Online discussion of the post-adoption review of the Judicial Code of Armenia – Newsroom

Council of Europe portal
Feb 26 2021
Yerevan, Armenia 26 February 2021

  • Diminuer la taille du texte
  • Augmenter la taille du texte
  • Imprimer la page
  • Imprimer en PDF

On 26 February 2021 an online discussion of the ”Post-adoption review of the Judicial Code of Armenia” took place within the framework of the Partnership for Good Governance (PGG II) Project ”Support to the judicial reform – enhancing the independence and professionalism of the judiciary in Armenia” (further – the Project), funded by the European Union and the Council of Europe and implemented by the Council of Europe.

One of the Project components is focused on the assessment of legislation related to the justice system of Armenia and the provision of recommendations as to strengthening the independence, impartiality and efficiency of the judiciary in Armenia, in line with the Council of Europe standards.

In March 2020, following the Joint Opinion CDL-AD(2019)024 of the Venice Commission and the Directorate of Human Rights of the Directorate General of Human Rights and Rule of Law (DGI) of the Council of Europe, the National Assembly of Armenia adopted the Law on Amendments and Addenda to the Judicial Code and 13 related laws, which entered into force in May 2020. In December 2020, the Project initiated a post-adoption review of the amended Judicial Code with the objective to identify to what extent the recommendations provided by the Joint Opinion CDL-AD(2019)024 are incorporated into the amended Judicial Code.

The post-adoption review was conducted by international experts Mr. Gerhard Reissner (former President of the Consultative Council of European Judges) and Mr. Duro Sessa (former President of the Consultative Council of European Judges, the President of the Supreme Court of Croatia). Both experts have been involved broadly in the expert work in many Council of Europe member states, including by various Council of Europe Committees. They were also a part of the group of rapporteurs engaged in providing the Joint Opinion of the Venice Commission CDL-AD(2019)024 in 2019.

The objective of the discussion was to agree with the Armenian stakeholders the preliminary findings and conclusions of the post-adoption review with regard to the Judicial Code. The discussion was attended by the representatives from the Ministry of Justice, the Supreme Judicial Council, the Court of Cassation, the Delegation of the European Union to Armenia. Following the exchange of opinions during the online discussion, the text of the post-adoption review will be finalised with the account of the suggestions and commentaries of the national partners. The final version of the post-adoption review will be disseminated publicly.

Pashinyan fires Chief of General Staff

Tweet

 12:51, 25 February, 2021

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 25, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has sacked the Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces Onik Gasparyan.

Pashinyan said he had signed the papers on the dismissal of Gasparyan and his deputy before the General Staff issued the statement calling for his resignation.

Gasparyan will officially be considered dismissed only after the President’s formalization of the document.

Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan

Putin May Have Triggered an Attempted Coup in Armenia After PM Insulted His Missiles

Yahoo! News
Feb 26 2021

Anna Nemtsova
Fri, , 12:57 AM

MOSCOW—Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan has announced that his nation’s military had attempted a coup on Thursday, the latest development in a country still recovering from last year’s lost war with Azerbaijan.

Now, politicians and political analysts are speaking of Russia’s hand in the attempted coup, pointing to President Vladimir Putin’s strained relationship with Pashinyan. On Tuesday, Pushinyan had insulted Moscow by complaining about Russian missiles, an indirect criticism of the Kremlin’s strategy of waiting to intervene until Armenia was weakened in the conflict, despite its official status as a military ally.

“They didn’t explode, or maybe 10 percent of them exploded,” Pashinyan said of the missiles Tuesday. The military generals—already angry over Pashinyan’s firing of military generals in an effort to modernize the force—objected, setting off the conflict.

According to political analyst Artur Paronyan, Russia’s General Staff Chief Valery Gerasimov had made a call to his Armenian counterpart, General Onik Gasparyan, earlier in the day. “Moscow clearly signaled to General Gasparyan to get rid of our prime minister,” Paronyan told The Daily Beast.

Led by Gasparyan, dozens of generals signed a statement calling for Pashinyan’s removal over his alleged inability “to make adequate decisions in this crisis.” It marked the first direct intervention by the military in Armenia’s domestic politics since 2008, when 10 demonstrators were killed after the military clamped down on a protest in Yerevan’s Freedom Square.

Armenia has healed from that tragedy, and has since changed course. Over the past decade, the country has developed a vibrant civil society, confronting some of its most acute social issues. But the threat of a war with Azerbaijan over the enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh has been in the air for decades. Generations grew up preparing for the next war, and in September, the fighting began. It went on for six weeks, and Armenia was turned upside down.

After the war, thousands of bitter protesters crowded Yerevan’s center, blaming the government for the defeat and demanding Pashinyan’s resignation. A Russian-brokered ceasefire saved Armenia from defeat in Nagorno-Karabakh, but it also left Armenia desperately dependent on Russia for security.

The opposition called for Pashinyan’s ouster, and was joined by the army on Wednesday. Many men in crowds of protesters wore military uniforms and said they would not leave Freedom Square until Pashinyan was gone. On Thursday, Gasparyan published his statement formally calling for the prime minister’s resignation and criticizing him for “discrediting” the military.

In an exclusive interview with The Daily Beast, Pashinyan’s key rival, former Minister of Defense Vazgen Manukyan, claimed he had powerful support from the Armenian military. “We blame Pashinyan for the total diplomatic failure in peace negotiations with Baku and for our defeat in the war against Azerbaijan’s aggression.” He added that he was “in touch with all the commanders,” and that he knows that “some operations [led by Pashinyan] were more than dubious.”

“Everything that my army managed to win from 1992 to 1993, he lost. We plan to put Pashinyan on trial and investigate why we have lost territories and 5,000 lives,” he said. Manukyan also stressed his support for peaceful demonstrations only, as a civil war would devastate an already vulnerable Armenia.

Many of Manukyan’s supporters are openly championing Russian support for the coup. “The war showed us that neither the United States nor France were here to save us. Moscow negotiated peace for us. Even now, Russian peacekeepers are on guard in the conflict zone,” a pro-Manukyan analyst, Stepan Danielyan, told The Daily Beast.

Armenian leaders have had a hard time earning the trust of a disillusioned public. The public demanded justice for years after the massacre in Freedom Square, blaming the president at the time, Robert Kocharyan, for ordering the shootings. A velvet revolution swept Nikol Pashinyan, once a political prisoner, to power in 2018. The same year, a court ordered former President Kocharyan arrested on charges related to the shooting incident.

“Putin considers Pashinyan a traitor and an enemy who failed in his promises many times,” Sergei Markov, a Kremlin analyst, told The Daily Beast.

Markov explained how the conflict between Putin and Pashinyan goes beyond the missile insults. According to media reports, Putin had unsuccessfully lobbied for the release of his friend, former president Kocharyan, after his 2019 arrest.

“Putin called Kocharyan on his birthday a few months ago to demonstrate what he thought of that arrest,” says Markov. “Now the Kremlin would like to see [Pashinyan] drink the entire glass of shame so everybody would see what happens to an American puppet.”

Correction: Former Armenian Minister of Defense Vazgen Manukyan told The Daily Beast that he had powerful support from the Armenian military in his conflict with Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, a key political rival. A previous version of this report inaccurately stated that Manukyan said he had support from Russia’s military, due to a reporting error.

Armenia’s Armed Forces fully fulfill their functions regardless of political processes

Public Radio of Armenia
Feb 27 2021

The Armed Forces of Armenia fully fulfill their functions of ensuring the security of the country regardless of the political processes, and continue their service for the security of the state and the people, the Defense Ministry said in a statement.

“We demand to refrain from making statements on behalf of the armed forces, not to involve the army in political processes, not to subordinate the country’s security to own political interests,” the Ministry stated.

“The Ministry of Defense and the Armed Forces are out of politics and will consistently continue to take steps aimed at the implementation of reforms and modernization of the defense sphere,” the statement reads. 

Kremlin sees no risk now of Karabakh agreements being derailed due to events in Armenia

Save

Share

 14:55,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 26, ARMENPRESS. Developments in Armenia have so far not affected the implementation of the agreements on Nagorno Karabakh, Russian Presidential Spokesman Dmitry Peskov said when asked whether Moscow saw the threat of the Nagorno Karabakh settlement process being derailed because of the situation in Yerevan, reports TASS.

“No, everything is being implemented so far”, he said. The Kremlin spokesman noted that, despite the developments in Armenia, it is important to follow the path of the implementation of the agreements on Nagorno Karabakh.

On February 25 the General Staff of the Armenian Forces of Armenia issued a statement, demanding the resignation of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his Cabinet.

In his turn Pashinyan commented on the statement, calling it as a “military coup attempt”. He invited all his supporters to the Republic Square to discuss the ongoing developments.




HDIF Secures Sustainable Jobs For Women In Armenia’s Rural Communities

Forbes
Feb 18 2021

Members of the Berd Women’s Resource Center – with Anahit Badalian (front row, red dress) – are … [+]

 ANAHIT BADALIAN

“My entire professional career I’ve worked with and for women,” says Norwegian and Finnish Honorary Consul to Armenia, Sir Timothy Straight, who in 2013 founded the Homeland Development Initiative Foundation (HDIF) social enterprise NGO to carve out a niche for ‘Handmade in Armenia’ products within the global economy. Providing sustainable jobs for some 200 women crafters across 14 rural communities, HDIF is Armenia’s only fully guaranteed member of the World Fair Trade Organization.

Sir Timothy Straight, founder, the Homeland Development Initiative Foundation (HDIF) social … [+]

 HDIF

With nearly $150,000 in total sales in 2020, HDIF disbursed nearly half of that in wages to skilled women artisans across 18 groups producing handmade products including home décor, jewelry and accessories for men, women and children The crocheted, knitted, embroidered, and sewn handicrafts as well as ceramics, woodcrafts, beeswax candles, printed and decorative painted products attest to the nation’s proven artisanry. Except for two men, the remaining crafters are all multi-generational women living in rural communities.

Born out of the Homeland Handicrafts project launched by Straight, HDIF is committed to Armenia’s rural economic development since poverty-stricken residents make up nearly 25 percent of the country’s nearly three million population. Various organizational partners support HDIF’s mission, including the Armenian International Women’s Association (AIWA), which aligns with HDIF’s commitment to empowering women.

Revitalizing Armenia’s Rural Economy By Empowering Women

Anush Badalyan one of the HDIF women crafters.

 HDIF

MORE FOR YOU

“The massive emigration in Armenia left women, mothers and children behind as the men went abroad to find employment. Women need more opportunities in the job market internationally, not just in Armenia,” says Straight, who as executive director of HDIF Foundation and HDIF Trading LLC, first came to Armenia in 2000 as the Norwegian Refugee Council’s Country Director to lead a staff of 15 and build some 1,500 houses and apartments for refugees. Witnessing the dire poverty, unemployment and total lack of social and economic development opportunities in Armenia’s rural areas, he remained in Armenia, offering his extensive experience in product development with a Sri Lankan fair trade organization and to Fair Trade development in Europe. 

With Armenia’s NGOs lacking a legal frame to earn an income, Straight’s idea to develop a handicraft organization as an income generation source received a resounding positive response from the NGOs and started a “snowball roll.” He involved American Peace Corps volunteers in the southern city of Goris and in the far eastern part, at Berd, which jumpstarted HDIF to empower rural women with employment opportunities.

HDIF’s signature Teddy Bear Berd.

 HDIF

“We don’t discriminate against anyone–our oldest crafter is 65 years-old. We select the women crafters based on their capacity, motivation and family status,” explains Berd Women’s Resource Center founder, Anahit Badalian. Berd crafters produce crochet, sewn and knitted handicrafts–and HDIF’s signature Teddy Bear Berd. In 2020, the Berd group also produced certified organic jams sold solely in Armenia. Annually, Badalian says, the group can produce 20,000 jars, but exporting will be a challenge.

HDIF’s full-time women crafters earn nearly $130 per month–above Armenia’s minimum wages. Working from home allows the women to earn an income while attending to their families and domestic responsibilities. With a shoestring operating budget, HDIF’s two-and-a-half staff–including Straight, are “paid humbly”.

HDIF’s crocheted animal stick rattle.

 HDIF

The Fair Trade world was HDIF’s largest sales channel in 2019. The animal themed crocheted baby rattles, and animal stick rattles are the most sought after products by the international Fair Trade organizations. In 2020, the highest sales volumes came from the Armenian Diaspora following the “#BuyArmenian tsunami” campaign, says Straight, launched in protest to the 44-day Turkey-backed Azerbaijan war in the disputed, predominantly Armenian populated region of Artsakh.

Extending HDIF Into North America

Since Armenia doesn’t service PayPal and other e-commerce payments, HDIF continues to search for a viable financial structure or functioning system for local producers. In 2017, HDIF launched its first international affiliate–HDIF-USA.

Beth Broussalian, founder and executive director of the 501-c3 HDIF-USA

 BETH BROUSSALIAN

“One reason HDIF-USA was set up is to provide HDIF with an online sales channel connected to PayPal,” explains Beth Broussalian, founder and executive director of the 501(c)(3) HDIF-USA. “We import and sell Armenian handicrafts in North America as well as give U.S.-based donors a way to make tax-deductible donations to HDIF.”

HDIF-USA is an enormous advantage in supporting the economic development initiatives in Armenia, says Straight who in 2018 established HDIF Trading LLC to manage the daily operations of HDIF’s Fair Trade shop in Armenia, product manufacturing and supply management. As the U.S. and Canada distributor, some 90 percent of HDIF-USA’s sales are via its eCommerce site through Shopify. Broussalian also offers wholesale and resale price points to customers, and hopes to attract U.S. Fair Trade retail shops interested in unique products with an ethnic look, like the pomegranate oven gloves.

“Our first-tier sales come from the Armenian community, followed by the Fair-Trade community where we’re trying to get a foothold, and then we will set our sights on the larger well-known retailers,” explains Broussalian.

Each Product Reflects A Piece Of Armenia

Crocheted finger puppet.

 HDIF

“Each product tag conveys the uniqueness of the product and the region,” Broussalian explains how HDIF products promote Armenia’s cultural heritage traditions by including a photo of the crafter, a map, and a description of the region from where the craft originated.

Crochet handicrafts are HDIF’s top sellers since crocheting became a national pastime for Armenia’s women during the 1993 economic blockade imposed by Turkey. The protest over the Armenian control of the predominantly indigenous region of Artsakh, deprived Armenia of electricity, heating oil and gas.

Crocheted Baby Rattle – by HDIF.

 HDIF

 “Most women sitting in the dark were knitting and crocheting clothing for their children,” explains Badalian. “That’s why they’re now professionals at it.”

Crocheting wasn’t considered “sexy” Straight says, “but I dare say we revolutionized crocheting in Armenia.” Armenia has become a crochet country with techniques that amaze the visitors to the annual international Fair Trade shows in Germany.

Employing displaced Syrian-Armenian women, now living in Armenia, HDIF has introduced a new layer of Syrian “story telling” with unique embroidery designs reflective of historic Armenian regions (now Eastern Turkey) uncommon in Armenia. HDIF also employs displaced women following the war in the Artsakh region, who now live in Armenia.

Sustaining Employment With EcoTourism

“Our focus is to keep people gainfully employed throughout the year to meet and fulfill our mantra: “Roof over your head, food on the table, education for the kids,” Straight meets this demand by combining sales across various markets, the Fair-Trade world being easier and the largest.

Organic jam produced by Berd Women’s Resource Center.

 ANAHIT BADALYAN

The Bears & Berries Eco-center, an initiative of Berd Women’s Resource Center, supported by HDIF, Fund for Armenian Relief/FAR, UNDP, and Prague Civil Society Center, will be the town’s first multi-functional center focused on ecotourism development through women’s empowerment. Offering a safe, art therapy space to help the women destress, it will integrate the last decade of HDIF’s achievements. Raising eco-tourism levels by the year’s end and into 2022, will involve transforming some houses into B&Bs, and offering tourism workshops on hosting, safe food preparation and management. While the agritourism will unify the HDIF brands, B&Bs and restaurants will leverage the region’s rich biodiversity, Badalian explains, connecting scenic rural mountain roads with overnight and extended stay attractions. It will also boost the growing interest in social entrepreneurship among the women crafters who hope to impact progress in their rural communities.

Janna Eghikyan is one of the HDIF crafters.

 HDIF

“Integrating eco-tourism with food service, B&Bs along with handicraft production will increase the women crafters’ income. In making small changes we can have a large impact in our communities,” Badalian says small life-altering changes brought by HDIF have translated into big successes in the women’s lives. “Working together has helped the women realize their own needs–there are obvious changes in the way they think and live.”

If at least four functioning B&Bs are completed by this September, Straight will be “very proud, and can double the number of women employed.” Determined to create more jobs for the women crafters this year, Straight faces many unknowns–from the pandemic’s continuation, to #BuyArmenian campaign’s lifespan, to whether Armenia’s high tourism rates will be revived. Regardless, HDIF is on track, developing an Easter collection, engaging all their producer groups.

A set of Easter eggs embroidered in different traditional Armenian techniques by Syrian Armenian … [+]

 HDIF

 HDIF-USA will engage the American and Canadian Fair Trade sectors for expanded sales, which Broussalian says will lead to buying larger quantities from Armenia–ultimately employing more women and increasing production levels.

“With the world moving toward up-cycled products, we also plan to use Armenia’s natural sheep fibers and recycle the damaged transport pallets to create new products. We are particularly interested in meshing new products with Armenia’s cultural heritage,” says Straight.

 

Artsakh President attends Divine Liturgy at Amaras Monastery

Public Radio of Armenia
Feb 21 2021

President of the Artsakh Republic Arayik Harutyunyan attended a Divine Liturgy at Amaras Monsatery celebrated by His grave Archboshop Vrtanes Abrahamyan, Primate of the Artsakh Diocese of the Armenian Apostolic Curch.

The President stressed the key role of the Armenian Apostolic Church in public life, assuring that, in cooperation with the Artsakh Diocese, the government will provide funds every Sunday to provide transport communication from the capital to the churches in the regions of the Republic.

Secretary of the Security Council of the Republic of Azerbaijan Vitaly Balasanyan, Head of the Martuni Region Administration Edik Avanesyan, servicemen of the Defense Army, pilgrims also took part in the liturgy.

Wendy Morton highlights ceasefire in NK and unblocking regional infrastructures

Save

Share

 20:06,

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 16, ARMENPRESS. President of the National Assembly of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan received Wendy Morton, United Kingdom’s Minister for European Neighborhood and the Americas, who highlighted the establishment of the ceasefire regime in Nagorno Karabakh and the unblocking of the regional infrastructures. Ararat Mirzoyan hoped that the United Kingdom, as a partner country which is a member of the UNSC, will make all possible efforts for the speedy return of the POWs according to the principle of ”all for all”.

As ARMENPRESS was informed from the press service of the National Assembly of Armenia, greeting the guest, the President of the parliament noted that the partnering relations between the two countries need to be further activated, which can be greatly fostered by the activation of inter-parliamentary interactions.

Referring to the situation over Nagorno Karabakh, Ararat Mirzoyan emphasized that for the implementation of the November 9 trilateral declaration and preservation of the regional peace the speedy return of the Armenian POWs and other detainees is priority for the Armenian side. Ararat Mirzoyan added that the negotiations on the status of Artsakh under the auspices of the OSCE Minsk Group Co-chairs remains on the agenda of the Armenian side.

The interlocutors exchanged views on the reform agenda of Armenia, as well as the process and achievements of the program ”New Armenia, modern parliament” carried out in the National Assembly of Armenia by UK funding.

Film: ‘Songs of Solomon’ Review: A Clumsy Rendering of Key Chapter of Armenian History

Variety
Feb 8 2021
The Armenian crusade for truth about Ottoman atrocities deserves better than this ham-fisted drama.


The eminent Armenian composer Komitas, born Soghomon (Westernized as Solomon), clumsily flits in and out of Arman Nshanian’s “Songs of Solomon,” his figure used as a historical marker in a drama designed to draw attention to the Hamidian massacres perpetrated against the Armenians in the 1890s. Despite the shocking number of deaths, estimated at between 200,000 to 300,000, the atrocities tend to receive little attention when compared with the Armenian Genocide two decades later, so while any focus is welcome, it’s deeply frustrating that “Songs” does it so poorly. Ineptly plotted and criminally slapdash in its history, “Songs” is heritage patriotism at its most prosaic, making it a natural for submission as Armenia’s foreign Oscar candidate. Less understandable is Nick Vallelonga’s involvement as producer.

The story is narrated by Sevil (Arevik Gevorgyan), a fictionalized Turkish woman who, together with her Armenian chum Sona, befriends Soghomon in 1881 when they’re all children in the western Anatolian town of Kütahya (also known as Koutina). This was a time, she tells us, when Armenians and Turks all got along splendidly, though the statement is unironically contradicted a couple of scenes later when we see schoolchildren tormenting Soghomon (Slava Seyranyan) for his ethnicity.

The boy is a poor orphan — a fact frequently repeated — living with his blind grandmother (Shake Toukhmanian) who’s instilled in him a love of music. His prodigious melodic memory and fine singing voice draw the attention of the local archbishop (Jean-Pier Nshanian), and he’s sent to the seminary in Etchmiadzin for music and religious training.

Fast forward 13 years, and Sevil’s fiancé Osman (the director, Arman Nshanian) warns her that anti-Armenian sentiment is running high so she should distance herself from Sona (Tatev Hovakimyan) and her new husband, the potter Sarkis (Sos Janibekyan). She scoffs at the idea, but then the wicked Ottoman colonel Abdullah (Artashes Aleksanyan) comes to town sowing fear, destroying Sarkis’ ceramics and subjecting him to a beating. Sultan Abdülhamid II’s new orders are to root out the Armenians, and notwithstanding an attempt by the soon-strangled mayor (Davit Hakobyan) to dissuade the officials, a roundup is begun, the Armenian quarter is set alight, and the Hamidian massacres enflame Kütahya.

The problem is, the Hamidian massacres never reached Kütahya, and the town, long an important center of Armenian ceramic work, was spared the carnage. Not only that, but during World War I when the Genocide began, the Ottoman district governor Faik Ali Ozansoy risked his life to protect Armenians of the region and has since been labeled one of the “Righteous.” Given that the massacres and the Genocide, historical realities, are still contested by the Turkish government, it behooves anyone recreating the period to tread carefully when tinkering with the facts; doing otherwise does the Armenian cause a major disservice.

Historical license can of course be welcome — the whole Sevil/Sona story is fictional, and a skilled writer could have made it come alive — but “Songs of Solomon” wants to have it both ways, lightly grafting the real Soghomon onto an invented tale while cloaking itself in the righteousness of truth. In his director’s statement, Nshanian writes, “The atrocities in this film are 100% dreadful yet sadly 100% accurate,” but this claim to accuracy is disingenuous, as is the ridiculous, gratuitously offensive allegation, spoken by Sarkis, that the Turks have no culture.

Soghomon as an adult (Samvel Tadevossian) is more an occasional offscreen presence than a genuine character, and the film ends with his arrest in 1915 in Istanbul (he survived the Genocide, but the trauma left an indelible mark and from 1919 until his death in 1935 he lived in an asylum in France). Unfortunately the film makes weak use of his influential music. Visually, “Songs” looks like an extended re-enactment from a second-rate history program, the kind that always has a smoke machine just off-screen to provide atmosphere when the evil guy approaches.


 

Will Armenian Gain From New Regional Transit Routes?

IWPR – Institute for War and Peace Reporting, UK
Feb 12 2021

Critics fear that risks outweigh any potential benefits. Friday,

Manya Israyelyan

Armenian analysts have cast doubt on how much the country is likely to benefit from the planned reopening of regional transport corridors following the recent war in Nagrony Karabakh.

A new agreement envisages Armenia guaranteeing the security of transport links between Nakhichevan and the western regions of Azerbaijan. Citizens, vehicles and goods will enjoy unimpeded movement in both directions, supervised by Russian security services.

According to the joint statement from the heads of states of Russia, Armenia and Azerbaijan issued after their January 11 meeting in Moscow, a working group headed by the deputy prime ministers of the three countries will deal with transport links and economic issues.

Russian newspaper Kommersant published a map of the transport corridors in question. This showed Azerbaijan gaining access to one corridor and railway from Nakhichevan through Armenia’s southern Syunik region to the Azerbaijani-controlled part of Karabakh. This would also connect Azerbaijan to Turkey.

Armenia will see two railway routes reopened, one through Nakhichevan to Iran and another through Azerbaijan to Russia. Armenia will also have access to the same southern railway from Yerevan to Syunik and through Nakhichevan.

However, much remains undecided in terms of both technical arrangements and time frames.

“Whether roads will open before the railway or vice versa is unclear,” said Hayk Gevorgyan from ruling My Step faction.

He noted that Azerbaijan had estimated that reconstructing a section of railway from Agarak to Horadiz, which used to be under Armenian control, would take at least two years.

“Before that, opening the vehicle routes should be discussed,” Gevorgyan added. 

Spinnaker Group LLC co-founder Norayr Gevorgyan, a specialist in cargo transportation, told an online discussion that this 120 km stretch would take longer than two years.

“Why go to Baku from Yerevan through Nakhichevan and then Russia, if Kars-Akhuryan through Ghazakh to Russia cuts the road by 250 km?” he asked.

Because this shorter route would involve more Armenian territory, revenue from transit fees could double or even triple.

Some maintain that freeing these channels will be an economic win for Armenia. Minister of economy Vahan Kerobyan outlined what he said would be the opportunities for Armenia as a result of unblocking regional transport corridors. 

In the short term, he said, “competition results in better products,” while in the longer term, he continued, “Our products could be exported to Russia and other countries via better roads than they are now.”

Critics disagree, warning that domestic instability would only escalate in the face of direct competition with the more powerful economies of Turkey and Azerbaijan.

Avetik Chalabyan, leader of the National Agenda opposition party, said that unblocking regional transport corridors would only be possible under conditions of permanent peace.

He argued that Karabakh needed to be given some kind of internationally recognised status, the Armenian settlements occupied by Azerbaijan in the most recent conflict should be freed, with displaced Armenians able to return to their homes with security guarantees and all prisoners of war released.

“Otherwise, it turns out that we place the cart before the horse,” he said. “There is no peace, but we are trying to establish transport communication through mutual territories, which is not realistic.”

While officials state that Armenia is interested in cargo transportation to Russia and Iran via Azerbaijan, experts are less upbeat. Any potential benefits, some fear, may be reaped by Azerbaijan, Turkey and Russia rather than Armenia. 

“The route to Russia via that railway is two to three times longer than through Georgia,” said economist Hrant Mikaelyan, a researcher at the Caucasus Institute, adding that the new route would also be vulnerable to arbitrary closure by others.

“Now we are going to have a corridor in Armenia proper, which will be controlled by a third party, Russia, and corridors controlled by Azerbaijan,” he concluded.

The security risks of opening these corridors could also not be ruled out, given the disruption to the balance of power in the region.

“Those risks are too high in the face of an unfinished war and by providing the enemy with a passage through our territory, we open an additional door of potential aggression against our country, it is quite obvious,” Chalabyan stressed.

While the Armenian ministry of economy has not yet published its calculations, their argument is that Armenia has the potential to grow a significant transit economy.

“We are going to develop a programme that will prepare us to reap all the benefits that unblocking of the region may yield,” said the minister.

Chalabyan said that an Armenian railway route through Nakhichevan might at best lead to an increase in transit from Iran to the Black Sea as well as in the opposite direction.

However, if international sanctions on Iran increased, this might massively reduce any possible flow of goods.

“Therefore, at this moment we should focus not so much on abstract talks about opportunities, but on the restoration and strengthening of our security system, which has been really disrupted as a result of the war,” Chalabyan concluded.   

This publication was prepared under the “Giving Voice, Driving Change – from the Borderland to the Steppes Project” implemented with the financial support of the Foreign Ministry of Norway.