh, the resolution of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict, as well as the establishment of regional peace and stability, and the process of unblocking transportation links.
“Armenia’s principled position regarding the Artsakh conflict has been expressed on numerous occasions. That includes a comprehensive and lasting resolution of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict, which can be achieved under the auspices of the only internationally mandated format–-the OSCE Minsk Group Co-chairmanship—based on the well-known principles and elements, which implies the determination of the final status of Artsakh taking into account the unbreakable right to self-determination of the Armenians of Artsakh,” Gevorgyan said.
In this phase, he prioritized the re-launching of the peace process under the OSCE MG Co-chairmanship, as well as prioritizing humanitarian issues, including the repatriation of Armenian prisoners of war, the determination of the fates of those missing or who are victims of forced disappearances, and the preservation of Armenian cultural heritage.
To that end, Gevorgyan said that process of the so-called unblocking of transport routes cannot take place at the expense of the security, sovereignty and vital interests of Armenia.
“Establishment of a peaceful and beneficial environment for co-existence in the region is also based on the unblocking of the region. Thus, the implementation of the January 11 trilateral statement is very important. The effective implementation of the unblocking process is possible if all players demonstrate a constructive stance and take practical steps. At the same time it’s important to note that this process cannot take place at the expense of Armenia’s security, sovereignty and vital interests,” Gevorgyan explained.
The deputy foreign minister announced that the top diplomats of Armenia and Azerbaijan will hold new meetings mediated by the OSCE Minsk Group Co-chairs and new conditions will be created for the complete re-launch of the peaceful resolution process of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict.
Gevorgyan cited a meeting in New York between the foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan and mediated by the Co-chairs as an example of the peace talks resuming, in response to another Armenia bloc lawmaker Anna Grigoryan.
“After the meeting, the Co-chairs issued a statement reiterating that they are working within the framework of their mandate, which is the resolution of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict,” said Gevorgyan. “I believe that at this juncture this is an important aspect to register.”
The international recognition and condemnation of the Armenian Genocide is also among the priorities of the Armenian foreign policy. Gevorgyan reaffirmed that Armenia will continue to actively contribute to the international community’s efforts for preventing genocides and other crimes against humanity.
RFE/RL Armenian Report – 11/04/2021
Thursday, November 4, 2021
Azerbaijan Found Guilty In 2014 Deaths Of Armenian Captives
November 04, 2021
• Robert Zargarian
FRANCE – The building of the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg,
September 11, 2019
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has found Azerbaijani authorities
guilty of torturing two residents of Armenian border villages who died after
crossing into Azerbaijan in 2014.
In separate rulings announced on Thursday, the ECHR ordered Baku to pay the
families of Karen Petrosian and Mamikon Khojoyan a total of 80,000 euros
($92,000) in damages.
Petrosian, a 33-year-old villager from Tavush province bordering Azerbaijan,
crossed the frontier for unclear reasons in August 2014. He was first spotted by
residents of an Azerbaijani border village and then detained by the Azerbaijani
military. Petrosian was accused of being part of an Armenian “sabotage group”
that tried to infiltrate Azerbaijan.
Petrosian was pronounced dead the following day. Baku claimed that he died of
“acute heart failure.”
The Armenian authorities rejected the claim, saying that Petrosian was murdered
or beaten to death. The United States and France expressed serious concern at
the man’s suspicious death and called on Baku to conduct an objective
investigation.
Azerbaijan - Azerbaijan soldiers escort Karen Petrosian, an Armenian villager
who crossed into Azerbaijan, 7Aug2014
The 77-year-old Khojoyan, who lived in another Tavush village, was detained in a
nearby Azerbaijani settlement in January 2014. Baku claimed that he was an armed
guide of an Armenian sabotage group that tried to carry out a cross-border
incursion. Yerevan laughed off the claim, saying that the elderly man strayed
into Azerbaijani territory by accident.
Khojoyan was freed and repatriated in March 2014. He died more than two months
later. Armenian doctors said he suffered serious injuries during his captivity.
The ECHR ruled that in both cases Azerbaijan violated articles of the European
Convention on Human Rights that guarantee people’s right to life and prohibit
torture. It said that Petrosian and Khojoyan were subjected to violence in
Azerbaijani custody.
The Azerbaijani government did not immediately react to the rulings. It can
appeal against them in the ECHR Grand Chamber.
Armenia - Mamikon Khojoyan, a 77-year-old villager detained and later freed by
Azerbaijan, is treated at a hospital in Ijevan, 5Mar2014.
In January 2020, the Strasbourg-based court handed down a similar verdict on an
appeal lodged by the parents of Manvel Saribekian, a 20-year-old resident of
another Armenian border village who was detained Azerbaijan in September 2010.
Azerbaijani authorities paraded Saribekian on national television, saying that
he was trained by an Armenian commando unit and sent to Azerbaijan to carry out
terrorist attacks. Saribekian’s family strongly denied the allegations,
insisting that he accidentally crossed the border while grazing cattle.
Saribekian was found hanged in an Azerbaijani detention center in October 2010.
Azerbaijani officials claimed that he committed suicide.
The young man’s body underwent a forensic examination after being handed over to
Armenia. Law-enforcement authorities in Yerevan concluded that he was tortured
to death.
Provincial Governor Resigns After Election Setback
November 04, 2021
• Satenik Kaghzvantsian
Armenia - Shirak Governor Hovhannes Harutiunian.
The governor of Armenia’s northwestern Shirak province was relieved of his
duties on Thursday more than two weeks after the ruling Civil Contract party’s
failure to win a municipal election in the provincial capital Gyumri.
Hovannes Harutiunian topped the list of the party’s candidates for the October
17 election marked by a very low voter turnout. In a serious setback for Prime
Minister Nikol Pashinian, Civil Contract finished second with about 30 percent
of the vote. It trailed a local political group linked to Gyumri’s outgoing
mayor, Samvel Balasanian.
Harutiunian held a farewell news conference in Gyumri hours after Pashinian’s
government formally accepted his resignation. He insisted that he was not forced
to resign.
“As soon as it was decided that I will be leading the list of Civil Contract’s
local election candidates it became obvious that regardless of the outcome of
the election I will not hold the post of Shirak governor anymore,” he said.
“What happened today is a logical continuation of that decision.”
“We need to understand why our citizens didn’t want to go to the polls,”
Harutiunian said when asked about reasons for the ruling party’s failure to
install Gyumri’s next mayor. Pashinian’s party respects any decision made by
voters, he added.
Despite the election defeat, Civil Contract reached a power-sharing agreement
with the election winner, the Balasanian Bloc, whose top candidate, Vardges
Samsonian, was elected as Gyumri mayor by the new city council on Monday. As
part of that deal, the ruling party will name the two deputy mayors and other
senior officials in the municipal administration.
The deal was signed on October 30 two days after two senior Gyumri officials
affiliated with the Balasanian Bloc were arrested by Armenia’s National Security
Service on corruption charges. The bloc did not publicly allege political
reasons behind the arrests.
Some Armenian outlets reported earlier in October that the Balasanian Bloc is
facing strong pressure from the central government to cut a power-sharing deal
with Pashinian’s party and even cede the post of mayor to it. Senior party
figures denied such pressure.
Armenia, Azerbaijan ‘Not Holding’ Border Demarcation Talks
November 04, 2021
• Naira Nalbandian
• Tatevik Sargsian
ARMENIA -- Azerbaijani (L) and Armenian army posts at the Sotk gold mine on the
Armenian-Azerbaijani border, June 18, 2021
Armenia and Azerbaijan have still not begun negotiations on demarcating their
contested border, a senior Armenian diplomat insisted on Thursday.
Tensions have run high at several sections of the long border where Azerbaijani
forces reportedly advanced a few kilometers into Armenian territory in mid-May.
Armenia has repeatedly demanded their unconditional withdrawal. Azerbaijan
maintains that its troops took up new positions on the Azerbaijani side of the
frontier.
Russia proposed later in May that Yerevan and Baku set up a commission on border
delimitation and demarcation. President Vladimir Putin reiterated late last
month Russian offers to act as a mediator in such talks with Soviet military
maps at its disposal.
“As long as there are no [border] delimitation negotiations it is too premature
to speak about what maps and documents we will be guided by,” Armenian Deputy
Foreign Minister Vahe Gevorgian told reporters. “When such negotiations start we
will address those issues.”
The Aliqmedia.am news service reported last week that that Putin will host fresh
talks between Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and Azerbaijani President
Ilham Aliyev on November 9 on the first anniversary of a Russian-brokered
ceasefire that stopped the war in Nagorno-Karabakh. Citing unnamed Armenian
diplomatic sources, the publication claimed that Aliyev and Pashinian will sign
two documents envisaging the demarcation of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border and
its opening for cargo traffic.
Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan did not rule out afterwards the possibility of
an Armenian-Azerbaijani summit while saying that it is not planned yet. His
Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov said on Thursday that he has “no
information” about such an encounter.
Aliyev complained, meanwhile, that Yerevan has still not responded to Baku’s
proposals to sign an Armenian-Azerbaijani “peace treaty” and start demarcating
the border on the basis of recognizing each other’s territorial integrity.
Armenian leaders have repeatedly called for demarcation talks. The secretary of
Armenia’s Security Council, Armen Grigorian, said last week that Yerevan is
still awaiting “positive signals on that score from Azerbaijan.”
Armenian Health Ministry Seeks COVID-19 Health Pass
November 04, 2021
• Nane Sahakian
Armenia - Police officers talk to women not wearing mandatory masks on a street
in downtown Yerevan, November 2, 2021.
The Ministry of Health advocated on Thursday the introduction of a mandatory
health pass for entry to cultural and leisure venues following record numbers of
coronavirus cases and deaths registered in Armenia.
Health Minister Anahit Avanesian said the ministry will circulate later in the
day a relevant draft decision that will be discussed by an interagency
commission.
It would require people to produce, starting from December 1, the health pass
showing that they have been vaccinated against COVID-19 or have had a recent
negative test in order to visit bars, restaurants and other public venues.
Armenians working for public or private entities already have to get inoculated
or take coronavirus tests twice a month at their own expense. The draft Ministry
of Health directive cited by Avanesian would require such mandatory testing to
be done once a week.
Armenia - People line up outside a mobile vaccination center in Yerevan's
Liberty Square, September 24, 2021.
The purpose of the proposed measures is to speed up vaccinations and thereby
contain the latest wave of coronavirus infections in Armenia. Speaking at a
weekly cabinet meeting earlier on Thursday, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian
complained that the vaccination process remains slow despite having accelerated
in recent weeks.
Avanesian told the cabinet that more than 852,000 vaccine shots have been
administered in the country of about 3 million to date. Only about 264,000
people have received two doses of a vaccine, she said.
Daily coronavirus cases have steadily increased since June, reaching record-high
levels late last month. The Ministry of Health reported a record 62 deaths from
COVID-19 on Tuesday.
The ministry’s National Center for Disease Control and Prevention reported that
the respiratory disease killed at least 41 more Armenians on Wednesday. The
center also said that as much as 19 percent of about 12,200 coronavirus tests
carried out across the country came back positive.
Armenia - Health Minister Anahit Avanesian speaks during a cabinet meeting in
Yerevan, November 4, 2021.
Avanesian said Armenian hospitals remain overwhelmed by the increased number of
infected people in need of urgent care.
“We have a slight drop in the number of citizens awaiting hospitalization but
[hospital] beds still don’t stay vacant for a single second,” she told Pashinian
and fellow ministers.
Pashinian made clear that the government still has no plans to impose lockdown
restrictions and will continue to concentrate on its immunization campaign. For
his part, Education Minister Vahram Dumanian said he is unlikely to again extend
school holidays that end on November 7.
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2021 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
Armenpress: Russian government approves signing interregional cooperation plan with Armenia
Russian government approves signing interregional cooperation plan with Armenia
09:20, 4 November, 2021
YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 4, ARMENPRESS. The government of Russia approved the 2022-2027 interregional cooperation plan with the government of Armenia, TASS reports.
The government approved the Russian economic development ministry’s proposal which has been discussed with the ministry of foreign affairs and other concerned agencies of the executive power.
The ministry of economic development has been tasked to sign that cooperation plan with Armenia on behalf of the Russian government.
Editing and Translating by Aneta Harutyunyan