Massis Weekly Online – Volume 27, NO. 8 (1308)

Massis Weekly Online

VOLUME 27, NO. 8 (1308)
SATURDAY, MARCH 17, 2007
——————-
– Israel Parliament Rejects Armenian Genocide Bill
– Memorial in Glendale Honors Dink, Captivates Audience
– Lower Learning: Students Say Bribery in Universities is ?Normal?
– Armenian Community Meets With Leader of Liberal Party Of Canada
– Elizabeth Manasserian Conveys Goals As Candidate For GUSD Board
——————–

– Israel Parliament Rejects Armenian Genocide Bill

JERUSALEM — Israel?s parliament on Wednesday rejected a motion
recognizing the Turkish mass killings of Armenians dating back to 1915
as a genocide.
?Stop ignoring and rejecting the catastrophe of another people,? MP
Haim Oron, who submitted the motion, told the plenum before the vote.
?We refuse to accept the turning of a blind eye to the Armenian
genocide,? the opposition left-wing Meretz party MP said. ?We owe this
vote not only to the Armenian people, we owe it to ourselves,
especially in a period where we are struggling to prolong the memory?
of the Nazi Holocaust of six million Jews during World War II.
The motion was nevertheless rejected by parliament in a vote of 16
against 12, with a low turnout by MPs. It would have needed a second
ratification if it had passed.
The issue of the Armenian massacre has been raised several times in
the past in Israel?s Knesset, but there has never been an implicit
vote branding it as genocide. If approved, Israel would have joined a
growing list of countries which have recognized the killings as
genocide. It would have marked April 24, the day when the massacres
started in 1915, as Armenian genocide memorial day.
Israel has close diplomatic ties with Turkey ? one of the few Muslim
countries with which it has relations ? and has in the past steered
clear of the recognition issue.
Oron told AFP he had been under heavy pressure from Israeli Prime
Minister Ehud Olmert?s office and the foreign ministry to withdraw his
motion. ?I have been under a lot of pressure, but that is something
any MP must face,? Oron said. ?Turkey has been exerting its pressure
everywhere. This is their right. But they can not set the agenda of
the Israeli parliament.? Government spokeswoman Miri Eisin said that
Israel ?did not intend to place itself at the forefront of this issue,
which is being handled by the international community.?

– Memorial in Glendale Honors Dink, Captivates Audience

GLENDALE, CA – A memorial honoring the legacy of assassinated
journalist Hrant Dink along with the participation of a multitude of
Armenian organizations, drew hundreds to the Glendale Civic Auditorium
on March 11 featuring various speakers, video presentations and
cultural performances.
Master of Ceremonies, Armen Hovannisian, Vice Chairman of the Armenian
Bar Association, introduced Dink as a pioneer who was ahead of his
time and a martyr for free speech fighting for the rights of Armenians
and other minorities in Turkey despite criticism from his colleagues
and those who opposed his ideas. Video clips of Dink were shown to the
audience as his life, beliefs and his hope for the future of democracy
in Turkey were expressed in his own words.
A somber musical performance of ?Groonk,? which happened to be a
favorite of Dink, played by the Wings of Passion duduk ensemble set
the tone for the evening which included many tears and sighs from the
audience made up by members of clergy, public officials, community
leaders, professors, Armenian American activists and supporters of the
Armenian Cause. The Zvartnots group performed a dance adorning gowns
resembling Khatch Kars.
Edvin Minassian of the Organization of Istanbul Armenians presented
the more personal, human side of Dink and his brief encounter with the
free speech advocate during his last visit to the U.S. in late October
to early November of last year. He read a famous quote deeply
inspirational to Dink which states, ?I?d rather die standing on my
feet than live on my knees.? The profound statement laid an imprint on
Dink as he carried out his day to day actions bearing this quote in
mind which he first learned of during his recent U.S. visit.
Also during his brief visit, Dink was interviewed on the Pari Louys TV
program hosted by Stepan Partamian where he discussed issues dealing
with his personal life to his thoughts on how recognition of the
Genocide should be dealt with from the bottom up as opposed to the top
down methodology.
His grassroots approach in educating Turks versus State recognition
and the implementation of Genocide resolutions were what set Dink
apart from other advocates of the Armenian Cause. His controversial
approach to the sensitive issue often ostracized him from his
colleagues. Only after his untimely death were his ideas viewed in a
different light.
A photo featuring Dink holding a Freedom of Speech Award given to him
by the Armenian Bar Association was displayed as Frank Zerunyan,
Chairman of the ABA and Council Member of the Rolling Hills Estates
talked about how Dink was so incredibly proud to receive that award;
it was the first honor received from an American-Armenian organization.
He stated that the significance of the award was monumental to Dink
because it symbolized his perseverance and served as a reminder to him
that those who falsely accused him of being anti-Turk had a lot to
learn about democracy and the open dialogue and exchange of ideas no
matter how divergent the ideas or the people voicing them may be.
An emotional Simon Acilacoglu, Chairman of the Organization of
Istanbul Armenians shared his personal experience at Dink?s funeral as
video clips from CNN Turk were being shown to the audience. ?I saw his
lifeless body as his face was cleansed with holy water at the church
where his family watched in grief,? said Acilacoglu. ?There was a dove
sitting on his casket during the entire procession. It refused to fly
away and was consequently removed by someone so that mourners could
resume placing soil on the casket,? he added. It was mentioned that
Dink often compared himself to a dove during the last few turbulent
years of his life where he was under constant attack for his ideals.
The evening ended with a moving speech made by Consul General of
Armenia, Armen Liloyan, who reminded the audience that The Republic of
Armenia has and always will welcome dialogue with its neighbor Turkey
despite the hesitation displayed by the Turkish government. He
believes dialogue is key in settling the Armenian Question but
remained skeptical of Turkey?s willingness to cooperate with Armenia.
?How can Turkey punish the killer of Hrant Dink when they have yet to
recognize the Genocide of 1.5 million Armenians?? he stated.
A special note of gratitude is extended to the following organizations
for their active participation and involvement in making the event
possible: The Organization of Istanbul Armenians, Armenian Bar
Association, Armenian Assembly of America, Nor Serount Cultural
Association and the Armenian Council of America.

– Lower Learning: Students Say Bribery in Universities is ?Normal?

By Gayane Abrahamyan
ArmeniaNow reporter

Is there corruption in Armenia?s institutes of higher learning? Ninety
percent of university students seem to think there is.
The Sargis Tkhruni youth union of the Social-Democratic Hunchakian
Party has made an attempt to define the drastic picture of corruption
in universities and has surveyed 2,000 students. 1,821 of those
surveyed said corruption in universities is wide spread, and that the
lower the dollar exchange, the higher the cost of bribing professors
and examination board panels.
The survey was conducted among 2,000 students at all state-run higher
schools of Yerevan, which makes five percent of all students at
state-run higher schools. A questionnaire including 11 questions was
used as the method for gathering information.
Only students at the Department of Law and Culture of the Yerevan
State University refused to fill in the questionnaire. The
Agricultural Academy scored 96 percent on the corruption index, with
83 percent of interviewees saying they have personally given bribes
for grades. Students there report that success on a ?pass-fail? exam
can cost up to $20 and a good mark on a graded exam costs from $20-50.
Ninety percent of Academy students surveyed said bribing is ?normal?.
According to the survey, medical school is the second most corrupt,
with 89 percent, where 74 percent say they?ve personally paid bribes.
At Mkhitar Heratsi Medical University, students say they have paid up
to $1,000 for good marks. ?They don?t take money from those who learn,
but take from those who don?t. That is, those who have entered the
university with a bribe, graduate it with a bribe. I know a student in
my group who paid $900 or $1,000 for the last re-take exam not to be
expelled,? says Naira, a fourth year student, who asked not to mention
her last name.
Next in the level of corruption is the State Engineering University,
where 85.5 percent of the interviewed acknowledge corruption. ?The
most awful thing is that the bribe giving and taking is a normal thing
for 80-90 percent of the surveyed. But the lack of understanding in
the villainy of the phenomenon makes the fight against it almost
impossible,? says the head of the research group Anahit Sargsyan.
She says the students seem to have adjusted to the situation and are
skeptical whether the university officials would do anything to
correct the problem. In fact, students are concerned that if they
raise the issue they, themselves, might be expelled.
According to the survey the lowest level of corruption is recorded at
the arts universities ? with 18, 14 and 13.5 percents at the Academy
of Fine Arts, the Conservatoire and the State Institute last 20 days,?
says the head of the Sargis Tkhruni youth union Narek Galstyan.
Upon initiation of the survey, the youth union invited student
councils of the institutions for cooperation, which the greater part
of them denied. The chairpersons of the economic and medical
universities strictly prohibited any kind of interviews in their
institutions.
?We were directly told we were prohibited [from interviewing] and that
was it. But of course we managed to interview 250 students of the
medical university just at the entrance and found out that the student
councils had many things to hide,? says Sargsyan. The last letter the
youth union has received was written by the rector of the Medical
University Gohar Kyalyan, where she strongly condemned and questioned
the impartiality of the sociological survey.
?The letter says there is no corruption at the medical university. But
everyone knows there is. The problem should be accepted and should be
fought against. There is a need to stop the policy of making the
institutions of higher education places of worship and many things
will change,? says Galstyan.
All ArmeniaNow attempts to talk to the rector of the Medical
University throughout the week failed.
?I have always welcomed the activity of youth organizations, this
survey is especially welcome, as at last students have risen to their
feet to raise their voice and defend their rights,? says Minister of
Education and Science Levon Lazarian.
At Yerevan State University, corruption ? as defined by the survey ?
is 42 percent. Rector Aram Simonyan says the figure is troubling. ?I
do not deny there is corruption in our higher education institutions
including our university. Moreover, at the moment we have students
complaining of corruption on the side of some lecturers.
We fight it, but it?s unrealistic to eradicate it in one day,? says
Simonyan. Asked for a solution to bribery in education, 93 percent of
interviewees say increasing teacher salaries is the answer, while 87
percent say inner discipline should be stricter.

– Armenian Community Meets With Leader of Liberal Party Of Canada

The Congress of Canadian Armenians held a reception in Montreal on
March 6, 2007 to honour Stephane Dion, the new Leader of the Liberal
Party of Canada. The event was a resounding success, with over 100
invited people present including many of the leaders and prominent
members of our community.
Mr. Dion, who has been a firm advocate for the recognition of the
Armenian Genocide and a friend and consistent supporter of the
Armenian community and of Armenian causes, was presented with a plaque
naming him an ?honourary Armenian?. At the end of his speech, he
expressed his appreciation for the warm welcome that he received, and
he read a brief statement of friendship in Armenian. He also had an
opportunity to circulate, talking to people about their concerns and
answering their questions.
In his comments, Mr. Dion said he is in favour of opening a Canadian
Embassy in Armenia, and he would like very much to see Armenian
candidates getting elected to the House of Commons. This event was
part of a series organized by the Congress of Canadian Armenians, to
meet with the leaders and key members of the major political parties
of Canada.
The Congress of Canadian Armenians is comprised of the following
participating organizations (in alphabetical order): AGBU Alex
Manoogian School, AGBU Montreal Chapter, Armenian Democratic Liberal
Party, Holy Cross Church of Laval, St. Gregory the Illuminator Church
of Montreal, S.D. Hunchakian Party, Society of Armenians from
Istanbul, Tekeyan Cultural Association

– Elizabeth Manasserian Conveys Goals As Candidate For GUSD Board

By Christine Aghakhanian

She has been a loud voice in the Glendale community for many years and
now Elizabeth Manasserian, after participating and taking leadership
roles in numerous civic, academic and professional organizations, is
running for the elected position of Glendale Unified School District
Board Member.
Her heavy involvement in the academic sphere of the City and her
innate ability to relate to parent?s concerns is what differentiates
Manasserian from her opponents running for the two-seat position. ?I
have an active relationship with students, teachers and parents of
GUSD,? said Manasserian. ?My sons are currently enrolled in the
Glendale schools. Having said that, I think it is vital for any school
board member to have children, or to have children in the schools that
the candidate is looking to serve as a School Board Member.?
Being the first Armenian PTA (Parents Teachers Association) President
at Wilson Middle School, Manasserian experienced first hand, the
opportunities that exist for Armenian students and the importance for
an Armenian candidate to voice their concerns. She took on the
leadership role of PTA President for selfless reasons. Her main
concern were the students and the parents and having their needs
addressed by the school and the district. Manasserian proved that, by
having a record breaking support from Armenian parents along with
parents of other ethnic groups creating a unity in the school community.
?As I attend varieties of different school functions on various school
campuses, I see the Armenian youth making great and phenomenal and
academic strides,? she stated. ?By supporting good, well rounded
Armenian candidates, Armenians? voices will be heard. Placing me as a
school board member is giving a representation and a voice. Better
yet, I have already been creating a better understanding of who we are
a s Armenians. It is not always about fighting back, rather showing
the good.?
The three main areas of focus in Manasserian?s campaign are safety in
schools, class size reduction and child obesity including the
promotion of proper nutrition and maintaining a healthy lifestyle. She
believes school safety is one of the most paramount challenges facing
the school board today. Her business background, she says, will enable
her to make important budgetary decisions in helping generate funds
that schools are currently lacking, which in turn, will lead to a
lower teacher to student ratio hence creating smaller classrooms. As a
member of the Glendale Healthy Kids, Manasserian is confident that
through teacher and parent education, the growing problem of obesity
among youth can become a thing of the past.
Among other organizations, Manasserian has been active in various
Glendale organizations such as the Rotary Club, Chamber of Commerce,
PTA, Educational Foundations and Board of Realtors to name a few. ?It
is important that the candidates be a part of the greater whole and
our great Glendale community,? she said. ?That is what I became, not
just one thing, But I am a part of the community at large. It made me
well rounded and exposed me to different areas of the city. This
knowledge will create more resources for me to bring to the Board as a
School Board Member.?
It has become her goal and top priority to have Glendale schools lead
the nation in academic excellence. She plans on working to implement
areas of funding, partnerships and mentoring programs to reach this
goal. Creating an enjoyable and enriching environment for teachers
through various educational programs is also on Manasserian?s agenda.
?We need to make our children?s schools competitive with the nation so
our children may compete equally or with an advantage,? she said. ?I
want Glendale to become the model school for this nation.?
Having strong relationships within the community is key to
Manasserian?s success as a community leader. She plans on bringing the
influence she has gained through her involvement with various groups
to the GUSD Board. She believes this is an essential quality for a
candidate to possess in order to be heard and to be an effective
leader capable of creating change. Additionally, she believes, her
background as an engineer will help the school board gain support for
the highest standards of technology in schools and her experience in
the commercial real estate industry will be utilized in areas of
budgeting, and finance. ?I am doing this for no other interest than
what I can offer to our children, with your vote on ballot three I
will do just that.?
For more information about Manasserian?s campaign, visit


Massis Weekly Online
MassisWeekly.com
1060 N. Allen Ave, Suite 203
Pasadena, CA 91104
Tel. 626.797.7680
Fax. 626.797.6863

http://MassisWeekly.com
www.elizabeth2007.com

Ambassador Evans Salutes Armenians at Bay Area ANC Hai Tad Evening

Armenian National Committee of San Francisco-Bay Area
51 Commonwealth Avenue
San Francisco, CA 94118
Phone: 415.387.3433
Fax: 415.751.0617
E-mail: [email protected]
Web:

PRESS RELEASE
March 16, 2007

Contact: Matt Senekerimian
Tel: (415) 387-3433

Ambassador Evans Salutes Armenians at Bay Area ANC Hai Tad Evening

San Francisco, CA – On March 10, 2007, Ambassador John Evans, who
recently left his post as U.S. Ambassador to Armenia, saluted a capacity
crowd of over 400 at the Bay Area ANC’s annual "Hai Tad Evening,"
Saturday night. A 35-year career diplomat serving in Europe and the
Middle East, John Evans was U.S. Ambassador to the Republic of Armenia
from September, 2004 to December, 2006. In February, 2005, Evans told
an audience at UC Berkeley, "I will today call it the Armenian
Genocide…There’s no doubt in my mind what happened. I believe in
calling things by their name." As a result of his public statements,
Ambassador Evans was recalled from his position prior to the conclusion
of his term. He is now retired, and this month began speaking out for
the first time about his experience.

"Those of you who’ve devoted hours of your days, years of your lives,
fighting for recognition for what happened to your forebears – I stand
here tonight in admiration of all of you. I salute you tonight, and I
also thank you for your efforts on my behalf, when it seemed to you as
if I was being done an injustice," stated Amb. Evans. "When I spoke out
at UCLA, Fresno, at Berkeley, about the Armenian Genocide, I knew what I
was doing. This was not a slip of the tongue. No one put me up to it, I
took responsibility for my words, and of course, I did pay a price. But
as a result, I’m free to be here with you tonight," said Evans, who
spoke at the Khatchaturian Armenian Community Center in San Francisco.

Ambassador Evans briefly described some of the circumstances leading to
his statements, and informed the audience that he would give more
details in a forthcoming book. "My efforts – and I did make efforts to
address the question more openly and forthrightly within the State
Department had failed. I could not even get the issue on the agenda,
much less engage in an argument about policy. At a certain point, I
realized that the way things are set up in the State Department, there
would never come the day when the issue would be dealt with honestly.
No one above me would do anything. No one below me could do anything.
There are real US interests in Turkey. They are predominant."

Evans also made clear his support for the official recognition of the
Armenian Genocide by the U.S. Congress, saying, "When an official policy
diverges wildly from what the broad public believes is self-evident,
that policy ceases to command respect." Citing the many eye-witness and
survivor accounts of the Genocide, he said, "The overwhelming consensus
of those sources is clearly, the tragic events of 1915, despite all the
complicating factors of war, rebellion, great power politics –
constituted genocide. The Armenian Genocide should be recognized as
such by this Congress."

Evans also spoke about the current situation in Armenia and the work
there that remains to be done. "I’m proud to have been involved in
implementing the official assistance programs that now include, most
importantly, the Millennium Challenge project," said Evans. Referring
to the upcoming presidential elections in Armenia, Evans expressed his
hopes for free and fair elections. "To the extent that the Republic of
Armenia can become an exemplary democracy in that part of the world, it
will win favor not only in Washington but in other Western capitals.
Now we all know that the challenges are immense. Political culture tends
to persist. This is not going to be easy. But as I’ve said before,
preconditions for a flourishing democracy are there in Armenia, and it’s
going to happen. I’m not sure when, but I certainly hope its sooner
rather than later."

Evans closed his remarks using quotes by Patrick Henry, a prominent
figure in the American Revolution. "At the time, Patrick Henry was
considered a hothead and a rabble-rouser," Evans said. "In another
time, I can imagine Patrick Henry saying instead of, ‘Give me liberty or
give me death,’ ‘Mah Gam Azadoutioun.’ But actually, so far as I know,
Patrick Henry was not a Dashnag," Evans said to laughter and applause.
"But seriously, my friends, Patrick Henry said something else in that
famous speech that is worth recalling: ‘The battle is not to the strong
alone. It is to the vigilant, the active, and the brave.’ So in the
spirit of Patrick Henry, I urge you to stick to your beliefs, and
continue to fight the good fight. In our American democracy, it is your
perfect right to do so."

Roxanne Makasdjian, Chairperson of the Bay Area Armenian National
Committee, opened the evening with a discussion of the events of the
last year, including the assassination of Armenian newspaper editor
Hrant Dink in Turkey, the Evan’s dismissal, the nomination of Richard
Hoagland as ambassador to Armenia, and the Armenian Genocide resolution
before Congress.

"Hrant Dink’s assassination is inextricably linked to Turkish government
policies," said Makasdjian. "We must be on guard against attempts by the
government to use his assassination to further their denial campaign."
Referring to the writers and minority groups in Turkey who are now more
reluctant to speak out, Makasdjian said, "As if those effects aren’t
enough, the Turkish government actually attempts to use Hrant’s
outspokenness as a way to demonstrate how democratic Turkey is becoming.
It makes public overtures to Armenia, not for true reconciliation, but
to communicate to the European Union, the U.S., and other nations that
‘There’s no need to pass resolutions recognizing the Genocide, because
we’re already on the road to reconciliation with the Armenians, and a
resolution would only antagonize the situation.’ "

"The truth is that it is Turkey’s Genocide denial that fueled the fires
that led to Dink’s murder, directly or indirectly, and for which it is
unrepentant," said Makasdjian." It’s the DENIAL that must end, not the
international community’s recognition of the Armenian Genocide. It is
NOT THE TRUTH that must be suppressed and opposed, it is the LIE. It’s
the LIE that poisons the atmosphere in Turkey; It’s the lie that fuels
hatred and mistrust; it’s the lie that complicates Turkey’s relationship
with its neighbors and its allies. It’s the LIE that prevents
reconciliation. And reconciliation can only come through truth and
restitution for Armenians, and hopefully some redemption and
rehabilitation for Turkey."

Steven Dadaian, ANCA Western Region and National Board member,
congratulated the Bay Area ANC for its years of work advocating for the
Armenian Cause. "Let me thank the Bay Area ANC for their unparalleled
commitment and dedication to the struggle of truth to power. They’ve
done that very effectively for over 3 decades now. They’ve proven again
and again that a motivated and educated, relatively small community has
been able to produce results."

Dadaian spoke about the need for citizens to be more active in our
democracy. "The gap between the problems and solutions is the democracy
gap. That gap is the failure of citizens to allocate their time and
their resources to important civic pursuits. Hai Tad is one of those
civic pursuits." Dadaian discussed the efforts ANCA has undertaken to
bring to the attention of the Armenian-American community the true
motivations and voting records of government officials. He pointed out
that civic organizations do not oppose bills about the Armenian Genocide
or aid to Armenia and Karabagh, but individuals and groups representing
corporate interests. "It’s important that you as voters, as citizens,
understand the double-talk that goes on in Washington, DC. Our
organization provides that window."

Elizabeth Chouldjian, ANCA Communication Director in Washington, DC,
introduced John Evans. She spoke about the "firestorm" that was touched
off by his public statements about the Armenian Genocide and his
subsequent removal from office. Chouldjian also spoke out against the
State Department’s nomination of a Genocide denier, Richard Hoagland, to
become US ambassador to Armenia, and their obstinacy in re-nominating
Hoagland a second time.

Hrant Dink’s assassination also revealed the U.S. government’s
"shamelessness," said Chouldjian, describing how State Department
officials mourned Dink’s loss and praised his courage and decency, but
are fighting hard against a resolution commemorating Dink and calling
for a repeal of the laws under which Dink was prosecuted.

"As I look at the current situation in the State Department," said
Chouldjian, "I am reminded of a quote by the first U.S. Secretary of
State Thomas Jefferson. Jefferson said, ‘In matters of style, swim with
the current. In matters of principle stand like a rock.’ Is this the
State Department of Jefferson? Is this the legacy of Henry Morgenthau?
Are these the fundamental truths, the moral values that this great
nation is built upon?" asked Chouldjian. "Our message to the State
Department is clear — come clean on the firing of Ambassador Evans,
withdraw the Hoagland nomination, and end the shameless pandering to the
Turkish Government. And if the State Department doesn’t have the guts to
stand by one of its own, to honor the man, who tried to bring dignity
and morality to American foreign policy, then the ANC and Armenian
American community will."

###

Photo Caption: Ambassador John Evans addresses the attendees of the ANC
San Francisco-Bay Area Hai Tahd Evening (Raffi Momjian)

www.anca.org

Hilda Tchoboyan: The Bill Criminalizing Armenian Genocide Denial Wil

HILDA TCHOBOYAN: THE BILL CRIMINALIZING ARMENIAN GENOCIDE DENIAL WILL BE PROBABLY PUT ON SENATE AGENDA IN AUTUMN

ArmRadio.am
13.03.2007 17:34

Most probably, the bill criminalizing the negation of the Armenian
Genocide adopted by the French National Assembly will put on the
Senate agenda in October after the parliamentary and presidential
elections in the country. During today’s press conference Charwoman
of the European Armenian Federation Hilda Tchoboyan said it hardly
possible for the resolution to be put on Senate agenda immediately
after the parliamentary elections. "Most probably, it will be included
in the autumn agenda. We shall do everything possible to have the
bill be included in the Senate agenda," she assured, not excluding
that there will be strong resistance.

According to Hilda Tchoboyan, after the adoption in the French National
assembly the bill criminalizing the Armenian Genocide met strong
resistance in France, especially on the part of historian. "They were
protesting that politics should not be mixed with the historic reality,
which left its trace in the formation of public opinion. Definitely,
Turkish lobbyist organizations and interested forces stand behind
the creation of such atmosphere," said Hilda, adding that a new wave
has escalated, which counters the first one. "Some intellectuals
stand behind this new wave, according to which the genocide is not
a historic reality: it is a heavy and irreversible all-human crime."

The Chairwoman of the European Armenian Federation noted also that the
three strong presidential candidates of France do not deny the fact
of the Armenian Genocide. According to her, no one in France denies
that there was genocide and everyone agrees that France must adopt a
law on the Armenian Genocide, but the question today is the issue of
punishment. "Although the Socialist candidate has not addressed the
law personally, it can be supposed that he will not stand against the
bill authored by his party. Nevertheless, positions differ before and
after elections, therefore, we cannot assert anything definitely. UMP
candidate Nicola Sarkozy personally opposes Turkey’s accession to the
European Union, and in general his stance is beneficial for us. Nicola
Sarkozy has not directly expressed his position on the criminalizing
the Armenian Genocide denial, but he says genocide denial should
be punishable. President of the center-right party minds Turkey’s
accession to the EU, but opposes also the ratification of the law,"
Hilda Tchoboyan mentioned.

In her words, in general, the Armenian community stands against
Turkey’s accession to the European Union. Therefore, it will support
the candidate whose opposition to this accession turns out to be
the strongest.

Media Observation Body Created On Initiative Of Yerevan Press Club

MEDIA OBSERVATION BODY CREATED ON INITIATIVE OF YEREVAN PRESS CLUB

Noyan Tapan
Mar 13 2007

YEREVAN, MARCH 13, NOYAN TAPAN. On the initiative of Yerevan Press
Club, Rules of journalists’ Conduct were adopted and Observation
Body was elected at the March 10 meeting of heads of a number of
media and journalist organizations. As Chairman of Yerevan Press
Club Boris Navasardian reported at the March 13 press conference,
the mission of Observation Body is to discuss application-complaints
relating to violations of Rules of Conduct and to draw the respective
conclusions. He expressed satisfaction that 21 Armenian media, 8
journalist organizations and a group of individual journalists have
joined this initiative. Among these media and journalist organizations
are Union of Journalists of Armenia, A1+, Azg, Aravot dailies,
Arminfo news agency. B. Navasardian said that the Rules of Conduct
have an appendix, Declaration on Principles of Covering Elections and
Referendums. In the words of Astghik Gevorgian, Chairwoman of Union
of Journalists of Armenia, the process of self-regulation and control
will contribute to preservation of journalists’ civilized conduct and
moral characteristic. And in the words of Lilit Simonian, Chairwoman
of Center for Law and Information NGO, the more self-regulated
the journalist field is, the more independent media and individual
journalists are.

Armenian FM Expresses His Anxiety On U.S. State Department Report On

ARMENIAN FM EXPRESSES HIS ANXIETY ON U.S. STATE DEPARTMENT REPORT ON HUMAN RIGHTS

Arka News Agency, Armenia
March 13 2007

YEREVAN, March 12. /ARKA – Novosti-Armenia/. Armenian Foreign Minister
Vardan Oskanian expressed his anxiety to the US Charge d’Affaire
Anthony Godfrey concerning a number of provisions on the U.S. State
Department’s report on human rights, said Godfrey last Friday.

He said that he will inform Washington about Oskanian’s positions.

The USA goes on providing protection of human rights in Armenia and
supporting the OSCE Minsk group in the settlement of the Karabakh
issue, said Godfrey.

During the Friday conference Oskanian said "that there is a kind of
subjectivism in the State Department’s report to which we intend to
react." He said that there are some shortages towards Armenia which
should be treated seriously and removed in the future.

According to the U.S. State Department’s annual report, certain
progress in human rights issues was recorded in Armenia in 2006. In
particular, Armenian citizens obtained the right to apply to
the Constitutional Court, and strong measures are taken against
trafficking.

The report also said that the Government was not involved into
political assassinations, in contrast to 2005, neither government nor
human rights organizations reported about deaths caused by oppression
or humiliation.

However, the report mentions negative phenomena, particularly, use of
force against private soldiers by army officials and use of violence
against citizens and apprehended by police.

UCLA: Ebb and Flow of the Armenian Communities of the Indian Ocean

PRESS RELEASE
UCLA AEF Chair in Armenian History
Contact: Prof. Richard Hovannisian
Tel: 310-825-3375
Email: [email protected]

Ebb and Flow of the Armenian Communities of the Indian Ocean

International Conference, March 17-18, 2007
Saturday 9:30-5:00, Sunday 2:00-5:00
University of California, Los Angeles

Court of Sciences 50 (Young Hall)

Sponsored by
Armenian Educational Foundation Chair in Modern Armenian History

Co-Sponsored by
Center for India and South Asia
Department of History
International Institute
G.E. von Grunebaum Center for Near Eastern Studies
and the
AGBU Southern California District Committee

March 17: Saturday Morning (9:30 a.m.-1:00 p.m.)

Introduction-Ebb and Flow
Richard G. Hovannisian, UCLA

Armenian Settlements and Cultural Life

Chair and Discussant: Engseng Ho, Harvard University

Armenian Mercantile Communities in Southeast Asia
Margaret Sarkissian, Smith College

From Dispersion to Nation: Armenian Diasporic Speculations in 18th-Century
India
Khachig Tölölyan, Wesleyan University

The Indian Interlude in the Development of Modern Armenian Drama
Peter Cowe, UCLA

Refreshments

`Azdarar’ and Other Armenian Periodicals of India
Osheen Keshishian, Glendale Community College

Joseph Emin and British Colonial Policy in Calcutta
Mana Kia, Harvard University

Lunch Recess: 1:00-2:00 p.m.

Saturday Afternoon: (2:00-5:00 p.m.)

Indo-Armenian History and Relations

Chair and Discussant: Houri Berberian (California State University, Long Beach)

Colonial Counterflows: An Armenian Lady from Agra in London, circa 1610
Michael Fisher, Oberlin College

Khwaja Gorgin Khan: An 18TH-Century Armenian General of the Bengal Army
Bhaswati Bhattacharya, University of Leiden

Notables and Benefactors (with a film on Sir Catchick Paul Chater)
Richard G. Hovannisian, UCLA

Refreshments

Armenian-American GIs and the Armenian Community of India in World War II
Gregory Aftandilian, Harvard University

The Present State of the Indo-Armenian Community
Armen Baibourtian, Erevan, First Armenian Ambassador to India

Sunday March 18: (2:00-5:00 p.m.)
Long Distance Merchants and Julfan Trade in the Indian Ocean

Chair and Discussant: Edward A. Alpers, UCLA

French Commercial Ambitions and Armenian Interlocutors in 17th-Century Asia
Sanjay Subrahmanyam, UCLA

Long Distance Merchants and the Role of Julfan `Networks of Trust’
Sebouh Aslanian, Columbia University

Don Pedro di Zaratte: A Julfan Armenian in Mexico City, 1723-31.
Tatiana Seijas, Yale University

Photographic Exhibit by Richard and Anne Elizabeth Elbrecht, Davis

Open to the Public at No Charge. Parking: Structure 2 ($8.00), UCLA
Entrance, Hilgard at Westholme Avenue

A Second Group Of Turkish Legislators Visiting Washington To Lobby M

A SECOND GROUP OF TURKISH LEGISLATORS VISITING WASHINGTON TO LOBBY MEMBERS OF THE US CONGRESS

armradio.am
12.03.2007 13:02

A second group of Turkish legislators started a visit to Washington
yesterday to lobby members of the US Congress against a resolution
recognizing the killings of Armenians during World War I as genocide,
reports the Turkish Daily News.

Ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) deputies Egemen BagıÅ~_,
also a foreign policy advisor to the Turkish Prime Minister, and
Reha Denemec will today join the group made up of AKP deputy Vahit
Erdem, main opposition Republican People’s Party (CHP) deputies Ersin
Arıoglu and Bihlun Tamaylıgil. The deputies are scheduled today
to meet Turkish Ambassador in Washington Nabi Å~^ensoy. On Tuesday,
they will participate in a meeting of the Turkish-American Council
and have talks with the members of the Jewish organizations in the
United States. On Thursday they will have contacts with the members
of the US Congress and the next day they are expected to return
to Turkey. The first of the planned three separate delegations,
including members of both the AKP and the CHP, started a visit to
Washington in late February to seek support against the resolution,
expected to be debated at the House of Representatives soon. The
third delegation plans to lobby in Washington next month.

–Boundary_(ID_VlSWIwiwb6nvoaN8sZceMg)–

ANKARA: Pair Fined For Threatening Armenian Patriarch

PAIR FINED FOR THREATENING ARMENIAN PATRIARCH

The New Anatolian, Turkey
March 10 2007

Two men were yesterday fined for sending threatening messages to
Armenian Patriarch Mesrob II Mutafyan via their mobile phones.

After being released pending trial, Gokmen Akman and Hasan Ezer were
not present at the hearing at the Istanbul Second Criminal Court
of Peace.

The presiding judge commuted the men’s jail sentences to fines. The
court ordered Akman to pay YTL 1,287, while Ezer was fined to YTL 77.

According to the indictment prepared by Istanbul Public Prosecutor
Kadir Nazmi Yelkenci, Akman and Ezer were accused of sending
threatening messages to Mutafyan on Oct. 13, 2004 that said, "If
you can’t protect your head, there’s no use in trying to escape,"
"We’ll drive you mad," and "We’ll finish you."

Another threat against Mutafyan

On Thursday two people were arrested for shooting into the air after
a ceremony held on Sunday at the Mother Mary Church to commemorate
the death of Hrant Dink. One of the suspects, Volkan Karaova, stated
during interrogation that he went to the church to assassinate
Armenian Patriarch Mesrob II Mutafyan. Brought before the Istanbul
Judicial Court, Karaova stated that he didn’t fire a shot in the air,
but went to the church to kill Mesrob II.

Waving Ataturk’s Flag

Turkish nationalism

Waving Ataturk’s flag

Mar 8th 2007 | ISTANBUL AND WASHINGTON, DC
>From The Economist print edition

There has been a lethal upsurge in ultra-nationalist feeling in Turkey

SITTING in an office plastered with Ottoman pennants, portraits of Ataturk
and the Turkish flag, Kemal Kerincsiz, a lawyer, says his mission in life is
to protect the Turkish nation from "Western imperialism and global forces
that want to dismember and destroy us". In the past two years Mr Kerincsiz
and his Turkish Jurists’ Union have launched a slew of cases against Turkish
intellectuals under article 301 of the penal code, which makes "insulting
Turkishness" a criminal offence.

Mr Kerincsiz has confined his nationalism to the courts. But elsewhere new
ultra-nationalist groups, some of them led by retired army officers, have
been vowing over guns and copies of the Koran to make Turks "the masters of
the world" and even "to die and kill" in the process. In January one of Mr
Kerincsiz’s targets, a Turkish-Armenian newspaper editor, Hrant Dink, was
shot dead by a 17-year-old, Ogun Samast, because he had "insulted the Turks".
The murder, in broad daylight on one of Istanbul’s busiest streets, was a
chilling manifestation of a resurgence of xenophobic nationalism aimed at
Turkey’s non-Muslim minorities and the Kurds-plus their defenders in the
liberal elite.

The upsurge threatens to undo the good of four years of reforms by the
mildly Islamist government led by Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Indeed, it is partly
in response to these reforms-more freedom for the Kurds, a trimming of the
army’s powers, concessions on Cyprus-that nationalist passions have been
roused. The knowledge that many members of the European Union do not want
Turkey to join has inflamed them further (the EU partially suspended
membership talks with Turkey in December because of its refusal to open its
ports and airspace to Greek-Cypriots).

Another factor is America’s refusal to move against separatist PKK
guerrillas who are based in northern Iraq. If the United States Congress
delivers its pledge to adopt a resolution calling the mass slaughter of the
Ottoman Armenians in 1915 genocide, Turkey’s relationship with its ally
would suffer "lasting damage", says the foreign minister, Abdullah Gul.

Murat Belge, a leftist intellectual who is being hounded by Mr Kerincsiz,
sees disturbing similarities between the racist nationalism espoused by the
"Young Turks" in the dying days of the Ottoman empire (who ordered the mass
slaughter of its Armenian subjects), and the siege mentality gripping Turkey
today. The perception, now as then, is that Western powers are pressing for
changes to empower their local collaborators (ie, Kurds and non-Muslims),
with the aim of breaking up the country. "This social Darwinist mindset that
implies it’s OK to kill your enemies in order to survive" has been
perpetuated through an education system that tells young Turks that "they
have no other friend than the Turks," says Mr Belge. And it has been
cynically exploited by politicians and generals alike.

Mr Erdogan and Deniz Baykal, the leader of the opposition Republican
People’s Party, have proved no exception. When more than 100,000 Turks
gathered at Mr Dink’s funeral chanting "We are all Armenians", Mr Erdogan
opined that they had gone "too far". Both he and Mr Baykal have resisted
calls to scrap article 301, though there have been hints that it will be
amended.

The politicians are keen to court nationalist votes in the run-up to
November’s parliamentary election. Mr Erdogan also hopes that burnishing his
nationalist credentials will help him to coax a blessing from Turkey’s
hawkish generals for his hopes of succeeding the fiercely secular Ahmet
Necdet Sezer as president in May.

Yet a recent outburst by the chief of the general staff, Yasar Buyukanit,
suggests otherwise. He declared that Turkey faced more threats to its
national security than at any time in its modern history and added that only
its "dynamic forces" [ie, the army] could prevent efforts to "partition the
country". These words, uttered during an official trip to America, were
widely seen as a direct warning to Mr Erdogan to shelve his presidential
ambitions.

Others do not rule out possible collusion between nationalist elements
within the army and retired officers who are organising new
ultra-nationalist groups (one is said to be training nationalist youths in
Trabzon, where Dink’s alleged murderers came from). "The real purpose is to
sow chaos, to polarise society so they can regain ground [lost with the EU
reforms]," argues Belma Akcura, an investigative journalist whose recent
book about rogue security forces known as the "deep state" earned her a
three-month jail sentence. It would not be surprising if their next target
were a nationalist, she adds.

Meanwhile prominent writers and academics, including Mr Belge, continue to
be bombarded with death threats. Some are under police protection. Orhan
Pamuk, the Nobel prize-winning author whom Mr Kerincsiz took to court over
his comments about the persecution of the Armenians and the Kurds, has fled
to New York.

Where will matters go from here? This week one court banned access to
YouTube after clips calling Ataturk gay appeared on it; and another
sentenced a Kurdish politician to six months’ jail for giving the PKK
leader, Abdullah Ocalan, an honorific Mr. But a private television station
also withdrew a popular series, "The Valley of the Wolves", that glorifies
gun-toting nationalists who mow down their mainly Kurdish enemies, after the
channel was inundated with calls for the show’s axing. The battle for
Turkey’s soul is not over yet.

Discussion of Genocide bill in Congress may be postponed till 2008

Discussion of the Armenian Genocide bill in US Congress may be postponed
till 2008

10.03.2007 14:05
Marlena Hovsepyan
"Radiolur"

It is possible that the Armenian Genocide bill will not be included in
the agenda of the US House of Representatives by April 24. Moreover,
editor of the California Courier Harut Sasounsin told `Radiolur’ that
the discussions may be postponed by 2008. Why?

Currently the Armenian Genocide bill is being discussed in the House
Foreign Relations Committee, after which it will be submitted to the
vote of the members of the House of Representatives. However, Chairman
of the Foreign Relations Committee Tom Lantos may prevent the vote on
the Armenian resolution.

Ethnic Jew Tom Lantos, who escaped the Holocaust, had to be very
sensitive to a genocide perpetrated against another people. However,
he is known for his pro-Turkish position and has always been voting
against the Armenian bill. The vote two years ago was not an
exception, either. Then member of the Committee Lantos voted for the
pro-Armenian documentl only in order to punish Turkey. He said that
Turkey rejected the attack of the American Army on Iraq from the
Turkish side. `To teach a good lesson to Turkey I must say `yes’ to
the Armenian bill,’ Harut Sasounian quotes Lantos as saying.

But now the situation is different: during his visit to Washington in
February Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul met with Tom Lantos and
threatening to jeopardize the interests of Israel, made him promise to
prevent the adoption of the resolution. It’s worth mentioning that
only the Chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee is eligible to
decide the terms of discussion of this or that bill. Harut Sasounian
says only late March it will become clear whether this information
reported by Turkish sources is true or not.

Despite everything, it is obvious that the Turkish side is taking
every effort to prevent the voting on the bill. The editor-in-chief of
the California Courier is worried that the discussion of the
resolution may be delayed until next year. The reason is the
presidential and parliamentary elections expected in Turkey in 2007,
and the objective of the Turkish authorities is to refrain from
disappointing the electorate preceding the elections. `That is why
they are taking extreme steps by threatening to both Israel and the
United States,’ says Harut Sasounian.

It is logical that the Turkish passions towards the Armenian Genocide
bill will calm down after the elections. The importance of this bill
should not be exaggerated, Harut Sasounian says. According to him, in
reality its importance is not that big, since the Congress has already
adopted two similar resolutions. `It should not be perceived as a
question of life and death. In case the resolution is adopted, the
Genocide will be recognized. The Genocide has been recognized long
ago, it will just be another mark,’ Mr. Sasounian told ` Radiolur.’