CSTO Secretary General warns of “risk of destabilization” due to situation in Nagorno Karabakh

Save

Share

 13:07, 31 March 2023

YEREVAN, MARCH 31, ARMENPRESS. The Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) Secretary General Imangali Tasmagambetov has warned of a “risk of destabilization” stemming from the tense situation in Nagorno Karabakh.

Speaking at a joint meeting of the CSTO Secretariat and Joint Staff, Tasmagambetov said that the situation in Nagorno Karabakh and Afghanistan remains tense and creates “risk of destabilization” in the CSTO countries.

 “The tension in the Caucasus region persists as a result of the many years of disputes between Armenia and Azerbaijan,” Interfax news agency quoted the CSTO Secretary General as saying.

He warned of a serious risk of destabilization because of the risks relating to the situation in Nagorno Karabakh and the Armenian-Azerbaijani border.

“The situation in the Central Asian region is also tense, the threat of infiltration of extremist ideology and terrorist groups into the territory of CSTO allies is growing. The difficult threats coming from the territory of Afghanistan are especially concerning,” he said, adding that the organization is working to perfect its mechanisms of withstanding challenges and threats.

Nagorno Karabakh FM meets with Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes President Laurent Wauquiez in Yerevan

Save

Share

 11:29,

YEREVAN, MARCH 31, ARMENPRESS. The President of the French region of Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes, Laurent Wauquiez, visited on Friday the Permanent Representation of the Republic of Artsakh (Nagorno Karabakh) in Yerevan, Armenia.

Wauquiez met with the Foreign Minister of Artsakh Sergey Ghazaryan at the representation.

Photos by Hayk Manukyan

On March 29, Wauquiez visited the entrance of the Lachin Corridor – which is currently blocked by Azerbaijan. In Syunik, he a cooperation agreement with the Armenian province.

EU helping to preserve biodiversity in Armenia

March 20 2023

On 17 March, an event was held in Armenia to launch work to promote the Emerald Network and the management of Emerald sites in the country.

This work, conducted by the World Bank as part of the EU-funded EU4Environment programme, aims to ensure the long-term conservation of natural habitats, preserve  biodiversity and promote sustainable interaction between people and the environment.

Project activities include developing recommendations for a National Emerald Action Plan to facilitate the emerald network, developing guidelines for the preparation of Emerald Site Management Plans, developing management plans for selected Emerald Sites, and capacity building.

The meeting gathered participants from different target groups including governmental organisations, public bodies, academia, NGOs, intergovernmental organisations, and other environmental organisations.

The Emerald Network is an ecological network made up of Areas of Special Conservation Interest, launched by the Council of Europe and supported by the European Union.

Find out more

Press release

Armenia to Launch Comprehensive Health Insurance

Country has long had low spending on healthcare, leading to huge pressure on ordinary citizens.


Ani Aikuni is all too familiar with the stress of grueling and expensive cancer treatment.  

“It is really difficult, when you have to deal with a serious diagnosis and at the same time have to think about getting money to cover the costs of treatment,” the 37-year-old entrepreneur told IWPR. “If a person does not have financial resources, this can lead to a lot of stress. All this, of course, affects the patient’s physical and mental state.”

Aikuni, who was diagnosed in 2015, said that his family had quickly spent all their savings on treatment.

His life was only saved, he continued, thanks to a fundraising campaign launched by friends which brought in 30,000 US dollars of donations from all over the world. After recovering, Aikuni started a charitable fund providing financial support for cancer patients.

He wholeheartedly welcomed Armenia’s introduction of a new health insurance system he said could save many lives.

It would be great if the new health insurance could alleviate the financial burden for patients,” Aikuni continued. “If everything is well organised, citizens will only benefit. It is critical to ensure that a person can have access to health care services immediately after being diagnosed, so that they don’t wait months for their turn.”

Experts have long debated the need to reform Armenia’s current healthcare system, under which the general public pays for treatment, while those from vulnerable and disadvantaged groups can access free care.   

Armenia has low public funding for healthcare – 5.4 per cent of state budget expenditures or about 1.4 per cent of GDP, at least four times less than countries from the same income group.

According to ministry of health data, about nine per cent of the population spent more than a quarter of their entire consumer spending on medical care.

On February 2, 2023, the government decided to introduce a new system over the next four years. Announcing the measures, minister of health, Anahit Avanesyan said that the goal was “to provide timely and proper medical services to every citizen, regardless of their solvency, gender, age, etc”.

The strategy will be implemented in stages. After a year of preparatory work, 2024 will see it rolled out to cover some state employees, children and those from marginalised groups including socially disadvantaged citizens and those with special needs.  

In 2025, the system will extend to those aged 63 and over, as well as public sector employeesIn 2026, all those in employment will have the opportunity to join. People also have the option to join voluntarily ahead of schedule.

“I often meet patients who cannot afford the costs of cancer treatment.”

Yerevan aims to reduce mortality ratesincrease life expectancy and ensure fewer people live with health-related disabilities 

The plan is to cover 95 per cent or more citizens of the Republic of Armenia in the final stage of the comprehensive health insurance programme; all citizens can benefit from the same services, regardless of their income and social status,” Avanesyan said.

However, she did not specify the annual cost for insurance, saying only that it would be a fixed amount for all regardless of income.   For those who earn less than the average salarypart of the insurance cost would be subsidised, while those currently using state-funded free health care services would have their costs covered.

In various public discussions, officials previously stated that the annual cost for health insurance might range between 150,000-200,000 drams (375-500 dollars).

The programme will cover diseases with a high mortality rate in Armeniaparticularly, cardiovascular conditions, cancer and and diabetes.

For example, for oncology patients, the programme will cover costs for surgery, chemotherapy and up to 22 sessions of radiation therapy. Patients will also receive financial aid of 1.6 million drams (4,000 dollars).

Oncologist Vahe Ter-Minasyan welcomed the decision, noting that “I often meet patients who cannot afford the costs of cancer treatment and often get poorer in the course of the long-term treatment, losing not only health, but finances and property”.

The scheme would not entirely cover the amount needed for cancer treatment, but would certainly help many, he continued.

“Unfortunately, 1.6 million drams are not enough, because there are cases when this amount is only enough to buy medicines for two monthsBut on the other hand, of course, its better than nothing.”

Along with the insurance programme, the minister of health also promised to upgrade infrastructure, building or modernising 50 medical facilities by 2026.

Deputy prime minister Tigran Khachatryan said that he hoped that state funding to the healthcare sector would also be stepped up

“We must increase the amount of resources allocated to the healthcare system by several times, thereby emphasising the significance of public health,” he said.

Although the comprehensive health insurance has not yet been formally adopted, 89 per cent of users voted in favour of it on the public discussion platform e-draft.am.

But the new system has not met with universal approval.

Economist Tigran Jrbashyan argued that it would only change the way healthcare was funded, rather than improving the efficiency and quality of the system itself.

He said that comprehensive health insurance should only introduced after healthcare reforms were carried that could increase the chances of its successful implementation. The sector simply did not function properly, he continued.

“For 30 years, the reforms in the healthcare sector have been carried out without focusing on the efficiency and effectiveness of the sector,” Jrbashyan said. “As a result of this, we are in a situation, when Armenia, in terms of number of hospitals, doctors and beds, outdoes most developed European countries, but as for the efficiency, is falls behind many less developed.”

This publication was prepared under the “Amplify, Verify, Engage (AVE) Project” implemented with the financial support of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Norway.

War In Armenia: The Role Of The Armenian Diaspora – Analysis

By Observer Research Foundation

By Ani Yeremyan

Throughout history, Armenia was always subjected to foreign invasions. Being at the crossroads of Asia and Europe, the country has always been at the epicentre of conflicting interests thus losing its autonomy a few times in history. Eventually, Armenians were either exiled from their homeland or had to migrate for a better future.

Over time, various Armenian diasporic communities emerged as stateless social formations; they developed unique elements of their identity in relation to their homeland to preserve their language, religion, and traditions in the host land. In this respect, the Armenian trade diaspora in India played a significant role in nation-building by printing the first Armenian political tracts in the early 18th century.

However, the relationship of the Armenian diasporas with the homeland was re-shaped after the Independence of Armenia in 1991. This also marked the period of renewed conflict and the first Artsakh (Nagorno Karabagh) war between Armenia and Azerbaijan at the onset of the collapse of the erstwhile Soviet Union. Artsakh had been included in the territory of Soviet Azerbaijan as an autonomous region against the will of the people living there. In view of this, the role of various diaspora communities became significant in international politics.

Eventually, political and economic aspects also turn to be prevalent in the diaspora-home land relationship for the security of the nation-state and the promotion of its interests in the host country. Some governments granted permission to these communities for promoting their interests within their respective host countries in an institutionalised manner. In this respect, the significance of Armenian diasporic communities established in Western countries will be examined amid the vulnerable peace pact and the unstable situation in the region.

The emergence of the Armenian diaspora saw several push and pull factors, but the genocide in the Ottoman Empire was one of the main reasons for the Armenian diaspora to be considered ‘classic’, ‘victim’ and ‘archetypal’ one. The deportation and mass murder of non-Turkic ethnicities (such as the Armenians and the Greeks), resulted in the creation of a relatively homogenous population of Muslims including Turks, Kurds, and others. Thus, the massacres of the Armenians in the late 19th century caused forced displacement (1.75 million people) during 1915–16 by the Ottoman Turks to Syria and Palestine. Many Armenians subsequently migrated to western countries such as France and the United States (US). The genocide forced Armenians worldwide to carry out a “struggle” for preserving their national identity by establishing churches, schools, and other organisations.

As a matter of fact, consciousness of home and belonging became prevalent in the construction of the Armenian diasporic identity. Though the idea of “home” remained ambiguous, as many identify it with their lost homeland in the Ottoman Empire, others with their history and culture, and the rest with the Republic of Armenia, they show solidarity with their home state when it faces a challenge.

The recent 44-day war that broke out in 2020 attests to the significant role played by the worldwide Armenian diasporic communities in raising awareness about the war and in sending humanitarian aid to the affected. This war coincided with the COVID pandemic making it twice as hard to mobilise people. Armenian diasporic communities worldwide utilised the digital space as a meeting platform for a common cause.

The Armenian communities worldwide continued raising awareness about the existential threat against Armenians at home by organising protests under the aegis of organisations like the Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA).

The significant role of the worldwide Armenian diaspora was stressed at Global Armenian Summit also. It highlighted that the existence of both the diaspora and Armenia stemmed from one another. On balance, when there is an existential threat against Armenians, diaspora plays a significant role both in the domestic affairs of the home country and international affairs in promoting the national interests of the home state by drawing attention to the major issues. Protests by the Armenian diaspora organisations and communities in various countries resulted in calls by higher officials of their host countries for sanctions against Azerbaijan.

Apart from lobbying in host countries, organisations like Hayastan All-Armenia Fundand Armenian General Benevolent Union (AGBU) raised funds for the displaced and the affected. The vision of the Hayastan All-Armenia Fund is to have a global Armenian network that will support Armenians in Armenia and Artsakh through projects aimed at healthcare, social welfare, infrastructure betterment. Their objectives also include sustainable development of Armenia and worldwide Armenian diasporic communities based on a common identity.

Lobbying efforts by the Armenians worldwide for the Armenian cause does have an impact; this is best reflected in the strong reaction by the Turkish and Azerbaijani governments. Silencing the voice of diaspora, especially in France and the US, has been part of Türkiye’s foreign policy and has turned violent in many cases under the Erdogan regime.

The message of violence is also propounded by other higher officials. Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu , the foreign minister of Turkey,  showed the symbol of Grey Wolves—the armed wing of the MHP (Turkey’s Nationalist Movement Party)—in April 2022 to the Armenian community members in Uruguay who were marching before the 107thanniversary of the Armenian Genocide. The Grey Wolves sign could also be seen during the Lachin corridor blockade by Azerbaijani military personnel. Targeted anti-Armenian propaganda and anti-Armenian hate posters by Turkey and Azerbaijan have increased in the recent times in several Turkish and Azerbaijani diasporic communities .

In conclusion, it may be noted that amid the dire situation in Nagorno-Karabagh and considering the changing world order, the Armenian diaspora may be considered one of the primary strategic partners of the Armenian State. Despite the fact that the Armenian diaspora is heterogeneous with different ideas of home and homeland, it may be a significant transnational actor in the international arena to raise awareness about the existential threat faced by Armenians in their homeland.

ORF was established on 5 September 1990 as a private, not for profit, ’think tank’ to influence public policy formulation. The Foundation brought together, for the first time, leading Indian economists and policymakers to present An Agenda for Economic Reforms in India. The idea was to help develop a consensus in favour of economic reforms.

Inna Sahakyan’s Aurora’s Sunrise wins Grand Prix at 2023 FIFDH

Save

Share

 12:03,

YEREVAN, MARCH 20, ARMENPRESS. Aurora’s Sunrise, a film about Armenian Genocide survivor Aurora Mardiganian directed by Inna Sahakyan, has won the Grand Prix at the 2023 International Film Festival and Forum on Human Rights – FIFDH.

“The reconstitution of memories through a mise en scène that combines the strength of testimony, images from a film that was thought to be lost and the use of watercolour animation that carries the weight of tragic events. A cinematographic work that aims to prevent the Armenian genocide from being forgotten,” the jury statement reads.

Filmmaker Inna Sahakyan commented on the win by saying that it is a unique award. “Aurora was fighting to keep humanity alive within herself, mitigating the pain on screen, and this means that her mission still goes on and will never be forgotten. Surviving her pain on screen, Aurora was struggling for human rights. This award proves that her mission continues,” Sahakyan said in comments to the national cinema center.

The odyssey of Aurora Mardiganian from Armenian genocide survivor to silent movie star is close to unreal. Having lost her family, escaped slavery and now enduring trauma, she journeys far to tell the world of the Armenian Genocide as it happened. Once in Hollywood, as a star of the silent screen, her story becomes the biggest blockbuster of the time. 30 million dollars is raised, which will save 160 000 orphans, whose descendants number in the millions today. Her courage long forgotten, “Aurora’s Sunrise” revives Aurora’s story through unique testimony, archive footage, and the magic of animation.




Opinion: Florida politicians could learn from Armenia’s educators

Washington Post
March 9 2023
LETTER

It was inspiring and reassuring to read in the March 6 news article “For Russian children in exile, hard questions in classroom” about the education of Russian children who attend the Liberated School in Yerevan, Armenia. It is good to know that not all Russian youngsters are force-fed their homeland’s prevailing orthodox thinking and propaganda.

I was stirred by the words of one staff member at that school. The school’s director said, “Children should make their own decisions. They should decide themselves how they relate to a political situation or a religious belief.” She added, “We will not bend to anyone. We will not be told who are the good guys, who are the bad ones, who we should support and so on.”

So it is good to know that there are educators in this world who encourage free thought and free _expression_ among students who want candidly to discuss events relevant to their lives. Perhaps also, just possibly, there are places of intellectual refuge available to families with children in Florida’s schools.

Bill CoeWashington










Days after first high-profile talks, a deadly clash in Karabakh

March 6 2023
John Horan Mar 6, 2023
The Lachin corridor connects Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh

A shooting in Nagorno-Karabakh on March 5 left three Karabakhi Armenian police officers and two Azerbaijani soldiers dead. 

Naturally, Azerbaijan on the one hand and Karabakh and Armenia on the other are offering vastly different accounts of what happened. 

The incident comes just as Azerbaijan-Karabakh talks seemed to be picking up steam, and nearly three months into the blockade of Karabakh by Azerbaijani government-sponsored activists. 

Those activists are camped out near the town of Shusha, on the road that forms the Lachin corridor, Karabakh’s only lifeline to Armenia and the outside world. 

The Azerbaijani defense ministry’s account of the incident suggested that Armenian vehicles were attempting to bypass the blockade — which Baku denies is a blockade — in order to transport “military equipment, ammunition, and personnel” from Armenia to Karabakh. 

Azerbaijani army units had attempted to “stop and inspect” some such vehicles which had been using the “Khankandi-Khalfali-Turshu dirt road,” it said. (Khankandi is the Azerbaijani name for Stepanakert, the administrative center of Nagorno-Karabakh.)

“The opposing side opened fire and there were casualties and injuries from both sides as a result of the firefight,” it added. 

The ministry said that the only road that can be used between Armenia and Karabakh is the “Khankandi-Lachin road” and that the use of the detour constitutes a violation of the November 9, 2020 Russian-brokered peace agreement between Armenia and Azerbaijan. 

It called on the Russian peacekeeping contingent, deployed in the area under the same agreement, to intervene. 

Karabakh’s de facto foreign ministry, meanwhile, said “a group of saboteurs from the Azerbaijani armed forces” crossed into Karabakh-administered territory and “committed an armed attack on a patrol car of the passport and visa directorate” of the Karabakh police, killing three officers and wounding another. 

This incursion represents a violation of the trilateral agreement, it said. 

Armenia’s foreign ministry supported that version, adding that the police vehicle that was attacked was on its way from Stepanakert to villages inside Nagorno-Karabakh and that there was nothing in it besides documents and a service pistol. It dismissed as “absurd” Baku’s accusation of personnel and weapons being transported from Armenia to Karabakh. 

Azerbaijan has long made such claims, including that Armenian and Karabakhi forces have continued to lay mines since the 2020 war that ended in Azerbaijan’s victory.

The International Court of Justice, the top court of the United Nations, ruled on February 23 that Azerbaijan should ensure movement on the blockaded Lachin corridor. In its ruling it rejected Azerbaijan’s request that the court demand new measures related to allegations that Armenian forces are continuing to plant land mines on Azerbaijani territory. 

A day before the clash, Azerbaijani media reported that an Azerbaijani soldier had been killed when a mine “planted by Armenians” blew up (the location of that incident was not reported).

Azerbaijan’s defense ministry said the March 5 incident demonstrates the need for establishing Azerbaijani checkpoints on the Lachin corridor. 

This demand was issued recently by President Ilham Aliyev in parallel with moving back from Baku’s demand for the establishment of a seamless transportation link from mainland Azerbaijan to the Nakhchivan exclave through Armenia known as the “Zangezur corridor.”

Karabakh’s foreign ministry said that the timing of the “attack” — four days after the most public yet meeting between Azerbaijani and Karabakhi representatives — indicated that there was no point in negotiations. 

“Through its actions Baku is openly demonstrating its rejection of talks as a means for resolving any issues,” it said.

John Horan is Eurasianet’s Caucasus editor.

Armenian Deputy FM, US Co-chair of the OSCE MG exchange views on regional security issues

Save

Share

 20:33, 7 March 2023

YEREVAN, MARCH 7, ARMENPRESS. On March 7, Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia Vahe Gevorgyan received Louis Bono, the Senior Adviser for Caucasus Negotiations, the U.S. Co-Chair of the OSCE Minsk Group, ARMENPRESS was informed from the MFA Armenia.

The interlocutors exchanged views on regional security issues. The recent developments of the normalisation process of Armenia-Azerbaijan relations were discussed.

During the meeting, the humanitarian crisis in Nagorno-Karabakh resulting from Azerbaijan’s illegal blockade of the Lachin corridor was touched upon. The Deputy Foreign Minister of Armenia emphasized that Azerbaijan is maliciously disregarding the decision of the International Court of Justice regarding the request for provisional measures on the unblocking of the Lachin corridor.

Vahe Gevorgyan briefed Louis Bono on the details of the ambush of Azerbaijan in Nagorno-Karabakh on March 5.

EU, NATO ‘Concerned’ about Azerbaijani Ambush in Artsakh Police

Russian peacekeeping forces at the site of the Azerbaijani ambush on an Artsakh police vehicle


The European Union and NATO voiced “concern” about the ambush of Azerbaijani forces on an Artsakh police vehicle on Sunday that killed three officers and injured a fourth. In statements reacting to the incident, neither body condemned Azerbaijan for its brazen attack.

“The EU is sorry for the violence that broke out on the Karabakh contact line yesterday, which resulted in at least five victims. The circumstances of this fatal incident must be thoroughly investigated. We call on all interested parties to exercise restraint to prevent further actions that could further undermine regional stability and threaten the peace process,” Peter Stano, the EU’s foreign affairs spokesperson said in a statement on Monday.

The EU is currently deploying a 100-person mission on the border of Armenia that has been characterized as an effort to quell tensions.

In a similar statement on Monday, Javier Colomina, the NATO Secretary-General’s special representative to the Caucasus voiced “concern.”

“Very concerned with reports of deadly incident in vicinity of Stepanakert. This incident demonstrates the urgency to find solutions for outstanding issues at the negotiation table. NATO supports the normalization of relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan,” Colomina wrote on social media.

Meanwhile, Sunday’s ambush by Azerbaijani forces on the Artsakh police dominated a meeting between Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and Brice Roquefeuil, the French co-chair of the OSCE Minks Group, who is in Yerevan on a working visit.

Pashinyan emphasized that the actions of the Azerbaijani sabotage group cannot be described as anything other than terrorism and added that in addition to the blocking the Lachin Corridor and the actions aimed at provoking a humanitarian disaster in Nagorno-Karabakh for almost three months, “Azerbaijan continues the actions of terrorizing the Armenian population of Artsakh with the ultimate goal of accomplishing ethnic cleansing,” a statement from the prime minister’s office said.

Both leaders reportedly emphasized the need for Azerbaijan to immediately implement the decision of the International Court of Justice on unblocking the Lachin Corridor.

At the same time, Pashinyan added that, under the existing conditions, sending an international fact-finding team to the Lachin Corridor and Nagorno Karabakh “is a vital necessity.”

The United States Senior Advisor for Caucasus Negotiations Louis Bono, who is also the American OSCE Minsk Group co-chair said that the U.S. stands ready to provide further assistance to Armenia and Azerbaijan in signing a peace treaty.

“The peace treaty must be enduring and come from the two parties, rather than the United States or other countries,” Bono said after his meeting with President Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan in Baku on Monday, according to Interfax.

“It is important to Washington that Armenia and Azerbaijan interact irrespective of the mediation format. The final goal of the United States is peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan, Bono said. He noted that both sides would profit from peace, as they reaffirmed the aspiration for peace at a meeting in Munich on February 18, 2023,” added Bono, who, like his European counterparts, did not condemn Baku for the killing of three Artsakh officers. He is due in Armenia for talks on Tuesday.

The European reaction, especially a statement from the EU’s special representative to the Caucasus Toivo Klaar has angered Artsakh’s former state minister and human rights defender Artak Beglaryan, who in a tweet criticized the European diplomat for his lack of condemnation for Azerbaijan when visiting Baku.

“Back in Baku. Look forward to substantive meetings with [Azerbaijani] leadership to advance peace process after meetings in Munich,” Klaar tweeted. “The deadly incident today underscores the urgency of pushing forward with negotiations to achieve stability & a fair peace.”

Beglaryan hit back by calling Klaar “amateur.”

“My mistrust/doubts to Toivo Klaar get deeper due to his reactions to Azerbaijani crimes,” Beglaryan tweeted. “He is either: Amateur diplomat, Under Az [Azerbaijani] brainwashing, Corrupt official, With deviated perceptions of European values, interests & human rights. All four options require changes.”