My Karabakh – Part VI: Baku and Heydar Aliyev’s hands

JAM News

An Armenian journalist and writer recounts his experience surrounding the events of Nagorno-Karabakh, exclusively for JAMnews

This is the sixth installment in a series of essays written exclusively for JAMnews by Armenian journalist and writer Mark Grigoryan.

The first five installments are as follows:

My Karabakh – Part I: Hadrut, a donkey, water and a brawl

My Karabakh – Part II: 1988 – The Karabakh protests begin

My Karabakh – Part III: Summer of 1988 – Yerevan demands that Karabakh be returned

My Karabakh – Part IV: The Sumgait Chronicles

My Karabakh – Part V: War

“I can’t come in for the next procedure,” I told the dentist, “I’m leaving tomorrow.”

“Where to?” he asked.

“Baku,” I said smiling.

“How come?!” she asked with more than a hint of surprise on her face. “Isn’t it dangerous?”

We were assured our safety by the presidential administration. It was the end of June 1999, and this was the first post-war trip made by a group of Armenian journalists to Azerbaijan.

We flew to Baku on a small UN plane. Having left our stuff in the hotel, we set out for the presidential administration office where we were met by Vafa Guluzade, an advisor to then-president Heydar Aliyev. Rather agitated, Guluzade said that Armenia was nothing but a vassal of Russia, and that Russia does all it can to help Armenians.
And to support his assertion, he shook an edition of the Moscow Nezavisimaya Gazeta from the day before, on which a portrait of my friend Aleksandr Iskandaryan was clearly seen.

In the centre: Vafa Guluzade after meeting with Armenian and Azerbaijani journalists. In the background, TV journalist Artur Grigorian. On Guluzade’s left – Mark Grigorian, on the right – journalist Aleksey Manvelyan. Photo: Mark Grigorian.

Heydar Aliyev met us a day after in a brightly-lit hall. We sat at a long table, a pear-shaped glass of tea placed neatly in front of us all. Aliyev himself sat at the head of the table.

I was surprised at how thin he looked. It looked as if he had put on a suit that was tailored for a larger man – on him it looked as if it was hanging off a coat rack. Apparently he had lost a lot of weight after his heart operation which he had recently undergone in Cleveland.

His face, too, was surprising, immobile, with frozen muscles similar to that of a waxy mask. And the impression wasn’t different when he laughed either.

The conversation was, of course, about the conflict and Aliyev spent most of the time speaking about himself.

“There is no such thing as an eternal conflict, as there is no such thing as an eternal enemy,” he said, leaning back in his chair. “Sooner or later, the Karabakh conflict will be resolved.”

The TV cameras that were placed far away at the end of the hall studied him carefully. When Aliyev was brought a cup of tea, he leaned forward and glanced at his hands that he had folded on the table. I watched his gaze. The hands of the president were trembling.

Aliyev looked at his hands and I saw hatred in his gaze. It appeared as if he was trying through sheer will, through the energy of his gaze, to stop these tremors, but his hands did not obey him. There was something surreal about this: Heydar Aliyev was obeyed by all in Azerbaijan, except for his own hands, which continued to shake. His physiology and nature were above his own will. And that drove him crazy.

He looked at the cup of tea in front of him. One could see that Aliyev indeed wanted tea, but that he wouldn’t at any cost take the cup of tea in his hands and show any kind of weakness by spilling a drop or two or more.

He didn’t take a single sip.

Heydar Aliyev, June 1999. Photo: Mark Grigorian

The day before the meeting with Aliyev, I met with Eldar Zeynalov – a well known Azerbaijani human rights advocate. I asked him about Armenians that were still living in Baku, and he immediately reacted:  “One of them is in my office at the moment.”


And that’s how I met a young woman by the name of Angela. One could call her a modern Juliette who fell in love with an Azerbaijani Romeo. But their problem was that they couldn’t get married because of her full name: Angela Misakovna Ohanova. That was a distinctly Armenian name, which for many in post-war Baku sounded like the name of an enemy, the kind which workers at the marriage registration office would look at, throw her passport back in her face and say: “Go back to your Armenia and get married there. You’ve nothing to do here!”

I really wanted to help Angela and her beau – a quiet and pleasant guy. But how? I decided to speak to Heydar Aliyev. Understandably, this had to be done with as much tact as possible. And so, during the tea-drinking session, I asked: “How do Armenians get along in Azerbaijan?”

This was a move that allowed Aliyev to show himself in all his glory. He spoke at length about how Armenians, like other ethnic minorities, had the same rights as the majority population. And then I told him about Angela.

“Who is she?” he asked. “Why don’t I know about her?”

The thing was, as everybody said, Aliyev had a phenomenal memory. He could see and meet a person once and remember them 10 years later – their name and their profession and so on.

“Allow me,” Vafa Guluzade chimed in with zeal. “I’ll deal with it.”

Aliyev gave his permission. Two weeks later, I received an e-mail with some wedding photographs from the couple. And on that day, I called Guluzade from my office in Yerevan and thanked him.
When I was preparing this part of the article for publication, I was told that Angela had died. She had had a weak heart, and she had passed away several years ago.

From left to right: Angela Ohanova with her future husband. Mark Grigorian, Eldar Zeynalov. Photo: Mark Grigorian

In 2001, the French embassy in Azerbaijan invited me to a conference dedicated to the relations of the countries of the South Caucasus and Europe. I agreed. But when I arrived in Baku, something it seemed had gone wrong and I was left without a guard.

The thing was that after the war, when Armenians came to Azerbaijan or vice-versa, state security guards always accompanied them. They carefully watched and made sure that guests were not harmed. They also made sure that guests didn’t feel too free either – that is, so that they didn’t see anything that they shouldn’t.

And so I was deserted by the state security guards. Some administrative failure, and I ended up in Baku alone. Of course, I tried not to go outside on my own, but on the second day of the conference I decided to get some newspapers.

The kiosk was about 100 meters away. I got my newspapers, paid for them, and all of a sudden the vendor came out of the kiosk, closed the door behind him and asked: “Excuse me, when will this conflict finally end? We lived better with the Armenians than with Georgians.” I understood that he had seen a report about the conference on TV.

Avoiding to walk on the streets of Baku on my own, I nevertheless went out of the hotel with my friends and acquaintances.

Things weren’t entirely smooth. When we met with political analyst Arif Yunusov, we were walking around Armenikend – a formerly Armenian-populated part of the city – when someone approached us.

“This here,” Arif said, “is Mark Grigorian. An Armenian.”

The man put out his hand, shook mine, and then sharply pulled away.

“We’ll meet on the battlefield!” he cried.

It turned out that he was one of the deputy chairs of a very anti-Armenian political group headed by Arif Naqi. But, despite this little incident, I had a great time walking around the old city – I went up into Maidan Tower and had coffee on fountain square.

Journalist Shahin Rzayev took me to a souvenir shop. The vendor, a Russian woman about my age, asked me:

“Where are you from?”

“From Yerevan,” I answered.

She was a bit confused. She didn’t quite believe that it was possible to see an Armenian in downtown Baku.

“If you’ve come to us with good intentions, then welcome. But if you’ve come with other ideas… .”

She was still confused. She was even a bit afraid. I understood: after so many articles, TV reports and other stories about how Armenians – ALL Armenians – are terrorists and killers, it’s difficult to see such a terrorist at your front door. It’s impossible to know what to think.

But, as it turned out, I had not come with bad intentions. I bought some matroyshki – nested dolls – which instead of traditional female faces depicted owls.

Soon after this trip, Armenian journalists were prohibited from going to Azerbaijan. Now, only politicians and athletes could go.

Expert: Neither Peskov, nor Azeri president can decide who should represent Armenia in Artsakh talks

Panorama, Armenia

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told Russian media still on Wednesday that no meeting is scheduled to take place between Armenian and Azerbaijani presidents in Moscow.

According to some experts, the Russian official’s statement is a subtle hint to the fact that only Armenian president can engage in the negotiations over the Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) conflict settlement regardless of the fact both Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev are currently on a visit to Moscow to attend the 2018 FIFA World Cup opening.

Speaking to Panorama.am, political technologist Vigen Hakobyan stated Peskov’s hint is not in line with the stance adopted in the Armenian-Russian relations.

“I find it difficult to understand exactly what this means at all, since neither Peskov nor Azerbaijani president can decide who should represent Armenia in the Artsakh talks or in other interstate negotiations,” he stressed.

“At least, Russian President Vladimir Putin seems to have no such questions,” Hakobyan said, citing the recent talks between the Russian leader and Armenian PM in Moscow.

“In this case, I see a huge discrepancy in the actions of Peskov’s boss and his statements. Peskov acts more like a spokesman for the Azerbaijani president in this case. The Azerbaijani president has, perhaps, expressed such an opinion.

“I would understand if Putin himself had voiced his intention of holding talks only with the Armenian president, with Peskov commenting on it. But I see obvious inconsistency when Peskov talks about it, in fact speaking about the meeting of the leaders of two other countries and hinting to the impossibility of holding it since Azerbaijan wants to meet with Armenia’s president rather than its prime minister,” he noted.

The expert observes no hints in the spokesman’s statement. “I believe there is a violation of subordination in this case. I would like to ask Mr. Peskov if this is the case why Putin met with Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and in fact discussed interstate issues apart from the economic ones. There is an issue of subordination here,” he added. 

Sports: Yura Movsisyan undergoes surgery

Public Radio of Armenia
13:15, 14 Jun 2018

Armenia international Yura Movsisyan has undergone a surgery.

“My surgery went really well and the road to recovery starts today. It will be difficult and challenging four months for me but I will strive to be 100% ready to play in less than that,” Movsisyan said in a Facebook post.

The player thanked all supporters for all the well wishes and prayers.

Pashinyan and Putin Meet Ahead of World Cup

Armenia’s Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan (left) met with Russian President Vladimir Putin in the Kremlin on Wednesday

MOSCOW—Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Wednesday arrived in the Russian capital to attend the opening ceremony of the 2018 World Cup, before which he met with Russian President Vladimir Putin, his second meeting with the Russian leader since taking office on May 8.

The focus of the meeting was strengthening relations between Armenia and Russia, both viewing the other as a strategic partner. Pashinyan said the fact that this was his second meeting with Putin in one month, attests to the important place Russia occupies for the Armenian government.

He assured Putin that some of the agreements that were reached during their meeting on May 14 are already being implemented in Armenia and expressed hope for continued opportunities to discuss matters of mutual importance—economy, politics, regional stability—in person.

“Everybody knows that the scope of our relations [with Russia] is rather broad and there is much to be discussed in terms of the economy, politics and the region. Of course, we hope for a positive and constructive dialogue and we have made sure that it is such on our end,” said Pashinyan.

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his wife, Anna, were greeted by Zabivaka, the official mascot of the 2018 World Cup games

Putin emphasized the critical role Russia plays as Armenia’s leading trade partner.

“Given the strategic nature of our relations and the great scope of cooperation in different areas, I think meetings between the two nations are warranted. The first thing I would like to note is that Russia continues to confidently preserve its leading position in terms of trade with Armenia. Last year trade turnover between our countries increased by over 30 percent, and the growth continues this year as well,” said Putin.

He emphasized that the trade centers on Armenian agricultural exports to Russia, adding that Armenia’s membership in the Eurasian Economic Union has played a positive role in advancing relations between the two countries.

Pashinyan, who arrived in Moscow with his wife, Anna Hakopyan were greeted upon deplaning by Zabivaka (literally meaning goal-scorer), the official mascot of the 2018 FIFA World Cup
Zabivaka and Pashinyan kicked around a soccer ball and posed for photographs. Pashinyan and his delegation will attend the opening ceremony of the World Cup and view the first match at the Luzhniki stadium in Moscow.

168: President Sarkissian pays first visit to Artsakh

Categories
Artsakh
Official
Politics
Region

President of Armenia Armen Sarkissian has departed to Artsakh in the morning of June 13 at the invitation of President Bako Sahakyan, the president’s office reported.

This is the first visit of Armen Sarkissian to Artsakh in the capacity of president.

168: National Security Service agents “carry out actions” in Yerevan City Hall

Category
Society

The national security service is carrying out actions in the Yerevan City Hall, head of the service’s press center Samson Galstyan told ARMENPRESS.

“At this moment I can only confirm that indeed actions are underway in the Yerevan City Hall. However, I urge to wait for the official statement for additional information,” he said.

According to various media reports, the operation concerns the activity of the Yerevan Foundation.

168: Glendale CA renames stretch of Maryland Ave. to Artsakh Ave. in homage

Category
World

The Glendale (CA) City Council has renamed a stretch of the city’s Maryland Avenue to Artsakh Avenue, a move honoring the Republic of Artsakh, ANCA said.

Earlier in March, the city council of the City of Glendale unanimously voted to initiate the process of renaming Maryland Avenue between Wilson and Harvard Street in honor of the Republic of Artsakh. The city council made the decision one day after Artsakh President Bako Sahakyan’s visit to the United States.

NSS probes bribery-related report involving Yerevan City Hall officials, agents raid offices

Category
Society

The National Security Service says two citizens have reported that officials of the Yerevan City Hall have demanded transferring certain amounts of money to the account of Yerevan Foundation for being granted construction permit, in addition to the legally required payments.

The NSS says the initial investigation revealed that come of the illegally demanded money was in turn embezzled.

A criminal case has been initiated on misconduct.

The national security service said it raided the offices of the Yerevan Foundation. The offices are located inside the building of the Yerevan City Hall.

Lawmakers reject Elizaveta Danielyan’s candidacy for Constitutional Court judge

Category
Society

Elizaveta Danielyan, the sole nominee for the position of judge at the Constitutional Court, has been rejected by lawmakers during today’s confirmation vote.

Chairman of the counting committee of the parliament Gagik Melikyan presented the results of the vote.

He said 54 lawmakers took part in the voting, with one ballot being invalid.

36 MPs voted in favor of Danielyan’s candidacy, while 17 voted against.

She needed at least 63 votes to be confirmed.

Earlier, Yelk and Tsarukyan factions dropped out of the voting, announcing they would not participate.

Azerbaijan doesn’t pull back heavy military build-up since April

Categories
Artsakh
Region

Azerbaijan is still not pulling back its military build-up along the line of contact with Artsakh, presidential spokesperson of Artsakh David Babayan told ARMENPRESS.

Azerbaijan began mobilizing troops and military equipment along the line of contact since April.

“[Azerbaijan] has brought a large military presence to territories very close to the line of contact since April, however the permanent deployment site of these units isn’t there. These units still haven’t been pulled back. Certain movements are seen regularly, as well as exhibition drills. I.e. they want to terrorize us in all ways, however still in an exhibition way. We absolutely don’t give in to their terror and the Defense Army of Artsakh is carrying out all actions in order for [Azerbaijan] not to give in to temptation. We must treat this ni a balanced and serious way and not think that this is simply an information made because of the domestic situation. Our domestic situation is very calm, although a few provocations happened lately”, he said, referring to the recent protests in Stepanakert.

“We must always be ready because Azerbaijan is a country which is terroristic in essence and everything is expected from it,” he added.

He said Azeris are likely to take advantage of the FIFA World Cup in terms of attention and escalate the situation.