Unseen Armenia: An Only Slightly Disappointing Day

Author (left) with freedom fighter Vahan (right) at his fruit stand near Tigranakert, Artsakh.

BY HOVSEP DAGHDIGIAN

We left Shushi in Artsakh, passing Tigranakert, the remains of one of Armenian King Tigran II’s regional capitals. King Tigran ruled from 95-55 BC. I’d have loved to have revisited the site but other places were on our agenda that day.

Last year when visiting here we stopped at the intersection just before Tigranakert. We bought some fruit at the fruit and melon stand there and also got directions and a bit of insight from the vendor, Vahan. Vahan is originally from Vanatsor in northern Armenia. He volunteered to fight in the war for Artsakh’s liberation; he stayed in Artsakh, got married, and has 3 children and 14 grandchildren. While standing at our car’s driver’s window, he talked eloquently and with determination about protecting Armenia and its land. Walking over to the passenger side window where I was seated, he stuck his head in the window and asked “You’re not from Armenia, are you?” “No”, I answered. Much to my embarrassment he said “Thank you for all your support for Artsakh, and when you return, please thank the Diaspora.” My embarrassment stems from the fact that during one day of battle he has probably helped Artsakh more than I have during a lifetime. He, and unnamed individuals like him, should be thanked.

This year, passing Vahan’s fruit stand again, we stopped to say hello and to buy some tomatoes and cucumbers to eat during our travels. Vahan remembered us. Once again he had volunteered, this time fighting in the April conflict last year.  Then he suffered some medical problems and is no longer able to till his fields. He now sells fruit and vegetables grown by another villager. He did not want to charge us for the produce we bought, but that was out of the question. He has a family to support. It was great seeing Vahan again, though of course we were saddened to hear of his health problems. He remains an inspiration. How many more are there like him? I hope and pray for his health and the well-being of those like him.

The next stop was Mokhratagh, a good size village near Martakert – a highly militarized city in Artsakh. In Mokhratagh’s village center are memorials to the village’s WWII and Artsakh martyrs. The WWII memorial was sculptured by Ara Sargsyan. Sargsyan was born near Constantinople, studied art in Europe, and became a noted sculptor. All the while he was a clandestine Nemesis operative helping track down the Turkish criminals responsible for the Armenian Genocide. He subsequently moved to Soviet Armenia, keeping his past ARF and Nemesis activities secret from the KGB. Here, in Armenia, he made enormous contributions to Armenia’s artistic development. He sculptured a number of war memorials, the most notable perhaps being the WWII memorial in Janfida village, a village which suffered extraordinarily high casualties during that war. Sargsyan’s most familiar works are probably the Tumanyan and Spandiaryan statues in front of Yerevan’s Opera House. Sargsyan was hospitalized for a non-life-threatening leg injury. The day before his scheduled release he died. An autopsy revealed no obvious cause of death. KGB involvement is suspected as the KGB probably found out about Sargsyan’s ARF and Nemesis activities. The subsequent honors Sargsyan received in Soviet Armenia were now an embarrassment for the KGB. See https://armenianweekly.com/2017/06/07/unseen-armenia-janfida/ .

Memorials to martyrs of the Karabagh war (left) and to WWII (right), Mokhratagh village, Artsakh. WWII memorial is by sculptor and Nemesis agent Ara Sargsyan.

Our next stops were to be the churches of Yerits Mankats, in Martakert province west of the Sarsang Reservoir, and Yeghishe Arakyal, west of the village of Mataghis. I doubted if we could visit both sites in a single day, but we’d try. Heading towards Yerits Mankats we encountered a soldier at the Sarsang Reservoir. At first he directed us towards Mataghis, confusing the two churches we wanted to visit. Mistakenly he directed us towards Yeghishe Arakyal. When I pointed out the mistake, the soldier realized the mistake as well. He added that to get to Yerits Mankants, we’d have to hike through 6 km of forest; there is no road.

Visiting Yeghishe Arakyal would be fine. We headed towards Mataghis, the last stretch of which was down a long, dry, unpaved and dusty road. Mataghis is heavily armed; it is near Talish where Azerbaijan made incursions into Armenia in April last year. Had we continued, the road to Yeghishe Arakyal would have passed right through the military base there and ended well before our destination which was on a forested hill. So I guess both churches were out of the question. Disappointing!

Exiting Madaghis on the same dry, dusty road we stopped for a rest. I stepped outside the car to eat one of the tomatoes we bought from Vahan, the fruit vendor. It had been a disappointing day, two of the sites we wished to visit weren’t accessible. From Madaghis a car with closed windows (it obviously had air conditioning – it was a hot day) came speeding towards me. The car stopped in a cloud of its own dust. There were 3-4 men in the car. The rear passenger side window opened. An arm extended out the window and handed me a loaf of dense, recently baked bread. The man connected to the arm asked “Do you want some water?” “We’re fine”, I replied, “we have water.” The car sped off leaving a trail of dust.

Where but in Armenia could this have happened? I guess it wasn’t such a disappointing day after all!

Azerbaijan Blacklists Three Members of Congress for Visiting Artsakh

From left to right: Representatives David Valadao, Tulsi Gabbard, and Frank Pallone

BAKU, Azerbaijan (RFE/RL) – On September 22, the Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry called a recent visit to the Artsakh Republic by three US lawmakers a “provocation” and said it had blacklisted them, Russian news agency Interfax reported.

Earlier in the week, Azerbaijan’s state-run APA news agency said the ministry had threatened to blacklist the three members of the U.S. House of Representatives. During their visit to Armenia, Frank Pallone, David Valadao, and Tulsi Gabbard all made a side trip to Artsakh and met with various officials.

“Pallone, Valadao, and Gabbard paid an illegal visit to the occupied Azerbaijani territories, thus breaching Azerbaijani law,” Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry spokesman Hikmet Hajiyev told Interfax. “All three are added to the list of undesirable persons in Azerbaijan.”

The legislators’ visit was “a provocation aimed at undermining efforts of the co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group, including the United States, in settling the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict,” he told Interfax.

While in Artsakh, the U.S. legislators, who are members of the U.S. Congressional Armenian Caucus, met with Nagorno-Karabakh legislators and visited the Shushi Arts College and a cathedral.

Pallone said the legislators’ goal was to learn and educate the American public about the region.

“We try to learn about the military situation on the border and what measures are being taken to eliminate the consequences of the April war,” Artsakh Press quoted Pallone as saying. He was referring to a sharp uptick in violence in the region that occurred in April.

“One of the goals of our work is to contribute to the activity of the OSCE Minsk Group, and we believe that the people of Artsakh should have the right to self-determination and have security mechanisms,” Artsakh Press quoted Pallone as saying.

Representatives Gabbard and Pallone traveled to Artsakh on September 20, while Rep. Valadao was in Artsakh a few days prior. During his visit, Rep. Valadao reviewed the  life-saving HALO Trust de-mining programs that he helped fund as a leading member of the House Appropriations Committee.

Azerbaijani Press: Azerbaijani defense minister checks readiness of military formations’ resources

Trend News Agency, Azerbaijan
Sept 20 2017


20:09 (UTC+04:00)
  • Baku, Azerbaijan, Sept. 20

    Trend:

    Azerbaijan’s defense minister, Colonel General Zakir Hasanov has checked the level of readiness of the mobilization resources of formations and units intended for rapid deployment and use during combat operations, the Defense Ministry told Trend Sept. 20.

    Hasanov heard reports of commanders of various levels on the complement, combat coordination, staff structure and combat capabilities of troops participating in large-scale exercises.

    Depots of military units temporarily storing military equipment and weapons, guns, reserve ammunition, as well as other material and technical means were inspected.

    The minister checked the combat readiness of reserve military equipment, familiarized himself with the activities of points for the reception and complement of equipment, as well as reserve military personnel, heard reports of military officials of varying ranks and gave instructions.

    The defense minister highly appreciated the personnel’s level of readiness and organization, the technical condition of the stored military equipment, arms and ammunition.

    Culture: Armenia’s Vanadzor city to host annual Harvest Festival this year

    Panorama, Armenia
    Sept 16 2017

    The annual Harvest Festival held in Armenia’s Lori province is scheduled for Vanadzor city on 8 October 2017.

    The preparatory works for the traditional festival are already under way, the governor’s office reports, adding this year the festival will essentially differ from the previous ones, featuring increased number of participants.

    In addition to the display of the harvest from the local rural communities and locally produced food, pedigree cattle, agricultural machinery and other products and services, the festival will also feature an agricultural fair.

    The organizers of the event promise to create a real rural environment, accompanied by traditional songs and dances, as well as theatrical scenes.

    ABN B-Networking Event – Sep 13, 6:30pm @ Abby Lane in Boston

    Dear Friends & Colleagues;

    Please join us Wednesday, September 13, 2017 @ 6:30pm at Abby Lane in Boston, MA for the ABN Business Networking Event and Speaker Presentation with Mr. Michael Zeytoonian presenting “Situational Dispute Resolution”

    RSVP to [email protected] by September 11th

    ABN is excited to feature Mr. Michael Zeytoonian, founding member of Dispute Resolution Counsel, LLC and former partner at Hutchings, Barsamian, Mandelcorn & Zeytoonian, LLP.
    At one time or another, we disagree and get into it with someone. Whether it’s an argument between parents and children, spouses, disagreeing voices in non-profit organizations, different approaches to business success or succession, contract disputes, employer-employee conflicts, intellectual property disputes, political spectrum debates, disputes are a part of our lives. They can have devastating consequences, or they can be opportunities to transform a situation into something better.
    Mr. Zeytoonian will focus on the broader spectrum of dispute resolution, beyond lawsuits and courts. He will provide some answers and approaches to rational thinking to an emotionally-charged landscape. He will shed some light on approaches you may have heard about – litigation, arbitration, mediation, collaborative law, ombuds services – but could use more of a guide and road map for navigating through the legal minefield so you don’t make the wrong step.”
    The presentation will be followed by a networking event at Abby Lane. As always this event is free of charge. Please feel free to bring your business cards and collateral for display.

    We look forward to seeing you all on September 13th!

    SCHEDULE:
    6:30pm – Registration
    7:15pm – Presentation “Employment Laws & Rights”
    Networking immediately after presentation.

    VENUE:
    Abby Lane @ 253 Tremont Street Boston, MA 02116

    We are grateful to Mr. Dimitri Petrosian, Mr. Andrew White and the Abby Lane Team for sponsoring ABN’s Summer Networking Event! Please find more information on the venue at www.abbylaneboston.com

    If you are not currently an ABN Member you can join at the link below, however, membership is not a requirement for attending this event. Please feel free to extend this invitation to your Armenian contacts in the New England area, as you deem appropriate.

    To join ABN visit and request to join on the ABN homepage, through the LinkedIn and Facebook icons.

    Kind Regards

    ABN Executive Team

    Artsakh Foreign Ministry Paper on Azeri Isolation Circulated in UN

    The United Nations

    UNITED NATIONS—On August 23, the Artsakh Foreign Ministry circulated a document at the United Nations, presenting its position regarding the Azerbaijani policy of isolation against Artsakh. Since September 1, the document was published on the UN official web-site.

    Read the entire Artsakh Foreign Ministry report.

    The document states that Azerbaijan’s policy aimed at isolation of Artsakh is a blatant violation of the right to development enshrined in the Charter of the United Nations, the Universal Declaration on Human Rights, the UN Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, and the UN Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The right to development is an inalienable human right that can be invoked both by individuals and peoples, and includes: full sovereignty over natural resources; self-determination; popular participation in development; equality of opportunity; the creation of favorable conditions for the enjoyment of other civil, political, economic, social and cultural rights.

    By making a reference to a number of norms of international law, the document emphasizes that the realization of individual and collective human rights and fundamental freedoms, including economic and social rights, must not be dependent on the status of the territory where people live. Therefore, the lack of international recognition cannot affect the ability of a state to engage in international relations, including carrying out foreign economic activity.

    Chess: Aronian seals victory at the World Chess Cup first round

    Panorama, Armenia
    Sept 2 2017
    Sport 10:17 04/09/2017Armenia

    Armenian GM Levon Aronian started with a victory at the 2017 FIDE World Chess Cup, taking place in Tbilisi, Georgia. Aronian defeated Daniel Cowdery (SAR). Other representatives of Armenia Hrant Melkumyan and Robert Hovhannisyan played draw against Boris Grachov (Russia) and Maxim Rothstein (Israel) respectively.

    Rounds are two games each, plus a tiebreak if necessary. As the National Olympic Committee of Armenia reports, the seconds games of first round are slated for Monday.

    To note, the FIDE World Cup is a 128-player knockout with a $1,280,000 prize fund that qualifies two players for the Candidates tournament next year which decides who will be Magnus Carlsen’s next challenger.

    Serzh Sargsyan: NKR Armed Forces protect not only security of Artsakh, but also Armenian, and generally speaking of all Armenians

    ARMINFO News Agency, Armenia
    September 2, 2017 Saturday
    Serzh Sargsyan: NKR Armed Forces protect not only security of Artsakh,
    but also Armenian, and generally speaking of all Armenians
    Yerevan September 02
    Marianna Mkrtchyan. President of Armenia Serzh Sargsyan congratulated
    Artsakh on Independence Day.
    According to Armenian President's press service, the congratulatory
    message, in particular, reads: "Dear compatriots, I congratulate you
    on the occasion of Independence Day of Artsakh. 26 years ago, today,
    the Armenians of Artsakh proclaimed their independent statehood.
    From the fire and the ashes of the war, he was able to reborn and face
    the world with his heroic army, state institutions, serious economic
    progress, exemplary educational and cultural foci, and ultimately his
    organized public. A society that is true to its national values, but
    modern and capable of applying on the ground the best that humanity
    has created in the scientific, economic, political and other spheres.
    Over the past 26 years, Artsakh has emerged as a strong, free and
    democratic state. Peaceful Artsakh is not only combat-ready, but also
    viable and competitive. Defenders of Artsakh are able to fight and
    know what they are fighting for. The Armed Forces of Artsakh defend
    not only the security of Artsakh, but also Armenia, and, by and large,
    all Armenians. Last April's military actions, initiated by Azerbaijan,
    once again demonstrated the impossibility of a military solution to
    the Karabakh issue. This adventure was initially doomed to failure,
    since the Defense Army is strong, and behind the back of Artsakh is
    Armenia and the whole Armenians. On this day we bow our heads to those
    who fell for the freedom of Artsakh. Long live the free and
    independent Artsakh!"
    

    Historic Anniversary of Hope and Despondence

    The Armenian Mirror-Spectator
    Sept 2 2017
    Historic Anniversary of Hope and Despondence

    By Edmond Y. Azadian

    On August 5, a bell rang in Hiroshima exactly at the hour when 65 years ago the first atomic bomb was dropped, scorching to death 145,000 people in a brief moment. The tolling of the bell reverberated around the globe through the electronic media, reminding the world of the anniversary of a great human tragedy of historic dimensions.

    The same day, another anniversary came and passed, almost unnoticed, even by Armenians whose lives it had impacted irreversibly. Only the state TV channel in Armenia broadcast a three-minute footage remembering the 90th anniversary of a political act to restore home rule in Cilicia, now called Chukur Ova, situated on the Mediterranean Sea Coast of the present Republic of Turkey.

    Indeed, August 4 and 5 were eventful days in Cilicia, raising hopes of achieving home rule by the Armenians, who were promised by the Allies, especially as a  compensation for Armenian participation in World War I on their side.

    What happened on August 4 and 5, 1920, has a long and sometimes intricate background.

    Armenians had inhabited Cilicia many centuries before Seljuk Turks appeared in that region. An Armenian kingdom even ruled that territory between the 10th and 14th centuries, when the Memluks deposed the last king, Levon VI Lousignan, and took over the country, in 1375 AD.

    After centuries of subjugation, a historic opportunity was presented in the 20th century, right before the signing of the Sevres Treaty of August 10, 1920, to restore home rule in Cilicia.

    The Armenian National Delegation, headed by Boghos Nubar Pasha, was negotiating with the victorious Allies the future of Armenia. Before the war ended, the Allies requested from the Armenians to form a legion and fight against Turkish-German forces, under the Allied command.

    In 1916, the French government under President Aristide Briand, had promised home rule for Armenians in Cilicia, during negotiations leading to the formation of the Armenian Legion.

    Victory has many parents, while defeat is always orphan. After the failure of the Cilician dream, some historians, including Armenian ones, claim that there was no formal document signed by the Allies to that effect.

    After the French government pledge, Armenians demonstrated a rare _expression_ of unity. Indeed, Nubar Pasha commissioned a delegation comprising the representatives of three political parties and dispatched them to the US to recruit volunteers to fight in the legion. In 1917, Mihran Damadian (Ramgavar), Stepan Sabahgulian (Hunchak) and Ardavazt Hanemian (Armenian Revolutionary Federation) headed to the US to raise funds and to recruit volunteers. (At that time Constitutional Ramgavars and
    Reformed Hunchaks had not united yet; therefore four parties combined their forces to achieve the mission.)

    Despite the tensions of traditional Armenian disunity, the mission was accomplished. Twelve hundred volunteers, survivors of the Genocide, who had already achieved security and comfort in this land of opportunity, returned to the Middle East in cargo ships, defying German gunboats in the Atlantic. They were joined in Cyprus, by the survivors of the battle of Musa Dagh. They were trained and armed and joined the Allied forces in Palestine, numbering about 4,000. By comparison, today, one would not venture to guess how many volunteers from the diaspora joined the Karabagh forces to fight the Azeris.

    At that time, patriotic fervor and the sense of revenge were overwhelming.

    The Armenian Legion spearheaded the assault on unified Ottoman and German forces, fortifying a hilltop in Palestine called Arara. Armenians made history by breaking the backbone of the enemies on September 19, 1918, turning the tide of World War I in the region.

    It was agreed that the volunteer legion would become the nucleus of the Armenian Army after autonomy was granted under a French mandate in Cilicia.

    After the Legion entered Cilicia victoriously, 150,000 Genocide survivors returned to their homes there. Nubar Pasha appointed Mihran Damadian as the Cilician  representative vis-à-vis occupying forces.

    Euphoric optimism reigned throughout Cilicia, as Armenians prepared to achieve their dreams.

    It was a historic moment. The Allies were forcing on the defeated Germans and Ottomans the Treaty of Sevres, which included an independent Armenia crafted by President Woodrow Wilson. Yet Cilicia, where Armenians had been reassembled, was not part of the deal. An elusive historic opportunity was to be missed had the Armenians failed to act.

    The defeated Turks had already regrouped on the ground, under Mustafa Kemal and were planning a comeback. Damadian assembled all the minorities — Armenian, Greek, Arab, Assyrian and others, and a declaration was drafted to be submitted to the French Commander Bremon. They were trying to create a fait accompli, like the Turks had done, six days before the signing of Sevres Treaty. The next day, on August 5, a delegation headed by Damadian occupied the government office and announced the formation of the Armenian government in Cilicia under a French mandate.

    Damadian named himself prime minister and formed a cabinet to reflect the ethnic diversity of the region, which the French statesman George Picot had defined as a “purely Armenian territory” and where 100,000 other Christian ethnic groups had joined the 150,000 Armenians.

    At the dramatic moment of achieving statehood, the French commander dispatched a battalion who forced the Armenians out of the government House at the butt of bayonets and then later in October and November evacuated their forces secretly from Cilicia, leaving the Armenians unarmed and defenseless before marauding Kemalist forces, who came to finish the grizzly mission which the Ittihadists had began during the war, by exterminating Armenians.

    “Cilicia is destined to become Armenia’s future window open to the sea, to Europe and to civilization,” wrote Damadian in his memoirs — a dream that never realized.

    The August 5 act may have been a last-ditch desperate initiative, but it was a historic necessity, which any prudent leader, with a sense of history, would and should have taken, regardless of the consequences. The French betrayed their formal pledge, because they had negotiated a secret deal with the Turks, not realizing that the Kemalist Milli nationalist movement was also financed, supported and armed by the newly-rising Lenin’s communist forces.

    Damadian has a sad yet realistic commentary about this act of betrayal: “The conscience of diplomacy is broad and very flexible. If need be, it can level with rebels and rascals, and can even sit down to negotiate with people like Mustafa Kemal and his cohorts, vile thugs and blood hungry killers and sign armistices.”

    The Cilician home rule was a dream so close to being realized, but it was sacrificed by the treachery of the French government. The Cilician dream may be lost forever, but valuable political lessons are learned which can be implemented today in the Karabagh conflict. Muster your forces and don’t trust even the closest allies, because they may sell you down the river for their selfish interests.

    Fresno’s Armenian School Board President Needs Lessons in History and Tolerance

    Fresno Unified School District President Brooke Ashjian

    BY ARA KHACHTOURIAN

    On Wednesday night, during a heated discussion at the Fresno Unified School District Board of Directors meeting, the board president Brooke Ashjian equated the LGBT community to Ottoman Turks who perpetrated the Armenian Genocide.

    The discussion centered on the California Healthy Youth Act, a law requiring schools to teach medically accurate sex education, including lessons on birth control, abortion and LGBT relationships. Ashjian who has opposed the law and has been on a war path with the LGBT community and other city leaders who have not only criticized him but have called for his resignation chose to defend himself by equating opposition to his views with state-sponsored campaign to annihilate an entire race—the Armenian people.

    In his remarks, Ashjian invokes his relatives whom he claims were subjected to the genocidal policies of the Ottoman Turks, making his statements absurd by equating a minority community to perpetrators of a crime against a minority population.

    “It is sad, they like the Ottomans are trying to be the thought police,” Ashjian said on Wednesday reading from a two-page statement he wrote. “They are trying to make people of faith second-class citizens, as they seek to silence our voices in the public square. Just like what my grandparents and millions of other grandparents had to endure at the hands of the Ottomans before escaping to America.”

    It is clear that the lessons of the Armenian Genocide have evaded Ashjian, who also seems to have forgotten the manner in which newly immigrant Armenians were treated in Fresno during the nascent years of our community there. He also seems to have forgotten that the very group he is labeling as genocide perpetrators were themselves subjected to mass killings during the Holocaust.

    Rev. Ara Guekguezian, the pastor of First Congregational Church of Fresno pointed out to the Fresno Bee that it was dangerous to minimize the horrors of the Armenian Genocide, adding that the LGBT community should not be compared to Turkish officials who carried out the Armenian Genocide.

    “If the Ottoman Turks say, ‘We are trying to silence you or marginalize you or demonize you,’ that is frightening because eventually they end up killing you,” Guekguezian told the Fresno Bee.

    The 102-year fight for justice for the Armenian Genocide has called for recognition of the crime, based on a clear premise that the Genocide was the ultimate violation of human rights and the usurpation of people’s basic freedom through murder.

    In Turkey, the country that continues to deny the Genocide, Garo Paylan, an Armenian member of the Turkish Parliament representing the People’s Democratic Party (HDP), has filed a law suit against the Ankara mayor who used the term “Armenian” to describe one of his opponents. Ashjian clearly has taken a page from our adversary’s playbook.

    What is more repugnant in the Ashjian scenario is that he has been elected by the people of Fresno to uphold the highest standards of education in the fourth largest school district in the state. His ignorance calls into question his qualifications for leading the public school system in that city. Fresno voters must take this into consideration at the ballot box if Ashjian seeks re-election.

    (It is worth noting that other on the FUSD, as well as the school’s interim superintendent have denounced Ashjian’s comments and have assertively advocated for inclusion and providing a safe educational environment for students in Fresno).

    Ashjian’s unrepentant attitude and egregious comments seem to mirror the current national discourse, which, especially during the past two weeks, seems to have veered off course when the president decided to equivocate when those carrying torches and Nazi flags clashed with those who opposed that flagrant breech of humanity.