PAN-ARMENIAN GAMES SEEK ETHNIC UNITY AMIDST DIVISIONS
EurasiaNet, NY
Aug 31 2007
A EurasiaNet Photo Story by Onnik Krikorian
In theory, it was all about unity. But the tensions on display at the
IV Pan-Armenian Games, a mini-Olympics style event that attracted some
2,500 competitors from Armenian communities worldwide, indicated that
divisions can run as deep as consensus in Armenia’s far-flung Diaspora.
On the surface, though, positive PR prevailed. Diaspora members
make up the bulk of the estimated 10 million Armenians worldwide,
and already play a critical role in providing investment in Armenia’s
economy and support for its cultural and educational institutions.
The August 18-26 Games, with events ranging from table tennis to
volleyball and swimming, were meant to strengthen those ties still
further.
As a sign of that aim, Armenian Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian chairs
the Games’ executive committee. Mohammad Aliabadi, vice president
of Iran, which has an estimated ethnic Armenian population of a few
hundred thousand, attended the event’s August 18 opening ceremony in
Yerevan’s Vazgen Sarkisyan soccer stadium.
But domestic politics also played a role. Prime Minister Serzh
Sarkisian, who has announced his intentions to run for president in
2008, took center stage in the August 26 finale, handing out awards
and crowning the most beautiful sportswoman, Miss Pan-Armenian Games.
Perhaps not surprisingly, given the Games’ government ties, the
prime minister was awarded an honorary order by the event’s "world
committee."
Also in attendance was influential pro-government parliamentarian and
oligarch Gagik Tsarukian, chairman of the Prosperous Armenia Party,
who had earlier urged the heads of Diaspora athletic organizations
to involve themselves more in Armenian sports. Tsarukian also used
that opportunity to offer an incentive: a reward of $700,000 to any
of the 20-25 athletes competing for Armenia who wins a gold medal in
Beijing’s 2008 Olympics.
Opposition political activists were given a less warm official
welcome. At the opening ceremony attended by Armenian President
Robert Kocharian, Foreign Minister Oskanian and Armenian Apostolic
Church Catholicos Karekin II, police detained three activists from the
anti-Kocharian Impeachment bloc as they handed out leaflets calling
for the release of alleged political prisoners.
One parliamentary deputy from the opposition Heritage Party, Zaruhi
Postanjian, who works as a human rights lawyer, alleges that stadium
police took a bag containing client documents from her.
Most events, however, were poorly attended, with many local Armenians
unaware of where the venues were situated, and media access was
tightly controlled. Despite accreditations, only film crews from Public
Television H1, which was beaming the Games worldwide via satellite,
were given unrestricted access to competitions.
Some of what was broadcast, however, was as much about existing
divisions within the Diaspora as about building a sense of ethnic
community.
On August 19, things turned ugly when a basketball team from Glendale,
California, attacked their counterparts from the Armenian community
in Istanbul. Local media were not present at the game.
Turkish Armenian players charged that the American-Armenians called
them "dirty Turkish dogs." Representatives of the California team
denied the allegation. Police intervened on court to break up the
ensuing fight and separate the two teams.
Police were again called on court in the game that immediately followed
after local basketball players attacked Egyptian players with their
fists and chairs. Four Diaspora Armenians from Cairo were reportedly
hospitalized as a result. The Yerevan basketball team was disqualified
from the Games the following day allegedly in return for the Cairo
team not pressing charges.
Other Armenians from Muslim countries such Iran, Iraq and Syria,
including those studying in Yerevan, also alleged to reporters
similar taunts.
Local reaction to the Games was muted, with many potential spectators
disinterested or unaware that they were even happening. Zara Gevorgian,
a 21-year-old recent university graduate, attended only because she
says she knew some of the local players taking part. "The opening
ceremony was terrible and reminded me of Komsomol events during
Soviet times," she said. Nor are player fights a rare occurrence,
according to Gevorgian. "Every time I go something happens…"
For the vast majority of those taking part in the Games from the
Diaspora, however, such spars barely registered. Speaking on the
sidelines of a women’s basketball match, athlete Valya Efstathiou
Vajraduni, a 23-year-old Greek-Armenian on her first visit to Armenia,
termed the event "wonderful."
One Lebanese-Armenian academic, however, was more critical and argued
that more systematized and efficient activities than the Pan Armenian
Games, which started in 1999, or Armenia-Diaspora conferences are
needed to engage the Diaspora.
"The Diaspora is tired of the last 17 years," said Asbed Kotchikian,
a visiting lecturer and political analyst from the University of
Florida at a press conference earlier in the week. "The Diaspora
assists Armenia, but receives only declarative gratitude… There is
no unification or practical policy."
One local journalist, deriding the event’s "lyrical digressions,"
agreed with Kotchikian’s take, but considered that the Games did at
least highlight the prejudices and problems facing Armenians.
"[A]ll the sides of the Fatherland should be shown to the Diasporans,"
wrote Hakob Badalyan in the Lragir newspaper, an online publication
often critical of the government, the day after the Yerevan-Cairo
fight. "Not only the sights, but also the hospitals."
Editor’s Note: Onnik Krikorian is a freelance photojournalist and
reporter based in Yerevan.