Thousands of Armenian Christians flee homes: ‘Mass exodus has begun,’ expert says

Sept 26 2023
A girl sleeps in a street in the town of Stepanakert on Sept. 25, 2023. Ethnic Armenian refugees began to leave Nagorno-Karabakh on Sept. 24, 2023, for the first time since Azerbaijan launched an offensive designed to seize control of the breakaway territory and perhaps end a three-decade-old conflict. | Credit: HASMIK KHACHATRYAN/AFP via Getty Images

Thousands of Armenian Christians have fled their ancestral homeland in the region of Nagorno-Karabakh over the weekend and more are expected, the government of Armenia confirmed Monday.

“The mass exodus has begun,” Siobhan Nash-Marshall, a U.S.-based human rights advocate who has been speaking to witnesses on the ground, told CNA.

Nash-Marshall founded the Christians in Need Foundation (CINF) in 2011 to help Armenian Christians in the region, and in 2020 she started a school for children and adults in Nagorno-Karabakh.

Now, Nash-Marshall has received word from her school in Nagorno-Karabakh that “all is over” and that “people from all regions, all villages, are homeless” and without shelter, food, and water. 

Hundreds of ethnic Armenians are sleeping in the streets and cannot even drink water because they claim it has been “poisoned by Azeris,” according to Nash-Marshall’s contacts. 

Nash-Marshall was told that there are lines of “2,000 in front of the only bakery” near her school and that “all are hungry, frightened, and hopeless.” 

According to the government of Armenia, 6,650 “forcibly displaced persons” entered Armenia from Nagorno-Karabakh since last week.

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan said Sunday that he expects most of the 120,000 ethnic Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh to flee the region due to “the danger of ethnic cleansing,” Middle Eastern news source Al Jazeera reported.

Both former soviet territories, Armenia and Azerbaijan have been fighting over Nagorno-Karabakh for decades. With the backing of Turkey, Azerbaijan asserted its military dominance over Armenia in the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War, which ended in November 2020.

Though Nagorno-Karabakh, also known as Artsakh, is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan, the region is almost entirely made up of ethnic Armenian Christians.

Until last week, Armenians in the region claimed self-sovereignty under the auspices of the “Republic of Artsakh.”

On Sept. 19, Azerbaijan launched a short but intense military offensive that included rocket and mortar fire. The offensive, labeled “antiterror measures” by the Azeri government, resulted in the deaths of more than 200 ethnic Armenians and over 10,000 displaced civilians, according to the Artsakh Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

On Sept. 20, the ethnic Armenians agreed to a cease-fire that resulted in the dismantling of their military and self-governance.

Following the breakaway region’s defeat by Azerbaijan, Azeri President Ilham Aliyev said that Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh would be integrated and that representatives from the enclave were “invited to dialogue” with the Azeri government.

Despite these promises, widespread fears of religious and cultural persecution have led large swathes of the population to flee to Armenia proper.

Eric Hacopian, a human rights advocate who has been on the ground in Nagorno-Karabakh, told CNA that Armenians in the region are facing “horrendous” conditions in which they have “little food” and “no medicine or security.” 

Hacopian called the Azeri actions in Nagorno-Karabakh “genocide” and said that by tomorrow he expects the number of refugees to rise to 15,000 to 20,000. 

Ultimately he believes “95% to 99%” of the Armenian population in the region will flee because of the “risk of being murdered and tortured.” 

Photos posted on social media showed the highways leading out of the region’s largest city, Stepanakert, filled with massive lines of cars filled with refugees.

Eric Hacopian, a human rights advocate who has been on the ground in Nagorno-Karabakh, told CNA that Armenians in the region are facing “horrendous” conditions in which they have “little food” and “no medicine or security.” 

Hacopian called the Azeri actions in Nagorno-Karabakh “genocide” and said that by tomorrow he expects the number of refugees to rise to 15,000 to 20,000. 

Ultimately he believes “95% to 99%” of the Armenian population in the region will flee because of the “risk of being murdered and tortured.” 

Photos posted on social media showed the highways leading out of the region’s largest city, Stepanakert, filled with massive lines of cars filled with refugees.

She said that deeply rooted anti-Armenian sentiment in Azeri culture is exhibited by the military’s executions of Armenian prisoners of war in 2022 as well as recently erected memorials in the Azeri capital city, Baku, that depict “grossly exaggerated life-sized figures of dead and dying Armenian soldiers and chained captives.”

“Anyone who knows the history of the Armenian Genocide will recognize the pattern of Azerbaijan’s actions with respect to Eastern Armenians and the Artsakhtsi,” Nash-Marshall said.

According to Gegham Stepanyan, an Artsakh human rights defender, “thousands” more displaced ethnic Armenians “are now waiting for their evacuation to Armenia.”

“Many of them,” Stepanyan said, “simply have nowhere to stay, so they have to wait for their turn in the streets.”

Some experts believe that Armenia itself is in danger of invasion.

Both Azerbaijan President Aliyev and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan have proposed constructing a highway in the far southern portion of the Armenian province of Syunik, which is bordered by Azerbaijan both to the east and the west.

The road would connect the main portion of Azerbaijan to both its western enclave, known as Nakhchivan, as well as to Turkey.

If built, experts fear Azerbaijan could soon move to wrest control of all of Syunik.

“Let us be realistic,” Nash-Marshall said. “Azerbaijan already has grabbed a part of the region … They are also firing on border villages and have been for a year. What, then, is the threat to Armenia? Invasion.”

Aliyev and Erdogan met in Nakhchivan on Monday, further increasing fears that the pair could be eyeing a Syunik takeover.

In a Monday press conference, Aliyev lamented that “the land link between the main part of Azerbaijan and Nakhchivan” was “cut off” when Soviet authorities assigned Syunik to Armenia instead of Azerbaijan, according to reporting by Reuters. 

Hacopian also said that he believes an invasion of Armenia is “quite likely” to create a highway in what is currently southern Armenia. 

Samantha Power, chief administrator for the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), and Assistant Secretary of State Yuri Kim landed in Armenia Monday.

In a Monday X post, Power said: “I’m here to reiterate the U.S.’s strong support & partnership with Armenia and to speak directly with those impacted by the humanitarian crisis in Nagorno-Karabakh.”

Many still feel that the U.S. is not doing enough to address the situation unfolding in Nagorno-Karabakh.

New Jersey Republican Rep. Chris Smith introduced a bill Friday to require the U.S. State Department to take concrete actions to guarantee the human rights of the Armenian Christians in Nagorno-Karabakh.

Titled the “Preventing Ethnic Cleansing and Atrocities in Nagorno-Karabakh Act of 2023,” the bill is co-sponsored by California Democrat Rep. Brad Sherman and Arkansas Republican Rep. French Hill.

If passed, the bill would require the U.S. government to take several actions in support of the impacted Armenians including terminating military aid to Azerbaijan and establishing military financing for Armenia, authorizing humanitarian assistance to Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh and dispatching diplomats to the region to monitor the situation and immediately report any further human rights abuses. 

“The people of Nagorno-Karabakh are in grave danger,” Smith said in a Monday press release. “Tragically, they have been forced to disarm and surrender their independence to a ruthless dictator whose government has repeatedly committed horrific abuses against them over many years, expressed its will to ethnically cleanse them, and even initiated a genocide by starvation with the blockade of the Lachin Corridor.”

Smith went on to say that “we must work with them to ensure that the transition is not marked by continued human atrocities.”

https://www.catholicnewsagency.com/news/255473/thousands-of-armenian-christians-flee-homes-mass-exodus-has-begun-expert-says

During phone call with Pashinyan, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz expresses readiness to support peace efforts

 13:06, 9 September 2023

YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 9, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan spoke by phone on Saturday with Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany Olaf Scholz.

PM Pashinyan and Chancellor Scholz discussed issues related to the deepening of the humanitarian crisis in Nagorno-Karabakh as a result of the illegal blocking of the Lachin Corridor, the accumulation of Azerbaijani troops around Nagorno-Karabakh, and the increasing tension on the Armenia-Azerbaijan state border, the Prime Minister’s Office said in a readout.

Prime Minister Pashinyan reaffirmed his commitment to the approaches of settling all issues exclusively through diplomatic means and in a constructive atmosphere, based on the agreements reached on October 6, 2022 in Prague and on May 14, 2023 in Brussels.

Chancellor Scholz noted that he is ready to support efforts aimed at establishing peace and stability in the region.

Prime Minister Pashinyan emphasized that he is ready to hold urgent discussions with the President of Azerbaijan aimed at reducing tension.

The Economist: An Armenian enclave inside Azerbaijan is on the point of starvation

 The Economist 
Sept 4 2023

After more than eight months of an ever-tightening blockade, the humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh has turned catastrophic. Bread, a staple for many people, is rationed to one loaf per family per day. Critical medicines have run out; there is so little fuel that many patients cannot get to a doctor anyway. Desperate residents have taken to social media to barter, say, home-laid eggs for a kilo of sugar. One young mother posted a photo of baby formula, saying: “I will buy this at any price.”

The siege represents the toughest tactic yet employed by the Azerbaijani government, as it seeks to regain control of Nagorno-Karabakh, an enclave of around 4,400 sq km (1,700 sq miles) at the heart of its decades-old conflict with Armenia. Karabakh has been internationally recognised as Azerbaijani territory since the break-up of the Soviet Union, but ethnic Armenian forces won control of it in a war that ran from 1988 to 1994 (Armenians made up most of the population). In a second war, in 2020, Azerbaijan reversed many of those losses. The Azerbaijani government is now pushing for a deal that would complete its victory.

Now surrounding the territory completely, Azerbaijan holds virtually all the cards. Armenia’s prime minister, Nikol Pashinyan, has said he is willing to accept Azerbaijan’s sovereignty over Karabakh and its tens of thousands of ethnic Armenian residents. The Armenians still hope to secure some kind of guarantee of the rights and security of the Karabakh Armenians. But an impatient Azerbaijan is trying to accelerate the diplomatic process—at the expense of the Armenian population it claims to want to welcome back into the fold.

In December government-backed Azerbaijani protesters launched a blockade of the “Lachin corridor”, the only road that leads in and out of Karabakh to Armenia. Civilian traffic was restricted and shipments into Karabakh of food, fuel and other necessities were curtailed, although enough got through to ward off severe hardship. But in April Azerbaijan dismissed the protesters and set up an official border checkpoint on the corridor; in mid-June it halted traffic altogether. No goods have got through since then.

In the face of the mounting privation inside Karabakh, Azerbaijan has offered a lifeline: to open its own road on which supplies could be sent from elsewhere in Azerbaijan. But the Karabakh Armenians see this as a Trojan horse that would lead to Azerbaijan regaining effective control of the territory. They have gone so far as to erect their own blockade, with cement blocks, on the new road. For now, their political concerns outweigh the humanitarian consequences.

International mediators, led by the European Union, are trying to help the two sides find a way out. A compromise would see both roads opened, but the governments are at loggerheads over the sequencing. The Azerbaijanis have offered to open the Lachin corridor if their road is opened first, but the Armenians say that is a trick and demand that the two roads be opened simultaneously.

Independent information from inside sealed-off Karabakh is hard to come by. But there are signs of a fierce power struggle among ethnic Armenian leaders there. At the end of August Arayik Harutyunyan, the de facto president, stepped down after coming under fire for his supposed willingness to compromise with Azerbaijanis. More intransigent figures have been ascending.

Meanwhile, frequent clashes break out at the border: on September 1st three Armenian soldiers were reported killed after cross-border firing. It is hard to see a solution to the impasse. But regardless of the outcome, any hope that the Karabakh Armenians might live peacefully in Azerbaijan is dwindling fast.


https://www.economist.com/europe/2023/09/04/an-armenian-enclave-inside-azerbaijan-is-on-the-point-of-starvation

EU Again Urges Baku to Open Lachin Corridor

EU foreign affairs chief Josep Borrell speaks at a summit of EU foreign ministers in Toledo, Span on Aug. 31


The European Union’s foreign affairs chief Josep Borrell called on Azerbaijan to open the Lachin Corridor.

“We call on Azerbaijan’s authorities to ensure the safe and unimpeded movement along the Lachin Corridor,” Borrell told reporters on Thursday after a meeting of EU foreign ministers in Toledo, Spain, where the issue of the humanitarian crisis in Artsakh was an agenda item, Armenpress reported.

Borrell statement echoes the wording of a ruling by the International Court of Justice, which in February ordered Baku to open the Lachin Corridor. The ICJ reaffirmed its order in July, yet Azerbaijan has refused to carry out the order, despite international calls for it to do so.
Earlier on Thursday, German Foreign Minister German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock announced that Artsakh situation would be discussed at the Toledo summit

Baerbock said that she and French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna had included the matter on the meeting’s agenda.

The German foreign minister described the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh as “disastrous” and emphasized the importance of opening the Lachin Corridor, according to the Tass news agency.

“We are resolutely calling upon Azerbaijan and Russia, that the people of Nagorno-Karabakh must eventually get what’s necessary for life. The Lachin Corridor must be open for humanitarian aid,” Baerbock said.

Baerbock added that discussions have been ongoing for several days with the United States to guarantee that the people of Nagorno-Karabakh will receive humanitarian aid.

Azerbaijan refuses to receive Personal Representative of the OSCE Chairman-in-Office

 14:54,

YEREVAN, AUGUST 25, ARMENPRESS. Azerbaijan has refused to receive Ambassador Andrzej Kasprzyk, the Personal Representative of the OSCE Chairman-in-Office who planned to visit the country after his trip to Armenia.

According to the Azerbaijani APA news agency, “official Baku did not see the need for his visit, considered it a waste of time and did not agree.”

Kasprzyk met with Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan on August 22.

He then visited the Armenian village of Kornidzor on August 25 to inspect the entrance to the blocked Lachin Corridor.

Kasprzyk intended to visit Azerbaijan after his Armenia trip.

UN Under-Secretary-General for Political and Peacebuilding Affairs briefed on Nagorno- Karabakh humanitarian crisis

 14:47,

YEREVAN, AUGUST 18, ARMENPRESS. On August 18, in New York, Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan met with United Nations Under-Secretary-General for Political and Peacebuilding Affairs Rosemary DiCarlo, the foreign ministry said in a press release. 

Ararat Mirzoyan particularly presented the extremely difficult humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh, stressing that the responsible actors of the international system should not allow it to turn into a real humanitarian catastrophe. The Minister emphasised the special role and prevention function of the UN Security Council as a structure with a mandate to maintain peace and security.

Touching upon the unfolded difficult conditions for the vulnerable groups of 120,000 people in Nagorno-Karabakh, Minister Mirzoyan stressed the urgency of implementing the Orders of the International Court of Justice of February 22 and July 6 and lifting Azerbaijan’s illegal blockade of the Lachin corridor.

In the context of establishing lasting stability in the region, Minister Mirzoyan emphasised the need for Azerbaijan to refrain from actions and provocations aimed at neutralising international efforts in that direction and the possibility of achieving peace.

Romanian Foreign Minister briefed on Nagorno-Karabakh humanitarian crisis

 21:16,

YEREVAN, AUGUST 17, ARMENPRESS. On August 17, Minister of Foreign Affairs of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan had a telephone conversation with Luminița-Teodora Odobescu, Minister of Foreign Affairs of Romania.

Ararat Mirzoyan emphasized that the humanitarian crisis, resulting from Azerbaijan’s illegal blockade of the Lachin corridor, is deteriorating in Nagorno-Karabakh hour by hour, presenting in detail the serious problems created for the 120,000 population of Nagorno-Karabakh and especially for the vulnerable groups, the foreign ministry said in a statement.

Minister Mirzoyan noted that since December 2022, the discussions of the two sessions of the UN Security Council, as well as the appeals made so far by various governments and international bodies show that the civilized world has a common understanding of the humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh. Nevertheless, resolution of the crisis in Nagorno-Karabakh requires the international community to take clear steps in order to implement the legally binding Orders of the International Court of Justice of February 22 and July 6 and to restore free and unimpeded movement in both directions through the Lachin corridor.

Reiterating the position of the Armenian side on establishing stability in the region, Minister Mirzoyan noted that by escalating the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh, Azerbaijan threatens the efforts of Armenia and the international community in that direction.

Genocide scholars call for immediate UN intervention in Nagorno-Karabakh

 19:43,

YEREVAN, AUGUST 11, ARMENPRESS. Prominent genocide scholars have submitted an open letter to the UN Secretary-General, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, the Special Adviser of the UN Secretary-General on the Prevention of Genocide, and Member States of the UN Security Council regarding the potential for genocide in Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh).

Below is the full letter:

H.E. António Guterres
UN Secretary-General,

Mr. Volker Türk
UN High Commissioner for Human Rights,

Ms. Alice Wairimu Nderitu
Special Adviser of the UN Secretary-General on the Prevention of Genocide,

UN Security Council Member States

9 August 2023

We, the undersigned scholars and experts on genocide, are writing to you with an overwhelming sense of urgency and concern about the potential for genocide in the Republic of Artsakh (also known as the Nagorno Karabakh Republic). As scholars deeply engaged in the study of genocide, we bear witness to the horrors of history, rigorously analyze past and present atrocities, working to prevent new genocides from occurring. Presently, we find ourselves profoundly concerned by the emergence of unmistakable warning signs of genocide in Artsakh. The most significant risk factor is the unlawful blockade of the Lachin Corridor, which serves as the vital link connecting Artsakh to Armenia.

Since December 2022, the Lachin Corridor, the sole lifeline connecting the Artsakh population to the outside world, has been unlawfully blockaded by Azerbaijani authorities. This distressing situation reached a critical juncture on June 15, 2023, when Azerbaijan sealed off this vital road, subjecting the Republic of Artsakh and its 120,000 residents to a dire state of siege. For the past two months, Artsakh has been forcibly deprived of its ability to access essential supplies such as food, medicine, and other critical goods. Even humanitarian relief efforts conducted by Russian peacekeepers and the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) have been obstructed, exacerbating an already grave humanitarian crisis.

The escalating humanitarian crisis has prompted the ICRC, the sole international organization with a presence on the ground, to issue a grave alert. In a public statement released on July 25 (https://www.icrc.org/en/document/azerbaijan-armenia-sides-must-reach-humanitarian-consensus-to-ease-suffering), the ICRC unequivocally documented that“The civilian population is now facing a lack of life-saving medication and essentials like hygiene products and baby formula. Fruits, vegetables, and bread are increasingly scarce and costly, while some other food items such as dairy products, sunflower oil, cereal, fish, and chicken are not available.”

Furthermore, the Global Centre for the Responsibility to Protect has issued an alarming atrocity alert for Nagorno Karabakh(https://www.globalr2p.org/publications/atrocity-alert-no-358/), highlighting the persistent risk of enduring mass atrocity crimes.

Considering the aforementioned circumstances and drawing upon additional pertinent information provided by various impartial organizations, human rights organisations, and other relevant stakeholders, we, as experts in the field of genocide studies, hold the view that compelling indicators exist that in the absence of prompt and resolute action, a genocide targeting the ethnic Armenian population of Artsakh is a looming possibility. The prevention of genocide and safeguarding vulnerable populations stand as fundamental obligations of the global community, as underscored by the United Nations Charter and the Genocide Convention of 1948, along with subsequent pledges undertaken by international actors. Guided by these principles, we strongly urge member states and UN bodies to promptly and resolutely step forward, exercising their responsibility to forestall any additional loss of innocent lives and preclude the occurrence of large-scale atrocities.

Specifically, we call upon the United Nations to activate its early warning mechanism, as stipulated within its mandates, to expeditiously address the tangible and imminent threat of genocide in Artsakh. We urge a concerted international effort to bring this grave situation to the attention of the UN Security Council. The Security Council should take decisive action to avert the progression of genocide by urgently removing the blockade on the Lachin Corridor, thereby reinstating unimpeded movement of persons, vehicles, and cargo along this life-supporting corridor in both directions. Security Council action should also support of the Provisional Measures order of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) of 22 February 2023 (reaffirmed 6 July 2023), which ordered Azerbaijan to ‘take all measures at its disposal to ensure unimpeded movement of persons, vehicles and cargo along the Lachin Corridor in both directions’. A Provisional Measures order is binding, and Azerbaijan remains in breach of its international law obligations by not complying with the ICJ’s order. Furthermore, we urge that the UN establish and send a fact-finding mission to Artsakh for a thorough analysis of data, on-site reporting, and engagement with local communities and organizations to identify and eliminate the consequences of the ongoing crime.

The prevention of genocide requires a collective effort, a unified resolve, and unwavering commitment from the international community. We urge the United Nations and its bodies to prioritize the prevention of genocide in Artsakh and take decisive action to protect the lives and dignity of thousands of innocent people.

Time is of the essence. We urge you to act swiftly and decisively, guided by the principles of the United Nations and the mandate to protect humanity from the scourge of genocide.

Respectfully signed,

Melanie O’Brien, Associate Professor of International Law, University of Western Australia; and President of the International Association of Genocide Scholars

Henry C. Theriault, Associate Vice President for Academic Affairs at Worcester State University, Past President of the International Association of Genocide Scholars (2017-2021)

Andrew Woolford, Professor, Head of Department of Sociology and Criminology, University of Manitoba, Past President of the International Association of Genocide Scholars (2015-2017)

Israel Charny, Director of the Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide in Jerusalem, Past President of the International Association of Genocide Scholars (2005-2007)

Armen Marsoobian, Professor of Philosophy, Southern Connecticut State University, Past First Vice President of the International Association of Genocide Scholars (2019-23)

Elisa von Joeden-Forgey, Chair of Department of Holocaust and Genocide Studies, Keene State College, Past First Vice President of the International Association of Genocide Scholars (2015-17)

Hervé Georgelin, Assistant Professor, Department of Turkish Studies and Modern Asian Studies, National and Capodistrian University of Athens

Dr. Vasileios Meichanetsidis, Greek Genocide scholar

Armenpress: Kim Kardashian, Eric Esrailian raise awareness of former ICC prosecutor’s genocide warning in Nagorno-Karabakh

 20:18, 9 August 2023

YEREVAN, AUGUST 9, ARMENPRESS. American reality TV star, entrepreneur Kim Kardashian and UCLA physician, Emmy-nominated film producer Eric Esrailian took to social media to raise awareness of Nagorno-Karabakh and the report issued by a former chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court concluding that the Azerbaijani blockade of Lachin Corridor constitutes genocide.

Former chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court Luis Moreno Ocampo has warned that Azerbaijan is preparing genocide against the Armenian population in Nagorno-Karabakh and called for a U.S. Security Council intervention.

Esrailian, who produced the 2016 historical drama The Promise set during the years of the Armenian Genocide, and who visited the Armenian Genocide Memorial in Yerevan the following year together with filmmaker Terry George, shared the report on Instagram.

Armenian-American media personality Kim Kardashian, who has also personally visited the Armenian Genocide Memorial in Yerevan and in 2021 thanked U.S. President Joe Biden for officially recognizing the 1915 Armenian Genocide, shared Esrailian’s post on Instagram.

“Please share! This report is by Luis Moreno Ocampo – former Chief Prosecutor at the International Criminal Court. He argues Azerbaijan’s blockade of the Lachin corridor should be considered a genocide against the ethnic Armenians of Artsakh/Nagorno-Karabakh. The government of Azerbaijan is using oil & gas leverage to cleanse the Christian Armenian population from the region. Read & share the report! The link to the full report is in my bio,” Esrailian said.