European Court delivers judgement on Sargsyan v. Azerbaijan case

In today’s Grand Chamber judgment1 in the case of Sargsyan v. Azerbaijan, the European Court of Human Rights held, by a majority, that there had been:

a continuing violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (protection of property) to the European Convention on Human Rights;

a continuing violation of Article 8 (right to respect for private and family life) of the Convention; and

a continuing violation of Article 13 (right to an effective remedy).

The case concerned an Armenian refugee’s complaint that, after having been forced to flee from his home in the Shahumyan region of Azerbaijan in 1992 during the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh, he had since been denied the right to return to his village and to have access to and use his property there.

In Mr Sargsyan’s case, the Court confirmed that, although the village from which he had to flee was located in a disputed area, Azerbaijan had jurisdiction over it.

The Court considered that while it was justified by safety considerations to refuse civilians access to the village, the State had a duty to take alternative measures in order to secure Mr Sargsyan’s rights as long as access to the property was not possible.

The fact that peace negotiations were ongoing did not free the Government from their duty to take other measures. What was called for was a property claims mechanism which would be easily accessible to allow Mr Sargsyan and others in his situation to have their property rights restored and to obtain compensation.

In today’s Grand Chamber judgment1 in the case of Chiragov and Others v. Armenia  the European Court of Human Rights held, by a majority, that there had been:

a continuing violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (protection of property) to the European Convention on Human Rights;

a continuing violation of Article 8 (right to respect for private and family life) of the Convention; and

a continuing violation of Article 13 (right to an effective remedy).

The case concerned the complaints by six Azerbaijani refugees that they were unable to return to their homes and property in the district of Lachin, from where they had been forced to flee in 1992 during the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh.

The Court considered that there was no justification for denying the applicants access to their property without providing them with compensation. The fact that peace negotiations were ongoing did not free the Government from their duty to take other measures.

What was called for was a property claims mechanism which would be easily accessible to allow the applicants and others in their situation to have their property rights restored and to obtain compensation.

Catholicosate of Cilicia reiterates its demand for the return of its historical seat from Turkey

The Catholicosate of the Holy See of Cilicia has issued a statement to clarify the nature and purpose of its claim for the return of its historical Seat in Sis (present-day Kozan in Turkey), currently pending before the Turkish Constitutional Court:

The lawsuit claims the right of ownership and religious worship with regard to the Monastery and Cathedral of St. Sophia, the Seat of the Catholicosate from 1293 until at least 1921. To comply with the procedures for filing of property claims before the Turkish Constitutional Court, the application indicated a provisional estimated value for the property. The demand however is clearly and emphatically for return of the property and its restoration and use for religious worship, and this demand cannot be satisfied by the payment of monetary compensation.

The claim therefore is for restitution of the property and not for compensation.

The decision of the Catholicosate to initiate this lawsuit was motivated by the historical and religious significance of this property for the Armenian Church and Nation. There are two separate legal grounds for the claim; namely (1) the property rights of the Catholicosate; and (2) the religious rights of the Catholicosate. While the ownership rights of the Catholicosate may raise issues of compensation under Turkish laws and procedures, the rights of religious worship are a separate matter and can only be remedied by return of the property, its restoration and use for worship. This is a non-negotiable demand that will not be withdrawn under any circumstances.

The lawsuit has been submitted to the Turkish Constitutional Court to satisfy the requirement of the exhaustion of domestic remedies as a precondition for any appeal to the European Court of Human Rights. If the Turkish court ruling is not favourable, or if the Turkish Government does not otherwise return the property, the Catholicosate will appeal the decision to the European Court of Human Rights, and seek to enforce its rights under international law.

The lawsuit is a matter of great complexity and sensitivity and the legal process will unfold over the coming months and years. It is unfortunately not possible to reveal all details and aspects of the case while it is still pending before the courts, as this will prejudice the claim of the Catholicosate. During this period, uninformed comments and speculation in the media will not contribute to the success of this historical initiative against the many obstacles it will invariably encounter.

The Catholicosate will pursue every possible means within the law to assert its property and religious rights, to reclaim its historical Seat, and to reclaim the historical heritage of Armenian Church and Nation.

Council of Europe grants to support citizen participation initiatives in four communities in Armenia

Four Armenian communities – Urtsadzor, Ararat Marz, Vardenik, Gegharkunuk Marz, Akhtala, Lori Marz, and Artik, Shirak Marz signed agreements, on 3 June 2015, with the Council of Europe to receive grants for implementing citizen participation initiatives in their communities.

The four communities have been selected through a competitive process and will receive coaching and expert support from the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe.

“This is the first time that the Council of Europe will provide grants to its partners in Armenia,” stated Natalia Voutova, the Head of Council of Europe Office in Yerevan, congratulating partner municipalities.

Starting from June 2015, the four communities will launch citizen participation processes by involving their residents in identifying, prioritising and finding shared solutions to urgent community problems, which will then be included in the following community annual budget.

“These are actually participatory budgeting pilot initiatives, which as a process, practically doesn’t exist in Armenia. We are confident that these “pilots” will be successful. We will assist the dissemination of results and lessons learnt to other local governments throughout Armenia,” concluded Ms Voutova.

This initiative is implemented by the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe as part of the project “Support to consolidating local democracy in Armenia”, which is funded by the Government of Denmark.

Egypt willing to create free trade zone with Eurasian Economic Union

Egypt has sent a request to Russia to create a free trade zone with the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU), Russian Industrial and Trade Minister Denis Manturov said Wednesday, Sputnik News reports.

“An official request from the Egyptian side has been received, today we received a copy of it in order to study it and help them in accordance [with the request] as we are interested,” Manturov said on Rossiya-24 television.

In recent years, Moscow and Cairo have boosted military, trade, security and economic cooperation.

Earlier this week, Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev approved a free trade zone agreement between the EEU and Vietnam.

The EEU, which officially came into force January 1, comprises Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan and Russia. The bloc aims to achieve the free flow of goods, services, capital and labor across its member states, with provisions for a greater integration in the future.

Mary-Jean O’Doherty praises the Welsh support to Armenia at Eurovision 2015

An opera singer from Cardiff will perform in front of millions when she represents Armenia in the Eurovision Song Contest final this weekend.

Mary-Jean O’Doherty, 33, will sing Face The Shadow in Vienna on Saturday as part of the Armenian group Genealogy.

Speaking to , she praised the Welsh support which helped the group through the semi-final on Tuesday.

“It’s just one of those surreal moments where you just think ‘wow’,” she said.

“There was a lot of Armenian flags and Welsh flags as well which was great. There was so much positive energy.”

O’Doherty, born in the United States to an Australian father and a Greek-Armenian mother, has settled in Cardiff with her Welsh husband.

She was selected for this year’s contest by broadcaster Public Television of Armenia.

“I have never been to Armenia and I have always wanted to know about my heritage, about my genealogy,” she added.

“I couldn’t think of a more interesting or outstanding way to do both.”

Beirut’s little Armenia keeps tradition alive

Bourj Hammoud, also known as “Little Armenia,” is a suburb in the Metn district of northern Beirut. The city was created by survivors of the Armenian genocide of 1915, most of whom settled there after the death marches in Deir ez-Zor, Syria. Today, the second generation of Armenians after the genocide are trying to find ways to save their heritage, mainly through the promotion of traditional crafts, Florence Massena writes in an article published by .

In the streets of Bourj Hammoud, you can find plenty of different goods: spices, soaps, candied and dried fruits, wooden ​molds and many others. And nestled together, jewelry, leather goods and tailors’ shops keep open for those interested in handicrafts, with storefronts in Armenian, Arabic and sometimes English.

These shops do not look fancy, yet are a very important trace of Armenian cultural heritage, after 100 years of exile in Lebanon. One of the patrons helping to sustain this culture on a daily basis is Arpi Mangassarian, an architect working in the Bourj Hammoud municipality planning office. In 2009, she helped the French-speaking cultural magazine Agenda Culturel contact local craftsmen for a book.

“I always had a passion for crafts. My father was an artist and a handyman,” she told Al-Monitor. “This book made me realize that these people need promotion. So I restored a traditional pink villa and in 2011 opened the Badguer Cultural Center to organize visits, tours and exhibitions about traditional Armenian crafts. Our role is to put the spotlight on the artisans by bringing visitors to their stores to discover their work, like actors that we bring on stage. We have mainly goldsmiths, especially for Italy, leather shoes and bags, clothes, fabrics for fashion designers, turners and smelters’ shops.”

Badguer’s aim is to help the craftsmen keep their traditions alive and help them face the harsh realities of economics and modernity. “After the Lebanese civil war, there was like an embargo over goods produced in Lebanon for exportation, and cheap-standard goods arrived on the market from China and Syria, for example,” Mangassarian said.

“Many children of the local artisans started to think about taking jobs in big companies so they could provide for their family, so we lost around 40% of the traditional shops in Bourj Hammoud. And it is still going on. … The leather sector is declining because of international competition and deterioration of purchasing power.”

Badguer was founded as a way to enhance and promote the artisans’ activities, putting them in touch with designers, stylists and architects that might be interested in quality traditional goods, but also to show the young generations that they can make money in their parents’ jobs.

“Usually, the fathers teach their children how to work, and they take over their business later on,” Mangassarian said. “I want to make them realize that good work brings good money. All they need now is promotion.”

Ago Karakolmikilian and his brother took over their father’s shoe shop. “It’s a family business, and my father was tired after all these years,” he told Al-Monitor. “I have learned everything from him. For us, it’s a cultural resistance. It’s a hard business, but we need to keep going. Plus, we produce popular and high-quality styles to fit any budget.” For him, Armenian culture has to be perpetuated through “Armenian schools, language and manufacturing, forever.”

Other artisans’ sons decide to add more specialties to their fathers’ activities, and are learning other crafts in schools. That is the case of Roger Astourian, a diamond setter for over 20 years. “I work with my father now, but not like him,” he said. “My father has been a goldsmith for over 50 years, so I work in his store to diversify his business.”

This year, which marks the centenary of the Armenian genocide, the Badguer Center prepared a special cultural program by the name of “The Armenian Rebirth After the Genocide.” For Mangassarian, not focusing on 1915 was very important: “Everyone talks about the genocide, but what happened after? We are people; we have a living culture, artisans that survived and perpetuated through all this time.”

She organized a four-pronged program: an exhibition of 100 Armenian calendars provided by associations and institutions that publish them every year, with poems and images from Armenia and Lebanon; lessons about two Kilim, the flat, tapestry-woven carpets traditionally from the Balkans to Pakistan made on weaving machines that will lead to future carpets and rug exhibitions; an exhibition of Armenian embroidery; and storytelling by people who remember their family histories.

“Usually, the stories are told in private, at home, so it will be new and maybe helpful to keep the memory alive,” she said. “The Armenians transmitted such powerful stories about the past. It is not only about deportation and genocide; it is also about life in the villages before 1915, and also about life in the host countries.”

Arpi herself was raised on these stories, told by her grandparents. She reminisced, “My father used to ask them a lot of questions, so they wouldn’t stop talking. My brother and I unconsciously kept this memory alive through our school compositions, but also through singing and dancing. My mother was part of an Armenian choir interpreting pieces from the traditional composer Komitas, an Armenian priest who is known as the founder of the Armenian national school of music at the beginning of the 20th century, and my grandmother used to dance and sing songs from her village in Armenia.”

This is why she asked people she knew, of her age and younger, to come and tell her their own family stories, which she now wants to record and diffuse. “You know, on these calendars we are going to exhibit, there is a sentence on every page,” she added. “It says, ‘Be proud of your past, be proud and keep your cultural heritage.’ That is what I am trying to do in Bourj Hammoud.”

Iraqi Yezidis hope for Armenia’s support in preventing genocide

 

 

 

The Yezidis in Iraq’s Shangal Province are still being persecuted, enslaved and forced to change religion. President of the “Midia-Shangal” national union of Yezidis Amo Sharoyan says the aim of the Islamic State is to exterminate the Yezidi people from their native land of Shangal. He says “despite the resistance of the Yezidi military brigade, the terrorist organization still keeps 5-6 thousand people, mostly women and girls, in slavery.

Amo Sharoyan has applied to international structures, to foreign diplomatic representations in Armenia, requesting assistance to Iraqi Yezidis. He’s confident, however, that like during the Armenian Genocide, Europe has closed its eyes before justice and has assumed the same policy in the case of Yezidis. His only hope is the Armenian people, the descendants of survivors of the Armenian Genocide.

German President: We Bear Responsibility For Armenia Genocide

GERMAN PRESIDENT: WE BEAR RESPONSIBILITY FOR ARMENIA GENOCIDE

Times of Israel
April 24 2015

Government set to debate resolution on World War I-era killings by
Ottoman allies of German empire

Email the Newsroom Facebook Twitter

Related Topics

Armenian genocide Germany Joachim Gauck

More on this story

Turkey’s Erdogan denies ancestors committed genocide Why Israel still
refuses to recognize a century-old genocide Armenia marks centennial
of Ottoman genocide Poland accepts FBI chief’s regrets on Holocaust
comments Israel sends delegation to Armenian genocide ceremony Urging
recognition, Jerusalem Armenians mark 100th anniversary of genocide
Israel grapples with question of Armenian genocide recognition Armenian
Church canonizes 1.5 million genocide victims

Germany condemns the massacre a century ago of 1.5 million Armenians by
Ottoman forces as a “genocide”, President Joachim Gauck said Thursday,
adding that Germany bore partial blame for the bloodletting.

Get The Times of Israel’s Daily Edition by email and never miss our
top stories Free Sign up!

Gauck’s speech at an event commemorating the centenary marked the
first time that Berlin has officially used the word “genocide” to
describe the killings during World War I, and an unusually strong
acknowledgement of the then-German empire’s role in them.

“In this case we Germans must come to terms with the past regarding
our shared responsibility, possibly shared guilt, for the genocide
against the Armenians,” he said at an ecumenical service in Berlin.

Armenians say up to 1.5 million of their kin were killed between 1915
and 1917 as the Ottoman Empire was falling apart and have long sought
to win international recognition of the massacres as genocide.

Modern Turkey, the successor state to the Ottomans, rejects the claim,
arguing that 300,000 to 500,000 Armenians and as many Turks died in
civil strife when Armenians rose up against their Ottoman rulers and
sided with invading Russian troops.

This 1915 file photo, shows Armenian victims of the massacres in
Turkey. (photo credit: AP Photo, File)

Gauck, a Protestant pastor and former East German dissident, is the
head of state and serves as a kind of moral arbiter for the nation.

His statement was expected to draw an angry reaction from Ankara,
which has close defense and trade ties with Berlin.

Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu said earlier Thursday that
a decision by Austrian lawmakers this week to condemn the massacre as
“genocide” would have “unfavorable repercussions” for bilateral ties.

Ankara on Wednesday recalled its ambassador to Austria in response
to the lawmakers’ condemnation.

Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu, September 12, 2014. (Photo
credit: AFP/ADEM ALTAN)

In his speech at the Berlin Cathedral, Gauck said that the German
empire, then allied with the Ottomans, deployed soldiers who took
part in “planning and, in part, carrying out the deportations”.

German diplomats and observers who reported back to Berlin the
atrocities they witnessed were “ignored” for fear of jeopardizing
relations with the Ottomans, he said.

The presidents of Russia and France — two of nearly two dozen
countries to formally recognize the genocide — are to join a handful
of world leaders attending a commemoration of the massacre in the
Armenian capital Yerevan on Friday.

Germany plans to send a junior foreign minister to the event.

While Gauck clearly labelled the mass murders a genocide, the German
government has backed a compromise resolution to be debated on Friday
in parliament.

“Their fate exemplifies the history of the mass murders, ethnic
cleansing campaigns, expulsions, indeed the genocides that marked the
20th century in such a horrible way,” reads the draft text obtained
by AFP on Monday.

http://www.timesofisrael.com/german-president-we-bears-responsibility-for-armenia-genocide/

Remarks By New York Mayor On Armenian Genocide Centennial

REMARKS BY NEW YORK MAYOR ON ARMENIAN GENOCIDE CENTENNIAL

21:55, 24 Apr 2015
Siranush Ghazanchyan

The Mayor of New York Bill De Blasio has issued a statement on the
occasion of the Centennial of theArmenian Genocide:

“Today, we commemorate the Meds Yeghern and honor those who perished
in the Armenian genocide 100 years ago in one of the worst atrocities
of the 20th century, when over a million Armenians were subjected to
state-sanctioned murder, rape and massive forced deportations.

For many Armenians in New York City and around the world, this
historical trauma is compounded by Turkey’s refusal to recognize the
devastation inflicted upon the Armenian people as an act of genocide.

Pope Francis spoke of this in a recent sermon, and it bears repeating
on this painful anniversary: There cannot be closure on an atrocity
of this magnitude if we do not call it by its name.

The bravery of a new generation of Turks – who are challenging those
in their country who deny this tragedy – is an encouraging step toward
long overdue justice and reconciliation. Against today’s background
of rising religious intolerance, we must take this solemn occasion
to reflect on the past – and to directly confront the discrimination
of the present.”

http://www.armradio.am/en/2015/04/24/remarks-by-new-york-mayor-on-armenian-genocide-centennial/

Armenians In Baghdad Hold Protest March To Turkish Embassy

ARMENIANS IN BAGHDAD HOLD PROTEST MARCH TO TURKISH EMBASSY

17:49 24/04/2015 ” POLITICS

In the framework of the Armenian Genocide Centennial events, the
Armenians of Baghdad have marched towards the Turkish Embassy in
protest against the policy of denial of Turkey, the Facebook page of
the Armenian diocese of Iraq reports.

More than 500 Armenians, with the guidance of the leader of the
Armenian diocese of Iraq, Archbishop Avag Asaturyan, and accompanied
by the representatives of the National Central Department and priests,
have held a protest march towards the Turkish Embassy.

Reaching the Embassy of Turkey, the Chairman of the National Central
Department, Melkon Melkonian, read the protest statement of the
Iraqi Armenians addressed to the authorities of Turkey which was
later pasted on the Embassy walls.

The protest statement was also handed to the local news media which
in their turn widely covered the topic.

It is noted that this is the first case in the history of the Iraqi
Armenian community that such a large-scale event is held.

http://www.panorama.am/en/politics/2015/04/24/baghdad-armenian-genocide/