Russia Considers The Minsk Group To Be The Most Effective Format For

RUSSIA CONSIDERS THE MINSK GROUP TO BE THE MOST EFFECTIVE FORMAT FOR KARABAKH SETTLEMENT

armradio.am
20.03.2008 17:10

Russia is stable in its position and considers that the current
negotiation process on the Nagorno Karabakh conflict settlement,
i.e. the OSCE Minsk Group is the most acceptable and effective, Russian
Deputy Foreign Minister Grigory Karasin told a press conference
in Yerevan today, summing up the results of his visit to Armenia
March 18-20.

Mr. Karasin noted that Russia is anxious about the events that took
place the line of contact between the Armed Forces of Nagorno Karabakh
and Azerbaijan and expect that the possible meeting of the leaders
of the two countries will help to reduce the tension in the region.

RF Deputy Foreign Minister, State Secretary Grigory Karasin noted that
a broad framework of Armenian-Russian relations was discussed during
the meetings with RA President Robert Kocharyan, President-Elect, Prime
Minister Serge Sargsyan and Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian. Reference
was made to the schedule of bilateral political contacts envisaged
for 2008, including the forthcoming visit of RA President-Elect Serge
Sargsyan to the Russian Federation.

Other issues of bilateral interest were discussed, including the
foreign policy of Armenia and the domestic political situation.

ANCA And GI-Net Team Up For second "End The Cycle Of Genocide" Grass

ANCA AND GI-NET TEAM UP FOR SECOND "END THE CYCLE OF GENOCIDE" GRASSROOTS LOBBYING CAMPAIGN

DeFacto Agency
March 20 2008
Armenia

YEREVAN, 20.03.08. DE FACTO. Over 100 anti-genocide activists from
across the nation joined the Armenian National Committee of America
(ANCA) and the Genocide Intervention Network (Gi-Net) for their
second annual "End the Cycle of Genocide" campaign held in Washington,
DC from March 12-14th, reported the ANCA.

The three day program, hosted for the second year in a row by the ANCA
and the GI-Net, puts community human rights advocates directly in touch
with dozens of legislators and every single Senate and House office
in support of practical legislative initiatives to stop the genocide
in Darfur and end Turkey’s ongoing denial of the Armenian Genocide.

"It was so wonderful to participate with the Genocide Intervention
Network once again this month to advocate on these important human
rights issues," commented ANCA Eastern Region Executive Director,
Karine Birazian. "It was exciting to see new and familiar faces
throughout the region participate. We will continue to work to build
momentum and push genocide legislation forward in Congress."

Birazian, along with activists from the Eastern Region, spent three
days on Capitol Hill meeting with various members of Congress as
well as distributing informational folders on the Armenian Genocide
and the genocide taking place in Darfur, and highlighting legislation
pertaining to these matters. Eastern Region activists including those
from Georgia, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York,
Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Tennessee, and Virginia visited close to
300 offices in the House of Representatives and over 60 offices in
the Senate.

First time participants of the "End the Cycle of Genocide" Advocacy
Days included several youth activists and professionals. Arin
Vartanian, an Armenian Youth Federation (AYF) member from the New
Jersey Arsen Chapter commented: "Participating in this past week’s
Advocacy Days has definitely left me with a greater understanding
of what it means to fight for genocide recognition. After making
countless phone calls to my senators and representatives over the
years, it was unbelievable to have the opportunity to speak to
my congressmen in person rather than over a receiver. Lobbying on
Capitol Hill with the ANCA, GI-Net, and my fellow AYF members was an
amazing and unforgettable experience and I would like to participate
again." Vartanian, a constituent of Cong. Gary Ackerman (D-NY-5) also
had a chance to meet with the office to thank the Congressman for his
support on human rights issues and his leadership during the October
10, 2007 markup of H. Res. 106, the Armenian Genocide Resolution,
in the House Foreign Affairs Committee.

Eastern Region activists met with over 50 congressional offices,
including Members of the House Committees on Foreign Affairs,
Intelligence, and Homeland Security, many of whom are cosponsors of
H. Res. 106.

Those in attendance took part in a reception on Wednesday evening
during which several representatives spoke out on this important
issue and stressed the need to continue to lobby and push forward for
genocide recognition. At the close of the Advocacy Days, activists
were invited to tour the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in
Washington, DC.

Economist: Turkey’s Secular Constitution – See You In Court

TURKEY’S SECULAR CONSTITUTION – SEE YOU IN COURT

Economist
rope/displaystory.cfm?story_id=10881280
March 19 2008
UK

A state prosecutor wants to ban the ruling party

Hands off our mildly Islamist partyAUTOCRATIC regimes in the Muslim
world often ban religious parties, which then go underground and turn
violent. Turkey’s Islamists have taken a different path. Despite being
repeatedly outlawed and ejected from power, pious politicians have
shunned violence, embraced democracy and moved into the mainstream. No
Islamic party has been as moderate and pro-Western as the Justice
and Development (AK) party, which catapulted into government in 2002
promising to lead Turkey into the European Union.

Yet the country’s secular elite is still fighting to oust the
AK government, on thinly supported charges that it wants to wreck
Ataturk’s secular republic. A senior prosecutor has made the charges
official, by asking the constitutional court to shut AK down because
it has become "a centre for anti-secular activities". In a 162-page
indictment, Abdurrahman Yalcinkaya argued that AK is using democracy
as a vehicle for imposing sharia law. He asked the court to slap
a five-year ban on more than 70 AK officials, including the prime
minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, and the president, Abdullah Gul.

The court, dominated by pro-secular judges, said it would decide by
April whether to proceed with the case. Already jittery financial
markets have taken fright. On March 17th the Istanbul Stock Exchange
plunged by 7.5% and the Turkish lira fell by 3.5% against the dollar.

Should the court decide to take up the case, the battle could last
for a year, pushing Turkey into a prolonged period of instability,
hampering reforms and jeopardising membership talks with the EU.

Mindful of all this, TUSIAD, the main business lobby, has denounced
the case. "Shutting down parties is not compatible with democracy,"
said its president, Arzuhan Yalcindag. America and the EU have also
rushed to AK’s defence. A combative Mr Erdogan has opined that AK’s
legal woes will only raise its popularity. He is probably right. The
most recent challenge to AK rule came a year ago when he nominated
Mr Gul for the presidency. The prospect of a president whose wife
wore the Islamic headscarf and who would not veto AK-inspired laws
galvanised the generals into threatening a coup. Many believe the
army’s meddling helped AK to a bigger share of the vote (47%) in
last July’s election. So why has the prosecutor chosen to act against
AK now?

Some see it as a last-ditch attempt by Turkey’s old guard to cling
to power. A new and pious class of Anatolian entrepreneurs, who
have thrived under AK, is challenging the elite. One such group,
Calik, which employs Mr Erdogan’s son-in-law, has acquired a media
conglomerate, whose assets include a television channel, ATV, and
the third-biggest daily, Sabah. "The reign of the Bosporus princes
is over," says a Western banker.

Ertugrul Gunay, the culture minister, has another explanation. He
believes the case is connected to the recent arrests of generals,
academics and journalists linked to a string of murders, including
that of an ethnic-Armenian editor, Hrant Dink. Proponents of this
theory note that Turkey’s first Islamist-led government was ejected
in 1997 after it began investigating links between the army and
organised crime. Another theory is that the case was prompted by AK’s
efforts to ease the strict secular ban on the Islamic headscarf in
universities. This move is cited in Mr Yalcinkaya’s indictment. Other
"evidence" is said to range from the AK-run Istanbul council’s
censoring of bikini ads to an AK official’s observation that "asking
a pious girl to remove her headscarf is akin to telling an uncovered
one to remove her underpants".

It is hardly the stuff of an Islamic revolution. Yet even AK’s closest
allies agree that Mr Erdogan should have done more to reach out to
secular opponents. On the headscarf, he might have worked harder to
protect the rights of women who choose not to cover their heads. He
might also have scrapped Article 301 of the penal code, which has
been used to prosecute scores of Turkish writers and academics for
"insulting Turkishness". With much of Mr Yalcinkaya’s case built
on things that the prime minister and his lieutenants have said, Mr
Erdogan should see the value of free speech. His secular opponents,
meanwhile, would do better if they left their ivory towers and spent
more time with the ordinary people of Turkey.

http://www.economist.com/world/eu

According To Stepan Safarian, Amended Law On Holding Of Mass Events

ACCORDING TO STEPAN SAFARIAN, AMENDED LAW ON HOLDING OF MASS EVENTS IS ANTI-POPULAR AND WILL RESULT IN MANY NEW ARRESTS

Noyan Tapan
March 19, 2008

YEREVAN, MARCH 19, NOYAN TAPAN. When making amendments and addenda to
the law On Holding Meetings, Rallies, Processions, and Demonstrations
the parliament committed a number of procedure violations. Stepan
Safarian, the Secretary of the Zharangutiun (Heritage) party, a memer
of the RA National Assembly faction of the same name, stated at the
March 19 press conference.

In particular, according to him, the faction members have failed in
finding out the names of the authors of the above mentioned amendments
so far.

Besides, NA Speaker Tigran Torosian’s indications were not included
in the draft, and no co-reporters spoke during the discussion.

Reminding T. Torosian’s words that the draft authors are nearly 70
deputies, who spoke for convening a NA special sitting, S. Safarian
under the circumstance considered nonsense the fact that all 70
deputies asked questions to the reporter during the discussion. And
Zharangutiun’s proposals, as the faction member mentioned, have been
rejected, as they were against the amendments.

As S. Safarian evaluated, the amended law is anti-popular and
contradicts the international norms of human rights. As the deputy
is convinced, the amended law will not only fail to liquidate the
home political tension, but also "will result in many new arrests." "A
possibility of freedom of expression should be created, the information
obstacle should be removed.

Driving the people to the corner will never do good," S. Safarian
stated.

The Voting In The UN General Assembly Didn’t Bring The Results Azerb

THE VOTING IN THE UN GENERAL ASSEMBLY DIDN’T BRING THE RESULTS AZERBAIJAN WAS EXPECTING

PanARMENIAN.Net
15.03.2008 GMT+04:00

The fact, that the UNO has already expired itself as an organization
capable of making any reasonable decisions, was clear already when it
approved the resolutions on the Genocide of Rwanda and the Genocide
of Darfur. No less shameful did the organization act when it forbade
the exhibition dedicated to the Armenian Genocide.

As it was expected, the voting in the UN General Assembly of the
resolution on "the situation in the occupied territories of Azerbaijan"
didn’t bring the results Baku was expecting. But the deputy of Milly
Mejlis of Azerbaijan Asim Molladze hurried to congratulate the Azeri
diplomacy with the big victory.

A recurrent maxim about the "dethronement of the Armenian powerful
lobby" wasn’t left aside either. As a matter of fact, Molladze didn’t
make any new discoveries.

/PanARMENIAN.Net/ But if the voting of OIC and GUAM may be qualified
as a "big victory", then we don’t know how Armenia may define the
position of the OSCE Member Countries and other 100 countries, which
simply didn’t want to participate in the shameful event. The fact,
that the UNO has already expired itself as an organization capable of
making any reasonable decisions, was clear already when it approved the
resolutions on the Genocide of Rwanda and the Genocide of Darfur. No
less shameful did the organization act when it forbade the exhibition
dedicated to the Armenian Genocide. The last unsuccessful step of
the UN Security Council was passing the Ahtisaari plan.

Baku has already started to speak against the countries, having voted
against the resolution. "The Embassy of Azerbaijan has carried out
many works with the Indian party, so that the latter would at least
abstain from voting in the UN regarding the Karabakh issue," said the
Ambassador of Azerbaijan in India Tamerlan Karaev. However, according
to him, Baku failed. "We had very big plans regarding the two-sided
relations, but unfortunately with the step that India took yesterday
crossed out all the possibilities. Now the Embassy of Azerbaijan in
Deli is waiting for certain instructions from the Ministry of Foreign
Affairs, after which we will officially declare our position to the
Indian party. Undoubtedly, the position of India in the UNO was a
great disappointment to us, and certainly all this will seriously
effect on further relations between the two countries," said Karaev.

Araz Azimov didn’t keep aside from the issue either.

"The co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group on Nagorno Karabakh (the USA,
Russia and France) must take into consideration the resolution of
the UN General Assembly in all their actions. The co-chairs have out
themselves in an impartial situation; have put shame on themselves
by acting against the Azeri viewpoint.

We will not forget the hostility they feel fro us. We have always tried
to create an atmosphere of trust between us. But after this trust was
destroyed, perhaps it will not be possible to mend this situation any
more," he declared. For some reasons, none of the Azeri diplomats
mentions that this resolution doesn’t have any legal effect. They
think that the Azeri nation doesn’t have to worry about such trifles.

According to RA Minister of Foreign Affairs Vartan Oskanyan, the
resolution is very hypocritical. "On the one hand this is an attempt to
misinform the UN Member States and that is why the document contains
an article supporting the efforts of the OSCE Minsk Group. The Member
Countries have clearly declared that they are not going to support the
resolution and that they are going to vote against it," he emphasized.

Vartan Oskanyan mentioned that Armenia is curious about the next step
that Azerbaijan is going to take.

"The question is how this resolution will effect on the process of
negotiations or whether Azerbaijan will really receive a clear note
and will get back to negotiations," said the Minister of Foreign
Affairs of Armenia. In his turn Armen Martirosyan mentioned that the
resolution of the UN General Assembly with the demand of immediate
withdrawal of the Armenian forces from "the occupied territories of
Azerbaijan" will interrupt the peaceful process of the Nagorno-Karabakh
Conflict regulation. According to him this document contradicts to
the fundamental international norms.

It is quite understandable that it was not difficult for Azerbaijan
to gain the support of the GUAM Countries and OIC. Serbia’s position
is also quite understandable; the country is very upset with the UNO
for its decision on the Kosovo issue. But it is hard to understand
what Columbia and unknown countries like Tuvalu or Myanmar have to do
with this issue. By the way, it is worth mentioning that Kazakhstan,
Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan, which are OIK member countries, abstained
from voting being very well aware of the state of affairs. So it is
quite untimely to speak about victory. But there is no doubt that this
has served as a very good lesson for the Armenian diplomacy. It is
natural that Baku will not content itself with the UNO, and will try
to promote this kind of resolutions in all competent international
organizations. And only the truth about the situation in Nagorno
Karabakh may fight all these lies. However, it’s very unlikely that
the 39 countries having participated in the voting are not aware of
the real state of affairs. Simply the Islamic solidarity, which is
unfortunately much stronger than the Christian solidarity, worked
out well.

According To Latest Data, 31 Detained And 59 Arrested Among People B

ACCORDING TO LATEST DATA, 31 DETAINED AND 59 ARRESTED AMONG PEOPLE BROUGHT TO POLICE DEPARTMENTS

Noyan Tapan
March 13, 2008

YEREVAN, MARCH 13, NOYAN TAPAN. 764 people have been brought to police
departments on suspicions of having taken part in mass disorders in
Yerevan on March 1-2 night, according to March 12 15:30 data, 568
out of whom in regions, 1496 in the capital, 59 people have been put
under arrest, 31 have been detained and 513 set free. This statement
was made by Sayat Shirinian, the Head of the Public Relations and
Information Department of the RA Police, at the press conference,
which was held on March 12. Within the frameworks of the filed case,
the materials concerning 62 people have been sent to the prosecutor’s
office, 4 to the National Security Service, and those of 14 people
to the Administrative Court for settling the issue on submitting
to administrative responsibility. 19 people have been sent to
narcological dispensaries, the decisions of medical commission of
experts have not been received yet, the data concerning 72 people
are still being checked.

As of this moment, on March 1-2, in general, 203 police collaborators,
including 162 servicemen of the Police forces, received body injuries
of different degrees. 54 received grave body injuries and 43 fire-arms
splinter injuries. As of this moment, 47 people are continuing to
receive treatment.

Football Federation Of Armenia Approves Schedules Of Higher And Firs

FOOTBALL FEDERATION OF ARMENIA APPROVES SCHEDULES OF HIGHER AND FIRST LEAGUES CHAMPIONSHIPS

Noyan Tapan
March 12, 2008

YEREVAN, MARCH 12, NOYAN TAPAN. The Football Federation of Armenia has
approved the schedules of the Higher and First Leagues Championships.

Country’s champion Pyunik will receive its competitors in the Nairi
sports ground, Banants in its club’s playground, Ulus in Voskehat,
Mika in Ararat, Ararat in Abovian, Kilikia in the Hrazdan playing
field, Shirak in Gyumri, Gandzasar in Kapan.

The RA Football Cup Tournament will start on March 21, the Higher
League Championship on April 6, and the First League Championship on
April 5.

Clients Praise Westwood Lawyer

CLIENTS PRAISE WESTWOOD LAWYER
Erin Prawoko

Daily News Transcript
page/x701183715
March 12 2008
MA

Immigration Lawyer Samia Chandraker, right, meets with her clients,
dance instructor Gayane Ghazaryan, left, and soccer coach Karen
Babayan.

By Jeb Bobseine/Daily News staff Daily News Transcript

————————————– ——————————————
WESTWOO D – In 2003, Karen Babayan was stopping international soccer
stars like France’s Zinedine Zidane from scoring goals.

Five years later, the Armenian-born Babayan coaches at the New England
Sports Academy on University Avenue and lives nearby with his family.

That new life, Babayan says, is possible because local lawyer Samia
Chandraker took his immigration case.

Chandraker, a Scotland native, opened her first office in Cambridge
11 years ago – after studying at Harvard Law School – before moving
to the Westwood area in 2000.

Her clients include New England Sports Academy, Computer Arithmetic,
as well as physicians, academics, scientists and others.

One client, Henry Shterenberg, says he couldn’t manage without her
expertise.

Shterenberg opened the New England Sports Academy in 2003 to offer
youth athletic instruction.

Coaches from all over the world make up the staff, said Shterenberg,
a refugee from the former Soviet Union. Many are former high-level
athletes who he said are extraordinary assets to the United States.

"They’re the best in their field," Shterenberg said.

Chandraker helps foreign citizens enter the U.S., get their green
card and citizenship papers, he said.

"She’s done a phenomenal job. She’s never failed."

In 2007, Chandraker took on Babayan’s application for a green card.

She made his case as an alien of "extraordinary ability," as he played
professional soccer in Europe, and for the Armenian national team.

Unlike a professor or researcher seeking permanent status – aliens in
the medical field make up half of Chandraker’s practice – there is less
tangible supporting data for an athlete like Babayan, she explained.

As a result, she loaded the case with statistics, colleague
testimonials, and explanations of the nuances of European soccer.

She called the case an "incredible challenge."

Instead of documents and publications, Chandraker said she relied to
newspaper articles describing Babayan’s athletic prowess; photographs
with famous players, including French superstar Zidane; even a National
Geographic article arguing for the importance of soccer as a way to
"change dialogue between nations."

Babayan, who received his green card in five months, was pleased with
the outcome, as well as Chandraker’s work.

It took such a short time, he said. "She’s very, very smart … a
nice person … (and she) knows everything," he said.

Gayane Ghazaryan, another Academy instructor, echoed Babayan.

Ghazaryan has taught dance and gymnastics at the Sports Academy for
two years. Before that she choreographed performances for a dance
troupe she started in her native Armenia.

Ghazaryan is waiting for her green card. Chandraker helped prepare
her application.

Her case is a bit tougher than Babayan’s because it is hard to
quantify ones excellence in dance, according to Chandraker. It has
fewer international structures and no overarching organizing body,
as soccer does, she said.

One of the ways she made the case was to test the market for
Ghazaryan’s skills by placing ads, through the Sports Academy, to
see if any similarly qualified U.S. workers were available.

None were.

Ghazaryan’s case highlights one of Chandraker’s self-proclaimed
strengths. "Transparency of communication" makes her law office
different from others, Chandraker wrote in a press release.

To achieve this she, or her associate Meghna Shah, provides detailed
one-page monthly case status reports for each client showing how the
case is progressing and what the next step will be.

There are these traditional stereotypes in the legal profession, she
said. People think of lawyers as arrogant, too busy and inaccessible.

Even with her office handling around 100 cases each year, the hope
is her clients don’t feel that way, she added.

"She’s a great tool for us to improve people’s lives," Shterenberg
said. She not only helps the coaches whose cases she handles, but
the hundreds of kids they are then able to teach, he added.

http://www.dailynewstranscript.com/home

ANCA: Knollenberg/Schiff Press Sec. Rice on Armenia/Azerbaijan Aid

Armenian National Committee of America
1711 N Street, NW
Washington, DC 20036
Tel. (202) 775-1918
Fax. (202) 775-5648
Email [email protected]
Internet

PRESS RELEASE

For Immediate Release
March 12, 2008
Contact: Elizabeth S. Chouldjian
Tel: (202) 775-1918

KNOLLENBERG AND SCHIFF PRESS SEC. RICE ON WHITE HOUSE
PROPOSAL TO BREAK ARMENIA-AZERBAIJAN MILITARY AID PARITY

— Knollenberg Seeks to Cut all Military Aid to Azerbaijan
in response to Aliev’s threats of Renewed Aggression

— Rice: Some U.S. Aid Programs in Armenia "Suspended" due to Domestic Turmoil

WASHINGTON, DC – Congressional Armenian Caucus Co-Chairman Joe
Knollenberg (R-MI) and Representative Adam Schiff (D-CA) pressed
Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice today on the Administration’s
proposal to break an agreement to maintain military aid parity
between Armenia and Azerbaijan, citing Baku’s threats of renewed
aggression and its recent cross-border attacks against Nagorno
Karabagh, reported the Armenian National Committee of America
(ANCA).

Calling the recent Azerbaijani attacks against Nagorno Karabagh’s
Mardakert region as the "the worst breach [of the cease fire] in
over 10 years", Rep. Knollenberg asked Secretary Rice how the
Administration intends to respond to Azerbaijan’s aggression and
war rhetoric. She replied that, "we are very concerned about the
heating up rhetoric but I think the way to deal with this is to
open channels to both sides and to try to bring them to a
solution."

Rep. Knollenberg followed up noting that, "I wasn’t the least bit
kidding about removing their military funding because if Azerbaijan
is building up to a point, that they have also said that they would
move into Armenia and challenge them whenever they want to because
they have an economic situation that is far stronger than Armenia,
and in time they probably could put together a military
organization that would march in and take over. Now that’s not the
outcome any of us want, but I am really concerned about that. That
is why I am suggesting that we take away their military funding or
at least threaten it – because they are threatening Armenia."

In response to Rep. Schiff’s concerns that the President’s budget
called for a break in military aid parity to Armenia and
Azerbaijan, Secretary Rice cited concerns about the current state
of emergency in Armenia. Rep. Schiff interjected that no state of
emergency existed when the President’s budget was announced in
early February, prompting Secretary Rice to state that Armenia
received Millennium Challenge Account funding and is the highest
recipient of per capita aid in the Caucasus.

Noting Armenia’s recent domestic turmoil surrounding the Armenian
elections, and specifically the state of emergency declared by the
government, Sec. Rice twice referenced the suspension of
implementation of some U.S. assistance programs to Armenia and
stated that they continue to work with the authorities to bring
stability to the region.

The budget proposed by the White House last month sought to
dramatically slash aid to Armenia by 59%, and, once again, proposed
tipping the military aid balance in favor of Azerbaijan, despite
Baku’s threats to use it growing military arsenal to restart its
war against Armenia and Nagorno Karabagh.

Congressman Knollenberg and his Congressional Armenian Caucus Co-
Chairman Frank Pallone (D-NJ) are currently collecting signatures
>From their House colleagues on a letter urging the leaders of the
U.S. State-Foreign Operations Appropriations Subcommittee to
support provisions in the FY09 foreign aid bill that advance U.S.
interests and American values in Armenia and the surrounding
region. Citizens seeking to reverse the President’s proposed cut
in aid to Armenia and to support the other aid priorities in the
Armenian Caucus letter, can send a free ANCA WebFax to their
elected officials in Washington today:
d=11011351&type=CO

http://capwiz.com/anca/issues/alert/?alerti
www.anca.org

Hey Look, More Protests!

HEY LOOK, MORE PROTESTS!

Registan.net
dex.php/2008/03/10/hey-look-more-protests/
March 11 2008
WA

Sigh. This time in Georgia. 7,000 in Tibilisi against Saakashvili
for allegedly stealing the presidental election back in January. The
protestors are mostly supporters of Levan Gachechiladze, who was
the runner-up in the election. The election was very similar to the
Armenian election last month, in that I don’t think anyone really
disputes that Saakashvili got more votes, but there were enough
reports of irregularities that one could make a case that he didn’t
really clear the 50% mark necessary to avoid a run-off (the official
results were Saakashivili 53%, Gachechildaze 27%).

It really seems like the trend now in post-Soviet countries is that
any time you lose an election, you stage protests and claim that the
incumbent used illegal and undemocratic means to steal the election,
and that you’re the true representative of the people. If, like
Saakashvili and Yuschchenko, you actually manage to get into office,
the roles quickly reverse. I don’t mean to trivialize the situation,
as free and fair elections are of course fundamental to a democracy,
but at some point I think these protests start to lose their impact and
just become part of the ritual. I remember reading once that one of
the biggest tests of a democracy is whether the losers of elections,
or those whose terms have expired, can accept that they’re not in
power and step aside. Clearly, most of the post-Soviet countries
haven’t gotten there yet.

On the other hand, it’s certainly a positive sign that so many
people feel so emboldened that they join these protests, often at
risk to themselves.

Tomorrow, I promise a post with nothing at all to do with protests
or disputed elections.

http://www.registan.net/in