Israel’s Refusal to Recognize the Armenian Genocide Is Indefensible

Foreign Policy

YEREVAN, Armenia—Walking atop Tsitsernakaberd Hill overlooking the Armenian capital of Yerevan, one can see the striking similarities to Jerusalem. The view resembles that from Yad Vashem, the main Israeli memorial site that honors and commemorates the 6 million Jews who perished in the Holocaust.

At Yad Vashem, also located on a hill, there is the “Avenue of the Righteous Among the Nations,” where trees have been planted to commemorate gentiles who saved Jews. In Yerevan, foreign leaders and other dignitaries are also asked to pay respect to the memory of those who died by planting trees.

Tsitsernakaberd (which means “swallows’ fortress”) hosts the central memorial monument to the 1.5 million Armenians who died as a result of the Ottoman Empire’s premeditated decision during World War I to harass, arrest, and eventually deport them to the Syrian Desert to let them die.

The 144-foot-tall monument is meant to symbolize rebirth. Twelve slabs form a circle that represents the parts of Armenians’ historical homeland in present-day Turkey, and an eternal flame dedicated to those killed during the Armenian genocide lies in the center of the circle.

After the war, during the short-lived first Armenian Republic, assassins volunteered for Operation Nemesis. Its aim was to avenge the deaths of their people by killing Turkish ministers and generals who were responsible for the genocide. Among those assassinated were the “Three Pashas”: the war minister, Ismail Enver; the interior minister, Mehmed Talaat; and the navy minister and governor of Syria, Ahmed Djemal.

Israel has consistently refused to acknowledge that what happened to the Armenian people was a genocide.

More than 20 years later, after World War II, Jewish fighters known as “The Avengers” also decided to take revenge and devised a plan to kill German SS officers responsible for murdering Jews during the Holocaust. They planned to poison German drinking water and bakeries. (Dozens of Germans were killed, but the poisoning plans failed.)

Despite the shared experience of genocide, Israel and Armenia are worlds apart today.

Israel has consistently refused to acknowledge that what happened to the Armenian people was a genocide. This decision doesn’t derive so much from a desire to monopolize victimhood and portray the Holocaust as a unique and unparalleled historical event. It is primarily a cynical political ploy.

For many years, Israel feared Turkey’s wrath if it recognized the genocide. Since the late 1950s, Turkey had been a strong strategic ally of the Jewish state—one of its only friends in the Muslim world. There were close ties between the two nations’ intelligence and security establishments, and Turkey was an important and lucrative market for Israeli weapons. Whenever Israeli parliamentarians, human rights activists, and historians called for recognition of the Armenian genocide, the initiative was blocked by the government. Regardless of their ideology and political orientation, consecutive Israeli governments, knowing that any change of heart and policy would anger Turkey and jeopardize arms sales, placed economic interests before universal values. They agreed to define the genocide only as a “tragedy.”

But in the past decade, relations between Turkey, under the leadership of Recep Tayyip Erdogan, and Israel have deteriorated. Arms sales were halted, and the clandestine intelligence cooperation aimed against the mutual enemy—Syria—was terminated. Nowadays, with Turkish-Israeli political and military relations at a new low, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his son Yair regularly exchange nasty verbal blows over Twitter with Erdogan, calling each other “tyrant,” “murderer,” and more.

My Grandmother Escaped The Armenian Genocide, But She Never Forgot

WBUR
 
 
My Grandmother Escaped The Armenian Genocide, But She Never Forgot
 
John Christie
The author and his grandmother, Hovsepian “Rose” Banaian, circa 1950. (Courtesy)
 
On April 24, Armenians all over the world will gather for the annual Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day, recognizing the onset of the Ottoman Empire’s campaign of ethnic cleansing. It began in 1915, ultimately killing 1.5 million Armenians, including my Nana’s mother, my great-grandmother. She died as many Armenians did — on a forced march to a concentration camp.
 
My great-grandfather was murdered in another Turkish murder spree, a rehearsal to the genocide, the 1909 Adana massacre.
 
For me, my family and Armenian-Americans from Watertown to Fresno, our hearts are hardened doubly on the day of remembrance. Once, for the cruel deaths of our parents, grandparents or great-grandparents. And once again for the insulting fact that the perpetrators continue to this day to deny, with impunity, what happened.
 
Scholars worldwide recognize the Armenian genocide and many western countries, including France and Germany, have formally declared the event a genocide. But Turkey maintains that whatever happened in 1915 was a civil dispute between Armenians and Turks — with deaths on both sides.
 
People outside the Turkish Consulate protest the deaths of an estimated 1.5 million Armenians under the Ottoman Empire, Monday, April 24, 2017, in Los Angeles. (Jae C. Hong/AP)
 
Turkey’s denial of the truth has for years admonished Armenians to never set foot in Turkey. I had always taken the warning to heart.
 
But something changed as I grew older. Like many Baby Boomers, I’ve been reflecting on my past and discovering a deep well of gratitude for the immigrants who sacrificed to give us a good life.
 
I wanted to honor them, especially my Nana, who died in 1995. I wanted to do what she would not: return to the village she’d fled as a child, to declare — by my very presence — that she survived and even thrived.
 
In the spring of 1909, Gulenia Hovsepian — who would become my Nana — was a 9-year-old girl tending her family’s livestock in Bitias, a mountainous village in the Musa Dagh valley overlooking the Mediterranean. She recalled in a tape recording that a Turkish boy ran up to her, declaring “They’re killing the kafirs!” Kafirs were Christians like her family.
 
The Musa Dagh valley, Turkey, once the home of six Armenian villages, including the author’s grandmother’s, Bitias. (Courtesy)
 
She ran home through a grove of mulberry trees, the leaves tickling her cheeks.
 
When she arrived, her father was arming himself to join other Armenian villagers to fend off the Turks. But he was among hundreds of villagers killed, most likely stabbed to death.
 
My Nana was rescued by missionaries and spent her teenage years in a Lutheran orphanage in Beirut, safe from the genocide. But when she was 19, she made her way to America for an arranged marriage with an Armenian man living in New Hampshire. They had six children, including my mother.
 
She lived in a tenement on a dead-end street in our New England mill town, Dover, New Hampshire. My mother, father, brother and I lived in the same tenement, one door away. Nana raised me as much as my parents did, feeding me when they were at their factory jobs, reading Golden Books to me, singing me a lullaby she learned in the orphanage.
 
Despite her tragic life story, I never heard hateful words from her until I heard her on the recording talking about the Turkish government.
 
“Damn them,” she said. “They don’t want to admit it.”
 
On a warm day in June 2018, I boarded a flight to Istanbul with my 38-year-old son, Nick. He asked to come along to honor his great-grandmother and help his 70-year-old dad negotiate any obstacles.
 
Our driver took us up the lush Musa Dagh valley to Bitias, through steep switchbacks, swerving around pedestrians, women pushing baby carriages, couples on scooters and wayward chickens.
 
I wanted to do what she would not: return to the village she’d fled as a child, to declare — by my very presence — that she survived and even thrived.
 
Nick and I walked the narrow streets of my Nana’s hometown, absorbing what surely had not changed since she roamed here: the intense sunlight, the heat, the Mediterranean breezes, the smell of wood fires and cow manure. Standing in a field we believed once belonged to our family, I thought: An awful thing happened here. But instead of anger, I felt something unexpected: pride and defiance.
 
There was one more thing we could do. We went looking for mulberry trees. We walked up and down the hilly village; olive and orange trees everywhere. Nary a mulberry, until we spotted one in the corner of a yard, its branches overhanging at eye level. I snatched a dozen leaves and carried them home in the pages of a notebook. I couldn’t bring my grandmother to her home, but I could bring a piece of home back to her.
 
A few weeks after returning to the U.S., I drove to Pine Hill Cemetery in Dover where she was buried in the shadow of a tall spruce. I slipped one of the leaves out of my notebook, set it on her gravestone, securing it with a rock. I stepped back and took in the scene: Nana’s name engraved on the stone, the mulberry leaf and the ground below me where her body lay.
 
My breath quickened and tears came unbidden. All I could think, all I could say was, “Nana, here’s that leaf that tickled your cheeks when you were a little girl about to lose everything. Nana, I’m here, and I’m sorry.”
 
On Remembrance Day, like other descendants of Armenian genocide victims, I don’t know whether to bow my head in grief or shake my fist in anger.
 

France marks first national commemoration of Armenian genocide

France 24, France
 
 
France marks first national commemoration of Armenian genocide
 
Latest update : 24/04/2019
 
© Boris Horvat, AFP | A march in the city of Marseille commemorating the Armenian genocide on April 24, 2016.
 
 
France is marking its first “national day of commemoration of the Armenian genocide” on Wednesday, fulfilling a pledge by President Emmanuel Macron that has angered the Turkish government.
 
Macron announced the commemoration at a meeting with representatives of the country’s large Armenian community in February, honouring a promise made during his 2017 presidential campaign.
 
“France is, first and foremost, the country that knows how to look history in the face,” he said at the time, noting that France was among the first countries to denounce the World War I slaughter of Armenians by their Ottoman rulers.
 
France’s recognition of the massacre as a genocide was enshrined in law in 2001, following a lengthy struggle that has strained relations with Turkey.
 

For decades, Armenia and Turkey have been at odds over whether the World War I killings and deportations  which Armenia says left 1.5 million dead  should be described as genocide.

Turkey accepts that many Armenians living in the Ottoman Empire were killed but denies that the killings were systematically orchestrated and constitute a genocide.

Macron’s announcement in February drew an angry response from Ankara, with a spokesman for Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan declaring: “No one can sully our history.”

Earlier this month, Turkey also chastised the Italian parliament for approving a motion to officially recognise the killings as genocide.

Armenians commemorate the massacres on April 24 – the day in 1915 when thousands of Armenian intellectuals suspected of harbouring nationalist sentiment and being hostile to Ottoman rule were rounded up.

 

Turkish Press: Turkey remembers Ottoman Armenians who died in WWI

Anadolu Agency, Turkey
Turkey remembers Ottoman Armenians who died in WWI

Enes Kaplan   | 24.04.2019

ANKARA

Turkey on Wednesday commemorated the Ottoman Armenians who died during the course of World War I. 

“With respect I commemorate the Ottoman Armenians who died in hard conditions during World War I,” Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said in a letter on Wednesday to Archbishop Aram Atesyan, general vicar of the Armenian Patriarchate of Turkey.

Erdogan said that peace, security, and happiness of Turkey’s Armenian community are greatly important for Turkey.

Offering his condolences to the descendants of Ottoman Armenians who died in the war, Erdogan stated that the Armenian community has raised many valuable young people to contribute to Turkey’s well-being.

He said that as free and equal citizens in Turkey, Armenian people have important roles in the country’s social, political, and business life.

Erdogan said that Turkey aims to cement ties between ethnic Turks and Armenians, who have shared mutual pains and joy in history.

He stated that Turkey will continue to stand by Armenians to relieve their pains and solve their problems.

“I believe the way to build a joint future can only be done by standing united and together,” Erdogan said.

He warned Armenians against circles who want to poison this shared past by sowing hatred and hostility.

Turkey’s position on the events of 1915 is that the deaths of Armenians in eastern Anatolia took place when some sided with invading Russians and revolted against Ottoman forces. A subsequent relocation of Armenians resulted in numerous casualties.

Turkey objects to the presentation of these incidents as a “genocide,” describing them as a tragedy in which both sides suffered casualties.

Ankara has repeatedly proposed the creation of a joint commission of historians from Turkey and Armenia as well as international experts to tackle the issue.


Sports: Olympic champion Khadzhimurat Gatsalov to represent Armenian team

News.am, Armenia

Olympic champion of 2004, five-time world champion and three-time European champion, a former member of the Russian freestyle wrestling team Khadzhimurat Gatsalov, expressed a desire to act under the Armenian flag, the official website of UWW reported

“Within the last few weeks, Gatsalov began the transfer process and has aspirations of competing in an Armenian singlet at the 2019 World Championships in Nur-Sultan, Kazakhstan, which take place in mid-September,” the source added.

Gatsalov performs in the weight category of 97 kg, in which Russia is represented by the Olympic champion of 2016, three-time world and European champion, 22-year-old Abdulrashid Sadulayev.

President of Artsakh attends opening ceremony of Zaven Sargsyan’s individual photo exhibition

President of Artsakh attends opening ceremony of Zaven Sargsyan’s individual photo exhibition 

Save

Share

16:49,

YEREVAN, APRIL 23, ARMENPRESS. Artsakh Republic President Bako Sahakyan attended the opening ceremony of an individual photo exhibition by Zaven Sargsyan, director of The Yerevan Sergey Parajanov Museum, held in Stepanakert Gallery on April 23, the Artsakh Presidential Office told Armenpress.

The President noted with satisfaction that exhibitions of Zaven Sargsyan in Artsakh were of a periodic nature expressing hope that this tradition would be maintained in the future too.

Edited and translated by Aneta Harutyunyan




President Bako Sahakyan visits editorial office of

President Bako Sahakyan visits editorial office of “Azat Artsakh” newspaper

Save

Share

16:51,

YEREVAN, APRIL 23, ARMENPRESS. Artsakh Republic President Bako Sahakyan visited on April 23 the editorial office of “Azat Artsakh” [Free Artsakh] republican newspaper to meet with the staff, the Presidential Office told Armenpress.

Issues related to the activity and future plans of the newspaper were on the discussion agenda.

Edited and translated by Aneta Harutyunyan




Armenia requests Russia to extradite arrested ex-official

Armenia requests Russia to extradite arrested ex-official

Save

Share

17:08,

YEREVAN, APRIL 23, ARMENPRESS. Armenia has submitted the package of required documents to Russia requesting the extradition of Mihran Poghosyan (pictured above), a former lawmaker and former government official wanted on charges of abuse of power and embezzlement, the General Prosecution told ARMENPRESS.

Poghosyan was detained by Russian authorities in the Republic of Karelia in pursuance of an Armenian arrest warrant.

He was charged and declared wanted on April 15th.

Poghosyan is suspected in the crimes during his tenure as Head of the Service of Mandatory Execution of Judicial Acts, a governmental agency under the Ministry of Justice in charge of enforcing judicial rulings.  He resigned from the position in 2016 when his name appeared in the Panama Papers scandal, although he denied wrongdoing.

Edited and translated by Stepan Kocharyan




Central Bank of Armenia: exchange rates and prices of precious metals – 23-04-19

Central Bank of Armenia: exchange rates and prices of precious metals – 23-04-19

Save

Share

17:15,

YEREVAN, 23 APRIL, ARMENPRESS. The Central Bank of Armenia informs “Armenpress” that today, 23 April, USD exchange rate down by 0.42 drams to 481.56 drams. EUR exchange rate down by 0.18 drams to 542.00 drams. Russian Ruble exchange rate stood at 7.56 drams. GBP exchange rate up by 0.47 drams to 626.56 drams.

The Central Bank has set the following prices for precious metals.

Gold price down by 17.23 drams to 19751.04 drams. Silver price down by 0.20 drams to 231.54 drams. Platinum price down by 21.46 drams to 13779.44 drams.

Three police officers from Sevan PD indicted for torturing, humiliating handcuffed suspect in 2018

Three police officers from Sevan PD indicted for torturing, humiliating handcuffed suspect in 2018

Save

Share

17:17,

YEREVAN, APRIL 23, ARMENPRESS. Three police officers of the Sevan Police Department are charged with abuse of power and torture as the Special Investigative Service concluded an investigation into an October 7, 2018 case.

On that day, a misdemeanor suspect was detained by the Sevan Police Department officers and taken into custody at the local police station.

According to the investigators, two officers physically abused the handcuffed suspect at the station. He was then taken to another room, where another officer, a high-ranking one, joined the two and resumed torturing the suspect by beating him. The officers also humiliated the suspect by expectorating on him.

The suspect sustained numerous physical injuries.

One of the officers is arrested pending trial, while the other two are on bail and banned from leaving the country.

The Special Investigative Service has concluded the investigation and the indictment has been sent to the prosecutor for further proceedings.

Edited and translated by Stepan Kocharyan