Movses Hakobyan: Army Capable of Maintaining Ceasefire

Movses Hakobyan: `Our army is capable of maintaining the ceasefire in
the conflict zone’

10-05-2008 13:32:10 – KarabakhOpen

An interview with NKR Defense Minister General-Lieutenant Movses
Hakobyan

Q – Mr. Hakobyan, I’d first like to congratulate you on the anniversary
of the liberation of Shushi and my first question relates to it. What
was the significance of Shushi’s liberation for Karabakh?

A – Thanks for the congratulations. As for the significance of the
liberation of Shushi in terms of Karabakh we can look at the issue from
several angles. As a commander in the military services of the republic
I would single out only two factors. First, the victory won in Shushi
restored Armenians with the belief that they could rely on their own
strengths and lead them to take solace in one overriding truth. That is
if you wish to command the respect and esteem of others first see to it
that you can defend yourself and that you master the skills to
neutralize the threat posed by the enemy, when the need arises.
Secondly, the operation involving the liberation of Shushi showed that
victory is inevitable if you have a leadership force and an army with
all its prerequisite structures in place. Yes, these were the two
important lessons that Armenians learned on May 9, 1992 and served as
the core of their future dazzling victories.

Q – The Azeri military budget grows yearly. Won’t this upset the
balance of power? What steps are being taken to maintain the balance?

A – Lately, I’ve answered this question on several occasions and I must
confess that the yearly increase in the Azeri military budget is of
concern and only goes to show the aggressive intentions of Baku. Let me
add however that in the final analysis every military budget gets its
final evaluation on the battlefield. In passing I should also note that
during the war itself the Azeri military budget outstripped our battle
expenses many fold but as it turned out Baku couldn’t translate this
superiority into victory. I don’t believe that it is possible to obtain
an advantage or upset the relation of forces merely through additional
military expenditures. Success is achieved not so much through the
growth of the military budget but rather as a result of the more
efficient and targeted utilization of the resources at hand. And I can
assure you that we’re accomplishing this otherwise Azerbaijan wouldn’t
have tolerated the ceasefire for fourteen straight years.

Q – Lately American-Armenian analyst Richard Giragosian stated in an
article that the military preparedness of the Azeri army was less than
its military expenditures would indicate. Do you agree with this
evaluation?

A – If I wasn’t an army commander but still possessed all the
information regarding the Azeri armed forces that I do know, perhaps
I’d agree with Mr. Giragosian. But my responsible position within the
government obligates me to overestimate the resources of our potential
opponent. It is incorrect to underestimate the enemy and we cannot
afford to make such a mistake.

Q – According to several studies the south Caucasus region is the most
militarized in all of Europe. Do you agree with this viewpoint? In
general, is the arms race a danger or a guarantor of security today?

A – Given that there are still a number of unresolved conflicts in our
region the arms build-up is perhaps inevitable. We are thus forced to
view the process as both a threat to and a guarantor of security. This
is the situation confronting us today and we must take it into account
in all our decision-making.

Q – The NKR army is considered to be the most fighting-ready force in
the Transcaucasus. Is this still the case today?

A – I am not the person to talk about this…There are higher bodies
that periodically evaluate what we have accomplished. But it remains an
indisputable fact that for many consecutive years our army has
succeeded in maintaining the ceasefire in the conflict zone and
ensuring the peaceful livelihood of our people without the intervention
of a third force. All this speaks to the high level of our army’s
military preparedness. Those high marks given to our army from time to
time, rather than lull us into a false sense of satisfaction, serve to
make us work even harder. As to the comparison regarding various armies
in the region, as always, I’d rather hear about that from others than
myself.

Q – The Karabakh war is included in the curriculum being taught in
military academies in Russia. What was it about the Karabakh War that
has made it required subject matter in Russian military instruction?

A – Generally, the study of the lessons derived from various wars is
vital in establishing a top-level school of military science. It is not
by accident that 2007 was declared to be the `Year to reassess our
army’s track record and to appreciate our best traditions’, during
which the main emphasis was placed on those military operations that
took place in the Artsakh liberation war that can garner the interest
of any given specialist in the field of the military arts, with their
uniqueness and operational characteristics. Of particular interest are
the operations conducted by small detachments, their quick redeployment
from one battle front to another, the characteristics inherent in
creating army structures parallel to carrying out military operations,
etc. Naturally, these are narrow specialist issues whose study and
dissemination require more time. I am convinced that many others will
study the lessons culled from our war as well in the future.

Q – What’s your evaluation of the negotiation process?

A – I am convinced that the negotiations taking place under the
auspices of the OSCE constitute the only avenue leading to the peaceful
settlement of the Karabakh conflict.

Q – In your estimation what’s the probability that Azerbaijan will
resume military operations or do you think those bellicose declarations
were merely pre-election campaign rhetoric?

A – Regardless of whether those statements reflect a willingness on the
part of Azerbaijan to resume military operations or not, our forces are
always in the necessary state of military preparedness and will
effectively confront any military challenge whenever the need arises.
As to the probability that warfare might resume I must tell you that,
given my official position, I am obliged to confront such an
eventuality at any moment, even right now as we speak…

Pope, Armenian patriarch pray for restored unity

Catholic World News
May 9 2008

Pope, Armenian patriarch pray for restored unity

Vatican, May. 9, 2008 (CWNews.com) – At a midday meeting on May 9 with
the leader of the Armenian Apostolic Church, Pope Benedict XVI (bio –
news) looked forward to Pentecost Sunday and said, "we will pray in a
particular way for the unity of the Church."

The Holy Father was joined by Catholicos Karekin II in an ecumenical
prayer service in the Clementine Hall of the apostolic palace. Karekin
was accompanied by a number of Armenian bishops and a large group of
lay faithful of the Armenian Apostolic Church.

"If our hearts and minds are open to the Spirit of communion, God can
work miracles again in the Church, restoring the bonds of unity," the
Pope said. "Striving for Christian unity is an act of obedient trust
in the work of the Holy Spirit."

Recalling the breakthroughs in ecumenical dialogue with the Armenian
Church over the past several years, the Pope said that the two
churches must pray "that the day will come when our unity in faith
makes possible a common celebration of the Eucharist." The immediate
predecessors of the two Church leaders, Pope John Paul II (bio – news)
and Catholicos Karekin I, signed a theological accord that settled the
major Christological disputes that have divided the churches for 15
centuries. A joint commission is now working toward common agreements
on remaining theological differences.

Catholicos Karekin, during brief remarks that he delivered at the
Pope’s public audience on Wednesday, May 7, had called for a general
recognition of the Armenian genocide. Pope Benedict responded to that
plea during their Friday meeting, and also alluded to the oppression
of religious faith under the Communist regime, noting that "the recent
history of the Armenian Apostolic Church has been written in the
contrasting colors of persecution and martyrdom, darkness and hope,
humiliation and spiritual re-birth."

In more recent years, the Pope continued, "the restoration of freedom
to the Church in Armenia has been a source of great joy for us all."
He praised the leadership of the Armenian patriarchs, under whose
leadership "the glorious light of Christ shines again in Armenia and
the saving words of the Gospel can be heard once more."

Meeting

MEETING

Hayots Ashkhar Daily
Published on May 08, 2008
Armenia

According to the preliminary agreement, on May 6, Armenian Foreign
Minister Edward Nalbandyan, who is in Strasburg to participate in 118th
Session of Council of Europe Committee of Ministers, met with
Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Elmar Mamediarov, in the Permanent
Representation of France in the Council of Europe. An extended meeting
in the presence of OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs Bernard Fassier, Mathew
Braise, Yury Merzlyakov, and the representative of OSCE
Chairman-in-Office Kasprchik followed the meeting.

After the meeting Edward Nalbandyan informed the journalists that the
meeting between the Ministers was of familiarization nature and the two
Ministers expressed opinions regarding Karabakh process. The Ministers
will introduce the results of the discussions to the two Presidents,
who will decide their future steps.

‘Adoration’ gets love

Daily Variety
May 7, 2008 Wednesday

‘Adoration’ gets love

by WINTER MILLER

NEW YORK

Sony Pictures Classics has picked up domestic and select international
rights to Atom Egoyan’s "Adoration."

Pic, starring Rachel Blanchard, Scott Speedman, Arsinee Khanjian and
Devon Bostick, will preem in Competition at Cannes on May 22. Release
plans are to platform with a bow in the fourth quarter of this year.

Foreign territories in the deal include Latin America, Australia and
New Zealand, with additional rights still available through Maximum
Film Intl.

Contempo drama concern a teen who creates a false Internet persona and
goes in search of a family secret. Pic marks the seventh collaboration
between Egoyan and producer Robert Lantos.

In addition to Egoyan and Lantos, "Adoration" producers are Simone
Urdl and Jennifer Weiss, with Marcy Gerstein as associate producer.

Separately, Egoyan has nabbed the 2008 Dan David Prize for the arts,
which carries a $1 million purse to be shared with his fellow winners,
author Amos Oz and playwright Tom Stoppard. Cited for "superb
modernist filmmaking that explores Armenian history and culture,"
Egoyan will be honored with the others on May 19 in Israel before
President Shimon Peres.

BAKU: Armenian DM: "We should always be ready to resist any threat"

Today.Az, Azerbaijan
May 5 2008

Armenian Defense Minister: "We should always be ready to resist any
threat"

05 May 2008 [10:37] – Today.Az

Armenian people should always be ready to resist any threat.

The due announcement was made by Armenian Defense Minister Seyran
Oganyan, visiting military parts in Tavush region of the country on
the Azerbaijani border.

"The people of Armenia should realize that this is our reality, we
locate in such a geopolitical region and are in such
military-political situation that we should always be ready to resist
any threat", said Oganyan.

Oganyan noted commenting on the announcements of the Azerbaijani side
about readiness of return the lands occupied by Armenians that their
purpose is "to prepare their people and settle internal political
problems".

"In this connection, we do not underestimate their activity and
transformations in their army. On the contrary, we draw certain
conclusions, in particular, for raising the combativeness of our armed
forces", said the Defense Minister.

According to the Armenian Foreign Minister, Armenian side maintains
the balance of powers in the sense of quality. Owing to this quality,
we have once won the war for national independence", said Oganyan.

/Novosti-Armenia/

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/politics/44767.html

DUBAI: Ex-inmate argues with Dubai judge in warden case

Gulf News, United Arab Emirates
May 5 2008

Ex-inmate argues with Dubai judge in warden case

By Bassam Za’za’, Senior Reporter
Published: May 05, 2008, 00:28

Dubai: A frightened former inmate from Egypt and a judge had an
argument in court on Sunday because the former inmate was afraid he
would not be sent back to Egypt if he had to testify now.

The Egyptian completed his sentence last week and will be deported.

The judge warned the 28-year-old Egyptian that his imprisonment would
be extended if he refused to testify before the Dubai Court of First
Instance’s bench of three judges.

The argument between the frightened inmate, S.J., and Presiding Judge
Fahmi Mounir lasted about five minutes.

S.J., who is an essential prosecution witness in the case of 25 prison
wardens being tried for abusing their authority and beating inmates,
persistently told Presiding Judge Mounir: "I repeat the statement I
made before the Public Prosecution. I don’t want to testify because I
just completed my punishment and I want to get deported. I am afraid
if I testify I won’t get deported."

"You have to testify. The court and the Public Prosecution are
different things. I will extend your detention if you keep on
refusing," warned the judge.

Eventually S.J. agreed, and testified: "I was hit by three suspects. I
was forced to lie on my stomach while they beat me."

When asked by the judge to identify who beat him from among the 25
wardens who were present at courtroom four, he pointed at two of the
defendants.

Defence lawyers, including Khalifa Al Salman, Ali Mosabah, Amal Bakri,
Kawthar Marwan, Samir Jaafar and Nabih Badr, also questioned
S.J. during the 9am hearing.

The Public Prosecution charged some of the accused with abusing their
power and beating 41-year-old Armenian inmate, S.K., who was later
deported. He sustained a ten per cent permanent disability to his
spinal cord.

Other building

"I didn’t see anyone beat S.K. because he was detained in another
building. Some inmates alleged that S.K. was beaten, while others
claimed he fell down the stairs," said the Egyptian witness.

The accused, excluding the former director of the prison, were all
charged with injuring inmates by using excessive force against
them. The former director and one of the lieutenants were charged with
inciting the others to commit violent and abusive acts.

EU: Turkey faces lingering political crisis

PanARMENIAN.Net

EU: Turkey faces lingering political crisis
05.05.2008 18:38 GMT+04:00

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Turkey is facing a political crisis.
The struggle between different political parties
involves Turkey into a lingering political crisis,
said Olli Rehn, the European Union’s Commissioner for
Enlargement.

Turkey’s Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan also
warned against negative consequences of banning his
AKP. `Our economy will be damaged. We already witness
outflow of foreign capital. We are accused on
intention to impose the Shariath on secular Turkey.
But we are a party of ordinary Turks. Faithful Turks
are defenders of secular state. Turkey managed to
maintain balance between Islam and democracy, RFE/RL
reports.

In March 2008, the Turkish Constitutional Court said
it will consider a request to ban the ruling political
party of PM Erdogan.

Earlier, the CC banned two parties for using religion
for political purposes.

Armenian and Azerbaijani FM meet in Strasbourg

Armenian and Azerbaijani FM meet in Strasbourg

2008-05-07 10:07:00

ArmInfo. Foreign Minister of Armenia Edward Nalbandyan, being in
Strasbourg for participation in the118th session of CE Ministerial
Committee, met Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov,
according to the preliminary agreement.

As RA FM Information and Press Department told ArmInfo today, the
meeting was held in the permanent representation of France in the
Council of Europe. According to the message, a meeting with OSCE MG
co-chairs Bernard Fassier (France), Matthew Bryza (USA), Yuri
Merzliakov (Russia) and Personal Representative of OSCE Chair-in-Office
Andrzej Kasprzyk was held after the meeting the two countries
ministers. Upon completion of the meeting, E. Nalbandyan told
journalists that the ministerial meeting was of fact-finding nature,
the parties exchanged opinions regarding Karabakh conflict settlement,
presented their countries’ approaches and agreed to go on with
negotiations. The ministers will introduce the results of discussions
to the presidents and the latters will make a decision on further
actions.

Iraqi refugees need Christian solidarity

Today.az, Azerbaijan
May 6 2008

Iraqi refugees need Christian solidarity

By Annegret Kapp
6 May 2008

"Although I had been threatened many times in Iraq, I did not want to
leave," says the Armenian Orthodox hairdresser Cayran. "But then my
shop was burnt and the car of my husband, who used to work as a
driver, was robbed. So we left everything behind and fled to Syria."

"Stories of lost loved ones, the sudden need to flee home and
community and the hardship of life as refugees need to be told. And
those who have the power to help end the tragedy of being a refugee
need to listen."

At an April 2008 meeting of Iraqi Christian refugees and church
representatives from around the world at the Greek Orthodox
Patriarchate of Antioch and All the East in Damascus, Iraqi Christians
who are now refugees in Syria spoke as church members from the US,
Germany, Lebanon, Pakistan and Sweden, along with the general
secretaries of the World Council of Churches and Middle East Council
of Churches listened.

What the church representatives heard were stories of incredible
suffering in Iraq and overflowing hospitality in Syria. They heard
about the pain of living in Iraq and eventually leaving. They heard of
the strain the influx of 1.5 million Iraqi refugees have placed on the
economy of Syria creating the need for jobs, safety and security
despite the unanswered questions of what next for the Iraqis.

The prices for food and housing are skyrocketing, and it is extremely
hard to find a well-paid job. "Even if there were no refugees, the
economy would have to create thousands of job opportunities a year in
order to integrate our young people who join the labour market," Samer
Laham, director of ecumenical relations at the Greek Orthodox
Patriarchate, explained to the visitors from abroad.

That evening many spoke of the trauma suffered by their children and
the insecurity of their future. Cayran said her son cannot speak
normally since he closely escaped a kidnapping.

"Animals live better lives than human beings in Iraq," said Samira, a
Syrian Orthodox refugee. "At least they have the freedom to move. We
were even too afraid to go to church because people were kidnapped
from church."

One day, when she was still living in Iraq, Samira went shopping with
her daughter. "Three gunmen stopped us. They pushed my daughter around
and asked her why she was in the street without a veil. Since then,
she did not want to leave home and she dropped out of university."

Aram, who had been a member of the Armenian Orthodox Church in
Baghdad, said: "My wife and I knew some Christians who were killed. As
our numbers were on their mobile phones, their murderers used them to
call and threaten us."

Aram also told about the mistrust that is poisoning communities in
Iraq: "We had some friends, who turned out to work for the Mahdi
Army. We thought they were friends, but they took our pictures in
order to have us killed."

Incidents such as the publishing of the prophet Muhammad cartoons in
Denmark in 2005 benefit the extremists, who use them to justify their
hidden agenda to kick "non-believers" out of the country, Munir from
the Calvinist community in Baghdad is convinced.

"My family was threatened: either you leave within 15 minutes or we
will kill you," Munir described his own experience. He added that they
did not know how serious the threat was, so they went to his sister’s
apartment next door and waited. Really an armed gang arrived. "They
raped our wives, and even my eighty-year-old mother was beaten."

After Munir’s brother-in-law, who had been kidnapped, was freed, the
family left "immediately, without even taking any clothes with us,"
selling the apartment for a fourth of its value.

But life in Syria is not easy, either, as the resources which refugees
managed to bring with them are soon used up, and jobs are hard to
find.

"I have a brother and a sister outside the region," Munir said. "We
depend on them and are a burden on them. But they cannot afford to
send us money all the time."

A psychological burden for many families is the knowledge that any
emergency or illness will find them without protection. Kwarin, a
father of four, left his job with a security company in Baghdad to
join his family in exile and take care of his children. "My wife
urgently needs an operation," he said, "but I have no money to pay for
it."

While the refugees are grateful to Syria and the churches there for
welcoming them, many feel let down by the international
community. Frustration prevails with regard to the Western embassies
who have rejected visa applications again and again.

"Do they want that parents go back to Iraq and get killed before they
allow the children to get out? Must our young women go back and be
raped before they are allowed out?" one man asked angrily.

Cries of "No!" or even "Never!", both in English and Arabic, filled
the room, as the question of whether they want to return to Iraq was
put to the refugees. "Of course I want to go back to my country," a
young woman from Basra explained. "But can you guarantee that I will
not be killed? My relatives went back and were killed in one night."

The Rev Dr Volker Faigle of the Evangelical Church in Germany thanked
the men and women who gave their testimonies to the WCC delegation for
this clear message. "We cannot bring airtickets or visas along," he
acknowledged. "But my church and the Roman Catholic Church in Germany
will join hands and approach the government, the parliament and the
European institutions to tell them what we have seen and heard. (…)
When we return to our countries, we will think of you, we will pray
for you and we will act for you."

The concern felt by Syria’s Christian communities for their sisters
and brothers in and from Iraq was tangible in all the encounters the
WCC delegation had with church leaders.

Patriarch Mor Ignatius Zakka of the Syrian Orthodox Church, who was
himself born in Iraq, told the ecumenical visitors about a priest of
his church who had been killed just one week earlier, after he
conducted the Holy Mass. "We do not want Iraq to be emptied of
Christians but if they are in danger there, how could we tell them to
stay?" asked the patriarch.

Many Christian refugees experienced that in Iraq belonging to a
religious minority is dangerous. "Christians and other minorities are
paying the price of the Iraq war," said Samer Laham, "because they are
suspected of being traitors and of helping the allied forces – as if
they were not an original part of the social fabric and had not shared
the bread with their Muslim brothers since centuries. "

So when they arrive in the host country, Christians put most trust and
expectations for help on the churches. Denominational boundaries, on
the other hand, are easily overcome. "Our church is an open house for
Iraqi either to hold their own services or to join ours, said the
Melkite Greek Catholic Patriarch Gregorios III. He added that his
patriarchate works hand in hand with an Islamic centre to care for
Iraqi refugees, whether they be Christian or Muslim.

Pastor Boutros Zaour, of the Evangelical National Church, said "it is
Syria’s destiny to be hospitable to refugees, ever since the Armenians
fled here from the persecutions they suffered in the Ottoman Empire."

"The personal stories the delegation heard were heartwrenching," said
Clare Chapman, deputy general secretary of the National Council of
Churches USA, at the end of the visit.

"We must pray for the Iraqi refugees and work together as member
churches of the WCC and as citizens of our home countries, to address
the conditions they daily endure. We must take our responsibility
seriously, as people of faith, to do whatever we can to support them
as they try to rebuild the lives they lost through no fault of their
own," she said.

————

(c) Annegret Kapp is web editor for the World Council of Churches
(WCC) and a member of the Evangelical Church in Württemberg, Germany.

http://www.ekklesia.co.uk/node/7079

Pope seeks Christian unity, welcomes head of Armenian Apostolic Chur

Catholic News Agency, CO
May 6 2008

Pope seeks Christian unity, welcomes head of Armenian Apostolic Church

Vatican City, May 6, 2008 / 10:38 am (CNA).- Continuing his efforts to
build Christian unity, Pope Benedict XVI will be welcoming His
Holiness Karekin II, the head of the Armenian Apostolic Church, for a
three day visit, May 6-9.

Karekin II’s trip is one that will include several liturgical
celebrations and opportunities for dialogue with the Roman Catholic
Church. Throughout his visit, he will be accompanied by an entourage
of 18 bishops as well as 75 faithful from Armenia and other countries
in the region.

The schedule for the visit is packed with events.

On Wednesday, after having prayed at the tomb of St. Peter and visited
the statue of St. Gregory the Illuminator, the saint who converted
Armenia to Christianity, Karekin II will be welcomed by Pope Benedict
at the beginning of the general audience in St. Peter’s Square.

In the afternoon, the Catholicos will receive a doctorate "honoris
causa" in "the theology of youth pastoral care" from the Pontifical
Salesian University. Patriarch Karekin is known for his use of
technology, especially television broadcasts, as a tool of
evangelization and outreach, according to the Armenian Church of
America’s web site.

On Thursday, the Patriarch will visit the Pontifical Armenian College
and, during the afternoon, participate in an academic congress being
held at the Pontifical Oriental Institute on "holy sacrifice in the
Armenian tradition".

His Holiness Karekin II and those accompanying him will visit the
offices of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity on
Friday morning.

Benedict XVI will then meet privately with Karekin II in the Vatican
Apostolic Palace. After the private meeting between the two leaders,
the 18 Armenian Apostolic bishops will be received in audience by the
Pope.

Later in the day on Friday, the two church leaders will jointly
preside over a celebration of the Word with the Armenian Apostolic
delegation.

The Catholicos and his entourage will conclude their visit by praying
Vespers at the papal basilica of St. Paul’s Outside-the-Walls.

Karekin II has had good relations with the Roman Catholic Church since
his election in October 1999. A statement issued announcing the visit
describes past joint declarations signed between the Pope and the
Catholicos as significant, since they deal with `questions of great
ecumenical importance in the historical, theological and pastoral
fields.’

http://www.catholicnewsagency. com/new.php?n=12557