The California Courier Online, December 16, 2021

1-         Reminiscing an Unforgettable Trip

            To Armenia with Sen. Dole in 1997

            By Harut Sassounian
            Publisher, The California Courier
            www.TheCaliforniaCourier.com
2-        PM Nikol Pashinyan addresses the Summit for Democracy

3-         Baroness Cox asks UK Government to assess ceasefire
violation by Azerbaijan,           failure to return Armenian POWs

4-         Armenian Artist Puts Her Reproductive Egg On Sale At Art Basel

5-         Armenia Continues Fight Against COVID-19

************************************************************************************************************************************************

1-         Reminiscing an Unforgettable Trip

            To Armenia with Sen. Dole in 1997

            By Harut Sassounian
            Publisher, The California Courier
            www.TheCaliforniaCourier.com
A lot has been written about larger than life Sen. Bob Dole since his
passing on December 5 at the ripe old age of 98. He was a soldier,
Kansas State Representative for two years, member of the U.S. House of
Representatives for 8 years, U.S. Senator for 27 years, three-term
Senate Majority Leader for 11 years, Republican vice presidential
nominee in 1976, and presidential nominee in 1996. He was a decorated
war hero and champion of the Armenian Cause.

His life took a tragic turn after he got critically wounded in Italy
during World War II while serving in the U.S. Army, crippling his
shoulder and right arm. Armenian orthopedic surgeon Dr. Hampar
Kelikian was able to save Dole’s wounded arm, after seven surgeries
which the miraculous doctor performed free of charge.

More importantly than treating him physically, Dr. Kelikian boosted
the self-confidence of the future Senate leader to focus on what he
was left with rather than complaining about what he had lost. This was
an important lesson that Bob Dole kept in mind the rest of his life.

Dr. Kelikian was a survivor of the Armenian Genocide. He shared with
his patient, Bob Dole, the hellish experience of the Armenian
Genocide, during which he lost several members of his family and
barely survived himself. Those horrible stories left their indelible
mark on young Dole who never forgot the Armenian tragedy. When he rose
to the highest ranks of power, he did his best to bring a degree of
justice to the long-suffering Armenian nation by trying to get the
United States acknowledge the Armenian Genocide.

Dole’s valiant efforts in the Senate on behalf of the Armenian people
were thwarted by the Clinton Administration and Sen. Robert Byrd
(Democrat-West Virginia). However, 30 years later, the publicity
generated by Sen. Dole’s persistent dedication to the recognition of
the Armenian Genocide paid off. Fortunately, Bob Dole lived long
enough to see the fruits of his untiring efforts, when Pres. Joe
Biden, Bob Dole’s close friend and political rival, issued a Statement
on April 24, 2021 recognizing the Armenian Genocide. Dole sent a
personal note to Pres. Biden thanking him for his acknowledgment of
the Armenian Genocide.

I would like to share with readers my recollections of accompanying
Sen. Dole on a fact-finding trip to Armenia, October 13-15, 1997, to
assess Kirk Kerkorian’s planned multi-million dollar humanitarian
projects through his Lincy Foundation. The delegation included Alice
Kelikian, the daughter of Dr. Kelikian, Armenia’s Ambassador Rouben
Shugarian, Chairman of Lincy Jim Aljian and his wife Marjorie, two of
the Senator’s aides, and Sue Temkin, a tax attorney from Dole’s
Washington law firm. We travelled on board Kerkorian’s private jet. I
travelled with the delegation in my capacity as the person in charge
of the Lincy projects in Armenia.

In a gesture reserved to visiting heads of state, then Prime Minister
Robert Kocharyan and several high-ranking officials came to the
Yerevan airport to welcome Sen. Dole to Armenia. Also present at the
airport was the U.S. Ambassador to Armenia Peter Tomsen. Although
Pres. Levon Ter-Petrossian was out of the country on a visit to
France, he spoke with Sen. Dole by telephone.

Sen. Dole, as a hero to the Armenian nation, was received
enthusiastically both by the public and officials. During the couple
of days we were in Armenia, we met with the Prime Minister, Chairman
of the Central Bank, Minister of Trade and Industry, Deputy Minister
of Economy and Finance, Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs (their
respective ministers were with the President in France), Chairman of
Parliament and his two deputies, Chairmen of all parliamentary
committees, local businessmen and bankers. Sen. Dole also met with
leaders of three opposition parties and held a press conference.

We visited the U.S. Embassy, where we were briefed by the Ambassador,
Commercial Attaché, and representative of USAID. We also met with
Catholicos of All-Armenians Karekin I at the Cathedral of Holy
Etchmiadzin. We toured a state-of-the-art clothing factory owned by a
businesswoman who had 500 employees. Finally, we visited the
Children’s Cardiac Center where Dr. Hrayr Hovaguimian, an
Armenian-American, was the chief surgeon.

Sen. Dole was deeply touched during his visit to the 70 young children
at the Nork Orphanage. When he learned that the staff of the orphanage
had not received their salaries for several months, he graciously
offered to provide their back pay.

Another moving experience was Sen. Dole’s visit to the Armenian
Genocide Memorial Monument and Museum where he laid a wreath. He and
Alice Kelikian planted a tree in memory of Dr. Hampar Kelikian.

This was Sen. Dole’s second trip to Armenia. He and his wife Elizabeth
visited Armenia in 1989, following the December 1988 earthquake. In
2019, the Republic of Armenia bestowed the prestigious “Order of
Honor” on Sen. Dole.

Sen. Dole was still active at the age of 97. On September 15, 2020,
Sen. Dole and his lobbying firm, Alston & Bird, signed a contract with
the Armenian government to “monitor current events relevant to
US-Armenia relations and provide strategic counsel with respect to
improvement of that relationship.” Sen. Dole wrote: “These services
may include outreach to United States Government officials as well as
Members of Congress and their staffs.” The contract was for one month
at a cost of $10,000.

The Armenian nation will long remember this great man who never forgot
the Armenian surgeon who restored his health and did his best to bring
acknowledgment to the Armenian Genocide.

************************************************************************************************************************************************
2-         PM Nikol Pashinyan addresses the Summit for Democracy

Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan delivered on Dec. 10 remarks at the
virtual “Summit for Democracy” initiated by US President Joe Biden.

The Prime Minister stated:

“It is my honor to represent the Republic of Armenia at today’s Summit
for Democracy. Citizens of Armenia do not take for granted the value
of government of the people, by the people, for the people. We have
fought for it throughout our modern history. By voting for
independence in 1991, we also restored a multi-party system and a
framework of political rights that is meant to empower the individual
citizen. Over the last three years, Armenians have chosen democracy
over authoritarianism twice. The first time was in 2018, following the
non-violent Velvet Revolution, and the subsequent free and fair snap
election. The second time was in 2021, following a devastating war.
Armenians went to the polls, again, to ensure that we would not return
to the ways of the past. Indeed, democracy is a perpetual work in
progress.

“We are committed to the consolidation of democracy in Armenia through
strengthening democratic institutions. By embracing transparency and
accountability, we are planning governance reforms and the
implementation of policies that will build faith both in Armenia and
among our partners abroad. By 2026, we aim to achieve continuous
improvements in comparative indicators, specifically rising from a
score of 50 to 60 in the World Bank’s Worldwide Governance Indicator,
and 49 to 60 in Transparency International’s Corruption Perception
Index.

“We also consider tackling climate change as fundamental to democratic
governance, and are committed to building a low-emission energy sector
and a vibrant green economy.

“In our bid to consolidate our democracy, we are facing multiple
challenges. The biggest challenge for us comes in the form of military
threats to our security. Fighting for democracy at home is yet another
challenge. That challenge is compounded when threats arise from beyond
our borders. If we are to restore the appeal of democracy throughout
the world, we need to join forces to face these challenges together.
Armenia is committed to contributing to the global mission of
strengthening democracy, and we hope that we are not alone”.

The two-day event was attended by leaders and representatives of more
than a hundred countries.

Joe Biden delivered a speech at the opening of the Summit, after which
the panel discussions started. Representatives of non-governmental
organizations and the private sector also took part in the conference.
While Armenia was invited to the summit, Turkey—a NATO ally—and
Azerbaijan were not invited.

Issues related to countering threats to democracy, fighting corruption
and protecting human rights were on the agenda of the two-day debates.

************************************************************************************************************************************************

3-         Baroness Cox asks UK Government to assess ceasefire
violation by Azerbaijan,           failure to return Armenian POWs

Member of the House of Lords, Baroness Caroline Cox has asked Her
Majesty’s Government what assessment they have made of reports of
violations of the Nagorno-Karabakh ceasefire agreement by the
government of Azerbaijan, and the number of Armenian military and
civilian personnel who have yet to be released by the government of
Azerbaijan.

Lord Goldsmith of Richmond Park, the Minister of State, Department for
the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and Foreign, Commonwealth and
Development Office, said: “The Minister for Europe and Americas has
repeatedly highlighted the need for both countries to avoid
provocative actions. She has also raised the long-standing issues of
prisoners of war, detainees and the missing or deceased in calls with
both Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Bayramov and Armenian Foreign
Minister Mirzoyan. We urge both Governments to engage in substantive
negotiations to settle all matters relating to the conflict.”

Baroness Cox stressed that the impunity enjoyed by Azerbaijan has
encouraged continuing violations of the ceasefire agreement by
Azerbaijan. “As Azerbaijani forces continue to advance into Armenian
territories, a few weeks ago I visited a village, Davit Bek, in Syunik
province, and witnessed the suffering of the Armenian people there.
Azerbaijan also refuses to release Armenian prisoners, subjecting many
to torture and killing. What will Her Majesty’s Government do to
require Azerbaijan to stop violations of the ceasefire agreement and
of human rights?” she asked.

Lord Goldsmith of Richmond Park said: “The UK has engaged very
actively both during and after the conflict. The Minister for Europe
and Americas, Wendy Morton, speaks regularly with her counterparts in
both countries. She continuously urges de-escalation and a return to
the negotiating table under the auspices of the OSCE Minsk Group, and
she has condemned the alleged war crimes, including the deliberate
shelling of civilian areas, videos purportedly showing beheadings of
soldiers, and alleged deliberate use of white phosphorus against
civilians. The allegations come from both sides in this conflict.”

Lord Bishop of Coventry said he visited the border inclusion area of
Syunik province, at an earlier stage than Lady Cox. “In Khoznavar, the
incursion had cut off the nearby village from its main water source,
and access to grazing land had been denied, threatening the survival
of this poverty-stricken village. Following my letters of  July 7 to
the Foreign Secretary and of 5 November to the Minister for Europe and
Americas, what further steps are Her Majesty’s Government taking to
challenge those illegal incursions, to ensure the integrity of
Armenia’s borders and to press for the withdrawal of Azerbaijani
troops according to the terms of the November 2020 ceasefire?” the
Lord asked. Lord Goldsmith of Richmond Park responded that “the UK
notes the ceasefire agreement reached in November last year.” “Both
countries had to make difficult decisions to secure stability and
peace, and it is important that remaining issues relating to the
conflict are resolved through negotiation. In particular, the OSCE
Minsk Group is the obvious and key forum for this, facilitated by
France, Russia and the US. The UK is not a formal member of the OSCE
but we continue to support its efforts to negotiate a permanent and
sustainable settlement,” he added.

Lord Risby emphasized that the major cause of tension and violence has
been the lack of a clear and mutually acceptable demarcation of the
international border and asked whether the UK considers assisting or
promoting the process. “The UK supports the OSCE Minsk Group process
and, alongside that, the basic principles. Last updated in 2009, these
include a return of the occupied territories and the acceptance of a
free _expression_ of will on the status of the Nagorno-Karabakh region,”
Lord Goldsmith of Richmond Park noted.

**********************************************************************************************************************************************

4-         Armenian Artist Puts Her Reproductive Egg On Sale At Art Basel

By Mike Walters

(The Blast)—An artist is taking the saying “priceless piece of art” to
a whole new level, after deciding to sell one of her reproductive eggs
as an NFT, during this year’s Art Basel.

Armenian artist Narine Arakelian says she has created a painting
titled ‘Live’ — which will include an embedded contract promising one
of her eggs to the buyer willing to hit a certain price point. This
will be her first NFT and is being offered at this year’s Art Basel in
Miami, Florida. That’s right, along with the painting, the buyer will
get an actual egg which can be used to conceive a child.

As you know, NFT’s (Non-Fungible Tokens) are a type of digital art,
which is verified and confirmed as a unique piece of art using
blockchain authentication. The NFT’s are bought and sold using
cryptocurrency like Ethereum.

Shockingly, Narine claims she fully expects the person who buys the
NFT to conceive a child from the egg that she is selling. But, she is
not doing it as a stunt that might cause issues for the said unborn
child — she is hoping it will be purchased by a couple who is having
trouble conceiving a child of their own.

“My artworks are all my children and the fact this one will actually
produce a child is wonderful. The art will always mean so much to the
buyer because it brought them their child! It will always carry that
special memory,” Arakelian said.

She continued, “I am so happy to bring a child into the world through
my artwork, It’s a beautiful act of creativity to give the gift of art
and life.”

It should be noted, Narine is a mother and has a 21-year-old son.

The good news, the artist is fully aware of the implications of
something like this, and wants everyone to hear that “the child will
be a child once they are born, not a piece of art.”

Arakelian also exhibited a triptych titled ‘Love, Hope, Live’ at Art
Miami — which is a satellite fair near the Art Basel Miami Beach.

Arakelian is a Siberian-born Armenian artist who spends time in both
Los Angeles and Moscow, Russia. She is a college graduate who
completed a year-long internship at the Digital Arts Department at the
Los Angeles Academy of Art.

This isn’t the first time she has made waves in the art world. In
2019, the artist transformed the iconic 15th-century spiral staircase
of Palazzo Contarini del Bovolo in Venice into a colorful lighthouse.

She then performed, passing through each room and discarding elements
of her clothing, until she was completely naked.

***********************************************************************************************************************************************

5-         Armenia Continues Fight Against COVID-19

Armenia continues the fight against COVID-19, as the country continues
promoting the vaccination phase.

The U.S. State Department on July 26 warned American citizens to
reconsider travel to Armenia due to the increase in cases of the
Covid-19.

“The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has issued a
Level 3 Travel Health Notice for Armenia due to COVID-19, indicating a
high level of COVID-19 in the country,” said the State Department.

The State Department also urged U.S. citizens not to travel to the
Nagorno-Karabakh region due to armed conflict.

“The U.S. government is unable to provide emergency services to U.S.
citizens in Nagorno-Karabakh as U.S. government employees are
restricted from traveling there,” the State Department added.

WHO, with funding from the European Union, in September supplied X-ray
equipment to 7 COVID-19 frontline hospitals – 1 in the capital Yerevan
and in 6 other cities in Armenia.

A new law came into effect on December 10, by order of the Armenian
Ministry of Health, that would allow employers to fire workers who
refuse to provide proof of vaccination. Armenia has the lowest
vaccination rate in the region and Europe. Armenia began its mass
vaccination campaign in April with authorities planning to inoculate
700,000 of the country’s 2.9 million citizens by the end of the year.
However, only 516,989 citizens had been fully vaccinated by Dec. 6.

620,000 doses of the Moderna vaccine were donated to Armenia by Norway
with the support of the EU Civil Protection Mechanism within the
framework of the Team Europe initiative is already in Armenia.

“The entire infrastructure is ready to carry out a large number of
vaccinations. I add that vaccination does not exclude the disease, but
reduces the risk of contagion”, Armenian Health Minister Anahit
Avanesyan reported during a recent press conference, adding that the
late entry into force of the restrictive measures was a shortcoming of
her department. According to the minister, they are currently
considering the option of requesting certification of negativity from
Covid or vaccination to enter restaurants and attend concerts.

There were 8,953 active cases in Armenia as of December 13. Armenia
has recorded 342,604 coronavirus cases and 7,819 deaths; 325,832 have
recovered.

************************************************************************************************************************************************

************************************************************************************************************************************************

California Courier Online provides readers of the Armenian News News Service
with a few of the articles in this week’s issue of The California
Courier. Letters to the editor are encouraged through our e-mail
address, . Letters are published with
the author’s name and location; authors are required to disclose their
identity to the editorial staff (name, address, and/or telephone
numbers for verification purposes).
California Courier subscribers can change or modify mailing addresses
by emailing .

The 3+3 regional format may cause problems – Tigran Abrahamyan

Panorama, Armenia
Dec 9 2021

“The so-called 3+3 regional consultative mechanism in the South Caucasus may cause and has already caused problems to the Nagorno Karabakh talks within the auspices of the OSCE Mink Group Co-Chairmanship,” opposition MP Tigran Abrahamyan told reporters on Thursday in parliament. 

Abrahamyan’s comment came after the news of the first session of the mentioned format planned tomorrow in Moscow. 

The lawmaker reminded that days ago the Azerbaijani foreign minister refused to meet with the Armenian counterpart in Stockholm with the participation of the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs. Added to this, the periodic statements coming from Baku that the Nagorno Karabakh issue does not exist any more, complicate the situation.   

“In this situation we should assess what topics are planned to be discussed in the new format, as we have no idea. This is to say there are issues which are not clarified, have not been made public and it is difficult to come up with conclusions,” stressed Abrahamyan. 

In his words, while entering the process, Armenia should have made clarifications about the nature of that format and what was its aim when joining the platform. 

Abrahamyan also reminded that Turkey’s long-pursued aim has not only been to become a co-chairing state within the Minsk Group but also secure a wider involvement in the regional processes, and the proposed format is part of those Turkish aspirations.   

“Both Turkey and Azerbaijan consider there is no issue of Artsakh. In this situation, the efforts of the both countries would be aimed at diminishing the role of Armenia, sidelining issues of Armenia’s concern,” stressed Abrahamyan. 

Armen Charchyan released in the courtroom

Panorama, Armenia
Dec 10 2021

The Yerevan court released on Friday Armenian professor, lawmaker from opposition ‘Armenia’ bloc Armen Charchyan, granting the appeal of the defense team to change his preventive measure. The Court, however, barred Charchyan from leaving the country. 

The ruling is subject to appeal at a higher instance court within 10 days of its release.  The people present at the trial met the court ruling with applause. Charchyan left the courtroom and hugged his family members and colleagues standing at the entrance to the courtroom.  

Recall, Charchyan, the former head of the Izmirlian Medical Center in Yerevan, has been charged for allegedly pressuring his employees to participate in the June 20 parliamentary elections and to vote for the ‘Armenia’ bloc. The defense lawyers have repeatedly requested the court to release him from pre-trial custody, citing his worsening health.

Turkish press: Engineers create bird bots that can perch and grab objects

This undated handout image courtesy of William Roderick/Stanford University shows the grasping robot that Stanford engineers developed based on studies of birds. (Photo by William RODERICK/Stanford University via AFP)

Inspired by how birds land and perch on branches, a team of engineers at Stanford University has built robotic graspers that can fit on drones, enabling them to catch objects and grip various surfaces.

The advance could allow flying robots to conserve power in situations where they might otherwise be required to hover – for example in search and rescue missions – or help ecologists collect data more easily in forests.

“We want to be able to land anywhere – that’s what makes it exciting from an engineering and robotics perspective,” David Lentink, who co-authored a paper about the design in Science Robotics released Wednesday, told Agence France-Presse (AFP).

The team has dubbed their project “stereotyped nature-inspired aerial grasper,” or SNAG.

Roboticists often look to animals to resolve difficult engineering problems, but mimicking the way birds fly and perch after millions of years of evolution is no easy feat.

Branches differ in size, shape and texture. They can be covered in lichen or moss, or might be slippery from the rain.

The team studied previous data they’d gathered on parrotlets – the second smallest species of parrot – using high-speed cameras to watch how the birds landed on perches of different sizes and materials, including wood, foam, sandpaper and Teflon.

The perches also contained sensors to capture the level of force associated with landing, roosting and takeoff.

What they found was the birds approached every landing the same way, using their feet to deal with any variability they encounter.

Specifically, birds curl their claws around a perch, and they also have soft, wrinkly toe pads that provide reliable friction.

The team had to build a grasper large enough to support a small quadcopter drone and so modeled their design on the legs of a peregrine falcon.

It has a 3D-printed structure that took 20 iterations to perfect, with motors and fishing line standing in for muscles and tendon.

Its clutching action takes 20 milliseconds, and once wrapped around the branch, an accelerometer in the right foot tells the robot it has landed.

This in turn triggers a balancing algorithm, which tilts the bot forward to avoid falling, again like real birds.

The finished bird bot successfully caught items thrown at it like bean bags and tennis balls and was able to land in real-world conditions in the forests of Oregon.

Beyond the potential future applications for drones, Lentink said that building such robots can give rise to new insights into avian morphology.

For example, the team tried out the two most common toe arrangements seen in birds – three toes in front and one in the back, versus two in front and two in the back – and found they did not make a difference to the bot’s grasping ability.

This tells biologists that these evolutionary differences arose for other reasons.

“Part of the underlying motivation of this work was to create tools that we can use to study the natural world,” co-author William Roderick said in a statement.

Hayastan Fund: Legal restrictions precluded review of source documentation of funds spent by Armenian government

Panorama, Armenia
Dec 2 2021

The Board of Trustees of the Hayastan All Armenian Fund on Wednesday released a statement regarding Agenda Item 1 of the 30th meeting of the Board on November 27. The full text of the statement is provided below.

“The Board of Trustees of the Hayastan All Armenian Fund received and acknowledged reports made by the Working Group convened by the Board, the outside auditor conducting the Fund’s annual audit and the Armenian Minister of Finance, regarding the targeted use of the funds donated to the Republic of Armenia during 2020, raised as part of the “We Are Our Borders” global fundraising campaign.

The Working Group reported that they did not receive any credible evidence that funds were misappropriated. The Working Group and the outside auditor further reported that legal restrictions precluded their review of source documentation of funds spent by the Government․

The Prime Minister addressed the Armenian Audit Chamber and requested that they assess the possibility of involving the Working Group and the outside auditor in the capacity of external experts in all Audit Chamber inquiries regarding this issue.

The Prime Minister emphasized the Government’s readiness to act in the utmost transparent and accountable manner and make available all source documents to both the Working Group and the outside auditor in order to complete the record and, more importantly, reassure the Board and the public about the appropriate use of the Fund’s contributions through the Government.

This issue will continue to be a priority for the Trustees and will be revisited as necessary.

Emphasizing the importance of the role of the Hayastan All Armenian Fund in uniting global Armenians around a common goal, the Trustees once again thanked all donors and supporters.”

№13 kindergarten of Etchmiadzin Municipality to be renovated with assistance of Japanese Embassy in Armenia

Save

Share

 17:10, 1 December, 2021

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 1, ARMENPRESS. On December 1, 2021, the signing ceremony of the Grant Contract for “The Project for Renovation of №13 Kindergarten in Etchmiadzin Municipality” in the amount of USD 90,181 within the framework of Grant Assistance for Grassroots Human Security Projects was held at the Ministry of Education, Science, Culture and Sports of the Republic of Armenia.

The Grant Contract was signed between Mr. Fukushima Masanori, Ambassador of Japan to Armenia and Ms. Anna Soghomonyan, Director of №13 Kindergarten of Etchmiadzin Municipality.

The ceremony was further attended by Mr. Arkadi Papoyan, Head of Department for Foreign Relations and Diaspora of the Ministry and Mr. Mher Mkrtchyan, Deputy Mayor of Etchmiadzin.

The project aims to improve the learning and working environment for children and teachers of №13 Kindergarten of Etchmiadzin by renovating classrooms, sports hall, event hall, toilets, kitchen parts and balconies of two buildings of kindergarten. As a result, more than 420 people will benefit from the project.

Fatalities reported in Azerbaijan military helicopter crash

Save

Share

 13:02,

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 30, ARMENPRESS. A military helicopter crashed during a training flight in Azerbaijan’s eastern Khizi District, the Azeri Trend news agency reports citing the State Border Service.

An unspecified number of crew members died in the crash. 

The helicopter, operated by the Azeri State Border Service, crashed Tuesday morning in the Bibiheybat aviation range, according to Trend.

Editing and Translating by Stepan Kocharyan

CivilNet: Will Iran-Azerbaijan tensions backfire on Aliyev’s regime?

CIVILNET.AM

29 Nov, 2021 11:11

Eldar Mamedov, an adviser for the Socialists & Democrats groups in the European Parliament, speaks to CivilNet’s Emilio Luciano Cricchio, in a personal capacity, about the impact of the latest tensions between Iran and Azerbaijan.

Emilio Cricchio: Azerbaijan has put customs check-points on parts of the road, which link the Armenian cities of Goris and Kapan. Those sections of the road pass through Azerbaijani controlled territory. The previous closure of this road and the arrest of Iranian truck-drivers triggered tensions between Iran and Azerbaijan. How do you think Tehran will react this time?

Eldar Mamedov: The truck drivers were released, and Tehran committed to not let its trucks go to the Nagorno-Karabakh territory. So, Baku feels it has “won”. However, Tehran also decided that it would prefer Armenia, and not Azerbaijan, as its preferred route for north-south trade. It’s a political decision that shows a displeasure with Baku, and signals Iran’s intention to balance Azerbaijan off in the long run. 

EC: In the last few months, there has been a lot of talk about tensions between Azerbaijan and Iran. There were military drills on the new Iran-Azerbaijan border. There were sabre rattling statements out of both Baku and Tehran, even the office of the representative of Iran’s Supreme Leader in Baku was closed. But, has the situation deescalated, it seems Azerbaijan-Iran tensions aren’t in the headlines as much. Was this just an episode or something that will continue into the future in your opinion?

EM: It is true that the tensions have dissipated, but long-term relations will remain volatile. Not only was Iran’s Supreme Leader’s office closed in Baku, but also a number of Shia clerics were detained, one of them charged with treason, and a number of Shia religious websites were closed for their supposed “association” with Iran – even though the evidence for such things is rather flimsy. Azerbaijani pro-government media outlets continue pouring anti-Iran rhetoric. 

On the other hand, in Iran there is a growing awareness of the challenge of Azerbaijan, its close relations with Turkey and Israel, and what resurgent irredentism concerning so-called “southern Azerbaijan” (Iran’s northern provinces) presents for Iran. There is growing political pressure from sectors of society, diplomatic, intellectual and security environments to take the “pan-Turkist” threat to Iran seriously. It is noteworthy that Iranian Azeris are often at the vanguard of such demands. Many of them don’t see Baku as a beacon to which they should strive to “liberate themselves from the Persian yoke”, as Azeri ethno-nationalists would have it, but to the contrary, they see it as a renegade territory that should “rejoin the Iranian motherland”, from which it was separated as a result of the Russo-Persian wars in the early 19th century. The growing prominence of such narratives is a new phenomenon which is a direct consequence of the latest spat between Iran and Azerbaijan.

EC: How does Azerbaijan’s ruling elite and population view Iran in the context of the conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Is Iran viewed as pro-Armenia?

EM: The ruling elite and associated journalists and opinion leaders share a negative outlook on Iran. Not only do they see Iran as essentially pro-Armenian, but also as an embodiment of everything they, the elite, don’t want to be: “oriental”, Persian, overtly Muslim and Shia. A combination of the Turkic ethnic nationalism, militant secularism and remnants of Soviet modernism that used to see Iran as a backward society predetermine the views of the Azeri elite on Iran. This attitude is also evident in attempts to minimize historical Iranian influence on culture in the Republic of Azerbaijan, including appropriating the Iranian poet Nizami Ganjevi who happened to live on the territory of contemporary Azerbaijan in the 12th century but wrote in Persian, using a musical instrument called the tar, etc.

The attitudes of the broader population are more difficult to gauge as there are no credible sociological surveys in Azerbaijan. It would be fair to suggest, however, that especially outside Baku, attitudes are not that hostile. In the villages around Baku and in the south of Azerbaijan there are still pockets of devout Shia believers who may not all sympathize with Iran’s policies, but do not share the strongly negative outlook of the elites. 

EC: How do Iranian and Azerbaijani societies perceive each other? What about the Azeri population of Iran? Are they culturally more closer to Azerbaijan or to Iran?

EM: What the latest crisis exposed is the little mutual interest and appreciation beyond the cliches. Many in Azerbaijan have difficulty understanding why Iran, for example, has relations with Armenia and why they are important for Tehran, and the reality and historical rootedness of the Armenian community in Iran. Many in Baku just assume that Iran as a Muslim country should simply automatically and unconditionally side with them in their conflict with Armenia. 

Conversely, while on the official level Iran has accepted the existence of the Republic of Azerbaijan as an independent state, there is little understanding and curiosity as to what drives its foreign policies and choice of allies. Iran has irrevocably lost the soft power struggle over Azerbaijan to Turkey. The Islamic Republic’s system of governance is not attractive to the majority of people in the Republic of Azerbaijan. In part due to American sanctions, Iran is also not seen as a promising economic partner too.  

At the same time, there is booming medical tourism from Azerbaijan, particularly southern regions, to Iran. Which is quite ironic: people from the ostensibly “modern”, secular society going to the supposedly “backward” Islamic Republic for the simplest of medical operations. 

As to the Azeri population of Iran, culturally it would be fair to say they are indistinguishable from other ethnic groups in Iran, chiefly Persians. While they share the language with their co-ethnic group on the northern side of the Araz river, their culture was shaped by the fact that they remained part of Iran after the Russo-Persian wars in the 19th century. 

EC: Many Iranian officials made references to Azerbaijan’s relationship with Israel. How does Israel fit into this dynamic between Iran and Azerbaijan?

EM: Azerbaijan’s ties to Israel are clearly a key irritant in bilateral relations. Iranian officials believe, for example, that Azerbaijan aided Israel in assassinating the nuclear scientist Mohsen Fakhrizade in 2020. The perception of Israel expanding its hold in Azerbaijan after the Second Karabakh War in 2020 is a major concern for Iran, and one of the reasons for the recent spat between Tehran and Baku.

EC: You wrote an article, in which you said that the United States is encouraging Azerbaijan to stoke tensions with Tehran. You write “an array of Washington think-tanks sought to expand the conflict with Iran,” can you unpack this for us?

EM: I referred to a specific group of Washington think-tank pundits who for years promoted tensions with Iran, rather than the current US government. Many of these think-tanks, like the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD), influenced Trump’s “maximum pressure” campaign against Iran. They are very critical of Biden’s attempts to revive the nuclear agreement with Iran. So, they used the Armenia-Azerbaijan war to try to expand the conflict to Iran. The plan is to get Iranian Azeris excited about Azeri ethno-nationalism and incite them against the government in Tehran. Undermining Iran from within, or ideally, provoking its disintegration along ethnic lines, which would benefit Israel, according to these pundits. And Israel was always at the center of their interest in the Middle East. Azerbaijan, in this context, is seen as a useful tool in achieving these goals. 

EC: What do you think is next? You mention in the article that Iran is an expert in asymmetrical warfare, could this be a pandora’s box for Aliyev and his administration?

EM: Indeed, Aliyev’s policies are likely to backfire. Iran will probably keep trying to build up proxies or allies in Azerbaijan. So far it wasn’t very successful in this effort, but it will keep trying. Aliyev, ironically, is facilitating that task for Tehran – by systematically marginalizing the secular opposition, it opens up more space for religiously-oriented ones. Socio-economic difficulties and widespread corruption will continue to increase the pool of the disaffected. The victorious post-war euphoria can, for a while, mitigate these risks for the regime, but not indefinitely. In this context, arresting Shia clerics can be seen as a preemptive step highlighting the government’s sense of vulnerability. 

At the same time, the likelihood of bilateral tensions erupting into a full-fledged military conflagration is low – as neighbours, Iran and Azerbaijan share a lot of interdependencies. Recently prospective oil and gas related deals between Tehran and Baku were announced. It shows that, alongside tensions, there are also economic interests that might mitigate them. We have to, however, see the details of these deals more clearly. It happened in the past that Iran and Azerbaijan announced ambitious plans in the economic sphere which didn’t eventually amount to much.

EC: And finally, how do you think Armenia fits into this? There are multiple perspectives in Armenia, some believe that deteriorating relations between Iran and Azerbaijan will align Iran more closely with Armenian interests. Others believe that a new conflict or hostile relationship on Armenia’s doorstep is problematic. What do you think about Armenia’s place in all this?

EM: The Armenian experts are obviously best placed to answer this question, but I think that Armenia has really few good geopolitical options. Relations with Iran, which are traditional and historically rooted, are in any case of strategic interest to the Republic of Armenia independent of the state of Iranian-Azerbaijani relations. 

From an Armenian perspective, however, I think it would be a mistake to count too much on Iran’s problems with Azerbaijan in the long term. Relations may be tense and volatile, but there is also an element of interdependence that probably won’t let deterioration go too far.

What, in my opinion, the politically active Armenian diaspora could do in countries like the US or France is to use its influence to join forces with those organizations that promote engagement with Iran. An Iran that is fully “normalized” and integrated into the world economy would improve Armenia’s situation. It, of course, is a delicate balancing act to perform as US relations with Iran are bad, and no one wants to be made a target for supposedly “siding with an enemy”. But there are growing constituencies in the US, from the progressive left to the libertarian right, who are tired of “endless wars”, particularly in the Middle East, and are trying to shape a different US foreign policy in that region – one based on diplomatic and economic engagement rather than military dominance. I think it is in the natural interest of the Armenians worldwide to support that tendency.

By Emilio Luciano Criccio

Pashinyan reminds Aliyev about Armenian POWs

Save

Share

 18:26, 26 November, 2021

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 26, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan does not agree with the statement of the President of Azerbaijan that all the points of the November 9, 2020 trilateral statement, except for the unblocking of the regional communications, have been fulfilled, ARMENPRESS reports PM Pashinyan said during the trilateral meeting with the Presidents of Russia and Azerbaijan in Sochi.

Addressing Russian President Vladimir Putin, Nikol Pashinyan reminded that they have repeatedly discussed the issue of Armenian prisoners of war and other detainees kept in Baku during personal meetings and telephone conversations. The Armenian PM noted that it’s a very important issue.

“But I want to say that we have gathered today not only to raise the issues, but to discuss their solution. I have also stated many times that Armenia is ready to start the process of delimitation and demarcation. The issue of unblocking, opening of transport and economic communications is also very important for us. We are sincerely interested in resolving these issues”, PM Pashinyan said.

Mirzoyan, Zas discuss CSTO mechanisms to stabilize situation in Armenia’s eastern border

Mirzoyan, Zas discuss CSTO mechanisms to stabilize situation in Armenia’s eastern border

Save

Share

 19:19,

YEREVAN, NOVEMBER 18, ARMENPRESS. Foreign Minister of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan held a phone conversation with CSTO Secretary-General Stanislav Zas on November 18.

As ARMENPRESS was informed from the press service of the MFA Armenia, Minister Mirzoyan emphasized that Azerbaijan has launched another aggression against the sovereign territory of Armenia. He added that since the signing of the trilateral declaration on November 9, the military-political leadership of Azerbaijan has been undermining security and stability in the region and Armenia’s efforts aimed at de-escalation of the situation through provocative actions.

The interlocutors discussed the possible consideration of steps within the framework of the mechanisms and tools of the CSTO in order to stabilize the situation in the eastern border of the Republic of Armenia.