Constitutional Court can make no decision over any concrete criminal case – Gor Abrahamyan

Constitutional Court can make no decision over any concrete criminal case – Gor Abrahamyan

Save

Share

20:54, 4 September, 2019

YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 4, ARMENPRESS. Advisor to the Prosecutor General of Armenia Gor Abrahamyan commented on the decision of the Constitutional Court over Robert Kocharyan’s case.

”I read the headlines of different news outlets and there is the impression that the Constitutional Court of Armenia has made a decision over a criminal case or has expressed opinion over the defense of his rights.

And this is only when the Constitutional Court has published only the final part of the decision, which means there is no complete decision yet.

The Constitutional Court cannot make a decision over any concrete criminal case. It is authorized to make a decision only regarding the constitutionality of the legal acts and their provisions.

It will be possible to speak about the cosnequences of the decision only after getting aquainted with the complete decison. We should not get ahead of time”, reads Abrahamyan’s statement, reports ARMENPRESS.

Edited and translated by Tigran Sirekanyan




YSU History Museum named after late founding-director Ludwig Gharibjanyan

YSU History Museum named after late founding-director Ludwig Gharibjanyan

Save

Share

10:34, 5 September, 2019

YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 5, ARMENPRESS. The Yerevan State University’s (YSU) Academic Council has decided to name the YSU History Museum after Professor Ludwig Gharibjanyan, the late renowned historian who was the founding director of the museum.

The decision was made on the occasion of the 100th anniversary of YSU’s foundation. The university said in a news release that Gharibyanjan “had invaluable contribution in the foundation and development of the museum”.

The recommendation to make the decision was made by YSU History Museum’s Director Heghine Gasparyan earlier in August.

Gharibjanyan died in 2011 at the age of 89. He lectured at the YSU from 1945.

Edited and translated by Stepan Kocharyan

A1+: Some data presented were not accurate – Erik Grigoryan (video)

September 4, 2019

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s government held a consultation today on the situation with the Amulsar project.

Minister of Nature Protesction Erik Grigoryan summarized the general situation.

There were exchanges of views on the issues related to Amulsar Project Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) procedures, legal aspects of the problem, emergence of new environmental factors, etc.

Summing up the discussion, the Prime Minister instructed all interested departments and institutions to work in a coordinated manner to provide comprehensive analysis and complete data for the investigation.e


Asbarez: Armenia’s High Court Finds Jailing Kocharian to be ‘Unconstitutional’

Former president Robert Kocharian addresses the court during the fourth day of his trial on May 16 (Photo by Armenpress)

YEREVAN (Azatutyun.am)—Armenia Constitutional Court on Wednesday declared unconstitutional a legal provision that has been used by law-enforcement authorities for arresting and prosecuting former President Robert Kocharian.

Kocharian’s lawyers had challenged the legality of two articles of the Armenian Code of Procedural Justice invoked by investigators accusing him of taking bribes and overthrowing the constitutional order shortly before the end of his decade-long rule in 2008.

The court ruled that one of those articles is unconstitutional because it does not take account of current and former senior Armenian officials’ immunity from prosecution guaranteed by the Armenian constitution. But it dismissed the defense lawyers’ objections to the other clause that spells out legal grounds for arresting criminal suspects.

The ruling was signed by six of the nine Constitutional Court judges, including the court chairman, Hrayr Tovmasyan. Two other judges wrote dissenting opinions that were not immediately made public.

The ninth judge, Vahe Grigoryan, was excluded from the consideration of Kocharian’s appeal because of having previously represented relatives of the eight protesters killed in the March 2008 post-election unrest in Yerevan. Kocharian and three retired Armenian generals stand accused of illegally using the armed forces against opposition supporters who demanded the rerun of a disputed presidential election. They all deny the accusation.

Speaking to reporters, one of Kocharian’s lawyers, Aram Vartevanyan, seemed satisfied with the Constitutional Court verdict read out by Tovmasyan. Vartevanyan said the ruling means that Kocharian’s arrest constituted a “violation of his constitutional rights” and that the ex-president should therefore be released from jail.

Asked whether he believes his client must also be cleared of the coup charges, Vartevanyan said: “We will be able to answer this question only after familiarizing ourselves with the full text of the court’s decision.”

Armenian prosecutors and the Special Investigative Service (SIS), which indicted Kocharian in July 2018, did not immediately react to the court ruling.

In July, Pashinian accused Tovmasyan of cutting political deals with Kocharian’s successor, Serzh Sarkisian, to “privatize” Armenia’s highest court. Tovmasyan responded by warning the government against attempting to force him and his colleagues to resign.

Kocharian was set free five days after the start of his trial in May. A district court judge presiding over it, Davit Grigoryan, further angered government supporters with his decision to suspend the trial and ask the Constitutional Court to rule on the legality of the charges brought against the ex-president.

Kocharian was arrested again after Armenia’s Court of Appeals overturned Grigoryan’s decisions in late June. Law-enforcement authorities charged Grigoryan with forgery in the following weeks. The judge was suspended as a result.

The case was then assigned to another judge, Anna Danibekyan. She is due to resume Kocharian’s trial on September 12.

Asbarez: Pianist Sofya Melikyan in Concert at Fresno State

Pianist Sofya Melikyan

FRESNO—Award-winning pianist Sofya Melikyan will perform a recital as part of the “Young Armenian Talent” series of the Philip Lorenz Memorial Keyboard Concert Series at Fresno State. The performance will take place at 7:30 p.m. on Friday, September 27 in the Concert Hall on the Fresno State campus. Melikyan will be performing works by Chopin, Rachmaninov, Komitas, and Geghuni Chitchyan.

The concert is co-sponsored by the Armenian Studies Program of Fresno State and the Thomas A. Kooyumjian Family Foundation.

Melikyan has recently performed in recitals at Carnegie Hall, Lincoln Center, the American Liszt Society in New York, the Kennedy Center in Washington, D.C., Guangzhou Opera House in China, Bulgaria Concert Hall in Sofia, Santiago de Compostela Auditorium in Spain, “Chopin+” Festival in Luxembourg, as well as debuts with the North Shore Symphony Orchestra in Chicago and Vancouver Symphony in the U.S.

Born in Yerevan, Armenia, Sofya Melikyan began her musical formation at the Tchaikovsky Special School of Yerevan with Anahit Shajbazyan. She completed her further training at the Royal Conservatory of Madrid with Joaquin Soriano (where she graduated with Honors), Ecole Normale de Musique Alfred Cortot in Paris with Ramzi Yassa (where she, again, graduated with Honors), and the Manhattan School of Music in New York with Solomon Mikowsky.

Hailed for her “magnificent singing line and exquisite artistic sensibility,” this Armenian-born pianist is recognized as an artist with a unique voice combining “high-wire virtuosity” with “deep musical intuition and the ability to connect with the audience” (Mundoclasico).

General tickets for the Concert are available for $25 per person, $18 for seniors,, and $5 for students. Ticket reservations for the concert can be made online, or by calling 559.278.2337.

Free parking will be available in Lot P1 (Shaw and Maple entrance to campus). For more information please contact the Armenian Studies Program at 559.278.2669 or visit the website.

Priotix Advances Armenia’s Competitiveness in Global IT Market

The Priotix team

Priotix Software Development Company is one of the many ventures that are advancing Armenia’s burgeoning IT sector and advancing the country’s goals of becoming a regional hub for advanced technologies and innovation.

The company’s chief executive office Lusine Vardanyan said that Priotix has been developing and maintaining both enterprise software solutions as well as web and native mobile applications with global clients for several years. She also discussed the growth in IT and how technology is strengthening Armenia’s future. Below is her interview with Asbarez.

Asbarez: Lusine, how would you describe the IT market’s development in Armenia?

Lusine Vardanyan: Armenia has been one of the great innovation hubs for centuries, one that many have unfortunately never heard of. That is why many global tech companies are surprised by the quality results they achieve through opening development offices in Armenia.

As a strategic economic cluster for the country, the government tries to boost the IT sector by providing tax breaks and investments in education, which remains behind in its desired benchmarks.

Nationwide, there are about 800 IT companies. In the past ten years, the industry has been growing by an average of 23%, and a number of experts in and around the space have agreed that this growth will continue. You may also have seen an article, titled “Yerevan – Silicon Mountains,” in which Yerevan is ranked fourth among the top 10 startup capitals.

Asbarez: How else is that growth being encouraged and fostered?

L.V.: Promoting young talent is a priority in the Armenian IT sector. By 2018, around 19,550 people were employed by the industry, with the government’s target being to employ around 40,000 IT professionals by 2025.

The industry is also comparatively feminine. Almost 30% of Armenian IT professionals are women, though I still face predominantly male executives at industry events as one of the few female CEOs in the Armenian tech industry.

Lusine Vardanyan Priotix CTO Felix Khachatryan

Asbarez: What is the main focus of Priotix?

L.V.: Priotix, which was previously known as Sourcio, is a full-service custom software partner with an incredibly experienced senior development team based in Armenia. The team has been developing and maintaining both enterprise software solutions as well as web and native mobile applications with our global clients for several years.

Asbarez: How do you differentiate yourself from competitors in the domestic software development market?

L.V.: Our team prides itself on engineering maturity, quality and scalability of our delivered solutions, and our ability to meet time-to-market requirements. This is what makes the company different, and it’s how we’ve been able to secure a client return rate of more than 95% and a satisfaction rate close to 100%.

We are one of the very few software partners in Armenia securing high quality scalable cloud architecture and deployment, CI/CD, automated workflows, and testing environments, as well as automated monitoring and alerting.

Another differentiator of Priotix is that we usually don’t commit to short-term and one-time projects. Our strategic business model is partnering with global clients who are looking for long-term dedicated teams that fully substitute their IT departments.

We commit to those long-term software development projects which bring with them exciting end products and business propositions, as we usually negotiate equity partnerships for both the company and the dedicated team on top of signing a service contract. Partnership is our cornerstone business model both with the team and clients.

Asbarez: What are your company’s future plans, both in the near future and in the long term?

L.V.: One of our mid-term goals is developing a new service of big data engineering, trying to leverage the expertise of our certified engineers to assist both current and new clients with their ever-growing big data engineering needs.

Our company’s growth is very dynamic, so, in the long term, we plan to expand by bringing more like-minded experienced software developers, data engineers, DevOps, QAs, and other professionals to our great team.

Priotix team members

Asbarez: Can you tell us about some of the flagship products developed by Priotix?

L.V.: One such flagship product that we’ve partnered with is a Minnesota-based startup with an Armenian founder focusing on competitive video games and the esports industry.

We have developed an unparalleled web platform called WIN.gg that is a content hub covering such popular games as Dota 2, Counter-Strike: Global Offensive, League of Legends, Overwatch, Fortnite, and more.

It’s a venue through which gamers, enthusiasts, bettors, and any other industry stakeholders may benefit from individually customized news content, statistics, tournament standings, and more. In the near future they will also be able to access dynamic rankings and AI-powered match projections.

WIN also has its own CS:GO competitive league targeting up-and-coming teams looking to launch their careers forward. Winners League 3rd season starts from October 2019. And we’ve recently launched mobile apps for iOS and Android that can be downloaded from App Store and Google’s marketplace.

For now, WIN’s main markets are North America and Europ, with strategic goals of expanding to China and other Asian markets in the future.

Asbarez: What drew you to work on this particular project?

L.V.: You likely know that video gaming is booming in the United States and around the world, with 22.3 percent annual growth rate in the industry. 1 out of 4 millennials are playing at least one competitive game on a daily basis. The annual growth rates for both revenue and audience have been higher than for traditional sports for several years now.

With all of this being considered, we think WIN.gg has incredible potential.

WINN.gg  founder and CEO Serge Vardanyan

Asbarez: Can you tell us more about WIN.gg?

L.V.: Pre-seed and Seed investors of the startup company share our belief in the industry’s future and in the product’s potential, as the founder and CEO Serge Vardanyan has already raised several million dollars from local angel investors.

Serge has always had a passion for competitive gaming, as well as a dream of creating his own successful company. He was born in Armenia and moved to the U.S. in 2015 upon accepting a job offer from a leading international gaming technology and service provider to manage operations in the Americas.

He decided to leave that company and pursue his dream. He was fortunate enough to find like-minded peers with whom he could start building an ambitious product that would eventually better any potential competitor in the market. With that ambitious goal in mind, he turned to Armenia and contracted Priotix in early 2018 for web and mobile development services, and WIN.gg has been our flagship partner since.

Baghdagyulyan Wins 1st Place at World Powerlifting Championship

AWPC World Powerlifting Championship 2019, from l to r: President of WPC Mike Sweeney, Secretary of WPC Amy Jackson, Vachagan Baghdagyulyan

Vachagan Baghdagyulyan, a professional master trainer Gold’s Gym in Armenia, won first place in his weight category at the AWPC World Powerlifting Championship in Orlando, Fla. The World Powerlifting Congress consists of 46 countries worldwide that participate in the annual championships. This year, the event was held from August 15 to 17.

Baghdagyulyan received the highest scores and becoming a 2019 World Champion of AWPC. His competition results were as follows:

  1. Squat: 567 lbs
  2. Bench Press: 391 lbs
  3. Deadlift: 639 lbs

Vachagan Baghdagyulyan at the 2019 World Powerlifting Championship

Baghdagyulyan was born on February 23, 1988 in Armenia, the city of Yerevan. He studied at a comprehensive school, Belinsky, from the 1995 to 2005. At the age of 10, Vachagan began playing professional soccer. He played for well-known teams in Armenia, in local team leagues, as well as major leagues.

In 2009, Vachagan graduated from the Armenian State Institute of Physical Culture with a bachelor’s degree in Sports Coaching. At the University, he began to engage in arm wrestling. During a competition between athletes of different professional institutes of the country, he was able to take the first place.

After graduating from university, he served in the army from 2009 to 2011. Continuing his arm wrestling competitions while in the army, he became a two-time champion.

Vachagan became an arm wrestling medalist in the national championship.

Upon returning from the army, he worked at Armenia’s Gold’s Gym, as a fitness trainer, from 2011 to 2013. In 2013, he received became certified as an international fitness trainer.

Between 2013 and 2017, he worked at the Mega Sport fitness center in St. Petersburg Russia.

After leaving his position at Mega Sport, Vachagan began working at Armenia’s Gold’s Gym as a Pro Master Trainer.

In 2017, he received the title “Master of Sports of International Class” from the Minister of Sports of Armenia.

Baghdagyulyan is a Pro Master Trainer from Armenia’s Gold’s Gym

Vachagan’s accomplishments include:

  1. Master of Sports of international class in deadlift
  2. Master of sports in the bench press
  3. Master of sports in powerlifting
  4. Prizewinner of St. Petersburg in the bench press (2015)
  5. Winner of the European Deadlift (2015)
  6. Champion of St. Petersburg in deadlift
  7. Absolute champion of the Northwestern Federal District in deadlift (2016)
  8. Absolute winner of St. Petersburg Powerlifting (2017)
  9. Winner of the Russian Open Deadlift Championship (2016)
  10. Winner of the World Cup of Deadlifts (Moscow, Russia) (2017)
  11. Prizewinner of the World Deadlift Championship (Kursk, Russia 2016)
  12. Winner of the St. Petersburg Powerlifting Cup (2017)
  13. 3rd place in deadlift, at the 35th WPC Powerlifting World Championship among professionals (U.S., Orlando 2018)
  14. 1st place in the AWPC World Powerlifting Championship 2019 (U.S., Orlando) with the results of 1598 lbs

168: US government demands that Armenia withdraw military group from Syria, Armenian defense minister categorically against withdrawal

Categories
Politics
World

And here we have it…According to 168.am, the US government recently demanded that Armenia withdraw its military group from Syria. A few days ago, the press issued an article stating that the Ministers of Defense and Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Armenia recently held a closed discussion with some ambassadors. Of course, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs refuted the meeting of the ministers, but according to the mass media, the topic of the meeting was the sending of a military group to Syria — something that was negatively perceived by the US government. Interestingly, this “message” was conveyed to the Armenian government right after Secretary of the Security Council of the Russian Federation Nikolai Patrushev paid a visit to Armenia on August 12-13, 2019. Rumor has it that Patrushev had recommended increasing the personnel of the military group.

According to 168.am’s sources, Permanent Representative of the Republic of Armenia to the United Nations Mher Margaryan told the Armenian authorities about the US government’s discontent and emphasized that the presence of an Armenian military group in Syria is having a negative impact on US-Armenia relations. According to the same sources, relevant US institutions also stated that failure to withdraw the military group will lead to consequences in US-Armenia relations and that Armenia must not use the equipment provided by the US government for demining in Syria. Minister of Defense Davit Tonoyan and Minister of Foreign Affairs Zohrab Mnatsakanyan considered the report of the diplomatic envoy. Mnatsakanyan said he was concerned about Armenia’s response to the US and recalled the speech that Nikol Pashinyan had given on August 17 of last year, announcing about an Armenian-Russian humanitarian project that will be unprecedented in the history of the newly independent Armenia.

During their discussion with the diplomat, both ministers tried to understand how Armenia can get out of this situation. Armenia may face problems with Russia and the United States. According to the same sources, Minister of Defense Davit Tonoyan was categorically against the demand to withdraw the military group. The decision of Nikol Pashinyan and his response to the demand of the Russians and Americans remains unclear.

Both the political opposition and experts had warned the government that Armenia would face foreign policy challenges after sending a military group to Syria under the flag of the Republic of Armenia. The former authorities were more flexible and were able to avoid such problems, maintaining the geopolitical balance. Pashinyan is compressing the circle around him on his own since he fails to observe all the warnings. The consequences are grave when a government takes uncalculated steps in order to maintain power, and those consequences are first and foremost grave for the country. By the way, let us not forget that the “boiler” of Amulsar (exploitation of the Amulsar gold mine) is “seething”.

Hours after this article was released, Minister of Defense of the Republic of Armenia Davit Tonoyan, in response to journalists, said the following: “The US government hasn’t demanded that Armenia withdraw its military group from Syria”, and Spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs Anna Naghdalyan said the following in regard to a discussion of Armenia’s government agencies under the title “US government demands that Armenia withdraw military group from Syria”:

“The Ministry of Foreign Affairs has refuted the information several times already. Currently, an attempt is being made to circulate the information already refuted by a state institution with new details that are fictional and don’t correspond to reality, and by doing this, they create fake news composed of several layers. The Ministry of Foreign Affairs does not accept the nonsensical speculation of issues related to the security of the Armenian community of Syria and the assistance that is provided to the community for narrow and personal interests. I would like to go off topic and simply add that the government agencies operating in the security sector and their leaders always hold consultations over various issues, and the heads of those government agencies have made statements on that several times.”

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 09/04/2019

                                        Wednesday, 
Judicial Official Expects ‘Legal’ Rulings From Constitutional Court
        • Astghik Bedevian
Armenia -- Ruben Vartazarian, head of the Supreme Judicial Council, holds a 
news conference in Yerevan, September 4, 2019.
The head of a state body overseeing Armenia’s judiciary said on Wednesday that 
the Constitutional Court will deal with the criminal case against former 
President Robert Kocharian in a way defined by the law.
“The issue will find a solution on the legal plane and on the plane of correct 
formulation of issues,” Ruben Vartazarian, the chairman of the Supreme Judicial 
Council, told a news conference.
Vartazarian spoke hours before the Constitutional Court ruled on one of the 
appeals lodged by Kocharian against his arrest and prosecution on charges 
stemming from the 2008 post-election violence in Yerevan.
One of the court’s nine judges, Vahe Grigorian, demanded last week that three 
of his colleagues, including the court’s chairman, Hrayr Tovmasian, recuse 
themselves from the case. Grigorian said that they cannot be impartial and 
objective because of having been previously involved in controversial decisions 
relating to the 2008 unrest case.
Grigorian himself was excluded from the consideration of Kocharian’s appeal in 
July. Tovmasian argued that he has represented relatives of the eight 
protesters killed in March 2008 in other courts.
The relatives’ current lawyer, Tigran Yegorian, backed Grigorian’s demand 
before it was effectively rejected by Armenia’s highest court. Yegorian said 
failure to accept it would mean that Constitutional Court rulings on the case 
are illegitimate and can be ignored by other courts and law-enforcement bodies.
Vartazarian declined to say whether he agrees with Yegorian’s claims. He 
suggested only that a district court judge who will resume Kocharian’s trial on 
September 12 might “take Tigran Yegorian’s opinion into account.”
“I have neither the right nor the desire to say what [judge] Anna Danibekian 
should do,” added the head of the judicial watchdog.
Vartazarian also said that both the Armenian authorities and Kocharian’s allies 
are “making attempts” to put pressure on the courts dealing with the 
high-profile case. He pointed to rival protests staged by the ex-president’s 
backers and detractors outside the Constitutional Court building in Yerevan.
Pashinian Again Meets Top Officials On Amulsar
        • Susan Badalian
Armenia -- Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian discusses with senior government and 
law-enforcement officials the future of the Amulsar mining project, Yerevan, 
September 4, 2019.
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian met with senior government and law-enforcement 
officials on Wednesday for further discussions on the future of a controversial 
gold mining project in Armenia disrupted over a year ago.
The meeting focused on the Armenian government’s response to the results of an 
environmental audit of the project conducted by a Lebanese company, ELARD.
During a video conference with Armenian officials moderated by Pashinian last 
week ELARD experts said they cannot definitively evaluate environmental dangers 
of the project launched by the British-American company Lydian International. 
They claimed that Lydian had submitted flawed and incomplete information to 
regulatory authorities about its plans to mine gold at the Amulsar deposit 160 
kilometers southeast of Yerevan.
ELARD sent a written report to Armenia’s Investigative Committee earlier in 
August. According to the law-enforcement body, the report concluded that 
Lydian’s operations would pose only “manageable” risks to the environment.
Pashinian said at the end of the video conference that the government will now 
wait and see whether the Armenian Ministry of Environment decides to order 
Lydian to draw up another environmental impact assessment and submit it to a 
relevant ministry division for approval. Environment Minister Erik Grigorian 
said the decision will be announced by September 4.
Grigorian spoke at Wednesday’s meeting chaired by Pashinian and attended by 
other cabinet members as well as the heads of the Investigative Committee and 
three other law-enforcement agencies and Central Bank Governor Artur Javadian.
A government statement on the meeting did not say whether Grigorian believes 
that Lydian should go through another licensing process that would probably 
take several months. It only cited him as saying that Lydian had presented 
inaccurate “starting data” before being granted its mining license in April 
2016.
“There is no final decision yet [on the new impact assessment,]” Pashinian’s 
spokesman, Vladimir Karapetian, told RFE/RL’s Armenian service. “The 
environment minister presented the existing situation, and I think that the 
decision will be made by the cabinet.”
Karapetian said the situation will become clearer in the coming weeks.
According to the statement, Pashinian and the officials discussed “procedures” 
for the possible conduct of a new environmental impact assessment, “legal 
aspects of the issue” and “the emergence of new ecological factors.” Pashinian 
then told the relevant state bodies to “work in a coordinated manner for having 
a comprehensive analysis and complete data for the investigation,” the 
statement added without elaborating.
Lydian rejected ELARD’s verbal comments on Amulsar and accused the Beirut-based 
consultancy of misleading the Armenian government on August 30. It again argued 
that its environmental impact assessments had been certified by more 
authoritative Western experts.
All roads leading to Amulsar have been blocked by several dozen protesters 
since June 2018. They want the government to pull the plug on the project, 
saying that it would contaminate water, air and soil in the area.
Lydian, which claims to have invested $400 million in Amulsar, maintains that 
it would use modern technology that would prevent damage to the ecosystem. The 
company has repeatedly demanded that the authorities put an end to what it sees 
as an illegal blockade. In March, it threatened international legal action 
against Armenia.
Constitutional Court Partly Accepts Kocharian’s Appeal
        • Naira Bulghadarian
        • Ruzanna Stepanian
Armenia -- Constitutional Court Chairman Hrayr Tovmasian (C) reads out a ruling 
on an appeal lodged by former President Robert Kocharian, Yerevan, September 4, 
2019.
Armenia’s Constitutional Court on Wednesday declared unconstitutional a legal 
provision that has been used by law-enforcement authorities for arresting and 
prosecuting former President Robert Kocharian.
Kocharian’s lawyers had challenged the legality of two articles of the Armenian 
Code of Procedural Justice invoked by investigators accusing him of taking 
bribes and overthrowing the constitutional order shortly before the end of his 
decade-long rule in 2008.
The court ruled that one of those articles is unconstitutional because it does 
not take account of current and former senior Armenian officials’ immunity from 
prosecution guaranteed by the Armenian constitution. But it dismissed the 
defense lawyers’ objections to the other clause that spells out legal grounds 
for arresting criminal suspects.
The ruling was signed by six of the nine Constitutional Court judges, including 
the court chairman, Hrayr Tovmasian. Two other judges wrote dissenting opinions 
that were not immediately made public.
The ninth judge, Vahe Grigorian, was excluded from the consideration of 
Kocharian’s appeal because of having previously represented relatives of the 
eight protesters killed in the March 2008 post-election unrest in Yerevan. 
Kocharian and three retired Armenian generals stand accused of illegally using 
the armed forces against opposition supporters who demanded the rerun of a 
disputed presidential election. They all deny the accusation.
Speaking to reporters, one of Kocharian’s lawyers, Aram Vartevanian, seemed 
satisfied with the Constitutional Court verdict read out by Tovmasian. 
Vartevanian said the ruling means that Kocharian’s arrest constituted a 
“violation of his constitutional rights” and that the ex-president should 
therefore be released from jail.
Asked whether he believes his client must also be cleared of the coup charges, 
Vartevanian said: “We will be able to answer this question only after 
familiarizing ourselves with the full text of the court’s decision.”
Armenia -- Former President Robert Kocharian talks to reporters outside a 
prison in Yerevan, June 25, 2019.
Armenian prosecutors and the Special Investigative Service (SIS), which 
indicted Kocharian in July 2018, did not immediately react to the court ruling.
The ruling’s significance was downplayed by Alen Simonian, a deputy parliament 
speaker and close associate of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian. He insisted that 
the high court’s decision to uphold the other Code of Procedural Justice 
article means that the ex-president’s release is “out of question.”
“Nevertheless, we have to wait for the publication of the full text,” Simonian 
added in comments to RFE/RL’s Armenians service. “At this point any further 
comment on the decision published today would be wrong in the legal and all 
other senses.”
Simonian also took a swipe at Tovmasian, saying he and most ordinary Armenians 
“have no confidence” in the court chairman installed by the country’s former 
leadership. He claimed that Tovmasian had personally benefited from the March 
2008 bloodshed and cannot make impartial decisions on the Kocharian case.
In July, Pashinian accused Tovmasian of cutting political deals with 
Kocharian’s successor, Serzh Sarkisian, to “privatize” Armenia’s highest court. 
Tovmasian responded by warning the government against attempting to force him 
and his colleagues to resign.
Kocharian was set free five days after the start of his trial in May. A 
district court judge presiding over it, Davit Grigorian, further angered 
government supporters with his decision to suspend the trial and ask the 
Constitutional Court to rule on the legality of the charges brought against the 
ex-president.
Kocharian was arrested again after Armenia’s Court of Appeals overturned 
Grigorian’s decisions in late June. Law-enforcement authorities charged 
Grigorian with forgery in the following weeks. The judge was suspended as a 
result.
The case was then assigned to another judge, Anna Danibekian. She is due to 
resume Kocharian’s trial on September 12.
Press Review
“Zhoghovurd” says that former President Robert Kocharian’s conviction and 
imprisonment is inevitable because “anyone who committed crimes must be held 
accountable sooner or later regardless of their status and chronology.” “This 
fact has been established as a reality during Nikol Pashinian’s rule,” writes 
the pro-government paper. It goes on to lambaste Pashinian’s Health Minister 
Arsen Torosian for refusing to “face up to the reality” and “fleeing” from a 
news conference held by him on Tuesday.
“Zhamanak” says that Kocharian’s continued arrest depends on the Constitutional 
Court’s upcoming ruling on one of his appeals. “If the Constitutional Court 
decides that there is a problem [with his arrest and prosecution] it will 
effectively mean that Robert Kocharian has to be freed before his trial resumes 
on September 12,” writes the paper. “That would in turn mean a new political 
situation which could somewhat lose the current authorities the confidence of 
radically-minded strata of the society. Against that background, Armenia is due 
to host a Eurasian Economic Union (EEU) summit which will be attended by 
Russian President Vladimir Putin.” The paper points to rumors about Putin’s 
possible boycott of the summit in case Kocharian is not released from custody.
“Aravot” comments on angry verbal exchanges between Kocharian’s supporters and 
detractors. “The problem is not so much Kocharian’s being or not being in jail 
as the fact that just like many other phenomena this case has become an 
occasion to split the society,” editorializes the paper. “Just like Amulsar, 
just like the Istanbul Convention, just like any major political development. 
Generally speaking, those who have made Levon Ter-Petrosian, Robert Kocharian, 
Serzh Sarkisian and Nikol Pashinian subjects of hatred are most active in the 
social life these days. The voices of other people are not heard, while the 
haters demonstrate remarkable unity. Unity should be displayed on other issues 
relating to national interests. In the United States, for example, [President 
Donald] Trump’s supporters and opponents are united on some key issues.”
(Lilit Harutiunian)
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2019 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org

Sports: Armenia women’s team trains ahead of World Weightlifting C’ship

MediaMax, Armenia
Sept 4 2019
Armenia women’s team trains ahead of World Weightlifting C’ship

Weightlifting | 2019-08-29 13:25:13
The athletes are training in the Olympic center Olympavan, under the guidance of Artashes Nersisyan.

Izabella Yaylyan (59kg weight class) and Tatev Hakobyan will represent the country in the tournament scheduled for September 18-27 in Pattaya, Thailand.

Back in April, the two weightlifters competed in the European Championship in Batumi, Georgia. Yaylyan finished 5th with total result of 207kg and won a silver medal in snatch. Hakobyan came 4th with 230kg and took a bronze medal for snatch.

Mediamax Sport covered the competition in Batumi and returned with a photo report.

https://sport.mediamax.am/en/news/weightlifting/34723