Author: Nahapetian Zhanna
Any encroachment of adversary being immediately neutralized-defense minister comments on border situation
Armenia’s defense minister Davit Tonoyan says the situation in the Artsakh-Azerbaijan line of contact and the Nakhijevan section of the Armenia-Azerbaijan border is calm.
“At the moment the situation in Artsakh and the Nakhijevan section of the Armenian-Azerbaijani border is relatively calm”, the defense minister told reporters at the Monte Melkonyan Military-Sports College.
Minister Tonoyan also assured that any encroachment of the adversary is being immediately neutralized.
Asbarez: Kocharian’s Attorneys Say He is Innocent
Former president Robert Kocharian’s attorney from left Ruben Sahakyan and Aram Orbelyan and his spokesperson Viktor Soghomonyan during a press conference on Saturday
YEREVAN—Attorneys for former president Robert Kocharian, who was arrested and remanded into custody Friday on charges of breaching Armenia’s Constitutional order, said during a press conference on Saturday at Erebuni Plaza that their client was innocent and the case against him does not make sense.
One of his attorneys, Ruben Sahakyan said during the press conference that the case against Kocharian was “legally illiterate,” adding that it was a directive. He, however, did not elaborate as to from where the so-called directive was emanating.
“It was clear that this was a directive that needed to be carried out,” Sahakyab said. “Who is the directive from? Naturally, I can’t say. I can assume, [but] to voice [it]—no. I believe the [real] culprits can be found the Prosecutor General’s Office, [and] the Armenia’s Special Inestigative Service.”
Another attorney, Aram Orbelyan, said the criminal case launched against Kocharian is not well developed.
“We cannot understand the charges brought against Kocharian. The material presented [to us] contain no proof. I am unable to understand the charge, there are some facts, then comes the Article 300.1 [breaching the constitutional order]. I cannot understand the specifics of the criminal offense so that we can defend or not to defend him. I cannot understand whether he is accused of using the army or declaring state of emergency. There is no concrete charge for us to assess whether it is a crime or not,”,Orbelyan said adding that the entire process is illegal.
Viktor Soghomonyan, Kocharian’s spokesperson said that the former president would be released soon.
“We haven’t committed any wrongdoing, Kocharyan has no sense of guilt. He returned to Armenia with a clear conscience, he didn’t avoid any of the processes,” said Soghomonyan.
Kocharian was called into the SIS for questioning on Thursday and when he showed up he was officially charged with colluding with others to breach Armenia’s Constitutional order. After a lengthy arraignment hearing Friday, he was arrested and remanded into pre-trial custody, where he will remain for two months.
In an unprecedented interview with Yerkir Media on Thursday Kocharian vowed that he will fight the charges “to the end,” calling them a politically motivated “vendetta.”
“I will go. I will sit [in jail] but I will fight this until the end,” a visibly shaken Kocharian told Yerkir Media’s Gegham Manoukyan in an exclusive interview that aired on the channel Thursday evening.
During the more than 47-minute interview, during which he continuously repeated himself, Kocharian called the charges a “political vendetta” by the current regime, saying “they have already determined who the guilty parties are and are searching for ways to make the charges stick.”
“When I see that people are skilled at inventing such fabrications, I realize that for them nothing is sacred. They are capable of anything,” said Kocharian who called the entire episode “judicial surrealism” and warned that it will have a lasting impact on Armenia and its judiciary.
Also charged with “breach of Constitutional Order” was Yuri Khachaturov, who during the March 1 events was head of the internal security forces, and currently serves as the executive director of the Collective Security Treaty Organization—the post-Soviet regional security group, of which Armenia is a member.
Khachaturov was also arrested Friday. He was released after posting a 5 million dram (approximately $10,000) bail.
Earlier this month, the SIS charged Armenia’s Defense Minister at the time Mikael Harutiunyan with the same offense.
On July 3, SIS charged that on February 23, 2008, Harutiunyan secretly and illegally ordered the army to help enforce the official vote results. Military units began moving in to Yerevan in the following days and were actively engaged in the ensuing crackdown that resulted in the 10 deaths.
The SIS statement at the time said that the “de facto martial law” regime created by the deployment of the army violated constitutional provisions guaranteeing the military’s neutrality.
“A number of high-ranking officials of the acting authorities, including Defense Minister Mikael Harutiunyan, carried out actions aimed at violently breaching the constitutional order in the Republic of Armenia,” read the SIS statement based on which the charges were brought against the 72-year-old Harutiunyan, who served as the Armed Forces chief of staff from 1994 to 2007, before being named defense minister by Kocharian.
Armenia might not endure “temptation” to use entire available arsenal in the event of Azerbaijani attack, says defense minister
Armenia’s defense minister Davit Tonoyan says he is especially concerned over the activation of Azerbaijani armed forces in the Nakhijevan direction of the Armenia-Azerbaijan border, where a relative calm existed until now.
“Any manifestation of military provocation in this section is fraught with incitement of crisis, which will also relate to other regional actors,” Tonoyan said during an interview with EADaily.
At the same time, Tonoyan emphasized that Armenia is not in a status of peace requester and that it might not endure the temptation of using its entire military arsenal in an event of an Azerbaijan aggression.
“Along with Armenia’s constructive stance, I wouldn’t want you to have an impression that Armenia is in a position of a peace requestor. I would advise the Azerbaijani side not to be so certain that it is the one controlling the issue of escalating the military situation. Meaning it will not be the way that mediators will succeed in convincing the Armenian side to stop response-punitive actions in an event of Azerbaijan re-launching military operations, even in an event if limited scale military operations carried out by Baku. In an event of a repetition of the 2016 April War aggression scenario the Armenian side might not refrain from the temptation of using its entire available arsenal to give a massive and decisive counter-blow to the adversary,” Tonoyan said.
Speaking about the dangers of new large scale military operations and Azerbaijani build-ups of manpower and military equipment along the Artsakh-Azerbaijan line of contact, the Armenian defense minister said that the likelihood of resumption of large scale military operations is always high in conditions of Baku’s maximalist demands during negotiations.
“Reports about the activation and build-ups of Azerbaijani military are accurate and similar processes are observed not only at the Artsakh-Azerbaijan line of contact, but also at the Armenia-Azerbaijan border, namely in the Nakhijevan direction. Azerbaijan’s conduct is nothing else but threat to use force, whereas it is the ruling out of the use of force that is the basis of the peaceful settlement process of the NK conflict, like of any other conflict,” he said.
Artsakh’s international scientific integration is very important
Prominent physicists from around the world gathered in Artsakh to discuss the recent achievements and developments in the broad field of quantum condensed matter physics. Around 50 experts from over 10 countries had applied for participation in the international conference entitled “New Trends in Quantum and Mesoscopic Physics”, held in Stepanakert from June 28 to July 2. The conference was proposed by a well-known specialist, professor Alexei Kavokin of the University of Southampton and Saint Petersburg State University.
In an exclusive interview to Mediamax Alexei Kavokin told about results of the conference and possible ways of developing science in Artsakh.
How did the idea of holding a conference on Quantum and Mesoscopic Physics in Artsakh come about?
With my colleagues from the Mediterranean Institute of Fundamental Physics and the Quantum College of Yerevan, we are frequently organizing scientific events (international conferences or schools) in Armenia, mostly in Tsakhadzor. Last year, I have been awarded by the Honorary Professorship from the Russian-Armenian University. Some of my colleagues from Italy, UK, France and Russia came to the ceremony. Then we went to Tsakhadzor for an international school.
During one of the round-tables in Tsakhadzor, the idea of a large scale international conference in Artsakh has been born. It originated from Dr. Kamo Atayan, who knows Artsakh very well, and Professor Hayk Sargsyan from the Russian-Armenian University. I was more than happy to support this idea. We have immediately formed an international Program committee and started the work. It was a significant challenge to organize a high-level conference on “New trends in Quantum and Mesoscopic Physics” having just 6 months for the whole preparation work. The enthusiastic and dedicated effort from many colleagues in Artsakh, Armenia and Russia made it possible.
Had you been in Artsakh before the conference? How did you learn about the country?
My first visit to Artsakh was in 1998. I knew about it very well: by my mother’s (Nina Madatova) side my family comes from Artsakh. The legends of this beautiful land and its history were always alive in our family. I have visited Artsakh again about 5 years ago, then in April this year, when we started the work on the organization of the International conference.
I had a privilege to meet remarkable people in Artsakh, and all of them were glad to help!
All together, we realized this little miracle, and I am very proud of it.
Are you acquainted with the level of science, in particular physics in Artsakh?
I have visited the University of Stepanakert and one of the schools specialized in physics and mathematics there. I had many meetings with the researchers and physics teachers working in Artsakh. I believe, there are many talented people in this country, and some disciplines of physics, in particular, theoretical physics, should flourish there. A better international integration is needed to allow talented young physicists from Artsakh to take part in major international projects.
What is the role of similar conferences in the development of science in Artsakh?
The role of prestigious international conferences is hard to overestimate. For the local scientific community it is a unique opportunity to meet and start collaborating with world-leading scientists. For the world-leading scientists this is a unique chance to visit Artsakh and see by their own eyes how quickly this country develops.
The conference gathered a number of international scientists. What are their impressions about Artsakh and the development level of science in the country?
As far as I know, everyone remained deeply impressed with what we have seen in Artsakh, with the beauty of the country, the hospitality of its talented people. It has been an unusual conference: a lot of time was dedicated to the cultural and social events, excursions, informal meetings and discussions. My colleagues enjoyed this, and I am confident that they will keep very good memories of this unique event.
Trainings for school teachers of physics have also been organized during the conference. What kind of trainings were those and what knowledge did the teachers acquire?
We have brought to Artsakh a group of physics teachers from several famous schools specialized in physics and mathematics. The Director of the Physical-Technical school of St-Petersburg delivered a very impressive master-class. The physics teachers from the Presidential lyceum N 239 that is the highest ranked school of Russia and from the internationally famous Quantum college of Yerevan gave lectures for the school teachers. Also, several active researchers, including myself, gave talks for the teachers. And many teachers attended also the purely research sessions of the conference. I believe, it is very important for the communities of teachers and researchers to come together on a regular basis, to exchange ideas, to discuss new methods of teaching physics at school.
Photo: Minister of Education, science and sport of Artsakh
How would you generally assess the work and results of this conference?
I believe, it has been a stunning success. So many high-level physicist and talented teachers took part in this conference! It was a challenging project, not easy to organize, but it has been crowned with an impressive success. The international resonance of the meeting is very significant. Azerbaijan has already threatened to put all its participants on a “black list”. I must say, I am proud of being in this “black list”, this certifies that my work and the work of my colleagues was not in vain!
In your view, what are the best ways of developing science in Artsakh?
The international integration is one of the best ways, in my opinion. This may go through the organization of regular international scientific events, schools and research meetings. It would be great to attract a few internationally recognized Armenian scholars for a part- or full-time work at the University of Stepanakert. This would motivate the students to remain in their country and help building new labs and research centers in Artsakh.
Do you consider further cooperation with Artsakh and what would be your contribution in the country’s mission of keeping up with international scientific developments?
I would be most glad to come back with new projects, new international events and new ideas. On the way back to Yerevan, we were discussing an opportunity of the organization of a new large scale international event, probably in a format of the International school on New Trends in Physics. It would be organized for a wide international audience of Master and Bachelor students, PhD students, physics teachers. The speakers would be world-leading experts in different branches of modern physics and prominent professors of the best high schools. I believe, we shall be able to organize such an event by April 2020, if everything goes well.
Marie Taryan talked to Alexey Kavokin
Agreement with EU to create favorable environment for development of Armenia-Poland ties – Ambassador Ghazaryan
YEREVAN, JULY 3, ARMENPRESS. The ratification of the Armenia-EU Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement (CEPA) both at Poland’s Sejm and Senate took place in an atmosphere of complete solidarity and unity, Edgar Ghazaryan – Armenia’s Ambassador to Poland, said in an interview to ARMENPRESS.
-Mr. Ambassador, on June 7 the Polish Sejm, and on June 29 the Senate ratified the Armenia-EU Comprehensive and Enhanced Partnership Agreement. What further processes are expected in this regard?
-First of all, I want to highlight an important factor that the ratification of the agreement both at Poland’s Sejm and Senate took place in an atmosphere of complete solidarity and unity. In particular, 429 MPs in the Sejm have voted in favor of the agreement (0 against, 1 abstained), and in the Senate the agreement has been adopted unanimously with 83 votes in favor. According to the Polish legislation, the final ratification of the agreement also supposes its signing by the President of the country. I think it will not late, and that important process will be completed soon in Poland.
-After signing the CEPA the Armenian foreign ministry’s leadership stated that this step opens new page in the Armenia-EU relations. In your opinion, what opportunities can this agreement provide to Armenia?
-The comment made by the Armenian foreign ministry, as you mentioned, already highlights the importance of that document, therefore, nothing can be added to that. I think it can be very useful not only in the Armenia-EU relations, but also in Armenia’s bilateral relations with the EU member states.
-What role Poland can play in this context, given the fact that the existing cooperation between Armenia and Poland continues growing?
-Firstly, Poland played a great role from the very start since it is one of the countries that initiated the EU’s Eastern Partnership program. Poland always acts not only from the positions on strengthening and developing the EU, but also significantly contributes to the development of cooperation with the EU and other countries. The relations between Armenia and Poland have always been at the high level. I am confident that the CEPA will create new, more favorable environment for development of bilateral relations between our two countries in different sectors.
Full interview is available in Armenian.
Interview by Anna Gziryan
Edited and translated by Aneta Harutyunyan
Ministry of Diaspora of RA, Zareh Sinanian
-- Please find the attached press release of the Ministry of Diaspora. Sincerely, DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION AND TELECOMMUNICATION (+374 10) 585601, internal 807
JPEG image
Zareh_Sinanyan.docx
application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document
Armenian Governments Takes up Fight Against Corruption and Organized Crime
National security chief vows more revelations in anti-corruption sweep
Head of the National Security Service (NSS) of Armenia Arthur Vanetsyan vows to make new corruption-related revelations.
Reporters spoke to Vanetsyan during today’s Cabinet meeting about the probe into the Yerevan City supermarket chain. Yerevan City is owned by the family of MP Samvel Alexanyan.
Reporters argued that the revelations in Yerevan City supermarket aren’t that much of revelations because the scheme had happened with an agreement with the State Revenue Service (SRC). Vanetsyan responded: “People who’ve acted illegally for many years can say many things. They even manipulated the 350 figure, however the figure exceeded 460. While the number of organizations, which are yet to be questioned, will reach 1000 or more,” he said.
Asked if there is a need to question former SRC chief Vardan Harutyunyan, the NSS director said the investigation will show.
Earlier the NSS had questioned two former vice presidents of the SRC in connection with an alleged corruption scheme involving a customs clearance brokerage firm – Norfolk Consulting. The NSS says the company’s illegal revenues might total nearly 7 million dollars for just 9 months of activities.
A few days ago the NSS carried out inspections in the Yerevan City supermarket chain. The NSS said it has discovered an illicit scheme which the chain used for a lengthy period of time. The mechanism used fraudulent tax records using fake companies under the names of hundreds of unaware citizens.
The NSS says that Alex Holding, the parent company of Yerevan City, had conspired with the former leadership of the State Revenue Committee to use a scheme to pay only 2% circulation tax instead of 20% VAT and income tax.
According to the NSS, Alex Holding had registered more than 461 private entrepreneurship accounts under the names of its personnel and their acquaintances, who were used to be engaged in the scheme.
According to preliminary estimates, the total sales of the 461 accounts totaled more than 40 billion drams.
Armenian public debt "frozen" at around $ 6.9 billion by May 2018
Yerevan June 01
Karina Melikyan. The state debt of Armenia, demonstrating a monthly growth of 1.5% in the first quarter of 2018, declined only slightly (by 0.3%) in April, which “delayed” it at $ 6.9 bln. In the annual cut (in April 2018 by April 2017), the state debt of Armenia increased by 14.2%. According to preliminary data of the RA Ministry of Finance, provided by the ArmInfo National Statistical Service, foreign debt increased by 12.2% per annum – up to $ 5.5 billion (2.7 trillion drams), with an annual growth of domestic debt by 8.3% to $ 1.3 billion (644.5 billion AMD).
On a monthly basis, external debt, after rising 1.8% in the first quarter of 2018, declined in April, and domestic debt continued to grow, a total of 4.2% in January-April.
By way of comparison, in April 2017, by April 2016, the growth of the external debt by 8.9% and domestic debt by 50% increased the total state debt of Armenia by 14%. Only in January April 2017, external debt grew by 2.1%, domestic debt – by 9.1%, which increased the total national debt by 2.4%. In the structure of external debt 89.1% or $ 4.9 billion accounted for by the government, and the remaining 10.9% or $ 606.1 million – by the Central Bank. And the external debt of the government increased by 14% in April 2018 by April 2017, which is slightly lower than the growth rate of the external debt of the Central Bank by 15.9%, against the more modest growth rates in April 2017 by April 2016 – 8.3% and 6, respectively, 6%. Only in January-April 2018 the government’s external debt increased by 0.8% and the same growth was recorded in the external debt of the Central Bank (against growth of 0.7% and 3.6% a year earlier, respectively). Moreover, the external debt of both the government and the Central Bank, after monthly growth in the I quarter of 2018, in April showed a decline – by 0.7% and 0.8%, respectively, while a year earlier in January-April both the government and the Central Bank monthly increased external debt.
In the structure of the domestic state debt, government bonds dominate, in April 2018 the share was 87.9% ($ 1.2 billion or 567 billion AMD), with an annual growth of absolute value of 9.1%. Then followed the Armenian Eurobonds – $ 151.3 million or 73.1 billion AMD, which accounted for 11.3%, with an annual increase in the absolute value of 24.7%. The rest is covered by guarantees – 0.8% ($ 9 million), with an annual unchanged. Only for January-April 2018 domestic debt on government bonds increased by 9.1%, and on eurobonds, on the contrary, fell by 2.5%. A year earlier, in April 2017, government bonds accounted for 89% of the internal state debt structure, with an annual increase in the absolute value of 57.1%, followed by Eurobonds – 10.2%, with an annual increase in absolute value of 42.4%, and the share guarantees was 0.8%, with an annual increase in the absolute value of 7.1 times.
To note, according to the World Bank’s updated forecasts in May, the share of Armenia’s state debt in GDP is expected to be at 58.6%, with a slight decrease to 58.3% in 2019. On the economic growth of Armenia, the World Bank has improved its forecast for 2018 from the previous 3.8% to the current 4.1%, and by 2019, the growth expectations have been kept at 4%.
To note, Armenia’s state debt increased by 15.3% to $ 6.8 billion (3.3 trillion AMD) in 2017 due to the growth of external debt by 14.6% to $ 5.5 billion (2.7 trillion AMD) and the growth of domestic debt by 18.2% to $ 1.3 billion (619.5 billion AMD). By way of comparison, we note that for 2016, the growth of the external debt by 11.6% and domestic debt by 49% increased the total state debt of Armenia by 17%. The growing national debt and continuing migration in Armenia have already deepened the specific debt load per capita to $ 2.3 thousand by January 1, 2018, of which over $ 1.8 thousand comes from external debt, against $ 2 thousand and $ 1.6 thousand, respectively, by January 1, 2017. Taking into account the real scale of migration, the burden of public debt per capita would be much higher (according to statistical data as of January 1, 2018, the population of the RA was 2.973 million, against 2.986 million a year earlier and 3.274 million five years earlier). In 2017, the degree of coverage of external debt with gold and foreign exchange reserves decreased from 45.9% to 39.6% amid a significant increase in external debt, with a meager decline in reserves. The share of national debt in Armenia’s GDP reached 58.8% by the end of 2017, against 56.6% in 2016.