RFE/RL Armenian Report – 11/27/2020

                                        Friday, 
Armenian Businessman Named Economy Minister
'
Armenia - Businessman Vahan Kerobian at a news conference in Yerevan, January 
17, 2019.
The founder and chief executive of Armenia’s largest food delivery company has 
been appointed as economy minister in a government reshuffle announced by Prime 
Minister Nikol Pashinian following the recent war in Nagorno-Karabakh.
The 44-year-old businessman, Vahan Kerobian, is the sixth new cabinet member 
named by Pashinian over the past week. The five others are the ministers of 
defense, foreign affairs, labor, emergencies and education.
Pashinian announced the cabinet shakeup on November 18 amid anti-government 
demonstrations sparked by significant Armenian territorial losses suffered 
during the war. He has since continued to reject opposition demands for his 
resignation and snap parliamentary elections.
Kerobian set up the Menu.am company together with his wife and a friend in 2012. 
He previously managed an Armenian supermarket chain that went bankrupt and was 
purchased and rebranded by other investors.
Kerobian has publicly supported the current government and Pashinian in 
particular. Still, he criticized government policies during the prime minister’s 
meeting with a group of entrepreneurs held this summer.
Pashinian recalled this fact when he introduced Kerobian to senior Ministry of 
Economy officials on Friday.
“He now has an opportunity to carefully listen to business and the private 
sector and not only raise the sector’s problems with the government but also 
personally address them,” said Pashinian.
Kerobian said, for his part, that the war and the continuing coronavirus 
pandemic have created new economic challenges for Armenia. He also said that the 
Armenian economy could grow by 10 percent annually in the near future, an 
ambitious target set by Pashinian earlier this year.
The economy is now projected to shrink by about 7 percent in 2020 after three 
consecutive years of robust growth. The government forecast a less drastic GDP 
contraction before the war with Azerbaijan that broke out on September 27 and 
was stopped by a Russian-brokered ceasefire on November 10.
In its budget bill submitted to the Armenian parliament early this month, the 
government said economic growth will resume and reach a 4.8 percent rate already 
next year. The International Monetary Fund offered last week a less optimistic 
outlook for the Armenian economy.
More Aid Pledged By Armenian Diaspora For Karabakh
NAGORNO-KARABAKH -- The Mayor of Martakert Misha Gyurjian inspects a house 
destroyed by shelling in Martakert, October 19, 2020.
A pan-Armenian charity has raised over $26 million in fresh funds in the United 
States and France for humanitarian and economic aid to Nagorno-Karabakh.
The Hayastan All-Armenian Fund said on Friday that it attracted the bulk of the 
donations pledges, worth almost $23 million, during an annual telethon broadcast 
from Los Angeles. The remaining $3.1 million was raised by its French branch in 
an annual phonethon held on November 22.
“In light of recent developments in Artsakh (Karabakh) and Armenia, all proceeds 
of Telethon 2020 will be directed to supporting 100,000 displaced individuals 
and families of our fallen soldiers who lost their lives to protect the 
sovereignty of both republics,” the head of the fund’s U.S. branch, Maria 
Mehranian, said in a statement.
Nagorno-Karabakh - Rita Khachatryan, 50, whose husband and son were sent to the 
front line, walks in a basement shelter in Stepanakert, October 23, 2020.
Hayastan launched an international fundraising campaign immediately after the 
outbreak of the Armenian-Azerbaijani war in and around Karabakh on September 27. 
Hundreds of thousands of Armenians from around the world responded to its appeal 
for urgent aid to Karabakh and its population severely affected by the fighting.
Hayastan collected $170 million from them before its latest fundraisers in the 
U.S. and France. It emerged earlier this month that the charity headquartered in 
Yerevan redirected more than $100 million of those proceeds to Armenia’s 
government.
The Armenian Finance Ministry said on Tuesday that the hefty contribution will 
finance the government’s “infrastructure, social and healthcare expenditures” 
necessitated by the war.
The six-week hostilities, halted by a Russian-brokered truce on November 10, 
displaced most of Karabakh’s ethnic Armenian population and destroyed or 
seriously damaged much of its civilian infrastructure. Encouraged by the 
deployment of Russian peacekeeping troops, tens of thousands of refugees have 
returned to Karabakh in the last ten days.
Hayastan has implemented $370 million worth of various infrastructure projects 
in Karabakh and Armenia since being set up in 1992. Its board of trustees mostly 
comprises Armenia’s political leaders and prominent Diaspora philanthropists.
Pashinian Blasts, Warns Armenian Opposition
Armenia - Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian delivers a televised address to the 
nation, 
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian lashed out at his political opponents on Friday, 
saying they want to “spread chaos” in Armenia in a bid to oust him from power in 
the aftermath of the war in Nagorno-Karabakh.
Pashinian insisted that most Armenians continue to support him and his 
government despite Azerbaijan’s victory in the war stopped by a Russian-brokered 
ceasefire on November 10.
“In Armenia and outside it, there are people and groups who are trying to create 
a semblance of anarchy and spread chaos in our country,” he said in a televised 
address to the nation. “They want to bring the war into Armenia and, using 
assault rifles and criminal groups, leave the country in a state of freefall in 
order to ensure their return [to power] as saviors.
“I want to state clearly and unequivocally that we will not allow that to 
happen. Not because we are clinging to power but because the people do not want 
that.”
“Yes, the people have questions and are sometimes bitter and angry, sometimes 
disappointed and sometimes hopeless. But I see in all this the people’s trust 
[in the government] and want to thank the people for that trust,” added 
Pashinian.
The embattled premier thus pointed the finger at Armenia’s former leaders but 
did not name any of them. Nor did he specify “external forces known to you” who 
he suggested are helping the former regime topple him.
Pashinian’s latest speech came amid continuing calls for his resignation made 
not only by opposition forces but also President Armen Sarkissian, some public 
figures and media commentators. They blame him for significant territorial gains 
made by Azerbaijan during the six-week war.
The opposition criticism intensified on Thursday amid media reports that 
Azerbaijani soldiers entered a large gold mine on Armenia’s border with the 
Kelbajar district west of Karabakh which was handed back to Azerbaijan on 
Wednesday in line with the truce agreement. Some opposition figures accused 
Pashinian of ceding Armenian territory to Baku.
NAGORNO-KARABAKH -- Azerbaijani army soldiers sit atop of their military vehicle 
on a road in Kelbajar, 
A deputy chief of the Armenian army’s General Staff, General Tiran Khachatrian, 
denied those claims at a late-night news conference in Yerevan. But he said at 
the same time that the Armenian military agreed to pull out of a checkpoint set 
up near the Sotk mine after “lengthy negotiations” with Azerbaijani and Russian 
military officials.
More importantly, Khachatrian acknowledged that half of the gold mine, the 
largest in Armenia, is technically located on the Azerbaijani side of the 
internationally recognized border and will no longer be under Armenian control. 
He said the talks followed a brief standoff between Armenian and Azerbaijani 
servicemen deployed in the mountainous area.
Pashinian too insisted that the border cuts across the mine operated by a 
Russian company. He accused the opposition of spreading “disinformation” about 
the loss of territory in Armenia proper.
Armenia - A gold mine at Sotk.
Pashinian also faced late on Thursday more protests by parents and other 
relatives of Armenian soldiers who went missing during the war. They rallied 
outside the prime minister’s office before being received by Pashinian after 
midnight.
Pashinian’s press secretary, Mane Gevorgian, said afterwards that the premier 
“heard their demands” and briefed them on the Armenian side’s efforts to find 
the missing soldiers or recover their bodies believed to be lying on 
Azerbaijani-controlled territory.
Pashinian wrote on Facebook at around the same time that he has twice spoken 
with Russian President Vladimir Putin by phone over the past hour to discuss a 
wide range of issues relating to the implementation of the truce accord. He said 
they included the mutual search for and handover of dead soldiers’ bodies as 
well as the exchange of prisoners of war.
Karabakh Not Recognized By France
NAGORNO-KARABAKH -- Men walk along a street in Stepanakert, November 16, 2020
The French government has made clear that it does not recognize Nagorno-Karabakh 
as an independent republic despite a resolution adopted by France’s Senate on 
Wednesday.
The resolution calls on the government to “recognize the Nagorno-Karabakh 
Republic and use this recognition as an instrument of negotiations for the 
establishment of a sustainable peace.” It also urges the government to pursue a 
tougher European response toward Turkey, which has supported Azerbaijan in 
Karabakh the conflict, and an international war crimes investigation.
In a statement on the resolution issued late on Thursday, a French Foreign 
Ministry spokesperson said: “During the [Senate] debate preceding the vote, Mr. 
Jean-Baptiste Lemoyne, Secretary of State for Tourism, French People Abroad and 
the Francophonie, recalled the French government's position on this issue: 
France does not recognize the self-proclaimed Nagorno-Karabakh Republic.”
“Our responsibility as co-chairman of the OSCE Minsk Group is to work towards a 
negotiated solution to the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, in particular on the issue 
of the future status of Nagorno-Karabakh, and the outcome of this negotiation 
cannot be determined beforehand and unilaterally,” added the statement.
“Our priority today must be to ensure the safe return of those displaced by the 
conflict of the past few weeks. In his address to the Senate, the Secretary of 
State further noted that no state has yet recognized Nagorno-Karabakh.”
Armenia was quick to welcome the resolution, with Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian 
calling it “historic.”
Azerbaijan condemned the measure introduced by several pro-Armenian French 
senators. The Azerbaijani parliament on Thursday accused Paris of pro-Armenian 
bias and demanded an end to French co-chairmanship of the OSCE Minsk Group.
French President Emmanuel Macron criticized Azerbaijan’s military action in 
Karabakh shortly after the outbreak of the war on September 27. Macron has been 
even more critical of Turkey’s strong political and military support for Baku.
Earlier this week, the French government sent two planeloads of humanitarian aid 
to Karabakh’s ethnic Armenian residents displaced by the fighting.
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2020 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

France, Russia and the US bear a special responsibility for Karabakh, French FM says

Public Radio of Armenia

Nov 22 2020

French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian has emphasized the great responsibility that the Minsk Group countries bear in the settlement of the conflict in Nagorno-Karabakh.

“France, Russia and the United States have a special responsibility. Because they were the ones who were entrusted by the UN to monitor compliance with the commitments assumed by the parties to the conflict. As co-chairmen of the Minsk Group, we made a lot of efforts to achieve a ceasefire. Three times in one week initiatives were undertaken to achieve a cessation of hostilities, in particular, by my Russian colleague Sergei Lavrov and by the United States, Michael Pompeo, but at that moment it did not work, “Le Drian said on Sunday during an interview with the French news channel LSI.

“We bear the responsibility that the international community has entrusted to us. And Armenia itself wants us to keep this responsibility. All this requires us to adhere to a balanced position,” he said.

“Both the Armenian and Azerbaijani leaderships stressed the importance of preserving our role. But this does not prevent France from providing assistance to Armenia now – an airplane with humanitarian supplies arrives in Yerevan, another one will leave there next week,” the minister said. During the interview, he especially stressed that “Armenia is a friendly people for France.

“However, it should be admitted that there is uncertainty regarding the ceasefire reached – and we want the necessary clarifications to be made to us in this regard. They concern displaced persons, since there are many Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh, and we strive to ensure that those Armenians, who were driven from their places of residence, return there,” the French minister said.

“It is also the issue of mercenaries – their withdrawal should be achieved, and all three countries – the co-chairs of the Minsk Group agree with the necessity of this,” he continued.

“There is also the issue of protecting religious and cultural heritage. In this regard, French President Emmanuel Macron took initiatives jointly with UNESCO, which I discussed on Saturday with my colleagues from Armenia and Azerbaijan,” Le Drian said.

“Only after the settlement of these problems can we move on to the issue of the status of Nagorno-Karabakh. At the moment it is not possible to discuss this. And the Armenian leadership agrees with this,” Le Drian said.

The French Foreign Minister said that the topic of Nagorno-Karabakh was discussed by him during the recent visit of US Secretary of State Michael Pompeo to Paris.


French Senate to Discuss Artsakh Recognition Resolution

November 19,  2020



French Senate Chamber

The French Senate on Wednesday decided that it would discuss on November 25 a resolution on the recognition of the Republic of Artsakh.

The measure is supported by the heads of the five largest political factions represented in the French Senate—Bruno Retalier, Patrick Cannet, Herve Marmel, Eliane Assassi, Guillaume Gontard.

The senate announcement came hours after the Paris City Council adopted a detailed resolution recognizing Artsakh and urging the French government to follow suit. Mayors of 15 municipalities in France on Tuesday also urged the French government to recognize Artsakh. France, which is one of three co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group, was taking part in a meeting of the mediation body in Moscow on Wednesday.

A similar resolution was also introduced in France’s Lower House last month, as reports of Azerbaijani aggression and war crimes against Artsakh were mounting and Turkey’s active role in the conflict through military assistance and backing of mercenaries posed a threat to the region.

During talks in Paris earlier this week, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Derian signaled the they wanted further clarification from Moscow about Turkey’s role in the “end of war” agreement engineered by President Vladimir Putin of Russia, who along side his Azerbaijani counterpart Ilham Aliyev and Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan signed the document. Pompeo and Le Derian also called for details about the terms of the agreement.

While France and the United States separately welcomed the end of military hostilities, they urged that the conflict settlement process through the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairmen continue, in order to find what Pompeo called a “lasting solution” to the conflict.

Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov was quick to brush aside the French and American concerns saying on Tuesday that that Moscow worked in close contact with the co-chairs from the United States and France “from the very beginning of the efforts that Russia made in the interests of ending the military phase of this conflict.” He addd that the State Department’s statements about the lack of information either reflect the lack of information by its officials, or are the result of a misunderstanding.

Sergei Naryshkin, Russia’s head of foreign intelligence service on Wednesday accused the U.S. and its European allies of taking provocative steps to disrupt the “end of war” agreement, reported Sputnik-Armenia.

Naryshkin cited “available intelligence” to claimed that the U.S. and EU were trying to convince the Armenians that Karabakh peace was a “defeat to Yerevan.”

Armenia MFA spox denies reports claiming all deputy FMs have resigned

Save

Share

 16:58,

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 17, ARMENPRESS. Deputy foreign ministers of Armenia continue fulfilling their working duties, Spokesperson of the foreign minister Anna Naghdalyan told Armenpress, commenting on the reports which claim that all deputy FMs have submitted resignation letters.

Earlier today deputy foreign minister Shavarsh Kocharyan has been dismissed according to the prime minister’s decision.

On November 16, according to the presidential decree, Zohrab Mnatsakanyan has been relieved from the position of Foreign Minister of Armenia.

Reporting by Norayr Shoghikyan; Editing and Translating by Aneta Harutyunyan

Status of Nagorno Karabakh will be determined in the future – Putin

Public Radio of Armenia

Nov 17 2020

Russian President Vladimir Putin has declared that the status of Nagorno-Karabakh will be determined in the future.

“The final status of Karabakh has not been settled, we agreed that we will maintain the status quo that exists today,” Putin said in an interview with Rossiya 24.

“What happens next is to be decided in the future, or by future leaders, future participants in this process. But, in my opinion, if conditions are created for a normal life, for the restoration of relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan, between people at the household level, especially in the conflict zone, it will create conditions for determining the status of Karabakh,” the Russian President added.

https://en.armradio.am/2020/11/17/status-of-nagorno-karabakh-will-be-determined-in-the-future-putin/


Emergency unit for coordination of humanitarian aid from France to Armenia established

Save

Share

 12:27,

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 18, ARMENPRESS. The Armenian Fund of France, the Aznavour Foundation and the AGBU France announce joint establishment of an emergency humanitarian aid unit, the Aznavour Foundation said in a statement.

On Thursday, November 12, President Emmanuel Macron received at The Élysée Palace the representatives of humanitarian organizations in solidarity with Armenia and Artsakh to affirm France’s support after the announcement of the ceasefire.

The following humanitarian organizations took part in the meeting at the invitation of the Presidency of the Republic: the Armenian Fund of France (represented by Bedros Terzian, President of the Fund); the Aznavour Foundation (represented by Kristina Aznavour, CEO of the Foundation) and the Armenian General Benevolent Union (AGBU) France (represented by Nadia Gortzounian, President of the Union). The meeting was also attended by Youri Djorkaeff, Nicolas Aznavour, André Manoukian and Stéphane Hasbanian.

The head of state reaffirmed on this occasion the “historic friendship” between France and Armenia. “In this difficult time, France stands by Armenia”, he said. In addition to sending medical mission to Armenia, the President of the Republic also announced the provision of humanitarian aid to Armenia through a cargo plane and the pursuit of Franco-Armenian cooperation in healthcare.

In the course of the meeting, all the guests stressed the importance of recognizing the Republic of Artsakh to build a lasting peace and to ensure the security of the Armenian populations on their ancestral lands. They also mentioned the urgency of safeguarding cultural and religious heritage in Artsakh and the need for French local authorities to work towards closer cooperation and provision of humanitarian aid.

At the end of the meeting, a working group was organized with the Crisis and Support Center of the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs to contribute to the initiatives of humanitarian organizations in solidarity with Armenia.

The Armenian Fund of France, the Aznavour Foundation and the Armenian General Benevolent Union (AGBU) therefore announce the establishment of an emergency unit for the coordination and implementation of humanitarian and medical aid from France to Armenia, in cooperation with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Presidency of the Republic. This unit is at the disposal of all humanitarian organizations which wish to help and support those displaced by the war, facing numerous urgent needs.

For any further information, please contact AGBU France at the following address: .

ANN/Armenian News – Week in Review – 11/08/2020

Armenian News Network / Armenian News

Armenian News: Week in Review

ANN/Armenian News

November 8, 2020

  • Asbed Kotchikian

  • Emil Sanamyan

  • Yeghia Tashjian

  • Hovik Manucharyan

  • Asbed Bedrossian

Hello, and welcome to the Armenian News Network, Armenian News, Week in Review for Sunday November 8, 2020. In this episode we continue to discuss various topics around the War in Artsakh. We’ll be talking to our panel about the following major topics:

  • Six weeks of war

  • What is Russia thinking?

  • To recognize or not to recognize?


Our guests for this episode were:

Emil Sanamyan, a senior research fellow at USC’s Institute of Armenian Studies specializing in politics in the Caucasus, with a special focus on Azerbaijan.

Yeghia Tashjian, a regional analyst and researcher based in Beirut, with expertise in China, Iran and the Persian Gulf. Tashjian is the Regional Officer of Women in War, a gender-based think tank, and hosts a weekly radio program called “Turkey Today”.

and

Asbed Kotchikian, a senior lecturer of political science and international relations at Bentley University in Massachusetts where he teaches courses on the Middle East and former Soviet space.

This episode was recorded on Saturday, November 7, one day before Nikol Pashinyan along with Ilham Aliyev and Vladimir Putin signed a ceasefire treaty, which some would say is a capitulation for Armenia.

YouTube           Apple            Google         Spotify       Facebook

The war has been ongoing for six weeks. 

During the past week, Russia has stressed its discomfort with the presence of terrorists in Azerbaijan and Nagorno-Karabakh at multiple layers. President Putin has said it, foreign minister Lavrov, as well as foreign ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova. Many governments worldwide (including that of the US, France, Iran) have also confirmed this news.

Yet, Aliyev continues to deny:

“I regret that high-ranking officials of the countries that should be neutral and act on the basis of the mandate given to them by the OSCE use these unconfirmed ‘information’ and rumors,” Aliyev said, reiterating that there are no mercenaries on the territory of Azerbaijan. (Azatutyun)

It was in response to this statement that director of Russia’s Foreign Intelligence Service (SVR), Sergey Naryshkin, re-affirmed that they have very high confidence in their intelligence. In addition to this, Naryshkin also claimed that Turkish intelligence or special ops units are active in Artsakh. 

Earlier today, Russia’s foreign minister Lavrov and his French colleague had a telephone conversation where the main topic was the fight against “terrorism in all its forms”. During this meeting, they also raised their concern about Syrian and Libyan extremists fighting in Artsakh.

Does Russia seem to be building some sort of a case for taking action against the war in Artsakh in some form or another, perhaps with the full cover of international legitimacy and support? What do you think Russia is strategizing?

Iran has moved significant armed forces and weaponry to its border with Azerbaijan and also Armenia. It also has expressed concern about terrorism at multiple layers of its top leadership. What are its concerns, why does it need so many army assets on its northern border?

Let’s come back to Yerevan for a moment.

That concludes our program for This week’s Armenian News Week in Review. We hope it has helped you understand some of the current issues. We look forward to your feedback, and even your suggestions for issues to cover in greater depth. Contact us on our website, at Armenian News.org, or on our Facebook PageANN – Armenian News”, or in our Facebook Group “Armenian News – Armenian News  Network.

Special thanks to Laura Osborn for providing the music for our podcast. I’m Hovik Manucharyan, and on behalf of everyone in this episode, I wish you a good week. Thank you for listening and we’ll talk to you next week.

Armenia, Artsakh, Azerbaijan, Karabakh Negotiations, Geneva, Iran, Turkey

Additional: Suren Sargsyan, Asbed Kotchikian, Russia, France, United States, OSCE Minsk Group, Ceasefire, Aliyev, Pashinyan, Abbas Araghchi, Robert Kocharyan, Levon Ter-Petrosyan, Gagik Tsarukyan, Putin, United Russia, Bargavach Hayastan, Prosperous Armenia

It seems that the vacuum of a strong north-south relationship – between Pashinyan & Putin, – created a pathway for the east-west relationship between Aliyev & Erdogan to rise, and for the latter to project power into the South Caucasus.


TURKISH press: Muslim call to prayer recited in Azerbaijan’s Shusha for 1st time after 28-year Armenian occupation

People celebrate on the streets after Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev said the country’s forces had taken Shusha, during the fighting over the region of Nagorno-Karabakh, in Baku, Azerbaijan, Nov. 8, 2020. (Reuters Photo)

The Muslim call to prayer, known as the adhan, was heard Wednesday in Nagorno-Karabakh’s symbolic city of Shusha for the first time in nearly three decades.

Footage on social media showed an Azerbaijani soldier reciting the adhan at Shusha’s historical Yukhari Govhar Agha Mosque.

Shusha was occupied by Armenian forces on May 8, 1992. The town has significant military value due to its strategic location about 10 kilometers (6 miles) south of the region’s capital near Khankendi (Stepanakert) and on the road linking the city with Armenian territory.

Gaining control of Shusha was a major victory for Azerbaijani forces on their way to a cease-fire signed Nov. 10, seen as a victory for Baku in the conflict over the Armenian-occupied Nagorno-Karabakh region.

Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev announced on Nov. 8 that Shusha had been liberated from Armenian occupation.

“After 28 years, the adhan (call to prayer) will be heard in Shusha,” Aliyev, wearing a military uniform, said in an address to the nation.

“We proved to the world Nagorno-Karabakh is historical Azerbaijani lands,” he said.

“Our victory march continues. If the Armenian leadership does not respond to my demands, we will go till the end,” Aliyev said in his speech in the Alley of Martyrs in the capital Baku.

Azerbaijan and Armenia have been locked in a bitter conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh since Armenian separatists backed by Yerevan seized control of the mountainous province in a 1990s war that left 30,000 people dead.

Nagorno-Karabakh’s self-declared independence has not been recognized internationally, even by Armenia, and it remains a part of Azerbaijan under international law.

The heaviest fighting since a 1994 cease-fire erupted on Sept. 27 and persisted for over a month despite intense diplomatic efforts to bring it to a halt. Azerbaijan’s victory became official Monday as Armenia agreed to accept its defeat through a peace deal that confirms the withdrawal of its troops from the Nagorno-Karabakh region.