The Armenian Genocide Resolution And The Perils Of State-Sponsored H

THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE RESOLUTION AND THE PERILS OF STATE-SPONSORED HISTORY

JURIST
Oct 11 2007

JURIST Guest Columnist Dr. Laurent Pech, Jean Monnet Lecturer in
European Union Law at the National University of Ireland, Galway,
says that the experience of France – and some principled reflections –
should make the US House of Representatives think twice before adopting
any resolution labelling the early twentieth-century killings of
Armenians in the Ottoman Empire (now Turkey) as "genocide"…

To quote Justice Stewart, the "camel’s nose is in the tent." Indeed,
the 110th US Congress appears willing to follow in the footsteps of
the French Parliament by attempting to legislate on past historical
events. The numerous advocates of House Resolution 106, the so-called
"Affirmation of the United States Record on the Armenian Genocide
Resolution", want the US President to acknowledge that the mass
killings of Armenians committed in Turkey between 1915 and 1923
constitute, this is the controversial aspect, a "genocide", i.e. the
intentional destruction, in whole or in part, of a national, ethnic,
racial or religious group.

This attempt to use the force of the law to promote a particular
historical interpretation is reminiscent of the 2001 French law which
acknowledges the existence of the Armenian genocide in 1915. One may
hope, however, that Resolution 106 will not have the votes to pass
on the House floor and that history will be left to historians.

Principled and pragmatic reasons may be offered to justify this view.

One should note, in passing, that I do not intend to debate here
whether the term "genocide" – a crime under international law since
1948 – is the accurate term to a posteriori characterize the 1915-1923
massacres. My general position is that no Parliament should legislate
to promote or worse, enforce particular historical truths.

In France, the statutory characterization of the mass slaughter of
Ottoman Armenians as a genocide led to the introduction in 2006 of
several bills (yet to be adopted) whose purpose was to punish with
criminal sentences those who "dispute" this characterization. Such
content-based prohibition on free speech is certainly and thankfully
unthinkable in the US, since the First Amendment precludes the
government from prohibiting "the expression of an idea simply because
society finds the idea itself offensive or disagreeable" (Texas
v. Johnson, 491 US 397, at 414). Yet, the "mere" statutory recognition
of the Armenian genocide may encourage diverse groups to lobby the
US Congress to have their historical narratives enshrined in the law.

Generally speaking, it is important to be wary about the slippery
slope effect of such laws. And indeed, the French Parliament, since
it first acknowledged the existence of the Armenian genocide, seems
to have found a new raison d’etre in legislating with the view of
promoting and eventually compelling people to accept state-sponsored
historical interpretations. For instance, another law passed in
2001 obliges people to describe the slave trade as "a crime against
humanity" and a provision of a 2005 law – later struck down by the
French constitutional court – also required school history teachers
to stress the "positive aspects" of French colonialism.

The American congressional resolution may also be opposed on the
grounds that no individual country has the moral authority to sanction
particular historical truths regarding events in which it is not,
directly or indirectly, involved. On the contrary, what I would call
"historical imperialism", the action of legislating to sanctify a
particular interpretation of a past event which took place in another
country, appears to be counterproductive. First of all, historical
imperialism may lead to a vicious circle where each country tries
to expose each other’s past crimes and hypocrisy. For instance,
Turkey may be tempted to push for the adoption of bill aimed at
punishing anyone who does not characterize as genocide the killings of
Algerians under French colonial rule or the mass slaughter of American
Indians by European settlers. Secondly, the passing of time and the
promotion of free speech values is more likely to help the Turks to
"arrive at the truth on their own" as a former chief of Armenia’s
National Security Council put it. The French Republic, known for its
persistent refusal until 1995 to recognize the responsibility of the
French State in the deportations of French Jews to Nazi Germany under
the Vichy regime (1940-44), would have been well-advised to show more
self-restraint. The atrocities committed against the Armenians in
Turkey took place before Ataturk proclaimed the Turkish Republic. If
the French Republic could distance itself from the actions of the Vichy
regime, the Turkish Republic should also be entitled to distance itself
from the actions of the so-called Committee of Union and Progress at
the time of the Ottoman Empire.

If the causes of historical truth and the prevention of future
genocides are the genuine concerns of those in favor of adopting
Resolution 106, strict adherence to human rights standards at home and
the non-selective defense of those standards abroad would certainly
constitute a wiser policy than legislating on other countries’
historical misdeeds.

Laurent Pech is Jean Monnet Lecturer in European Union Public Law
at the National University of Ireland, Galway and the author of a
comparative study (in French) on the right to free speech in the
US and in Europe: La liberte d’expression et sa limitation (PU
Clermont-Ferrand/LGDJ, Paris, 2003). He is currently preparing an
article on the 2007 EU framework decision on racism and xenophobia.

7/10/armenian-genocide-resolution-and-perils.php

http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/forumy/200

Genocide resolution advances

Article published Oct 11, 2007

Genocide resolution advances

October 11, 2007

By Jon Ward – A House committee rejected warnings from the Bush
administration yesterday and approved a resolution condemning Turkey
for committing genocide against Armenians during World War I, an act
the White House said could jeopardize military operations in the
Middle East.

The House Foreign Affairs Committee voted 27-21 in favor of the
resolution, which will go to the House floor for a full vote in
mid-November, Democratic leaders said.

"I just don’t know how many people can be destroyed before that word
[genocide] can be applied," said Rep. Gary L. Ackerman, New York
Democrat. "Our friends in Turkey have to understand that they can get
beyond this."

But White House spokesman Gordon Johndroe said President Bush was
"very disappointed" with the result. "The president made it clear that
this resolution could cause grave harm to U.S.-Turkish relations," he
said. "We will continue to oppose this resolution."

The White House yesterday used its biggest guns to argue that a
resolution could provoke Turkey to cut off U.S. access to its Incirlik
Air Base – a key component of resupply routes for the U.S. military in
Iraq and Afghanistan.

Mr. Bush spoke in a hastily arranged statement to reporters. "We all
deeply regret the tragic suffering of the Armenian people that began
in 1915," he said. But "this resolution is not the right response to
these historic mass killings."

Turkish President Abdullah Gul quickly denounced the resolution as
"unacceptable."

"Unfortunately some politicians in the United States of America have
closed their ears to calls to be reasonable and once again sought to
sacrifice big problems for small domestic political games," the state
news agency Anatolian quoted him today as saying.

Earlier yesterday, Mr. Bush met with Secretary of State Condoleezza
Rice and Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates, and then sent them to
speak with reporters.

"About 70 percent of all air cargo going into Iraq goes through
Turkey. About a third of the fuel that [U.S. troops] consume comes
>From Turkey," Mr. Gates said.

Mr. Gates said U.S. military commanders raised concerns about the
resolution because "they believe clearly that access to air fields and
to roads and so on in Turkey would be very much put at risk if this
resolution passes and the Turks react as strongly as we believe they
will."

Miss Rice said the military commanders "asked us to do everything we
could to make sure this does not pass" and said "we are very dependent
on a good Turkish strategic ally to help with our efforts" in Iraq.

The Armenian National Institute estimates that about 1.5 million
Armenians were killed at the hands of the Turks or died from Turkish
persecution between 1915 and 1923.

Democrats downplayed concerns about a Turkish reaction to the
resolution, saying their threats will turn out to be false.

"We will get a few angry words out of Ankara for a few days, and then
it’s over," said Rep. Brad Sherman, California Democrat.

House Majority Leader Steny H. Hoyer, Maryland Democrat, said the
resolution "was about another government at another time, and should
not be perceived … as a reflection on the present government, the
Turkish people or their present posture."

Rep. Dan Burton, Indiana Republican, was irate. "I just don’t
understand why we’re going to cut our nose off, shoot ourselves in the
foot at a time when we need this ally," he said.

The committee hearing drew a standing-room only crowd that included
Turkish officials and four elderly Armenian women who sat in
wheelchairs at the front of the room, wearing stickers that read, "I
am a survivor of the Armenian genocide."

One of the women Sirarpi Khoyan, 102, who was born in Istanbul, said
"there’s no two ways about" whether the Turkish killings of Armenians
>From 1915 to 1923 amounted to genocide.

"Of course it was [genocide]," she said.

Source: TION/110110076

http://www.washingtontimes.com/article/20071011/NA

Turkey Irked By U.S. Genocide Bill

TURKEY IRKED BY U.S. GENOCIDE BILL
Written by The Media Line Staff

The Media Line, NY
Oct 11 2007

Ankara has expressed anger over a decision of a key United States
House of Representatives panel to recognize the Armenian genocide.

Turkish President Abdullah Gul said endorsing a measure branding the
killing of Armenians by Ottoman forces as genocide was "unacceptable."

The decision has "no validity and respectability for the Turkish
people," Gul said. He accused American politicians of sacrificing
major issues for the sake of domestic politics.

The House of Representatives Foreign Affairs Committee passed the
non-binding resolution with 27 votes in favor and 21 against. It
awaits a vote in the full House.

The resolution says the killing of 1.5 million Armenians during
the First World War was a genocide which should be acknowledged in
Washington’s foreign policy towards Turkey.

Turkey denies that the Armenians were killed in a genocide by the
Turks during 1915-1917 in the Ottoman Empire. Ankara insists the
deaths were the result of inter-ethnic strife and the hardships of
the war. Turkey says between 250,000 and 500,000 Armenians and at
least as many Turks died in the civil strife when Armenians took up
arms demanding independence during the war.

U.S. President George W. Bush is unhappy about the vote. He said its
passage "would do great harm to our relations with a key ally in NATO."

Meanwhile, Turkish military and political leaders authorized troops
to cross the Iraqi border and eliminate separatist Kurdish rebel
camps in northern Iraq.

The U.S. is against the measure.

"We don’t think unilateral incursions into Iraq is the best way to
solve the problem," State Department Spokesman Sean McCormack. He
said the U.S. wanted Ankara to engage in more cooperation with the
Iraqi government on this issue.

il.asp?NewsID=19221

http://www.themedialine.org/news/news_deta

Injection For NHS Incluides GP Surgeries At Weekends

INJECTION FOR NHS INCLUDES GP SURGERIES AT WEEKENDS

AZG Armenian Daily #185
11/10/2007

Healthcare

PM unveils initiatives as report by surgeon-minister urges big changes

Gordon Brown yesterday unveiled a clutch of populist NHS reforms
to increase hospital safety and improve patients’ access to GPs,
presenting them as the first fruits of a fundamental review of
healthcare in England by the surgeon-minister Lord Darzi.

The prime minister’s pre-election pleasers included a plan for at least
half the nation’s GP surgeries to open during evenings or weekends,
which he described as "an immediate aim". He also promised to fund 150
extra health centres in easily-accessible places across the country,
open seven days a week from 8am to 8pm.

Mr Brown said the battle to combat MRSA will extend next year to
testing all patients arriving for planned surgery, with a hotline
for NHS staff whistleblowers to report risks. The initiatives
are expected to cost hundreds of millions of pounds a year, but
Alan Johnson, the health secretary, refused to disclose the amount
until the comprehensive spending review is announced on Monday. He
said the review would bring "real-terms growth" for the health
service. Ministers are also understood to be hoping for a big cash
injection into mental health therapies and adult social care.

Lord Darzi, the leading cancer surgeon chosen by Mr Brown to be a
health minister responsible for reshaping NHS services, published an
interim report to the prime minister calling for fundamental changes
in the NHS.

He said small incremental improvements were not enough to satisfy
rising public expectations. "Alternatively we can choose to be
ambitious and set out a clear vision for a world class NHS focused
relentlessly on improving the quality of care … Only this approach
enables us to deliver the kind of personalised care we all expect."

Lord Darzi presented his findings to the 72 leading doctors, nurses and
healthcare professionals he has recruited to work out local solutions
in the nine English regions outside London. Their proposals will
emerge in his final report in May or June.

This timetable would leave voters in any early general election
uncertain about whether the government is preparing for a big round of
closures of key hospital departments including maternity, paediatric
and emergency services. In a review of NHS services in London, Lord
Darzi said in July: "The days of the district general hospital seeking
to provide all services to a high enough standard are over." It was
not safe or economic to treat patients with complex medical conditions
in dozens of local hospitals with inadequate expertise or equipment,
he added.

But yesterday he said the London proposals might not be suitable for
other parts of England. The NHS in the capital had been well behind
other areas in modernising hospital services, making the solutions
to its problems more drastic. "The bigger challenge outside London is
the provision of healthcare in some of the more rural areas," he said.

Mr Johnson said there would be no moratorium on change pending
Lord Darzi’s final report. But he would refer any closure proposals
submitted by health authorities and trusts to an independent panel.

The interim report included a batch of quick-fix proposals, which
were all accepted by the prime minister. They included 100 new GP
practices in the areas of England with the least number of doctors,
where about 900 GPs, nurses and healthcare assistants will offer
"an innovative range of services, including extended opening hours".

Traditional GP practices will be invited to compete with private
sector corporations to win these contracts. To help people choose a
GP and switch if they are unhappy with the service, the government
will publish data about each practice on an official website.

Mr Johnson said he wanted negotiations with the British Medical
Association to secure longer surgery opening hours. He did not want to
tear up the GPs’ contract which has increased family doctors’ earnings
by about 25% since 2004. "We are not giving up on the contract and
we are not issuing any threats," he said.

Richard Vautrey, deputy chairman of the BMA’s GPs committee, said
doctors wanted to sit down with ministers to work out how to tailor
services to meet patients’ needs. He said: "It is important to remember
that one size does not fit all when you are talking about healthcare."

Lord Darzi also proposed MRSA screening of all patients admitted
to hospital for planned operations from next year and all emergency
admissions as soon as practicable within the next three years. The
aim would be to stop patients bringing MRSA into the hospital from
outside. There will be legislation to give health inspectors the power
and money to inspect every hospital every year to ensure compliance
with the hygiene regulations. NHS trusts found wanting will be subject
to hefty fines.

Lord Darzi instructed David Nicholson, the NHS chief executive, to
begin work on drawing up an NHS constitution to put the service "at
greater distance from the day to day thrust of the political process".

There will also be a review of the health service’s ?12bn programme
to update IT and a drive to encourage the NHS to accelerate the pace
of medical innovation.

David Cameron described the proposals as "another blueprint for cuts."

The Tory leader told BBC Radio 4’s World at One: "Lord Darzi has said
the days of the district general hospital are over. What that means
is, up and down the country, hospitals are going to be threatened with
cutbacks and closures like the ones we have seen over the last year. I
want to stop that. We can stop that, but only if we have an election."

The shadow health secretary, Andrew Lansley, said: "Ara Darzi is
a honest man set amongst thieves. He is a trusted clinician who is
being used by Gordon Brown to push through this government’s plan
to downgrade local services across the country despite the fact that
there is no clinical evidence for this." The Liberal Democrat health
spokesman, Norman Lamb, said: "By putting off all decisions on service
changes till next year, Labour can safely go into an election without
the axe of closures hanging over the ballot box."

President Kocharyan’s Meetings In Brussels

PRESIDENT KOCHARYAN’S MEETINGS IN BRUSSELS

ArmRadio – Public Radio
Oct 10 2007
Armenia

Issues related to the simplification of visa regime between
Armenia and EU countries were discussed during RA President Robert
Kocharyan’s meeting with the Vice-President of the European Commission,
Commissioner for Justice, Freedom and Security Franco Frattini.

Mediamax correspondent reports from Brussels that Robert Kocharyan and
Franco Frattini discussed issues connected with judicial-legal reforms.

Issues of simplification of visa regimes for culture workers of
Armenia were discussed during President Kocharyan’s meeting with the
EU Commissioner for Culture Ian Figel.

House Panel Passes Armenian Genocide Resolution

HOUSE PANEL PASSES ARMENIAN GENOCIDE RESOLUTION

Reuters
Wed Oct 10, 2007 5:27 PM EDT

WASHINGTON (Reuters) – A U.S. House committee approved a resolution
calling the 1915 massacres of Armenians genocide on Wednesday,
brushing aside White House warnings that it would do "great harm"
to ties with NATO ally Turkey, a key supporter in the Iraq war.

The House of Representatives Foreign Affairs Committee approved the
resolution 27-21. It now goes to the House floor, where Democratic
leaders say there will be a vote by mid-November. There is a companion
bill in the Senate, but both measures are strictly symbolic, and do
not require the president’s signature.

Turkey calls the resolution an insult and rejects the Armenian
position, backed by many Western historians, that up to 1.5 million
Armenians suffered genocide at the hands of Ottoman Turks during World
War One. Turkey has warned of damage to bilateral ties if Congress
passes the measure.

The Armenian Weekly; Oct. 6, 2007; Literature and Arts

The Armenian Weekly On-Line
80 Bigelow Avenue
Watertown MA 02472 USA
(617) 926-3974
[email protected]
menianweekly.com

The Armenian Weekly; Volume 73, No. 40; Oct. 6, 2007

Literature and Arts:

The Search: From Tigran Mets to Sayat Nova (Part VII)
By Knarik O. Meneshian

September, 2007

After leaving Blblan Zham (Shimmering Chapel), Murad and I continued on our
walk, at times quietly reflecting, at times chatting as we strolled down the
street. The elderly woman we had seen minutes before sitting on the stool
behind the chapel had reminded me of another woman I had visited a few years
earlier in Yerevan. She too was seated with her hands folded, but instead of
looking up at the sky and then down at the ground she was looking at the
ceiling and then at the worn wooden floor of the house she shared with
relatives-the home of her youth. "Bala jan (Child dear)," she whispered as
she raised her head, "Please tell them I cannot chew the food they give me;
I have no teeth." Tearfully, she opened her mouth and pointed to her gums.
"I tell them and tell them, but still every day the food is the same." Tears
rolled down her soft, wrinkled cheeks as she pointed to the cracked and
chipped plate on the wide window sill. On the plate were four slices of
potatoes and a small piece of meat-all too dry and hard for anyone to eat.
As I recalled her plea, my thoughts turned to yet another elderly woman I
saw not long ago on Sayat Nova Street holding a plastic bag with a loaf of
bread sticking out of it. She was trying to cross the street. "Aghcheek jan
(Girl dear), please help me!" she called out as she reached for my hand.
"Help me, I have been standing here for so long, but the cars will not stop
and people just rush by." Taking hold of her hand for a second and then
releasing it to put my arm around her stooped shoulders, I held her tightly
as we waited for the light to turn green. When it did, we stepped down onto
the street and began walking, stopping every few steps for honking and
speeding vehicles ignoring both traffic lights and pedestrians. As we
approached the curb we were nearly struck by a car. I will never forget the
fright on the poor woman’s face or my anger at the fellow who gave us a
dirty look as he came to a screeching halt and then sped by. As I helped her
up onto the sidewalk she took hold of my hand and squeezing it, repeatedly
thanked me. "Maireek jan (Mother dear), it was nothing; it was my pleasure,"
I said.

I remembered thinking, as I watched her make her way slowly down the street,
every once in a while stopping to rest, how difficult it must be for those
who have no one who care about them-their only solace a prayer, their only
hope a plea. As I watched the woman disappear into the distance, I could not
help but think of our life back home and the various types of services
offered the elderly. In Gyumri-in Armenia-every time I’d see an elderly
woman or man, and the handicapped too, with their hands meekly, barely
extended, and their heads hanging low, I would think, They are not beggars,
they are people earning their daily bread the only way they can.

In front of us, just before the road curved, a father and his two young sons
were playing ball in the street while the mother stood nearby watching. In
front of their house, the dadeek (grandmother) was sitting on a chair
watching them all. Across the street, a young woman was sweeping the steps
leading to her house; to the right of the door big and little shoes were
lined in a neat row. We stopped for a moment to watch the children and the
father playing, and then continued on our way. As we were about to turn the
corner, we heard barking and a large black dog came darting towards us.
Someone whistled and the dog turned around and disappeared down the street.
We looked at each other with relief as we turned onto a short street. There
were no quaint old homes or embellished black tuff houses and buildings of
long ago-the work of skillful stone cutters. There were just shacks and a
few destroyed buildings with piles of debris dumped in and around them.
Behind the buildings was a sports stadium. Bending in the wind alongside the
cracked and crumbling sidewalks were overgrown weeds riddled with debris.
Nearby, a couple of sickly dogs sniffed the ground. We walked cautiously and
quickly past them and made our way to a street called Kars, once the road to
Kars. Traveling on this road to Gyumri in 1829 and 1830 were Armenians from
Kars and Erzerum fleeing oppression. They were traders, craftsmen and
peasants; they had come to this ancient city filled with new hopes and
dreams. We walked south and after a while came to a domeek standing at the
edge of the pavement. A whiskered man in tattered clothes was sitting on a
chair in front of it smoking a cigarette. He stared at us, and we greeted
him with a barev dzez (greetings to you). He nodded and blew puffs of smoke
into the air as we walked past him. In the near distance we saw dilapidated
houses and a large, round, empty shallow pool. In it were several rusted
fountains. A boy about nine years old appeared out of the tall weeds and
said with a big smile, "Barev dzez!" We in turn greeted him and asked if he
lived nearby. He replied as he pointed, "Just down there! See, that is my
dadeek there hanging clothes on the line!" The house was a shack.

After telling us his name, we asked, "Do you have any brothers and sisters?"

He shook his head and said, "I only have my dadeek. My father died a long
time ago and my mother works somewhere far away. We do not see her often."
The boy then got closer to us and said, "I am a very good guide. If you
would like, I can show you around here. See that pool over there?" We
nodded. "The fountains in it used to work and all the area kids would come
here in the summertime to cool off, but the pool has been dry for years.
Come this way," said the boy, and we followed him to a tree-lined walk.
Weeds were growing in between the cracks, and scattered on the walk were
used condoms, some old and disintegrating, others not yet. We looked up and
there before us stood Mayr Hayastan (Mother Armenia)! Two couples sitting on
the steps leading up to the statue were passionately embracing and kissing
one another. When they saw us approaching they stopped. They glanced at each
other, then giggled as they raised their bottles of beer in the air and
called out, "Egek (Come), join us for some drinks!"

"Shnorhagal enk (We are thankful), but another time!" we said, smiling as we
passed them on the steps.

"Come this way," said the boy. Just above, to the right of where we stood,
was Sev Ghul (Black Fortress), the fortress built in 1837 by Czar Nicholas
I. In that same year, Gyumri, a town at the time, was renamed Alexandropol.
Soon, one of the oldest towns in Armenia (dating back to 401 B.C.) known
first as Kumayri, then Gyumri, and then Alexandropol, would grow and develop
into a trade and handicraft center as well as a strategic military location.
In 1924, during Soviet rule, it would be renamed Leninakan and flourish as a
cultural, industrial and scientific center. Evolving from a town to Armenia’s
second largest city-now once again called Gyumri.

With our eyes fixed on Sev Ghul, we asked the boy, "Are we allowed to go up
there, to climb it?"

"Ha (Yeah), follow me!"

We walked up the hill and into the fortress where puddles and mounds of cow
dung dotted the ground. We stepped carefully as we made our way to stairs
leading up to the top of the fortress. What a breathtaking view it was!
Facing West, the province of Kars was before us. Down below, close to the
Akhuryan River, was the Russian military base. We could hear bugle calls,
singing and marching, voices shouting out as one-soldiers were performing
military exercises. In the near distance looking north was Garmeer Ghul (Red
Fortress), Sev Ghul’s smaller brother. We turned around, and there she
was-Gyumri-glimmering in the sunlight! Visible in the distance was the
steeple of a church, one of several Armenian churches in the city. Once,
there were also Greek and Russian churches.

"Son, you have been a very fine guide!" we said to him as we prepared to
leave.

"Would you like to come to our house for a while?" he asked.

"We would love to, but it is getting late and we have a long walk back home.
Here, though, is a gift for you."

He smiled as he put the bill, without looking at it, in his pocket, and
began skipping then running through the weeds towards home, every so often
looking back and waving to us, and we to him.

We began walking at a quicker pace. Before too long it would be evening and
time for the street dogs to form their packs. "Shall we go through the
park?" asked Murad as we reached the end of the street. I nodded and we
climbed the stairs leading up to it. We followed the tree-lined, meandering
path all the way to the other end of the park, near Freedom Square, where
the churches and fountains and shuga were. We passed a small side street and
remembered the married couple, Peace Corps workers, who had lived in one of
the old houses on that street before returning home around Christmas time.
"Remember the day we went to visit them?" I asked Murad. They were people
one could not forget. The man and woman had greeted us warmly at the door as
they showed us into their living room. We stopped for a moment to look at
the latched, metal door jutting out from one wall of the living room. It was
a Russian-era heating system. "Would you like some homemade apple pie and
tea?" asked the woman, her kind eyes sparkling.

"Oh, that sounds wonderful! We haven’t had homemade apple pie in ages." we
said as we sat down on the sofa. As we chatted with them about Armenia,
about life in Gyumri, we could not help but marvel at the couple’s spirit
and courage. They were both in their 70s. Not knowing the language or the
customs of Armenia, they had left behind the comforts and security of home
and family to offer their help to a people and a country they knew only of
as "somewhere in the Caucuses."

Approaching the square, I looked at Yot Verk (Seven Wounds) or Soorp
Astvatsatsin Arakelagan Yegeghetsee (Holy Mother of God Apostolic Church,
built in the 17th century), and said to Murad, "Let’s go in for a few
minutes." It was cool, dim and quiet inside. A young woman, carrying a
child, was purchasing candles, and another was lighting some. How different
was this scene from the day I first entered the church in 1990. The
square-the entire city-was in shambles. It was a cloudy, gray afternoon and
the church was packed with people of all ages. Some were standing, some were
kneeling; with hands together some were looking up, while others were
looking down. They were praying, they were whispering the words "tsavut
danem (let me take your pain)"-words rarely heard anymore. Again and again
they whispered the two words. The church was aglow with flickering candles
yet gloomy with the pain of loss. Now, as we stood here together, the church
was almost empty. Murad and I lit candles and said prayers before we left.
One was for Gyumri, one was for Armenia, and one was for Armenians
everywhere.

Back in the square, we walked towards the little eatery known simply by the
sign above it-Dak Lahmajo (Hot Lahmajo) -where the owners, a husband and
wife, made lahmehjune, or as they called them in Armenia, lahmajo. "Barev
dzez!" we said as we sat at a table. The husband stepped out from behind the
open curtain where they were preparing the Middle Eastern specialty.

"How many would you like?" asked the man as he began setting our table.

"Two for my wife, three for me, and two Fantas," said Murad.

"And we would like a dozen to take home," I added.

He called out the order to his wife.

When he finished setting the table, I asked, "May we watch you make the
lahmajo?"

"Eeharge (Of course), egek (come)!" said the man and motioned for us to come
with him.

We followed him to the back of the eatery, just a few feet from our table.
>From the window we could see the end of Rishkov Street where it met the
square. The husband began rolling out formed mounds of dough on a small
table until each mound became as thin and round as plates, and then spread
spicy meat filling on each of them. His wife, standing next to him in front
of a hotplate with a frying pan on top of it, reached for an uncooked
lahmajo, placed it in the frying pan and covered it with a cover. Before we
knew it she lifted the cover and presto-a perfectly cooked lahmajo! And so,
one after another, each lahmajo, cooked to perfection, was made. In this
eatery adorned with geraniums growing in metal cans, sparkling-clean
windows, oil-cloth covered tables, rickety chairs and a staff of two who did
everything, including greeting customers with a smile, we experienced dining
at its finest!

"Before we go home, Murad, we have to stop at the grocery store for a few
things. I’m going to make Karine’s father chocolate pudding." Dr. Amatuni’s
father was a World War II war veteran. When he learned that I was born in
Austria, he told me that when he was in Austria during the war he had eaten
chocolate pudding there for the "first and only time" and had always
remembered its "delicious flavor and smooth texture." He also mentioned that
he liked Austria because of its "neatness and orderliness." The doctor’s
father, a gentle and soft-spoken man, reminded me of another World War II
war veteran, a physician, I had spoken to in Yerevan. He had said that
during the war he, too, had been in Austria and had admired the country for
its neatness and orderliness.

"Since we’re running out of tea, let’s stop at Tartu (one of three grocery
stores in the vicinity)," said Murad as we prepared to leave. After saying
goodbye to the owners of the eatery we stepped out into the street where we
heard singing. "Let’s see where it’s coming from," I said, and we walked
towards the sound. In the square, a few feet from where the shuga began, a
thin old man, wearing frayed clothes too large for him, was standing with
his eyes closed and his head tilted toward heaven singing a folk song put to
music by Gomidas. It was a song of lament. In his deep, sweet, soulful voice
he was singing-"Dle yaman. Mer doon (Our home), dzer doon (your home), vai
(oh), dle yaman." Near him on the ground was a small jar with a couple of
coins in it. ".Vai, dle yaman."

I had seen the man a number of times before during my trips to the shuga. He
was always in the same area, always had his eyes closed, and always, whether
he was standing or sitting on the concrete slab used as a bench, had a small
jar and a walking cane near him on the ground. Sometimes he would sit or
stand silently, and sometimes he would sing one song after another. Never
before, though, had he sung this song, and never with such deep passion. I
often wondered what he was seeing with his closed eyes, and especially now
as he sang Dle Yaman.

At the grocery store we purchased a quart of milk (in a jar), a few
chocolate bars, corn starch, sugar, lavash, a box of tea, some yersheeg
(sausage) and dzver (eggs)-six of them. The clerk put the eggs in a plastic
bag, twisted the top of the bag and tied it. I was always amazed at how the
eggs never broke. As we approached Sayat Nova Street, Murad and I began
talking about the young female Peace Corps worker, a graduate student, who
lived near our apartment building. We would meet her from time to time at
Yegheeshe’s shop. There were others Peace Corps workers in the city too. Day
in and day out they lived alongside the locals-some in cities, some in
towns, some in remote villages. They learned the language and the customs of
the country. They experienced and shared in the joys, sorrows and hardships
of the local people, accepting the good moments along with the bad. They had
come to make a difference, and each did in his and her own way.

We were on Sayat Nova Street and almost home. As usual, the street vendor
was on the corner selling his produce, but today without his young son.
"Would you like to buy some cabbage?" he asked as he held one up for us to
inspect.

"Vaghuh (Tomorrow)!" I said as we waved goodbye to him. Tomorrow I would buy
one and make a pot of borsch. As we walked up the stairs to our apartment, I
thought about the street vendor below selling his cabbage. He and the
cabbage reminded me of the autumn day I had accompanied the female Peace
Corps worker (the one in her 70s) on a shopping trip to the part of the
shuga where there were shops. "I’ll meet you at the fountains!" she had said
on the phone. When we met at the designated spot, she explained, "I saw
something I’d like to buy in one of the shops down there, but I’m not able
to ask the clerk how much it costs."

"Barev dzez!" I said as we walked into the shop filled with household items
and specialty gifts. A clerk was busy with a customer, while the owner was
arranging items in the display case. He looked up and nodded at us. "My
friend would like to purchase that," I said pointing to the item and then
asked, "How much is it?" He looked at me and then at her and said, "Kooyreek
jan (Sister dear), for you, 4,000 drams, but for her, 5,000!" My heart sank
because of what he said and how he said it, and I was ashamed for him. I
said nothing to him, and turned to the Peace Corps worker and told her the
price he had quoted for her. With a smile as warm as the sun she handed him
the money. Stepping out of the store, I knew that I would never go in there
again. After walking around and exploring a few new shops, we stopped at a
cabbage and onion stand. The middle-aged vendor was arranging his produce.
The Peace Corps worker picked up a head of cabbage and asked me to ask him
the price.

The man, a humble farmer from one of the nearby villages, whom I saw
standing on the street corner in good weather and bad selling his meager
produce every time I went to the shuga, shook his head and said, "Kyooreek
jan, she is our guest. Tell her the cabbage is my gift to her, a ‘Thank You’
for coming here to help us." When I told the Peace Corps worker what the man
had said, her eyes grew misty. She handed him some drams for the cabbage and
insisted that he take them, but he shook his head. With gratitude, she
accepted his gift.

Home at last, and time to make dinner! We were having yersheek with dzoo
(egg) along with cheese, lavash, green onions and parsley. "I’ll cook the
sausage and eggs, while you take care of the rest," said Murad. I sliced the
cheese, sprinkled water on the lavash and wrapped it in a towel to soften,
washed the onions and parsley, took out some raspberry jam, and set the
table. The tea kettle was on and soon the tea would be ready, just in time
for us to begin our meal. After dinner, while Murad watched television, I
gathered my ingredients to make chocolate pudding. As I poured the freshly
bought milk into the pot, I remembered Karine’s warning to make certain to
boil the milk before using it." As I waited for it to boil and rise, I mixed
the cornstarch with cool drinking water. (We always boiled our drinking
water because of the occasional warnings on television instructing people to
boil their water because of contamination due to the aged plumbing system.)
I then broke the chocolate bars into small pieces, and measured the sugar in
a bowl. Then I poured, added and stirred until the ingredients in the pot
bubbled dark and smooth and sweet. The pudding was ready to be poured into
glass jars where they cooled.

I called Karine, but no one answered the phone. Just as I finished cleaning
the kitchen, there was a knock at the door. "I’ll get it!" I said and went
to open it. It was Karine. "The pudding is ready for your father!" I said
excitedly as I took her to the kitchen. I hoped that her father would like
it, but then wondered, How could a food flavored with fond memories ever be
duplicated? Karine smiled as I showed her the jars. In the living room, as
on other evenings, the three of us sat and chatted as we sipped tea and ate
chocolate biscuits. It was another delightful evening. Then, saying our
goodnights, I made arrangements with Karine to visit her one day at
Samaritair (Samaritan) Hospital, the place where patients affectionately
called her Bshgoohee (shortened version of bzheeshgoohee, or lady doctor),
the place where doctors worked under the most spartan of conditions,
intermittent power outages and frequent lack of water.

It was late and I had finished collecting water for tomorrow. While Murad
finished reading the local newspapers, I went to the bedroom to look out the
window for a while. As I pulled back the curtains and looked into the
darkness, a feeling of sadness came over me. School was coming to an end and
with the ringing of the vercheen zang (last bell) it would be time for us to
leave this apartment that had been not only our home but a place of
discovery and learning, adventure and joy. Oh, how I missed "our Gyumri
home" already! Tomorrow we would have to tell Gamo that we were leaving
soon. Because the school year was coming to an end, and thus our work at the
public school, we were moving to the Ani District to live at the Our Lady of
Armenia Convent and Center/Orphanage, where the bulk of our work would then
be. During the week, we would travel to the AMA Center to continue with our
classes there until their classes, too, came to an end, thus marking the
beginning of summer for the students.

It was moving day. Karine, Melkon and Hovik had come to say goodbye. Sitting
in the living room with them was the new tenant we had found for Gamo-a
young female Peace Corps worker. He had accepted half the rent we paid him.
While we chatted with one another, Gamo walked into the apartment with his
little granddaughter. His face was glum as he looked at our suitcases lined
against the foyer wall. "Shall we walk through the apartment together?" I
asked him.

"Oh, it is not necessary. I know everything is in order," he said with a
hint of sadness both in his eyes and voice.

"No, let us go through the apartment anyway," I replied. "Since we did it
when we rented the apartment, we should do it now as well," and led him to
the kitchen.

Gamo did not look around the room. Instead, he leaned against the counter,
stared at me for a moment and then almost in a whisper asked, "You are not
really leaving, are you?"

"Yes, Gamo, we are leaving," I replied and gently handed him the keys.

He nodded, then said softly, "There is no need for me to look at the other
rooms; I know everything is in order," and holding his granddaughter’s hand
walked out of the kitchen.

As Murad and I walked down the stairs for the very last time, with our
friends in front of us, and Gamo and his granddaughter behind us, I thought
about the various people that had knocked on our door-the man from the
electric company; the neighbor who sometimes stopped by with our mail; the
matzoon lady; the AMA staff members; some of our students; the man who asked
us to help him build a home for his family; the woman who asked if we could
invest in her business idea-a massage therapy center for disabled children;
the grandmother who pleaded for help for her family; the young woman who
wanted to know how to go to America. And I thought about the friends we had
made, as well as our landlord and his family.

Arriving at our third home in Gyumri, I wondered what life was going to be
like in a convent and orphanage. No doubt, it would be quite different from
living in a house with a family and living in an apartment on our own. As
the Center gates shut behind us, and we were greeted by Sister Arousiag, the
Superior and a couple of other nuns, with our suitcases in hand, we entered
the world of prayer and meditation, the world of orphaned, poor and
abandoned children, the place where abused women and the impoverished came
knocking on the door.

"This is your room," announced the Sisters warmly, and then said before they
left, "If you need anything, please let us know." Lining our suitcases
against the wall, I stepped over to the window, just a couple of feet away,
and pulled back the curtains. The window to the bedroom we would now call
home for the remainder of our stay in this city had bars on it. From this
window I could not see the outside world anymore, only a wall and a pretty
garden.

To be continued.

http://www.ar

Generous Donor Challenges ATP to Raise $500,000 by End of 2007

ARMENIA TREE PROJECT
65 Main Street
Watertown, MA 02472
Toll Free: (866) 965-TREE
Email: [email protected]
Web:

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
October 9, 2007

Generous Donor Challenges ATP to Raise $500,000 by End of 2007

— Harry T. Mangurian, Jr. Foundation Will Match Donations Received

WATERTOWN, MA–Armenia Tree Project (ATP) is proud to announce that Harry T.
Mangurian, Jr. has agreed to match donations made in support of the
organization between September 15 and December 31, 2007.

"The goal of this campaign is one million dollars ($1,000,000). If we raise
$500,000 by December 31, then Mr. Mangurian will give $500,000 from his
foundation," explains Executive Director Jeff Masarjian. "Our programs stir
people’s passions and energy, and we are thrilled that this wonderful offer
will allow us to increase our planting of new trees. We need everyone’s help
to meet the challenge."

A second generation Armenian-American, Mr. Mangurian became familiar with
ATP only last year and in a very short period of time began supporting the
organization’s effort to expand the number of donors contributing to ATP. He
helped to create a unique mail appeal with photographs of ATP’s work and a
20 dram Armenian coin–symbolizing ATP’s program to purchase tree seedlings
grown by families in the Getik River Valley. A record number of new donors
responded to that appeal at an introductory level.

"We still have a long way to go to reach our 2007 tree planting objectives,"
states Masarjian. "This spring, ATP planted the first 20,000 trees at the
new Hrant Dink Memorial Forest near our Mirak Family Reforestation Nursery
in northern Armenia. Our goal is to plant the remaining 33,000 trees this
fall to create a lasting tribute to this noble Armenian who was killed this
past January in a tragic criminal act."

In addition to this memorial project, ATP will plant another 350,000 trees
this fall at dozens of urban and rural sites around the country. Since 1994,
ATP has planted and restored more than 1.5 million trees and created
hundreds of jobs for impoverished Armenians in tree-regeneration programs.
The organization’s three tiered initiatives are tree planting, community
development to reduce poverty and promote self-sufficiency, and
environmental education to protect Armenia’s precious natural resources.

Some of the impacts of deforestation include degraded farmland, depleted
water supplies, climate change, loss of wildlife habitat, and poor air
quality. ATP is working on an increasingly larger scale to reverse the
tragic loss of forests in Armenia, which went from covering 25 percent of
the land at the turn of the 20th century to less than eight percent today.

www.armeniatree.org

France Encourages Turkey To Step Up Regional Role

FRANCE ENCOURAGES TURKEY TO STEP UP REGIONAL ROLE

Ya Libnan, Lebanon
Oct 5 2007

France backs a strong Turkish role in resolving Middle East issues
such as the turmoil in Iraq, the dispute over Iran’s nuclear program,
the instability in Lebanon and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict,
Foreign Minister Bernard Kouchner said Friday.

Kouchner, pictured right, staring a one-day visit to Turkey, said
Paris wants to mend fences with Ankara But has not made up its mind
on whether this mainly Muslim country should join the European Union.

"We have recently gone through a difficult period in our relations
with Turkey … My visit reflects our common desire to give a strong
new impetus to our relations and start a period of normalization of
our ties," Kouchner said in an interview with the Milliyet newspaper.

Kouchner is the highest-level French official to visit Ankara since
Nicolas Sarkozy, a staunch opponent of Turkey’s EU bid, was elected
president in May.

Kouchner was to meet his Turkish counterpart Ali Babacan, President
Abdullah Gul and Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan before wrapping
up his visit late Friday.

Sarkozy is opposed to Turkey’s EU membership, arguing that most of
its territory is in Asia and that the idea of a united Europe would
be diluted if its borders stretch that far. Instead he had proposed
a close EU partnership agreement.

He recently appeared to have softened his stance, however, saying
France would not block Turkey’s membership talks.

Sarkozy told Erdogan on the sidelines of the U.N. General Assembly in
New York last month that such negotiations would lead to closer bonds
between Turkey and the EU "even though we disagree on the ultimate
goal of these talks," Kouchner told Milliyet.

"Therefore, everything is open-ended today," he said, adding that a
debate on the future of Europe was also needed.

Ankara has slammed Sarkozy’s stance, insisting that full membership
is the only objective of the talks.

Turkey conducted far-reaching reforms to win the green light for
accession talks in October 2005,despite strong opposition in European
public opinion, notably in France.

Last year, its bid took a serious blow as the EU suspended talks
in eight of the 35 policy areas that candidates must negotiate in
response to Ankara’s refusal to grant trade privileges to Cyprus.

Kouchner said France wants to cooperate with Turkey in energy and
would discuss its opposition to the participation of Gaz de France
(GDF) in the Nabucco pipeline project to carry natural gas from the
Middle East and Central Asia to the EU via Turkey and the Balkans.

"This is a very important issue for France and I hope for speedy
progress," he said.

The Turkish gas company BOTAS is reportedly blocking GDF’s inclusion
in the project in retaliation for a French bill adopted in October
2006 calling for jail sentences for those who deny that Ottoman Turks
committed genocide against Armenians during World War I.

Turkey had threatened unspecified measures against the bill, which
followed a 2001 resolution by the French parliament recognizing the
killings as genocide that had already poisoned bilateral ties.

Turk President Urges Change In Identity Law

TURK PRESIDENT URGES CHANGE IN IDENTITY LAW

Morning Star
October 4, 2007 Thursday

Turkish President Abdullah Gul said on Wednesday that there were
problems with a contentious law that makes it a crime to insult
Turkish identity and it needed to be changed.

Nobel-winning author Orhan Pamuk and murdered ethnic Armenian
journalist Hrant Dink were among those prosecuted under the law.

So far, Turkey’s government resisted those calls.

"We know there are problems with regard to article 301," Mr Gul told
journalists at the Council of Europe. "I support the idea of article
301 to change."

He told parliamentarians that an "unfair perception" prevailed that
people were imprisoned because of article 301 and he insisted there
was freedom of speech in Turkey.