Reading The Runes In Baku

READING THE RUNES IN BAKU

Posted by: Thomas de Waal Wednesday, October 16, 2013 Print Page

Ilham Aliyev has won reelection as president of Azerbaijan for a
third term. The result was never in doubt. Nor was the fact that
election observers would criticize the conduct of the poll-the OSCE
monitoring team promptly released a statement describing a number of
serious defects.

Now it gets more interesting. As Aliyev begins his eleventh year as
president of Azerbaijan, the huge shadow of his father and predecessor
inevitably begins to recede and this is the moment for him to set
a new political agenda for the country-if he wants too. As I have
argued recently, a changing geopolitical environment means that he
needs to do so or risk facing a whole new set of problems.

Reading the runes in post-election Baku, there is already one important
piece of news to ponder. This is that under a presidential pardon
former Economic Development Minister Farhad Aliyev has been released
from jail, along with his brother Rafik.

Farhad Aliyev was jailed in 2005. Formally the charge was corruption
but his imprisonment was obviously the result of a political falling
out. Aliyev had picked the wrong side in an internal power struggle
and got punished for it.

Farhad Aliyev (not a relative of the president) had the reputation of
being a modernizer, in favor of reforming the economy. Significantly,
his only statement on being granted his freedom was to declare loyalty
to the president.

It may be that the release of the former minister is the beginning of
a thaw and that a reelected and relaxed president wants to initiate
political and economic reforms in this third term (all within limits,
of course). If that is the case, other actions must follow, including
the release of other jailed political figures, such as Ilgar Mammadov.

Or maybe not. The other story out of Baku is of the government
pushing back hard against the U.S. government’s sharp statement on
the election. Veteran Soviet-era survivor and Presidential Chief of
Staff Ramiz Mekhtiev claimed that the Americans had “advised” them to
give the opposition 25 percent of the vote in the poll. He again spun
the story that the United States is captive to the Armenian lobby and
“double standards” when it comes to Azerbaijan.

Both these are episodes without a trend. It will take a few weeks
before a clearer narrative emerges from Baku.

From: Baghdasarian

http://carnegie.ru/eurasiaoutlook/?fa=53312

Union Of Poultry Breeders Chairman Speaks Of Market Situation

UNION OF POULTRY BREEDERS CHAIRMAN SPEAKS OF MARKET SITUATION

18:57 ~U 16.10.13

In an interview with Tert.am, Chairman of the Union of Poultry Breeders
of Armenia Sergey Stepanyan addressed the latest developments in the
chicken and egg market, particularly the rise in the egg price.

He cited two major reasons for the lack of eggs in the market.

“First, since all the poultry farms are under the credit burden,
they lacked the funds to purchase young layers. Daily consumption is
700,000 eggs. We are going to have problems this December and will
have to import eggs. We are doing our best to prevent a deficit and
price rise,” Mr Stepanyan said.

According to him, egg prices have risen, but there is no deficit.

Although egg production ensures return on investment sooner than
other businesses, Mr Stepanyan said that a young chicken lays the
first egg in 140-160 days.

From: Baghdasarian

http://www.tert.am/en/news/2013/10/16/sergey-stepanyan/

Mobilisation Pour Un Lyceen Parisien Expulse En Armenie

MOBILISATION POUR UN LYCEEN PARISIEN EXPULSE EN ARMENIE

Liberation, France
16 oct 2013

Sylvain MOUILLARD 16 octobre 2013 a 17:10

REPORTAGE

Khatchik, elève en CAP dans un lycee parisien, a ete expulse le
week-end dernier vers l’Armenie. Revoltes, des elèves de la capitale
ont manifeste devant le rectorat.

Khatchik Kachatryan a ete arrete le jour de son anniversaire, le 19
septembre. Le lyceen, scolarise a Paris mais sans-papiers, fetait ses
19 ans. Envoye dans la foulee au centre de retention administrative
(CRA) de Vincennes, il a ete expulse samedi dernier, au petit matin,
vers l’Armenie, son pays d’origine. Mais ses anciens camarades de
classe ne desarment pas. Depuis un mois, ils se battent pour que
Khatchik puisse construire son avenir en France. Ils s’etaient donne
rendez-vous ce mercredi matin, devant le rectorat de Paris (dans le
XXe arrondissement), pour protester contre la politique d’expulsion
des elèves etrangers. Durant près de deux heures, plusieurs centaines
d’elèves, venus de divers etablissements de la capitale, ont bloque la
circulation sur l’avenue Gambetta. Leurs slogans : “Liberez Khatchik
!” et “Valls demission !”

Ulysse a 16 ans. Elève en première au lycee Helène-Boucher (XXe),
il ne connaissait pas le jeune Armenien, mais est quand meme venu
lui apporter son soutien. “C’est une expulsion parmi tant d’autres,
et ce n’est pas normal. Toutes les personnes qui sont scolarisees
en France devraient etre regularisees.” Steven, lui, a rencontre
Khatchik debut septembre, lors de la rentree scolaire. Elève dans la
meme classe de CAP entreposage, au lycee professionnel Camille-Jenatzy
(XVIIIe), il decrit quelqu’un de “sympathique”, qui “voulait donner
les moyens a ses parents de sortir de leurs problèmes”.

L’adolescent se felicite de la mobilisation pour son camarade de
classe. “On avait reussi a empecher son embarquement dans un premier
avion pour l’Armenie. Meme s’il a fini par etre renvoye, on continue
!” Il appuie : “Jamais je n’aurais pense faire quelque chose comme ca.

Avant, je serais reste dans mon coin. Mais la, je me dis que je
n’aimerais vraiment pas etre a sa place.”

La prison ou le service militaire

Depuis son retour en Armenie, Khatchik est assigne a residence dans
son village d’origine. Place sous contrôle judiciaire, il risque,
d’après le Reseau education sans frontières (RESF), trois a cinq
ans de prison pour insoumission. A leur majorite, tous les jeunes
hommes armeniens doivent en effet se faire recenser. Ce que Khatchik,
refugie en France en raison des activites politiques de son père,
n’a evidemment pas fait… S’il echappait a l’emprisonnement,
Khatchik devrait de toute facon effectuer son service militaire
a partir du 1er novembre. Soit, selon RESF, deux ans de service,
“avec des risques reels d’avoir a mener des operations de guerre”.

La famille de Khatchik, elle, est toujours en France. Inquiète et
cachee : “Ses parents et leurs autres enfants sont sous le coup d’une
Obligation de quitter le territoire (OQTF) depuis le mois de juin,
souligne Dante Bassino, representant de RESF et de la CGT Educ’action.

Ils ont très peur et ne comprennent pas pourquoi leur fils a ete
expulse.” Arrives en France en 2011, les Kachatryan ont vu leurs
demandes d’asile refusees, “car l’Armenie est consideree comme un
pays sûr”.

Nouvelle mobilisation jeudi Dante Bassino espère que la mobilisation
des elèves et professeurs incitera les autorites francaises a faire
machine arrière. Plusieurs elus de gauche de la capitale, dont la
candidate a la mairie de Paris Anne Hidalgo, ont signe un appel
pour Khatchik, demandant l’arret des expulsions de lyceens. Jacques
Daguenet, adjoint au maire du XIe et present au rassemblement devant
le rectorat, va plus loin : “Il est grand temps de regler la situation
de ces jeunes scolarises mais prives de papiers. J’esperais de la
gauche qu’elle le fasse, ce n’est pas le cas. On en est encore au
système du cas par cas, a la discretion des prefectures.”

A ses côtes, Christine Maillard, professeur au lycee Dorian, le
premier etablissement de Khatchik, s’emporte : “Le dernier lyceen
parisien expulse, ca remonte a 2006, alors que Nicolas Sarkozy etait
ministre de l’Interieur. Cela avait fait suffisamment de bruit pour
que ca ne se reproduise pas pendant sept ans. Et la, en 2013, sous un
gouvernement de gauche, on recommence avec les memes attitudes…” Du
côte des elèves, on appelle a un blocage des lycees parisiens ce jeudi
et a une manifestation de la place de la Nation jusqu’au ministère
de l’Interieur.

From: Baghdasarian

http://www.liberation.fr/societe/2013/10/16/mobilisation-pour-un-lyceen-parisien-expulse-en-armenie_939990

BAKU: ICRC Representatives Meet H. Injighulian In Azerbaijan

ICRC REPRESENTATIVES MEET H. INJIGHULIAN IN AZERBAIJAN

Azeri-Press news agency (APA)
October 15, 2013 Tuesday

Victoria Dementieva; “Representatives of the International Committee
of the Red Cross (ICRC) met today with Armenian serviceman Hakob
Injighulian,” the head of communication programs of ICRC Yerevan
Office Ms. Zara Amatuni told Aysor.am.

In her words, an exchange of information took place: ICRC
representatives conveyed a message to the Armenian soldier from his
family and provided him with information about his relatives.

Asked if there was information about the transfer of Armenian POW to a
third country, Zara Amatuni replied: ‘The fact that they met with him
in Azerbaijan means that he continues to remain in that country. We
have no other comments at the moment”.

On the night of August 7-8, serviceman of Armenian armed units Akop
Injugulyan crossed the part of the contact line controlled by the
Azerbaijani Army in the direction of Aghdam front.

From: Baghdasarian

A Mainstream Home For Alternative Art In Armenia

A MAINSTREAM HOME FOR ALTERNATIVE ART IN ARMENIA

The New York Times
Oct 16 2013

By ELIZABETH ZACH
Published: October 16, 2013

YEREVAN, Armenia – Every weekend at the Vernissage Market here,
locals and tourists survey handsomely woven Persian rugs, vintage
Soviet military medals, samovars, chess sets and intricately carved
jewelry boxes. It’s like a step back in time to a Silk Road bazaar.

In contrast, just across the street sits a staid and humble building,
designed as an auditorium when the Cold War was drawing to a close
and then, for a time afterward, left vacant. In front, appropriately,
is Yervand Kochar’s towering 1959 sculpture “Melancholy,” seemingly
serving as a testament to the political and economic crises that have
convulsed Armenia since the collapse of Communism in the region nearly
a quarter century ago.

The statue, however, also gestures promisingly to the building itself,
which since 1995 has housed the Norar Pordzarakan Arvesti Kentovon, or
Armenian Center for Contemporary Experimental Art. Founded by Armenian
emigres to the United States and hailed by many as the epicenter of
Armenia’s culture revolution and renaissance, it hosts exhibits by
young, avant-garde artists and offers concerts and performances in
its large auditorium.

Among other endeavors, artists at the center initiated and organized
Armenia’s participation at the Venice Biennale in 1995, and continued
to do so for eight years. And the center’s founders are set to
introduce an independent study program for graduates in the arts
and architecture, modeled on a similar one at the Whitney Museum of
American Art in New York.

“It used to be that many of our young artists would exhibit their
work in underground galleries,” said Sevada Petrossian, the center’s
coordinator of architectural events. “We like to think of the center
as a mainstream place for alternative art.”

For a city of roughly one million, Yerevan’s artistic standing and
cachet have been notable in the past century. In 1972, the Soviet
Union established its first Museum of Modern Art here. The city’s
National Art Gallery showcases the third-largest collection of European
masters in the former Soviet Union, including works by Rodin, Rubens
and Tintoretto. And Yerevan itself exudes a distinct bygone elegance,
with its softly hued 19th-century tuff stone edifices that line its
leafy boulevards.

Aside from the center and its focus on experimental art, there is
also the Cafesjian Center for the Arts. Opened in November 2009, it
holds an extensive collection of contemporary and glass art, as well
as works by Marc Chagall and John Altoon, who was of Armenian descent.

And yet, despite Yerevan’s artistic fervor, when Edward Balassanian and
his wife, Sonia, set out to establish the contemporary and experimental
art center, they expected – and encountered – resistance.

“While we believe in academic education, we also promote breaking
away from it once study is completed,” Mr. Balassanian said. “Those
within certain art circles, namely some artists schooled during the
Soviet era and most of the members of the Painters Union of Armenia,
still either don’t understand the center’s motives and/or vocally
reject its projects.”

The Balassanians are part of Armenia’s global diaspora of eight
million. They were both born and raised in Iran, fleeing the country in
1979 after the Islamic revolution and eventually settling in New York.

But when Armenia declared its independence from the Soviet Union in
1991, Mr. Balassanian, an architect and urban planner, and Mrs.

Balassanian, a painter and poet who has exhibited at major venues
in the United States and Europe, including The Project Room of the
Museum of Modern Art in New York, were eager to return.

After the Islamic revolution, Mrs. Balassanian began concentrating
her art on cultural, political and social suppression, and she felt
a natural calling toward Armenia. In 1992, she organized her first
contemporary art exhibit in Yerevan, including her work and that of
eight other artists, culminating in the center’s official opening in
1994. She and her husband gradually introduced video and multimedia art
to the Armenian art scene, as well as photography as its own art genre.

Not everyone in Yerevan has been receptive. Among those is Anatoly
Avetyan, who began his artistic career in the 1970s and has gone
on to command strong sales of his art, which includes metal works,
paintings and sculptures now owned by current and past presidents of
Russia, Finland and Germany, not to mention George W. Bush.

“Much of the best generation of artists has already passed away,”
he said. Rather than reinvent the wheel, he said, he and his
contemporaries are pushing for a larger building to house the works
now at Yerevan’s Museum of Modern Art.

In response, Mr. Balassanian says the establishment of the Museum of
Modern Art in 1972 was indeed “a daring act,” and he draws a parallel
between it and the center he co-founded.

“It was an expression of resilience and audacity under politically
repressive conditions,” he said, noting that his center had
“institutionalized the concept and role of the curator as a distinct
profession, something that didn’t exist previously in Armenia, as
such tasks had been performed by government-appointed managers.”

With poverty, corruption and a weak democracy continuing to bedevil
Armenia, the center’s artists say they seek to tether their work to
social and political issues alongside questions of national identity
and culture. The center organized an exhibition in 2007 called “Yerevan
Crisis,” for example, which focused on social problems resulting
from rapid growth, a spontaneous boom in high-rise construction and
escalating property prices.

This issue was also at play in 1997, when Gagik Ghazareh, a film
student at the time, was hard-pressed to find a place to screen his
work. Despite Yerevan’s growth, there is only one operating cinema
in the city, and he did not feel it fit his alternative genre, he
said. A friend suggested contacting the center, which offered him a
screening room.

“One year later, I was invited by the center to chair their cinema
department,” said Mr. Ghazareh, who joined in 1999, later becoming
the center’s artistic director and has since gone on to develop annual
festivals in Yerevan for film and theater.

Vahram Akimian, another young filmmaker who joined the center’s staff
in 2005, is now the program director for the “One Shot” International
Short Film Festival, which has partners in Italy, the Netherlands,
Russia and Slovakia, among other countries. He was also the center’s
associate curator of the Armenian Pavilion at the Venice Biennale in
2009. Today, he is the center’s director of video, cinema and theater.

“Our government speaks of a ‘national culture’ or ‘national art,”‘
said Mr. Akimian one afternoon at the center as he looked across
the street at the bustling Vernissage Market. “But there’s still no
agreement today on what that is.”

From: Baghdasarian

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/17/arts/international/a-mainstream-home-for-alternative-art-in-armenia.html?_r=2&

A Legacy Of Armenian Treasures: Testimony To A People; The Alex And

A LEGACY OF ARMENIAN TREASURES: TESTIMONY TO A PEOPLE; THE ALEX AND MARIE MANOOGIAN MUSEUM

Library Journal Reviews
October 15, 2013

REVIEWS; Arts and Humanities; Pg. 95 Vol. 138 No. 19

This is the first title published by the Alex and Marie Manoogian
Museum. Opened in 1992 and located near Detroit, the institution is
dedicated to the artistic history of the Armenian people and houses
the largest collection of such art outside of Armenia. Highlighting the
best of the museum’s collection, the work thoroughly discusses around
160 of its more than 1,500 items, including illuminated manuscripts,
textiles and clothing, paintings and sculpture, religious items, coins
and other ancient objects, ceramics, and secular metal works. Each
chapter features an introductory essay detailing the cultural
significance of the medium in the country’s history. In turn, each
object is covered in a stunning color spread complete with a detailed
description and historical analysis. Additional context is provided
through maps, a chronological history of Armenia, and a bibliography.

VERDICT This beautiful work provides an excellent introduction to
the art practices of the Armenian people. Artists, historians, and
those interested in the culture of the Caucasus will enjoy reading
this coffee-table book.-Shannon Marie Robinson, Denison Univ. Lib.,
Granville, OH

From: Baghdasarian

Mass Murderers In The 20th & 21st Centuries

MASS MURDERERS IN THE 20TH & 21ST CENTURIES

Daily News (Sri Lanka)
October 15, 2013 Tuesday

Sri Lanka

Sri Lanka, Oct. 15 — Here is a tentative list of modern mass murderers
and the estimated number of people killed by their orders (excluding
enemy armies). In many cases (notably Stalin’s and Mao’s cases)
one has to decide how to consider the millions who died indirectly
because of their political decisions. The Chinese cultural revolution
caused the death of 30 million people (according to the current Chinese
government), but many died of hunger. Stalin is held responsible for
the death of millions by Ukrainians, but “only” half a million people
were killed by his order. Khomeini sent children to die in the war
against Iraq, but it was a war.

Mass killings occurred under some Communist regimes during the
twentieth century with an estimated death toll numbering between 85
and 100 million.

The highest death tolls that have been documented in communist states
occurred in the Soviet Union under Joseph Stalin, in the People’s
Republic of China under Mao Zedong, and in Cambodia under the Khmer
Rouge. The estimates of the number of non-combatants killed by these
three regimes alone range from a low of 21 million to a high of 70
million. There have also been killings on a smaller scale in North
Korea, Vietnam, and some Eastern European and African countries. Two
of the worst atrocities of the 20th century started in the month of
April: the killing of 1.5 million Armenians in Ottoman Empire Turkey
in 1915 and 1916, and the slaughter of 800,000 Tutsis and moderate
Hutus in Rwanda in 1994. Scholars and survivors say the process of
healing is not easy.

Most of these ruthless mass murderers have been considered as
heroes by many people. That was totally due to lack of knowledge of
their activities. Most of these killers were eccentric sociopaths
(psychopaths). They have not remorse, they never felt guilty and they
never had to apologize to anybody. Unfortunately United Nations became
a toothless, gutless organization who could never effectively curb
these activities of these mass murderers. UN was not in existence
during World War II.

Still today UN has become a totally ineffective organization, with no
control over these killers and cannot protect the innocent civilians.

They cannot prevent the chemical weapons used in Syria. UN try to get
the credit, but by closing the barn door after the horses have escaped.

Many people are of the opinion that the UN officials can be bought.

This is where some officials are bias when it comes to dealing with
governments over human rights. They become partial even to lawless
terrorists. UN needs a complete overhaul if they want to become a
world organization who can protect innocent civilians. What happened
in the African Continent and how millions were slaughtered by the
ruthless dictators cannot be forgotten.

From: Baghdasarian

Experts Call Ancient Settlements In Ararat Valley A Sensational Disc

EXPERTS CALL ANCIENT SETTLEMENTS IN ARARAT VALLEY A SENSATIONAL DISCOVERY

by Karina Manukyan

Wednesday, October 16, 19:21

Archaeologists are pleased with the sensational results of excavation
in Ararat Valley.

“Until now we dated the most ancient settlements in Armenia to the
first half of VI millennium BC. Now we have discovered new layers,
which demonstrate that these settlements are even older. To all
appearances, they date back to VII millennium BC”, Pavel Avetisyan,
Director of the Institute of Archeology and Ethnography of the Armenian
National Academy of Sciences, said in his interview with ArmInfo.

Ancient layers have been discovered during the excavations of Aknashen
and Masis Blur. Avetisyan thinks that it is a very important event,
because until quite recently the available data showed that Ararat
Valley was improper for settling in VII millennium BC.

“These are sensational results. We haven’t thought before that would
be able to register settlements dating back to an earlier period than
the first half of VI millennium BC”, he said. These data are of much
significance not only in terms of studies of the ancient history of
Armenian Highland, but also for correct understanding of the history
of formation of cultures in West Asia.

From: Baghdasarian

http://www.arminfo.am/index.cfm?objectid=9CB97ED0-3676-11E3-AB0F0EB7C0D21663

Armenian Opposition MP Invites Attorney General To Public Debate

ARMENIAN OPPOSITION MP INVITES ATTORNEY GENERAL TO PUBLIC DEBATE

October 16, 2013 | 11:55

YEREVAN. – I demand from Prosecutor General to take part in a public
debate and answer my-and my constituents’-questions concerning the
manipulation of the investigation into what transpired near the home
of former Syunik Regional Governor Surik Khachatryan, on June 1.

Opposition Armenian National Congress MP Nikol Pashinyan released a
statement to this effect.

“In this unusual situation, when Armenia’s Prosecutor General [Gevorg
Kostanyan] is suspected of [committing] a crime, the body politic
should have the opportunity to confirm or dispel its [relevant]
suspicions.

“And the fact that Kostanyan is evading a public debate means he
realizes that the suspicions will be confirmed during the debate,”
Pashinyan specifically noted in his statement.

To note, in response to Gevorg Kostanyan’s statement that he is
prepared to receive Nikol Pashinyan and discuss with him the matters
of his interest, Pashinyan had invited Kostanyan to a live debate,
but the attorney general had turned down this invitation.

News from Armenia – NEWS.am

From: Baghdasarian

Saribekian: OSCE Should Tighten Control At Border

SARIBEKIAN: OSCE SHOULD TIGHTEN CONTROL AT BORDER

Wednesday,
October
16

The international community, particularly the OSCE, should
pay attention to the constantly unstable situation at the
Armenian-Azerbaijani border, deputy of the Armenian parliament,
member of the Yerkrapah Union of Volunteers Karen Saribekian told the
correspondent of Aysor.am, when discussing the planned monitoring
conducted regularly by the OSCE on the line of contact of Karabakh
and Azerbaijani troops.

According to him, international organizations don’t take consistent
actions aimed at stabilizing the situation on the border.

“The countries interested in the resolution of the Nagorno Karabakh
conflict should put forward new proposals and solutions so as to
reduce the number of border incidents,” Saribekian noted.

In the opinion of the parliamentary deputy, the OSCE should tighten
control at the border, otherwise the number of incidents will not
decline.

TODAY, 15:30

Aysor.am

From: Baghdasarian