We knew for sure – they came to kill us: Ishkhan Trdatov survived the horror of the genocide in Sumgait

We knew for sure – they came to kill us: Ishkhan Trdatov survived the horror of the genocide in Sumgait

Save

Share

16:01, 9 March, 2019

Ishkhan Trdatov is one of the 18 thousand of Armenians who survived the horror of the genocide in Sumgait. Besides this, he is a true hero – someone who fought back against the members of the pogrom mobs along with his neighbors for more than 6 hours. They were able to protect their families, rescue their children. Despite this, what they have witnessed 31 years ago does not let go from them, fails to be forgotten…
Today Ishkhan presents the story to us the way it has happened…

“Before the events in the morning we, together with my wife and two sons, were going to my brothers’ at 2 o’clock in the afternoon. We were just leaving home, when Aydin’s wife, an Azerbaijani woman came to us: “I beg you, do not go Ishkhan. I know you and your wife very well. Do not go out of the neighborhood. If you do, they will kill you. They have already started to kill.

Everything started on the 27th, you know, I think Sumgait was targeted purposefully. The first attempt was planned to be in Kirovabad where an entire city block was inhabited by the Armenians and nothing could be done there, and when they came to Sumgait it was just what they wanted.

About 18 thousand Armenians lived there, but they all lived scattered; 2 or 3 Armenian families in one building. Before they broke into our entrance, they went to 5th flat right in front of our building. We saw what was going on there… They took Cherkez Grigoryan out of the house from the 1st flat, beat her, left her lying next to the entrance and went upstairs. That’s when I told my father to get an axe immediately. He was a carpenter but there were two axes at home.

When they walked into the entrance, we saw a crowd with an impressive number of people – they wouldn’t fit in the entrance all at once. There were about 200-300 people outdoors as well. They were also many children and teenagers from 12-14 years of age and even children. Most of them were natives – I could tell from the conversations.

Those who were not able to get to the entrance were throwing stones at the windows of all Armenian flats. I had never seen such kind of stones in our city and I assume it was brought beforehand. … There was an arbor in front of our house, and a free space, you could pass –that’s where they were spilling the stones brought from the production zone of Sumgait Pipe Rolling Plant.

What happened in the neighboring 4th, 5th and 6th flats was something terrible.
After that, they made it to our entrance. The first thing I heard was someone screaming that Armenians live in the 12th and 8th flats.
Our flat was the 6th and the 12th flat belonged to the Huseynovs. I had an instant thought – maybe we’ll be lucky?

Me and my father beat the first attack back and made them ran off to the 1st floor. My wife Elmira threw a mix of pepper and salt into their eyes when they barged the 2nd time and it made them go back another time.

After some time our upstairs neighbors – Raffik Tovmasyan and his father-in-law Hrant Adamyan joined us. Thus we were already 4 men. By that time I was able move wife with children to the neighbor’s house. 
Every 20-25 minutes 2-3 people came upstairs in order to break into our flat. My dad, mom and I were able to hold them back together. Then they tried to squeeze through from our balconies. I can still totally picture the moment when I saw someone’s hand with an axe on the handrail. I hit him with the axe and he fell of screaming. I heard voices from the street saying I was a monster and that they will burn me alive but before that they will burn my children in front of me, rape my wife and burn me later. It was something horrible. Yes, and I say, get to me to start with…But in the end, of course, it was all horrible…

There was no doubt that they will kill us. Either we kill them, or they will. I had only one thought – I have to protect my family and that’s all.

Surprisingly our telephones were not turned off as it happened to most Armenians in Sumgait then. And we called wherever we could – both the police and the ambulance…“Flashes are all over the city, we cannot promise you anything. We will come as soon as we are free”, the police told us. I mean, they did not refuse directly, but it was clear that they will not come as I saw a few policemen through the window standing by the crowd. They were just standing and watching.

About 2-2.5 hours later I saw a few people going up again but this time leading naked woman in front of them. I recognized her – it was Sveta Grigoryan, Volodya Grigroyan’s wife. All her body was covered with traces of cigarette butts. They smoked the cigarettes and doused them on her body, do you get it? She came to our door and asked to let her in. I told her I can’t do it because if I do so, the ones following her will break into our house. She turned and went back. Then we heard her heart-rending screams from the street.

Then we heard some noise. My father told me they’re breaking over here through the wall. Thus they were not able to break into the entrance and the balcony but they had to think of something else, they had to get to us. Me and dad went to our bedroom, ripped the carpet on the wall and saw a hole at about 80 cm distances from the floor and suddenly a scrap popped out. But the wall was really solid and they did that little aperture for almost 1 hour. I think it was 20 x 40 in size.

Actually they were able to pull out a brick from the wall by that hole. I heard something gurgling and pouring into the flat. I couldn’t smell it as my nose was broken. My father ordered to go away from the wall and as soon as I moved they threw a match from the hole. Everything was burnt down – they poured petrol.

We had a bath full of water and my mom started pouring it out immediately. But I caught some fire. It harmed my face. I didn’t have any scars before. All of the scars are from Sumgait – 16 scars on my face, head and legs…

When the fire broke out they called the Fire department. Instead of helping us, they put the stairs on the wall pointing to the roof in order to get to us from the 5th floor. No one risked climbing – all of them knew that they’ll get hurt.

In the meantime I sent my mom to the neighbors. By 11pm it was just 4 of us, 4 men – me, Rafik Tovmasyan and Hrant Adamyan. There was no doubt – they wanted to kill us. They continued going up and down but couldn’t come up from the 2nd floor using the entrance doors to shelter behind and threw them at our staircase when running back.

I had about 40 liters of diesel oil in the balcony which I poured into everything they threw at the staircase and lit them up. This way we blocked their road. That’s the reason they called a fire truck

At the same time they came up with ultimatums saying they have already burnt my neighbor from the 2nd floor and will do the same with me. Besides this, they told me they have burnt a young boy and killed his father and that all of this is waiting for me and my father. I figured it was Arthur Aramyan who was living on the 2nd floor.

What happened during these 6 hours cannot be described or be forgotten. I was all in blood. Then they started throwing bricks, the ones I mentioned before, at our windows. Those were not ordinary stones – they were mixed with an iron. One of those hit me on the face and broke my teeth literally breaking into 2 pieces. I fainted.

Regained consciousness and felt that the floor was wet. I’m lying face down, I remember, there were some blankets and mattresses above me. Wanted to stand up but couldn’t even move. No voices around me, no sound, just a deathly silence. I was trying to understand what was going on with me, maybe I was even dead. Then somehow I came out the matrasses and blankets and went straight to the 5th flat. I still had an axe in my hand. I hit the door with it a few times and shouted: “Shovkat, Shovkat”. That was the name of my neighbor.

It turns out Elmira, my wife, was there with children but did not hear anything. My neighbor had covered them under blankets and other clothes leaving them alone and they stayed there till the morning.

It was the night of the 28th of February. I went up to the 5th floor where my mom was hiding. The neighbor opened the door, looked at me surprised and asked, ““How is it, are you alive?”. She was a Talysh from Lenkoran. I said, “As you can see, I am”. She told me to drop the axe and come in. I followed her. She called the police. And she called the police. Here came the military and the police chief. I started yelling at them saying, “You, jerk, I’ll get the axe and kill you!”.

The Colonel tried to calm me down and explained, “They gave us the order too late”. This means the military was in the city as well but didn’t have any order to be involved in anything.

Both I and my mother were taken to the hospital. My mother was bandaged in the head in the hospital; from there she went to my brother barefoot. You know, what’s that, it was about 4 o’clock in the morning.

The neurosurgeon who operated on me told me that 20 years later I will realize the consequences these events had on me. Turned out he was right – it’s already 10 years that I have problems with my health.

Then I got to know that my father and Rafik were both killed – they were taken outside and murdered there. No one told me about it at first. My father’s head was severed by an axe. He died in the hospital, they say.

My uncle took my father from morgue. He then told me that he saw many bodies and most of them in a horrible state.

Our flat was burnt down, everything was stolen, was caused a damage of 28 thousand rubles but we did not receive a single penny despite the fact that I had the decision preceded by the USSR prosecutor’s office. Not like here, the Turks received all after the earthquake, all that they needed. But what was done with the Armenians, no one paid that money, didn’t even thought of it.

They initiated criminal proceedings but the trial didn’t take place. No one was punished.

They say time wounds heal. But that’s not true. It’s been more than 30 years now but I remember even the small details. Sometimes it seems like everything happened yesterday…

Azerbaijani Press: What will they talk about, if there is nothing to talk?

Turan Information Agency, Azerbaijani Opposition Press
March 1, 2019 Friday
What will they talk about, if there is nothing to talk?
 
by Kamal Ali
 
 
The OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs announced the consent of the leaders of Azerbaijan and Armenia to hold a new meeting. A day earlier, Armenian Prime Minister N. Pashinyan declared his desire to meet with I. Aliyev in Iran. We will turn to Pashinyan’s Iranian speech later. Now let’s ask ourselves: Pashinyan told the Armenian community of Iran that “the time has come to make dreams come true … we together are one on the way to achieving our dreams, such as economic opportunities of Armenia, the realization of the just demands of the people of Artsakh, the realization of our dreams.” Then, reporting on his intention to meet with I.Aliyev, added that there is no agenda for the future meeting.
 
In a statement dated March 1, the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs Igor Popov, Stefan Visconti and Andrew Chaufer reported that they had met with Pashinyan and Aliyev on February 20-21. “The co-chairs positively assessed the continued absence of victims on the line of contact. They also welcomed the developing discussions in the region about preparing the population for peace,” Turan reported.
 
Now the main point: are there really discussions in the region about preparing people for peace?
 
The only one who spoke about preparations for peace in Azerbaijan is the director of the NGO Society for Humanitarian Research (Baku) Avaz Hasanov, whose initiative was not welcomed by his antagonist, the Karabakh Liberation Committee, together with their many supporters. The attacks on Hasanov in social networks were full of obscene expressions. There were not peace-loving speeches by officials Azerbaijan; on the contrary, representatives of the Foreign Ministry and the Presidential Administration of Azerbaijan gave very sharp answer to every reactionary statement of the Armenian side.
 
As for the actions, the Azerbaijani peacefulness towards the enemy was reflected in a significant reduction in attacks from the Azerbaijani side. The withdrawal of the army from the western borders, which are now guarded by our border guards. The termination of work of snipers. Establishment of a communication line between representatives of President I.Aliyev and Prime Minister N.Pashinyan. Because of these measures of the Azerbaijani command, the rare casualties in the manpower of the Armenian army are explained by the low discipline and military skills of military personnel.
 
Now about the so-called “peace loving and preparing the Armenian population for peace.” In February of this year, Armenian Defense Minister David Tonoyan announced the transition of the Armenian army to the offensive tactics of waging a possible war with Azerbaijan, with the aim of destroying combat positions and infrastructure in the depths of the Azerbaijani defense at a distance of up to 100 km. For this, Armenia buys SU combat aircrafts in Russia, equalizing the capabilities of the air forces of the opposing armies. There were two sensational statements by Tonoyan on the transition of Armenia from defensive to offensive tactics. Official Yerevan makes it clear that hopes for a peaceful settlement, in which the areas around Karabakh will be returned to Azerbaijan, have failed.
 
The information about the intention to purchase 12 Russian Su-30SM fighters became an effective reinforcement of the new intention of Tonoyan.
 
The first four cars will arrive in Armenia at the end of 2019 – the beginning of 2020.
 
Then, after the Azerbaijani satellite photographed and distributed the photographs about facilities under construction in the occupied territories, Director of the National Security Service Arthur Vanetsyan, who visited Karabakh, said that Armenian settlers should live in Jabrail-Fizuli and southern Karabakh regions. “The statements of individuals that the land will be donated, will negotiate on this subject, are refuted by this settlement program. We thereby send a clear message to the Armenian people and the world that no one will surrender land. On the contrary, our compatriots should live in our territories, live and build up,” Vanetsyan quotes” Sputnik Armenia. “According to Armenian media, the purpose of the visit was to discuss the issues of settling the territory along the Araz River (Araks).
 
The article can cite numerous Armenian public figures, deputies and politicians who call on Armenia to take radical action against Azerbaijan. The executor of their will is Pashinyan’s “peace-lover”, who demands the involvement of the unrecognized regime in negotiations on the fate of Karabakh and completely rejects the participation of the Azerbaijani community of Karabakh in the same negotiations. For this, a logical (at first glance!) Conception of the absence of Pashinyan”s legitimate right to represent the Karabakh Armenians who did not elect him was thought up in Yerevan, while Azerbaijani refugees participated in the presidential elections, casting ballots for Ilham Aliyev. Speaking in Iran at a meeting with the Armenian community, Pashinyan stood facing a huge transparency depicting the flag of the illegal Karabakh regime and the inscription “Artsakh is Armenia. That’s all”.
 
Against this bitter reality, the Azerbaijani official propaganda is trumpeting about our economic blockade of Armenia, along with Turkey, the lack of prospects for the development of the enemy, and the underlying readiness of the Armenian people to hand over Karabakh to Azerbaijan. These verses are brought to naught by the fact of economic statistics, according to which in January, when the growth of Azerbaijan”s GDP was “successfully” – three percent, the same indicator in Armenia was six percent.
 
The most realistic assessment of the current situation was given by the British expert on the South Caucasus, the author of the book “Black Garden” Tom de Waal. In a letter to the author of the article, he explained: “The year 2019 in the Karabakh process began in a more positive spirit than it has been for many years. Improvements followed 2018, when only 14 deaths were recorded on the contact line of the armies, which is much better than in many previous years. But we have to be realistic and not trust too high expectations … The peace Karabakh process was almost dead since the meeting at the presidential level in Kazan, in 2011 … (Pashinyan) takes this position in order to “play for a while” … Azerbaijan”s position remains but it has lately softened its attitude on some more minor issues. This was undoubtedly done to give Pashinyan more chances to “weaken him a little” … However, the political positions of both sides remain unchanged. Now it is much more difficult to understand how they can achieve progress on political issues in the near future …”
 
Tom de Waal does not believe that the current generation of politicians will solve the Karabakh problem, since Armenians and Azerbaijanis do not perceive the pain of a neighbor. “Perhaps the next generation will be able to make a step …” – suggests a British analyst.
 
A logical question arises: why did I. Aliyev agree to the fourth meeting with N. Pashinyan, if since the last meeting in Davos (January 2019) Yerevan has much radicalized its attitude to Azerbaijan and negotiations with it, putting the two countries on the verge war?

Owners of restaurants in Yerevan shocked with huge bills for garbage removal service

ARKA, Armenia
March 1 2019

YEREVAN, March 1. /ARKA/. Restaurants in Yerevan have received huge bills for garbage removal in January, Zhamanak reports. According to the media source, owners of catering facilities in Armenia’s capital city are shocked with the received bills, which have tripled in January, compared with December. 

The entrepreneurs asked explanations from the city authorities. They were told that the city council has decided to increase the duty for garbage removal services. 

Zhamanak reports that the size of the population’s payment for the garbage removal service will be increased as well on July 1. -0—

Armenian PM, Chairman of Iranian Majlis see great prospects for developing partnership

Armenian PM, Chairman of Iranian Majlis see great prospects for developing partnership

Save

Share

18:55,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 27, ARMENPRESS.  Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan, who is in Tehran on an official visit, met with Chairman of the Iranian Majlis Ali Larijani.

As ARMENPRESS was informed from the office of the Prime Minister of Armenia, Ali Larijani welcomed the visit of the delegation led by Pashinyan to Iran and expressed confidence that it will foster the future development of economic and political relations between the two states.

Nikol Pashinyan thanked for the warm reception and noted that the last time he visited the Iranian Majlis was when he was part of an Armenian parliamentary delegation and maintains warm and pleasant memories from that visit.

The interlocutors highly assessed the bilateral friendly relations, which continue to develop in an atmosphere of mutual understanding.

The sides considered the necessity of continuous strengthening of economic cooperation and highlighted the expansion of ties between the parliaments of the two countries for that. In this regard, the interlocutors underlined the necessity of the development of relations between the parliaments’ friendship groups, mutual visits, and noted that the cooperation of the legislative bodies also contributes to the further strengthening of Armenian-Iranian relations.

Nikol Pashinyan expressed satisfaction with the results of the meeting with Iranian President Hassan Rouhani, underlining that the Armenian side is interested in implementing the agreements reached, in particular, in the economic sphere, which will give new impetus to bilateral relations.

Ali Larijani stressed that the Iranian parliament is inclined towards expanding relations. According to him, there are great opportunities for developing cooperation both in bilateral and multilateral formats. In this context, the importance of the free trade agreement between EAEU and Iran and the ratification of the document by the parliaments were touched upon. The parties also attached importance to the promotion of cooperation in tourism and culture.

Issues related to regional issues were also discussed during the meeting.

Edited and translated by Tigran Sirekanyan




Karekin II, Aram I Meet with Pashinyan to Discuss ‘National Agenda’

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan greets Catholico Aram I, with Catholicos Karekin II in the background on Feb. 22, 2019

YEREVAN—The Catholicos of the Holy See of Etchmiadzin and the Catholicos of the Great House of Cilicia met with Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan on Friday to discuss what he describes as “a very important mission of establishing a national agenda.”

Pashinyan explained that during his tenure as prime minister he has had several meetings with His Holiness Karekin II, Catholicos of the Holy See of Etchmiadzin, saying that the two have “managed to create a sincere and open atmosphere” to address matters of church and state—specifically touching on an agenda for the nation.

“This particular dialogue is of key importance for the future of our country—for the future of our people—because I think that we have a very important mission to discuss our agenda for the nation and establish a national agenda,” Pashinyan told the two pontiffs.

“We know one thing for sure –we, our people, our church and our religious leaders have a shared appreciation that we will not be defeated and have to overcome all the challenges facing our state, people – the Republic of Armenia, the Republic of Artsakh and the Diaspora. I am confident that such interactions, our relations with the Church and discussions are of decisive and key importance,” added Pashinyan.

Karekin II briefed Pashinyan on the discussions he has had with His Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of the Great House of Cilicia, who arrived in Armenia on Tuesday has been at Holy Etchmiadzin, where the two have held extensive discussions about various problems facing the Armenian Church and attempts to find reasonable solutions for them.

According to Karekin II, Pashinyan has established a working group to address and examine issues concerning the church and state with the aim of finding appropriate solutions to them.

“We also referred to the mission of our Church in our national and spiritual life, highlighting our role for the spiritual and national consolidation of our people, as well as for the progress of our country,” Karekin II said of his meeting with Aram I.

“We emphasized the importance of stability in our country and that the atmosphere of love prevails in our country, as well as how the Armenian Church has always stood with the state whenever we had our independent statehood, and made a contribution to the safe and secure existence of our country. We have had numerous opportunities to emphasize that the Armenian Apostolic Church will continue the same work with the same vigor and enthusiasm, so as to enable our people to overcome all the difficulties with collective efforts, all the problems facing our country and the worldwide Armenian people. Naturally, this goes for the issue of the recognition of Artsakh’s independence, recognition of the Armenian Genocide and the stable, safe progress of our country,” explained Karekin II.

“Your success is the success of our homeland and the success of the homeland is the success of our entire nation, because the Republic of Armenia has some responsibilities beyond its borders toward the Diaspora,” said Aram I adding he anticipated the people’s expectations would be met during Pashinyan’s tenure.

“You set out on this path with that commitment and emphasized in all your public speeches that you come from the people; that the people represent the power and it’s the expectations of the people that must inspire you and the government,” Aram I told Pashinyan.

“Of course, it is necessary to be realistic and not be emotional. My final expectation is that the aspirations and needs of the people are met, and I anticipate that in this process you will be emphasize the benefit and need for diversity,” continued Aram I, explaining his belief that having differing opinions are enriching and inspiring as long those opinions intersect “around our national values and ideals,” said Aram I.

“It’s necessary to avoid polarizations. If there is polarization, then [the sides] must be bridged over the same values. And for this I greatly highlight the role of the Church. I am glad you highlighted the role of the Church in your speech. The Catholicos of All Armenians also said that the Church-State relations, or I would say partnership, is a must for nation building. Naturally, there are different opinions and approaches. As I already said, these differences should become useful, because we are all in the same ring and on the same path,” added Aram I.

Sports: Former Real Madrid manager to arrive in Armenia this summer

Panorama, Armenia
Feb 20 2019
Sport 14:35 20/02/2019 Armenia

Former Spain and Real Madrid head coach Vicente del Bosque will visit Armenia this summer to share his experience with Armenian coaches at the invitation of the Football Federation (FFA) of Armenia.

The visit is part of the FFA-implemented program aimed at improving the quality of coaching education in Armenia, the federation told Panorama.am.

Under Vicente del Bosque, one of the best coaches in the world, Real Madrid won seven trophies including two La Liga titles and two Champions League Finals, while the Spanish national team won the 2010 FIFA World Cup and 2012 European Championship.

On June 18, del Bosque, his long-time assistant Toni Grande, as well as conditioning coach of the Armenian national football team Javier Miñano will deliver a lecture for Armenian coaches.

Bright Armenia Party: Government demonstrates intolerance towards opposition

News.am, Armenia
Feb 14 2019
Bright Armenia Party: Government demonstrates intolerance towards opposition Bright Armenia Party: Government demonstrates intolerance towards opposition

15:53, 14.02.2019
                  

YEREVAN. – Current Armenian government demonstrates intolerance towards the opposition, Bright Armenia Party head Edmon Marukyan said on Thursday in Parliament.

“I am surprised how fast the force which was an opposition becomes so intolerant toward the opposition,” he said.

The opposition leader also commented on Armenian PM Nikol Pashinyan’s statement that “poverty is in people’s heads.”

“I remember the 90s when I was a child, and we were poor the only one to blame was Levon Ter-Petrosyan. In 2000s when we were poor, the only one to blame was Robert Kocharyan. Until 2018 the it was Serzh Sargsyan to blame for us being poor. This is our political system. The revolution comes then, and the leader of the revolution says that the poverty is in the heads of the people,” Marukyan noted.

According to him, Armenians are used to the fact that all responsibility lies on the leadership, and this is fully justified.

From Sikh to Hindu, new book profiles ten diverse faiths of the UAE

The National, UAE
Feb 8 2019

Celebrating Tolerance: Religious Diversity in the United Arab Emirates comes as the UAE marks the Year of Tolerance

Followers of the Baha’i faith pictured with the late Vice President and Ruler of Dubai Sheikh Rashid. Courtesy: Motivate

When Surender Kandhari first came to Dubai in 1975, there were only a handful of Sikhs in what was then a small fishing village centred around the Creek.

The UAE was barely a few years old but tolerance was already an ingrained part of life.

“I never had any problems,” said Mr Kandhari, chairman of the Sikh temple in Dubai. “Everyone who saw me treated me well. We were accepted.”

Today, more than 100,000 Sikhs live in the UAE. The GuruNanak Darbar temple that opened in Jebel Ali Village seven years ago gives free food to anyone who turns up and, on Fridays, tens of thousands pass through its doors.

It is this freedom to live and worship so epitomised by the Sikh story that is the subject of a new book about faiths living together in the UAE.

Celebrating Tolerance: Religious Diversity in the United Arab Emirates is edited by Reverend Andy Thompson, chaplain at St Andrew’s Church in Abu Dhabi, and launched this week — during Pope Francis’s historic visit to the UAE.

It charts the experiences of ten different faiths, including Hindu, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Sikh, Jewish, Baha’i and Christian, who have come to work, live and coexist peacefully. It also examines some of the rituals involved in each faith.

Other communities have welcomed, guided and supported us and offered us their friendship

Spokesman for the Jewish community

Many came here decades ago and the Christian Armenian community is one. By 1950, as the first oil exploration camps were established in what was then the Trucial States, a handful of Armenians came as engineers, car mechanics and tradesmen to support the burgeoning energy industry.

By the 1970s, this handful had turned into a wave because of Lebanon’s civil war and the Iranian revolution that prompted Armenians leaving these countries for the Emirates. The first Armenian mass took place in 1977, the first church was built in Sharjah in 1996 and the Armenians were officially recognised as a community. Today, Armenians here number in the thousands.

The Jewish community is also profiled in the book. Jews have lived in the UAE for decades and there are now thought to be close to 200 in the UAE.

They come from across the globe and work as teachers, artists, academics and doctors. The community is organic and functions without teachers, rabbis or formal institutions. They live mainly in Dubai, where there is a small synagogue.

“Our community has nothing of the grandness or scale of the old Jewish communities that once lived in Syria, Libya, Yemen, Algeria, Iraq and Egypt,” members of the community write in the book.

“We have come here as individuals generally not expecting to find other Jews and imagining that our Jewish identities may, by sad necessity, be diminished. To find it here again gives it a fresh and even primal quality.”

The leadership of the Jewish community in the UAE also welcomed the book’s publication, saying it was an important milestone for them. “It is our first opportunity to share the wonderful story of our life in the UAE with a local audience,” it told The National.

“Other communities have welcomed, guided and supported us, and offered us their friendship as we have built our flourishing community.”

Mr Thompson is also the author of Jesus of Arabia and Christianity in the UAE, a book that shows the links between Islam and Christianity. He believes the new book confronts stereotypes that the Arabian Gulf is home to just one religion.

Aram I, head of the Armenian Apostolic Church, opens a community centre in Abu Dhabi. Courtesy: Motivate

“There is a huge diverse, thriving community here and the good news is that they have been quietly living the values of the tolerance and mutual respect for decades,” said Mr Thompson.

“They had come to the UAE as migrant guest workers and although we are all strangers in a strange land, we have each created a spiritual home.

“In the present climate of intolerance in the West and in other parts of the Middle East, the story of the UAE gives us hope.”

The publication of the book is also timely. The UAE is marking the Year of Tolerance and the book was given to Pope Francis during his visit to the UAE this week. An anti-discrimination law ­— criminalising all forms of prejudice on the grounds of religion, caste, creed, doctrine, race, colour or ethnic origin — that came into force in 2015 had also helped improve the spirit of tolerance.

The book has also been endorsed by Sheikh Nahyan bin Mubarak, Minister of Tolerance, who has written the foreword.

“That wonderful fact of tolerance deserves the celebration accorded by this splendid book,” he said.

“I daresay that we will learn something new about our own religion as well as much about religions different from our own.

“Without our active attention, tolerance can swiftly vanish. Let the essays in this book inspire tolerance in perpetuity.”

Celebrating Tolerance: Religious Diversity in the United Arab Emirates is published by Motivate and costs Dh145.

Verelq: The government was formed by violating the Constitution. Marukyan vs. Pashinyan

  • 06.02.2019
  •  

  • Armenia:
  •  

1
 72

Edmon Marukyan, the chairman of “Lusavore Armenia” party, claims that the RA government was formed in violation of the Constitution. In this regard, he issued a statement.


“In general, the formation of the government, unlike other bodies of the RA executive power, is distinguished by its unique order of formation. The start of the formation of the government begins after the appointment of the prime minister, and then continues with the appointment of ministers.

I think that there has been a violation of the procedure for forming the government, that is, Article 150 of the RA Constitution. That article defines a clear procedure for the formation of the government, according to which, after his appointment, the Prime Minister proposes to the President of the Republic the candidates for Deputy Prime Ministers and Ministers within 5 days. Naturally, here we are talking about the presentation of candidates to be appointed to the positions of members of the government in accordance with the law on the structure and operation of the current government.

The RA Prime Minister did not present all ministerial candidates, and the RA President appointed only those who were presented by the Prime Minister.

According to Article 2 of the Law on the Structure and Activities of the Government, the Government consists of the Prime Minister, the First Deputy Prime Minister, two Deputy Prime Ministers and ministers.

The structure of the government includes the following ministries:

1) Ministry of Labor and Social Affairs
2) the Ministry of Health,
3) Ministry of Justice,
4) the Ministry of Emergency Situations,
5) the Ministry of Foreign Affairs,
6) the Ministry of Environmental Protection
7) Ministry of Agriculture,
8) Ministry of Energy Infrastructure and Natural Resources,
9) Ministry of Education and Science,
10) the Ministry of Culture,
11) Ministry of Defense,
12) Ministry of Sports and Youth Affairs,
13) Ministry of Diaspora
14) the Ministry of Territorial Administration and Development,
15) Ministry of Economic Development and Investments,
16) the Ministry of Transport, Communications and Information Technologies,
17) Ministry of Finance.

Meanwhile, the Prime Minister of RA presented the candidacy of 2 Deputy Prime Ministers and 12 Ministers. In other words, the nomination of five ministers was not submitted, leaving the existing ministries without ministers. However, those ministries and ministerial positions are defined by the above-mentioned law, which is an active law and there is no other law that would define otherwise. At the moment, there is not even any legislative change initiative regarding the structure and activity of the Government. 
It can only be assumed that the Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia was misled by his advisers on legal issues, due to which he was guided by Article 3, Part 9 of the Law of the Republic of Armenia “On the Structure and Activities of the Government”, which defines the guarantee that should ensure the normal functioning of the government.

According to the quoted provision of the above article, the government is considered constituted if at least 2/3 of the members of the government have been appointed. This provision regulates a completely different relationship, it has nothing to do with the constitutional obligation to present the composition of the Government to the President of the Republic of Armenia. It exclusively refers to the cases when the President of the Republic of Armenia appealed to the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Armenia on the issue of contesting the ministerial candidates proposed by the Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia. And the Constitutional Court did not see a problem with at least 2/3 of the candidates. And the other candidates were considered incompatible for those positions, or their candidacy is still under discussion.

This provision is exclusively a provision establishing a guarantee, the meaning of which is to ensure the normal operation of the government in order to avoid a constitutional crisis, and not to grant the RA Prime Minister the right to present fewer ministerial candidates from the government within a five-day period.

Based on the above, it should be stated that the RA Prime Minister did not fulfill the direct obligation imposed on him by the RA Constitution, due to which the requirement of Article 150 of the RA Constitution was violated. 

I urge the Prime Minister to first get rid of those advisers who interpreted the solution of the problem in such a way. As well as to immediately submit to the National Assembly a draft law on the structure and operation of the Government, which will present the structure of the new government, will not leave ministries without ministers in the air and will include the NSS, the police and the SRC in its structure,” said Marukyan’s statement.

The members of the RPA discussed the development of Armenian-Russian cooperation with the Russian ambassador

  • 06.02.2019
  •  

  • Armenia:
  •  

     

1
 64

RPA first deputy chairman, RPA GM member Vigen Sargsyan, RPA deputy chairman, RPA GM member Mushegh Lalayan, RPA speaker, RPA GM member Eduard Sharmazanov, RPA GM member Vahram Baghdasaryan and RPA council member Artak Zakaryan hosted Sergey Kopirkin, Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of the RA RF on February 5.


During the meeting, issues of further development of the Armenian-Russian allied relations were discussed. The necessity of regular organization of similar meetings was emphasized on both sides.