Karabakh’s Development Set to Transform the South Caucasus

Nov 10 2021

While no one is watching, the social and economic geography in the South Caucasus is continuing swiftly to evolve. Signal among these developments, indeed its driving force, is the rebuilding of the Karabakh region following the expulsion of occupying military forces from the Republic of Armenia, or under its direct control, which had been there for 30 years. The development has deep implications for the geopolitics of the broader region.

Danger still exists from Armenian irregular forces that continue to operate from the Azerbaijani territories where Russian peacekeeping troops are located. At the same time, there are periodic attempts to infiltrate special-operations teams from the body of Armenia proper into the newly liberated lands.

So far the headline story, but far from the only one, in the redevelopment of the Karabakh region is the opening of a new international airport in Fuzuli, a city that became a ghost town after its Azerbaijani population was driven out following its capture in August 1993 by Armenian forces who destroyed its civilian infrastructure.

It happens that the Azerbaijani army was able to retake important areas of Fuzuli district in 1994, although not the city itself. The development of non-occupied Fuzuli distinct since 1994 is an indicator of what to expect not only for Fuzuli city but for the whole of the de-occupied territories, once they are de-mined from the vast amounts of ordnance implanted by Armenian forces. This procedure is complicated by Yerevan’s general refusal to turn the requisite maps over to Baku. In one case where they did so, for the city of Aghdam, it was determined by inspection that these maps were only about 25 percent accurate.

In 1979, the city of Fuzuli had a population of 13,091. The whole of the Fuzuli district had population of 76,013, of which almost 97 percent was ethnic Azerbaijani. By 1989, the population of Fuzuli city had reached 17,090, an increase of 23 percent. Applying this rate of growth and ethnic apportionment to Fuzuli district would give it a population of 93,450, of which over 90,000 ethnic Azerbaijanis. This would be the number ethnically cleansed by Armenian forces from Fuzuli district alone during the First Karabakh War.

Making a very rough calculation based on Azerbaijan’s population growth of 42 percent over three decades, from 7.02 million in 1989 to 9.98 million in 2019, these figures indicate that proportionally the old Fuzuli district should be able to support almost 128,000 Azerbaijanis, or indeed more, given the now-planned economic development there.

It is estimated that in the mid-1990s 40,000 Azerbaijanis had returned already to those areas of Fuzuli district not under Armenian military control, where they have thrived. This established demographic and economic base, an advantage that most of the de-occupied administrative districts do not enjoy, will facilitate the further development of Fuzuli city and the rest of Fuzuli district.

Azerbaijan is building two more airports in the formerly occupied territories, in Zangilan and Lachin districts. Construction of Zangilan International Airport began in May 2021 and will be completed next year. These three airports will go far to re-integrate the region economically back into Azerbaijan. It is planned to create industrial zones adjacent to the airports. Private Turkish companies have already started to construct an agropark in Zangilan district.

Thus, it is planned that the new airports will also become foci for modern logistics and transportation centres. The airports and their associated infrastructure will strengthen the region’s own security and connectivity by linking important new highways there, already under construction. New highways have already been finished that link major Karabakh cities, in the mountains, to the country’s eastern plain.

The catastrophe of the contamination of the de-occupied territories by land mines is becoming more widely recognized. Estimates made in 1998 supposed about 100,000 mines in the occupied territories. However. the mine maps provided for the city of Aghdam alone on 12 June 2021 showed no fewer than 97,000 mines. Official Baku believes that the occupying Armenian forces sowed no fewer than a million mines throughout the territories over the course of 30 years.

The United Kingdom has provided US$677,000 to Azerbaijan for de-mining activities via the United Nations Development program. France has donated US$473,000 directly to Azerbaijan for the same purpose. The United States has recently pledged US$500,000. Other countries have stepped up by providing trained personnel as well as funding.

Unfortunately Canada has not been among them, despite its having once vaunted itself with pride for having promoted and motivated the 1997 signature of the so-called “Ottawa Treaty” (full title: Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Land Mines and Their Destruction), which entered into force in 1999.

Azerbaijan’s deputy foreign minister Elnur Mammadov has told the International Court of Justice (ICJ) that Armenian forces continue to lay landmines in a “campaign of ethnic cleansing and incitement to violence against Azerbaijanis [that] is ongoing” and which have killed or injured “at least” 106 Azerbaijanis, including 65 civilians as of the middle of last month. Azerbaijan has applied to the ICJ for an order to Armenia to hand over maps showing the location of land mines in the liberated territories.

Even if it takes a decade to clear the mines, the economic development of the liberated territories is not being delayed. Baku is dedicating already in 2021 $1.5 billion dollars for the restoration of these territories. Similar figures may be foreseen for the future. This sum is not a great burden on the country’s state budget, which estimated an oil price of $45 per barrel; this price has risen to over $80 lately, with further increases likely.

The results of these investments will not only transform the territories themselves. The broad rebuilding of the infrastructure, including international links, will equally transform the geostrategic map of the whole South Caucasus region and beyond.

 

Robert M. Cutler is a Fellow at the Canadian Global Affairs Institute.

The views expressed in this article are those of the authors alone and do not necessarily reflect those of Geopoliticalmonitor.com


Azerbaijan’s plans for Nagorno-Karabakh are huge, but can Baku deliver on its promises?

Nov 10 2021

Azerbaijan wants to make Nagorno-Karabakh a model of sustainability, based on the use of renewable energy and the development of what it calls “smart villages”.

Azerbaijan has made no secret of its plans to revitalise the economy of Nagorno-Karabakh ever since it regained control over the majority of the disputed region last year, following a 44-day war with Armenia.

Its first concern is energy.


  • Nagorno-Karabakh reconstruction draws criticism from both Armenians and Azeris
  • Azerbaijan is ready to play its part in the realisation of peace. What about Armenia?
  • Concerns grow for the fate of Nagorno-Karabakh’s cultural heritage

The end of the war left Baku in control of a 36 hydropower plants in Karabakh, as well as the Kelbajar and Lachin regions. Prior to the conflict, the territory produced all of its own electricity and even exported some to Armenia. It was one of the few areas in which Karabakh’s authorities did not depend on Yerevan.

According to a report by the Electricity and Energy Efficiency Department at the Azeri Ministry of Energy, after the war ended, Armenian forces destroyed a number of power plants as they retreated. However, Armen Tovmasyan, Karabakh’s de facto Minister of Economy and Agriculture, has denied these allegations, claiming that even though some infrastructure was damaged during the fighting, the plants were not destroyed.

In February, just three months after the ceasefire agreement was reached, a medium-sized hydropower plant was reopened in the village of Gulabird in the Lachin region.

Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, who was at the inauguration ceremony, said that the powerplant had “great significance” as “renewable energy has huge potential” for the region’s development.

In summer, other two medium-sized plants in the Terter region, Sugovushan-1 and Sugovushan-2, were put back to work. The plants used to be owned by Armenian company Artsakh HEK and operated under different names, Mataghis-1 and Mataghis-2.

Under Baku’s control, these plants are owned by the state and are operated by a state-owned energy firm, Azerenergy.

Two other power plants, Khudaferin and Maiden, are being constructed on the Araz River, which also serves as the border between Azerbaijan and Iran. The construction of these plants began under Soviet rule but was interrupted after the first Karabakh War in 1993 when the region fell into Armenian hands. Nevertheless, Iran continued with the project on its side of the river.

In 2016, Azerbaijan and Iran made a deal to continue the construction of the power plants, even though Baku at the time had no control over the territory. The power plants are now expected to start producing energy in 2024: output will be shared equally between Tehran and Baku.

Aside from hydropower plants, the Azerbaijani government is planning to build wind and solar energy facilities and transform Karabakh into what it has called a “green energy zone”. According to Azerbaijani Energy Minister Parviz Shahbazov, electricity in the Karabakh region will be produced entirely through green energy sources.

The region’s energy production is so important that the loss of the territories has negatively affected the energy security of the Yerevan-controlled part of Karabakh, and even Armenia itself.

Electricity transfers between Armenia and Karabakh have been interrupted after the Kelbajar region, which was crossed by energy transmitting lines, was ceded to Azerbaijan.

According to Murad Muradov, deputy director of Topchubashov Centre, a Baku-based think tank, Armenia’s energy vulnerability has considerably increased as a result of the de-occupation of Karabakh.

“In recent years, [Armenia] illegally imported electricity from hydropower stations in Karabakh,” he says.

“Now, clear signs of persistent supply problems which cannot be fundamentally resolved without cooperation with the Azerbaijani authorities.”

The Azerbaijani government is also now preparing to resettle its citizens in the territory it retook during the war.

Baku has said that it wants to build “smart villages”, which will accommodate hundreds of thousands of internally displaced people. The smart village is a concept focused on holistic rural development and implies small communities aimed at maximising economic development through the use of modern technologies of automation and renewable energy.

The government has been also planning to expand the “agroparks” system: large-scale, government-subsidised agribusiness enterprises, to further accelerate the redevelopment of rural Karabakh.

While agroparks have been operating in Azerbaijan in 2012, the idea of smart villages is new, seen by Baku as a way of resettling more than 600,000 displaced Azerbaijanis.

Azerbaijani media have been hyping the smart village concept extensively, citing the government’s statement on the use of automation that will significantly reduce human labour. On October 17, Minister of Agriculture Inam Karimov stated that smart villages would be implemented using green and alternative energy and a smart management system. He added that the villages would be surrounded by smart farms.

According to President Aliyev, the first project would be implemented in the Zangilan district, where people could return “by the end of this year [2021] or early next year [2022]”. In October, he laid a foundation stone for a smart village in the district of Fuzuli.

While Baku has planned to invest 1.3 billion US dollars in the project, there are several challenges facing the efficient implementation of the project.

“In my opinion, there are two major potential threats that could forestall the success of projects: the lack of comprehensive infrastructure and broad mismanagement (including corruption),” Muradov tells Emerging Europe. “The cost is also a challenge. That’s why the government has been so active in attracting foreign capital.”

Muradov adds that the Azerbaijani government is – at least in its declarations – keen to improve transparency and do away with corruption and unnecessary expenditure.

The Azerbaijan Investment Holding, established in August 2020, is now revising business processes and procurement of the country’s largest state-owned enterprises, including energy giants SOCAR, AZAL, Azerenerji.

“These SOEs are bound to play a key role in the reconstruction of Karabakh, so it is very important to minimise mishandling of public property and increase the management competencies,” he says.

Muradov believes that the key to the implementation of smart villages and agroparks in Karabakh is progress in Azerbaijani-Armenian negotiations and the active willingness of the two countries to avoid a restart of the conflict.

“In a positive scenario the ideas which are now mostly on paper will be convertible into reality in about four to five years,” he concludes.

Turkish Press: ​Key piece of Karabakh pact on Zangezur corridor still awaits implementation

Anadolu Agency, Turkey

Nov 10 2021

Key piece of Karabakh pact on Zangezur corridor still awaits implementation


Implementation of Zangezur corridor 1 year after end of Karabakh war delayed due to Armenian intransigence, while other parts carried out

Ruslan Rehimov   |10.11.2021

BAKU, Azerbaijan

It has been a year since the signing of a tripartite declaration between Azerbaijan, Armenia, and Russia ending the war over Nagorno-Karabakh, yet its section on a corridor connecting western Armenia to the exclave of Nakhchivan has yet to be implemented due to Armenia’s uncompromising stance.

A year ago today, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, and Russian President Vladimir Putin signed a declaration declaring the end of the conflict in Karabakh, also known as Upper Karabakh, following a nearly three-decade occupation by Armenian forces.

In its first year, some articles of the declaration were applied, while some articles remained on paper due to Armenian intransigence.

The parts on the Zangezur corridor are among those that have not yet been put into force.

Articles 2 and 6, which envisage the withdrawal of Armenian forces from the provinces of Agdam, Kelbajar, and Lachin, were applied long ago. By the end of last November, the Armenian army had left the three occupied provinces, and the Azerbaijani army had settled there.

According to Article 3, Russian elements were placed in the Armenian-populated areas of Karabakh and in the Lachin corridor. A total of 1,960 lightly armed Russian soldiers and 90 armored personnel carriers were deployed to the region. Their term of duty was set at five years, but that could be extended if all parties agree.

In Article 4, which stipulates that “Russian forces are deployed in parallel with the withdrawal of Armenian forces” has not been fully implemented. The Armenian army has withdrawn, but the fact that there are still armed Armenian groups in the region is one of the issues vexing the Azerbaijani side.

Article 5, which provides for the “establishment of an observation center to improve the efficiency of monitoring the compliance of the parties to the cease-fire,” was implemented, and a Joint Turkish-Russian Observation Center was established in Agdam, Karabakh this January.


The issue of return of refugees under the control of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) specified in Article 7 has also not yet been implemented due to how the settlements were completely destroyed by Armenians during the occupation period and also for security reasons.

Article 8 on the issue of the exchange of prisoners and the dead was also applied. Azerbaijan has handed over to the opposite side the bodies of more than 1,700 Armenian soldiers which had remained on the battlefields.

The last article, which Azerbaijan has been focusing on with great importance and which provides for the connection of the country’s contiguous territory and the Autonomous Republic of Nakhchivan – its exclave – via land and rail routes through Armenia, has not yet been implemented.

Azerbaijan has started work on this issue, and construction of the part of this line called the Zangezur corridor up to the Armenian border is underway.

Although Armenia tried to resist, Prime Minister Pashinyan made positive statements about the opening of transport between the western provinces of Azerbaijan and Nakhchivan.

Aliyev, Pashinyan, and Putin are expected to meet once again soon and sign a more detailed statement on the determination of transport lines and the borders of the two countries.

Armenia will not take positive steps of its own accord

Ferid Shefiyev, chairman of the Azerbaijan Center of Analysis of International Relations, based in the capital Baku, told Anadolu Agency in a statement that Azerbaijan, which won the war, should put diplomatic pressure on Armenia from now on.

“History shows that Armenia will not take positive steps of its own accord,” he said.

“On Jan. 11, 2021, another declaration on transport lines was signed. Although months have passed since then, Armenia has been sitting out the process.

“Due to pressure from Azerbaijan and the influence of Russia, the Yerevan administration has now responded positively to this issue,” he added.

“Unfortunately, there are still armed Armenian forces in the region controlled by Russian elements,” Shefiyev stressed, referring to the non-implemented articles of the trilateral declaration.

“There are also problems in the Lachin corridor. We have to enforce control there sooner or later.

“Foreign citizens still use this corridor. Compared to the beginning of 2021, the rate of visits by foreigners has fallen. As far as I know, Russia also doesn’t want problems with this matter.”

Shefiyev said that 4,000 Azerbaijanis were missing in the first Karabakh conflict of the early 1990s, but that Armenia has not yet responded on the fate of these people.

Conflict between Azerbaijan, Armenia

Relations between Azerbaijan and Armenia have been tense since 1991, when the Armenian military occupied Nagorno-Karabakh, also known as Upper Karabakh, a territory internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan, and seven adjacent regions.

New clashes erupted on Sept. 27 last year, with the Armenian army attacking civilians and Azerbaijani forces and violating several humanitarian cease-fire agreements.

During the 44-day military conflict, Azerbaijan liberated several cities and some 300 settlements and villages that were occupied by Armenia for almost 30 years.

Prior to this, about 20% of Azerbaijan’s territory was under illegal occupation.

The two countries signed a Russian-brokered agreement on Nov. 10 to end the fighting and work toward a comprehensive resolution.

The cease-fire was seen as a victory for Azerbaijan and a defeat for Armenia, whose forces withdrew in line with the agreement.

This Jan. 11, the leaders of Russia, Azerbaijan, and Armenia signed a pact to develop economic ties and infrastructure to benefit the entire region. The deal also included the establishment of a Turkish-Russian monitoring center.

*Writing by Merve Berker

Azerbaijan celebrates victory in war by killing Armenian civilians

Nov 10 2021
Exactly one year ago Armenia she was forced to sign a painful armistice with Azerbaijan to end the war in Nagorno-Karabakh, the third in its history. If in just over a month, contrary to previous conflicts, Baku managed to wrest three quarters of Nagorno-Karabakh from the Republic of Artsakh, it is thanks to Turkey, which by financing the Ilham Aliyev regime and putting drones and heavy artillery at its disposal. And Syrian Islamist mercenaries to fight at the front he changed the balance of forces on the field.

To celebrate the victory in the conflict that killed some 6,000 people, yesterday Aliyev together with the Turkish Defense Minister Hulusi Akar visited the city of Shushi, conquered last year, where the Azeris they damaged and vandalized the cathedral of Cristo San Salvatore.

While they were celebrating and talking about the “restoration of historical justice”, a soldier from the Azerbaijani army was just a few kilometers away opened fire without reason against four Armenian workers who were repairing some water pipes near the city of Shushi, in Armenian territory. One of the four men, a young man of just 22, died, the other three were rushed to hospital and are reported to be serious but not dying.

According to some witnesses, the incident occurred a few hundred meters from the Russian peacekeepers, who have the task of maintaining security in the Lachin corridor, along the road that connects the capital of Artsakh, Stepanakert, to Armenia.

It is not the first time that the Azerbaijani army has opened fire indiscriminately on unarmed Armenian civilians. In October, a man who was cultivating his fields, accompanied by the Russian army, was killed by a soldier from Aliyev.

The latest incident “demonstrates once again the armenophobic, genocidal and fascist character of Azerbaijan”, he has declared the human rights officer of the Artsakh government, Gegham Stepanyan. “The only way to stop the connivance and impunity of the Azerbaijani government is to introduce clear mechanisms to investigate the criminal actions of the Azerbaijani army and punish them for their responsibilities.”

On the anniversary of the end of the war, on the Armenian side, thousands of opponents gathered in Freedom Square to demand the resignation of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan again and to put pressure on the government to does not make new concessions to Azeris during Russian-mediated talks.

https://d1softballnews.com/azerbaijan-celebrates-victory-in-war-by-killing-armenian-civilians/

Armenian opposition marks anniversary of end of "autumn war" with protest rallies

Caucasian Knot, EU
Nov 10 2021

At a rally in Yerevan, supporters of Robert Kocharyan, the second president of Armenia, accused the authorities of failures in all spheres of politics and economy.

The “Caucasian Knot” has reported that on November 10, 2020, the trilateral agreement signed by Russia, Azerbaijan, and Armenia on the cessation of hostilities in Nagorno-Karabakh came into force. On the same day, residents of Yerevan, dissatisfied with the signing of the peace agreement with Azerbaijan, broke into the building of the Armenian government and demanded the resignation of Nikol Pashinyan.

On November 9, in Yerevan, the “National Democratic Pole” (NDP) Movement organized a rally-march. The participants marched along streets of Yerevan with an appeal to take part in the rally in Freedom Square.

The rally-march was dedicated to the first anniversary of signing the trilateral agreement on Karabakh and began with a minute of silence in memory of those who perished in the 44-day-long Karabakh war.

A year has passed since the end of the war, but the Armenian party continues losing not only people’s lives, but also territories, the organizers of the rally have claimed, stating that their short-term goal is to overthrow the power of Nikol Pashinyan and prevent the signing of a new anti-Armenian document; after which an interim government should be formed.

At another rally held in Yerevan on November 8 by the ARF “Dashnaktsutyun”, oppositionists criticized the current authorities, accusing them of the defeat in Nagorno-Karabakh and a failed domestic policy in Armenia.

Robert Kocharyan, the second Armenian President, has blamed the incumbent government of beheading the army, persecuting heroes and failed diplomacy. He has added that authorities are guilty of the current situation in Armenia and Karabakh, of the rise in prices, immigration, appearance of new monopolists and oligarchs, etc. He has assured that the opposition “will expel the current authorities by any means – by barricades or elections.”

This article was originally published on the Russian page of 24/7 Internet agency ‘Caucasian Knot’ on at 03:20 am MSK. To access the full text of the article, click here.

Author: Armine MartirosyanSource: CK correspondent

Source: 
© Caucasian Knot

Armenian troops "stop Azerbaijanis’ attempted advance near Goris"

PanArmenian, Armenia
Nov 10 2021

PanARMENIAN.Net – The Azerbaijani troops attempted to advance near the Armenian town of Goris but met the resistance of the Armenian armed forces on Tuesday, November 9, Goris deputy mayor Karen Kocharyan has said, according to Sputnik Armenia.

Kocharyan confirmed media publications about an incident that happened near Sev Lake, which he described as “positional”.

“No shots have been fired. The Azerbaijanis attempted to move forward, our guys stopped them. Our boys have improved their positions,” Kocharyan added.

Armenia finishes alternative to road passing through Azeri-held areas

PanArmenian, Armenia
Nov 10 2021

PanARMENIAN.Net – The alternative road to replace the one passing through pockets of Azerbaijan-controlled territories in Armenia’s Syunik province is “practically completely ready”, Minister Territorial Administration and Infrastructure Gnel Sanosyan told a press conference on Wednesday, November 10, Armenpress reports.

Sanosyan said roads are under construction in a number of communities of Syunik province, revealing that the one connecting the towns of Sisian and Kajaran is a priority.

Deputy Prime Minister Suren Papikyan said in late October that the alternative roads in Syunik will be ready in spring 2022.

The main road connecting the cities of Goris and Kapan in the region in some cases runs across territory which Baku gained control of as a result of the 44-day war in fall 2020. Azerbaijan has already set up border guard posts and police checkpoints, has at least once blocked a 21-kilometer section of it for nearly 48 hours and is now collecting taxes from Iranian trucks delivering goods to Armenia.

Armenia, Azerbaijan to set up customs checkpoints on Goris-Kapan road

Public Radio of Armenia
Nov 10 2021

Armenia and Azerbaijan will set up customs and border checkpoints on Goris-Kapan road, Secretary of Armenia’s Security Council Armen Grigoryan said in an interview with Public TV.

“The Azerbaijani side has informed the Armenian side that starting from 12 o’clock at night, it will carry out a border and customs control on the Goris-Kapan road, i.e. it will set up customs checkpoints. The Armenian side will take corresponding steps. In other words, it will install customs and border checkpoints on that section of the road,” the Secretary said, adding that work in that direction has already started.

Besides, he said the alternative Kapan-Tatev road is ready, and can be used for transporting goods, and is open to all kinds of vehicles.

Defense Ministry denies reports claiming 60 Armenian servicemen had been besieged

Public Radio of Armenia
Nov 10 2021

The Armenian Ministry of Defense has denied the reports of the Azerbaijani media outlets claiming that a fight had allegedly taken place between Armenian and Azeri servicemen in the area of Lake Black in Armenia’s Syunik province and that a group of Armenian servicemen had been besieged.

Azerbaijan’s Ministry of Defense later added to this misinformation, announcing that 60 Armenian servicemen had been besieged and were set free only with the mediation of the Russian side.

“The statement of the Azerbaijani Defense Ministry is obvious misinformation. Moreover, after the actions of the Armenian units following the provocation of the Azerbaijani side in the territory of Lake Black, the Azerbaijani Armed Forces appealed to the Russian side to resolve the situation, and it was due to the active work of the Russian side that the situation was stabilized,” the Armenian Defense Ministry stated.

It reiterated that the situation in the area of Lake Black is under the full control of the Armenian Armed Forces.

Criminal case initiated as Azerbaijani forces target Armenian farmer

Public Radio of Armenia
Nov 10 2021

A criminal case has been initiated in connection with the attempted murder of a resident of Khachik village, Artsakh’s Prosecutor General’s Office reports.

On November 9, 2021, at around 2:50 p.m., servicemen of the Armed Forces of Azerbaijan, motivated by national hatred, targeted a tractor driven by T. Asatryan in the administrative area of Khachik village, Vayots Dzor region.

The farmer, who was carrying our agricultural works with his tractor, escaped unhurt. The window of the vehicle was damaged.

Under an agreement reached between the Armenian, Russian and Azerbaijani prosecutors-general regarding exchange of information on criminal acts at the line of contact, the Russian authorities have been notified about the incident.