RFE/RL Armenian Report – 02/18/2021

                                        Thursday, 
Former Yerevan Mayor Indicted
Armenia - Yerevan Mayor Taron Markarian speaks at an election campaign rally in 
the city's Erebuni district, 21Apr2017.
A law-enforcement agency has brought criminal charges against Yerevan’s former 
Mayor Taron Markarian and three other former government officials.
The Investigative Committee claimed on Thursday that Markarian abused his had 
powers to sell three plots of municipal land to his cronies from in 2011-2014. 
The land belonging to public schools was privatized at knockdown prices, it said 
without specifying financial details of those deals.
In a statement, the committee said that two other former senior officials of 
Yerevan’s municipal administration as well as Arman Sahakian, a former head of 
the Armenian government’s Department of State Property Management, have been 
indicted as part of the same criminal case. It did not elaborate.
Markarian’s lawyer, Benik Galstian, was quick to laugh off the accusations, 
saying that his client regards them as a “farce.” He claimed investigators are 
illegally refusing to share with him all materials of the case and that he does 
not know “what exactly Mr. Markarian is accused of.”
In a Facebook post, Galstian also said that Markarian travelled to Moscow on 
February 7 for medical treatment and returned to Armenia on February 13 two days 
after being notified of his impending indictment.
Markarian, 42, served as Yerevan mayor from 2011-2018. Both he and Sahakian are 
senior members of former President Serzh Sarkisian’s Republican Party of Armenia 
(HHK).
Markarian’s late father Andranik was Armenia’s prime minister from 2000-2007. 
The latter headed the HHK until his sudden death in 2007.
Lawmaker Explains Decision To Leave Tsarukian’s Party
        • Gayane Saribekian
Armenia - Gevorg Petrosian attends a session of the Armenian parliament, May 25, 
2020.
Gevorg Petrosian, an outspoken opposition parliamentarian, said on Thursday that 
he decided to leave Gagik Tsarukian’s Prosperous Armenia Party (BHK) because it 
has been too soft on the country’s government.
He claimed that although the BHK is part of an opposition alliance trying to 
oust Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian many of its senior members have not 
adequately participated in anti-government rallies held after the autumn war in 
Nagorno-Karabakh.
“When I went [to opposition rallies] people shamed me, saying ‘Where is your 
party? Why is it not participating in this rally?’” Petrosian told RFE/RL’s 
Armenian Service.
“We are accused of being false opposition. I don’t want to be labeled false 
opposition,” he said.
The BHK is the sole member of the opposition alliance, called the Homeland 
Salvation Movement, represented in the parliament. The movement is scheduled to 
hold its next rally on Saturday. Tsarukian is expected to attend it. Like other 
opposition leaders, he has repeatedly demanded Pashinian’s resignation.
Petrosian complained that other senior BHK figures did not like his harsh 
anti-government rhetoric. He said they did not stand by him when a leading 
member of Pashinian’s My Step bloc demanded recently an end to his derogatory 
attacks on Pashinian and other senior officials.
Petrosian announced his decision to leave the BHK and remain in the parliament 
as an independent deputy on Tuesday.
The BHK spokeswoman, Iveta Tonoyan, said afterwards that the decision took her 
and her colleagues by surprise. She said that Petrosian did not discuss his 
grievances with them.
Petrosian’s exit reduced to 23 the number of seats controlled by Tsarukian’s 
party in the 132-member National Assembly.
The 48-year-old lawmaker has already had a turbulent relationship with the BHK 
leadership in the past. He left the party in 2010 but rejoined it five years 
later. He was expelled from the party ranks in 2016 only to be elected to the 
parliament on BHK ticket the following year.
Another Sarkisian Trial Defendant Dies
        • Artak Khulian
Armenia -- President Serzh Sarkisian (R) and Agriculture Minister Sergo 
Karapetian (L) visit Armavir province, April 7, 2011.
An Armenian court on Thursday again adjourned a trial of former President Serzh 
Sarkisian following the death of another defendant.
Sergo Karapetian died early in the morning as a result of what the director of a 
Yerevan hospital described as “complications” caused by the coronavirus. The 
72-year-old had served as Armenia’s agriculture minister from 2010-2016 during 
Sarkisian’s rule.
Karapetian’s former deputy and another trial defendant, Samvel Galstian, died 
from COVID-19 one month ago.
Sarkisian, Karapetian, Galstian and two other men went on trial on corruption 
charges one year ago.
Sarkisian stands accused of giving privileged treatment in 2013 to his longtime 
friend and businessman Barsegh Barseghian which allegedly cost the state over $1 
million in losses. According to prosecutors, he made sure that a government 
tender for supplies of subsidized diesel fuel to farmers is won by Barseghian’s 
Flash company, rather than another fuel importer that offered a lower price.
The ex-president rejects the accusations as politically motivated. They are 
reportedly based on Karapetian’s incriminating pre-trial testimony against him.
The former minister was jeered by Sarkisian supporters who gathered outside the 
court building at the start of the trial in February 2020. He repeatedly refused 
to talk to reporters about the high-profile case.
The judge presiding over the trial has held few hearings on the case over the 
past year due to the frequent absence of defendants and their lawyers.
Sarkisian, who ruled the country from 2008-2018, remains the chairman of the 
Republican Party of Armenia (HHK). HHK representatives have said he was indicted 
in December 2019 in retaliation for his public criticism of Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian. Law-enforcement officials and Pashinian’s political allies have 
denied that.
Pashinian has repeatedly implicated Sarkisian, his family and political 
entourage in corruption both before and after coming to power in 2018.
Prosecutors Seek To Criminalize Defamation Of Armenian Officials
        • Artak Khulian
Armenia -- Riot police guard the entrance to the Office of the 
Prosecutor-General during an anti-government protest in Yerevan, January 28, 
2021.
In a move condemned by press freedom groups, Armenian prosecutors have drafted 
legislation that would make defamation of government, law-enforcement and other 
state officials a crime punishable by up to two years in prison.
All forms of defamation were decriminalized in Armenia in 2010 during the rule 
of former President Serzh Sarkisian. The move was recommended by the Council of 
Europe.
A bill circulated by the Office of the Prosecutor-General and posted on a 
government website on Wednesday says that slander and insults directed at state 
officials performing their duties have become commonplace and must be 
criminalized. It says that individuals making slanderous claims through mass 
media or other public channels must face up to two years’ imprisonment and heavy 
fines.
Armenia’s leading media organizations expressed serious concern over the bill on 
Thursday, saying that it could be used by the authorities as a “tool” against 
legitimate criticism. In a joint statement, they described it as a “logical 
continuation” of recent legislative measures aimed at restricting press freedom 
in the country.
The statement pointed to the Armenian parliament’s decision last week to approve 
a fivefold increase in maximum legal fines set for defamation as well as 
pro-government lawmakers’ separate proposal to make it harder for journalists to 
use anonymous sources.
“We are expressing our disappointment with the fact that the authorities formed 
as a result of the 2018 revolution are planning unacceptable restrictions on the 
freedom of expression,” stated the 11 organizations.
“We do not want at all to defend slanderers and offenders,” they said. “But we 
find it necessary to remind that representatives of the authorities, officials 
and public figures must show utmost tolerance towards any criticism.”
The prosecutors’ initiative has been effectively endorsed by the Armenian 
Ministry of Justice. But it is not yet clear whether Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian’s government will back the proposed criminalization of defamation.
Some parliamentarians affiliated with Pashinian’s My Step bloc said last week 
that they would hail such a measure.
Daniel Ioannisian of the Union of Informed Citizens also criticized the 
prosecutors’ bill on Thursday, saying that it could result in media censorship.
“You will definitely find no European or democratic country that makes it a 
crime to insult or slander authorities but not [ordinary] citizens,” Ioannisian 
told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service.
“True, there are countries, including democratic ones, where defamation is a 
criminal offense … But there is no [democratic] country where insulting 
authorities is deemed a crime but insulting citizens is not,” he said.
Ioannisian said the authorities should tackle instead the spread of false 
information by anonymous or fake social media accounts.
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2021 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

CivilNet: Syunik: The Reality on the Ground

CIVILNET.AM

06:18

[OPINION]

By Gevorg Tosunyan

It’s impossible to get a full picture of what’s taking place in Syunik from Yerevan or from any other city․ You have to be on the ground, climb the military posts, visit the villages, and talk to the people. While on a reporting project, I traveled the entire length of Armenia’s southernmost Syunik Province, from Goris to Meghri. With Azerbaijan now on the other side, this is the reality on the ground. 

Russian border guards in Syunik

We were interviewing a volunteer serviceman in a military post in one of the villages in Syunik, near the town of Kapan, when we heard shots being fired in the distance. We wrapped up the interview, and the servicemann called the commander to ask which fired the weapon. The commander responds that it didn’t come from an Armenian position. So it was the Azerbaijanis.

“The Russians will get unsettled now. They want to know who did it. They don’t allow a single shot to be fired. Even firing drills are not allowed,” the serviceman tells us.

On our way back to Kapan from the military post, we noticed a Russian border guard speeding to the frontline.

Away from this region, the general public seems to have the impression that the Russian border guards are only stationed on the Shurnukh road, which in some places passes through the territories handed over to Azerbaijan. The reality is that Russian border guards are roaming Syunik’s entire frontline. At times, the Russians find out about certain tensions and respond even before the Armenian or Azerbaijani armies.

The eight kilometers of the Chakaten-Kapan road and most of the Shurnukh-Vorotan road pass through the territory handed over to Azerbaijan. Azerbaijanis have placed the now famous “Welcome to Azerbaijan” sign on those sections of the road. We are told that a few days ago, some people from nearby villages shot at the sign, and in response, the Azerbaijani army blocked the road. The situation was resolved with Russian mediation. Since that day, a Russian border guard vehicle has been parked in front of the sign day and night.

The military posts

Earlier in February, the Armenian border guards announced that any journalist wishing to travel to and film in Syunik must obtain permission from the National Security Service. So why doesn’t the government want journalists to go near military positions and speak with servicemen? I found the answer after visiting more than 20 military posts near the frontline. I saw Armenian volunteers and soldiers who with their own means are creating living and bathing conditions for themselves on the mountains. Meanwhile, the opposing Azerbaijanis have and continue to establish well-built tent settlements.

Azerbaijanis and Armenians deployed to this area at the same time, but the opponent was more prepared, at least that’s how it looks from Syunik.

Armenian volunteers and servicemen in the military positions have poor living conditions. But no matter how unpleasant, the volunteers don’t even consider leaving. They say that if they leave, the Azerbaijanis will move forward and position themselves in their place. So the volunteers stay and wait for the army to replace them. The Armenian army is in the process of setting up official military posts and deploying soldiers to the entire frontline of Syunik.

There won’t be any official news about this situation. But now, more than ever, we must be honest, raise the issues and find solutions.

Don’t underestimate the opponent and don’t overestimate us

I am from the generation that was fed a tale in which the Armenian soldier is smart and the Azerbaijani soldier is cowardly and ignorant. This short-sighted approach was one of the factors that led to our defeat.

After spending just a few days in Syunik, I was convinced that the enemy knows how to make us anxious, how to remind us of our defeat. At the moment, this is not done with weapons but with ordinary psychological tricks. The “Welcome to Azerbaijan” sign on the road is an example.

Most of the Vorotan road is now under Azerbaijani control. Once you exit that section, on the left side of the road you see Russian and Azerbaijani soldiers. Azerbaijanis have placed a fence on their side, and their flag accompanied by a soldier with a gun is always visible to both passing and arriving vehicles.

Azerbaijanis have also set up large white tents in their positions, at least four in each. Three out of four might be empty, but they try to give the impression that the area is controlled by a lot more of them than there really are.

For the dreamers

From Meghri, a southern town in Syunik near the border with Iran, we decided to return to Yerevan not via the main road, but by the secondary one, which passes through Shvanidzor, Tsavov, and Chakaten. At the foot of one of the mountains, there is a small village, or rather a collection of homes․ There are about 50 houses and churches — all abandoned, destroyed or half-destroyed. This village is not even on the map, but it is an important reminder for everyone who passes by it that we are indifferent towards our homeland. 

The villages near Kapan, especially the communities closest to Karabakh, are half-ruined and abandoned, while the natural beauty remains indescribable.

When I am told that we will bring back Kars, Ardahan, and the rest of Artsakh, these abandoned villages come to my mind. At times, it seems that those who dream of an Armenia from sea to sea cherish that dream more than they cherish what we have now.

About 400 explosive objects defused by Russian sappers in Martuni region of Artsakh

Panorama, Armenia
Feb 18 2021

The personnel of the humanitarian demining company of the Russian peacekeeping contingent carried out work on clearing the area of explosive objects in the area of the settlement of Karmir Shuka  in tMartuni district of Artsakh, the Russian defense ministry reported. 

According to the source, during the mine clearance, Russian sappers neutralized about 400 explosive objects, including 122-mm high-explosive artillery shells and cumulative tank ammunition.

Detected explosives removed and destroyed at the specially equipped Ballidzha training ground. Ammunition that could not be evacuated was destroyed on the spot, with all necessary safety measures being taken during the blasting operations.

In total, since November 23, 2020, 1,419 hectares of territory, 443 km of roads, 1,361 housing structures, including 30 socially significant objects, have been cleared of unexploded ordnance, 24,453 explosive objects have been found and neutralized, the source said. 

The Nagono-Karabakh conflict can not be considered solved unless the issue of status is regulated – Ararat Mirzoyan

Panorama, Armenia
Feb 18 2021

Armenia observes Iran as a friendly country and a reliable partner, Speaker of Armenian parliament Ararat Mirzoyan stated on Thursday at the meeting with Ambassador of the Islamic Republic of Iran (in Armenia Abbas Badakhshan Zohouri.

Touching upon the Artsakh conflict, Ararat Mirzoyan stated that it is necessary to call into life the affirmed agreements after the tripartite statement signed on November 9 on the ceasefire: to carry out the urgent exchange of prisoners of war and other captive persons as a priority with the principle all-for-all as soon as possible. The Speaker also added that the conflict could not be considered solved eventually, unless the issue of Nagorno Karabakh status would be regulated in the format of the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairmanship – the Artsakh Armenians’ right to self-determination. Ararat Mirzoyan underlined that Iran cannot abstain from expressing its position on Artsakh issue, taking into consideration also the active involvement of other regional states for the benefit of the Azerbaijani side, both in the phase of military actions and during its following period.

Ambassador Zohouri informed that the Iranian side welcomes the reaching of the agreement on ceasefire in Artsakh and reaffirmed the viewpoint voiced by the FM Zarif that the problem of repatriation of prisoners of war shall be speedily solved.

During the meeting the sides discussed a number of issues on more enlivening of the inter-parliamentary ties, the activation of the economic relations between the two countries and developing joint economic activities especially in Syunik, the press department at the parliament reported. 

3,577 bodies passed forensic examination, DNA analysis of other 428 in process

Panorama, Armenia
Feb 18 2021

3,577 bodies of killed servicemen passed forensic examination since September 27, 2020 to February 13, 2021 inclusive, Aysor.am news portal reports, citing the date of Armenia’s Ministry of Health. According to the source, as of February 13, DNA analysis of other 428 bodies are in the process.

It is noted that the number of killed servicemen announced by Artsakh Defense Army is 2,364 as of February 16, while as of February 17, Artsakh rescuers found bodies of 1,485 killed servicemen and civilians.

Sports: Armenian national team maintains its position in the FIFA/Coca-Cola World ranking

Panorama, Armenia
Feb 18 2021

The International Federation of Association Football (FIFA) has released the updated FIFA/Coca-Cola World rankings for national football teams on Thursday, with the Armenian squad maintaining the 99th position as of February 2021, the Football Federation of Armenia reported.

The other teams in the top 5 are France, Brazil, England, and Portugal.

Advisor to Armenia PM: There are problems with agriculture in Syunik Province, particularly in Vorotan

News.am, Armenia
Feb 18 2021

During today’s government session, Advisor to the Prime Minister of Armenia Robert Ghukasyan stated that the residents of the borderline settlements of Syunik Province have problems with farming and cattle-raising.

Ghukasyan noted that people used to farm and raise cattle in wider spaces, but they don’t have the opportunity to do that now. “This is especially a problem in Vorotan, which has a very small district. The government is working with the Ministry of Economy and will provide solutions for greenhouse economies, intensive gardens and smart cattle barns. I’ll present the final solutions during the next government session,” he said, adding that demining has already begun since the season for farming is approaching.

In his turn, Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan stated that the specific actions will help the residents of Syunik Province feel that the government supports them.