A century after 1915. Armenians are facing a cultural genocide again

Save

Share

 13:32, 26 April, 2021

YEREVAN, APRIL 26, ARMENPRESS. As every year on April 24, this year also the Armenian people will commemorate the victims of the Armenian Genocide.

However this year, the Armenian people commemorate the lose of 1,5 million victims and their homeland in such a conditions, as it seem to have taken them back to the post-genocide period, when Turkey began to commit the cultural genocide of the Armenian people.

The history seems to be repeating after the war unleashed by Azerbaijan against Artsakh, supported by Turkey. As a result of the war, Azerbaijan destroys and desecrates the Armenian cultural and historical heritage in the territories under its control.

This raises reasonable concerns among Armenians, that after the deprivation of homeland in 2020, Azerbaijan will pursue the same policy of annihilation of the Armenian heritage, which Turkey continues to pursue since the 1915 genocide.

The policy of erasing the traces of the Armenian people was implemented systematically in the historical homeland of the Armenian people and in various cities of Turkey in the years following the genocide.

Combining the fact-finding work of various structures, it turns out that before the Genocide, Armenians had more than 4600 churches, monasteries, schools, cemeteries and hospitals in the Ottoman Empire, particularly in the Western Armenia. Most of them, more than 2000, were places of worship. Most of these historical and cultural monuments have either been destroyed or irreparably damaged due to Turkey’s 100-year-old targeted policy.

Armenian churches and monasteries were destroyed deliberately, or were handed over as property to individuals and those far from settlements were abandoned to the whims of time and nature (1, 2). Some of them were used as ready-made buildings for other purposes, such as a stable, library, museum, cinema, but more frequently, they were turned into mosques, the Armenianness of which is denied (1, 2, 3, 4, 5).

Treasure hunters have rendered an invaluable service to the state in the issue of the destruction of the Armenian heritage. Obsessed with the thoughts of “finding the hidden gold of Armenians”, they irreversibly destroyed the Armenian churches, cemeteries and even houses left by Armenians with the permission of the state (1, 2).

In the last decade, Turkey created an illusion of a state-level responsibility for the preservation of cultural and religious sites of minorities, including Armenians, by partially restoring one or two institutions of religious significance, whose Armenianness is undeniable even in the face of systematic Turkish denial.

Such an example is the Surb Khach Church on Akhtamar Island in Lake Van, the restoration of which was actually a political and propaganda step, aimed at covering up the destruction of 1000 churches.

And the real narrative is that the destruction of the Armenian heritage continues today, which obviously violates the clause of the Treaty of Lausanne signed in 1923, according to which Turkey is obliged to preserve and renovate the religious and cultural heritage sites of the minorities. Over the last 10 years, the Armenian districts of Mush and Malatya in Turkey were destroyed and Armenian standing or half-ruined churches were put up for sale (1).

It is the policy of Turkey, that 106 years after the Genocide, April 24 forces Armenians to draw parallels between the ongoing anti-Armenian policy pursued by Turkey-Azerbaijan alliance in the 21st century that began in Turkey a century ago. Following the example of Turkey, Azerbaijan adopted the same systematic policy to cleanse the territories from Armenianness, which were under its control after the 2020 war. It uses almost the same toolkit as Turkey: everything that is Armenian is either completely destroyed or is presented as a property of other ethnic-religious groups by erasing the Armenian inscriptions from the walls.

In just a few months after the war, many such cases were reported with the direct participation of the state’s top leadership. Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliev has taken the lead in this issue. In March, he visited Surb Astvatsatsin Armenian Church in Tsakuri village of the occupied region of Hadrut, in Nagorno-Karabakh, claiming that it is an Albanian church and that the Armenian inscriptions of 12th century are falsified. The policy of appropriation of the Armenian heritage is pursued in almost all of the most important religious structures of Artsakh. The relatively new and not so famous churches are completely destroyed. A vivid example of this is the mysterious missing of the Armenian Church of St. Mariam Astvatsatsin in Jabrayil, under the control of the Azerbaijani Armed Forces, on which the British BBC prepared a report. In the same way, the Azerbaijani authorities destroyed the medieval Armenian khachkars of Jugha without leaving a trace in 2005-2006.

Only 6 months have passed since the war, but there are numerous videos spread on the social networks, where encouraged by impunity Azerbaijani soldiers vigorously demolish, desecrate and trample on Armenian cemeteries, houses, icons, presenting their deed as a great heroism.

However, it seems that Azerbaijan decided to surpass Turkey in the policy encouraged by the state. Everything that Turkey did to eliminate the Armenian trace in 100 years, Azerbaijan wants to do in a shorter period of time.

Perhaps, this is the reason why since now Azerbaijan has been delaying the visit of UNESCO independent experts to the region after the war, to assess the state of cultural values and inventory of Armenian cultural, religious and historical monuments under the control of Azerbaijan. This targeted policy probably has a clear goal to eliminate the Armenian trace from this part of the historical homeland of the Armenian people as much as possible.

Rafayel Sahakyan

Anahit Veziryan




Community Leaders, Allies in Congress Applaud Armenian Genocide Recognition

The National Herald, Greece
May 1 2021
Αssociated Press

A couple walk at the Tzitzernakaberd memorial to the victims of mass killings by Ottoman Turks, in the Armenian capital Yerevan, Armenia, Wednesday, Oct. 30, 2019. (AP Photo/Hakob Berberyan)

WASHINGTON, DC – Congresswoman Carolyn B. Maloney (D-NY) and the American Hellenic Institute (AHI) praised the historic action of President Joseph Biden, Jr., who on April 24 recognized the Armenian Genocide with a declaration stating the systematic killing of 1.5 million Armenians by the Ottoman Empire was an act of genocide. On April 22 U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman Bob Menendez (D-NJ, one of the longstanding leaders in the recognition effort, praised Biden for the impending announcement.

Maloney released the following statement for the April 24th commemoration of Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day:

“This week marks 106 years since the Ottoman Empire began its systematic and reprehensible genocide of 1.5 million Armenians.

“To honor all those murdered, and all who survived, the United States and the world must formally recognize this genocide. As a member of the Armenian Caucus, I was proud to vote in favor of the 2019 House resolution to do just that and have joined with my colleagues to urge President Biden to do the same in his upcoming statement. I am encouraged by reports that the President has heard the calls of the Armenian people, the generations of Armenian-Americans in NY-12, and the American public and will be making that formal declaration.

“We must irrefutably affirm the United States’ official recognition of the Armenian Genocide. This will enable us to enlist the full force of the federal government to encourage education of the facts so that future generations will continue to remember it for what it was and make sure it never happens again.

“We must also continue to push for Turkey to do the same. President Erdogan must finally acknowledge the mass murder of 1.5 million Armenians for what it truly is: genocide.”

The statement by Nicholas Larigakis, President of AHI, a Washington, DC-based non-profit public policy and advocacy center that works to strengthen relations between the United States and Greece and Cyprus, while also focusing on human rights issues in the East Mediterranean, declared:

“We congratulate the Armenian-American community who has endeavored for decades to reach this landmark moment … President Biden’s action, together with the passage of congressional resolutions by the U.S. House of Representatives and U.S. Senate, signify an end to America’s foreign policy silence on the Armenian Genocide, a crime against humanity. Today is a banner day for upholding justice, human rights, and the rule of law.”

Εθνικός Κήρυξ

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, center, attends a memorial service at the monument to the victims of mass killings by Ottoman Turks, to commemorate the 106th anniversary of the massacre, in Yerevan, Armenia, Saturday, April 24, 2021. (Tigran Mehrabyan/PAN Photo via AP)

In March, AHI applauded Senate Foreign Relations Chairman Robert Menendez’s initiative to send a letter to President Biden requesting the Biden administration to join Congress in recognizing the Armenian Genocide. Thirty-nine Senators signed-on to the letter.

Calling on the United States to recognize the Armenian Genocide has been a staple of annual AHI’s policy statements.

Menendez (D-NJ) applauded Biden’s reported decision in advance:

“I’m honored and incredibly moved to be able to commemorate this year’s anniversary of the Armenian Genocide by applauding the President’s reported decision to end over a century of official erasure of one of the darkest events in human history. Today we keep faith with all those who stand up to injustice anywhere and everywhere in the world. We honor those who lost their lives in this genocide, remember how they died and rejoice in knowing we’ve changed the way history will remember their deaths. After three decades of leading this fight in Congress, I am proud the U.S. government is poised to finally be able to say it without any euphemism: genocide is genocide. Plain and simple.”

International activeness increases optimism over return of POWs – Pashinyan

Save

Share

 11:02,

YEREVAN, APRIL 29, ARMENPRESS. Caretaker Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan assesses the international community’s activeness over the return of Armenian prisoners of war from Azerbaijan with optimism.

During today’s Cabinet meeting Pashinyan said Azerbaijan doesn’t fulfill its commitments on returning the captured persons.

“We can state that this fact is becoming a matter of the international agenda, and I want to note that yesterday the European Union has released a very important statement, clearly recording that Azerbaijan must return all captured persons regardless of the circumstances of their arrest”, Pashinyan said, adding that this statement also made a reference to the ongoing processes in the European Court of Human Rights, which adds a legal component to the political statement, which, according to him, is highly important.

“I want to note that the recent international activeness over the issues of the prisoners of war, is very important and increases the optimism that we will have concrete results on this issue. We need to be maximally united, patient and consistent, this issue must definitely get a positive solution”, Pashinyan said.

The European Union made a statement on April 28, calling on Azerbaijan to provide the outstanding information about the Armenian prisoners of war to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), which was requested by the Court earlier.

Editing and Translating by Aneta Harutyunyan

Armenian PM triggers early election a day after Biden’s genocide announcement

Arab News, Saudi Arabia

His resignation, which was expected, came a day after US President Joe Biden said that massacres of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire in 1915 constituted genocide, a move welcomed by Armenians worldwide and condemned by Turkey.

Pashinyan told Biden the symbolic decision was a matter of security to Armenia after the six week conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh, in which Turkey backed Armenia’s neighbor Azerbaijan, where the ethnic Armenian-populated enclave is located.

Pashinyan had been under pressure to resign since he agreed to a cease-fire after ethnic Armenians lost territory in the fighting with Azeri forces in and around Nagorno-Karabakh.
He had already named a June 20 date for an early election.

Announcing his resignation, he said on his Facebook page on Sunday that he was returning power received from citizens to them so they could decide the future of the government through free and fair elections.

He said he had been compelled to agree to the peace deal, which was brokered by Russia, to prevent greater human and territorial losses. The Armenian army called for his resignation and he then tried to sack the chief of staff, a decision blocked by the former Soviet republic’s president.

Pashinyan updated Russian President Vladimir Putin about the elections and the situation over the Nagorno-Karabakh region, where around 2,000 Russian peacekeepers have been deployed, in a phone call on Saturday, the Kremlin said.

The Armenian Prime Minister has complained before that some issues over the region, including the return of prisoners of war, have not been resolved yet.

According to the Sputnik media outlet, Pashinyan’s My Step ruling alliance led an opinion poll conducted by Gallup International Аssociation at the end of last month.
Its main rival is likely to be a grouping led by Robert Kocharyan, Armenia’s president from 1998-2008.

Lebanese delegation arrives in Yerevan to attend Armenian Genocide commemoration event

Save

Share

 17:40, 20 April, 2021

YEREVAN, APRIL 20, ARMENPRESS. Lebanon’s caretaker Sports and Youth Minister Vartine Ohanian arrived in the Armenian capital Yerevan on April 20 to represent the President of the Republic, Michel Aoun, at the 106th Armenian Genocide commemoration event, to be held on April 24th, the National News Agency of Lebanon reports.

Minister Ohanian is accompanied by the Ambassador of Armenia to Lebanon Vahagn Atabekyan.

Ohanian was greeted at “Zvartnots” International Airport by Armenian Deputy Minister of Sports Karen Giloyan and Lebanese Ambassador to Armenia Maya Dagher.

Discussions focused on topics of mutual interest in the sport sector, emphasizing the importance of sports activities and their significant role in the lives of young people.

A Home of Armenian Relics Becomes a Space to Heal From Trauma

Hyperallergic
April 22 2021


“My Relic” tells stories of Armenian culture through the lens of female Armenian artists living in the diaspora.
by Matt Stromberg


LOS ANGELES — Step inside the storefront at 117 North Artsakh Avenue in Glendale, California, and you’ll find a quaint domestic setting. A dining table and chairs, set up for a meal, occupy the center of the room, while a jacket and hat rest on a coat rack to the left of the door, as if the occupant has just returned home. To the right, family portraits hang on the wall above a comfy-looking couch and coffee table. The only thing indicating that this is not, in fact, an actual family’s living space is that every object in the room, including wine glasses, lamps, and pillows, is painstakingly covered with over 100 pounds of lavash, an Armenian flatbread. It is a symbol of the food, the rituals, the traditions that figuratively bind Armenians together, wherever they live, across generations and oceans.

B’reaking Bread” (photo by the author for Hyperallergic)

Titled “Breaking Bread,” the installation is one of three rooms that comprise My Relic, a public artwork created by the female artist group She Loves Collective. It was made possible by funding from the Glendale Arts and Culture Commission through its Urban Art Program, in recognition of Armenian Genocide Remembrance Month, anchored on Saturday, April 24, Armenian Genocide Remembrance Day. (Significantly, President Biden has indicated that he will formally recognize the Armenian Genocide, making him the first US president to do so.) The three spaces offer complementary views on Armenian culture, through the lens of female Armenian artists living in the diaspora (Glendale is home to one of the largest Armenian communities outside Armenia). Through different interpretations of relics — cultural objects that connect generations — the show illuminates the power of tradition in allowing one to survive, heal, and move forward from trauma. “A relic is what is left of us, sometimes it’s just a faint memory, or the story of the object, almost like a dream,” exhibition curator Adrineh Baghdassarian told Hyperallergic. “This is who we are, not just one specific, generic item.”


“Relics” (photo by Mari Mansourian)

The second room, titled “Relics,” is filled with 50 hanging banners printed with images of Armenian relics sourced from museums, churches, and family collections. They range from liturgical objects and jewelry, to family photos, rugs, and household items, and even a blanket brought to the United States by an orphan. The images provide a dynamic portrait of what Armenians have valued, what they decided to take with them when they left their homeland. One particularly striking banner is by photographer Armineh Hovanesian, who superimposed a self-portrait over an image of her grandmother Maryam. “She might not have a physical relic, but her genetics, her DNA is her relic,” explained collective member Ani Nina Oganyan.


Family photo from Ani Nina Oganyan (c. 1910) (image courtesy the artist)

One of Oganyan’s contributions to “Relics” is a family photo from roughly 1910, taken in Artsakh, the long-contested majority Armenian republic that was the site of a bloody 44-day war between Armenia and Azerbaijan last fall — My Relic is dedicated to the Armenian people of Artsakh and the soldiers who lost their lives defending it. The photo depicts her maternal great-great-grandfather, who lived in Artsakh, holding her great-grandfather, Yervand Martirosyan, on his lap. Surrounding him are other members of his family as well as a neighboring Turkish family, a reminder of the bonds of common humanity that would be shattered a few years later with the start of the Armenian Genocide. “There was a time when they were neighbors,” Oganyan said wistfully. 


The final room, titled “Reclamation,” is a hopeful finale that looks to the future. The floor is covered with mounds of dirt, from which spring forget-me-nots, symbols of the Armenian Genocide centennial. Pairs of white shoes sit on the earth, pointing towards a screen depicting Mount Ararat, a deeply significant site for Armenians that represents the dream of self-determination alongside the pain of territorial loss, having been located in Turkey for a century. The phrase “They tried to bury us, they didn’t know we were seeds,” flickers across the screen. Instead of characters from the Latin alphabet, the words are composed using letters from the Armenian alphabet.


While grounded in Armenian history, My Relic speaks to the larger experiences of displacement, trauma, and resilience. “So many non-Armenian community members can relate to the ‘Reclamation’ room. We’ve had African-American community members say, ‘this piece speaks to me, it reminds me of our struggles,’” recalled Oganyan. She shared that another visitor with a Native American background came up to her crying after leaving the room. “‘This is exactly the history we have and we continue to live on American soil,’” she told her.

“I have seen 30 people come out of those doors with tears streaming down their faces,” said Baghdassarian. “As an artist and a curator, when I know we’re successful is when I can make people feel.”

My Relic, by She Loves Collective and curated by Adrineh Baghdassarian, continues at 117 North Artsakh Avenue (Glendale, California) through May 2. 


more photos at   https://hyperallergic.com/640025/my-relic-she-loves-collective/

Azerbaijan continues violating its commitments, Head of Maat Foundation says

Save

Share

 13:28,

YEREVAN, APRIL 23, ARMENPRESS. Ayman Aqil, head of the Maat Foundation, says Azerbaijan continues violating human rights and its commitments by holding the Armenian prisoners of war still in custody after the end of the recent Nagorno Karabakh war. He notes that the human rights violations by Azerbaijan during the recent war have been accompanied by the support of Turkey.

“We have called on Azerbaijan to return the captives, the prisoners of war, however, that country still continues violating human rights, fundamental freedoms, as well as the agreement which was reached during the stop of the war. I want to state that when we made that call, the Azerbaijani embassy in Cairo contacted us, stating that they have no Armenian prisoners of war, but we responded that the POWs exist and you continue violating the human rights”, the head of the Maat Foundation told Armenpress.

According to him, it’s possible to talk about peace in the region only when Turkey stops assisting Azerbaijan, and Azerbaijan stops violating human rights.

Asked that 106 years after the Armenian Genocide, Turkey still remains unpunished, whether this is the reason that genocides are taking place in the 21st century, Ayman Aqil said “we have what we have, and the reason of it is that the international community still remains silent”.

“A key mission for us is to be able to use all the international levers, the UN, as well as the UN Security Council, for preventing such events. We have presented a report where we show the violations made by Turkey, in particular that it provided weapons, mercenaries and other resources to the Azerbaijani side”, he said.

 

Interview by Norayr Shoghikyan

Editing and Translating by Aneta Harutyunyan

Recognition of Armenian genocide by US ‘would be of historic importance’

Cyprus Mail

| Cyprus Mail

Vartkes Mahdessian, the representative of the Armenian community in the House of Representatives, is hopeful that US President Biden will recognise the Armenian genocide on Saturday.

Biden is likely going to use the word “genocide” as part of a statement on April 24 when annual commemorations for the victims are held around the world, three sources familiar with the matter told Reuters.

Asked for comment, Mahdessian told the Cyprus Mail that such a move would be of historic importance – likely leading to many other countries recognising the mass killings as genocide.

Last April, Biden said that: “Today, we remember the atrocities faced by the Armenian people in the Metz Yeghern — the Armenian Genocide. If elected, I pledge to support a resolution recognising the Armenian Genocide and will make universal human rights a top priority.”

“This would be the vindication of our struggles over so many years for recognition, of the tragic events which occurred in 1915 and 1923,” Mahdessian told us.

  • Turkey warns US not to recognise 1915 Armenian genocide
  • US expected to recognize massacre of Armenians as genocide

“Of course, in the past, we have been disappointed that promises were made by previous [US] presidents but these were not honoured.”

But notably, in 2019, the US Senate passed a non-binding resolution recognising the killings as a genocide, in a historic move that infuriated Turkey.

A year ago, while still a presidential candidate, Biden commemorated the 1.5 million Armenian men, women, and children who lost their lives in the final years of the Ottoman Empire and said he would back efforts to recognise those killings as a genocide.

Soon after the events in 1915-1923, Cyprus became one of the many destinations across the globe to which Armenians dispersed to.

“In the early ‘20s, Cyprus received with open arms the Armenian survivors who managed to escape the genocide – who arrived in Larnaca, mainly by French vessels,” he said.

“They developed very rich relationships with the local Greek Cypriots and also with the Turkish Cypriots, who also received us in a friendly manner.”

Mahdessian noted that many of the Armenians who sought refuge in Cyprus during the 1920s spoke Turkish and as such worked well with the Turkish Cypriots.

Cyprus’ deep history with the Armenian diaspora has led it to often lead the way in its diplomatic handling of the genocide.

“The Cypriot parliament was the first European country to officially recognise the Armenian genocide in 1975 and in 2015, on the one hundredth commemoration of the genocide, it was criminalised by law to deny it as such,” Mahdessian said.

While the Cypriot-Armenian community is relatively small, numbering approximately 4,000, they have established strong roots – building schools and churches.

Most of them are descendants of people who fled to the island in the early 1920s.

Parliament on Thursday, before its closing session, held a minute’s silence to honour the commemoration of the Armenian genocide.

Beirut: 34 Scholarships Have Been Granted To Lebanese-Armenian Students In Need

The 961, Lebanon
April 16 2021

The AEF announced that it has awarded 34 scholarships so far, amounting to a total of $47,400.-

“These scholarships not only give an educational lifeline to Lebanese Armenian students, many of whom come from families that have been devastated by the blast in Lebanon, but it also gives them a reason to stay and settle in Armenia,” said the AEF President, Al Cabraloff.

In Lebanon, the struggle to survive continues and the families of the Beirut Blast victims still await an evading justice, while friendly countries are pressuring the officials to break the government formation deadlock, notably France and the United States.

Last week, a gallery opened in tribute to one of the Lebanese-Armenian victims, Gaïa Fodoulian. It was set up by Fodoulian’s mother, gallerist Anne Vartivarian, who sought to see her daughter’s project come to life.

As of yet, over eight months later, there is no official memorial by the state for the 200+ victims.

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 04/16/2021

                                        Friday, 
Preparations Finalized For New Bridge On Armenian-Georgian Border
Armenia/Georgia - A Soviet-built bridge connecting Armenia and Georgia border, 
4Nov2016.
Armenian and Georgian government officials discussed on Friday final 
preparations for the repeatedly delayed construction of a new bridge on the 
Armenian-Georgian border designed to facilitate travel and commerce.
The “Friendship Bridge” is to be built over the Debed river flowing through the 
main border crossing at Bagratashen-Sadakhlo. It currently has a single narrow 
bridge constructed in Soviet times.
The Armenian and Georgian governments signed a deal on the new bridge in late 
2014 two years after the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) 
pledged to finance the project with a loan extended to Armenia.
Work on the bridge was originally due to start in 2017 and last for two years. 
However, the Armenian government completed an international tender for the right 
to build the bridge only in 2018. An Iranian construction firm, Ariana Tunnel 
Dam, won the tender with a $9 million bid.
Armenia/Georgia - Armenian President Serzh Sarkisian (R) and Georgian Prime 
Minister Giorgi Kvirikashvili at the opening ceremony for a newly reconstructed 
Armenian border checkpoint at Bagratashen, November 4, 2016.
The Armenian Ministry of Territorial Administration and Infrastructures 
announced the impending start of the construction on Friday after a virtual 
meeting of a Georgian-Armenian task force dealing with the project.
A ministry statement said the working group gave final approval to the 
architectural design of the planned bridge which is due to be 386 meters long 
and have two sections with a total of four traffic lanes. It also approved a 
“simplified procedure” for construction workers’ access to the border area.
The new bridge will be used for Armenia’s trade with not only Georgia but also 
Russia, its number one trading partner. Much of Russian-Armenian trade, worth 
almost $2.2 billion in 2020, is carried out by heavy trucks passing through the 
Bagratashen-Sadakhlo crossing.
Armenia - The main Armenian-Georgian border crossing at Bagratashen, 4Nov2016.
Armenian passport control and customs facilities at Bagratashen were expanded 
and modernized in 2016 as part of a $65 million program mostly financed by the 
European Union.
The session of the Georgian-Armenian task force coincided with President Armen 
Sarkissian’s official visit to Tbilisi. Meeting with Georgian parliament speaker 
Archil Talakvadze, Sarkissian said the two neighboring states should “encourage 
the implementation of joint projects” now that their economies are reeling from 
recessions caused by the coronavirus pandemic.
Former Army Chief Urges Parliament Probe Of Karabakh War
        • Astghik Bedevian
Armenia -- Colonel-General Onik Gasparian (C), the chief of the Armenian army's 
General Staff, meets with senior Russian military officials, Yerevan, January 
25, 2021.
Onik Gasparian, Armenia’s former top general controversially replaced last 
month, called on Friday for a parliamentary inquiry into the political and 
military authorities’ handling of last year’s war in Nagorno-Karabakh.
In a letter to the leadership of the Armenian parliament posted on Armlur.am, 
Gasparian cited the need to answer “many questions” about the outcome of the 
six-week war and ease political tensions in the country.
The appeal came two days after Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian blamed former 
Presidents Serzh Sarkisian and Robert Kocharian for Armenia’s defeat in the war 
stopped by a Russian-brokered ceasefire on November 10.
Addressing the National Assembly, Pashinian also attacked Gasparian, who was 
sacked as chief of the Armenian army’s General Staff after initiating a February 
25 statement by the army top brass that demanded the government’s resignation.
The embattled premier denied Gasparian’s December claims that three days after 
the outbreak of the 2020 hostilities he warned Pashinian that Armenia and 
Karabakh are heading for defeat and that the fighting must be stopped as soon as 
possible. He insisted that Gasparian made a statement to the contrary at a 
September 30 meeting of his Security Council.
Gasparian stood by his claims and accused Pashinian of “shamelessly distorting 
facts.”
Andranik Kocharian, the pro-government chairman of the Armenian parliament 
committee on defense and security, spoke out against the formation of an ad hoc 
parliamentary commission proposed by the general.
Kocharian argued that the commission would have no time to conduct such an 
inquiry because the current parliament is expected to be dissolved in June. Only 
the next National Assembly can properly investigate all circumstances of the 
war, he said.
One of the two parliamentary opposition parties, Bright Armenia (LHK), already 
demanded such a probe in December. The parliament’s pro-government majority 
objected to the idea.
During Wednesday’s parliament debate, LHK leaders accused Pashinian of trying to 
dodge responsibility for the outcome of the war which left at least 3,600 
Armenia soldiers dead and led to sweeping Azerbaijani territorial gains.
Armenian Government Accused Of Persecuting Top Judicial Official
        • Artak Khulian
        • Marine Khachatrian
Armenia - The head of Supreme Judicial Council, Ruben Vartazarian, at a press 
conference in Yerevan, December 29, 2020.
The head of an independent body empowered to nominate, sanction and fire judges 
on Friday accused Armenia’s political leadership of ordering criminal 
proceedings against him in a bid to replace him with a government ally.
Ruben Vartazarian told the Hraparak newspaper that he was formally charged with 
obstruction of justice on Thursday hours after the Supreme Judicial Council 
(SJC) agreed to suspend him pending investigation.
Neither the SJC nor the Office of the Prosecutor-General gave any details of the 
criminal case.
Under Armenian law, judges and other judicial officials cannot be prosecuted on 
charges stemming from their professional activities without the SJC’s consent. 
The SJC said on Thursday that the case against its chairman not connected with 
the performance of his duties.
Vartazarian asserted, however, that he stands accused of abusing his powers to 
interfere in the work of a court. He confirmed reports that the accusation is 
based on incriminating testimony given by Andranik Simonian, a newly appointed 
deputy director of Armenia’s National Security Service (NSS).
Simonian worked as a judge of the court of first instance of the country’s 
northern Lori province until being moved to the NSS by Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian late last month.
Lawmakers representing Pashinian’s My Step alliance harshly criticized 
Vartazarian during a parliament debate earlier in March. They implicitly accused 
him of encouraging courts not to allow pre-trial arrests of opposition figures 
arrested following last year’s war with Azerbaijan. Vartazarian denied those 
claims.
Armenia - Gagik Jahangirian, a former deputy prosecutor-general, is interviewe 
by RFE/RL, Yerevan, June 21, 2019.
Speaking to Hraparak, Vartazarian dismissed the charges leveled against him, 
saying that they are part of government attempts to oust and replace him with 
Gagik Jahangirian, another SJC member reputedly allied to Pashinian.
“Everything is very clear and simple,” said the SJC chairman, who is also a 
district court judge.
Jahangirian will head the SJC pending the outcome of the criminal investigation 
because he is the oldest member of the body overseeing the Armenian judiciary.
Zhanna Aleksanian, a human rights activist, also suggested that Vartazarian is 
prosecuted for political reasons. She deplored the lack of official information 
about the case.
“The authorities do not like transparency at all and I don’t exclude that they 
want to remove Vartazarian in this way in order to install a candidate 
acceptable to them,” Aleksanian told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service.
Nikolay Baghdasarian, a pro-government parliamentarian, denied any political 
motives. “If the authorities wanted to persecute him there were many ways of 
doing that,” he said. “But the existence of a criminal case means the 
prosecutors have more evidence than they do in the case of ordinary citizens.”
Reprinted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2021 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.