Artsakh Ombudsman: Armenia should clarify what it means when talking about the final status of Artsakh

NEWS.am
Armenia –

Armenia should clarify what it means when talking about the final status of Artsakh, Artsakh Ombudsman Gegham Stepanyan told reporters, answering the question that Armenia does not unequivocally insist on self-determination.

“The position of Armenia, reflected in six points, notes the provision of a secure life for the people of Artsakh and the clarification of the final status of Artsakh. I believe that Armenia should clarify what it means by saying “final status”, and at least clarify that this status does not mean being part of Azerbaijan.”

To the remark that one of the deputies of the ruling power in Armenia announced such a possibility, Gegham Stepanyan reacted:

“Whatever they want, let them say. For us, this option is unacceptable. The people of Artsakh will not accept such a settlement option.”

Regarding the well-known statement that the international community is demanding to “lower the bar”, the Ombudsman observed:

“I don’t know what ‘lower the bar’ means. But I know exactly what that can’t mean. The Artsakh side has always spoken about recognizing the right to self-determination and independence.”

He recalled that the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs also put forward proposals containing various, including intermediate options.

“There are many alternatives, there is only one exception: the presence of Artsakh as part of Azerbaijan,” Stepanyan said, adding that he does not think that a decision unacceptable for Artsakh can be made.

Freedom House concerned about Armenia’s anti-defamation law

PanArmenian
Armenia –

PanARMENIAN.Net – Marc Behrendt, the Director for Europe and Eurasia programs at Freedom House, has said that Armenia has made progress in democracy and human rights, but added that the organziation is concerned about legislation criminalizing defamation, Factor TV reports.

Behrendt told a forum on Armenian democracy in Yerevan on Friday, May 20 that the new law could restrict freedom of _expression_ in the country. He urged the government and the National Assembly to pay attention to criticism on the matter.

The expert also assured that Freedom House will do their best to achieve positive changes in the fight against disinformation in Armenia

Earlier too the organization slammed the new legislation as “controversial”, which it said signifies a clear degradation of democratic norms in Armenia, including freedom of _expression_. Freedom House called on the Armenian authorities to immediately cease enforcement of the law.

Opposition`s "toxic nature" accounts for absence of broad masses outside – Karen Sargsyan

ARMINFO
Armenia –
David Stepanyan

ArmInfo. It is the “toxic nature” of the parliamentary opposition calling on people to take to the streets that must be accounting for the absence of broad masses  outside, the sociologist Karen Sargsyan said in an interview with  ArmInfo. 

“In other words, our people are well aware that in case they take  sides with the opposition in the streets they will face many more  problems in the future, without solving the existing ones. Another  factor is that, after the ‘velvet’ revolution, our society is not yet  ready for such widespread protests for objective reasons – especially  after the pandemic and war,” Mr Sargsyan said. 

Another reason – perhaps the major one – for the people’s reluctance  to participate in the protests against Armenia’s incumbent  authorities is the opposition’s vague agenda. Any poll in any  Armenian region would show lack of understanding of the objectives of  the ongoing protests. “For example, I do not think any resident in  any of Armenia’s regions could explain the reasons for the opposition  putting up tents in Yerevan’s center – only because the demands being  put forward by the opposition have nothing in common with sitting in  the tents in Yerevan’s France Square. 

“After all, the public concern over Artsakh’s future does not change  anything at all. Such issues are normally solved in top-level  offices, not in the streets. I think it is common knowledge now. And  the foreign forces unwilling to spend their money on such opposition  are well aware of that as well,” Mr Sargsyan said. 

Six points about nothing – Levon Zurabyan

ARMINFO
Armenia –
Marianna Mkrtchyan

ArmInfo.Levon  Zurabyan, Vice-Chairman of the Armenian National Congress (ANC), has commented on the six points proposed by the Armenian side for normalizing the  Armenian-Azerbaijani relations.  

“The six points are about nothing,” Mr Zurabyan wrote on his Facebook  page. 

“We have once more been convinced that Armenia’s government does not  understand anything in diplomacy and is incapable in the true sense  of the word. The point is that Azerbaijan has presented its own ides  to Armenia of what specific provisions should be included in the  future peace agreement to be signed between Armenia and Azerbaijan. 

“Briefly, they are: 1) mutual recognition of territorial integrity 2)  ruling out territorial claims 3) ruling out use of force or threat of  force 4) border delimitation and demarcation and establishment of  diplomatic relations 5) unblocking of communications. That is,  Azerbaijan proposes its own vision or a draft peace agreement, its  vision of the form of the documents,” Mr Zurabyan wrote.  Armenia’s  response was clear. According to diplomatic rules, Armenia was to  present its vision of the same agreement.

“And now our government has proclaimed six points presented in  response. On May 13, Edmon Marukyan made them public. So what? We  find out that Armenia has no idea of what it wanted to include in the  agreement or of what it wanted to change in Azerbaijan’s proposals,”  Mr Zurabyan wrote.

Scrutinizing Armenia’s response shows that, instead of its own  proposals and ideas, Armenia presented the following: 

1) “Discontent” with an unnamed co-chair responsible for a 20-day  delay in Armenia receiving, allegedly on March 11, a letter sent by  Azerbaijan on February 21. 2) Stating the historical fact that,  according to the authors, proves that by joining the Declaration on  CIS back in 1991, Armenia recognized Azerbaijan’s territorial  integrity (and it remains unclear if Armenia is ready to include the  point on mutual recognition of territorial integrity in the text of  the agreement or not). 3) The claim about Nagorno-Karabakh’s final  status being a “matter of principle” for the Armenian side, which  does not specify the status or mechanism Armenia is proposing to  settle the issue (this claim cannot even be viewed as a proposal to  put the issue of status on the negotiations agenda)  

4) The claim about Armenia attaching “importance” to honoring the  commitments under the Russian- Armenian-Azerbaijani agreements, which  claim cannot even be viewed as a demand to honor the commitments or  as a precondition for negotiations or at least as a proposal for  putting it on the agenda. 

5) A statement on the readiness to start negotiations, which, in  fact, confirms Armenia is not putting forward any preconditions for  negotiations. 

6) A report claiming that the Armenian side applied to the OSCE Minsk  Group co-chairs for organizing negotiations (idiotic behavior given  the co-chairs’ inability for teamwork in the context of the  Russia-West relations) 

According to Zurabyan, this text shows that in their reply letter the  Armenian authorities only “stated their feelings about the ongoing  negotiations, made a dubious excursion into the historical domain,  hinting at the other negotiators honoring their commitments,  introduced romantic proposals for organizing the negotiations,” Mr  Zurabyan wrote. 

“In short, they have done all they could except for what they should  have done in this process of crucial importance for Armenia and  Artsakh,” he added.  

According to him, the Armenian authorities did not present its  proposals to either Azerbaijan or the international community.

“Even Azerbaijani Foreign Minister [Jeyhun] Bayramov jeered at this  lukewarm response, while reading the first point and asking ‘So what  is Armenia’s proposal here?’

“Have no doubts that these people are making a laughingstock of us  everywhere and failing any business.  They have no elementary  understanding of international politics and diplomacy of negotiations  – be it Nikol Pashinyan, Ararat Mirzoyan, Armen Grigoryan, Vahagn  Khachaturyan or Edmon Marukyan. Under the circumstances, as long as  Armenia lacks a competent and responsible government, the only hope  in the diplomatic process is that the superpowers’ interests and  plans will concur with those of Armenia. But it is a most slender  theoretical chance,” Mr Zurabyan wrote. 

Baku Welcomes Iran’s Role in Reconstruction of Karabakh

Financial Tribune, Iran

The foreign minister of the Republic of Azerbaijan welcomed the participation of Iranian companies in the process of reconstruction of the areas in his country that have been liberated after the last war over the Nagorno-Karabakh region.

In a telephone conversation with his Iranian counterpart on Saturday night, Azeri Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov expressed his country’s readiness for continued diplomatic visits and the expansion of political relations with Iran at different levels, Tasnim News Agency reported. 

Pointing to the close and unshakable relations between Baku and Tehran, Bayramov described the participation of the Iranian companies in the reconstruction of Karabakh as a major step in that process.

Iran’s top diplomat, Hossein Amir-Abdollahian, hailed the important agreements that the presidents of Iran and Azerbaijan have signed in the past months, saying the full implementation of the contracts is on the agenda.

He also referred to the fruitful results of the most recent meeting of the Iran-Azerbaijan Joint Economic Commission in Baku as a major progress in the promotion of mutual relations.

The two senior diplomats stressed the need to maintain regional and international cooperation between the two neighbors and save the relations from the plots hatched by the common enemies of their nations.

In a separate telephone conversation on Saturday, Amir-Abdollahian and his Greek counterpart Nikos Dendias talked about cooperation between Tehran and Athens and the latest developments in the Vienna talks on the removal of sanctions against Iran.

Stressing the need to broaden Iran’s economic and trade relations with Greece, Amir-Abdollahian called for plans to immunize bilateral ties against the influence of the third parties.

Highlighting the great potential of Iran and Greece for the promotion of economic and trade cooperation, Amir-Abdollahian stressed the need to immunize the age-old relations between the two countries against the influence exerted by certain third parties and actors.

Briefing his Greek counterpart on the latest developments in the Vienna talks on the removal of anti-Iran sanctions, the foreign minister reaffirmed Tehran’s resolve to strike a good and sustainable agreement.

Dendias highlighted the significance of relations with Iran, calling for the continuation of contacts between the Greek and Iranian authorities.

The two senior diplomats also emphasized the necessity of closer interaction between Tehran and Athens and their cooperation in the international organizations.

This Family Fled The Armenian Genocide. Their Arlington Rug Store Turns 100 This Year


Dona Manoukian looks closely at a photo of the Manoukian brothers and their family.

A young couple walks through a set of glass doors with a wagon. It’s heavy, so they’re both hauling it with purpose. Rolled up, laying inside it is a red rug.

“You didn’t convince him of the color?” asks Mikael Manoukian. His family has owned Manoukian Brothers Oriental Rugs in Arlington, VA for generations.

“He’s not quite sold,” says the customer, Tsholo Chidakwa, who just moved to the area from South Africa.

“Do you think the blue would work?” asks Manoukian. “I might be able to get one of these in a light yellow.”

“Just send us a picture and then we’ll come and take a look at it in the store,” says her husband, Munya. “Rugs, they define the space.”

Although he studied business management in college, Manoukian didn’t plan to become a businessman. His passion lies in video production and live events, having spent nearly two decades as a cameraman – and is a self-described “recovering” actor. But when his father, Paul, began to age out of work, it fell upon him to run the family business: The oldest “oriental” rug store in the D.C. region.

Mikael Manoukian walks through the back of the shop, where hundreds of rugs sit in stock.Héctor Alejandro Arzate / DCist/WAMU

“I wouldn’t have chosen to do it,” says Manoukian, 52. “My goal was to basically honor my ancestors and their effort and do the best I could do.”

Those ancestors were the Manoukian brothers – Manouk, Noury, Mishel, and Mikael’s grandfather, Moses. They were forced to flee the city of Aintab, which is present day Gaziantep in Turkey, during the Armenian Genocide. That genocide, which has been recognized by the United States, occurred between 1915 and 1923.

According to Rouben Adalian, the director of the Armenian National Institute, a non-profit organization that researches and documents the history of the genocide, more than two million Armenians were systematically killed and forcibly deported.

Outside the shop, a sticker with the flag of Armenia reads, “Armenia Wants Peace.”Héctor Alejandro Arzate / DCist/WAMU

“The Armenian-American community effectively emerged on account of the atrocities that were being committed in the Ottoman Empire,” says Adalian. “Nearly all of them were people seeking refuge, looking for a way to simply hang onto life now and restart.”

The Manoukian family was able to escape to Aleppo in Syria before catching a French boat traveling across the Mediterranean. Eventually, they reached Ellis Island in New York before moving to D.C., where the brothers started a new life.

“My grandfather and his brothers came over here not to start a business, but to flee a genocide,” says Manoukian.

Most of the brothers found work at places like the Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Co. (A&P) grocery stores to provide for their family, according to Manoukian. In 1922, with enough money saved up, Manouk opened A&P Rugs store in Foggy Bottom, taking inspiration for the name from his days at the grocery chain. Like many immigrants throughout U.S. history, Manoukian says his great-uncle opened a business that felt familiar to his own culture.

Tsholo Chidakwa and her husband, Munya, return a rug to Manoukian.Héctor Alejandro Arzate / DCist/WAMU

“He started the first little boutique, and it was probably simply because he came from an area and tradition that [knew] about rugs,” says Manoukian.

Seeing the benefit of selling products they were knowledgeable about, the rest of the Manoukians decided to open up rug shops in the District too. Not long after, says Manoukian, the brothers combined forces under one brand: Manoukian Brothers Oriental Rugs.

At the time, getting a hold of hand woven “oriental” rugs took both business acumen and hustle. The brothers would make their way to New York City to meet with rug dealers who imported the goods from Afghanistan and India, among other countries. They built relationships with the wholesalers, browsing hundreds of intricate rugs in between friendly games of backgammon and cups of thick Turkish coffee. When the brothers saw a rug they liked, they’d engage in lengthy negotiations before striking a deal.

“That was a very traditional thing to do,” says Dona Manoukian, Mikael’s mother, who continues to help run the business alongside him. “They brought their culture with them.”

Although it has gotten smaller over the past century, Adalian says the Armenian community in D.C. thrived for a time. Some families got involved in the hotel business, while some others specialized in the rug business.

A stack of rugs are spread by Manoukian to showcase the different styles and patterns.Héctor Alejandro Arzate / DCist/WAMU

“Small as it was, it was a coherent community,” says Adalian. “That’s one craft that many Armenians practice in the old country and one that turned out to be a profitable business in the U.S.”

Business was good for the Manoukians. The rug store became a staple not just for local customers, but nationally as well. In 1971, Manoukian Brothers supplied an antique sarouk rug from Iran to the federal government. When the rug was used as an underlayment for the U.S. Constitution inside the National Archive, it marked a milestone for the family. Since then, the business has provided, cleaned, and repaired rugs for institutions like Congress, the U.S. Capitol, and the Supreme Court.

As a youth, Paul, Mikael’s father, would help his father and uncles around the store. It was expected of him to not just continue the family business but also earn a college degree, Manoukian says. Paul became a civil engineer for the Washington Metropolitan Area Transportation Authority, but on his lunch breaks, evenings, and weekends, he was a part-time rug salesman.

As time moved on, however, Moses, Mikael’s grandfather, and his brothers got older and were unable to travel as frequently as they once were. As he approached retirement from the WMATA in 1998, Paul took on the responsibilities of running the family business full time, just as his son Mikael would eventually do for him.

A framed photo reads, “CONSTITUTION DAY – SEPTEMBER 17, 1971. Antique Sarouk Carpet from Manoukian Brothers with the Constitution of the United States of America.”Héctor Alejandro Arzate / DCist/WAMU

For more than 20 years, Dona and Paul carried the family business into a new generation. He strengthened relationships with clients both longtime and new, while she streamlined their management and hired more employees. For Dona, it was just part of being married to a Manoukian.

“You don’t just marry the person, you marry the whole family,” says Dona. “The food, the traditions…things like that.”

Paul continued to barter with rug wholesalers in New York City. Sometimes, returning with a carrier van filled to the brim with Afghan gabbehs or peshawars from Pakistan. Or sometimes, no rugs at all.

Despite the ups and downs of running a business, Dona says it was always one of Paul’s goals to be fair to his customers and make the hand-knotted rugs – which are sometimes seen as luxury goods – more accessible by making payment plans available for them.

Manoukian places his hand over a recently repaired rug.Héctor Alejandro Arzate / DCist/WAMU

“One of the things that Paul Manoukian always tried to do was to price rugs so that anybody who wanted a handmade rug could afford it,” says Dona.

Although the business sat in the heart of the District for most of its existence, they relocated to Arlington after losing their lease about 4 years ago – which is around the same time that Mikael took over the reins. While it hasn’t been easy, he feels an obligation to carry on the family business. He says it’s not so difficult compared to his family’s escape from the Armenian Genocide.

“All I have to do is run a business,” says Manoukian. “I’m not fleeing for my life.”

In addition to his daily responsibilities, Manoukian is focusing on community outreach. Last year, the business hosted the Rug Shop Concerts inside the store front. Utilizing his chops in video production, the performances were shot in 4K and provided local musicians with a safe venue to perform and receive donations.

Manoukian is also working to continue raising awareness of the Armenian Genocide. In March, the Virginia Senate and House of Delegates passed a resolution to commend the store for celebrating 100 years of business. Delegate Alfonso Lopez, the son of a Venezuelan immigrant, says the resolution is one way to honor the family’s history after escaping the Ottoman Empire.

“Not only is it a family-run business rooted deeply in the history of our region, but its past is grounded in the same kind of stories of perseverance and success that have drawn so many immigrant families to the United States, including my own,” says Lopez. “It’s only right that the Commonwealth of Virginia officially honor the Manoukian family and the success of Manoukian Brothers Oriental Rugs—because they embody the very best of what the American Dream has meant to so many who have come before us and will provide an example of hope to the many who will come after.”

Manoukian in his office.Héctor Alejandro Arzate / DCist/WAMU

As a second generation Armenian-American, Manoukian recognizes the challenges and sacrifices his ancestors had to endure. Like many immigrants and refugees, the Manoukian brothers didn’t plan to flee their home country. He hopes that Afghan refugees and other groups that have recently arrived in the region can find solace in his family’s story.

“I’m a product of a departure from 100 years on,” says Manoukian. “It might give hope to people who have come 20 years ago. Who have come 10 years ago. Who are coming now.”

While the next century has yet to be written for the business, Manoukian says it would be great if it could transition to someone who also cares about the quality of the work, even if it’s outside the family. Much like the Manoukians and their culture, Dona says she is certain that the demand for high-quality rugs will live on.

“They are classic just like classical music. It will always endure.”

https://dcist.com/story/22/05/15/va-manoukian-brothers-100-armenian-genocide/

ADMINISTRATOR SAMANTHA POWER’S MEETING WITH ARMENIA’S FOREIGN MINISTER ARARAT MIRZOYAN

  May 2 2022
Monday, May 2, 2022
Office of Press Relations

The below is attributable to Spokesperson Rebecca Chalif:‎

Today, Administrator Power met with Armenia’s Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan to reaffirm the United States’ commitment to supporting the Armenian people and strengthening ties between the U.S. and Armenia. They also discussed the U.S.- Armenia Strategic Dialogue and Armenia’s priorities for additional USAID support and programming.

The Administrator noted that USAID is deeply concerned by the growing regional impact of Russia’s unprovoked war against Ukraine, and is focused on helping regional partners in their efforts to strengthen and diversify their economies, provide energy security, and promote broader stability. During the meeting, the two also discussed the Armenian government’s efforts to support regional peacebuilding, work to combat corruption, and Prime Minister Pashinyan’s participation in President Biden’s Summit for Democracy. Administrator Power emphasized USAID’s support for these efforts, underscoring their critical importance in establishing the foundation for sustained economic growth and prosperity.

Armenia, US strengthen cooperation in field of peaceful and safe use of nuclear energy

Save

Share

 09:28, 3 May, 2022

YEREVAN, MAY 3, ARMENPRESS. On May 2 Armenia and the United States signed a Memorandum of Understanding on Civil Nuclear Cooperation, reports Armenpress.

This document represents another step in the bilateral partnership established in 1997 when the agreement on “Cooperation in the field of nuclear security and exchange of technical information” and subsequent agreements of 2007 and 2017 were concluded.

This Memorandum will strengthen the bilateral cooperation in the field of peaceful use of nuclear energy, providing wider access for the Armenian nuclear energy experts to the latest nuclear safety technologies.

The MoU was signed by Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and US Secretary of State Antony Blinken in Washington D.C..

The Armenian FM is in the United States on a working visit.

Thousands rally in Armenia against Nagorno-Karabakh concessions

May 2 2022

Thousands of opposition supporters rallied on Sunday in the Armenian capital Yerevan to warn the government against concessions to arch-foe Azerbaijan over the long-disputed Nagorno-Karabakh region.

Opposition parties have accused Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan of plans to give away all of Karabakh to Azerbaijan after he told politicians last month that the “international community calls on Armenia to scale down demands on Karabakh.”

On Sunday, several thousand opposition supporters gathered in the capital’s central Square of France, blocking traffic throughout central Yerevan.

Protesters sit around a fire to get warm as they take part in an opposition rally held to protest against Karabakh concessions in Yerevan, Armenia on May 1. Photo: AFP

Protesters shouted demands for Pashinyan to resign, with many holding placards that read “Karabakh”.

Parliament Vice Speaker and opposition leader Ishkhan Sagatelyan said: “Any political status of Karabakh within Azerbaijan is unacceptable to us.”

“Pashinyan had betrayed people’s trust and must go,” he told journalists at the rally, adding that the protest movement “will lead to the overthrow of the government in the nearest future”.

Addressing the crowd, he announced “a large-scale campaign of civil disobedience to begin on Monday”.

“I call on everyone to begin strikes. I call on students not to attend classes. Traffic will be fully blocked in central Yerevan.” 

On Saturday, Armenia’s National Security Service warned of “a real threat of mass unrest in the country.”

Yerevan and Baku had been locked in a territorial dispute since the 1990s over the mountainous region of Azerbaijan predominantly populated by ethnic Armenians.

Karabakh was at the centre of a six-week war in 2020 that claimed more than 6,500 lives before it ended with a Russian-brokered ceasefire agreement.

Under the deal, Armenia ceded swathes of territories it had controlled for decades and Russia deployed some 2,000 peacekeepers to oversee the truce.

In April, Pashinyan and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev met for rare EU-mediated talks in Brussels after which they tasked their foreign ministers to “begin preparatory work for peace talks.”

The meeting came after a flare-up in Karabakh on March 25 that saw Azerbaijan capture a strategic village in the area under the Russian peacekeepers’ responsibility, killing three separatist troops.

Baku tabled in mid-March its set of framework proposals for the peace agreement that includes both sides’ mutual recognition of territorial integrity, meaning Yerevan should agree on Karabakh being part of Azerbaijan.

Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan sparked controversy at home when he said – commenting on the Azerbaijani proposal – that for Yerevan “the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict is not a territorial issue, but a matter of rights” of the local ethnic-Armenian population.

Ethnic Armenian separatists in Nagorno-Karabakh broke away from Azerbaijan when the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991. The ensuing conflicts claimed around 30,000 lives.

https://www.scmp.com/news/world/russia-central-asia/article/3176201/thousands-rally-armenia-against-nagorno-karabakh