Attempts to disavow Russian-Azerbaijani-Armenian agreements seen as dangerous

TASS, Russia
Dec 14 2023
According to Maria Zakharova, Moscow reiterates its initiative to organize another round of talks on a peace treaty between Armenia and Azerbaijan in Russia as soon as possible

MOSCOW, December 14. /TASS/. Attempts to disavow the agreements between the Russian, Azerbaijani and Armenian leaders are extremely dangerous in the absence of a peace treaty between Baku and Yerevan, Russian Foreign Ministry Spokeswoman Maria Zakharova said.

"The package of trilateral agreements made up of the statements by the leaders of Russia, Azerbaijan and Armenia of November 9, 2020, January 11 and November 26, 2021, and October 31, 2022 is a roadmap for reconciliation between Baku and Yerevan and has no alternative," she said. "It embraces all key spheres of Armenian-Azerbaijani normalization: unblocking economic and transport links, delimiting the Armenian-Azerbaijani border, signing a peace treaty, and developing dialogue between public activists and experts. These agreements are in force, as neither of the sides has withdrawn its signature."

"In the absence of a peace treaty between Armenia and Azerbaijan, attempts to disavow these major documents are extremely dangerous," she stressed. "Such a step will inevitably entail serious risks, first of all, for Armenia." Moscow, in her words, reiterates its initiative to organize another round of talks on a peace treaty between Armenia and Azerbaijan in Russia as soon as possible.

Despite the recent agreements between Baku and Yerevan on a prisoner exchange and the work of the border delimitation commission, nothing has yet been done to begin delimitation efforts under Russia’s consultancy, or what the three leaders agreed to as far back as November 2021, she noted.

"The Armenian side has rejected CSTO (Collective Security Treaty Organization, a Russia-led security bloc – TASS) mechanism for the stabilization of the situation in border areas for the sake of inviting an EU mission," she said. "So, delays in the implementation of the above-mentioned decisions by the countries’ leaders are a direct result of Yerevan’s inconsistent actions rather than of Moscow’s policy as some are alleging.".

Armenpress: Armenian, Azerbaijani Foreign Ministers to meet in US in January

 10:34,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 14, ARMENPRESS. Baku has accepted the US proposal to hold a meeting between the foreign ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan in the United States in January.

Edmon Marukyan, Ambassador-at-Large of Armenia, announced this on the air of Public Television of Armenia.

Marukyan expressed hope that during the meeting it would be possible to finalize the draft peace treaty between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Earlier, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Armenia announced that Yerevan has accepted the proposal to hold a meeting between the Foreign Ministers of Armenia and Azerbaijan in Washington.

None of 32 captives returned from Azerbaijan to Armenia transferred to civilian medical centers – Healthcare Minister

 13:41,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 14, ARMENPRESS. The 32 servicemen, who returned to Armenia from Azerbaijan captivity as part of a prisoner swap deal, have underwent preliminary medical examination.

“The 32 Armenian captives underwent a preliminary medical examination at the Muratsan hospital and none of them was transferred to civilian medical centers as there was no need for it," Minister of Healthcare of Armenia Anahit Avanesyan told reporters.

Baku approves work regulations of Armenian-Azerbaijan delimitation commission

 15:06,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 14, ARMENPRESS. The Cabinet of Ministers of Azerbaijan has approved the regulations on the work and meetings of the Azerbaijani and Armenian commissions on the delimitation of the state border between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

 The corresponding resolution of the Prime Minister of Azerbaijan Ali Asadov has been published on the website of the country's government, which reads as follows:

“To approve the regulations on the organization and holding of meetings and joint working meetings between the State Commission on the Delimitation of the State Border between the Republic of Azerbaijan and the Republic of Armenia and the Commission on the Delimitation of the State Border and Border Security between the Republic of Armenia and the Republic of Azerbaijan.”

Armenia and Greece sign an agreement on military-technical cooperation

 18:06,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 14, ARMENPRESS. The official visit of the Minister of Defense of the Republic of Armenia Suren Papikyan to the Hellenic Republic commenced on December 14 with a wreath-laying ceremony at the monument of the Unknown Soldier in front of the country's Parliament, the Ministry of Defense said. 

Afterwards a dignified welcoming ceremony took place at the Hellenic Republic Ministry of National Defence, featuring the participation of an honor guard and a military band,

Subsequent to the ceremony, a formal meeting between the Minister of Defense Suren Papikyan and  the Minister of National Defense of the Hellenic Republic, Nikolaos Dendias took place. The issues related to the Armenian-Greek defense cooperation were discussed during the meeting.

At the meeting the considerable potential for cooperative development  was emphasized and, consequently, an agreement  was reached to invigorate the cooperation across various dimensions, encompassing military-technical engagements, experience exchange, educational initiatives, training programs, tactical training, and other directions.

At the culmination of the meeting, the Minister of Defense of the Republic of Armenia and the Minister of National Defense of the Hellenic Republic signed an Agreement "On Military-Technical Cooperation between the Government of the Republic of Armenia and the Government of the Hellenic Republic".

Afterwards, the ministers issued a joint statement to the press.

 



Armenian Government donates a precious Gospel of the 15th century to Matenadaran

 20:41,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 14, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan attended the ceremony of the donation of the precious Gospel of the 15th century by the Armenian Government to Matenadaran, Mesrop Mashtots Research Institute of Ancient Manuscripts,  the Prime Minister's Office said.

The manuscript was handed over to Matenadaran by Minister of Education, Science, Culture and Sports, President of Matenadaran Board of Trustees Zhanna Andreasyan.

Prime Minister Pashinyan congratulated everyone on the occasion of this important event. "The book of the 15th century, as the director of the Matenadaran noted, is returning home. Mr. Khzmalyan thanked me, I want to re-address my thanks to all the law-abiding taxpayers of Armenia, the money paid by whom gives the Government the opportunity to solve such problems.

I considered it important to emphasize this so that the taxpayers of the Republic of Armenia see that the payments they make are spent for such purposes as well. Of course, I don't think that the state budget expenditures have reached perfection in terms of effectiveness, but this is a very important point, because in general, our policy comes to the point that we must replace the logic of charity with the logic of law-abiding tax payment, because the biggest benefactors are those who pay their taxes dutifully, who, at the same time, strengthen the state, state institutions, and the state, in turn, gets the opportunity to strengthen the spiritual foundations, value foundations, and cultural foundations of the state.

And this is a very important point. Of course, we also intended for this not to be an isolated event or step. In the next year's state budget, we have earmarked funds for such acquisition, because this is indeed the case when the government reacted very quickly to Matenadaran's incitement. It is important that we have this example of quick response as a procedure for all cases when we have the opportunity to preserve, protect and return our spiritual and cultural values. This is one of our important political orientations, which we must develop.

I also want to draw attention to the fact that we are providing a lot of funds to preserve and restore cultural and historical monuments in Armenia, and we are also increasing the financing of science so that the research, preservation, and study of these monuments are placed on more institutional foundations.

I also want to draw attention to the fact that we are providing a lot of funds to preserve and restore cultural and historical monuments in Armenia, and we are also increasing the financing of science so that the research, preservation, and study of these monuments are placed on more institutional foundations.

As for the manuscript itself, to be honest, I can't say much about the manuscript. I am here to see it more with my own eyes, and in that sense I think I share the mission of many of you, and perhaps the experts will speak better about the value and history of the manuscript, and I am glad that we were able to give them that direct opportunity," Nikol Pashinyan said.

***

The manuscript donated to Matenadaran was written in the Arberd St. Astvastatsin Monastery of Vaspurakan, which is located not far from Narekavank and is unique due to the fact that it is a unique manuscript preserved from the famous Arberd Monastery and is also rich in illustrations.

The manuscript written and decorated in this now ruined monastery is the only witness of the culture and developed writing traditions of the Armenian people in that monastery. The manuscript was written in 1405 by Izit, of which only one Gospel has been known to us until now, copied in Narekavank in 1420, and which is kept in Matenadaran.

And today, hundreds of years later, two manuscripts of the same writer are located in Matenadaran.

Prime Minister Pashinyan also got acquainted with the "Christmas: miniature inspirations" exhibition opened in Matenadaran Museum ahead the Christmas holidays, which features unique examples of Armenian miniatures, many of which are being exhibited for the first time.

Armenia’s Oscar Submission Screened to Jam-Packed Theater at USC

LOS ANGELES—On December 5, the USC Dornsife Institute of Armenian Studies, in collaboration with the USC School of Cinematic Arts and Variance Films, hosted a sold-out theatrical screening and panel discussion of Amerikatsi, Armenia’s official Oscar submission for Best International Film. 

Due to an overwhelmingly large turnout, the USC School of Cinematic Arts held an additional screening in another room to accommodate the overflow. 

The screening was followed by a discussion with Michael A. Goorjian, the film’s writer, director and lead actor, and Patrick Malkassian, producer, in conversation with Luis Moreno Ocampo, Founding Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Ted Braun, USC Joseph Campbell Endowed Chair in Cinematic Ethics, and Steve Swerdlow, Esq., USC Associate Professor of the Practice of Human Rights. Dr. Shushan Karapetian, Director of the USC Dornsife Institute of Armenian Studies, introduced and moderated the discussion. 

USC Dornsife Institute of Armenian Studies Director Dr. Shushan Karapetian introducing the film

In her opening remarks, Dr. Karapetian highlighted the “rare and beautiful opportunity of being witness to dialogue between such invested and powerful voices, who may never have appeared in the same environment together otherwise.” 

The panelists provided an insightful analysis of the film’s universal themes of hope and belonging and the importance of giving voice to Armenian narratives for a global audience. 

Amerikatsi tells the story of Charlie, an Armenian-American who moves to Soviet Armenia in 1948 in hopes of finding a connection to his roots but instead finds a country crushed under Stalin’s rule. After being unjustly imprisoned, Charlie falls into despair until he discovers that he can see into a nearby apartment from his cell window—the home of a prison guard, Tigran. As his life unexpectedly becomes entwined with the guard’s, he begins to see that the true spirit of his homeland is alive in its people. 

For Michael Goorjian, making this film was an exploration of his identity as a filmmaker and an Armenian-American who had a desire to create something not limited by the experience of Genocide. Goorjian stated that this “film did not have to be about an Armenian at all.” He first heard the story that inspired the film from a Ukrainian friend who knew a man that could see into an apartment building from his prison cell. 

“Whether you are Greek or Italian, the exploration of your identity is a shared experience,” said producer Patrick Malkassian. In response to Dr. Karapetian’s inquiry about narrative scarcity, Malkassian described the difficulty of making a film about a group of people whose stories and narratives are historically overlooked. 

Ray Stark Family Theatre at USC

Commenting on Goorjian’s nuanced portrayal of the moral dilemmas faced by all the characters, Professor Braun stated, “By allowing us to empathize not just with Charlie, but also with Tigran the prison guard who is equally a captive, you help us understand how impossible the conflicting moral imperatives are, and you do it in a way that allows us to feel the humanity within all of the people trapped in this system…The film humanizes the perpetrator; that is the only way out. Because if you demonize the perpetrator, you repeat the cycle.” 

Steve Swerdlow drew parallels to Charlie’s experience in a Stalin-era prison with that of prisoners currently held in Azerbaijan, including Armenians abducted from Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) and outspoken Azerbaijani journalists who are being tried for trumped-up charges in kangaroo courts. 

Luis Moreno Ocampo, who was the first to blow the whistle about Aliyev’s authoritarian regime committing genocide in Artsakh, emphasized the need to engage a wider audience in the fight for prisoners in Azerbaijan, stating: “We need to talk about Armenia. If we talk about genocide our audience is small, but if we talk about this movie and the Oscar, the audience will be much bigger, and then we can talk about rescuing the 55 prisoners in Azerbaijan. You cannot go to Azerbaijan to rescue them, but you can support this film’s Oscar nomination. Your movie, Michael, is giving us an opportunity, because as I’ve learned, the more massive the demand, the easier it is to solve the problem.” 

L to R Dr. Shushan Karapetian, Patrick Malkassian, Michael A. Goorjian, Luis Moreno Ocampo, Ted Braun, Steve Swerdlow

“Responding as an artist, in a time like this with something that can reach people, is in many ways the most profound and important thing that you can do,” Braun said about the exodus from Artsakh and artistic response. 

The overflowing theater and engaged audience are proof of the film’s unique ability to reach across borders and boundaries, surpass language barriers, and deliver a human story of resilience and capacity for hope. 

“Film has the power to transform how we look at people, things, events, places and historical narratives we have taken for granted. It has the power to shape global perceptions and actions. The Institute is committed to bringing essential and pressing conversations to audiences in Los Angeles and beyond,” stated Dr. Karapetian. 

Established in 2005, the USC Dornsife Institute of Armenian Studies supports multidisciplinary scholarship to re-define, explore and study the complex issues that make up the contemporary Armenian experience—from post-Genocide to the developing Republic of Armenia to the evolving Diaspora. The Institute encourages research, publications and public service, and promotes links among the global academic and Armenian communities.




Mikael Vardanyan donated the maternity hospital of the Surb Grigor Lusavorich Medical Center the modern medical equipment amounting 116 million drams

Panorama
Armenia – Dec 14 2023

The maternity hospital of the Surb Grigor Lusavorich Medical Center of the RA Ministry of Health has been equipped with modern medical equipment of European, American and Japanese production.

Thanks to the financial support of benefactor Mikael Vardanyan, the maternity hospital already has new neonatal incubators, a neonatal portable ultrasound system, a high frequency neonatal ventilator, birthing, neonatal resuscitation and medical electric-hydraulic operating multifunctional tables, a neonatal electroencephalograph and MRI patient monitoring system.

Benefactor Mikael Vardanyan donated 116 million drams for the purchase of 15 life supporting equipment.

Opposition leader: Azerbaijan must be held to account for crimes in Artsakh

Panorama
Armenia – Dec 14 2023

Azerbaijan must be held to account for its crimes in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) in mid-September, Armenian opposition leader Seyran Ohanyan insists.

“The whole world should know that in a follow-up to Azerbaijan's criminal policy, the 10-month blockade of Artsakh by Baku which began in December 2022 was culminated in the illegal “anti-terrorist” operations, as a result of which genocide through forced exile was actually committed against the people of Artsakh,” Ohanyan, head of the opposition Hayastan parliamentary faction, told a press briefing.

The MP emphasized that the Artsakh issue has yet to be resolved through talks. "There is no alternative to negotiations," he said.

"Every Armenian realizes that the Artsakh issue has not been resolved. Only those with no sense of homeland can think that the time and resources spent on it were pointless, denying the fact that for more than a quarter of a century Artsakh was the guarantor of Armenia’s freedom and security," Ohanyan stressed.

Asbarez: EU’s Michel Refuses to Use the Word ‘Karabakh’

Council of Europe President Charles Michel during an interview with RFE/RL on Dec. 12


YEREVAN (Azatutyun.am)—The European Union’s top official, Charles Michel, has said that the EU keeps “working very hard” to help Armenia and Azerbaijan negotiate a comprehensive peace agreement.

“We are determined on the EU side to work with the partners and with them to ensure that as soon as possible a peace treaty will be signed between both sides,” Michel told RFE/RL in an interview.

In that regard, the president of the EU’s decision-making Council was encouraged by last week’s Armenian-Azerbaijani agreement to exchange prisoners reached as a result of direct negotiations.

“I would like to say that if it was possible for Armenia and Azerbaijan to make some joint announcements a few days ago, this is partially because we help them,” he said. “We encourage them. We suggested some options and some ideas to bring them closer to each other on the topics that have been announced. And we are still working on additional steps to encourage a peace treaty, a normalization agreement between Armenia and Azerbaijan.”

Michel was scheduled to host Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan in October for further talks on the treaty. However, Aliyev cancelled the talks. Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov likewise withdrew from a meeting with his Armenian counterpart slated for November 20 in Washington.

Michel declined to comment on Baku’s moves. “We are still working on a meeting that could take place in Brussels,” he said without giving potential dates.

Michel would also not say whether the EU or other world powers are ready to act as guarantors of Yerevan’s and Baku’s compliance with the would-be peace treaty. Nor did he clarify whether the treaty will likely make any reference to the rights and security of Karabakh’s ethnic Armenian population that fled to Armenia following Azerbaijan’s September 19-20 military offensive.

He pointedly declined to use the word “Karabakh,” referring instead to “this part of Azerbaijan” until recently populated by Armenians.

“We think that they [Karabakh Armenians] should have the right to return or at least to be able to visit this part of Azerbaijan and their security and rights must be guaranteed and there are international standards in terms of protection of the minorities that must be respected in line with the constitution of Azerbaijan, which should be a framework to guarantee those protections of minorities,” he said.

Brussels is therefore trying to “convince the Azerbaijani authorities to demonstrate that … they want to protect the minorities and to guarantee that the international standards are respected,” added Michel.

Even before their mass exodus triggered by the Azerbaijani offensive, Karabakh’s leaders and ordinary residents made clear that they will not live under Azerbaijani rule. Only a few dozen Karabakh Armenians are believed to remain in the territory recaptured by Baku. More than 100,000 others fled their homes later in September.