RFE/RL Armenian Report – 04/23/2019

                                        Tuesday, 
Pashinian Ally Hails Sarkisian Resignation Anniversary
        • Astghik Bedevian
Armenia -- Armenians celebrate the resignation of Prime Minister Serzh 
Sarkisian, Yerevan, April 23, 2018.
A close associate of Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian congratulated Armenians on 
Tuesday on the first anniversary of the dramatic resignation of the country’s 
former leader, Serzh Sarkisian, announced amid mass protests against his 
continued rule.
“I want to congratulate all of us in connection with that event and say that a 
very important event happened in Armenia one year ago,” said Alen Simonian, a 
deputy parliament speaker and senior member of Pashinian’s My Step bloc.
“The people of Armenia once again proved their superior qualities,” Simonian 
told reporters.
Sarkisian stepped down on April 23, 2018 just six days after completing his 
second presidential term in office and becoming Armenia’s prime minister amid 
intensifying street protests organized by Pashinian.
“Nikol Pashinian was right, I was mistaken,” Sarkisian said in a written 
address to the nation.“There are several solutions to the existing situation 
but I will not opt for any of them. They are not to my liking.”
“The movement in the streets is against my tenure. I am fulfilling your 
demand,” he added.
ARMENIA -- A man covered with a national flag waves an opened bottle of a 
sparkling wine celebrating Armenian Prime Minister's Serzh Sarkisian's 
resignation in Republic Square in Yerevan, April 23, 2018
The announcement sparked jubilant scenes in the streets of Yerevan filled with 
hundreds of thousands of people demanding his resignation.
Sarkisian publicly rejected the demands for his resignation as recently as on 
April 22. At a short televised meeting with Pashinian, he accused the 
opposition leader of blackmailing “the legitimate authorities of the state.” “A 
faction that got 7-8 percent of the vote [in the April 2017 parliamentary 
elections] cannot speak on behalf of the people,” he said, referring to the 
opposition Yelk bloc, of which Pashinian was a leader.
Pashinian was detained more than an hour after that meeting while holding a 
fresh demonstration in Yerevan. The arrest only added to popular anger, with 
tens of thousands of people flocking to Republic Square later on April 22.
The protests resumed in Yerevan and other Armenian cities the following 
morning. Pashinian was set free in the afternoon, shortly before the 
announcement of Sarkisian’s resignation.
The then Armenian parliament controlled by Sarkisian’s Republican Party (HHK) 
reluctantly elected Pashinian prime minister on May 8 under relentless pressure 
from huge crowds demonstrating across the country.
Pashinian’s protest movement was also backed by other major political forces, 
notably Gagik Tsarukian’s Prosperous Armenia Party (BHK). The BHK joined his 
first cabinet formed later in May. It is now in opposition to the government.
ARMENIA -- Opposition demonstrators gathered on the Republic Square celebrating 
Armenian Prime Minister's Serzh Sarkisian's resignation in Yerevan, April 23, 
2018
A senior BHK figure, Gevorg Petrosian, claimed on Tuesday that the “velvet 
revolution” has not lived up to the people’s expectations yet. “The people did 
the revolution in hopes that there will be a tangible, positive improvement in 
their lives in the very near future,” he said. “In the economic sense we don’t 
have tangible growth right now.”
Simonian disagreed, saying that Pashinian’s government is consistently 
improving the economic situation in Armenia with sweeping reforms. “This is an 
ongoing process which will continue unabated,” he said. “Everything will be 
done so that Armenia’s citizens feel the difference on their skin, in their 
family budgets.”
Earlier this month the current parliament controlled by My Step approved a 
government proposal to designate the last Saturday of April as a public holiday 
called Citizen’s Day. Pashinian insisted in March that the new holiday will be 
dedicated to “the victory of the people and democracy,” rather than his rise to 
power.
Russian Military Said To Deploy More Advanced Jets In Armenia
        • Emil Danielyan
Singapore -- A Sukhoi SU-30 fighter jet from the Royal Malaysian Air Force 
performs a slow fly past during the Singapore Airshow at Changi exhibition 
center in Singapore, February 16, 2016
Russia will replace its 18 MiG-29 fighter jets stationed in Armenia with more 
sophisticated and powerful aircraft, it was reported on Tuesday
Citing an unnamed official in the Defense Ministry in Moscow, the TASS news 
agency said the Russian military will start deploying Sukhoi Su-30SM jets to 
the Erebuni airbase in Yerevan next year.
“The delivery of the aircraft will be carried out in two phases: in 2020 and 
2021,” the said the unnamed source. “It is planned that all 18 MiG-29s, which 
are currently flown by pilots of the airbase, will be replaced by Su-30SMs.”
Su-30SM is a modernized version of a heavy fighter jet developed by the Sukhoi 
company in the late 1980s. The Russian military received the first batch of 
such aircraft in 2012. It can carry much heavier and more wide-ranging rockets 
and has more advanced electronic equipment than MiG-29, which was designed in 
the 1970s.
Armenia - A Russian MiG-29 fighter jet prepares for takeoff at the Erebuni air 
base in Yerevan, 12Mar2016.
The Russian ambassador to Armenia, Sergey Kopyrkin, did not deny or confirm the 
TASS report when he spoke to journalists later on Tuesday. “I am not prepared 
to talk about this subject in detail,” Kopyrkin said, according to the Sputnik 
news agency.
For its part, Armenia’s Defense Ministry declined to comment on the possible 
deployment of Su-30SM aircraft, saying that Moscow has made no official 
statements to that effect.
An Armenian government source told RFE/RL’s Armenian service that Yerevan would 
welcome such a deployment because Su-30SM is more modern than the aging MiG-29s 
that are part of the Russian military base in Armenia. The MiG-29s were 
modernized by the Russian Air Force several years ago.
The Russia base headquartered in Gyumri is in turn part of Russia’s Southern 
Military District. The district commander, Colonel-General Alexander Dvornikov, 
met with the visiting chief of the Armenian army’s General Staff, 
Lieutenant-General Artak Davtian, on April 19.
Russia -- Colonel-General Alexander Dvornikov (L), commander of Russia's 
Southern Military District, meets with Lieutenant-General Artak Davtian (R), 
the Amrenian army chief of staff, April 19, 2019.
According to the Armenia Defense Ministry, the two generals discussed “joint 
combat readiness activities.” A ministry statement said Dvornikov also praised 
the most recent Russian-Armenian military exercises that were held at a 
training ground 50 kilometers west of Yerevan on April 1-12.
Earlier this year, Moscow and Yerevan signed a contract for the delivery of 
four Sukhoi Su-30SM jets to Armenia. Defense Minister Davit Tonoyan said in 
February that the Armenian military will receive them by the beginning of 2020. 
It plans to buy more such aircraft in the following years, he said.
Financial details of the fighter jet deal remain unknown. Membership in the 
Russian-led Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) entitles Armenia to 
buying Russian weapons at discounted prices.
Armenian Law-Enforcement Body Reports Sharp Rise In Corruption Probes
Armenia -The Investigative Committee headquarters in Yerevan.
Armenia’s Investigative Committee said on Tuesday that the number of state 
officials and other individuals prosecuted by it on corruption charges more 
than doubled last year.
In a detailed statement, the law-enforcement agency, which conducts the vast 
majority of criminal investigations in the country, revealed that it opened 
1,077 corruption-related cases in 2018, up from 403 such cases in 2017. It said 
presumed embezzlement or misuse of public funds accounted for the largest share 
of those inquiries, followed by almost 130 alleged instances of bribery.
The Investigative Committee said 382 individuals working in the central or 
local government bodies, the security apparatus and other public institutions 
were charged with various corrupt practices as a result. It reported a total of 
77 corruption-related arrests of these and other people, compared with 23 
arrests made in 2017.
The committee did not specify whether the bulk of these actions were taken 
after last spring’s mass protests which toppled Armenia’s former government 
accused by its political opponents of not only tolerating but also sponsoring 
corruption.
Public discontent with widespread graft is thought to be one of the reasons for 
the “velvet revolution.” Nikol Pashinian, the revolution leader elected prime 
minister in May, claims to have already eliminated “systemic corruption” in 
Armenia.
The most high-profile corruption probes launched after the revolution have 
targeted relatives and cronies of Serzh Sarkisian, the country’s deposed former 
leader. In particular, one of his two brothers, Levon, was charged with 
“illegal enrichment” after tax inspectors discovered in June 2018 that he and 
his two children hold almost $7 million in undeclared deposits at an Armenian 
bank. Levon Sarkisian, who is known to have worked only in the public sector, 
apparently left Armenia shortly before being indicted.
Press Review
“Zhoghovurd” comments on the first anniversary of Serzh Sarkisian’s dramatic 
resignation as Armenia’s newly elected prime minister. “He resigned under 
popular pressure,” writes the paper. “Although he said the day before that ‘a 
political force that got 7 percent of the vote has no right to speak on behalf 
of the people’ and hinted at another March 1-style crackdown, he admitted on 
April 23: ‘Nikol Pashinian was right, I was wrong.’ There was a real jubilation 
in Armenia on the day of Serzh Sarkisian’s resignation.” The paper says that 
the greatest achievement of the past year was the conduct of free and fair 
parliamentary elections in December. It also praised the new government’s 
economic policies and record.
“Aravot” says that judging from continuing statements made by senior members of 
Sarkisian’s Republican Party of Armenia (HHK), they “still do not understand 
and do not even try to understand that they were rejected and are hated to this 
day.” “They think that the revolution which happened one year ago was the 
result of a skillful use of public relations and political ‘color’ techniques,” 
editorializes the paper. “Far from denying that factor, we have to point out 
that it plaid a secondary role. They key thing was the public mood which 
accumulated in the past 20 years.”
“The events of last year must also serve as a lesson for the current 
authorities. Childish jubilation and blind worship are as dangerous as 
courtier’s flattery,” concludes “Aravot.”
“Zhamanak” says Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian has trouble making Armenians 
understand what the “economic revolution” promised by him is all about. The 
paper says the main reason for this is that people have traditionally expected 
their government to give them tangible economic benefits, rather than create 
conditions for prosperity. “This is where a dialogue is not taking place,” it 
says, adding that Pashinian and his associates themselves nurtured this “old 
mindset” when they were in opposition to the country’s former governments.
(Lilit Harutiunian)
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2019 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org

Revenue Committee: Largest shadow economy in Armenia is in retail trade

News.am, Armenia
Revenue Committee: Largest shadow economy in Armenia is in retail trade Revenue Committee: Largest shadow economy in Armenia is in retail trade

16:02, 29.03.2019
                

YEREVAN. – The 50 percent which the Prime Minister noted was the information of an international organization, so we may have an accurate assessment; we are working in that direction, said Davit Ananyan, Chairman of the State Revenue Committee (SRC) of Armenia, on Friday speaking with reporters.

He stated the aforesaid in connection with the remark that Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan had announced that, according to international expert organizations, shadow economy reaches 50% in Armenia, whereas the SRC chief had stated that, according to the Statistical Committee of Armenia, it has dropped from 25% down to 22%, and when asked which indicator was closer to the actual picture.

As per Ananyan, international organizations issue various such indicators, the PM had voiced the view of one such organizations, but Armenia still needs to express its approach toward these assessments—and in terms of methodology.

The SRC chief noted that they are developing a methodology for assessing sectoral shadow economy in Armenia.  

Noting that the largest shadow economy in the country was in retail trade, Davit Ananyan added, however, that it is considerably much smaller in big supermarkets.

Sports: Arsenal want to get Armenian star’s £180k-a-week deal off the wage bill

Daily Mirror, UK
Wednesday
GUNS NEED MKHI TAKER: Arsenal want to get Armenian star’s £180k-a-week deal off the wage bill
 
by ADRIAN KAJUMBA
 
HENRIKH MKHITARYAN’S Arsenal future is in doubt.
 
HENR Arsen Th the Oz to The Gunners wamt to offload Armenian – as well as Mesut Ozil this summer – as they try reduce their huge wage bill. Attacking midfielder Mkhitaryan, 30, is one of Arsenal’s highest earners on £180,000 per week.
 
MA But, as he feels about £350,000-a-week World Cup winner Ozil, boss Unai Emery believes Mkhitaryan’s salary could better spent elsewhere. arsenal’s finances are strained their wage bill inflated. Emery was restricted to loan signings in the January window and start the summer with a transfer budget of just £45million if Gunners fail to make the Champions League.
 
£ win believe be bett Arse and th Eme signing could transfe the G Champ The Aaron Cech’s confirmed departure of Ramsey to Juventus, Petr retirement and Danny Welbeck’s likely release will help.
 
Welbe But Mkhita way to Mk the finding buyers for Mkhitaryan and Ozil will go a long easing the financial burden. Mkhitaryan joined Arsenal in January swap deal that saw Alexis Sanchez head to Manchester United.
 
But neither player has lived up to expectations – Sanchez being a bigger disappointment than Mkhitaryan – and both clubs are keen to move on the attackers.
 
Despite the size of his budget, Emery is targeting up to four signings this summer, with a leftsided winger his priority. Celtic’s Kieran Tierney is in his sights.
 
Central defence and central attacking midfield are other positions that the Emirates chief is keen to strengthen.
 
But Emery’s chances of signing £43m-rated Italy star Nicolo Barella could depend on whether Arsenal qualify for the Champions League.
 
The Cagliari midfielder scored his first goal for his country against Finland on Saturday and is seen as a replacement for Ramsey.
 
But the 22-year-old’s asking price could be a big problem.
 
Arsenal hope to boost their finances by offloading Mohamed Elneny, Calum Chambers and Shkodran Mustafi.
 
Arsenal signed Denis Suarez, 25, on loan from Barcelona in January, but he has failed to impress and the club are unlikely to take up their option to make it permanent.
 
LACAZETTE ON TARGET ARSENAL came from a goal down to beat Al-Nasr and end their Dubai trip with a win.
 
Ronnie Fernandez gave the hosts a shock lead, but the tourists levelled through Carl Jenkinson.
 
Alexandre Lacazette (left) then put Unai Emery’s men in front in the second half before young sub Tyreece John-Jules hit the Gunners’ third goal.
 
Al-Nasr got a late consolation penalty from Khalid Jalal to make it 3-2.

Sports: World Cup: Gymnast Arthur Davtyan in finals

Panorama, Armenia
Sport 17:32 26/03/2019 Armenia

Gymnast Arthur Davtyan has qualified for the finals of the Artistic Gymnastics World Cup ongoing in Doha, Armenia’s National Olympic Committee reported. At vault our athlete has gained 14,849 points and overcome the qualification round placing third.

Earlier, in the rings event Vahagn Davtyan overcame the obstacle of the qualification round with the second place, Arthur Tovmasyan – third place and Harutyun Merdinyan reached the finals of the pommel horse event with the third place.

It is noted that the Armenia team takes part in the World Cup with four gymnasts. The World Cup is a qualification tournament for the Tokyo 2020 Olympics.

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 03/20/2019

                                        Wednesday, 
Aliyev Again Rejects Armenian Proposal To Include Karabakh In Peace Talks
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev (file photo)
Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev has again rejected an Armenian proposal on 
the inclusion of Nagorno-Karabakh as a full party to internationally mediated 
negotiations for the settlement of the protracted conflict.
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian reiterated the proposal at a press 
conference in Yerevan on March 19, insisting that it will not constitute a 
change of the current format of talks mediated by the Organization for Security 
and Cooperation in Europe’s Minsk Group, but rather will be the restoration of 
the format that existed for several years after 1994 when Nagorno-Karabakh was 
a separate party to the ceasefire agreement that put a halt to active military 
operations in the region.
Aliyev, meanwhile, again referred to Armenia’s proposal as “a change in the 
negotiations format,” which he said is unacceptable.
“Azerbaijan cannot agree to that. And envoys of the Minsk Group co-chair 
countries made a serious statement, saying that the format of the negotiations 
should remain unchanged. Similar statements were also made by high-ranking EU 
officials. It is definitely a serious message to Armenia, and it also proves 
that Azerbaijan’s position is getting more and more support,” Aliyev said on 
Wednesday.
Speaking at yesterday’s press conference, Armenian Prime Minister Pashinian 
emphasized that his statements on the need for Nagorno-Karabakh’s engagement in 
the talks was not a “challenge”, but rather “an invitation to dialogue” in 
which Armenia was ready to listen to Azerbaijan’s counterarguments.
“We will continue discussions on this subject with our partners and will try to 
continue this discussion in the field of arguments, because negotiations are 
negotiations only when we listen to each other. At least Armenia has shown its 
ability to listen to its opponent, try to understand the other side, and we 
expect the same from them. Where our partners consider that our position can be 
viewed as excessively tough, we can soften this position, but we would expect 
the same from our partners, because otherwise no conversation will take place,” 
the Armenian leader said, in particular.
Meanwhile, at a press briefing in Yerevan today Armenian Foreign Ministry 
spokesperson Anna Naghdalian said that the expected meeting between the 
Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders will not be “negotiations around the 
Nagorno-Karabakh settlement issue proper, but an endeavor to elaborate 
appropriate interpretations regarding the principles and elements of the 
settlement process.”
“There are different interpretations of the three principles and six elements 
included in the document. Azerbaijan interprets them its own way, the Armenian 
side also makes its own interpretation… Therefore, there is a need for a 
meeting just to work out an appropriate interpretation for all three principles 
and six elements, and only then understand how to move forward,” said 
Naghdalian.
Opposition Lawmaker Sees ‘Growing Discontent’ In Armenia
        • Ruzanna Stepanian
Gevork Gorgisian, secretary of the Bright Armenia parliamentary faction
There is a growing wave of social discontent in Armenia and it is dangerous if 
the prime minister is not aware of it, an opposition lawmaker said on 
Wednesday, commenting on the statement that Nikol Pashinian amde at a press 
conference yesterday.
Pashinian, in particular, said: “There is no growing wave of discontent in 
Armenia and I am saying this for the record. In the next five years we will see 
if there is a growing wave of discontent in Armenia.”
Countering this statement, Gevork Gorgisian, secretary of the opposition Bright 
Armenia faction in parliament, referred to a number of recent protests staged 
by workers in different sectors of the economy.
“Now we are discussing the new tax legislation and there are lots of complaints 
about it. Right now the National Assembly is discussing amendments to the law 
on pawnshops, in which connection there are also different complaints in 
society. We get complaints every day, we meet with citizens who represent 
different sectors and have different issues while dealing mostly with 
government institutions. And all this must be handled and something must be 
done about it,” Gorgisian said.
The oppositionist claimed that daily contacts that he and his colleagues have 
with citizens show that “people yet do not feel the real changes after the 
revolution.”
“Very high expectations have been formed and now it is very dangerous that if 
the society does not see at least some of the expectations being met, we will 
face the risk of a very serious depression,” Gorgisian said.
According to the opposition lawmaker, the Pashinian government has also failed 
to fight against systemic corruption.
On the contrary, Pashinian and other members of his government have repeatedly 
stated that government corruption has been uprooted in Armenia.
Pashinian Congratulates Tokayev on Becoming Kazakhstan’s Interim President
Kassym-Jomart Tokayev being sworn in as Kazakhstan’s interim president
Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian on Wednesday congratulated 
Kassym-Jomart Tokayev on his assuming the office of Kazakhstan’s interim 
president following yesterday’s resignation of the Central Asian nation’s 
longtime leader Nursultan Nazarbayev.
In his message published on the prime minister’s official website Pashinian, in 
particular, said: “I cordially congratulate you on assuming the office of 
[interim] president of the Republic of Kazakhstan. I am convinced that your 
rich experience and knowledge will serve the best Kazakhstan’s further 
development and progress.
“The warm friendship and mutual respect between our peoples are a solid basis 
for the continuous strengthening of our inter-state relations. I express my 
readiness to cooperate closely with you in bilateral and multilateral formats 
for the further expansion and deepening of the Armenian-Kazakhstani relations.”
After announcing his resignation on March 19, Kazakhstan’s longtime ruler 
Nazarbayev, among other foreign leaders, also had a telephone conversation with 
Pashinian.
Armenia and Kazakhstan are both members of the Russian-led Eurasian Economic 
Union and Collective Security Treaty Organization.
Alabama Recognizes Armenian Genocide
People lay flowers to commemorate the 103rd anniversary of mass killings of 
Armenians by Ottoman Turks, at the Tsitsernakaberd Memorial Complex in Yerevan, 
Armenia, April 24, 2018
Alabama has become the 49th U.S. state to officially recognize Ottoman-era 
killings and deportations of Armenians as genocide.
Kay Ivey, Governor of the State of Alabama, proclaimed April 2019 as Genocide 
Awareness Month.
“We welcome this proclamation by Governor Ivey, making Alabama the 49th state 
in the union to officially re-affirm this international crime against 
humanity,” said Armenian National Committee of America-Eastern Region Board 
Chairman Steve Mesrobian.
“This proclamation serves as a powerful reminder that truth about genocides 
should never be held hostage to the denial of its perpetrators and those who 
continue to profit from that crime.”
Thus, all U.S. states except Mississippi have recognized the Armenian Genocide.
Since the 1960s, the Armenian community of the United States has sought 
Washington’s reaffirmation that the massacres of 1.5 million Armenians in 
Ottoman Turkey in 1915 constituted genocide and its condemnation of the crime. 
However, the White House leaders have generally avoided the use of the term 
genocide in their annual addresses and offered their support in the 
reconciliation of Armenians and Turks.
The 44th and 45th U.S. Presidents, Barack Obama and Donald Trump, used the 
Armenian expression “Meds Yeghern” in their April 24 messages.
Press Review
“Zhoghovurd” comments on the statement made by Armenian Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian during yesterday’s press conference that despite the smear campaigns 
on which “former government representatives every day spend millions of 
dollars, they still cannot get the support of the people.” “Indeed, the 
division between the former governing force and the people only grew wider over 
the past two decades and the society for years rejected that government and 
last year it finally succeeded in ousting it… But still one should not 
underestimate the opponent no matter how unenviable its situation is, 
especially that this opponent is spending huge sums of money for 
counterpropaganda against the Pashinian government,” the paper says.
“Haykakan Zhamanak” writes: “The Armenian media field is full of reports about 
planned protests and expected larger-scale demonstrations. An ordinary citizen 
does not understand well what is taking place in the country. What is taking 
place is that on the one hand there is quite a large segment in Armenia – the 
former authorities and circles linked to them – those who got richer under the 
previous government and who not only lost power and their comfort in the 
passing months, but also at every moment face the prospect of appearing behind 
bars. On the other hand, Armenia indeed has serious socio-economic, security, 
demographic and other problems to solve which serious financial means are 
required. The former authorities skillfully turn into occasions for propaganda 
any attempt to change something, optimize or restore justice in the tax field, 
awakening anti-government sentiments in society. In other words, they from the 
beginning torpedo any attempt to increase the budget.”
“Zhamanak” comments on Pashinian’s statement that Armenia is discussing with 
the European Union not the issue of shutting down the nuclear power plant, but 
the issue of creating equivalent capacities: “At first glance, it seems that 
equivalent capacities means the same amount of energy production that would 
allow closing one energy producer, having a new one, and thus not having a 
shortage of production. But the issue is more than that. For example, is a 
thermal power plant equivalent to a nuclear power plant? It is clear that only 
production capacity and cost of production cannot be considered equivalent in 
the deep sense of this word, because Armenia receives gas from abroad and in 
the case with the nuclear power plant it gets the nuclear fuel once and for 
quite a long period of time…There is also perhaps the most important political, 
geopolitical and even military-political component that a nuclear power plant 
has and no other energy producing facility has. A nuclear power plant is more 
than politics as nuclear technology at present is a desirable resource even for 
very developed, strong states.”
(Lilit Harutiunian)
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2019 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
www.rferl.org

Armenia sides with Russia again, this time in Syria

New Eastern Europe


Even after the change of power last year, Armenia continues to adhere to Russia on foreign policy and tolerate Russia’s massive role domestically. Most recently, this is demonstrated by Armenia supporting Russia’s vast military effort in support of the Syrian regime.

Abbas Zeynalli Rusif Huseynov

On February 8th, the Armenian Defense Ministry declared that 83 Armenian specialists – doctors, de-miners and security officers – will be dispatched to the Syrian city of Aleppo. According to the news release, this group was to provide humanitarian aid to the Syrian people. Severe humanitarian conditions, UN Security Council’s Resolutions 2393 (2017) and 2401 (2018), Syria’s formal requests, as well as Aleppo’s big Armenian community have been referred to as the main reasons for the deployment of the so-called non-combat team, which is supposed to work in those areas which are not engaged in any military operations.

This action is actually not the first engagement of Armenia in the Syrian civil war. Since the outbreak of the conflict, thousands of Syrian refugees, mainly of Armenian origin, were accepted by the South Caucasian nation. However, some of the refugees were illegally settled in Nagorno Karabakh, an Armenian-occupied conflict area which is internationally recognised as part of neighboring Azerbaijan.

Answering Moscow’s call

While some questioned the legality of the action, as Armenian law has no provisions for protecting civilians or involving its military personnel in such humanitarian activities, several politicians spoke out against the government’s decision. For instance, Hovsep Khurshudyan believes that Russia dragged Armenia into the Syrian conflict, which will have unpredictable consequences for Armenia, which has not received and will not receive anything in return.

The first international reaction to the Armenian team naturally came from Syrian dictator Bashar Assad’s key ally Russia, who covered the trip’s logistics and security issues. On the same day, Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu thanked his Armenian counterpart David Tonoyan, stating, “You were the first to respond to our call to provide assistance to the Syrian people”. The hypocrisy of this Russian statement, given that Russia is largely responsible for the Syrians’ suffering, is nothing new from Putin’s government[.

For a long time, at least since 2012, the Kremlin had been seeking support for its Syrian partner from its military allies. Although some news on a CSTO peacekeeping mission circulated in the following years, with Russia being especially interested in involving Central Asian Muslim countries Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, those speculations never materialised as other CSTO members seemed less enthusiastic to get engaged in the bloody conflict.

The negotiations on possible Armenian participation in the Syrian war started a few years earlier. In 2016, the Russian and Armenian foreign ministers discussed the deployment of army sappers to the Syrian town of Palmyra. These discussions took place during the presidency of Serzh Sargsyan, openly pro-Russian, who stepped down as a result of the Armenian revolution in spring 2018. The protests were led by Nikol Pashinyan, who had long criticised his predecessors foreign policies, opposing Armenia’s joining the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU) and calling it a “serious threat” to Armenia.

What revolution?

Therefore, Armenia`s teaming up with Russia in Syria now should raise some questions about Yerevan`s post-revolution government; Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and his team have already worsened their relations with Moscow but was nto willing to make any dramatic U-turn westward either, despite the expectations both from within and outside of Armenia.

In fact, the current government’s Syria deal with Russia was announced back in summer 2018, when Pashinyan disclosed on August 17th 2018 that Yerevan and Moscow were to undertake an “unprecedented humanitarian initiative”, as he called it, in the Middle East. Later in September, both Pashinyan and Defense Minister Tonoyan confirmed Armenia`s plans of dispatching troops to Syria.

The negative reaction by the United States arrived immediately in September 2018, during the visit of U.S. National Security Adviser John Bolton to Yerevan. The top official warned Armenia against sending its troops to Syria to back up government forces or their allies. “It would be a mistake for anybody else to get involved militarily in the Syrian conflict at the moment… There are already … seven or eight different combatant sides. To get involved with anyone of them for any other country would be a mistake,” he noted.

In February 2019, the U.S. Embassy to Armenia issued a special statement of the State Department, which “did not welcome” the initiative: “We do not support any interaction with the Syrian Armed Forces, regardless of whether it is about providing assistance to civilians or is of a military nature”.

This action was cited as why the planned visit of Armenian Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan to Washington was canceled by the U.S. State Department, which followed a conversation between Mnatsakanyan and John Bolton.

Interestingly enough, Armenian plans were announced and then realised amidst and despite the tensions between Yerevan and Moscow, as well as within the CSTO. Having not heavily interfered with the revolution and post-revolution processes in Armenia, the Russian authorities still did not welcome Armenia’s new officials warmly. Moscow seemed particularly upset with Pashinyan’s policies and attempts to bring to trial his pro-Russian predecessors.

As for the CSTO, during the Khachaturov case, when the post of Secretary General of the organization became vacant and the Armenian authorities tried to fill in the position with another representative[, they faced the resistance of other member-states, especially Belarus and Kazakhstan. The situation has fully exposed Armenia’s vulnerable position in the organization.

Among the main factors of Armenia`s decision to enter Syria could be Pashinyan`s desire to appease Putin, who considers any revolutions and attempts at democracy in Russia`s “near abroad” – neo-imperial objective – a threat. Moscow may have been especially interested in such a serious move in order to demonstrate to the Western community Armenia`s alliance with Russia despite the increased pro-Western sentiments in Armenian society, the cooling of Armenian-Russian relations and inner problems within the CSTO.

It is not the first time Armenia has openly sided with Russia against the West. After the violent and illegal annexation of Crimea into Russia, an event condemned by many countries, especially the Western community and those who support international rule of law, Armenian President Serzh Sargsyan was the first person to congratulate Vladimir Putin on a happy annexation. No surprise then that Armenia was also one of the 11 states which voted against the United Nations Resolution calling upon the states not to recognise changes in status of the Crimean region.

A humanitarian mission sent by the new government is said to either appease Putin or to acquire some concessions (e.g. non-interference in Armenia’s domestic policy) from the Kremlin.

No matter what could be the calculations of the post-revolution Armenian authorities who replaced a pro-Russian government, it is obvious that they cannot turn to the West or even balance between Russia and the West without overwhelming resistance from Russia’s government. Russia`s omnipresence in Armenia (Russian military bases, the dominance of Russian companies in the Armenian economy) leaves little or no room for maneuver for Yerevan, making it virtually impossible to shift its domestic and foreign policies.

It will be too difficult for Armenia to get rid of the Russian umbrella and diversify its foreign and security policies, given that the landlocked and resource-short nation has problems and sealed borders simultaneously with two of its neighbors – Turkey and Azerbaijan. Moscow`s relatively calm attitude towards the Armenian Maidan (unlike the cases of other color revolutions in the post-Soviet space) may also stem from the fact that the Russian authorities are fully aware of their strong positions in Armenia and realise that this country cannot dis-anchor from Russian sphere of influence. Perhaps the revolution did not change that much.

Rusif Huseynov is the Co-Founder of the Topchubashov Center, Azerbaijan. His main interest is peace and conflict studies, while his focus areas cover mainly Eastern Europe, the Middle East, the Caucasus and Central Asia.

Abbas Zeynalli is a Research Fellow from the Topchubashov Center, Azerbaijan. His areas of interest include the Middle East, Chinese foreign policy, the South Caucasus and European integration. 

NATO Secretary General’s Special Representative for the Caucasus and Central Asia to arrive in Armenia

NATO Secretary General’s Special Representative for the Caucasus and Central Asia to arrive in Armenia

Save

Share

14:34, 9 March, 2019

YEREVAN, MARCH 9, ARMENPRESS. NATO Secretary General’s Special Representative for the Caucasus and Central Asia James Appathurai will arrive in Armenia in the sidelines of “NATO week”. ARMENPRESS reports Appathurai will give a press conference on March 11.

NATO week is initiated by the embassies of NATO member states in Armenia with close collaboration with the Foreign and Defense Ministries of Armenia.


Edited and translated by Tigran Sirekanyan




Asbarez: With a Focus on Youth, ARF Western US Celebrates 128th Anniversary

BY ASBAREZ

GLENDALE—The Armenian Revolutionary Federation Western United States Central Committee celebrated the 128th anniversary of the organization during an event on Sunday, February 24 at the Glendale High School Auditorium, that featured as its keynote speaker the chairman of the ARF Bureau Hagop Der Khachadourian.

This year’s event was also dedicated to the Armenian youth, as the torchbearer of the Armenian Cause for the future, with the speakers emphasizing the imperative role the youth play in the advancement of the national aspirations of the Armenian Nation. A special video presentation highlighted the activities of the Armenian Youth Federation, the Armenian Youth Federation’s Junior Organization, the ARF Shant Student Association, AYF Camp and the organization’s youth-centric activities in the homeland.

A moving part of the ceremony was the procession of more than 100 AYF Junior novices who took their “Promise to Service,” officiated by Sanan Shirinian, a member of the ARF Shant Student Association and Principal of Orange County’s Ari Guiragos-Minassian School.

The commitment by the youth to shepherd the Armenian Cause into the future and the critical role young people have played in our history, as well as in the present, was highlighted by Mirna Kassamanian, who delivered remarks on behalf of the AYF.

“The future of the Armenian Nation rests on the shoulders of the Armenian youth around the world,” said Kassamanian, who pointed to the decisive role the youth played in last spring’s popular movement—Velvet Revolution—that toppled the oppressive Armenian government to usher in a new day for Armenia and all Armenians.

“That [Velvet] revolution stamped the soul of every young Armenian to aspire to climb new heights,” added Kassamanian.

In his keynote remarks, Der Khachadourian, the ARF Bureau chairman, eloquently and comprehensively outlined the positions of the party vis-à-vis the myriad and complex challenges facing the Armenian Nation. He explained that the ARF, having been born to serve the people, has the mammoth task of ensuring the strengthening of Armenia, being uncompromising in the Artsakh struggle and realignment of the Diaspora to effectively address the needs of the nation.

“In the 21st century, the Armenian people and the homeland represent a diverse reality, where on the one hand, the Armenian people during the last 30 years have attained massive achievements—Armenia is independent; Artsakh is liberated; the people of Javakhk have firmly planted their feet to their soil; and the Diaspora has matured politically and is at the forefront—huge achievements, about which we could only dream in our youth,” said Der Khachadourian.

“On the other hand,” the ARF Bureau chairman added, “the Armenian people naturally are facing enormous challenges—the Artsakh issue; the political and socio-economic situation in Armenia; the defense of the basic rights of the Armenians in Javakhk; the reinvigoration and strengthening of the Diaspora; the reawakening of the Armenian living on historic lands; and the new aspects of the pursuit of the Armenian Cause.”

Der Khachadourian said that the Armenian Revolutionary Federation has a unique role in all the aforementioned aspects, with it global presence, adding that ARF is not merely a political party that functions in the homeland, it is that large force that works for the realizations of the aspirations of the Armenian people.

The Bureau chairman meticulously outlined the ARF’s activities since last spring’s popular movement in Armenia, which toppled the old regime, as well as the steps the party has taken since the December 9, 2018 parliamentary elections, as a result of which, the party has become an extra-parliamentary force.

Der Khachadourian made it clear that the ARF is unequivocal in its unwavering efforts to strengthen the homeland. It is relentless in ensuring that compromises are not made in the Artsakh issue, the successes of which were won through the sacred blood of our people. The ARF, he said, will continue to advance a just resolution of the Armenian Cause and pursue the recognition of and reparations for the Armenian Genocide. Through its worldwide structure and vast Diaspora presence and influence, the party will stop at nothing to advance the just aspirations of the Armenian Nation, because “for us our biggest asset is our homeland and for the Diaspora, the biggest focus and ambition is a return to the homeland.”

Melkon Melkonian delivered the evening’s message on behalf of the ARF Western U.S. Central Committee. He boldly challenged those who have questioned the ARF’s motives and mission and delineated the many accomplishments by individual chapters and the region as a whole—all projects and programs that aim to strengthen the homeland and advance the Armenian identity abroad.

“For those who ask, what or what the Tashnagtsutyun is: It is that same organization who led the formation of the First Armenian Republic in 1918; it is that same organization that sough and executed justice for the perpetrators of the Armenian Genocide; It is the same organization that organized and preserved our diasporas all over the world, by building schools, churches, and community centers to serve the needs of our people; it is the same organization that stopped at nothing to send aid to our brothers and sisters in Artsakh; it is the same organization that continues to tirelessly work for our people and nation,” said Melkonian in his remarks.

“Today standing before you, I do not want to merely recount our past successes, but I want to tell you—I must tell you—about our work and accomplishments; because as we celebrate today, we are also here to stand accountable to you, our people, from whom we were born, for who we exist. The success of that work does not belong to an individual, or even a group of individuals, it belongs to the collective strength of the ARF in our region,” added Melkonian, who went on to list some of the projects launched and initiated that have advanced the true calling of the ARF.

In keeping with tradition, the evening’s program began with a procession of flags and the signing of the National Anthems led by the Homenetmen Western Region scouts and marching band. Another presentation at the event, which has become customary over the years, was the in memoriam video, which honored those ARF members who passed away during the past year.

The program was interspersed with cultural performances, among them a dance performance by the Ararat Dance Ensemble under the direction of Albert Vartanyan; and rendition of patriotic song by the singer Mkrtich “makitch” Mkrtchyan. The evening finale was a thunderous performance by the Rose and Alex Pilibos Armenian School Choir, directed by Lucine Melksetyan who was accompanied on the piano by Sofi Sarkisyan.

Lydian warns: Armenian government bears full responsibility for possible environmental degradation at Amulsar deposit

Arminfo, Armenia
Feb 18 2019
Alexandr Avanesov

ArmInfo.The Armenian government bears full responsibility for the deterioration of the environment, water and air in the Amulsar field in case any  environmental problem occurs. This is stated in the warning of  “Lydian” company received by the ArmInfo.

 According to the source,  since June 2018, Lydian, because of the blockade of roads, has not  been able to resume work at the Amulsar field. Not only the  construction work was not carried out, but also the construction of  protective environmental protection systems, in order to manage  erosion due to heavy spring precipitation and surface water, in  accordance with the conditions and permits issued to the company.  Lydian informed the government that the company was not responsible  for any environmental problems, including the exclusion of surface  waters, the occurrence of which was the result of the government’s  inability to take measures to eliminate the illegal blockade from  June 2018.

“Lydian” has repeatedly applied to the government to take the  necessary actions. This winter, heavy snowfall was recorded at the  Amulsar deposit. Under the conditions of illegal blocking, it was not  possible to build systems to prevent the appearance of surface water.  These activities had to be  carried out before snowfall. In the event  of resumption of work, it will take months to complete the  construction of water management systems. In this situation, the  Armenian government bears full responsibility for the deterioration  of the environment, water and air in the Amulsar field in case any  environmental problem occurs, the company warns. 

To note over the recent six months, protest actions were held against  several mining companies, including the Amulsar program, protesters  blocked roads and created obstacles for employees. The protests  against the Amulsar project led to a confrontation with the staff of  Lydian Armenia, who demanded that the protesters not interfere with  their right to work. Participants in the protest declared that there  are environmental problems, which the company refutes.

Lydian Armenia is a subsidiary of British Lydian International, whose  shareholders are major international institutional investors. The  Amulsar project is the largest industrial project in Armenia today  for the development of the Amulsar gold deposit, with a total value  of $ 370 million. Preparatory work has been going on since 2006. The  life of the Amulsar deposit should have been 10 years and 4 months;  it was planned to mine an average of 200 thousand ounces of gold  (about 10 million tons of ore) annually. The Amulsar program  envisaged the creation of 1,300 jobs during construction  (construction work will last about 2 years) and 650-700 jobs during  the entire field operation.